﻿

   Table of Contents
Title Page
Introduction
About This Book
Overview
The Bait and Switch of Unscientific Medicine. Steven Novella
Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions | H Hall
The Last Word on Homeopathy | H Hall
BASIC SCIENCE
Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part I. by Kimball Atwood 
Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part II by Kimball Atwood 
Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part III by Kimball Atwood 
Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part IV by Kimball Atwood 
Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part V by Kimball Atwood 
Homeopathy and Plausibility. Steven Novella
The Three Phantoms of Homeopathy | C Pearcey
Deconstructing Homeopathy Propaganda | S Novella
51 "Facts" About Homeopathy. Mark Crislip
Homeopathy and the Selling of Nonspecific Effects. Steven Novella.
Placebos as Medicine: The Ethics of Homeopathy. Scott Gavura 
Science vs Homeopathic Pseudoscience. Steven Novella.
A Science Lesson from a Homeopath and Behavioral Optometrist. Steven Novella.
When homeopaths attack medicine and physics. David Gorski 
Getting It On with Homeopathy Wallace Sampson
Homeopathy + AI = Still Nonsense | S Gavura
Researching the Magic of Homeopathy | S Novella
A truly homeopathic defense of homeopathy | D Gorski
The “Incoherent Mess” That Is Homeopathy: Old and New Insights | H Hall
Clinical trials of homeopathy versus “respect for science” | D Gorski
Delusion Update | M Crislip
QUACKADEMICS
Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part III). Kimball Atwood
The Dull-Man Law. Kimball Atwood 
“Urban Zen” and homeopathy at Beth Israel Medical Center, or: Dr. Gorski destroys his chances of ever being invited to join the faculty at BIMC or the Albert Einstein College of Medicine David Gorski 
"It's Just a Theory" Mark Crislip
Georgian College’s Homeopathy Program: Magical Thinking Presented as Fact | S Gavura
Homeopathy Embarrassing to Integrative Medicine | S Novella
Homeopathy Awareness Week shows that homeopathy is still a problem | D Gorski
CLINICAL TRIALS
Homeopathy and Pre-Registered Trials | S Novella
Homeopathy – Failing Randomized Controlled Trials Since 1835. Joseph Albietz
Another Review Finds Homeopathy Worthless | S Novella
A systematic review about nothing | S Gavura
Another Damning Homeopathy Report | S Novella
Fun with homeopaths and meta-analyses of homeopathy trials. David Gorski
Homeopathy’s Recent Woes | S Novella
Homeocracy. Wallace Sampson
Homeocracy II. Wallace Sampson.
Homeocracy III. Wallace Sampson.
Homeocracy IV. Wallace Sampson.
On the ethics of clinical trials of homeopathy in Third World countries. David Gorski
The Montagnier “Homeopathy” Study. Harriet Hall
Homeopathy and Sepsis. Mark Crislip
Some Sepsis Stuff | M Crislip
Homeopathy in the ICU? David Gorski.
Homeopathy for fibromyalgia: The Huffington Post bombs again. David Gorski.
Ososillyococcinum and other Flu bits. Mark Crislip.
How rabid dog saliva became an approved and endorsed remedy in Canada | S Gavura
Homeopathy, rabid dogs, and naturopathic propaganda | D Gorski
CEASE therapy for autism: Homeopathic quackery and “self regulation” by naturopathic boards | D Gorski
Australian review: Get homeopathy out of pharmacies | S Gavura
Pharmacies continue to sell sugar pills as flu remedy | S Gavura
Stop Making Sense | M Crislip
Fake Homeopathy COVID Scam | S Novella
The Worst Homeopathy Study. Ever | M Crislip
Homeopathy Ramblings | M Crislip
Homeopathy and COVID 45: The Toothless Old Man Laughs | M Crislip
Homeopathic Arnica in Plastic Surgery | S Novella
Homeopathic Syrup for the Treatment of Pediatric Colds: Randomized Controlled Nonsense is Still Nonsense | C Jones
New Study on Homeopathic Cough Syrup for Children Reveals a Lack of Effectiveness and Ethics | C Jones
American Journal of Public Health article touts “potential public health benefits” of homeopathy | J Bellamy
Systematic Review of Homeopathy for Rheumatological Disease | S Novella
Getting NCCAM’s money’s worth: Some results of NCCAM-funded studies of homeopathy | D Gorski
The World Has Moved On. Mark Crislip.
Homeopathy and Nanoparticles | H Hall
Is Homeopathy Unethical? | H Hall
Homeopath Quits Homeopathy but Thinks the Homeopathic Approach Has Value | H Hall
Ivermectin booster Dr. Tess Lawrie goes all-in for homeopathy for COVID and long COVID | D Gorski
Release Active Drugs – Homeopathy By Another Name | S Novella
Continued Battle over Homeopathy | S Novella
No, sugar pills won’t repel insects, and other consequences of regulating nonsense | S Gavura
False Balance for Homeopathy in the BMJ | S Novella
Scientific American Declares Homeopathy Indispensable to Planet and Human Health | H Hall
Update: Homeopathy in Brazilian Scientific American | H Hall
An Age of Endarkenment? The American Veterinary Medical Association and Homeopathy | B McKenzie
Homotoxicology | M Crislip
Homeopathy First Aid Kits | H Hall
Integrative Fire-Fighting | D Weinberg
Responding to Dr. Vinay Prasad’s “dunking on a 7′ hoop” criticism of SBM | D Gorski
AI And Pseudoscience | S Novella
LAW & POLITICS
The Swiss Report on Homeopathy | S Novella
Homeopathic regulation diluted until no substance left | J Bellamy
Should the FDA crack down on homeopathic “remedies”? | S Gavura
How should the FDA regulate homeopathic remedies? | J Bellamy
FDA and Homeopathy: Part Two. | M Crislip
Homeopathic industry and its acolytes make poor showing before FDA | J Bellamy
Society for Science-Based Medicine: Comment to FDA on homeopathic drug regulation | J Bellamy
FDA Proposes Changes to Homeopathy Regulation | S Novella
FDA strengthens homeopathic drug enforcement (but falls short of actually enforcing the law) | J Bellamy
FDA Warns About Homeopathic Teething Products | S Novella
An Update on FDA Concerns Over Homeopathic Teething Products | C Jones
Battle of the feds: FTC tells FDA to do its job regulating homeopathy | J Bellamy
The Federal Trade Commission takes on homeopathy—maybe | D Gorski
FTC Homeopathy Win | S Novella
What do consumers think about homeopathic remedies? | S Gavura
Is the Homeopathic Industry “On the Ropes”? | S Gavura
Good Thinking Society’s successful challenge to NHS homeopathy | M Marshall
A homeopathy supporter notices our visit with the director of NCCAM. David Gorski.
CAM and the Law Part 4: Regulation of Supplements and Homeopathic Remedies. Brennen McKenzie 
The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario’s muddled draft policy on “non-allopathic” medicine. David Gorski
The CAM Docket: Boiron I | J Bellamy
The CAM Docket: Boiron II | J Bellamy
The CAM Docket: Boiron III, et al. | J Bellamy
Homeopathy in Pharmacist Education | S Gavura
Pharmacy and homeopathy: Will the profession change, or will change be forced upon it? | S Gavura
Lawsuits against US pharmacy chains selling homeopathy to proceed | S Gavura
A homeopathic win for consumers | S Gavura
Walmart sued for deceiving customers in selling homeopathic remedies | J Bellamy
CVS sued for deceiving consumers in sale of homeopathic remedies | J Bellamy
CVS selling homeopathic remedies: It gets personal | J Bellamy
It’s time for pharmacies to stop selling sugar pills | S Gavura
Should physicians and managed care organizations offer homeopathy? | D Gorski
Junk science helps homeopathic remedy company win class action | J Bellamy
Closing the Door on Homeopathy. Steven Novella
ASA Smacks Down Homeopathy | S Novella
The Baloney Protection Act | S Novella
Homeopathy Gets a Reality Check in the UK. Steven Novella.
Homeopathy and the UK’s National Health Service | H Hall
Homeopathy: Magical thinking, not medicine | S Gavura
Russian Academy of Sciences Calls Homeopathy Pseudoscience | S Novella
Taking On Homeopathy in Germany. Steven Novella.
Homeopathy Declining in Germany | S Novella
1023 2011. Steven Novella.
Homeopathic Thuggery. Steven Novella
France To End Reimbursement for Homeopathy | S Novella
WHAT IS THE HARM
Homeopathy is Worthless and Not Always Harmless | S Novella
Belief in Homeopathy Results in the Death of a 7-Year-Old Italian Child | C Jones
Another Child Harmed by Pseudomedicine: Lead Poisoning from a “Homeopathic Healing” Bracelet | C Jones
Not just water! This homeopathy is contaminated with bacteria | S Gavura
Homeopathic Vaccines Revisited | S Novella
Homeopathic Vaccines. Mark Crislip.
Nosodes Redux: “I hate those meeces to pieces!” Mark Crislip
Randomized controlled trial of homeopathic nosodes finds, not surprisingly, that they are useless | S Gavura
Homeopaths Threaten Public Health Selling Sugar Pills as Vaccine Alternatives | S Novella
Canada Is Sending Homeopaths to Honduras | S Novella
Médecins Sans Medicine? “Homeopaths without borders” giving sugar pills for infectious diseases in Honduras | S Gavura
Smallpox and Pseudomedicine. Kimball Atwood.
FDA: Don’t use homeopathic eye drops | S. Gavura
   Title Page
Science-Based Medicine Reviews: Homeopathy
A Critical Guide for the Health Practitioner and Consumer 
2025 Edition

Executive Editor Steven Novella MD
Managing Editor David Gorski MD PhD
Series Editor Mark Crislip MD

   Introduction
Steven Novella
The world of health care is becoming an increasingly complex and challenging place. The internet is changing the way we generate and access information, and health information is one of the most popular uses of the internet. It represents an unprecedented democratization of information and opinion. 
While there are many advantages and benefits to such information access, there are also many challenges to health professionals, regulators, academics, and consumers. There is a proliferation of health related products and services, with many provocative health claims. Regulations are generally not keeping up, and often have been watered down, in the face of this onslaught of claims and products. 
The consumer is left with an overwhelming array of health claims, many of which challenge and even directly oppose the traditional experts and institutions. 
The mission of Science-Based Medicine (SBM) is to be a source of reliable information and analysis to help navigate the wild west of health information on the internet and elsewhere. The authors who contribute to this series of e-books are all physicians and other health care professionals who have a great deal of experience educating the public about complex medical issues. We especially take on controversial issues and try to expose pseudoscience and fraud wherever possible.
The Philosophy of Science-Based Medicine
The philosophy of SBM, at its core, is simple: Safe and effective health care is critical to everyone’s quality of life; so much so that it is generally considered a basic human right. Therefore, health care products and services that work and are safe are better than those that do not work or are unsafe. 
The best method for determining which interventions and health products are safe and effective is, without question, good science. Therefore it is in everyone’s best interest for health care to be systematically evaluated by the best science available.
Too often the nature of science itself is misunderstood or misrepresented to the public. Science is not an arcane and privileged discipline. By its very nature it is meant to be transparent and public. Science is nothing more than a systematic and careful use of evidence and logic to evaluate factual claims. And good science possesses certain virtues that are not unique to science but generic to all intellectual endeavors: fairly accounting for all available evidence, using valid and internally consistent logic, using unambiguous concepts and language, proper use of statistics, being quantitatively precise and accurate, and above all being honest.
And yet there are numerous and powerful influences in society that strongly appose the scientific basis of medicine. Driven by some combination of ideology or the desire for profit they wish to eliminate standards of science in health care, or (often under the guise of “health care freedom”) create a double standard in which unscientific methods and products can thrive unchecked. Others simply lack the training or knowledge to achieve minimal standards of quality for scientific medicine. And even the best traditions of scientific medicine can benefit from more critical analysis.
Recognition of the need for careful scientific analysis in medicine partly stems from a recognition that it is very difficult (almost impossible) to reliably assess treatments anecdotally. Human perception, memory, and cognition are prone to a host of flaws, weaknesses, and biases that will tend to mislead us, especially towards conclusions that we wish to be true. Placebo effects, confirmation bias, and simple statistics can make any intervention seem effective, even when they are worthless or harmful. 
Science-Based Medicine vs Evidence-Based Medicine
Within the practice of medicine there is already a recognition of the need to raise the standards of evidence and the availability of the best evidence to the practitioner and the consumer – formalized in the movement known as evidence-based medicine (EBM). 
EBM is a vital and positive influence on the practice of medicine, but it has its limitations. EBM tends to focus on clinical trial results to the exclusion of scientific plausibility. The focus on trial results (which, in the EBM lexicon, is what is meant by “evidence”) has its utility, but fails to properly deal with medical modalities that are highly implausible, or seem to defy well-established findings in science.
All of science describes the same reality, and therefore it must (if it is functioning properly) all be mutually compatible. Collectively, science builds one cumulative model of the natural world. This means we can make rational judgments about what is likely to be true based upon what is already well established. This does not necessarily equate to rejecting new ideas out-of-hand, but rather to adjusting the threshold of evidence required to establish a new claim based upon the prior scientific plausibility of the new claim. Failure to do so leads to conclusions and recommendations that are not reliable, and therefore medical practices that are probably not safe and effective.
The SBM Series
This is why the authors of this series strongly advocate for science based medicine – the use of the best scientific evidence available, in the light of our cumulative scientific knowledge from all relevant disciplines, in evaluating health claims, practices, and products. 
Some of the articles here will analyze individual studies, and explore the strengths and weaknesses of their methods, separating what the study really tells us from how it may be represented in the media. Other articles will summarize what many studies tell us about a specific medical question. 
We will also explore health information on the internet, separating out which information is reliable from that which is misleading, erroneous, or possibly even fraudulent. Likewise we will critique mainstream media coverage of health topics, giving the reader specific tools for to critically analyze health information for themselves.
Other articles will explore topics related to health regulation and academia. Regulations have struggled to keep up with the rapidly changing health care market place, with critical gaps that leave the health care consumer responsible for their own protection. Academic institutions themselves, long the defenders of high standards of scholarship in all fields, including medicine, have been infiltrated by promoters of pseudoscientific belief systems. The result is that there is no longer any single reliable guarantee of scientific integrity. 
The SBM series of e-books is organized by topic, such as acupuncture, chiropractic, homeopathy, and many others. The books are collections of essays, not intended to be a systematic reference, but rather to explore the various scientific issues related to each topic. The goal is to give the reader critical thinking skills and a deeper understanding of, not just the current findings of science, but the process of science, specifically how it relates to health care and the topic of each book. 
Science-based medicine can serve as your pocket guide through the wilderness of health information.

As of 2025, there are over 5000 essays on the Science Based Medicine website. I do no know about you, but I find it difficult to find any post I wrote, much less one written by another contributor. 

So I have updated the books and include almost all the articles through 2025. The volumes are

CAM Concepts
Chiropractic
COVID 
Critical Thinking
Diet and Nutrition
Ethics and CAM
Herbs, Supplements, and Diet
Homeopathy
Infections and Immunity
Law and CAM
Media and Internet
Medicine, Public Health, Dentistry and Pediatrics
Miscellaneous CAM
Naturopathy
Neurology and Psychiatry
Placebo
Quackademic Medicine
Regulation. FDA and FTC
SBM or EBM
Stem Cells, Genetics, AI and Gender
Supplements, Vitamins and Herbs
Vaccine & Anivax
Vaccines and Autism
Vaccines and Preventable Infections

The articles are roughly organized by publication date and topic. Many articles will be in multiple volumes as an essay of, for example, chiropractic and law will be found in both the chiropractic volume and the law volume.

You may find the organization a bit odd. I do. But 4700 plus articles are difficult to organize and I have more to do in my retirement than work of these volumes.

Still, if you find I have missed a nentry or some glaring error, drop me a note and I will fix it for the next edition.

About the authors
Steven P. Novella, MD – Founder and Executive Editor Science Based Medicine.
Founder and currently Executive Editor of Science-Based Medicine Steven Novella, MD.
David H. Gorski, MD, PhD – Managing Editor. Science Based Medicine.
Mark A. Crislip, MD. Editor, Science Based Medicine Guides. 
He did he editing of all the volumes so is to blame for any mistakes.
As to all the other contributors, if you are interested click on the ‘Link’ at top of each essay to go the SBM site, where further information about each author can be found.
A Note On References

The chapters in this book were originally blog entries at ScienceBasedMedicine.org.
Blog and web pages lend themselves to hyperlinks to sources and references that are tedious to translate into footnotes for this ebook.
Under the title of each essay is a hyperlink, cleverly titled ‘Link’, to the original blog entry with all the hyperlinks and references, as well as the comments to the blogs, which often have interesting and thoughtful insights by our readers, as well as some curious comments by the not so thoughtful.
Graphs, tables and links to videos are not in included these essays due to issues of copyright and permission. However, thanks to the ‘Link’, the graphics are a click away.
Thanks for reading the site.
Mark Crislip 



   Overview
Homeopathy was founded by Samuel Christian Hahnemann (1755-1843), a German physician who had become dissatisfied with the medicine of his day. Hahnemann lived in a time before the rudiments of modern medicine had been developed, before the germ theory of infectious disease, before the first antibiotic, before systematic testing of drugs for safety and efficacy, before surgical procedures were performed with anesthesia or sterile technique.
For many years Hahnemann’s search was unsuccessful, until he stumbled upon what he thought was an amazing observation. He took a small amount of cinchona bark, which contains quinine, the drug used to treat malaria, and developed the symptoms of malaria. From this observation he developed homeopathy’s first law, “similia similibus curentur,” or let likes be cured by likes. In other words, drugs which cause specific symptoms can be used to cure diseases which cause the same symptoms.
As homeopathy evolved, other laws were also discovered. The law of infinitesimal doses was actually a late development by Hahnemann, but today is often thought of as the primary characteristic of homeopathy. This law states that when drugs are diluted in either water or alcohol, they actually increase in potency. Today, serial dilutions of 1:100 repeated 6 or 30 times are commonly used. Between each dilution the substance is violently shaken, which is thought to be necessary to activate the properties of the drug.
Hahnemann also developed, as the underpinning of homeopathy, his own theory of disease, called the miasm theory. According to this theory there are three miasms which are responsible for all human disease, and homeopathic remedies are directed towards treating these offending miasms.
The goal of a homeopathic consultation is to find the “totality of symptoms,” physical, mental, and spiritual. They accomplish this goal by taking a “homeopathic history” which includes questions such as: do you feel sad when you hear piano music, are you excessively tidy or do you have a chilly personality. This information is combined with the patient’s symptoms and their physical “constitution,” which may depend on such facts as hair color. The homeopath then decides on what single remedy will treat the patient’s “totality.” The remedy is then prescribed, and is usually given in either a single dose or only a few doses.
The principles of homeopathy run contrary to modern science and have never been empirically established. The so-called law of similars, for example, is little more than an ancient and common superstition known as sympathetic magic – that things have an essence or essential quality that can be transferred. There is no scientific knowledge about biology or chemistry to support the notion that a small dose of a drug or substance will necessarily cause the symptoms it treats at higher doses.
Modern homeopaths have tried to justify the law of similars by comparing it to the effectiveness of vaccines – which involve giving small doses of an infectious pathogen to prevent a later infection. However, this analogy is not apt. Vaccines involve measurable doses of attenuated or killed organisms or their proteins, and operate by a known mechanism – they trigger an immune response. There is no analogy to homeopathic treatments.
The law of infinitesimal doses also runs contrary to chemistry, pharmacology, and thermodynamics. Homeopaths today use dilutions of substances which essentially remove all traces of the substance from the final dilution. There is not likely to be even a single molecule of the original drug in the final remedy which is given to the patient. Homeopaths conclude from this fact that the substance is transferring its essence to the water into which it is diluted. The more it is diluted, the more potent is the water. They offer, however, no possible explanation for how simple water molecules can contain the essence of far more complex substances.
Modern homeopaths have also tried to rescue the notion of infinitessimals by invoking the concept of water memory. They claim that water molecules can form a structure that contains the information of the homeopathic remedy. However, such claims are fanciful to the point of invoking magic and are devoid of any evidence. Water structure is very transient and ephemeral. They last moments and could not survive repeated dilution, let alone ingestion, absorption into the body, and transport to whatever their alleged site of action is.
Their model of illness is similarly constructed. Hahnemann developed his ideas before the disease theory of illness was fully developed. In other words, during his time physicians did not yet understand that illnesses were caused by specific diseases; that a given disease, such as diabetes, has a common underlying pathophysiology – a specific malfunction of a specific tissue, organ, or organ system leading to a specific disorder with recognizable signs and symptoms. This modern theory of illness has lead, for instance, to the treatment of diabetes with insulin replacement, vastly improving the quality and duration of life of patients suffering from this disease.
At this point many defenders of homeopathy would argue, “Who cares how it works, as long as it works.” There is a kernel of legitimacy to this argument (although it does not save homeopathy from being a pseudoscience) in that even in conventional medicine, treatments are often used before their mechanism of action is fully understood. There is a difference, however, between not fully understanding a mechanism and, as with homeopathy, violating basic laws of physics. In such cases it is necessary to demonstrate using carefully controlled clinical trials that such treatments do in fact work.
There has been mixed results from clinical studies of homeopathy, but a clear trend when all the evidence is reviewed – the better designed the study the less likely there is to be any effect, and the best designed studies are negative. Homeopathy, it turns out, is no more effective than placebo (an inactive treatment).
Therefore, according to everything we currently understand about biology, chemistry, and physics homeopathy is highly implausible and should not work. And, when we carefully study homeopathic remedies they in fact do not work.

   The Bait and Switch of Unscientific Medicine
Steven Novella 
Link
Savvy consumers are familiar with the classic scam of the “bait and switch” – in practice if not the term itself. My wife and I ran across it when we were shopping for our first car. We needed a bargain and so we were attracted to the ads that promised a new Colt for only $9,000 (that’s the bait). Of course when we got to the dealership they were all out of Colts with the configuration advertised, but they had plenty of others that had different options that cost several thousand dollars more (that’s the switch).
It’s a basic and very successful form of deception, and so even though there are laws against such practices it is impossible to eliminate in all its various and more subtle forms. It even permeates scientific, political, and other intellectual endeavors – anytime a more palatable idea or claim is put forward to represent the less acceptable truth.
Science, however, requires transparent honesty to function properly, and therefore scientific practitioners must vigilantly guard against the cognitive bait and switch. Generic intellectual virtues incorporate this vigilance – they include the need to unambiguously define terms, to make claims as specific and operational as possible, and the use of valid logic. Beware of any claims that subtly violate these rules because they are probably setting you up for a bait and switch.
The purveyors of unscientific medical claims have become as expert at this classic deception as the slickest used-car salesman – in fact they have left the hawkers of dubious transportation in the dust.
Practitioners of health fraud, unscientific and sectarian medical practices have learned how to apply the bait and switch at multiple levels – with respect to specific modalities and at higher categorical levels. First I will address some of the more common sectarian practices and show how they apply this deception, whether consciously or out of intellectual sloppiness.
Chiropractic
Chiropractic is perhaps the most common and egregious example of the bait and switch in medicine. The deception begins with the name itself – “chiropractic” fails the basic test of transparency because it is not unambiguously defined. There are in fact numerous professions doing very different things and employing mutually exclusive philosophies under the banner of “chiropractic.”
Therefore someone may go to see a chiropractor and think they will be seeing a medical professional who will treat their musculoskeletal symptoms, but in reality they will see the practitioner of a cult philosophy of energy healing. So-called “straight” chiropractors (who make up an estimated 30% of all chiropractors) still adhere to the original philosophy of chiropractic invented by “magnetic healer” D.D. Palmer, which is based upon the claim that an undetected life energy called “innate intelligence” flows through the spinal cord and nerves and is responsible for health. Such chiropractors will treat any disease or ailment with spinal manipulation.
Most other so called “mixer” chiropractors reject the notion of innate intelligence either partially or entirely, but still incorporate other pseudosciences into their practice. Chiropractors are the primary practitioners of homeopathy, applied kinesiology, and iridology in the US. The bait – claims that chiropractors are medical practitioners with expertise in the musculoskeletal system. The switch – practitioners of discredited pseudosciences that have nothing to do with the musculoskeletal system.
A more subtle form of the bait and switch among chiropractors is the treatment of musculoskeletal symptoms with standard physical therapy or sports medicine practices under the name of chiropractic manipulation. Ironically, the more honest and scientific practitioners among chiropractors are most likely to commit this subtle deception. The problem comes not from the treatment itself but the claim that such treatments are “chiropractic.”
Using techniques like massage, range of motion exercises, strength-building exercises, and mobilization of joints are all legitimate science-based techniques used by physical therapists and physicians with specialties in physiatry, orthopedics, and sports medicine. Some chiropractors also use similar techniques -and with good results. But by doing so and calling it “chiropractic” it legitimizes the pseudoscientific practices that are very common within the profession – like treating non-existent “subluxations” in order to free up the flow of innate intelligence.
Acupuncture
Many studies of acupuncture employ this latter form of bait and switch – studying something that is not really acupuncture but calling it acupuncture and thereby legitimizing pure pseudoscience. Acupuncture refers to a Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) pre-scientific philosophy of health and illness that is based (very similarly to straight chiropractic) on the flow of life energy called “chi”. Fine needles are inserted into special locations on the body called meridians for the purpose of improving, freeing, and balancing the flow chi.
No study has demonstrated that chi exists, or that acupuncture of the meridians has any specific effect. A look at the entirety of the acupuncture literature, in fact, clearly demonstrates that it does not matter where the needles are placed (or how deeply, or if they are manipulated in ways that are designed to manipulate chi). This means that any effects of sticking acupuncture needles into a patient are non-specific – they are not related to the flow of chi. There may be some small non-specific physiological effects – such as counter-irritation reducing pain or inhibiting nausea – but even these claims remain elusive and controversial.
But some studies of “acupuncture” show a larger and more reliable effect, usually on pain. What these studies have in common is that they employ “electrical acupuncture” (for example). Electrical acupuncture, however, is not acupuncture – it’s transdermal electrical stimulation, which is a scientific practice that has proven efficacy in the treatment of pain. Giving transdermal electrical stimulation through acupuncture needles, calling that “electrical acupuncture” and then using positive results to conclude that acupuncture works – is an elaborate bait and switch.
Homeopathy and Herbal Medicine
Homeopathy is another dubious practice based upon pre-scientific notions long discredited. A truly homeopathic remedy is diluted to the point that no active ingredients remain – so a homeopathic remedy is pure solvent, either water or alcohol, sometimes placed on a sugar pill (making a homeopathic pill a literal placebo). But much of the public believes that “homeopathic” simply means “natural” or “herbal”. Few realize that it means that the so-called medicine contains nothing.
But some homeopathic products are not even truly homeopathic – meaning they are not based upon homeopathic principles but rather contain measurable amounts of real drugs. This is now not uncommon for over-the-counters lotions and cold remedies. For example, this pimple cream contains many active ingredients at a “1x” dilution – that’s only 1:10, meaning there is still actual molecules of drugs in the cream. That’s not homeopathic.
A similar and more subtle deception is used in the marketing of herbs. They are sold and regulated as “natural supplements” when in fact they are drugs. Herbs contain chemicals that have pharmacological activity and they are usually taken in doses that are insignificant in terms of their nutritional content, but are significant in terms of their pharmacological activity. The bait is that they are nutritional supplements, the switch is that they are unpurified drugs.
CAM – the Biggest Bait and Switch
All of these modalities fall under an artificial category – so called “complementary and alternative” medicine (CAM) or “integrative” medicine that was created as the ultimate bait and switch.
The deception is largely two-fold. The first is to include modalities within this false category that are legitimate, like nutrition, exercise, physical therapy, relaxation, etc., – and then claim that these legitimize the entire category of CAM, even the far-out stuff like homeopathy. This is just a higher-order version of including physical therapy modalities within the umbrella of chiropractic, for example.
Essentially, at every level terms are used that are vague and poorly defined, and in practice are designed to be all-inclusive so that the purely pseudoscientific can ride on the coattails of the barely plausible or even the legitimate.
This is the opposite of what happens within scientific disciplines – where terminology evolves over time to become more discriminating, unambiguous, and specific. To take an example from my specialty, multiple sclerosis (MS) has been divided into sub-diagnoses: relapsing remitting and chronic progressive. Divisions multiplied and now there are seven subtypes – for example, primary progressive, and progressive remitting.
This increased “splitting” as it is called is not just a pedantic dedication to precision, but a recognition that such divisions may reflect differences in underlying mechanism of the disease. Also, different subtypes of MS respond differently to different treatments. Some drugs work in relapsing remitting but not in primary progressive. Part of the motivation for finer categories is to more accurately predict which MS patients are likely to respond to which treatments.
Contrast this to the maximally broad and imprecise but common marketing slogan “chiropractic works.”
The second kind of deception created by the category of CAM is in the language used itself – “complementary” and “integrative.” What, exactly, are CAM modalities integrating? On close examination it is quite clear – the movement is an effort to mix unscientific, disproved, and dubious modalities into scientific medicine. The bait is that CAM offers legitimate alternatives, the switch is that it primarily promotes treatments that don’t work or are at best untested and highly implausible.
If there were truth in marketing then we would have the Office of Implausible Medicine, the Journal of Bad Medical Science, the Center for Rejected Therapies, and the Institute of Dubious Medical Claims – all under the umbrella of unscientific medicine. It used to be called, even more simply, “health fraud.”
Conclusion
The public would be best served if they were given a reasonable expectation of honesty and clarity in the health marketplace. Instead, increasingly they are being given the old bait and switch, and increasingly the governments and institutions of medicine that should know better are instruments of this deception.
Science and intellectual honesty require that terms mean something specific and definable. Unscientific health modalities have become very savvy at using terminology to confuse rather than inform, to deceive rather than to illuminate.
It is the simplest form of the bait and switch – just call a product or service something that it isn’t.

Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions
I wrote an introduction to the first in a series of books republishing classic skeptical works – Oliver Wendell Holmes’ Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions. Reproduced here by permission of the James Randi Educational Foundation is that introduction. Enjoy!
Harriet Hall on January 31, 2012
Link
Note: The James Randi Educational Foundation (JREF) is publishing a new series of e-books. The first two offerings are an excellent new book on critical thinking by Bob Carroll, Unnatural Acts, and the first in a planned series of republications of classic skeptical works, Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions, by Oliver Wendell Holmes. I was asked to write the introduction for the latter, and the JREF has kindly given their permission for me to reproduce it here.

The German philosopher Hegel said, “We learn from history that we don’t learn from history.” “Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions” is a remarkable little book based on two lectures Oliver Wendell Holmes gave in 1842. It is a masterful debunking of homeopathy. If his lessons had been taken to heart, homeopathy would not have survived and we could have avoided a great number of other medical delusions that continue to plague us today, both from charlatans and from well-meaning advocates who lack Holmes’ critical thinking skills.
To realize just how remarkable this book is, imagine the world of 1842. Samuel Hahnemann, the inventor of homeopathy, was still alive. Roentgen wouldn’t discover x-rays until 1895. The germ theory was not yet established. Semmelweis wouldn’t make his observations on puerperal fever until 3 years later. It wasn’t until 1854 that John Snow removed the Broad Street pump handle and stopped a cholera epidemic. Koch’s postulates for determining infectious causes of disease weren’t published until 1890. Doctors didn’t wash their hands or use sterile precautions for surgery. Bloodletting to “balance the humors“ was still a common practice. The randomized placebo-controlled trial wouldn’t appear for another century. Contemporary medicine often did more harm than good. In fact, Holmes himself famously quipped “I firmly believe that if the whole materia medica could be sunk to the bottom of the sea, it would be all the better for mankind and all the worse for the fishes.”
Oliver Wendell Holmes did not have any of the advantages of modern medical science, but he did have a good brain and knew how to use it. He begins by saying that stories of cures are of little value because of the fluctuations of disease and the fallacies of observation, a lesson that today’s proponents of questionable treatments have yet to learn. We are constantly having to tell them that the plural of anecdote is not data and that even the most intuitively obvious medical beliefs must be tested. Holmes points out that ineffective treatments commonly appear to benefit patients through an influence on their imaginations, but advocating them is as deceptive and unethical as passing counterfeit money.
In his first lecture, Holmes reviews four nonsensical treatments to illustrate “the fallacy of popular belief and the uncertainty of asserted facts in medical experience.” The kings of England used to touch people by the thousands to cure scrofula, the weapon ointment was applied to weapons to heal the wounds they had caused, the estimable Bishop Berkeley promoted tar-water as a panacea for everything from smallpox to asthma, and patients were stroked with metallic rods, Perkins’ tractors, to relieve a variety of symptoms. These delusions were widely accepted over varying periods of time by the public, by respected clergymen, and even by doctors.
He explains why so many people were so easily fooled. Testimonials were called “facts,” and fallacious arguments were believed. The same arguments are being used today: “I know it works because I saw it with my own eyes,” they laughed at Galileo, doctors are suppressing a cure in order to protect their livelihood, we shouldn’t reject something just because we don’t understand how it works, science doesn’t know everything, the proponents couldn’t be wrong because they are benevolent people who treat the poor gratis, etc. People often do believe ineffective treatments made them better. Sometimes the natural course of their disease would have resulted in improvement without any treatment. Sometimes they “cheated themselves into a false and short-lived belief that they were cured.”
With this foundation, Holmes proceeds in the second lecture to an examination of homeopathy. Homeopathy began in hostility, claiming that all existing medical knowledge was false and inventing the term “allopathy” to denigrate medical practitioners who were not homeopaths. Holmes shows that homeopathy had already failed a number of simple tests, and there is no point in further testing: history shows that experiments disproving delusional medical practices achieve nothing because they are always explained away by true believers.
There are three basic doctrines in homeopathy:
     1.  “Like cures like:” the proper medicine for a disease is one that produces the symptoms of the disease in healthy people. Holmes stresses that this is different from “same cures same.”
     2.  The Law of Infinitesimals: homeopathic preparations are diluted by an elaborate process and the strength supposedly increases with the dilution. Holmes explains that a 12C dilution contains only one quadrillionth of the original substance. When Avogadro’s number later came into use, we could calculate the minuscule probability that even a single molecule remained; but even without Avogadro, Holmes was able to show that the amount of liquid required to directly make such a dilution would be impossibly huge.
     3.  Hahnemann claimed that “psora” or itch was the cause of seven eighths of all chronic diseases, everything from insanity to scoliosis. Even many of his own followers have rejected this doctrine.
Holmes points out that “Many persons, and most physicians and scientific men, would be satisfied with the statement of these doctrines, and examine them no further. They would consider it vastly more probable that any observer in so fallacious and difficult a field of inquiry as medicine had been led into error, or walked into it of his own accord, than that such numerous and extraordinary facts had really just come to light.”
Homeopathy just begs to be ridiculed, but Holmes tries to avoid ridicule and seriously examine the claims. He asks how likely it is that any single individual could have made three such unconnected momentous discoveries and overturned all other medical knowledge. He shows that the laundry lists of symptoms listed in the homeopathic Materia Medica and used to guide selection of remedies include irrelevant normal sensations that everyone experiences. He presents evidence from those who have experimented with the remedies and failed to substantiate Hahnemann’s claims. He critiques Hahnemann’s citations of earlier authorities whose writings supposedly supported homeopathic principles. He shows that comparisons of homeopathy with vaccination and treatment of frostbite are false analogies. He shows the fallacy of reporting success rates of homeopathy without comparison to patients treated otherwise and the fallacy of attributing every recovery to the homeopathic remedy itself. He shows that published case reports of homeopathic cures are nothing but meaningless propaganda. He exposes special pleading and the error of attributing a cure to homeopathy when other concomitantly given treatments probably deserved the credit. He mentions the meaninglessness of popular endorsements of homeopathy, for instance by the nobility in Britain, which unfortunately persist to this day in the form of the very gullible alternative medicine advocate Prince Charles.
He expected homeopathy to eventually break up and disappear, and he conjectured about how that might happen. He says “If it should claim a longer existence [than Perkins’ tractors], it can only be by falling into the hands of the sordid wretches who wring their bread from the cold grasp of disease and death in the hovels of ignorant poverty.” Holmes did his best to combat the harmful delusions of homeopathy, and to teach his readers how to think about medical claims in general. Alas, his effort was a drop in the bucket that had no chance against the power of human credulity.
This book is a classic. It speaks as clearly to our needs today as it did to readers in 1842; and its approach to critical thinking about medical claims is even more important today than it was back then, because we are flooded with vast amounts of misinformation through the Internet and other media. If his language is a bit convoluted for modern tastes, it offers unique pleasures: it is studded with gems in the form of delightful turns of phrase. Read, think, and enjoy!

The Last Word on Homeopathy
Harriet Hall on November 22, 2016
Link

No one will ever need to write about homeopathy again. Edzard Ernst has said it all in his new book Homeopathy: The Undiluted Facts.
Far too many trees have died in the service of praising or debunking homeopathy in the two centuries since Hahnemann invented it. The forests can celebrate, because this is the definitive book about homeopathy. It is neither “for” nor “against” homeopathy; it is explanatory. It is dispassionate and as unbiased as it could possibly be. It says good things about homeopathy, shows how arguments for and against it have been flawed, and contains nothing that the most ardent homeopaths should be able to complain about (but complain they surely will, because the facts Ernst reports are not what they want the world to hear).
Homeopaths have complained that their critics are not qualified to comment. Ernst says that in order to provide responsible and reliable information, it would be helpful, perhaps even necessary, to have the following types of expertise:
    • A sound knowledge of evidence-based medicine
    • The ability to tell good from poor science
    • Experience as a patient who has been treated by a homeopath
    • Research experience in homeopathy
    • Published scientific papers on the subject
    • Application of homeopathy in clinical practice
    • Skills of systematic analysis and critical thinking
Ernst has demonstrated that he fulfills each of these criteria. He has been a patient, a practitioner, and a researcher. As the world’s first Professor of Complementary Medicine, he has relentlessly and rigorously evaluated the evidence for all kinds of alternative medicine. Arguably, there is no one in the world better qualified to write this book.
He explains that he is not writing for those who are fully convinced that homeopathy is an effective and safe treatment for all ailments, nor is he writing for those who are persuaded that everything about homeopathy is rubbish. His aim is to provide a service to consumers by reporting the scientific facts in an accessible way.
The book’s format
There are two parts to the book. In ten chapters, he covers the definition and main principles of homeopathy; myths; current popularity, acceptance, and regulation; the history of homeopathy; different types of homeopathy and homeopaths; the patients; homeopathy as a criticism of conventional medicine; scientific evidence (what constitutes credible scientific evidence and what the evidence says both for and against homeopathy); and spurious arguments for and against homeopathy. The second part, longer than the first, is a Lexicon of Homeopathy that fleshes out the details, explains the terminology and concepts, and provides information about the players.
The book’s content
Homeopathy has been repeatedly discussed on this blog and elsewhere. Rather than repeating what has already been said ad nauseam about homeopathy, I’ll just mention a few of the points in the new book that struck me as interesting or noteworthy.
Epiphanies. Ernst says he was struck by the fact that almost all of the prominent homeopaths were converted by some personal, highly emotional epiphany. They say they started out as skeptics, and they claim to have a scientific mind; but their faith cannot be shaken by rational arguments.
Ullman. There is an entry in the Lexicon on Dana Ullman, a notorious supporter of homeopathy who has appeared repeatedly in the SBM comments. It quotes a judge who rejected Ullman’s expert testimony as “not credible” because of Ullman’s bias against conventional medicine, which Ullman views as witchcraft.
Vitalism. Ernst stresses that homeopathic theory is reliant on the outdated concept of vitalism. Although they have looked for a reality-based explanation, homeopaths basically believe some kind of spirit-like essence pervades the remedies and is responsible for their action.
Homeopathy is attractive. He explains what attracts consumers to homeopathy: it is risk-free; it offers compassion, empathy, and hour-long consultations; it doesn’t cause side effects like pharmaceuticals do. He cites a study showing that homeopathy’s patients are more likely than conventional medicine’s patients to be critical of mainstream medicine, to believe their general health could be improved, and to have higher psychiatric morbidity.
It fulfills a need. Ernst acknowledges that homeopathy fills a need. Patients want to establish a caring therapeutic relationship with a trusted provider, and they often fail to find that in conventional medicine. That doesn’t mean homeopathy is better than conventional medicine, or even that homeopathy is a viable alternative; it means conventional medicine can do better, and it might even learn a thing or two from homeopathy about establishing a good patient-provider relationship.
Guidance for patients. He provides guidance for patients consulting a homeopath or self-medicating with homeopathic remedies, including not using it as a replacement for proven conventional care and keeping their health care provider informed.
Cost-effectiveness. It has been claimed that homeopathy is less expensive, but cost-effectiveness research has not identified a single condition for which homeopathy would appear to be more cost-effective than the appropriate conventional treatment.
Ebola. There is an entry for Ebola in the Lexicon. There are few conditions that homeopaths do not claim to treat successfully. In 2014 a team of homeopaths went to Africa to treat patients with Ebola.
Real life effectiveness. Since scientific studies tend not to support their beliefs, homeopaths have introduced the concept of “real life effectiveness” to describe the effectiveness of the treatment itself plus all other phenomena that might be involved (placebo response, natural course of illness, regression to the mean, etc.). Ernst simply says “this is not an accepted concept in conventional medical research.” Of course it isn’t, and it shouldn’t be, for the obvious reasons.
Informed consent. Informed consent is an ethical imperative. For homeopathy, informed consent should provide this relevant information:
    • Homeopathy is not biologically plausible
    • Its effectiveness is unproven
    • Not all homeopathic remedies are entirely free of risks
    • Better treatments for the condition in question might be available
Variants of homeopathy. Ernst explains that there is not just one homeopathy but many. The most popular ones are auto-isopathy, classical homeopathy, clinical homeopathy, complex homeopathy, homotoxicology, and isopathy. There are also derivatives of homeopathy, including anthroposophical medicine, Bach flower remedies, and Schuessler salts.
Faulty criticism on both sides
Homeopaths have not been able to address criticism rationally. They think their critics fall into only two groups: those who are ignorant and repeat propaganda they’ve heard, and those who know homeopathy works but have a vested interest in destroying it.
Both homeopaths and their critics have used faulty arguments. He lists 20 spurious arguments by proponents, including the arguments that homeopathy has never been proven wrong, that Nobel Prize winners have used it, that it can’t be studied with clinical trials, and that only expert homeopaths can understand homeopathy well enough to competently criticize it. He lists and demolishes these seven spurious arguments by opponents of homeopathy:
    • In its 200-year history, homeopathy has done no good at all
    • There are no plausible theories to explain homeopathy
    • There is no credible evidence at all that supports homeopathy
    • All homeopaths are charlatans who have nothing to offer to their patients
    • Patients who use homeopathy must be stupid
    • The assumptions of homeopathy are being treated like dogmas
    • Homeopathy is a cult
Conclusion: The people who need to read this book won’t
My favorite book on homeopathy used to be Jay Shelton’s Homeopathy: How It Really Works. It is not as complete as Ernst’s book, but it tells the same story and it might still be the best introduction for the average reader, more accessible and written in a more entertaining style that is more likely to hold the reader’s interest. But for doctors, scientists, educated laymen, and for anyone seeking a more complete story, Ernst’s book is unbeatable. It should be the last word on homeopathy.
For that matter, Oliver Wendell Holmes’ “Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions” should have been the last word when it was published in 1842. For the reasons explained in Ernst’s book, homeopathy has endured and will continue to endure; and the people who most need to read this book won’t.

   Basic Science/Theory

   Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part I
Kimball Atwood 
Link
Introduction
“Either homeopathy works or controlled trials don’t!”
—Scottish homeopath David Reilly at the 2001 Harvard Medical School Complementary and Integrative Medicine Conference.
Reilly based that assertion on his own series of four small studies of homeopathic treatments of hay fever, asthma, and allergic rhinitis, the outcomes of which had been inconsistent and largely subjective. (1) Later he explained that small-minded skeptics in “conventional medicine” assume “homeopathy doesn’t work because it can’t work,” a view echoed by conference host Dr. David Eisenberg, then the Director of the Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education at Harvard Medical School (now of the Osher Center); these comments were met with appreciative laughter from the partisan audience. If such charges were valid, it would indeed be fortunate that Harvard Medical School, several other medical schools, and the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) are promoting homeopathy, both as a clinical method and as a topic worthy of research.
The inconvenient truth, however, is that for homeopathy and many other implausible health claims, Dr. Reilly was correct: controlled trials don’t work.
This will be a multi-part blog that develops that argument.† In so doing it will expose a major weakness of Evidence Based Medicine: that its calculus does not incorporate plausibility in a useful way. It will also offer examples of hazards that result from this problem.
History
The German Samuel Christian Hahnemann invented homeopathy in the late 18th century shortly before the proposal, by Avogadro, that would forever banish it to the realm of pseudoscience. In an effort to understand the widely-accepted efficacy of Peruvian Cinchona bark in the treatment of “intermittent [or ‘swamp’] fever,” Hahnemann took some himself:
“I took by way of experiment, twice a day, four drams of good China (Cinchona). My feet, finger ends, etc., at first became cold; I grew languid and drowsy, then my heart began to palpitate, and my pulse grew hard and small; intolerable anxiety, trembling, prostration, throughout all my limbs; then pulsation in the head, redness of my cheeks, thirst, and in short, all these symptoms which are ordinarily characteristic of intermittent fever, made their appearance, one after the other, yet without the peculiar chilly, shivering rigor, briefly, even those symptoms which are of regular occurrence and especially characteristic – as the dullness of mind, the kind of rigidity in all the limbs, but above all the numb, disagreeable sensation, which seems to have its seed in the periosteum, over every bone in the body – all these made their appearance. This paroxysm lasted two or three hours each time, and recurred if I repeated this dose, not otherwise; I discontinued it, and was in good health.” (2)
Hahnemann’s interpretation of this experience was that the elicitation of “symptoms which are ordinarily characteristic of intermittent fever” offered the key to the mechanism of action of the remedy. From this he deduced the “law” that gives homeopathy its name: the “law of similars.” This states that the best remedy for a condition is a substance that, when given to a healthy person, mimics the symptoms of the condition. Hahnemann’s singular experience with cinchona bark was the sole experimental basis for his first “law,” and it is still widely quoted in homeopathic literature that “Cinchona bark was to Hahnemann what the falling apple was to Newton and the swinging lamp to Galileo.” (3)
Science Intervenes
Later it was discovered that quinine, an ingredient of Cinchona bark, has a specific anti-malarial effect. (4) The mechanism of action has been elucidated, and it has nothing to do with “like cures like,” vitalism, “dynamism,” or any other process proposed by Hahnemann or his followers. Nor does it have to do with host defenses, even those that are real. Thus the very foundation of homeopathy has been definitively disproved. It has recently been proposed that Hahnemann’s own experience was a hypersensitivity reaction to quinine.(5)
Hahnemann’s conclusion was not so unreasonable for its time, when most therapeutic hypotheses were based more on tradition and folklore than on science. “Like cures like” was a variant of the “sympathetic magic” theme common to the folk medicine of many cultures. (6) Contemporary explanations for the effectiveness of cinchona bark, one of the few useful remedies of the day, had to do with its “astringency” and its “tonic effect on the stomach.” (7,8) Neither these theories nor Hahnemann’s were close to the truth, but they can be forgiven for a time when medical science lacked molecular theory, physiology, pharmacology, or the germ theory.
Armed with his imagined insight, Hahnemann set about to investigate the proper uses of the pharmaceuticals of his day, by a process he called “provings.” This he did by taking substances himself or feeding them to his family, and noting the subsequent “symptoms.” (9) Many of these agents, e.g., arsenic and mercury, were highly toxic. Hahnemann eventually decided that the less that was used, the better the outcome. This decision, fortunate as it was for his children, led Hahnemann to formulate his second law: the “law of infinitesimals.” This states that the more dilute a preparation is, the more potent. The series of dilutions and shakings (“succussions”) that characterizes the preparation of every homeopathic “remedy” is known as “potentizing.” Ultra-dilute solutions are claimed to aid the body’s “vital force.”
Typical homeopathic preparations are diluted 10¹²-1060 times. Thanks to Avogadro, it can be calculated that dilutions much beyond 10-23 contain nary a molecule of the original substance, or even any molecules of the diluent that had been in contact with the original substance, or any molecules of the diluent that had been in contact with that diluent, on ad infinitum. In addition, most completed “remedies” consist of a drop of diluent (water and/or alcohol) applied to a sugar pill and allowed to dry. Thus not only must any theory of action account for an increase in effect as the dilution approaches that at which none of the original substance remains, but it also must account for how such “memory” is amplified and transferred to multiple, further dilutions and ultimately retained by a sugar pill after the diluent has evaporated. It also must explain how the sugar pill lacks “memory” of any contaminants that may have been in contact with the diluent, among which must be every substance on the planet that has ever been in contact with water. Finally, such a remedy must act according to the first law of homeopathy, “like cures like,” the basis for which is known to be spurious.
The second “law” thus posits an incremental increase in the informational content of a preparation even as the original, purported source of that information, along with its fluid environment, progressively decreases to the point of nonexistence. This is incompatible with the facts of probability, of which information theory and the second law of thermodynamics are manifestations. Acceptance of Hahnemann’s own “second law” would require discarding evidence for the statistical nature of information decay that is tested and confirmed, in this era of electronics, countless times every millisecond. It would require overthrowing a universal law that Einstein called “the only physical theory…which I am convinced…will never be overthrown.” (10)
Next Week: “Symptoms,” “Provings” and More
References:
1) Taylor M A, Reilly D, Llewellyn-Jones R H, McSharry C, Aitchison T C, Lancaster T, and A Vickers. Randomised controlled trial of homoeopathy versus placebo in perennial allergic rhinitis with overview of four trial series. Commentary: Larger trials are needed. BMJ 2000; 321:471-476.
2) Quoted in Thomas WE. Hahnemann’s Allergy to Quinine. 1998. Accessed 1/08 at: http://web.archive.org/web/20030402035507/http://www.angelfire.com/va/quinine/allergy.html
3) Discussed in Thomas WE. Hahnemann’s Allergy to Quinine. Op cit.
4) Tracy JW and Webster LT. Drugs used in the chemotherapy of protozoal infections: malaria. In: Hardman JG, Limbird LE, Gilman AG. Goodman & Gilman’s The Pharmacological Basis of Therapeutics, 10th Edition. McGraw-Hill, New York 2001. pp. 1069-1095
5) Thomas WE. Hahnemann’s Allergy to Quinine (op cit.).
6) Stevens P. Magical thinking in complementary and alternative medicine. Skeptical Inquirer 25, 6: 32-37 (Nov/Dec 2001)
7) Thomas WE. Hahnemann’s Allergy to Quinine (op cit.).
Ransom S. Homoeopathy: What Are We Swallowing? Credence Publications. Uckfield, East Sussex, England 1999. P. 23.
9) Ransom S. Homoeopathy: What Are We Swallowing? Op cit. pp. 32-34,
10) Einstein A (1949), quoted in Harrison DM: Life, Emerging Structures, and the Second Law of Thermodynamics. Updated 2/2006. Accessed 12/07 at: http://www.upscale.utoronto.ca/GeneralInterest/Harrison/LifeEnergy/LifeAndThermo.html

   Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part I
Kimball Atwood 
Link
Part I of this blog† summarized the origin of homeopathy, invented in 1790 by Samuel Christian Hahnemann. It discussed Hahnemann’s first two “homœopathic laws of nature,” similia similibus curantur (like cures like) and the “law of infinitesimals,” and showed that his rationales for each have long been refuted. Hahnemann proclaimed a third doctrine, the “law of psora” ["itch"], said by him to be “the mother of all true chronic diseases except the syphilitic and sycotic.”[1] Oddly, it seems to have been forgotten.
Part II gives Hahnemann the opportunity to explain his assertions more thoroughly, as is his due. It considers those assertions from the vantage point of modernity, as is ours.
“Leave None of them Uncured”
According to Hahnemann, homeopathy is a panacea:
“Now, however, in all careful trials, pure experience, the sole and infallible oracle of the healing art, teaches us that actually that medicine which, in its action on the healthy human body, has demonstrated its power of producing the greatest number of symptoms similar to those observable in the case of disease under treatment, does also, in doses of suitable potency and attenuation, rapidly, radically and permanently remove the totality of the symptoms of this morbid state, that is to say, the whole disease present, and change it into health; and that all medicines cure, without exception, those diseases whose symptoms most nearly resemble their own, and leave none of them uncured.”[2]
How might this happen?
“Dynamic Deranging Irritations of the Vital Force”
Hahnemann proposed that if two diseases with similar symptoms strike a patient, the “stronger” disease will invariably cure the “weaker.” Moreover, “the human body is much more disposed to let its state of health be altered by medicinal forces than by natural disease.”[3] Thus, by simulating the symptoms of a disease, homeopathic medicines “substitute themselves for the natural morbid affection, and thereby deprive the latter of all influence upon the vital force.”[4]
Hahnemann and most of his contemporaries believed in a supernatural “vital force.” “Vitalism” was the explanation for life itself, which was thought not to conform to the same physical and chemical principles that appeared to govern non-living processes. According to Hahnemann, “during health a spiritual power (autocracy, vital force) animates the organism and keeps it in harmonious order.”[5] Diseases, he believed, “are purely dynamic deranging irritations of the vital force.” Thus “to regard those diseases that are not surgical as a peculiar distinct thing residing in the human frame is an absurdity which has rendered allopathy so pernicious.”[6] In other words, diseases other than surgical (few, at the time) were not to be explained by material processes.
Again, Science Intervenes
The sweeping discoveries of the century or so following Hahnemann’s epiphany rendered “vitalism” obsolete. Among these were advances in physiology, chemistry and biochemistry demonstrating that biological processes conform to the same physical laws that govern non-living entities, and the refutation, by Louis Pasteur in 1861, of “spontaneous generation.”[7] The Germ Theory of disease, discovered by Pasteur, Koch and others, and advances in pathology, pathophysiology, biochemistry, nutrition, pharmacology, toxicology, genetics, and immunology have proved beyond any doubt that diseases are entirely explicable as “peculiar distinct thing[s] residing in the human frame,” even if not all diseases have yet been explained. In summary, there is no need to invoke supernatural theories to account for either normal biological processes or diseases.
The great 19th century French physiologist Claude Bernard understood this by 1865, when he wrote:
“When an obscure or inexplicable phenomenon presents itself, instead of saying ‘I do not know,’ as every scientific man should, physicians are in the habit of saying, ‘this is vitalism’; apparently without the least idea that they are explaining darkness by still greater darkness…. Vitalism is nothing but a word that means ignorance, and when we characterize a phenomenon as ‘vital,’ it amounts to saying that we do not know its immediate cause or its conditions.” [8]
Homeopathy vs. “Allopathy”
As suggested in Part I, Hahnemann’s first law (“like cures like”) was nothing new. The second law (“infinitesimals”) was certainly the basis for the early, apparent success of homeopathy, when the practice contrasted with the harsh, frequently toxic ministrations of contemporary European medicine. Hahnemann himself called attention to the difference:
“…homœopathy sheds not a drop of blood, administers no emetics, purgatives, laxatives or diaphoretics, drives off no external affection by external means, prescribes no warm baths or medicated clysters, applies no Spanish flies or mustard plasters, no setons, no issues, excites no ptyalism, burns not with moxa or red-hot iron to the very bone, and so forth, but gives with its own hand its own preparations of simple uncompounded medicines, which it is accurately acquainted with, never subdues pain by opium, etc.”[9]
“Allopathy” was the term coined by Hahnemann to dramatize the contrast between homeopathy and its competition. According to Hahnemann, “allopathic” medicine sought to give only medicines that suppressed symptoms:
“In order to give a general notion of the treatment of diseases pursued by the old school of medicine (allopathy)… Whenever it can, it employs, in order to keep in favour with its patient, remedies that immediately suppress and hide the morbid symptoms by opposition (contraria contrariis) for a short time (palliatives), but that leave the disposition to these symptoms (the disease itself) strengthened and aggravated.”[10] (parentheses in the original)
That assertion was not really applicable to the medicine of Hahnemann’s time (bloodletting, purging and many other treatments derided by Hahnemann were used because they supposedly drew the causative pernicious humours from the body—not in an attempt to “suppress and hide the morbid symptoms”). It has even less to do with modern medicine, although homeopaths still denigrate drugs that ameliorate unpleasant symptoms (pain, for example),[11] and frown on any class of agents whose name includes the prefix “anti-,” whether the root word refers to a symptom (antidepressant) or not (antibiotic).
Hahnemann considered nothing other than symptoms—albeit “symptoms” that competent physicians then and now would find preposterous, as we shall see—because “If all the symptoms be eradicated, the disease is always cured internally also.”[12]Thus it is ironic that his statements about “allopathy” appear to be the basis for the now-common claim among homeopaths, naturopaths, “integrative” physicians, and others that they “seek to identify and remove the underlying causes of illness, rather than to eliminate or merely suppress symptoms.”
The term “allopathic” is of historical interest only; it has no role in describing modern medicine. Its use by modern “CAM” advocates is usually pejorative, as it was when used by Hahnemann himself. It is naïve when used by legitimate physicians, who appear unaware that they are misrepresenting their profession. The misnomer is especially regrettable when found in the language of state medical boards and agencies of the federal government, betraying the ignorance of those presumed by the citizenry to be experts.
“Provings” and “Symptoms”
Determinations of the type of substance and the dose (that is, the dilution) used in homeopathic preparations are made by “provings”: a homeopath-’investigator’ gives a preparation to one or more healthy subjects (“provers”), who each keep a detailed diary of every sensation, feeling, mood change, physical change, and anything else that may occur to them over the next several days to months. These “symptoms” are then compiled; their aggregate is presumed to have been caused by the “remedy” that preceded them, and the result is published in a Materia Medica. The practicing homeopath, after eliciting a litany of “symptoms” from a patient, then determines the correct “remedy” by finding the most closely-matching group in the MM. [13]
Shortly before Hahnemann died, Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr., one of the innovators of modern medicine and a critic of homeopathy, considered “symptoms”–as the term is used by homeopaths:
“The following list was taken literally from the Materia Medica of Hahnemann, by my friend M. Vernois, for whose accuracy I am willing to be responsible. He has given seven pages of these symptoms, not selected, but taken at hazard from the French translation of the work. I shall be very brief in my citations.
“ ‘After stooping some time, sense of painful weight about the head upon resuming the erect posture.’
“ ‘An itching, tickling sensation at the outer edge of the palm of the left hand, which obliges the person to scratch.’ The medicine was acetate of lime, and as the action of the globule taken is said to last twenty-eight days, you may judge how many such symptoms as the last might be supposed to happen.
“Among the symptoms attributed to muriatic acid are these: a catarrh, sighing, pimples; ‘after having written a long time with the back a little bent over, violent pain in the back and shoulder-blades, as if from a strain,’—‘dreams which are not remembered—disposition to mental dejection—wakefulness before and after midnight.’
“I might extend this catalogue almost indefinitely. I have not cited these specimens with any view to exciting a sense of the ridiculous, which many others of those mentioned would not fail to do, but to show that the common accidents of sensation, the little bodily inconveniences to which all of us are subject, are seriously and systematically ascribed to whatever medicine may have been exhibited, even in the minute doses I have mentioned, whole days or weeks previously.
“To these are added all the symptoms ever said by anybody, whether deserving confidence or not…”[14]
Are today’s homeopaths as liberal in their use of the term as was Hahnemann? Yes, as we shall see next week.
References
[1] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. 5th Edition (1833) translated by Dudgeon. 6th Edition (1842?) translated by Boericke. Available at: http://www.homeopathyhome.com/reference/organon/organon.html
[2] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[3] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[4] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[5] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[6] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[7] Pasteur L. 1861. Memoire sur les corpuscles organizes qui existent dans l’atmosphere. Examen de la doctrine des generations spontanees. [On the organized bodies which exist in the atmosphere; examination of the doctrine of spontaneous generation]. Annales des sciences naturelles, 4th series, vol. 16, pp. 5-98. Excerpt translated in: Brock TD (translator and editor). Milestones in Microbiology. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, Inc.; 1961. pp. 43-48
[8] Bernard, Claude. An Introduction to the Study of Experimental Medicine. Translated by Greene HC. New York: Macmillan; 1865 [Reprinted in 1927, p. 201]. Quoted in “Medicine in quotations online.” American College of Physicians website. Accessed 2002 at: http://www.acponline.org/cgi-bin/medquotes.pl?subject=Vitalism (no longer available online)
[9] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[10] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[11] Jonas, Wayne B. and Jennifer Jacobs. Healing with Homeopathy: the Doctors’ Guide. New York: Warner Books; 1996. P. 10
[12] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[13] Borneman JP, Field RI. Regulation of Homeopathic Drug Products. Am J Health-Syst Pharm. Vol. 63 (2006): 86-91. Available at: http://nationalcenterforhomeopathy.org/articles/regulation_of_homeopathic_drug_products.pdf
[14] Holmes, OW. Homeopathy and its Kindred Delusions. Two Lectures to the Boston Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge (1842). Available at: http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/holmes.html

   Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part III
Kimball Atwood 
Link
“Symptoms,” Continued
Part II of this blog† introduced the homeopathic understanding of “symptoms” as they pertain both to “provings” in healthy subjects (now called “homeopathic pathogenic trials” or “HPTs”) and to histories elicited from patients. Hahnemann conflated “symptoms” and every random itch, ache, pain, sniffle, feeling, thought, dream, pimple or other sign, and anything else that might occur to a subject or a patient. This was amply demonstrated by Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr., who seemed to doubt that such a morass would yield useful information. As unlikely as it may seem, today’s homeopaths are every bit as whimsical in their elicitation of “symptoms” as was Hahnemann.
The following examples are quoted from Homeopathic Medicine for Children and Infants by Dana Ullman, MPH, a contemporary homeopath who is respected in “integrative medicine” circles. Notice the ambiguous warning in his introduction:
Asthma is a potentially serious and even life-threatening condition. Infants and children with asthma should receive medical attention. Conventional drugs used for treating asthma, particularly steroids, can impair immune function and lead to more serious health problems. Homeopathic constitutional care is necessary to achieve a lasting cure of asthma, while the following remedies can often be helpful in reducing the distress that an acute attack can create.
Aconitum: This remedy is very useful at the very beginning stages of onset of asthmatic breathing. Noticeably present is anxiety, fear, and restlessness with the asthma.
Antimonium tart: The characteristic symptom of children who need this remedy is a rattling cough with an inability to expectorate mucus. Their condition is sometimes precipitated after being angered or annoyed. They feel drowsy, weak, and feeble, and their symptoms are usually worse at 4 a.m. Their difficulty in breathing may cause them to sit up rather than lie down. Concurrent with these breathing difficulties is anxiousness, restless, and irritability. They feel chilly but are averse to stuffy warm rooms and desire cool rooms and open windows. This remedy is rarely given at the beginning of an illness.
Arsenicum: Restlessness and anxiety are prominent with asthmatic children who need this remedy. As the asthma continues, they get more and more frightened and agitated. Their symptoms are worse from midnight to 2 a.m., and they will toss and turn in bed, unable to find a comfortable position. Their breathing is best when sitting erect. Despite their restlessness, they are tired and weak. They are very chilly and better by warmth. They are noticeably thirsty but for only sips of water at a time.
Chamomilla: This remedy should be considered for asthma brought on after a tantrum. Chamomilla children are very impatient during their suffering. They have a hard, dry cough during sleep, and their difficult breathing is relieved from bending their head backwards, being in cold air, or drinking cold water.
Ipecac: Persistent nausea with a loose cough and a rattling in the chest but an inability to expectorate are characteristic of children who need this remedy. They have wheezing and tenacious mucus that is blood-streaked. Vomiting provides some relief of their symptoms because it helps to eliminate some mucus. Their symptoms are worse in hot, humid weather and are aggravated by the least motion. They experience cold perspiration of the extremities. They may also have difficulty sleeping and excessive salivation.
Lobelia: This remedy is known for curing asthmatic breathing concurrent with nausea and vomiting. These children usually have prickling sensations all over, even on the fingers and toes, that precedes the asthma. The asthma is aggravated by exposure to cold. The child may feel weakness in the pit of the stomach and a sensation of a lump above the sternum (the chest bone).
Nux vomica: This remedy is good for treating asthma when children have fullness in the stomach, especially in the morning or after eating. They have asthma with choking, anxiety, pressure in the pit of the belly, humming in the ears, quick pulse, and sweating. Their attack is sometimes incited by hay fever. They feel they must loosen clothing around their waist. Emotionally, they are more irritable than fearful.
Pulsatilla: These children have asthmatic breathing in warm or stuffy rooms, in warm weather, or after eating fatty or rich foods. They want windows opened and cool air. They are more apt to have breathing difficulties in the evening, especially after a meal. They crave sympathy and the company of others. They are very clingy and needy. They are highly impressionable: if parents are anxious about the child, the child becomes more anxious, but if parents are confident in the child’s ability to get healthy soon, the child will be soothed.
Sambucus: These children get their asthma attack during sleep, commonly awakening them at 3 a.m. Their breathing is obstructed when they lie down and partially relieved when they sit up as they gasp for air. Their breathing improves while they sit up, but then is aggravated when they lie back down to sleep, only to rise again gasping for air. They sweat profusely during their waking hours but tend not to perspire during sleep.
Spongia: This remedy is known to be helpful for children with asthma who have a dry, barking, croupy cough. Their air passages are dry, the sputum is absent, and the voice is hoarse. The asthma and coughing can be exacerbated by cold air, warm rooms, tobacco smoke, talking, lying with the head low, drinking cold fluids, or eating sweets. The symptoms also tend to be worse in the early part of the night. Warm food or drinks, even in small doses, provide some relief, as does sitting up and leaning forward.
Homeopaths at the most conspicuous levels of academic “CAM” are no more discriminating. The following excerpts are from a book co-written by a past Director of the NIH Office of Alternative Medicine, who is now President and CEO of the Samueli Institute, which receives millions of dollars of federal grants for its Center for Research on Integrative Medicine in the Military; and by a past President of the American Institute of Homeopathy, who is Clinical Assistant Professor, Dept. of Epidemiology, University of Washington in Seattle:
Pulsatilla: “…indicated for the child who is very weepy and clingy, and wants to be held…the child’s mood is extremely changeable…better in the open air…very little thirst, refusing to drink…often a nasal discharge with thick yellow or green mucus.”
Belladonna: “…for the earache that comes on suddenly and with great intensity. The fever can be as high as 104º with a bright red, hot, flushed face and dilated pupils…there can also be delirium during sleep, with nightmares, especially of animals, causing the child to cry out.”
Chamomilla: “The child is extremely irritable and changeable, not knowing what he wants…the only thing that will calm him down is to be carried back and forth continually…Green stools are a common accompanying symptom, especially in cases of otitis that are associated with teething.”
Hepar Sulphur: “…indicated in a child who is very chilly…the ear pain is…a sticking or poking pain…worse from exposure to cold air…also indicated in cases of earache from referred pain from the throat.”
Mercurius vivius: “This patient has an erratic internal thermostat, alternating from extreme chills to flushes of heat and profuse sweating…Offensiveness is a characteristic that runs through Mercurius…a peculiar symptom is swelling of the tongue with indentation marks from the teeth.”[1]
Only such impressions are important. As previously explained, “the disease consists only of the totality of its symptoms” and “the physician needs only to remove the totality of the symptoms in order to cure the disease.”[2] About half of the 1300 entries in the US Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia are based on “provings” that occurred in the 19th century.[3] About 65 are attributable to Hahnemann himself, including most of those commonly prescribed by homeopaths of today.
Homeopaths claim that “provings” are scientific, but several recent studies have failed to demonstrate that they yield reproducible data. As might be expected from the myriad “symptom” descriptions that homeopaths are likely to hear, agreement among practitioners is also unlikely. Thus there is no reason to predict that different homeopaths would prescribe the same “remedy” even if faced with the same patient presentation.
Pseudoscientific “Innovations”
Some homeopathic “remedies” are “constitutional,” based on the practitioner’s interpretation of the patient’s personality type, physical type, dietary preferences, sleeping patterns, and so forth. Others, “nosodes,” are claimed to be equivalent to legitimate vaccines but much safer. These categories seem to be the bases for homeopathic pretensions to “wellness” and “prophylaxis.” Homeopaths prescribe both these and “acute remedies” to patients but usually not at the same time because, according to Hahnemann, “In no case is it requisite to administer more than one single, simple medicinal substance at one time.”[4]
Nevertheless, some contemporary homeopaths believe otherwise, though not for any reason based in evidence. Similarly, because the practice has existed for over 200 years and has never been subjected to real scientific rigor by its proponents, increasingly fanciful “remedies” have been invented. Examples include “potentized noise,” “potentized moonlight,” and “potentized sunlight.”[5] The pattern of continued adherence to an arbitrary belief system, unchecked by science but prone to increasingly fantastic “innovations,” is a hallmark of pseudoscience.
Paradoxically, homeopaths cite this very phenomenon as evidence for validity:
“[Hahnemann’s] observations, indications, and directions have remained constant for over two hundred years and applied by thousands of homeopaths around the world without any changes; this gives weight to the reliability of his observations.
There is no other branch of medical therapeutics that can claim this degree of stability.”
—American Institute of Homeopathy.
As we shall see next week, such misleading statements are the norm, whether offered by homeopaths or by their apologists in academic medicine.
References
[1] Jonas WB, Jacobs J. Healing with Homeopathy: the Doctors’ Guide. New York, NY: Warner Books, 1996. pp. 170-172[2] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. 5th Edition (1833) translated by Dudgeon. 6th Edition (1842?) translated by Boericke. Available at: http://www.homeopathyhome.com/reference/organon/organon.html
[3] Shelton JW. Homeopathy: How it Really Works. Amherst, NY:Prometheus Books, 2004.
[4] Hahnemann SC. Organon of Medicine. Op cit.
[5] Ransom S. Homoeopathy: What Are We Swallowing? Op cit. pp. 64-68.

   Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part IV
Kimball Atwood 
Link
Homeopathy and Science
This week’s entry† is a summary of some of the tests of homeopathy. It is a necessary prelude to a discussion of how homeopaths and their apologists promote the method. Several tenets of homeopathy lend themselves to tests. The doctrine of similia similibus curantur (“like cures like”) was tested by Hahnemann himself, as introduced in Part I of this blog. It is a special case that will be discussed further below. Hahnemann’s second doctrine, “infinitesimals,” suggests laboratory, animal, and clinical studies looking for specific effects of homeopathic preparations.
“Provings,” also called “homeopathic pathogenic trials,” suggest testing “provers” for the ability to distinguish between homeopathic preparations and placebos, and suggest asking homeopaths to identify specific remedies solely by the “symptoms” they elicit in “provers.” The homeopathic interview and prescribing scheme, gathering copious “symptoms” and matching them to the appropriate “remedy” in the Materia Medica, suggests testing homeopaths for consistency in symptom interpretations and prescriptions. The clinical practice suggests outcome studies, both of individual “conditions” (with the caveat that, strictly speaking, homeopathy does not recognize disease categories—only “symptom” complexes) and of the practice as a whole.
Several of these categories overlap. Several have been tested: the results have overwhelmingly failed to confirm homeopathy’s claims. I will mention a few of the more conspicuous examples.
Cinchona Bark: the Sole Test of the “Law of Similars”
Similia similibus curantur is the sine qua non of homeopathy: Hahnemann’s “eternal, infallible law of nature.” In Part I of this series I asserted that it had been “definitively disproved.” A few dissenting comments from readers have convinced me that I did not adequately explain the nature and the limitations of the experimental basis for Hahnemann’s first “law,” and therefore that I had not justified my categorical assertion. What follows is an attempt to remedy that failing.
Hahnemann took cinchona in 1790 believing, as did most of his contemporaries, that it was curative of “intermittent fever” (or “marsh ague”). He wondered how it worked, and hoped that he might learn something by testing it on himself. His reactions, as quoted in Part I of this blog, seemed to him to be similar to (“ordinarily characteristic of”) the symptoms of intermittent fever. Thus Hahnemann had his “eureka moment”: “like cures like,” he decided, must be a universal fact of nature.
Now comes the rub: we know that cinchona actually did cure most cases of intermittent fever, the disease that we call “malaria.” Cinchona was one of the few effective remedies known to European physicians at the time. Thus the first “proving” was partly evidence-based, if only by happy coincidence: in Hahnemann’s “n-of-1” pharmacodynamic trial, he began with the correct assumption that he would study an effective treatment. In all subsequent “provings,” however, he worked in the other direction: he began by assuming the truth of the “law of similars” and sought only to collect “symptoms.” He eventually “proved” the popular “allopathic” medicines of the era, but in doing so he no longer considered what “allopaths” used those medicines for, other than to disparage such uses.
Among the 65 substances listed in Hahnemann’s Materia Medica, cinchona (“china”) was probably the only one that specifically cured a disease*—although Hahnemann could not have known that at the time. Thus even if he had thought that he experienced the “symptoms” of syphilis after taking mercury, for example, it would not have supported his doctrine of “similars”; mercury is not a specific cure for syphilis, although it was prescribed for that at the time. Many substances that Hahnemann “proved”—opium, ipecac, belladonna, digitalis, etc.—had useful physiologic effects but were not curative of diseases per se. In any event Hahnemann disparaged even the few rational uses of those drugs (e.g., digitalis to “diminish the frequency of the quick, irritated pulse”), as he discussed at length in the Introduction to his Organon.
Thus, although Hahnemann and all homeopaths since his time have held that every “proving” is further proof of the doctrine that defines homeopathy, in fact none are so. Only the very first “proving” was even partly based on a medical fact (even if Hahnemann didn’t know it), and is thus the sole test of Hahnemann’s “first law.” The rest of the evidence relevant to that first “proving,” moreover, is not flattering to similia similibus curantur. In 1820 Pelletier and Caventou isolated quinine, the active anti-malarial ingredient of cinchona bark. [1] By the late 19th century, during the flowering of the Germ Theory of disease, Alphonse Laveran had established that malaria is caused by a blood-borne parasite. In the latter part of the 20th century the mechanism of action of quinine and other anti-malarial drugs was largely elucidated, and in each case it involves killing the protozoa that cause the disease. As previously stated, “it has nothing to do with ‘like cures like,’ vitalism, ‘dynamism,’ ‘inducing the self-healing response,’ or any other process proposed by Hahnemann or his followers.”
That is why we in the modern world may assert, with utter confidence, that “the very foundation of homeopathy has been definitively disproved.” There is irony in this history. One might expect, after Hahnemann’s famous encounter with cinchona bark, that homeopaths ought to be particularly adept at curing malaria. They are not. Not only do they frequently prescribe “remedies” that have no known or plausible role in eradicating malaria parasites, but even if they prescribe “cinchona” itself they don’t actually give any; their dilutions see to that. By the time Hahnemann assembled his thoughts for the cinchona entry in his Materia Medica, the therapeutic reality of treating malaria had become unrecognizable.
Testing the “Law of Infinitesimals”: the Benveniste Affair
Modern homeopaths grant that most of their “remedies” contain none of the original substances, but claim that since they “work” there must be a reason, as yet unexplained by science. Some of their favorite explanatory candidates are “spirit-like essence” and “water memory.” The latter is the explanation that homeopaths most commonly ascribe to a series of highly publicized experiments in the 1980s by the late Frenchman Jacques Benveniste, who reported persistence of biological activity of certain antibodies even after diluting them far past the point at which any could have remained in the solution.
Benveniste’s claims were not actually consistent with homeopathy per se: the activity that he reported did not increase progressively with each new dilution, as “potentizing” would have predicted, but sputtered in a series of peaks and troughs, never exceeding the potency of the original, most concentrated sample. The qualitative biological activity, moreover, remained the same whatever the dilution—whereas homeopathy’s “like cures like” doctrine would have predicted a very different, roughly opposite effect at high dilutions (“potencies”).
Nevertheless, any biological activity referable to a substance no longer in a preparation diluted 10^120-fold would have been news, had it been convincing. The journal Nature, with admitted trepidation, published Benveniste’s paper in 1988 after he had satisfied various requirements of reviewers. Subsequently, a three-person team visited Benveniste’s lab to give him the opportunity to repeat his experiments under their observation. The team included John Maddox, the editor of Nature; Walter Stewart, an expert in scientific error and fraud; and James (“The Amazing”) Randi, a professional magician and investigator of paranormal claims. The three found multiple flaws in the project, including a lack of checks against contamination, inadequate controls, a “disregard for statistical principles,” previously undisclosed sponsorship by a supplier of homeopathic medicines, a general belief among all in the laboratory, bordering on religious fervor, in the truth of their claims, no attempts to control for observer bias, lack of blinding in general, and no consideration of even the possibility of sampling errors.
Most importantly, the observers found that Benveniste’s results were not reproducible even when performed by his own group under lax controls, and that the experiments were a complete failure when performed under strict, double-blind conditions. Later, at least three other European labs were also unable to replicate Benveniste’s results.
In spite of these problems, or more likely because of them, Benveniste became a legend in “alternative medicine” circles. Thus Daniel Eskinazi of Columbia University’s Rosenthal Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine complained in the JAMA “Complementary, Alternative, and Integrative Medicine” series of November, 1998, that “established academic researchers have been discredited and have had difficulties when attempting to conduct alternative medicine research,” citing Benveniste as an example. But the discrediting of Benveniste was entirely justified, as reviewers of Eskinazi’s manuscript could have easily discovered. Benveniste was later the recipient of two “Ig Nobel” prizes, the first in 1991 for the project just discussed, and the second in 1998 after he had claimed to “digitize” biological messages from homeopathic dilutions and transmit them over the Internet. He died in 2004.
Other “Pre-Clinical” Tests…
…, at least until 1999, have suffered from “a lack of independent replication of any pre-clinical research in homoeopathy. In the few instances where a research team has set out to replicate the work of another, either the results were negative or the methodology was questionable.”
Clinical Tests: “Provings,” “Symptoms,” and Outcomes
As previously cited, several tests of “provings” have failed to demonstrate what homeopaths claim. Homeopaths also demonstrate poor “inter-rater reliability” in evaluating symptom diaries. Outcome studies of homeopathic treatments have not provided real evidence for specific effects. Two “meta-analyses” are worth mentioning only because they have been touted as supporting the claims of homeopaths. The first, in 1991, concluded: “The amount of positive evidence even among the best studies came as a surprise to us. Based on this evidence we would be ready to accept that homoeopathy can be efficacious, if only the mechanism of action were more plausible.” The second, in 1997, concluded: “The results of our meta-analysis are not compatible with the hypothesis that the clinical effects of homeopathy are completely due to placebo. However, we found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition.”
Subsequent reviews of those and other reports found that when corrections were made for publication bias and other method flaws, the apparent findings disappeared. Two projects involving trials of homeopathy for specific conditions are worth mentioning because they, too, are touted by proponents: the first is the series by David Reilly, mentioned at the beginning of this series. As stated, the results were “inconsistent and largely subjective.” The second was a trial of “individualized” homeopathic “remedies” for childhood diarrhea. It reported a slight, but statistically significant, reduction in the number and duration of loose stools. Subsequently our fellow blogger Wally Sampson, with co-author William London, wrote a damning critique of the diarrhea paper.
Next week: Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine
* The modern reader will recognize that Bismuthum may also be able to make that claim, but that wouldn’t have been known to Hahnemann.
References
[1] Tracy JW and Webster LT. Drugs used in the chemotherapy of protozoal infections: malaria. In: Hardman JG, Limbird LE, Gilman AG. Goodman & Gilman’s The Pharmacological Basis of Therapeutics, 10th Edition. McGraw-Hill, New York 2001. pp. 1069-1095

   Homeopathy and Evidence-Based Medicine: Back to the Future – Part V
Kimball Atwood 
Link
Homeopathy and Science: Discussion, Summary and Conclusions
I was not surprised by a couple of the dissenting comments after Part IV of this blog. One writer worried that I had neglected, presumably for nefarious reasons, to cite replications of Benveniste’s results; another cited several examples of “positive” homeopathy studies that I had failed to mention. I answered some of those points here. I am fully aware of such “positive” reports, including those seeming to support Benveniste. I didn’t cite them, but not in some futile hope of concealing their existence from the watchful eyes of the readership. I also didn’t cite several “negative” reports, including an independent, disconfirming report of one of the claims of David Reilly, whose words began this series,* and the most recent of several reviews (referenced here) to conclude that “the clinical effects of homoeopathy are placebo effects.” I didn’t cite those reports for the same reasons that I didn’t cite the “positive” studies: they are mere footnotes to the overwhelming evidence against homeopathy.
To explain why, it will be necessary to discuss some of the strengths and weaknesses of the project known as “Evidence-Based Medicine.”
“Evidence-Based Medicine” Primer
Academic defenders of homeopathy and other implausible methods argue that even though such claims are highly implausible, they still ought to be subjected to studies. It would be arrogant, they say, to simply abandon them without investigation, and there is the potential to overlook significant therapeutic advances. They argue that randomized, controlled trials (RCTs), especially those in which both subjects and investigators are blinded to the interventions, will separate the “wheat from the chaff.” This type of study is the “gold standard” for evidence of therapeutic efficacy of any heretofore-unproven treatment, and has been instrumental in the objective determination of both worthwhile and worthless treatments for several decades.
Eventually, several studies of a treatment are examined in the aggregate, in the form of “meta-analyses” (if they are similar enough to combine data) or “systematic reviews” (if they are not). If such reviews can justify a strong conclusion for or against the value of the treatment, it will typically be accepted by physicians as the most rational basis for clinical decisions. This process and its literature are keys to the practice that is collectively referred to as “evidence-based medicine” (EBM). It applies not only to therapeutic decisions, but also to diagnostic tests and other aspects of clinical medicine.
Some might be surprised to find that EBM is not synonymous with “science-based medicine.” Although based on previous, evolving standards of clinical trial designs, statistics, epidemiological methods and other pertinent tools, EBM is a semi-formal movement within modern medicine that has existed for fewer than 20 years; it comprises sets of guidelines for assessing evidence, which will be discussed further below.
EBM and “CAM”
To many in this era of EBM it seems self-evident that all unproven methods, including homeopathy, should be subjected to such scrutiny. After all, the anecdotal impressions that are typically the bases for such claims are laden with the very biases that blinded RCTs were devised to overcome. This opinion, however, is naive. Some claims are so implausible that clinical trials tend to confuse, rather than clarify the issue. Human trials are messy. It is impossible to make them rigorous in ways that are comparable to laboratory experiments. Compared to laboratory investigations, clinical trials are necessarily less powered and more prone to numerous other sources of error: biases, whether conscious or not, causing or resulting from non-comparable experimental and control groups, cuing of subjects, post-hoc analyses, multiple testing artifacts, unrecognized confounding of data due to subjects’ own motivations, non-publication of results, inappropriate statistical analyses, conclusions that don’t follow from the data, inappropriate pooling of non-significant data from several, small studies to produce an aggregate that appears statistically significant, fraud, and more.
Most of those problems are not apparent in primary reports. Several have already been discussed or referenced elsewhere on this site: here, here, here and here, for example. Academics active in the EBM movement are aware of most of them and want to correct them—as a quick scan of the contents of almost any major medical journal will reveal.
It is clear that such biases are more likely to skew the results of studies that are funded or performed by advocates. This has been found in studies of trials funded by drug companies, for example, as referenced here. In the case of “CAM,” the charge is supported by the preponderance of favorable reports in advocacy journals (here, here, and here) and by examples of overwhelmingly favorable reports emanating from regions with strong political motivations.
For those reasons we can predict that RCTs of ineffective claims championed by impassioned advocates will demonstrate several characteristics. Small studies, those performed by advocates or reported in advocacy journals, and those judged to be of poor quality will tend to be “positive.” The larger the study and the better the design, the more likely it is to be “negative.” Over time, early “positive” trials and reviews will give way to negative ones, at least among those judged to be of high quality and reported in reputable journals. In the aggregate, trials of ineffective claims championed by impassioned advocates will appear to yield equivocal rather than merely “negative” outcomes. The inevitable, continual citations of dubious reports will lead some to judge that the aggregate data are “weakly positive” or that the treatment is “better than placebo.” An example is the claim that stimulation of the “pericardium 6” acupuncture point is effective in the prevention and treatment of post-operative nausea and vomiting—a purportedly proven “CAM” method.
Homeopathic “Remedies” are Placebos
After 200 years and numerous studies, including many randomized, controlled trials (RCTs) and several meta-analyses and systematic reviews, homeopathy has performed exactly as described above. The best that proponents can offer is equivocal evidence of a weak effect compared to placebo. That is exactly what is expected if homeopathy is placebo.
Nevertheless, EBM advocates on the whole don’t see it that way. Those who want to see homeopathy vindicated, such as homeopath Wayne Jonas, the former director of the NIH Office of Alternative Medicine, point to the weakly positive evidence. Others, even those who find homeopathy implausible, are so convinced that EBM can answer the question (“Either homeopathy works or controlled trials don’t!”) that they call for more trials, with no end in sight. Such judgments expose a major weakness in EBM that is not apparent when the exercise is applied to plausible claims.
Evidence-Based Medicine and Evidence
When I use a word,” Humpty Dumpty said in a rather a scornful tone, “it means just what I choose it to mean — neither more nor less.
“The question is,” said Alice, “whether you can make words mean different things.”
“The question is,” said Humpty Dumpty, “which is to be master — that’s all.”
There are sources of substantial error in EBM that apply more to trials of implausible than plausible claims, and that are generally not acknowledged by academics. The first is that the EBM “levels of evidence” hierarchy renders each entry sufficient to trump those below it (Figure). Thus a “positive” clinical trial is given more weight than “physiology, bench research or ‘first principles’,” even when the latter definitively refute the claim.
For judging homeopathy, EBM deems the equivocal results of clinical efficacy trials to be of more value than other evidence discussed in this series: definitive refutation of the “law of similars”; the doctrine of “infinitesimals” violating the second law of thermodynamics; no coherent bases for predicting consistency or validity of “symptoms” and “provings,” or of the homeopathic prescribing scheme, and studies confirming the lack of such validity; definitive refutations of Hahnemann’s magical “theories” of what diseases are and how homeopathy works, based on his notions of “Dynamic Deranging Irritations of the Vital Force”; later homeopaths’ arbitrary inventions of more implausible treatments, e.g., “nosodes” and “constitutional” prescribing; recent inventions of fantastic theories to explain the failings of the rest, e.g., “water memory,” “non-local” (psychic?) explanations or “quantum-like” effects to explain the “entanglement-disrupting effects of blinding” in clinical trials, and more.
Another way of thinking about this is to observe that homeopathy lacks several criteria that suggest a viable hypothesis: simplicity, conservatism, fruitfulness, and scope. [1] Regarding the last two, is there anything in nature that the tenets of homeopathy—the “eternal, infallible law of nature”—can explain better than can current scientific theory? I can’t think of a single natural phenomenon that homeopathic “theory” can explain at all. [2] It doesn’t even explain homeopathy in a coherent way. Other, well-characterized but mundane social and psychological factors do that much better.
When this sort of evidence is weighed against the equivocal clinical trial literature, it is abundantly clear that homeopathic “remedies” have no specific, biological effects. Yet EBM relegates such evidence to “Level 5”: the lowest in the scheme. How persuasive is the evidence that EBM dismisses? The “infinitesimals” claim alone is the equivalent of a proposal for a perpetual motion machine. The same medical academics who call for more studies of homeopathy would be embarrassed, one hopes, to be found insisting upon studies of perpetual motion machines. Basic chemistry is still a prerequisite for medical school, as far as I’m aware.
In summary, the evidence that homeopaths’ perceptions are due to something other than what they claim is comparable to the evidence that the earth is spheroid rather than planar, that the planets orbit the sun rather than the earth, that the positions and movements of planets do not affect human affairs, that Newton’s gravitational theory holds to a high degree of precision for everything from apples falling from trees to the motions and long-distance effects of space ships, comets, and other celestial bodies, even though it is incomplete, that electricity and magnetism are the same thing, that mass is conserved, that the earth is several billion years old, that its crust comprises several “plates” that move around, that species evolved by a process of variation and natural selection, that Avagadro’s number is the same on Mars as it is here, and so forth. In other words, it is the sort of basic science that can reasonably be called “established knowledge.”
Is it realistic to assume that this “level” of evidence, when brought to bear on a claim that has no explanatory power in nature, can be overthrown by ambiguous clinical trials of dubious design? EBM makes that assumption.
It wasn’t meant to be like this. When I first discussed with my fellow bloggers the curious absence of established knowledge in the EBM “levels of evidence” hierarchy, at least one insisted that this could not be true, and in a sense he was correct. David Sackett and other innovators of EBM do include basic science in their discussions, but they recommend invoking it only when there are no clinical trials to consider:
Evidence based medicine is not restricted to randomised trials and meta-analyses. It involves tracking down the best external evidence with which to answer our clinical questions…And sometimes the evidence we need will come from the basic sciences such as genetics or immunology. It is when asking questions about therapy that we should try to avoid the non-experimental approaches, since these routinely lead to false positive conclusions about efficacy. Because the randomised trial, and especially the systematic review of several randomised trials, is so much more likely to inform us and so much less likely to mislead us, it has become the “gold standard” for judging whether a treatment does more good than harm.
That statement is consistent with EBM’s formal relegation of established knowledge to “level 5,” as seen in the Figure. I am not a historian of EBM and don’t care to be, but I suspect that the explanation for this choice is that “they never saw ‘CAM’ coming.” In other words, it probably didn’t occur to Sackett and other EBM pioneers that anyone would consider performing clinical trials of methods that couldn’t pass the muster of scientific plausibility. Their primary concern was to emphasize the insufficiency of basic science evidence in determining the safety and effectiveness of new treatments. In that they were quite correct, but trials of “CAM” have since reminded us that although established knowledge may be an insufficient basis for accepting a treatment claim, it is still a necessary one.
Lacking that perspective, Sackett’s Center for Evidence-Based Medicine promulgates an “Introduction to evidence-based complementary medicine” by “CAM” researcher Andrew Vickers. There is not a mention of established knowledge in it, although there are references to several claims, including homeopathy, that are refuted by things that we already know. Vickers is also on the advisory board of the Cochrane CAM Field, along with Wayne Jonas and several other “CAM” enthusiasts. The Cochrane Collaboration is a highly respected wellspring of “evidence,” in the EBM sense of the term. But its treatment of “CAM” claims suggests that “evidence” means just what the “CAM Field” chooses it to mean—neither more nor less. Perusing the Cochrane reviews of homeopathy reveals just how far down the rabbit hole the ghost of poor Archie Cochrane, the founder, has been led:
“In view of the absence of evidence it is not possible to comment on the use of homeopathy in treating dementia.”
“There is not enough evidence to reliably assess the possible role of homeopathy in asthma. As well as randomised trials, there is a need for observational data to document the different methods of homeopathic prescribing and how patients respond.”
“There is currently little evidence for the efficacy of homeopathy for the treatment of ADHD. Development of optimal treatment protocols is recommended prior to further randomised controlled trials being undertaken.”
“Though promising, the data were not strong enough to make a general recommendation to use Oscillococcinum for first-line treatment of influenza and influenza-like syndromes. Further research is warranted but the required sample sizes are large.”
And so on.
Next Week (or maybe later; this is time-consuming): Prior Probability: The Dirty Little Secret of “Evidence-Based Alternative Medicine” †
References
[1] Schick, T Jr. and Lewis Vaughn. How to Think About Weird Things; Critical Thinking for a New Age (2nd Edition). Ch. 7. Mayfield Publishing Company. Mountain View, CA 1999
[2] Atwood KC. Homeopathy and Critical Thinking. Scientific Review of Alternative Medicine 5; 3: 146-148. Summer 2001

   Homeopathy and Plausibility
Steven Novella
Link
The fundamental concept of science-based medicine (SBM) is that medical practice should be based upon the best available science. This may seem obvious, but there are many important details to its application, such as the relationship between clinical and basic science. Clinical claims require clinical evidence, but clinical evidence can be tricky and is often preliminary. It is therefore helpful (I would say essential) to view the clinical evidence in light of all of the rest of science.
A thorough basic and clinical science analysis of a medical claim can be summarized by the term “plausibility,” or “prior probability” if you want to put it into statistical terms. When we say a certain belief is plausible we mean it is consistent with what we know from the rest of science. In other words, because of the many weaknesses of clinical evidence, in order for a therapy to be generally accepted as part of SBM it should have a certain minimal supporting clinical evidence and overall scientific plausibility.
These can exist in different proportions – for example one therapy may be highly plausible (it would be shocking if it were not true) and have modest supporting clinical evidence, while another may have unknown plausibility but with solid clinical evidence of efficacy. But no therapy should have clinical evidence that suggests lack of efficacy, nor extreme implausibility (not just an unknown mechanism, but no possible mechanism).
The poster child for extreme scientific implausibility within medicine is, arguable, homeopathy. Its “law of similars” is little more than sympathetic magic, and its “law of infinitessimals” leads to concoctions diluted to the point that they have zero active ingredient and only the magical memory left behind. It is this reality which inspired a recent review to characterize homeopathy as “witchcraft.”
What about the clinical evidence? The clinical evidence, when taken as a whole, and even if we set aside the question of plausibility, shows that homeopathy does not work. Decades of research have failed to provide supporting evidence for any application of homeopathy. It has failed to reject the null hypothesis, to show efficacy, to allow for the recommendation of homeopathy for any indication, to differentiate homeopathy from a placebo – in other words, homeopathy does not work.
If we consider the SBM criteria above, we can summarize homeopathy by saying it has extreme implausibility and the clinical evidence shows lack of efficacy. It should not work, and it does not work. There is no legitimate controversy about this. The only think keeping homeopathy alive are delusional proponents and a public (including many regulators) who do not know what homeopathy truly is.
Proponents, however, are desperately trying to keep their pseudoscience alive by misrepresenting the evidence and the arguments of homeopathy critics. A recent example of this is a paper by Peter Fisher, the Clinical Director Royal London Hospital for Integrated Medicine, and a prominent homeopath. He is trying to coin the phrase “negative plausibility bias.” His argument, essentially, is that the evidence shows homeopathy works (at least as well as medical treatments that do not work, which is an odd argument), but there is a negative plausibility bias against homeopathy which motivates scientists to reject this evidence. Fisher is both wrong and irrelevant in this position.
Fisher is wrong in arguing that the clinical evidence supports the efficacy of homeopathy. He does this by cherry picking positive studies (which are part of the noise of any clinical research), a common strategy. Meanwhile, systematic reviews do not show supporting evidence for homeopathy. Worse for homeopathy, there is a clear pattern in the research. The better designed and controlled the study, the more negative the results – a clear pattern of lack of efficacy. Even reviews that desperately try to spin the results in a positive way in the end show there is no evidence to support the efficacy of homeopathy.
The main point of the article, however, is to dismiss the scientific assessment of homeopathy as a “bias.” It seems like it is news to Fisher that plausibility is not a bias – it’s science.
Interestingly, Fisher claims that the law of similars part of homeopathy is not even controversial – and then he makes the same, tired analogies to hormesis and paradoxical drug effects, which actually have no relevance to homeopathy. Homeopathy “ingredients” are chosen for magical reasons that have no relationship to actual biology or chemistry. Further, the high dilutions of homeopathic preparations render such analogies invalid. Fisher and other homeopaths are just fishing for any possible hand-waving justification for homeopathy, but they lend nothing to its plausibility because they fail to make a scientifically coherent argument.
Fisher then essentially argues that the clinical evidence shows homeopathy works (wrong) but is rejected because of the “negative plausibility bias.” There is a kernel of truth to his view in that, in the face of extreme scientific implausibility, even modestly positive clinical evidence is looked upon as insufficient and not definitive. We can look at it this way – what are the odds that a mountain of solid basic science is wrong vs some sloppy and tricky clinical research is wrong? It would take overwhelmingly rigorous and positive clinical evidence to call into question long established principles of basic science. Homeopathy does not come anywhere close – even if we take the distorted and incorrect view of the clinical evidence Fisher is pushing.
The article is essentially Fisher whining that the scientific community is not ignoring the extreme scientific implausibility of homeopathy.
Fisher also tries to make a tu quoque argument – recycling yet another old ploy of medical pseudoscientists. He says that the evidence for antibiotic use in upper respiratory tract infections (URTI) is no different than homeopathy but practitioners use antibiotics and not homeopathy. The evidence base for any other practice is irrelevant to homeopathy, but even that aside his argument is a curious one. I agree that systematic reviews fail to show efficacy for routine antibiotic use in URTI. Therefore – they should not be used. In fact there are efforts within mainstream medicine to reduce the use of antibiotics in URTI, and to eliminate their routine use.
The story with URTI is more complex, however, because some people do get bacterial interference with URTI and there may be a role for antibiotics in selected cases – the trick is in knowing how to select those cases. More research is legitimately needed to explore these issues.
The only consistent position, therefore, is to favor the elimination of routine antibiotic use in URTI, based upon current evidence, and also to favor the complete elimination of homeopathy as a practice. Meanwhile, it is reasonable to do more research into a possible limited role of antibiotics in selected cases (based partly on plausibility). It is also reasonable to favor the abandonment of any further research into homeopathy, based on its extreme scientific implausibility.
You can call it a “negative plausibility bias” or you can call it science, based upon your perspective.

The Three Phantoms of Homeopathy
Homeopathy claims it works through a variety of mechanisms which, when explored, merely demonstrates just how little homeopaths actually know about science.
Craig D Pearcey on March 29, 2017
Link

The topic of homeopathy has been discussed at length on Science Based Medicine. These discussions include a review of its dogmas, origins, and proposed abilities as well as articles on its proponents’ more interesting claims. Also reviewed were a number of the questionable studies quoted by its proponents as evidence of effectiveness and quantifiable beneficial effects above the observed placebo. In addition, its proponents have themselves not be lax in promoting it by any stretch of the imagination. Among one of its most outspoken and vocal proponents is Dana Ullman, whose activism in the field has made him one of homeopathy’s most known unofficial spoke-men. Mr. Ullman has also written for Mr. Mike Adams’ (The Health Ranger) Natural News on more than one occasion, with his most recent publication in late 2016. A descriptive overview by Ullman of homeopathy is also available on the internet for those interested, which includes discussed references to nanodosage and some mention of quantum mechanics. The author of this article will not revise the basics of homeopathy, its origins and its central tenets in depth, but a brief discussion on homeopathy does follow to instruct the less informed reader. This article will, however, attempt to further illuminate three of the more popular homeopathic mechanisms claimed by its proponents and explain why each is scientifically unsupportable.
Samuel Hahnemann and homeopathy – A brief introduction
Homeopathy is an alternative medical system initially devised by Samuel Hahnemann in 1796, during the era leading up to the start of modern medicine. Hahnemann never actually produced a final version of homeopathy, and repeatedly updated his theories throughout his life in an attempt to keep it relevant as real scientific progress in other fields progressively showed his prior claims to be unfounded. Homeopathy’s first central tenet is essentially that “like heals like”. Thus, if a patient is exposed to a specially-presented form of the agent making him ill, in a small dosage, then the patient’s body will “learn” how to counter/heal itself from that disease. Homeopathy’s second central tenet is that the more diluted the disease-causing agent exposed to, the stronger the body’s drive to cure the patient. It should be noted that, unlike immunization, the homeopath is not exposing the patient to the actual pathogen or toxin causing the illness (in weakened/modified form) but rather the “essence” of the disease (the disease’s “miasm” as defined by homeopathy), which homeopaths believe is present in other items/objects, etc. This is why homeopaths will not present, for example, the influenza virus to the patient suffering from flu, but rather some selected plant/animal/mineral extract (in extremely diluted form) which two key homeopathic works of reference (the “material medicia” and the “repertories”) claims hold the disease’s essence. Lastly, most homeopathic formulations usually have the agent/s containing the “essence of the disease” diluted out of existence in the final formulation, but that is the whole idea given that this should be the most potent formulation according to the tenets of homeopathy.
Catalysts
The first of the three proposed mechanisms used by homeopathic proponents to explain its supposed viability is a version of hormesis, which is the process where something which causes toxicity at high doses has very different (and even beneficial) effects at lower doses. Homeopaths typically link hormesis to nanodosing. Although generally promoted in this way, homeopathic proponents have never provided a more specific mechanism around their hypothesis. However, from a scientific point of reference, catalysis would come the closest to such a proposed homeopathic/hormesistic mechanism, in particularly heterogeneous catalysis. This is clearly indicated by attempts by homeopathic proponents to discuss the scientific phenomenon of large surface-area effects at extremely small volumes. However, such attempts by these proponents show a clear lack of understanding of the principles of heterogeneous catalysis.
To begin with, catalysis comes in two general forms depending on the physical state the catalyst is in compared to the physical state of the reagents it is catalyzing (i.e. solids, liquids or gases). In homogeneous catalysis both the catalysts and the starting reagents are in the same physical phase (e.g. both in liquid phase when the catalyst is dissolved in the same solvent at the reagents). In heterogeneous catalysis the catalysts and reagents are in different physical-phases (eg. a solid catalyst imbedded in a zeolite support with gas phase reagents passing over it). Although there are many similarities between the two catalyst types, there are also some key differences.
One of the key similarities between heterogeneous and homogeneous catalysts is their general mechanism of action. For any chemical reaction to occur the reagents need to come together and form an Activating Reaction Complex. Although collisions between starting reagents are constantly happening within the solvent, such collisions do not always form an Activating Complex. The Activating Reaction Complex is always thermodynamically much more energetic than both the thermodynamic starting (initial reagents) and final (reaction products) molecular energy states. Thus, the Activating Complex is only formed if sufficient energy is inputted into the system to allow for reaction. Under normal room-temperature conditions, an insufficient numbers of reagents are energetically excited enough to allow for a significant reaction as given by the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution in the figure below:If thermal energy is added, then the chemical reaction proceeds as the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution is shifted such that a sufficient numbers of energetically excited reagents are now available for reaction. However, catalysts work by lowering the energy requirements needed to generate a viable Activating Reaction Complex, thus facilitating significant chemical reactions at lower temperatures (even down to room temperature) as given by the following energy-reaction diagram:Enzymes, which are “living” highly selective catalysts, using the well-known “lock-and-key” mechanism operate under the exact same premises. So, although homogeneous and heterogeneous catalysts use a large variety of very different chemical mechanisms to catalyze the reactions relevant to them, their general mode of action is the same (namely to lower the thermodynamic energetic levels needed to achieve reaction-driven Activating Reaction Complexes).
In terms of differences, the issue of surface-area to volume ratio, which is a key consideration for heterogeneous catalysts, is irrelevant to homogeneous catalysts. In solution (mono-phasic gas or liquid), access to and from the homogeneous catalyst is almost completely unhindered. Only solution properties (i.e. density, temperature, turbidity, viscosity and Brownian motion) determine the reaction and its speed (assuming the actual chemical reaction itself is insignificantly fast). Thus, as homogeneous catalysts exist in the same solvent phase as the reagent(s), they are extremely susceptible to the dilution process used in homeopathic remedies. At even the lower standard dilutions (i.e. a more concentrated solution) used in homeopathy, catalyst levels can easily be below the part per trillion or nanograms per litre level for a 6C dilution (dynamisation /potentisation) and are typically diluted beyond existence at 12C. At higher dilutions, the 30C favoured by Hahnemann and typically found in most homeopathic remedies, this issue of vanishing contents is even more acute with any homogeneous catalysts being diluted out of existence almost ten to the power of thirty-six times over (1036 or 10 followed by 36 zeros). Another issue that homeopathic proponents don’t account for is that any catalyst’s activity can become unmeasurably small at content levels significant higher than that above non-existence in a solution. This varies from catalyst to catalyst, but usually below approximately the parts-per-trillion level (one tenth of a 4C dilution or “X.4C”), catalytic activity is too small to be measureable.
On the other hand, heterogeneous catalysts are not dissolved in solution (like homogeneous catalysts) but form suspensions, colloids, or “mixes” instead. They tend to be solid polyhedral structures, some of which of are crystalline in nature while others are isomorphic. Those that are crystalline are formed from a repeating unit cell of one type or another, while those that are isomorphic are randomly structured. Some heterogeneous catalysts are secured on or in a solid-support matrix (eg. zeolites) while others are not. The dimensions of these polyhedral catalysts range in size from less than a dozen or so nanometers to hundreds of nanometers across. Thus, heterogeneous catalytic polyhedrals can contain anywhere from about one-hundred-thousand catalyst atoms to more than half a trillion atoms each. However, regardless of size, shape, or structure, they all have one aspect in common, namely that they catalyze reactions on their surfaces only and, thus, a high surface area-to-volume ratio is vital. It is interesting to note that aluminum silica catalysts tend to have surface-areas in the tens to lower hundreds of square-meters per gram range, while zeolites can range up into the lower thousands of square-meter per gram range. These unique properties of heterogeneous catalysts have distinctive effects when homeopathic dilutions are undertaken. The one consequence is that heterogeneous catalysts will be diluted out of solution far quicker than homogeneous catalysts once homeopathic dilution is undertaken. Even at 6C dilution, the heterogeneous catalyst polyhedrals only number six million at the most compared to 6 x 1023 atoms for a single mole of catalyst. At 12C, they have been diluted out of existence by a hundred and seventy thousand times, let alone at 30C. Another aspect of heterogeneous catalysts is that they tend to suffer from catalytic poisoning more easily. Sulphur- (sulphides and sulphites) and nitrogen- (cyanides and nitrites) containing compounds/functional-groups are among the most common catalyst poisons, stopping all catalytic activity. Other known poisons (to a lesser extent) are also certain phosphorus and halogen containing compounds/functional-groups. The relevance of these poisons is that many homeopathic proponents suggest that homeopathic solutions are able to maintain their catalytic properties upon dilution since the catalytic polyhedrals become entrapped in some sort of material web in the solution which is somehow selectively kept aside for further dilutions that eventually end up in the final homeopathic formulation. However many of these supposed materials, typically being natural in origin (eg. lipid-carbohydrate macromolecules, peptide chains, etc.) contain the very functional groups of these catalyst poisons. Thus, the supposed inclusion of such “webbing” material is more likely to lead to the poisoning of the catalyst than the retention of its activities. In addition, no viable mechanism has been provided for the “webbing”-material to be preferentially retained in the solutions used in the next step of the serial dilutions.
In the end, to use catalysis as an argument to try support the claims of homeopathy is simply fatally flawed on multiple levels.
Water memory
The second and third proposed mechanisms used by proponents to support homeopathy are both based on water memory. Generally, these take one of two forms. The first is based on a physical restructuring of the water, while the second is based on claims around something more “ethereal” – namely an “essence “.
Water clusters
For the physical version, proponents argue that as a substance is first dissolved in a volume of water or any existing solution, the water molecules arrange themselves around the substance being dissolved. This is true and typically involves the hydrogen-bonding ability of the water molecules and any partial or complete charges on the material being dissolved. In addition, the dipole of each water molecule itself also plays a major contribution to the dissolution process. In fact, without these interactions nothing could dissolve in water at all. Up to this point there is no conflict with established scientific fact. It is the claims hereafter where the proponents’ argument collapses. They claim that when this solution is further diluted, that physical voids in the water itself are formed of the same shapes/functionality as the material dissolved therein. In fact, these proponents state that the further the solution is diluted, the greater the number of these voids/functionalities which in turn provides a more potent formulation. They also believe that this dilution must also be accompanied by succussion, which is nothing more than physically striking the container with the diluted solution against a surface or edge. This then allows for this potency to be “imprinted” on the water in preparation of further dilution.
Because water is a dynamic substance, many homeopathic proponents see it as an extremely disordered system until their dilution process starts. This concept fits well with the idea of having shaped voids in the water that are permanent or long enduring in nature. However, this is not true as water, although extremely dynamic, is also highly organized. Water tends to rapidly form highly ordered structures which are spherical or oval in shape, known as water clusters, throughout the medium. However, these structures are transient and only last less than a picosecond (10-12 seconds or one millionth of a millionth of a second) before dissociating and new water clusters forming. Under such conditions, it would be impossible to maintain a physical void or functionality anywhere near even a fraction of a second, let alone the time between dilutions (let alone the time between shipping out a homeopathic preparation and someone actually buying it). Thus, the concept around a physical explanation for water memory is even far more scientifically unfounded than the catalysts argument.
High energy physics and cosmology
As stated, the third proposed mechanism used to support homeopathy is yet another appeal to water memory, but using the more “ethereal” concept around the alleged “essence” of water. This is by far the most outlandish of the three proposed mechanisms and appears to be the one Mr. Ullman favours given his mention of quantum mechanics in his aforementioned published article and elsewhere. Given how easily the prior two mechanisms can be refuted, this would be the last refuge that homeopathic proponents can retreat too while still having a “viable” argument to revert to in defense of homeopathy. What aids it further is that this argument lacks any of the specifics that would make it more easily testable and few members of the general public (particularly those with no science back-ground) know enough about quantum mechanics to examine these claims with a critical eye.
Regardless of the starting point of the homeopathic proponents around this third mechanism, all their arguments distill down to involving the modification of space-time itself on scales ranging from the sub-atomic (quarks, meons, gluons, etc.) down to the Plank scale (1.616229(38)×10−35 metres, where space-time becomes “foamy”), while still squeezing enormous potential energy into the several higher dimensions in eleven dimensional space-time as given by super-string theory, or the more up-to-date M-theory (theories this author is only minimally familiar with). However, what most of these proponents do not realize (or acknowledge) is that to achieve even a temporary modification of space-time on even these small scales (i.e. a fraction of the formulation’s mass) will always involve enormous energy densities – typical significantly more than is achieved in the 27 km CERN Large Hadron Collider. The LHC at CERN pumps in 3.5 teraelectronvolts (TeV, a trillion electronvolts) per beam (7 TeV total) into a small number of hydrogen nuclei, accelerating them to within a fraction of the speed of light (99.999%+). Using Einstein’s simplified equation for Special Relativity, E=mc2 to solve for E for a single hydrogen nucleus would clearly show the mind-blowing energies required. Alternatively, as know by Star-Trek fans, the best modified solution to Miguel Alcubierre’s warp drive theory would require the mass of the entire Voyager space-probe (825.5 kg/1,820 lb launch mass) converted to pure energy to warp space and time. Using Einstein’s E=mc2, with a portion of Voyager’s mass, also gives an idea of the energies likely involved. In addition, the warping or space and time almost always involves the use of some very unique and strange forms of matter if a black-hole of adequate mass is to be avoided. It is impossibly unlikely that any homeopath or other could meet these requirements by their protocols of dilution or to match the energy input requirements (by succussion) in any form; regardless of any possible further ill attempts by the homeopathy proponents to include the superposition-of-states (eg. Bose Einstein condensates), quantum tunneling or the Heisenberg uncertainty-principle.
Thus, as with the other two mechanism, the third is by far the most scientifically unfounded.
Conclusion: Homeopathy, there’s nothing to it!
So what can be learnt for this review? Quite simply homeopathy has absolutely no scientific founding to stand on in any form, and that the continued pursuit by its proponents is an exercise in searching for the three non-existent phantoms behind homeopathy.

Deconstructing Homeopathy Propaganda
Steven Novella on August 17, 2016
Link

The definition of “propaganda,” like so many things, is a bit fuzzy. The dictionary definition is: “information, especially of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote or publicize a particular political cause or point of view.” There is no sharp demarcation line, however.
Speech occurs on a spectrum from obsessively objective, fair, balanced, and scholarly at one end, to deliberately deceptive and manipulative propaganda at the other. Most speech is somewhere in the middle. We are all coming from a certain narrative, one which we believe is valid and important, and often speech is meant to be persuasive.
Persuasive speech promoting a point of view or certain conclusion is fine – it does not necessarily deserve the label of propaganda. The fuzzy line gets crossed, however, the more logic and evidence are compromised for the sake of the narrative.
Homeopathy propaganda
I was recently sent a particular piece of pro-homeopathy propaganda, from a website whose very name is highly biased and misleading, What Doctors Don’t Tell You. The name implies that the medical profession is hiding information from their patients and the public for some nefarious purpose, but the plucky band of rebels who run this website will give you this secret information.
This, of course, is utter nonsense. It’s just another narrative from which to promote the usual array of snake oil and dubious treatments. (Yes, those are emotional terms meant to persuade, but they are also entirely fair and accurate.)
The article in question is a defense of homeopathy, which is the poster-child for unscientific medicine. Homeopathy is a 200 year old approach to treatment that is based entirely in pseudoscience and pre-scientific superstition. It has no legitimate defense, and so defending it requires distortion and misinformation. They begin:
Ever since the birth of the National Health Service in 1948, homeopathy has been an integral part of the medical care offered by GPs and hospital doctors. Costing a tiny fraction of the NHS’s overall drug bill—£4 million out of £113 billion last year—homeopathic remedies have offered any NHS doctor who cared to do extra training a clinical alternative to the monoculture of pharmaceutical drugs. Some 400 doctors who took the training now offer homeopathy in addition to standard medical care.
But this option is now under threat, largely as a result of a decade-long propaganda campaign mounted by a small band of British ‘sceptics’ who have lobbied the UK government to ‘blacklist’ homeopathic remedies.
The facts here are accurate, but the characterization of pharmaceutical drugs as a “monoculture” is nonsense. It is not even clear what this means, but “monoculture” is a common criticism of modern agriculture, and the target audience is already primed to have a negative association with it. How are the thousands of different drugs with different mechanisms of action a monoculture, and why aren’t the more limited homeopathic options a monoculture?
The second paragraph is pure distortion. The implication is that a small band of “sceptics” (with scare quotes) are waging an unfair propaganda campaign against the public’s choice to use homeopathy.
Homeopathy is under threat because decades of research shows that it does not work. Skeptics have simply been pointing out that homeopathy lacks any scientific plausibility and the clinical evidence is consistent with lack of efficacy. The editors of WDDTY are blaming the messengers.
It is technically accurate to use the term “blacklist” because the NHS does blacklist and will not pay for treatments that it deems worthless. But WDDTY misses the point that skeptics simply do not think the government should use taxpayer money to pay for demonstrably worthless treatments. They are not lobbying to make homeopathy illegal for private use.
Next the editors phrase the debate over homeopathy as nothing but a turf war (they are referring here to the Evidence Check: Homeopathy report):
Interestingly, the Committee’s most vitriolic opponents of homeopathy were MPs with a background in conventional medicine. Indeed, from the very beginning, there’s been a turf war between two opposing medical systems: the pharmaceutical doctors and the homeopathic doctors.
No – the war is between science and pseudoscience. Notice how they characterize mainstream medicine as “pharmaceutical doctors.” Doctors, of course, use many treatment modalities including pharmacology, nutrition, surgery, physical therapy, lifestyle interventions, and in fact any intervention that is adequately science-based.
The committee did a full investigation of homeopathy, looking at all the evidence, and giving homeopaths an opportunity to defend themselves, and they correctly concluded that homeopathy is witchcraft. So again, they attack the messengers with ad hominem attacks.
After accurately reporting the main criticism of homeopathy, that extreme dilutions lack scientific plausibility, they respond:
This kind of invective means it’s a dialogue of the deaf, says Noel Thomas, a GP in South Wales. “Opponents make much of the ‘consistent failure to demonstrate effect beyond placebo’ when trials of homeopathy are studied; this is untrue. It is depressing to see the interests of patients being threatened by a small posse of poorly informed and discourteous critics, who mix a little science with denigration and abuse,” he says.
“Only a very few critics confine themselves to what they regard as scientific principles—people who believe that science knows everything about everything, and nothing remains to be explained—scientific ‘fundamentalists’, perhaps.”
This is the cry of all quacks, charlatans, cranks, and pseudoscientists. I have heard this literally hundreds of times in many contexts. I will get to the one factual claim below, that it is untrue that homeopathy consistently fails clinical trials (it does). Thomas is claiming that scientists who oppose homeopathy are threatening the interests of patients. This is the opposite of the truth. They are defending the interests of patients from charlatans who want to use magical potions as if they were valid remedies.
Critics are also not poorly informed. Just here at SBM we have a vast library of articles delving deeply into the claims and evidence regarding homeopathy. Further, correctly characterizing pseudoscience as pseudoscience is not “discourteous.”
I find that to be a very common strategy. The pattern is this: say something completely outrageous that should offend the sensibilities of anyone who is reasonably scientifically literate. When they respond with a fair but sharply critical condemnation of the outrageous pseudoscience, then attack them with accusations of being discourteous, having an agenda, or (for the bit more sophisticated) being guilty of “scientism.”
Again, this is focusing on the messenger in a desperate attempt to distract from the facts.
The editors then double down:
Dr Thomas has put his finger on the nub of the issue. The war is not about evidence, but scientific ideology. Because homeopathic medicines often contain not a single molecule of an active ingredient, opponents mock them as an affront to rationality—and indeed, a threat to the whole of science. Hence the hostility from lobbying organizations such as the self-styled Sense About Science and The Good Thinking Society (a name eerily close to Orwell’s dystopian “Ministry of Truth”), whose attacks echo those of the medieval Vatican against Galileo: it cannot be true, so it’s not.
Ah, the Galileo Gambit – there is no more certain sign of pseudoscience than comparing oneself to the great astronomer. The difference, of course, is this – the medieval Vatican based their beliefs on rigid religious dogma. The modern scientific community bases their tentative conclusions on an ongoing campaign of careful scientific investigation. See the difference?
They recast an utter lack of scientific plausibility as nothing but ideology. That demonstrates that they have no idea what science is (or are motivated to deny it).
It is also very telling that they think “The Good Thinking Society” is the equivalent of “The Ministry of Truth.” “Good Thinking” is about following a valid process. “Truth” with a capital “T” is about enforcing a rigid conclusion.
This is exactly why it is useful to examine such propaganda from proponents of nonsense – it exposes their flaws. It says much more about them than the actual targets of their commentary.
Also very telling is their response to the valid accusation that homeopathy lacks scientific plausibility. They do not respond with a counter argument of how it can be plausible, but instead just make an appeal to anecdote.
GPs who prescribe homeopathy acknowledge that their medicines’ mode of action is difficult to explain scientifically, but they cannot deny the often startling evidence of their own eyes.
Andrew Sikorski, a GP in a group practice in East Sussex, tells of a powerful experience at the end of his NHS homeopathic training in the 1990s. “I was a locum in ENT surgery at a hospital in Winchester when I was called late one night to see a male patient who arrived as an emergency with an advanced case of quinsy [a rare complication of tonsillitis]. His throat was almost completely blocked by a large abscess, and he could barely swallow his own saliva. He was very ill, with a high temperature and rapid pulse. The GP had prescribed a week of oral antibiotics, which clearly had failed.
“The correct emergency treatment was intravenous antibiotics and lancing of the abscess. However, I happened to have a first-aid homeopathic kit in my white coat pocket. To my barely tutored eye, the patient’s presentation indicated the homeopathic medicine Belladonna—fortunately part of the kit.
“With the consent of the patient and his partner, I popped a Belladonna pill into his mouth before going off to prepare the intravenous drip. I returned a few minutes later and was astounded to see the patient sipping water and talking freely. Both his pulse and temperature had reverted to near-normal and, on examination, there was no abscess whatever—just a red flush in the area of the right tonsil where the abscess had been. That extraordinarily rapid and complete response was well-nigh miraculous: no conventional treatment could have achieved anything like it.”
Homeopathy’s mode of action is not “difficult to explain,” it is as close to impossible as we can get in science. This is what we call a “non-trivial problem,” but they just brush it off.
As I said above, the manner in which they argue tells us a great deal about their flaws. I also find this to be a common pattern – pseudoscientists often use impressive anecdotes to defend their beliefs, and they seem to think that the more dramatic the anecdote the more convincing it is. This, however, is the opposite of reality – the overly dramatic anecdote is simply more unbelievable.
I mean, wow. One sugar pill that had a drop of water that used to contain belladonna placed on it cured an abscess in minutes. I have no idea what actually happened to this patient, that is precisely why anecdotes are worthless, but am confident that the sugar pill had nothing to do with it (unless the mere act of swallowing a pill helped to burst the abscess that was on the verge of bursting anyway).
Think about the chain of implausibility here. First, why belladonna? That is an alkaloid toxin with anticholinergic properties. How would this, or the opposite of this, treat an abscess? I wonder what would have happened if he gave homeopathic Arnica instead.
Of course, the belladonna is not present in the pill, it was diluted out of existence. Homeopaths claim that the water remembers the “essence” of the belladonna. But then how is that memory transferred to the sugar pill? Do both water and sucrose have the same magical ability to encode chemical information? Once consumed, how is that essence then transferred to the body (surviving digestion and absorption and transport through the blood), and how does is interact with the target tissue?
How did this magical essence of belladonna lance and drain an abscess and treat a serious infection in a few minutes? The fact that the editors of WDDTY were impressed by this anecdote, and feel it is an adequate and compelling response to the accusation that homeopathy lacks plausibility, speaks volumes.
Of course, if homeopathic remedies were even a fraction as effective as this, it would be a trivial matter to demonstrate such powerful effects in clinical trials. Why, then, have clinical trials failed to show that homeopathy works for anything?
When confronted with this fact, as the WDDTY editors do here with further worthless anecdotes, they appeal to the lowest grade of evidence – uncontrolled clinical observations. They essentially argue that, “It works for me.” This is an extremely naïve position that fails to understand the history of medical knowledge. Uncontrolled observations lead to biased and often false conclusions. Carefully controlled observations are more reliable. Beware of anyone dismissing better evidence in favor of less reliable evidence.
Their response to this valid point is: “Well, mainstream medicine lacks evidence, too.” Again, a tired canard.
But over the past decade, conventional medicine itself has come under fire for having an equally poor evidence base. The first high-level critic was Dr Marcia Angell, formerly editor of the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine who, in 2005, made the astonishing claim: “It is simply not possible to believe much of the clinical evidence that is published”.3 Two years later, the BMJ agreed, publishing a survey showing that only 15 per cent of NHS treatments were definitely “beneficial” and 22 per cent “likely to be beneficial”, leaving the vast majority to be of “unknown effectiveness” or “likely to be ineffective”.4
This is highly misleading. Of course, there are problems with the rigorousness of evidence in mainstream medicine. We dedicate many pages here to detailing those problems and possible remedies. The editors, however, are guilty of false equivalency.
Homeopathy is 100% pseudoscience. Mainstream medicine is largely science-based, but has some quality control issues that need to be worked out. These are not the same.
Further, they are cherry picking one unscientific survey regarding mainstream medicine. A more thorough review of such evidence demonstrates that about 80% of mainstream medicine interventions are reasonably evidence-based (compared to 0% of homeopathic treatments).
The rest of the editorial is just doubling down on the same fallacious points we already discussed. The editors appeal to the “memory of water” claim, that homeopathic water has electromagnetic energy or nanoparticles that carry the memory of the treatment. They reference a few terrible studies that have already been thoroughly debunked.
They further try to cherry pick positive studies or bogus reviews, and appeal to the lowest grade of evidence that is uncontrolled.
Conclusion: Homeopathy is a living fossil of prescientific medicine
Nothing has changed in the world of homeopathy. There is no possible mechanism of action for the homeopathic position, which represents a chain of dramatic implausibilities. In order for Hahnemann to have been right, he would have to have won the scientific lottery not just once but a dozen times, stumbling upon multiple entirely new principles of nature. Further, these principles would all have to be of such a nature that they have eluded scientific investigation for the last two centuries.
Further still, there would have to be something about homeopathy that causes it not to work under carefully controlled observing conditions, and only work when observing conditions are loose enough to allow for placebo effects and random, quirky results.
Of course, the far simpler explanation to this dizzying chain of extreme implausibility is that homeopathy does not work. We don’t have to invent new physics, chemistry, and biology to accommodate homeopathy’s mercurial effects. We can simply recognize placebo effects and naked self-deception when we see it staring us in the face.

   51 “Facts” About Homeopathy
Mark Crislip
Link
Get your facts first, and then you can distort them as much as you please.
—- Mark Twain
I use a Mac, so I know I think different. I also coexist on an alternative parallel world where people live on the same planet as me, but have such a radically different way of thinking that I wonder if we have the same ability to evaluate reality (1).
The best example of different ways of seeing the same thing is homeopathy. Homeopathy is utterly and completely ridiculous with zero plausibility or efficacy. Only therapeutic touch is its rival. Yet homeopath Louise Mclean can suggest there are 50 facts that validate homeopathy (2). These facts were presented as an attempt to counter criticism that homeopathy is only water with no therapeutic effects.
Lets evaluate each fact.
Fact 1 – Hippocrates ‘The Father of Medicine’ of Ancient Greece said there were two Laws of Healing: The Law of Opposites and the Law of Similars. Homeopathy treats the patient with medicines using the Law of Similars, orthodox medicine uses the Law of Opposites, e.g. antibiotics, anti-inflammatories, anticonvulsants, antihypertensives, anti-depressants, anti-psychotics.
Errors: Hippocrates’ ideas as to disease treatment have no (as in zero) applicability to how we understand medicine. Also, medicine does not treat by the Law of Opposites, and using the ‘anti’ prefix as an understanding of how a process works is just weird. Its like finding significance in assume making an ‘ass’ of ‘u’ and ‘me’. Antibiotics, for example, work by targeting very specific bacterial chemical pathways to kill the organism. Anti inflammatories block a specific enzymes in the inflammatory pathway to decrease inflammation etc etc. There is no Law of Opposites in modern medicine. That is either a profound misunderstanding or a misrepresentation.
Fact 2 – Homeopathic theories are based on fixed principles of the Laws of Nature which do not change — unlike medical theories which are constantly changing!
Error: Homeopathy is based on nonsense, and there are no fixed “Laws of Nature” upon which it is based (I do like the the capitals, makes it seem so much more authoritative). What “Law” outside the fictions on Hanneman (he pulled his Laws out the his, well, imagination), is homeopathy based on? None. All the Laws of chemistry, physics, physiology, biology etc would suggest that homeopathy is unequivocal nonsense.
That medicine is changing is its strong suit. Ask yourself this (not applicable if you are Amish or a Homeopath) is there any part of your life where you would prefer to operate under the concepts and technology of the mid 1800′s? Modern medicine progresses. Homeopathy is not only nonsense, it is stagnant nonsense.
Fact 3 – Homeopathy is an evidence-based, empirical medicine.
Error: none. Unfortunately all the evidence based, empirical data demonstrates that homeopathy is totally useless.
Fact 4 – Homeopathy is both an art and a science.
Error: It is an art, like other works of the imagination. As to science, not so much. Homeopaths denies the applicability of all the basic sciences to homeopathy, especially chemistry and physiology. It does occasionally misinterpret quantum mechanics as applicable to its mechanism of action, but misapplying science does not a science make, in this they share a close kinship with the science of intelligent design.
Fact 5 – The Homeopathic provings of medicines are a more scientific method of testing than the orthodox model.
Error: This is only true if you think non randomized, uncontrolled, unblinded anecdotes based on unknown or unproven physical principles are more scientific than randomized, controlled, double blind studies based on therapies that have biologic plausibility. This statement is the same as postulating astrology is better science than astronomy.
Fact 6 – Homeopathic medicine awakens and stimulates the body’s own curative powers. The potentized remedy acts as a catalyst to set healing into motion.
Error: Which curative power and how it is stimulated and what is catalyzed is never said. It sounds impressive until you ask for details. Vague homilies, no meat. Potentized is homeopathy speak for really dilute and shaked/shook/shooken really well.
Fact 7 – Homeopathic medicines work by communicating a current/pattern/frequency of energy via the whole human body to jump start the body’s own inherent healing mechanisms
Error: This makes no sense as I understand the world. The phase “communicating a current/pattern/frequency of energy via the whole human body” really has no content in reality based medicine. Like Oakland, there is no there there. Much of alt med is often all sound and fury, signifying nothing. Big, impressive words and concepts that when analyzed carefully say nothing.
Fact 8 – Homeopathy assists the body to heal itself, to overcome an illness which brings the patient to a higher level of health. Orthodox medicine suppresses the illness, bringing the patient to a lower level of health.
Error: There is a presumption in alt med that the people have a perfect level of health they should be at all the time. Probably not true, as evolution has given us a system that mostly functions reasonably well, but is far from perfection. Next time I cure a heart valve infection, or my cardiology colleague limits the damage of heart attack, or my surgical colleague takes out that cancer, I tell the patient, sorry. I have only suppressed your illness, your level of health is now less.
Fact 9 – The homeopathic practitioner endeavours to search for and treat the cause of the disease in order to heal the effect.
Error: this is the big lie (Big Lie to make it more authoritative) of all alt med. This is what “orthodox” medicine excels at, and what alt medicine, because it is grounded in magic, superstition and faulty understanding of the physical world, can never do. Real doctors find and fix the root cause of illness, homeopaths cannot and do not do any such thing.
Fact 10 – Outcomes of homeopathic treatment are measured by the long term curative effects of prescribing and complete eradication of the disease state for preventing numerous diseases.
Error: none. however, when you diagnose and treat based on magic, you can define cure and prevention in non-verifiable ways.
Fact 11 – The homeopathic practitioner treats the whole person, believing all symptoms are interrelated and seeks to select a medicine which most closely covers them all.
Error: Again, being grounded in nonsense and magical thinking, homeopathy can only have an erroneous and faulty understanding of the whole person. See http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=137 for an extended rant.
Fact 12 – Homeopathic remedies are cheap.
Error: Yes, water is inexpensive. However, think for a moment what it takes to make a homeopathic preparation. Take a 25 ml (1.7 tablespoons) bottle of 200C homeopathic preparation. To make such a product you need 495 liters (about 130 gallons, or 1040 pints) of water to make the required dilutions for one bottle (4). That is an amazing waste of water. Environmentally maybe not so cheap.
Fact 13 – Pharmaceutical medicines are expensive.
Error: some real medications are expensive , some are not. Unlike homeopathy, pharmaceutical medicines are proven to work. Whatever the failings of science based medicine, those failings do not validate homeopathy. Homeopathy has to stand or fall on its own, not on the perceived failings of others. It is like declaring you are thin, because I am fat.
Fact 14 – There are more than 4,000 homeopathic medicines.
Error: Homeopathy is one ‘medication’: water.
Fact 15 – Homeopathic medicines have no toxic side-effects.
Error: tell that to Percy Bysshe Shelley. Medications can only have side effects if first they have an effect. No effect, no side effect. I wonder. Do homeopaths ever misdiagnose? If so, what is the effect of giving the wrong homeopathic treatment?
Fact 16 – Homeopathic medicines are non-addictive.
Error: you try going without water.
Fact 17 – Every true homeopathic medicine is made using one substance — whether plant, mineral, metal, etc. The exact substance is known, unlike most modern drugs where we are rarely informed of the ingredients.
Error: I could be in error, but I did not know that plants were made of one substance. A quick scan of the periodic chart, oh yeah, there it is: foxglove. Right after belladonna. The first mineral in the mineral database (4442 total minerals) is Anorthite,CaAl2Si2O8, made up of 4 substances. Plants and minerals are made up of many many substances. But I am a reductionist. Again it is true in that all homeopathic medications are water and only water.
As to modern drugs, I guess she has not seen a PDR, where the ingredients of medications are freely available, meticulously detailed and strictly controlled, the opposite, at least in the US, of all alt therapies which have zero oversight as to their composition.
Fact 18 – Any remedy up to a 12c or a 24x potency still contains the original molecules of the substance and this is known as Avogadro’s number.
Error: Say what? “Avogadro’s number, is the number of “elementary entities” (usually atoms or molecules) in one mole, that is (from the definition of the mole) the number of atoms in exactly 12 grams of carbon-12 (Wikipedia).”
As it applies to homeopathy, “According to the laws of chemistry, there is a limit to the dilution that can be made without losing the original substance altogether. This limit, called Avogadro’s number (6.023 x 10-23) corresponds to homeopathic potencies of 12C or 24X (1 part in 1024). At this dilution there is less than a 50% chance that even one molecule of active material remains (5).”
I thought it was the water that had the potency, not the molecule. BTW: who wants to go to a bartender who serves Cosmopolitans made with the principals of homeopathy? A 12 C martini would have 60% chance (6) of one molecule of alcohol in it, but should be more potent than a normal cosmo. At least if it were a homeopathic cosmo.
Fact 19 – Every Patient is Unique so homeopathic medicines are individualized.
Error: homeopathy appears to postulate 6 billion different treatments for each person in the world who has hypertension. And 6 billion different treatments for fever. And 6 billion unique treatments for…. on and on for each of the diseases out there. It is, of course, like the rest of homeopathy, impossible.
And for each individual treatment there are, by Fact 14, over 4000 homeopathic remedies. And you apply 4000 remedies to 6 billion people and make each treatment individualized how? There are over 13,000 prescription drugs. Who do you think is better able to provide an individualized therapy?
Fact 20 – Homeopaths treat genetic illness, tracing its origins to 6 main genetic causes: Tuberculosis, Syphilis, Gonorrhoea, Psora (scabies), Cancer, Leprosy.
Error: Say what? Tuberculosis, Syphilis, Gonorrhoea, Psora (scabies) and Leprosy are infections. Infections not genetic illnesses. Thats just stupid. Cancer, may be considered genetic.
Fact 21 – Epidemics such as cholera and typhoid were treated successfully using homeopathy in the 19th century with very high success rates, compared to orthodox medicine (http://www.whale.to/v/winston.html) .
Error: As best I can tell, in 1854 10 of 61 cases of cholera died in a homeopathic hospital, while 123 of the 231 died of cholera in a regular hospital. I am not able to find the details of the therapy and the rigorousness of the diagnosis. I can find insufficient information to comment on the validity of the information. If it is a valid conclusion it has been the only positive study in the 150 years of homeopathy.
Fact 22 – There are thousands of homeopathic books, available at specialist outlets, not sold in the high street.
Error: none. Reading fiction remains a popular pastime.
Fact 23 – There are 5 homeopathic hospitals in the U.K. — in London, Tunbridge Wells, Bristol, Liverpool and Glasgow. They cost the NHS under £10 million a year compared to the £100 billion for the total annual NHS budget for 2008!
Error: I do not doubt it is a true fact. No wonder the sun set long ago on the Empire.
Fact 24 – At one of the earliest debates on the NHS Act of 1948 the Government pledged that homoeopathy would continue to be available on the NHS, as long as there were “patients wishing to receive it and doctors willing to provide it”.
Error: As George Bush II said: “You can fool some of the people all the time, and those are the ones you want to concentrate on.” I bet there are those that wish cocaine had the same criteria for availability from UK doctors: someone wants it and a doctor will sell it.
Fact 25 – There is a campaign by certain U.K. Professors to oust homeopathy completely from the NHS after they wrote on NHS headed paper to all Primary Care Trusts in 2006 telling managers not to refer patients to the homeopathic hospitals.
Error: none. Certain U.K. professors are better at understanding good healthcare than others and much better than politicians pandering to nonsense with a promise of homeopathy forever.
Fact 26 – The Homeopathic Hospitals are clean, with friendly, well informed staff. The patients are generally pleased with their treatment unlike many orthodox National Health Service hospitals.
Error: none. Con men need to please their clients/victims since they have no real service to offer.
Fact 27 – The chances of contracting MRSA or C. Difficile at a Homeopathic Hospital are extremely rare.
Error: I do not doubt this. MRSA and C. difficile are unfortunate (and perhaps unpreventable) complications of doing interventions that work. MRSA most commonly causes a postoperative wound infection from surgery and C. difficile occurs after receiving antibiotics. SInce homeopathy does nothing, it cannot have these complications.
Fact 28 – Unlike orthodox medicine where two thirds of all conventional hospital admissions are due to the side-effects of pharmaceutical medicines, the bill for negligence claims soaring into billions, one U.K. leading insurance company reported only ‘a couple’ of claims against homeopaths in a ten year period!
Error: ” two thirds of all conventional hospital admissions are due to the side-effects of pharmaceutical medicines”. Where did this number come from? She appears to making stuff up (I bet someone finds it on the whale). Maybe 6% or so of hospitalitzations are due to adverse drug reactions (7). I somehow operate under the assumption that facts have a correlation with real data that can be evaluated and not, like Hahnemann’s Laws, just made up.
Fact 29 – In the United States in the early 1900s there were 22 homeopathic medical schools and over 100 homeopathic hospitals, 60 orphanages and old people’s homes and 1,000+ homeopathic pharmacies.
Error: And the life expectancy was 48.23 years (8). We abandoned homeopathy and doubled our life expectancy.
Fact 30 – Members of the American Medical Association had great animosity towards homeopathy after its formation in 1847 and it was decided to purge all local medical societies of physicians who were homeopaths.
Error: Curiously, as an MD (but not an AMA member), I have an animosity towards my patients wasting their money and jeopardizing their health on nonsense.
Fact 31 – Big Pharma does not want the Public to find out how well homeopathy works!
Error: its a paranoid delusion.
Fact 32 – In 2005 the World Health Organization brought out a draft report which showed homeopathy was beneficial causing Big Pharma to panic and The Lancet to bring out an editorial entitled ‘The End of Homeopathy’.
Error: its a paranoid delusion.
Fact 33 – In 2005 The Lancet tried to destroy homeopathy but were only looking at 8 inconclusive trials out of 110 of which 102 were positive. This was a fraudulent analysis.
“The meta-analysis at the centre of the controversy is based on 110 placebo-controlled clinical trials of homeopathy and 110 clinical trials of allopathy (conventional medicine), which are said to be matched. These were reduced to 21 trials of homeopathy and 9 of conventional medicine of ‘higher quality’ and further reduced to 8 and 6 trials, respectively, which were ‘larger, higher quality’. The final analysis which concluded that ‘the clinical effects of homoeopathy are placebo effects’ was based on just the eight ‘larger, higher quality’ clinical trials of homeopathy. The Lancet’s press release did not mention this, instead giving the impression that the conclusions were based on all 110 trials.” (http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articl…)
Error: meta analysis of impossible therapies are medical paradolia, seeing patterns were none exist. See http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=242 for details. The best quote ever on the topic:
“I see all the homeopathy trials as making up a kind of “model organism” for studying the way science and scientific publishing works. Given that homeopathic remedies are known to be completely inert, any positive conclusions or even suggestions of positive conclusions that homeopathy researchers come up with must be either chance findings, mistakes, or fraud.
So homeopathy lets us look at how a community of researchers can generate a body of published papers and even meta-analyze and re-meta-analyze them in great detail, in the absence of any actual phenomenon at all. It’s a bit like growing bacteria in a petri dish in which you know there is nothing but agar.
The rather sad conclusion I’ve come to is that it’s very easy for intelligent, thoughtful scientists to see signals in random noise. I fear that an awful lot of published work in sensible fields of medicine and biology is probably just that as well. Homeopathy proves that it can happen. (the problem is that we don’t know what’s nonsense and what’s not within any given field.) It’s a warning to scientists everywhere (10).”
Fact 34 – There have been many clinical trials that prove homeopathy works. In the past 24 years there have been more than 180 controlled, and 118 randomized, trials into homeopathy, which were analyzed by four separate meta-analyses. In each case, the researchers concluded that the benefits of homeopathy went far beyond that which could be explained purely by the placebo effect.
Error: The question is are there quality trials that show homeopathy works. Nope. And fact 5 dismisses these scientific trials as inferior to the homeopathic proving, so which is it? It is a case of having your cake and eating it too, which should be a logical fallacy.
Fact 35 – The Bristol Homeopathic Hospital carried out a study published in November 2005 of 6500 patients receiving homeopathic treatment. There was an overall improvement in health of 70% of them.
Error: association is not causation. They improved and received homeopathic treatment NOT They improved because they received homeopathic treatment. Causality is a tricky thing to prove, at least outside of homeopathy.
Fact 36 – Homeopathy can never be properly tested through double blind randomized trials because each prescription is individualized as every patient is unique. Therefore 10 people with arthritis, for example, may all need a different homeopathic medicine.
Error: facts 33 and 34 depend on their validity from double blind randomized trial, which are denied in fact 36 and fact 5. And if 4001 people have arthritis, that 4000 and first is out of luck. See fact 19. She sure isn’t one for consistency in her facts.
Fact 37 – Homeopathic medicines are not tested on animals.
Logical Fallacy: false dichotomy.
Error: If homeopathic medications are more effective on animals (fact 38) and have no toxic side effects (fact 15), then why is this a good thing? It is bad to test on animals because it harms them. If homeopathy is harmless, then there is no moral high ground to be gained from not testing on animals. We know water is safe for animals, especially for fish, who are subject to all the increasingly dilute, and therefore more powerful, homeopathic medications sent down the drain. Is that why the fish stocks are crashing?
Fact 38 – Homeopathic medicines work even better on animals and babies than on adults, proving this cannot be placebo.
Error: huh? The efficacy of the medication depends on age and species? How is this supposed to work? And if homeopathic medicines are not tested on animals (fact 37), then how do we know they are more effective?
Fact 39 – Scientists agree that if and when homeopathy is accepted by the scientific community it will turn established science on its head.
Error: absolutely true. If homeopathy is accepted because to experimental proof, then 500 years of progress in all the sciences have been in error. If homeopathy is accepted without scientific proof, then its back to the dark ages for western civilization, and only the morticians and homeopaths will profit.
Fact 40 – Homeopathic Practitioners train for 4 years in Anatomy and Physiology, as well as Pathology and Disease, Materia Medica, Homeopathic Philosophy and study of the Homeopathic Repertory.
Error: no argument here. Four years to learn anatomy, pathology and physiology just so you can ignore it later. I wonder if they study chemistry.
Fact 41 – Most homeopaths treat patients who have been referred to them by word of mouth. Most patients seek out homeopathy because conventional treatment has not benefited them or because it poses too great a risk of side-effects.
Error: none.
Fact 42 – The homeopathic community has thousands, even millions, of written case notes that demonstrate the positive benefits of their treatment. Some homeopaths have video proof of their patients before and after treatment.
Error: the plural of anecdote is anecdotes, not data.
Fact 43 – Homeopaths charge patients an average of £50 an hour. Specialist Doctors can charge up to £200 or more.
Error: one gets what they pay for. You can spend thousands of dollars on a car for transportation, but I bet a unicorn would cost less for the same purpose.
Fact 44 – The popularity of homeopathy has grown in the past 30 years, its revival entirely through word of mouth and estimated to be growing at more than 20% a year the world over.
Fact 45 – Hundreds of famous people throughout the past 200 years have enjoyed the benefits of homeopathic medicine (www.homeopathicrevolution.com) .
Error: being famous does not make your knowledge of medicine more (or less) valid (9).
Fact 46 – The aristocratic patronage of homeopathy in the U.K. extended well into the 1940s and beyond can be easily demonstrated. In the Homeopathic Medical Directories there are lists of patrons of the dispensaries and hospitals. They read like an extract from Burke’s or Debrett’s.
Error: Like being famous, being an aristocrat does not make your knowledge of medicine more (or less) valid.
Fact 47 – The Royal Families of Europe use homeopathic medicine and Queen Elizabeth II of England never travels anywhere without her homeopathic vials of medicine.
Error: since the Queen is a medical authority, as a medical doctor I am an authority on constitutional monarchy.
Fact 48 – Homeopathy is practised nowadays in countries all over the world. In India there are 100 homeopathic medical schools and around 250,000 homeopathic doctors.
Error: none. But Indians have a life expectancy 20 years less than the US. Cause and effect?
Fact 49 – In a recent Global TGI survey where people were asked whether they trust homeopathy the following percentages of people living in urban areas said YES: 62% in India, 58% Brazil, 53% Saudi Arabia, Chile 49%, United Arab Emirates 49%, France 40%, South Africa 35%, Russia 28%, Germany 27%, Argentina 25%, Hungary 25%, USA 18%, UK 15% (http://www.tgisurveys.com/documents/TGI…)
Error: The data is accurate, but does not validate homeopathy. In the USA, 18% was the percentage who trusted Wall Street in 2007 (11).
Fact 50 – The media as a whole has been unwilling to air a defence of the efficacy of homeopathy and the validity of this 250 year old profession.
Error: from my perspective, the opposite is true with the media all too willing to perpetuate nonsense like homeopathy.
Fact 51: I think Ronald Reagan was practicing homeopathy when he said “Facts are stupid things”.
Error: none.
References
1) Note: I said different, not better, he says in a feeble attempt to forestall comments.
2) http://www.naturalnews.com/024512.html
3) http://www.theskepticsguide.org/logicalfallacies.asp.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallacy
I am often uncertain re: which logical fallacy applies, feel free to correct of add to them. And I am sure I will hear about my own.
4) http://www.ratbags.com/rsoles/comment/homeopathy2.htm
5) http://www.skepticfiles.org/skmag/homeo.htm
6) http://www.ukskeptics.com/forum/showthread.php?t=67
7) http://www.bmj.com/cgi/content/full/329/7456/15
http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0005140.html
9) Unless you are a famous scientologist. Then you have expertise in psychiatry.
10) http://hawk-handsaw.blogspot.com/2008/10/shang-study-remains-firmly-in-water.html?showComment=1223476080000#c612742695616522486)
11) http://www.usnews.com/blogs/small-biz-scene/2007/3/6/small-business-tops-poll-on-trust.html

   Homeopathy and the Selling of Nonspecific Effects
Steven Novella
Link
One of the core features of science (and therefore science-based medicine) is to precisely identify and control for variables, so that we know what, exactly, is exerting an effect. The classic example of this principle at work is the Hawthorne effect. The term refers to a series of studies performed between 1924 and 1932 at the Hawthorne Works. The studies examined whether or not workers would be more productive in different lighting conditions. So they increased the light levels, observed the workers, and found that their productivity increased. Then they lowered the light levels, observed the workers, and found that their productivity increased. No matter what they did, the workers improved their productivity relative to baseline. Eventually it was figured out that observing the workers caused them to work harder, no matter what was done to the lighting.
This “observer effect” – an artifact of the process of observation – is now part of standard study design (at least well-designed studies). In medical studies it is one of the many placebo effects that need to be controlled for, in order to properly isolate the variable of interest.
There are many non-specific effects – effects that result from the act of treating or evaluating patients rather than a physiological response to a specific treatment. In addition to observer effects, for example, there is also the “chearleader” effect from encouraging patients to perform better. There are training effects from retesting. And there are long-recognized non-specific therapeutic effects just from getting compassionate attention from a practitioner. It is a standard part of medical scientific reasoning that before we ascribe a specific effect to a particular intervention, that all non-specific effects are controlled for and eliminated.
Within the world of so-called “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), however, standard scientific reasoning it turned on its head. After failing to find specific physiological benefits for many treatments under the CAM umbrella, proponents are desperately trying to sell non-specific effects as if they are specific to their preferred modalities. In other contexts this might be considered fraud. It is certainly scientifically dubious to the point of dishonesty, in my opinion.
The latest example of this is a study published in the journal Rheumatology: Homeopathy has clinical benefits in rheumatoid arthritis patients that are attributable to the consultation process but not the homeopathic remedy: a randomized controlled clinical trial. The study compared 5 groups: the first three received a homeopathic consultation and either individualized, complex (meaning a standard preparation), or placebo treatment for rheumatoid arthritis; the last two received no consultation and either complex homeopathic treatment or placebo. The study was double-blind with respect to the treatments, but not blinded with respect to whether or not a subject received a homeopathic consultation.
The results:
Fifty-six completed treatment phase. No significant differences were observed for either primary outcome. There was no clear effect due to remedy type. Receiving a homeopathic consultation significantly improved DAS-28 [mean difference 0.623; 95% CI 0.1860, 1.060; P = 0.005; effect size (ES) 0.70], swollen joint count (mean difference 3.04; 95% CI 1.055, 5.030; P = 0.003; ES 0.83), current pain (mean difference 9.12; 95% CI 0.521, 17.718; P = 0.038; ES 0.48), weekly pain (mean difference 6.017; 95% CI 0.140, 11.894; P = 0.045; ES 0.30), weekly patient GA (mean difference 6.260; 95% CI 0.411, 12.169; P = 0.036; ES 0.31) and negative mood (mean difference − 4.497; 95% CI −8.071, −0.923; P = 0.015; ES 0.90).
In other words – there was no difference in any outcome measure among individualized homeopathic treatments, complex (standardized) treatment, or placebo. According to this study – homeopathy does not work for rheumatoid arthritis. That is really the only thing we can conclude from this study.
However, the authors spend a great deal of time trying to argue that the study supports the conclusion that, even though homeopathic products have zero effect, the homeopathic consultation process does have a beneficial effect. This is a flawed conclusion on several levels.
First, the study was not blinded for consultation vs no-consultation. Any comparison of this variable, therefore, is highly unreliable. It is likely no coincidence that the blinded comparisons were all negative, while some of the unblinded comparisons were positive. Also, even there the results are weak. The primary outcome measure was negative. Only the secondary outcome measures, which are mostly subjective, were positive.
And, perhaps most significantly, the study was not even designed to test the efficacy of the homeopathic consultation itself because it was compared essentially to no intervention (and in an unblinded fashion). There is therefore every reason to conclude that any perceived benefit from the consultation process is due to the nonspecific effects of the clinical interaction – attention from a practitioner, expectation of benefit, chearleader effect, etc.
If the authors wished to test whether there is something special about the homeopathic consultation then they should have compared it to attention from a health care provider that was controlled for time and personal attention, but did not contain elements specific to the homeopathic consultation. This study did not do that.
Conclusion
The study itself was reasonably well designed. It is a bit small, especially for the number of comparison groups, and so was underpowered. But it did make a reasonable and blinded comparison between homeopathic preparations and placebo and found no difference. This is in line with research into homeopathy in general - it is no different from placebo, which means homeopathy does not work.
It is worth pointing out that homeopaths have complained in the past that comparing standardized homeopathic complex to placebo is not fair, because homeopathy requires and individualized treatment. This, of course, contradicts the claims for any homeopathic product on the shelves. But that point aside, in this study individualized treatments performed no better, contradicting that complaint.
The authors, however, are presenting the study as evidence that the homeopathic consultation works, when this study was not designed to test that variable. The effects can easily be explained as the non-specific effects of therapeutic attention. The study provides no basis upon which to conclude that there is any value to a homeopathic consultation beyond the raw benefit of time and attention.
The study does reinforce what previous studies have shown – attention from a provider does have measurable benefits to quality of life and subjective symptoms (even if not disease-altering). This should prompt a re-evaluation of the priorities given to reimbursing for provider time. It should be noted that homeopaths generally charge directly for their time, and are not typically contracted to accept an insurance-based fee schedule. So comparing a typical homeopathic consultation to a busy physician’s office is not fair.
Further – if we are going to advocate for increased money for provider time and attention, such resources should go to providers who are science-based and use modalities that have efficacy on their own. It is highly misguided, wasteful, and potentially dangerous to rely upon practitioners who utilize an unscientific philosophy and treatments that are admittedly worthless, just because there are non-specific subjective benefits from the attention given.
Edzard Ernst makes the same points in an editorial that the journal Rheumatology ran in the same issue. While I question the decision to publish this study with the conclusion as written (peer-reviewers and editors should have been much harsher on the hype and spin of the authors), at least they had the courage to include Ernst’s comments as well.

   Placebos as Medicine: The Ethics of Homeopathy
Scott Gavura 
Link
Is it ever ethical to provide a placebo treatment? What about when that placebo is homeopathy? Last month I blogged about the frequency of placebo prescribing by physicians. I admitted my personal discomfort, stating I’d refuse to dispense any prescription that would require me to deceive the patient. The discussion continued in the comments, where opinions seemed to range from (I’m paraphrasing) “autonomy, shmatonomy, placebos works” to the more critical who likened placebo use to “treating adults like children.” Harriet Hall noted, “We should have rules but we should be willing to break them when it would be kinder to the patient, and would do no harm.” And on reflection, Harriet’s perspective was one that I could see myself accepting should I be in a situation like the one she described. It’s far easier to be dogmatic when you don’t have a patient standing in front of you. But the comments led me to consider possible situations where a placebo might actually be the most desirable treatment option. If I find some, should I be as dogmatic about homeopathy as I am about other placebos?
Nicely, Kevin Smith, writing in the journal Bioethics, examines the ethics of placebos, based on an analysis of homeopathy. Homeopathy is the ultimate placebo in routine use — most remedies contain only sugar and water, lacking a single molecule of any potentially medicinal ingredient. Smith’s paper, Against Homeopathy — A Utilitarian Perspective, is sadly behind a paywall. So I’ll try to summarize his analysis, and add my perspective as a health care worker who regularly encounters homeopathy.
The first third of the paper is a concise summary of the scientific absurdity of homeopathy. Hahnemann’s “Law of Similars”, based on a single observation of the effects of quinine on malaria, is the basis for the non-scientific process of “provings” to match symptoms to substances. The results of provings are compiled in the Homeopathic Materia Medica, which homeopaths select their remedies from. (So now we have remedies based on products including “sleep”, Stonehenge, shipwrecks, ascending colons, light bulbs, and vacuum cleaner dirt.) Smith summarizes this law as:
More fundamentally, there is simply no plausible or rational basis for supposing that substances that produce particular symptoms can cure the same symptoms. The assumption that ‘like cures like’ places the onus on proponents of homeopathy to elucidate the special logic involved: to the knowledge of the present author, a satisfactory account of this logic has not been made.
Hahnemann’s second law, the “Law of Infinitesimals” is as absurd as the law of similars. That a product can gain potency and effect with dilution, and that effect persists (and even grows stronger) even after being diluted completely away defies physical laws. Smith points out the contradiction between the idea that water is touted to have a memory of the “proved” substance, yet has forgotten everything else that has every been dissolved in it:
The fact that physiological chaos does not ensure whenever we drink a glass of water provides a simple but powerful refutation of the ‘memory’ concept in homeopathy.
Smith then covers the research on homeopathy. Given its premise is implausible (or impossible), it is not surprising that the highest quality clinical trials have demonstrated no efficacy beyond placebo effects. Yet positive trials are to be expected from statistical effects alone. And when combined with bad design, weak blinding and other potential biases, it should not be surprising that a supportive clinical trials appear in the literature — and some even show up in Cochrane reviews. His conclusion is very much along the lines of the position taken by SBMers:
From Hume onward, it has been accepted that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Considering the extent to which the fundamental tenets of homeopath run counter to established rules of science and reason, empirical evidence in support of homeopathy would have to be particularly robust, in view of the fact that acceptance of homeopathy would entail a major epistemic scientific revolution.
So it’s implausible, the remedies contain no medicinal ingredients, and, not surprisingly, it works no better than a placebo. Yet it is popular, even among some physicians and scientists. But is it ethical? And here’s where we get to the meat of the ethical analysis.
Non-Invasiveness/Cost-effectiveness
Placebos, as commenters to my past post noted, do have one merit. If the alternative to antibiotics for a cold is homeopathy for a cold, then homeopathy is probably a better therapeutic choice, because “no treatment” is the preferred treatment. There are many medical conditions for which we have few effective medical therapies, and in some cases the impetus to prescribe a placebo may be simply to obtain the psychological (placebo) effects associated with their use. And given the habit (as I described last month) for some physicians to select impure placebos (those containing subtherapeutic or non-toxic ingredients), then isn’t a pure placebo like homeopathy sometimes preferable? Here’s where Smith gives homeopathy credit:
In cases where ineffective medication is considered to be in the best interests of the patient, which form of such medicine should be prescribed?
The answer to this question seems clear: the ineffective medicine that is the least invasive and least expensive should be used. On these criteria, homeopathy scores highly.
So in situations where a placebo is felt to be in the patient’s best interest, homeopathy might be felt to be favorable, particularly if an “impure” placebo has a greater potential for unwanted effects. But Smith makes a small error here: Homeopathy isn’t always the least expensive option – a point I’ll return to.
Holism
Holistic is a popular term among alternative medicine proponents and is usually used to deride science-based medicine, with the fallacious claim that various alternative treatments treat the “whole patient” while medicine does not. And as has been described elsewhere on this blog, the extended consultation offered by alternative medicine providers is probably the source of most if not all of the benefits of treatments. However the non-specific benefits of talk therapy, dialogue, empathy and reassurance are not limited to homeopathy, and can be incorporated into science-based practices. And importantly, since homeopathic “remedies” can be purchased in pharmacies and other stores without consultation, the “holistic” approach, and its benefits, are by no means certain when consultation is omitted. For these reasons, Smith rejects holism as providing any unique support for homeopathy.
Placebo effects
In the research setting, placebo effects are any measured response in patients that receive the inert (placebo) treatment. But as has been noted on this blog, there are actually multiple elements and observations that sum into what’s described as “placebo effects.” Some of what can contribute to the apparent efficacy of a placebo may not be due to patient-reported outcomes: Researcher bias, poor blinding, and weak overall study design and conduct can all add to the measurement of, and subsequent conclusion that a placebo has effects. Even a disease’s natural history, or regression to the mean can lead one to conclude a correctly-timed placebo treatment is effective.
Smith does not dive deeply into placebo effects, but makes two arguments against homeopathy’s value as a placebo. First, he notes that placebo effects are generally restricted to subjective symptoms like pain and fatigue, with no evidence supporting any meaningful disease-modifying effects. This limits the usefulness of homeopathy to those conditions for which there is some evidence to show that there may be placebo effects. Smith then raises the ethical appropriateness of a key component of successful placebo use: in order for placebos to work, patients must believe something that is untrue. From a utilitarian perspective, Smith notes that lying may be acceptable when it (on balance) is an overall positive — that is, it generates a positive utility. However, patient autonomy must also be considered — the right for patients to make an informed decision about their treatments. Smith suggests that if you personally rank autonomy above the potential placebo benefits, then the use of homeopathy is untenable from an ethical perspective.
But are homeopaths deliberately deceiving their clients? Smith argues (and I agree) that most homeopaths genuinely believe “remedies” to be effective — so they are not acting in bad faith when they advocate their use. However, the fact remains that patients that are told that homeopathy is effective are being given information that is contrary to the scientific evidence. Consequently Smith describes their actions as “ethically unacceptable” regardless of their sincere (but wrong) beliefs.
But what about placebo use by health professionals? While routine use of placebos wouldn’t be considered ethically acceptable, Smith notes that reinforcing the efficacy of a conventional medication, in a way that could enhance potential placebo effects, is acceptable. This is a routine part of the pharmacist’s dialogue with patients – understanding and addressing concerns, summarizing therapeutic effects, and managing overall treatment expectations. It can be done in a non-deceptive way that should maximize the non-specific effects. But what about pure placebos? Smith gives the example of battlefield use of saline injections for pain as a circumstance where pure placebo use would be ethically acceptable. So in situations where no other options exist, perhaps. But as a matter of course, providing pure placebos would not be considered ethically appropriate.
Autonomy
What if patients elect to choose homeopathy, despite counsel that the product is inert? I’ve encountered this situation in the pharmacy: when asked for advice, I inform the patient that the product has no active ingredients and has no medicinal effects. They’re usually grateful for that, but sometimes my advice will be challenged or ignored, and they’ll purchase it anyway. In situations where it’s clear that the patient may be avoiding appropriate consultation or treatment, I may press my argument further. But once I’ve described the scientific evidence, and given my advice, I’m comfortable letting the patient make their own purchasing decision. And that’s consistent with Smith’s analysis:
If utility is generally maximized by allowing patient autonomy, then patients should be free to choose homeopathy. Secondly, exercise of autonomy provides psychological benefits for the agent: it is well accepted that denial of free choice, or coercion, results in reduced happiness in the subjects concerned.
Smith describes the challenge of drawing lines between paternalism and autonomy, concluding that restriction of autonomy is probably reasonable when the risk of self-harm is greater — which is consistent with the case for restricting drugs to “prescription-only” status. While risks of contamination and unwanted medicinal effects do exist, the more common and real risk is probably the avoidance of proper medical treatment — which is one of the major disutilities of homeopathy.
Failing to Seek Medical Care
While some might be willing to accept the use of homeopathy in cases where placebo effects are possible and probably adequate, most draw the line when homeopathy is positioned as a substitute for effective medical treatment. Yet that’s the case when homeopathy is promoted as malaria prophylaxis, a substitute for vaccination, or even as a treatment for HIV or tuberculosis. Probably the best approach to mitigating this risk, while promoting individual patient autonomy, is to ensure that adequate information is provided to patients so that they are well informed of the lack of medicinal ingredients and the demonstrated lack of efficacy, beyond placebo, for any condition. Smith questions the ability of CAM practitioners to provide reliable advice on efficacy, and describes the promotion of a therapeutic doctrine, rather than reliable advice, as “ethically unacceptable.” He further characterizes any harms resulting in those unable to give fully informed consent (e.g., children or non-competent adults) as “ethically indefensible.”
Waste of Resources
If you’ve never bought it before, homeopathy is not cheap: its prices are comparable to conventional products with active ingredients. Given the lack of efficacy, every dollar spent on homeopathy is a waste of resources, in that it could otherwise be put to more effective use — for plausible treatments, or anything else, for that matter. So from a utilitarian perspective, Smith argues that this expenditure is unethical. Smith notes that homeopathy may not just act as a substitute for other care due to its lack of effect: When the homeopathy fails to work, conventional care may subsequently be sought.
Smith makes the same ethical evaluation of research into homeopathy, where because of a lack of “logico-scientific validity”, human trials of homeopathy are ethically contentious and an inappropriate use of resources.
Credibility Issues
One of the issues that concerns me as a pharmacist is the veneer of credibility that homeopathy gains when it’s packaged and positioned alongside conventional medicine in pharmacies. I suspect that most consumers expect the products on pharmacy shelves to contain medicinal ingredients, and to have some sort of evidence to support their sale. If I substituted placebos for prescription drugs, I’d quickly lose my license to practice. And if I sold boxes of toothpaste or tissue that were empty inside, I’d probably be out of business pretty quickly. So I’m dismayed when I see pharmacies selling cough syrups without active ingredients, sending an unwarranted message of homeopathy’s effectiveness.
Another credibility issue arises from an educational perspective, when homeopathy is “integrated” into science and and medical education as well, increasing the perception that homeopathy has medical credibility. Smith sums it up:
“…inappropriate ‘approval’ for homeopathy serves as a disutility, as it will tend to magnify several negative outcomes, namely resource wastage, risk of patients failing to seek effective healthcare, and reduced patient autonomy through the promulgation of erroneous medical knowledge”
Smith goes on to note a number of other concerns documented repeatedly at SBM, including a weakening of a societal commitment to scientifically-established treatments, as well as the confusion of ineffective treatments such as homeopathy with treatments that he describes as genuinely complementary, such as mediation, relaxation, music and exercise — something that has been described here as the CAM Trojan horse.
Conclusion
So where does that leave us? Unfortunately we cannot simply sum up the arguments in a formula to give us the ethical answer. It seems clear that the ethical downsides to homeopathy outweigh its benefits under most circumstance I can envision. Smith uses the example of an ineffective defibrillator to point out that the use of such a device device in the context of medical care would be “morally unjustifiable.” He notes,
Because it is inherently ineffective, homeopathy cannot be ethically neutral. It follows that the purchase, deployment or promotion of homeopathy is morally unacceptable.
Perhaps there may yet emerge a framework where placebos can be ethically (and judiciously) justified. Homeopathy isn’t it. So what should health professionals do? For one, we should stop promoting homeopathy, and the sale of homeopathic remedies. We should advocate against the allocation of limited health resources to researching, facilitating or providing homeopathy. We should avoid giving homeopathy undeserved credibility by selling it alongside actual medicine, or allowing it to be sold without clear labelling that describes its lack of ingredients and effectiveness. And when we’re asked, we have an ethical responsibility to explain why we believe homeopathy is no ‘alternative” at all.
Reference
Smith K (2011). Against Homeopathy – A Utilitarian Perspective. Bioethics PMID: 21320146

   Science vs Homeopathic Pseudoscience
Steven Novella
Link
Science is a philosophy, a technology, and an institution. It is a human endeavor- our collective attempt to understand the world around us, not something that exists solely in the abstract. All of these aspects of science have be progressing over the past decades and centuries, as we refine our concepts of what science is and how it works, as we develop better techniques, and organize and police scientific activities more effectively. The practice of science is not relentlessly progressive, however, and there are many regressive forces causing pockets of backsliding, and even aggressive campaigns against scientific progress.
So-called complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is one such regressive force. It seeks to undermine the concepts, execution, and institutions of medical science in order to promote sectarian practices and ideological beliefs. Examples of this are legion, exposed within the pages of this blog alone. I would like to add another example to the pile – the recent defense of homeopathy by Dana Ullman in the Huffington Post (names which are already infamous among supporters of SBM).
In a piece titled: Homeopathy for Radiation Poisoning, Ullman demonstrates yet again the pseudoscientific aspects of homeopathy and its proponents. The primary principle that is abused by Ullman this time is the need for scientists to carefully define their terms and concepts. Scientific concepts should be defined as carefully, precisely, and consistently as possible. Squishy concepts are very difficult to deal with in science – but are the bread and butter of pseudoscience.
The fuzzy concept is particularly useful to the pseudoscientist (someone pretending to do real science, but whose activity is devoid of genuine scientific exploration or rigor). Pseudoscientists generally start with a desired answer and then work backwards to their logic and evidence. Whereas genuine science endeavors to follow logic and evidence wherever it leads. Having a poorly defined term or concept allows pseudoscientists to better shoehorn in evidence and logic – to create the appearance of support for their beliefs where none exists.
Ullman’s article is typically full of anecdotes, cherry picked evidence, and tortured logic. There is far too much there to pick apart in detail, so I want to focus on his exploitation of poorly defined concepts. He writes:
Grubbe got the idea of using radiation as a treatment for Lee’s breast cancer from Reuben Ludlam, M.D., a professor at the homeopathic medical school. Ludlam knew that Grubbe had previously experimented with X-ray as a diagnostic procedure so much that he developed blisters and tumors on his hand and neck as a result of overexposure to this new technology.
Because one of the basic premises of homeopathic medicine is that small doses of a treatment can help to heal those symptoms that large doses are known to cause, Ludlam suggested to Grubbe that radiation may be a treatment for conditions such as tumors because it also causes them.
The toxicity and medical uses of radiation have absolutely nothing to do with any concept that can reasonably be considered part of homeopathy. But Ullman exploits superficial similarities to twist it into support for the deliberately squishy concept of homeopathy. Radiation is toxic to cells – high energy particles impart their energy to cell structures, breaking chemical bonds, killing cells outright in some cases or damaging their DNA. Radioactivity has greater toxicity to cells that rapidly reproduce, because they are more sensitive to DNA damage (partly because they have less time to repair DNA damage).
Low levels of radiation exposure carry a low risk because the repair mechanisms of cells can largely handle any damage done, and the number of lost cells is insignificant. It is not clear if low levels of radiation (such as the background radiation in which we all live) conveys zero risk or simply a very low risk – that type of distinction is inherently difficult to make with empirical studies.
But at all levels of exposure the effect of radiation is a toxic one – to do damage to cell structures. In this way radiation is very much like a drug. All drugs cause biological changes to the body. But those used as pharmaceutical agents have a dose range in which their effects can be exploited while the risk of negative effects is minimal. There are threshold at which certain toxic effects become significant, but at lower doses they are still present, just tolerable or insignificant. Some effects may display a threshold effect because of compensatory mechanisms, or because there are certain levels at which metabolic processes are overwhelmed.
Radiation damages and kills cells. Rapidly dividing cells are more susceptible to damage. There is therefore a dose range in which radioactivity can kill rapidly dividing tumor cells significantly more than surrounding healthy tissue. But in order to exploit this effect techniques must be use to focus the radiation on the tumor while minimizing exposure to surrounding tissue. And a certain level of damage to surrounding tissue is unavoidable. There is even the risk of later damage, and even cancer, from therapeutic radiation exposure. The use of radiation, like the use of drugs, is about risk vs benefit, or beneficial effects vs side effects. Given that the condition being treated is a potentially fatal cancer, a high level of side effects and risk are considered reasonable.
Ullman, however, would have you believe that what I described above is analogous to homeopathy, in which tiny or (more commonly) non-existent doses of a substance that causes certain symptoms in a healthy individual will treat those symptoms in an unhealthy person. This is not analogous to exploiting different levels of toxicity for a therapeutic effect. There is a superficial similarity in that different doses cause different effects – but with drugs and radiation there are specific mechanisms for this dose-response effect. Homeopathy does not display a dose-response effect – even as homeopaths understand it.
Science and evidence dictates that homeopathy shows no effect at all, but even within the belief system of homeopaths there is no consistent dose-response curve for their potions. There is, if anything, a mysterious and inconsistent relationship between dose and effect, without any plausible mechanism at all. This bizarre relationship between dose and effect claimed by homeopaths is such that dilutions where not even a single molecule of original ingredient is likely to remain behind are often claimed by homeopaths to be the most potent.
Further, while there are specific mechanisms for toxicity and therapeutic effects for interventions like radiation and drugs (although certainly we do not fully understand the precise mechanisms of every drug), there is no plausible mechanism behind the claims of homeopathy. The best that they can come up with is false analogies to vaccines, the speculative concept of hormesis, and now the dose-response effect of standard treatments. When pushed they speak vaguely about the “essence” of the drug, and restoring “balance”. But this is no closer to an actual explanation of how homeopathy might work than saying that it is “magic”, “witchcraft”, or “faith healing.”
Conclusion
The exploitation of poorly defined concepts is a hallmark of CAM. We see it in homeopathy, as above, with strained analogies and fallacious logic. We see it with acupuncture, for example, when “placebo acupuncture” (where there is no needle penetration and no acupuncture points) and electroacupuncture (where electrical stimulation is given) are used as support for acupuncture. This leads to the question – what is acupuncture? What is it that is specific an unique to acupuncture? Nothing, apparently – but this allows for a wide range of non-specific and other effects to be used as support for the vague concept of “acupuncture.”
And we can ask – what is homeopathy? What scientific concept that has been validated by experimentation constitutes the body of knowledge that is homeopathy? The answer is – nothing. There is no law of similars, nor a law of infinitessimals. There is no plausible mechanism to explain homeopathic potions. So instead we are given invalid analogies, innuendo, and a desperate attempt to confuse the public as to what homeopathy actually is.

   A Science Lesson from a Homeopath and Behavioral Optometrist
Steven Novella
Link
Charlene Werner is getting a lot of attention she probably did not anticipate or desire. She is the star of a YouTube video in which she explains the scientific basis of homeopathy. Before you watch it, make sure you are sitting down, relax, and brace yourself for an onslaught of profound scientific illiteracy combined with stunning arrogance. For those with more delicate constitutions I will give you the quick summary:
Einstein taught us that energy equals matter and light, but because matter can be condensed down to a very small space if you remove all the empty space between the elementary particles (I am paraphrasing to make her statements minimally coherent), we can mostly ignore matter. Therefore energy is light, and we are all made of energy – not matter (or at least so little matter, you can ignore it). Stephen Hawking then came up with string theory, which tells us that all matter (which we can ignore) is made of vibrating strings. Therefore we are made of vibrating energy. All diseases are therefore caused by unhealthy vibrational states, and all disease can be treated by returning the body to a previous healthy vibrational state. This can be done with homeopathy, which extracts the vibrational energy out of stuff and places it in a small pill that can be used at any time.
Got it? This is now my favorite example of meaningless pseudobabble from a CAM proponent. Also, I am not picking on some unrepresentative crank – this is as good as homeopathy gets. Werner may be more clumsy and fumbling than more eloquent homeopathy proponents, but when you strip it down, magical vibrations is what you get. But Werner does a fabulous job of exposing the gaping holes is homeopathic nonsense.
Werner is also Dr. Charelene Werner which made me curious of her degree and practice, and this led me to a topic that I do not think we have every covered on SBM – behavioral optometry. Dr. Werner is an optometrist who engages is a host of pseudoscientific practices, homeopathy being just one.
Behavioral or developmental optometry is similar to chiropractic, in that it is a health care profession that is self contained, separate from mainstream medical science, with historical roots survival into modern practice. There is a kernel of legitimacy (perhaps) to some of what they do, but then a vast expanding set of clinical claims for which there is little or not evidence. The big difference is that behavioral optometrists, unlike chiropractors, have largely been flying below the radar.
There also appears to be a spectrum, like with chiropractic, and I’m sure those behavioral optometrists who try to be evidence-based may take exception to being lumped in with the likely of Dr. Werner. But – professions have an identity, and you don’t like what’s happening under the banner of your profession, clean it up from the inside.
A look at Dr. Werner’s website give us a clear picture of her philosophy:
We are a holistic based optometric practice dedicated to the highest quliaty vision care for your entire family. We believe that 70% of how you physically function is through the vision system. Therefore, when the vision system is improved or enhanced it also increases overall physical wellness and performance.
This reflects, in my opinion, the tendency for practitioners who are not science-based to slowly expand their claims and scope of practice. If anecdotes are all you require (not even minimal biological plausibility) to accept that your interventions work, then before long you will think they work for everything. Dr. Werner likely does not grasp how extraordinary a claim it is to say that 70% of physical function is through the vision system. I wonder how she came up with that figure. The vague claims to “improve or enhance…physical wellness” leaves the door nicely open to treating just about anything.
Behavioral optometry is premised on the belief that eye and visual function can be improved, at any age, through training, exercises, or glasses with special lenses or prisms. There is little support or plausibility for this claim so broadly conceived, although there may be some truth to this concept in specific cases. A thorough review of the claims and literature for the various treatments of behavior optometrists is beyond one article, but I did find some recent reviews. This review from 2008 takes a broad look at behavioral optometry practices and concludes:
There is a continued paucity of controlled trials in the literature to support behavioural optometry approaches. Although there are areas where the available evidence is consistent with claims made by behavioural optometrists (most notably in relation to the treatment of convergence insufficiency, the use of yoked prisms in neurological patients, and in vision rehabilitation after brain disease/injury), a large majority of behavioural management approaches are not evidence-based, and thus cannot be advocated.
That is what I found from a look through the literature. The studies that are being cited by proponents are small, unblinded, pilot studies. There is a distinct lack of large randomized controlled trials.
Some of the claims made run directly contrary to evidence in the neurological literature. For example, using prisms to treat dyslexia (a reading disorder) based upon the premise that dyslexia is largely a visual problem (despite normal standard visual testing). However, the evidence has shown that dyslexia is not a visual problem but a disorder of the language area of the brain – a language and learning disorder. The claims of behavior optometrists regarding dyslexia started out being without evidence, but have increasing run contrary to prevailing evidence, but optomestrists failed to adapt or update their theories and practice.
The one condition that seems the most plausible and is most accepted is called convergence insufficiency – difficulty in properly focusing both eyes on near objects. There is weak evidence to support training exercises to help with this disorder, but other methods that are used to treat it (for example and exercise called pencil push-ups) has not been shown to be effective. While this condition requires more research, it is plausible.
At the other end of the plausibility spectrum is syntonic phototherapy. This is the use of specific colors of light to treat a wide range of symptoms and conditions, and improve performance. A search in pubmed on “syntonic phototherapy” yielded zero results. There is probably some research under different terms, but just using “phototherapy” as a search terms yields too many results to wade through (legitimate phototherapy is used for a range of skin and other conditions).
According to promotional sites, syntonic phototherapy dates back to the 1920′s and one man, Dr. Harry Riley Spitler- always a red flag. They seem to follow the pattern of referencing some legitimate basic science (for example the existence of light pathways in the brain that are not involved in conscious vision) to justify specific clinical claims without referencing quality clinical evidence.
Opthalmologists (MD eye doctors) historically have flirted with some of the claims of behavioral optometry, but a recent survey of practice concluded:
Although visual training has been used for several centuries, it plays a minor and actually decreasing role in eye therapy used by the ophthalmologist. At the beginning of the twenty-first century, most visual training is carried out by non-ophthalmologists and is neither practiced nor endorsed in its broadest sense by ophthalmology.
In short, there is generally low plausibility for many of the claims of behavior optometry, a lack of evidence for most of the methods used, a lack of consistency with the overall scientific literature and practice, and an expanding list of conditions they believe they can treat. These are all symptoms of a profession that lacks an appropriate level of respect for evidence and science-based medicine.
It is therefore no surprise to find a practitioner who also uses other unscientific modalities, such as homeopathy, and can so casually display such profound scientific illiteracy. Dr. Werner therefore managed to be an embarrassment to two professions at the same time.

   When homeopaths attack medicine and physics
David Gorski 
Link
I must admit, it is possible that our fearless leader Steve has a more robust constitution than I do. I say this because he actually managed to sit through an entire video full of the most bizarre pseudoscience and mangling of physics and medicine that I’ve seen in quite some time.
And that’s saying a lot.
So, behold, Dr. Charlene Werner, an optometrist (apparently) and a homeopath. I warn you, however. If you have any understanding of physics or chemistry whatsoever or if you’ve ever read (and liked) Stephen Hawking’s book A Brief History of Time (or anything else he’s ever written), sit down now. Take a deep breath. Heck, crack open a bottle of wine and down at least half of it before you watch this video. I’m serious. You’ll need it. You might need to lie down, too. In fact, you might need to lie down with a cool washcloth across your eyes.
Don’t say I didn’t warn you:
Truly, the woo doth flow. Like a river. Like the energy from a supernova. From Bozeman, Montana, where, apparently they don’t have enough woo and have to import it from Texas. I haven’t seen such a massive pseudoscientific abuse of physics and chemistry in quite a long time.
I really like how Werner starts out by asking the audience if they’ve all had chemistry or physics classes. Truly, if anyone there said yes and didn’t immediately see her talk for the hilariously rank pseudoscience that it is, he should demand his money back from whatever school or schools he attended. Either that, or he should go back for remedial physics classes; obviously whatever he or shelearned didn’t stick.
Be that as it may, Werner then asks everyone if they know what H2O is and who Einstein is. Now, I know why a homeopath would mention water. After all, homeopathic remedies are nothing but water. But what did poor Albert Einstein do to deserve this posthumous desecration of his monumental contribution to physics? (I know, I know, what did any physicist do to deserve such abuse of science and his good name by homeopaths?) Get a load of this:
You know that when light is energy, right? OK. And he [Einstein] gave us the theory that energy equals mass times the speed of light. E=mc2. OK. If we take that formula, and we think that there’s a lot of mass, right? OK. If you collapse all the mass down into the universe, so that there is no space between the mass, do you know how much mass there is in the entire universe? You think you’re a lot of mass, right?… Well, the whole universal mass can be consolidated down into the size of a bowling ball. That’s all there is in the whole universe. So, how much mass are you? That’s right, an infinitessimal amount.
I bet you’re wondering where Werner is going with this. So was I. But I was afraid. Very afraid. Yes, I wasn’t sure whether she was right about being able to collapse the entire mass of the universe into the size of a bowling ball. My memory of my physics doesn’t tell me if it’s a bowling ball, a softball, or something the size of a house. I get the point. The vast majority of matter is the empty space between atoms and between electrons and nuclei. For purposes of this discussion it doesn’t really matter, anyway. What matters is the mind-numbing ignorance of what Werner says next:
So if you take that formula, E=mc2, you can almost cross out mass. So the formula ends up being “energy = the speeed of light.”
Arrrrghhhh! Help, help, I’m being made more scientifically stupid just by looking at this video! Talk about a math FAIL. First off, if you remove the mass term, what are you left with? Zero! No mass, no energy! Even if you could legitimately just drop the mass term as an approximation, you wouldn’t be left with “energy = the speed of light.” What happened to the squared term? Moreover, Werner completely misunderstands the nature of the equation. c2 is the proportionality constant for how much energy is present within a given mass. It’s a huge number, meaning that a small amount of mass contains a lot of energy, if that mass can be completely converted to energy. The point of the equation is not that mass is unimportant, rather that mass is very important indeed! That’s why I have a new equation:
I = mair2 * c4
where I = ignorance; mair = the mass of the air necessary to speak a Werner sentence about science; and c = the speed of light.
That’s right. Werner’s ignorance could power the universe. (Yes, I know that the units don’t quite work out. Either that, or the units of ignorance are in fact energy squared. Just go with me on this.)
But it gets better. Look at what Werner says next:
That’s why the visual system is so important, because we have lots of photorecptors that receive light. But when Hahnemann died, the scientists didn’t fall in his camp. OK. And, um, the pieces of the puzzle didn’t fit well together.
Actually, the pieces of homeopathy never fit together when Samuel Hahnemann was alive. It was woo then, it’s woo now. The only difference is the science-y gloss that its practitioners try to put on it with quantum mechanics and mangling of physics and chemistry. But wait, there’s more:
So God in his infinite wisdom sent us another Einstein called Stephen Hawkings. Stephen Hawkings gave us the string theory. And what he discovered is that there are other “energetic particles” in the universe, and they’re shaped like little U-eys, and what they do is they work by vibration. So our body is so wonderfully designed. We have light receivers, and we have ears. Vibratory–they pick up vibration. So if we added to that theory–Einstein’s theory of relativity, E=mc2, but mass is crossed out–and strings, vibration. But that still doesn’t tell us the whole picture, because what is a cell, right.
Alright, now stop right there. How much technobabble can one woman fit into a single talk? How much mangling of physics can one woman accomplish? Truly, I fear to know the answer. It was at this point that I started to wonder whether I should back out now. Just say no. Stop watching. the mind-destroying horror was too great. I could feel my neurons crying out in pain. But, no. The things I do for SBM! So I looked at what Werner said next:
The cell has a cell wall, a cell membrane, cytoplasm. Is that mass? Not very much, really. So what are they? You can break down the cells into tiny pieces of energy called electrons, protons, neutrons, right? So the whole body has an infinitessimal amount of mass, but what is the remainder? Energy. So, I am energy; you are energy.
You’ll have to excuse me if I can’t follow that logic. Maybe it’s because I understand biology and a bit of physics! Come on! She completely misunderstands Einstein’s equations. The concept that the body is a small amount of mass does not mean that it’s all energy. True, there’s a whole lot of energy in the body’s mass, but, unfortunatey, to turn that mass into all the energy described by Einstein’s classic equation would not be pleasant for the person whose energy was being–shall we say?–released. That doesn’t stop Werner’s monumental misunderstanding of physics from leading her to try to use this line of “reasoning” to argue that homeopathy is real and scientifically supported:
Now if you go to study physics, we do not know how to create energy. But we don’t know how to destroy it, either. That is not humanly possible. So what we do is we take energy and we transform it from one state to another. That’s all we do. So if that’s all we do guess what the definition of disease is. It’s not mass. We have transformed our energy state into something different. That’s what the definition of disease is.
As a physician, I can most definitely say that Werner’s definition of “disease” is related to the real definition of disease only by her own delusions. Actually, it’s not related to the real definition of disease at all. What we’re really seeing is a form of primitive vitalism, where there is some sort of “life energy” that, when its flows are disordered, blocked, or otherwise messed with magically, then you have disease, all gussied up with science-y sounding mish-mash of physics-y sounding psuedoscience. Let’s put it this way. Werner keeps using that word (energy). I do not think it means what she thinks it means. In any case, never mind those nasty microbes. After all, they’re just “mass,” and they’re far less mass than a human body or even a single mammalian cell. It’s the same with those proteins whose function becomes disordered; that DNA that has abnormalities; or those cellular functions that go awry. All mass. So, by Werner’s logic, they must not be able to cause disease, or so it would seem. Instead, she thinks she can use light, sound, and homeopathy to fix these energy “imbalances.” But what is homeopathy?
Alas, Werner is too happy to tell us:
OK, so what is homeopathy? If nothing is really mass or an infinitessimal amount of it, and everything is energy, that means everything has a vibration to it. So what if I could encase some sort of energy for later use? So if I wanted to make a bomb and I took all these chemicals and I encased it in a bomb, and tonight my neighber let his dog poop in my yard literally, and I’m mad at that dog and my neighbor. I’m going to take this bomb and I’m going to get back at him. And I threw that bomb at his house, would he be happy about it? Because what happens now when that energy is released? It destroys something. It changes it…It changes its energetic state. Well, that’s what we can do with homeopathy. We take substances. And we put ‘em in solution and we succuss it just like a bomb, we threw the bomb, to release its energy into this liquid. And then we take these little white pellets. We sprinkle them with that solution, and guess what we have just made? An energetic substance to be used when we choose to use it. So, how homeopathy works is, whatever your disease process is, it’s an energetic change. And if I can find the remedy that matches your state and give it to you when we so choose, what can we do with your energy system? Transform it to a previous better state. That’s how it works.
How simple.
Actually, Werner is right about one thing. Homeopathy is kind of like a response to a dog pooping on your lawn. Not only is it a major stinker, but one could use homeopathy to clean off the residue of dog crap from the lawn, if you use enough of it. It is, after all, water. In case anyone doesn’t know what succussion is, too, it’s what homeopaths do with their remedies between each step on the way of diluting them into nonexistence. Basically, it’s vigorous shaking. Hahnemann used to do it by smacking the vial containing his concoction against a Bible; modern day homeopaths have machines that do it. Whatever method they use, though, since Hahnemann’s time, the way homepaths prepare their remedies is that they dilute them 1:100, succuss them, dilute them 1:100 again, and so on and so forth for however many “C” the remedy is ultimately to be. If the remedy is a typical 30C remedy, that’s 30 dilutions of 1:100, or a total dilution of 10-60, or roughly 36 to 37 orders of magnitude greater than Avagadro’s number, which guarantees that there almost certainly isn’t a single molecule left of the substance used for the homeopathy remedy. Of course, in general, it’s not a good idea to succuss bomb components. Bombmakers who do that tend to lose body parts or the physical integrity of their entire body. Now, there‘s some vibration!
After I had picked up my brain off the floor, its having oozed out of my ears as I watched this, and forced it back into my skull, I wondered just who Charlene Werner is. Apparently, in addition to homeopathy, she is a practitioner of a therapy that I’ve never heard of, namely behavioral or developmental optometry. If you wnat a flavor of what developmental optometry is, I’ll refer you to Dr. Werner’s own website:
We are a holistic based optometric practice dedicated to the highest quliaty vision care for your entire family. We believe that 70% of how you physically function is through the vision system. Therefore, when the vision system is improved or enhanced it also increases overall physical wellness and performance. Don’t take our word for it … ask our patients.
70% of how we physically function is due to our vision? Where did that number come from? Why not 100%? I do understand one thing that puzzled me before. Remember how at the very beginning she mentioned how our eyes can see light and vibration? Obviously, she was combining the woo that is homeopathy with her other favored treatment modalities, which–surprise, surprise–do not appear to be evidence-based, as Steve pointed out.
In any case Werner’s website emphasizes testimonials over science and is full of claims that “behavioral optometry” can treat ADHD, dyslexia, and a wide variety of other conditions. Indeed, it can even treat problems associated with autism! Now, I know that it could be very difficult to do a vision evaluation in an autistic child and that correcting poor vision is a good thing in any child, but the results reported on Dr. Werner’s website seem rather more glowing than seems plausible. Be that as it may, why not treat autism with “visual therapy”? Dubious practitioners of all stripes have tried everything else. No doubt Werner combines homeopathy with visual therapy to produce a one-two punch of woo. All she needs is chelation therapy to complete the triad. In any case, if vision is 70% of our “physical functioning,” then what can’t it help? Of course, I do notice a disconnect between Werner’s claims that we are “all energy” and “infinitesimal mass,” then why does she even care about the physical functioning of everything in our bodies? Just make one of those homeopathic energy bombs and fix whatever’s ailing the patient! We’re all energy, anyway, and disease is energy. Isn’t that what Werner just told us?
The really sad thing about the video above is that it’s not the worst of arguments that homeopaths make. (For that, you need Dana Ullman.) Rather, Werner’s arguments for homeopathy are pretty much standard fare, although they are not nearly as entertaining as those of, say, Lionel Milgrom. What they do show is a perfect case of crank magnetism.
Just don’t let your dog poop on Werner’s lawn. You might find yourself at the receiving end of a homeopathic energetic bomb, and you know that the more she dilutes it the stronger it gets.

   Getting It On with Homeopathy
Wallace Sampson
Link
I have more thoughts on the homeopathy matter than fit in follow-up notes, so here goes.
First, David Gorski recalls the 1994 Pediatrics report on childhood diarrhea treated with tailored homeopathic remedies for each patient. There is more to the story than has been written. I am certain much of this will get back to the authors, but others may benefit from knowing how this group of homeopaths operate.
I recall the paper well, because it was the first journal report that I deconstructed and published (Pediatrics, Oct 1995) as a regular article. I think it was the first time the journal had published a formal rebuttal outside the Letters section. The head of pediatric pharmacy at Valley Medical Center, San Jose, brought the paper to me and asked what I thought if it. Bill London of National Council against Health Fraud and I spent six months discussing it and working over the details.
The paper had so many flaws, that one letter could not contain them. It had five or six end points, several arithmetical errors, graphs with missing data, only one end point reached consensus signficance (barely.)
Each case received a remedy tailored to the age, condition, duration of symptoms, appearance and odor of the stool, the recall of the parent or relative about stool frequency (which depended on how often the child’s diapers were changed, and a number of other qualities, typical of a homeopathic approach to diagnosis. The remedies given were not based on etiology, but based on personal observations, We saw that the remedy was chosen at a snapshot in time, depending on all those factors which varied from hour to hour. So the remedies depended on the time at which the child was brought in for examination and were unchanged throughout the duration of illness. That made no sense at all. Besides, the specific remedies had no data behind them for proof of efficacy, and were chosen on basis of charts and computer references.
One could hardly find anything about the paper that would lend credibility to its conclusion that suggested homeopathy “worked“ better than placebo. The results in our opinion demonstrated nothing more than the variations in the clinical trial system (noise.)
The editors received dozens of complaining letters about its publication, and was embarrassed enough to depart from tradition and publish ours, which was four pages long. Although we made one technical error about the statistical analysis, the other criticisms were obvious and valid.
The current SBM discussion regarded the ethics of the study. (beginning with the one written about by Harriet Hall.) I must admit that ethics were not in our consciousness at the time we discussed the paper, so we did not comment on ethics. One wonders if standard therapy was withheld; but the authors were careful to have selected only children with mild diarrhea – less than 6 stools/day – who did not require rehydration fluids. Sicker children were excluded or removed from the trial and treated appropriately. I’d have to check on the informed consent – I don‘t recall. But unless it stated that there was no evidence that homeopathy works, any consent would have failed the criterion of informed. .
But more followed and the story got more interesting. We had pointed out that despite the absence of clear efficacy there was no assurance that the homeopathic remedies were not adulterated by antibiotics or anti-diarrheals. So the authors repeated the study, but next time in Nepal instead of Nicaragua. No reason was given for the change. This time an independent agent checked the remedies for adulteration and none was found. They published the results of the second study in the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine (2000). Word got around that it was submitted to standard medical journals and was rejected. When I saw the second study, the most apparent problem I saw was that the end points “positive” in the Nicaragua study were negative in Nepal and vice versa. I interpreted the studies as having disconfirmed each other. Nevertheless, the homeopaths claimed that the Nepal study confirmed the Nicaragua trial. As I recall also, the homeopathic group weighed more (was significantly older) than the control group; older children have shorter courses of diarrhea illness than younger. A letter to the “alt” journal would have been wasted effort. Unfortunately, the journal is abstracted on Medline.
If that was not enough to bother you, the authors went further. And here is where the two strains of recent discussions meet – the Hall/Gorski/Atwood et al discussion – homeopathy/ethics and clinical trial/meta-analysis. Jacobs combined the borderline data from the two studies plus the pilot study preceding the Nicaragua trial into a meta-analysis. They obtained a more significant P value. Not mentioned was that the respective data from the trials conflicted with one another. This MA they published in Pediatrics Infectious Disease Journal I 2003. I took the results of the MA to a well known authority on MAs at Stanford whose course I had been auditing. His response? A combined blank stare and shrug. Then a look like…don’t you really know? I did, of course.

Homeopathy + AI = Still Nonsense
Artificial Intelligence can’t make pseudoscience real
Scott Gavura on June 8, 2023
Link

What happens when you “combine” pseudoscience with a trendy but real science, one that’s popular but poorly understood? You get the ridiculous idea that artificial intelligence (AI) can be effectively combined with homeopathy, or make it more effective. Mark Crislip has many famous statements, and one of my favorites is:
If you integrate fantasy with reality, you do not instantiate reality. If you mix cow pie with apple pie, it does not make the cow pie taste better; it makes the apple pie worse.
Not surprisingly, there’s not much AI can bring to an alternative medicine practice that has no grounding in science or reality.
From “The Health Site“,
For the first time in India, Dr. Batra’s Healthcare is bringing AI skin treatment with the goodness of homeopathy. The company on Tuesday announced the introduction of AI Skin Pro, an AI-powered device for diagnosis of skin diseases. Imported from South Korea, it is claimed that the machine is the world’s 5th generation AI-powered skin analyzer and a futuristic method of treating skin problems.
According to experts at Dr. Batra’s, this AI-powered device (AI Skin Pro) can spot skin problems deep within the skin (dermis) before they appear on the surface. In conjunction with Homoeopathy, which is holistic, safe and without side-effects, AI Skin Pro offers an advanced method of treating skin problems.
What the vendor seems to be offering is a device that recommends homeopathy based on some sort of algorithm that is derived from a facial scan. I was unable to find any details about the device, but Dr. Batra’s seems to be a large homeopathy retailer. How the device evaluates the skin, and what it actually assesses, isn’t described. There are no shortage of supposed “AI-powered” skin analysis tools, but this seems to be the only company that links it to homeopathic remedies.
Which is actually perfect, given homeopathy remedies are typically chemically indistinguishable – they are all effectively placebo, yet felt to offer medicinal effects. So no matter what the algorithm identifies, consumers will likely receive the exact same product – a placebo.
Samuel Hahnemann invented the practice of homeopathy in the early 1800s. While the practice of medicine slowly progressed to a scientific model based on objective observations, homeopathy,  has never progressed or evolved. Its practices today are frozen in the same prescientific beliefs of Hahnemann. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like is simply sympathetic magic, a pre-scientific belief. Homoepathy proponents also believe that water has memory, and the more you dilute a substance, the more powerful its effects. The 30C “potency” is a common dilution used in homeopathy – that’s a dilution of 10-60. If something has been diluted this much, you would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original, pre-diluted material. The result of all this dilution is that most homeopathic remedies are completely inert, and don’t contain a single molecule of the original reference material. And that original reference material can range from table salt to sunlight to vacuum cleaner dust. There is no product so bizarre that homeopaths haven’t made a remedy out of it. Whether bottled as a liquid or added to creams and moisturizers and sold as medicine, they don’t contain any active medicine. Which perhaps is the point of homeopathic skincare…if it involves applying something to your skin, then the base cream/lotion will be doing the heavy lifting.
Admittedly while AI-powered homeopathic skin care is a minor issue, it illustrates how alternative medicine proponents crave the legitimacy of science, even as they reject it.
Let you have any illusions about ChatGPT, I asked it how how AI could benefit homeopathy, and this is what it said:
AI can potentially benefit homeopathy in several ways:
     1.  Data analysis: Homeopathy relies on collecting and analyzing vast amounts of patient data to determine the most appropriate remedies for individual cases. AI can assist in analyzing this data quickly and efficiently, identifying patterns and correlations that may not be immediately apparent to human practitioners. This can help in discovering new remedies, refining existing ones, and improving overall treatment outcomes.
     2.  Patient assessment: AI can aid in the initial assessment of patients by analyzing their symptoms, medical history, and other relevant information. By leveraging machine learning algorithms, AI systems can provide more accurate and personalized recommendations for homeopathic remedies based on a comprehensive analysis of individual cases.
     3.  Treatment recommendation: AI can assist homeopathic practitioners by suggesting potential remedies based on the symptoms presented by patients. By analyzing a vast database of remedies, historical treatment records, and patient outcomes, AI can generate recommendations that align with the principles of homeopathy and help practitioners in their decision-making process.
     4.  Research and development: AI can accelerate research and development in homeopathy by automating certain aspects of the process. AI systems can analyze scientific literature, clinical trials, and experimental data to identify new relationships between remedies and conditions, suggest potential avenues for further investigation, and aid in the formulation of new remedies.
     5.  Quality control: Homeopathic remedies are prepared through a process called potentization, which involves dilution and succussion (vigorous shaking). Ensuring the quality and consistency of remedies can be challenging. AI can assist in quality control by analyzing manufacturing processes, monitoring parameters such as dilution ratios and succussion duration, and providing feedback to ensure that remedies are prepared accurately and consistently.
It’s important to note that while AI can provide valuable support to homeopathic practitioners, the fundamental principles and practice of homeopathy should still be guided by the expertise and experience of trained professionals. AI should be seen as a tool to enhance and augment their capabilities rather than replace them.
Large language models, like ChatGPT, build their responses based on enormous amounts of data, and can organize paragraphs (like the ones above) in ways that seem coherent and convincing. But, like homeopathy itself, they are only as strong as their foundation. ChatGPT can spew nonsense answers if the inputs it considers are nonsense. Homeopathy is based on a foundation that is a belief system, and not a science. No amount of science applied to homeopathy, whether it’s AI-based or otherwise, can chance the fact that it is a pseudoscience.

Researching the Magic of Homeopathy
Steven Novella on October 12, 2016
Link
A Canadian academic, Dr. Mark Loeb, who is a respected infectious disease researcher who knows how to conduct high quality research, wants to study homeopathic nosodes. Nosodes are essentially homeopathic vaccines.
Tim Caulfield, a Canadian professor of health law and policy, thinks the study is misguided and unethical. The two are having a respectful public debate about the risks and merits of doing such a study.
David Gorski and I have actually published in the peer-reviewed literature on the broader question of studying alternative medicine: “Clinical trials of integrative medicine: testing whether magic works?” So we have both weighed in already on this debate, but since this is a major theme of science-based medicine I thought it was important to bring the discussion here as well. It is an interesting dilemma worth discussing, and we are seeing that exact dilemma play out on the question of this specific proposed study.
Homeopathy is pseudoscience
For quick background, both sides in this debate agree that homeopathy is 100% pseudoscientific nonsense. Homeopathy was invented by one person, Samuel Hahnemann, about 200 years ago. It was not based on any scientific research or knowledge base, it did not develop out of emerging knowledge of biology or physiology. It was simply invented out of whole cloth based loosely on the superstitious belief in sympathetic magic – the notion that substances contain a mysterious “essence” that can be transferred to the body and stimulate the life force.
The result is the homeopathy practices of like cures like and extreme dilutions. Take a substance that causes symptoms in regular doses then dilute it out of existence so that only the “essence” remains, and use that to cure the same symptoms. After 200 years, these principles are still magic and superstition. They are pre-scientific, and have not been validated by any subsequent scientific research.Despite this utter lack of scientific plausibility, there have been a number of clinical trials using homeopathy. Most use poor research methodologies and are of low quality, but some are well controlled. The entirely unsurprising result of this research, when viewed in total, is that homeopathy does not work. Even after two centuries, homeopathy has not been shown to work for a single indication.
The debate
Despite the complete lack of scientific plausibility and the negative clinical trials, homeopathy is still a multi-billion dollar industry and enjoys approval by most governments. In the US homeopathic potions are classified as drugs and given automatic approval, although the FDA is reviewing that policy.
Because of this, Mark Loeb argues, it is helpful to conduct high quality research into homeopathy. Even if this research does not convince the true believers, the results, assuming they are negative, can be used to pressure governments to more appropriately regulate homeopathy.
Loeb argues that on this specific question, that of nosodes, there has not been any high quality research. He intends to compare nosodes to vaccines to placebos, looking at the production of antibodies and B and T-cell responses. His hypothesis is that nosodes will be no different than placebo.
Caulfield takes the position closer to what David and I took in our article. If 200 years of science is not enough to convince someone that homeopathy is bunk, or to convince regulators, then one more study is not going to do it.
There are also a number of very real downsides to conducting such research. First, the very fact that homeopathy is being researched by a respected researcher at a university will be used by believers to argue that homeopathy is legitimate. Why else would they be studying it? At the very least, it’s an open question.
Second, this is a waste of limited research resources. We know the answer. Both sides agree on what the answer is overwhelmingly likely to be. The time, money, and infrastructure would be better used studying valid scientific questions.
There is also the question of ethics. It is actually unethical to subject people to treatments that the researcher knows to be worthless. There is the principle of equipoise – there has to be a legitimate scientific question at stake. As David and I pointed out in our published article:
Even so, the major assumption underlying EBM is that by the time an investigational treatment is ready for RCTs it has passed all preclinical tests and has thus demonstrated biological plausibility. Before, CAM or IM, treatments without biological plausibility and compelling evidence from preclinical studies and pilot clinical trials usually did not reach the stage of RCTs. Indeed, so integral to this process is biological plausibility based on preclinical data that the Declaration of Helsinki [8] states, ‘medical research involving human subjects must conform to generally accepted scientific principles, be based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific literature, other relevant sources of information, and adequate laboratory and, as appropriate, animal experimentation’.
This gets to the difference between evidence-based medicine and science-based medicine. Loeb is taking an EBM approach here, thinking that clinical evidence will settle this debate. However, SBM differs in that it explicitly holds that clinical trials are only meaningful if they are done in the context of supporting basic science. This is partly because clinical trials are difficult and are rife with false positives. The only way to know where to set the threshold for how much clinical evidence is convincing is to know what the prior probability is from basic science and existing clinical research.
In the case of homeopathy, the prior probability is effectively zero. Therefore, taking a Bayesian approach, one even very rigorous clinical trial cannot possibly change the prior plausibility to any significant degree.
History also suggests the study will not convince anyone of anything. Believers in homeopathy will simply argue that nosodes work through another mechanism not captured by measuring antibodies and white cells. That is a reductionist approach, when homeopathy is holistic and works in a much more subtle way through life essence, or some similar complete nonsense.
The hope that one more study is going to push us over some threshold and now regulators are going to start doing the right thing is not impossible, but is wishful thinking.
One could argue, as a compromise, to do the study in rats. At least then we won’t have the ethical issue of subjecting human subjects to a treatment known to be worthless.
The real problem
The real underlying problem that is creating this dilemma is the tolerance for pseudoscience in medicine. I understand Loeb’s intent, and it seems like a rational thing to do. Just do high quality research and use the results to convince everyone, or at least government officials, to do the rational thing. If only the world worked that way.
As Jonathan Swift said: “Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired.”
The truth is a bit more complicated, and there are always exceptions, but recent psychological research shows this to be essentially correct. If you hold a belief for ideological reasons, and you are emotionally invested in that belief, then evidence and reason will not dissuade you. Rather, you will dig in your heels when confronted with evidence.
However, not everyone has an emotionally-invested opinion about homeopathy or alternative medicine. For those without a strong conviction, evidence and reason do matter. So you might argue that doing a study might help convince the uncommitted.
But again – I would argue that we already have enough evidence. Loeb’s position would be semi-legitimate if there were no quality studies of homeopathy. We are simply way past that point – there is overwhelming scientific evidence that homeopathy cannot work and does not work, and any further evidence is redundant. Homeopathy is not an implausible unknown, it is a known failure.
What we really need, as Caulfield points out, is for the scientific, academic, and medical communities to get their shit together. There is a strong consensus that homeopathy is nonsense, the problem is that most academics don’t care. They are shruggies. They think it is harmless nonsense not worth their time or attention. They have either not bothered to look into it enough to know what nonsense it is, or they don’t want to dirty their hands by pointing out that it’s nonsense.
This is a cultural problem within academia. They are collectively failing society. Loeb is not going to fix this underlying problem with one high quality study.
Another way to look at the situation is this – further studies should only be conducted when they are explicitly and directly connected to regulatory action. In other words, do the research if the results of that research will be used to modify regulation. We need more than the hope that it will – we need a commitment ahead of time. Otherwise the research is truly pointless.

A truly homeopathic defense of homeopathy
David Gorski on December 17, 2012
Link
I realize that I’ve said it many times before, but it bears repeating. Homeopathy is the perfect quackery. The reason that homeopathy is so perfect as a form of quackery is because it is quite literally nothing. On second thought, I suppose that it’s not exactly nothing. It is, after all, water or whatever other diluent that homeopaths use (usually ethanol). However, thanks to some basic laws of physics and chemistry and a little thing known as Avogadro’s number, any homeopathic dilution greater than 12C (twelve serial 100-fold dilutions) is incredibly unlikely to contain even a single molecule of starting compound. That unlikeliness reaches truly astonishing levels as we reach the common homeopathic dilution of 30C, which is the equivalent of a 1060-fold dilution. Given that that little thing known as Avogadro’s number, which describes how many molecules of a compound are in a mole, is only approximately 6 x 1023, a 30C dilution is on the order of 1036– to 1037-fold higher than Avogadro’s number. Even assuming that a homeopath started with a mole of remedy before diluting (unlikely, given the high molecular weight of most of the organic compounds that can serve as homeopathic remedies), the odds that a single molecule could remain behind after the serial dilution and succussion process is infinitesimal. Appropriately enough, the “law” in homeopathy that states that diluting a remedy will make it stronger is the law of infinitesimals.
It is also the reason that homeopathy is nothing.
Homeopaths have known these facts for many decades. Anyone who is any sort of a scientist or has an understanding of science, when confronted with these simple, well-established physical laws, might—just might—start to rethink his belief in something that is so utterly implausible from a scientific standpoint. Indeed, homeopathy is about as close to impossible as anything I can imagine, because for it to “work” multiple well-established laws of physics and chemistry would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong. Yet, as Richard Dawkins famously put it, undeterred, homeopaths bravely paddle up the river of pseudoscience and invent explanations to “explain” how homeopathy could work, the most famous of which is the so-called “memory of water,” in which the water in the homeopathic remedy remembers all the good bits meant to heal but, as Tim Minchin so famously put it, somehow forgets all the poo that’s been in it. Homeopathy is truly magical thinking, which is why I love to use it as an illustrative example of quackery. Not only is it magical thinking, but because it is nothing but water, it’s a very useful educational example for placebo effects and the general types of fallacious arguments quacks and pseudoscientists make. Apparently it’s time for another one.
Not too long ago, I wrote about the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM), specifically how until fairly recently it would fund studies of the ridiculously implausible treatment modality that is homeopathy. I even looked at a couple of these studies to see if they had yielded anything of value. Not surprisingly, they did not, other than some unbelievably awful papers published mostly in bottom-feeding alt-med journals. The principal investigator (PI) of the grants in question, it turns out, is a woman named Iris Bell, who, it further turns out, is faculty at the University of Arizona, home to that godfather of “integrating” quackery into real medicine (i.e., “integrative medicine”), Andrew Weil. Now, it just so happens that I’ve found a “review” article on homeopathy written by this very same person, published in BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine a little more than a month ago and entitled A model for homeopathic remedy effects: low dose nanoparticles, allostatic cross-adaptation, and time-dependent sensitization in a complex adaptive system. Truly, this is an apologetic for homeopathy that could have been written by Dana Ullman or Lionel Milgrom, and it’s appearing in what is turning into one of the foremost journals of quackademic medicine.
Thw quackademia is strong in this one
The central thesis of the paper, which Harriet Hall has discussed before, is the concept that homeopathy works through “nanoparticles.” Of course, like so many things that quacks appropriate for themselves, like quantum theory and epigenetics, nanoparticles are a real phenomenon with many therapeutic promises. Unfortunately, the versions of nanoparticles described by Bell are related to real nanoparticles as scientists currently understand them only by coincidence. So, as you will soon see, what we have here is an NIH-funded investigator (funded through NCCAM) teaming up with Mary Koithan to write a mass of pseudoscience defending homeopathy and proposing a mechanism by which it might work. Think on that a moment as I delve into the actual paper. In fact, even though this paper is open-source (which means that you can read the entire thing for yourself), I think I’ll nonetheless lay down the abstract, because it is truly a thing of quackademic beauty:
BackgroundThis paper proposes a novel model for homeopathic remedy action on living systems. Research indicates that homeopathic remedies (a) contain measurable source and silica nanoparticles heterogeneously dispersed in colloidal solution; (b) act by modulating biological function of the allostatic stress response network (c) evoke biphasic actions on living systems via organism-dependent adaptive and endogenously amplified effects; (d) improve systemic resilience.
DiscussionThe proposed active components of homeopathic remedies are nanoparticles of source substance in water-based colloidal solution, not bulk-form drugs. Nanoparticles have unique biological and physico-chemical properties, including increased catalytic reactivity, protein and DNA adsorption, bioavailability, dose-sparing, electromagnetic, and quantum effects different from bulk-form materials. Trituration and/or liquid succussions during classical remedy preparation create “top-down” nanostructures. Plants can biosynthesize remedytemplated silica nanostructures. Nanoparticles stimulate hormesis, a beneficial low-dose adaptive response. Homeopathic remedies prescribed in low doses spaced intermittently over time act as biological signals that stimulate the organism’s allostatic biological stress response network, evoking nonlinear modulatory, self-organizing change. Potential mechanisms include time-dependent sensitization (TDS), a type of adaptive plasticity/metaplasticity involving progressive amplification of host responses, which reverse direction and oscillate at physiological limits. To mobilize hormesis and TDS, the remedy must be appraised as a salient, but low level, novel threat, stressor, or homeostatic disruption for the whole organism. Silica nanoparticles adsorb remedy source and amplify effects. Properly-timed remedy dosing elicits disease-primed compensatory reversal in direction of maladaptive dynamics of the allostatic network, thus promoting resilience and recovery from disease.
SummaryHomeopathic remedies are proposed as source nanoparticles that mobilize hormesis and time-dependent sensitization via non-pharmacological effects on specific biological adaptive and amplification mechanisms. The nanoparticle nature of remedies would distinguish them from conventional bulk drugs in structure, morphology, and functional properties. Outcomes would depend upon the ability of the organism to respond to the remedy as a novel stressor or heterotypic biological threat, initiating reversals of cumulative, cross-adapted biological maladaptations underlying disease in the allostatic stress response network. Systemic resilience would improve. This model provides a foundation for theory-driven research on the role of nanomaterials in living systems, mechanisms of homeopathic remedy actions and translational uses in nanomedicine.
Ah, I do so love me some good technobabble, and the above is some of the best, as I said before, on par with Lionel Milgrom’s quantum homeopathy or his visualization of quantum entanglement at a macroscopic level between practitioner, remedy, and patient. (Never mind that quantum entanglement doesn’t work that way. Never let reality or science get in the way of brilliant-sounding science-y blather that impresses the rubes.)
Let’s deconstruct a bit, shall we? First, Bell is saying that “research indicates” that there are measurable source and silica nanoparticles in homeopathic remedies. Hmmmm. I wonder where silica nanoparticles could come from, if in fact they have actually been detected in homeopathic remedies. It couldn’t have anything to do with the fact that most homeopathic dilutions are made in glass vials, could it? Perish the thought! In any case, if you delve into the introduction, which says essentially the same thing as the abstract, only longer and with a lot of nonsensical references, you’ll find that one of the references that purports to claim that there are “nanoparticles” in homeopathic remedies is the very same paper that our very own Harriet discussed. personally, even though the paper is two years old, I can’t resist taking a crack at it myself, because it is such an incredible joke that it has to be seen.
Back to the future, or: you should really check your solutions more carefully
The article to which I’m referring was an article by Prashant Satish Chikramane and his colleagues at Department of Chemical Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Bombay, India. Entitled Extreme homeopathic dilutions retain starting materials: A nanoparticulate perspective. Basically, the investigators…well, it’s too easy to give away the results in a sentence or two; so let me pontificate a little more before I do.
First off, this article appears in the journal Homeopathy. Yes, there is indeed a journal called Homeopathy. Given the level of pseudoscience that must be within the pages of a journal called Homeopathy, I fear a block hole of woo, which will suck all real science into its event horizon, leaving nothing behind but more woo. Personally, though, I like to think of Homeopathy as one of those fake journals designed to put a patina of science in the form of science-y sounding jargon and the appearance of using the scientific method but without actual science. Either that, or the articles within do actually adhere to the scientific method, but in the end they are nothing more than what Harriet Hall likes to call “tooth fairy science.” Given that homeopathy violates several known physical laws and that, for homeopathy to work, not only would scientists have to be wrong about huge swaths of well-characterized science they’d have to be spectacularly wrong.
So let’s see how Chikramane et al try to justify homeopathy. After all, I love reading introductions to homeopathy papers. After having declared homeopathy to have “stood the test of time,” Chikramane et al then go on to level this howler:
However, a major lacuna has been the lack of evidence of physical existence of the starting material. The main difficulty in arriving at a rational explanation stems from the fact that homeopathic medicines are used in extreme dilutions, including dilution factors exceeding Avogadro’s number by several orders of magnitude, in which one would not expect any measurable remnant of the starting material to be present. In clinical practice, homeopathic potencies of 30c and 200c having dilution factors of 1060 and 10400 respectively, far beyond Avogadro’s number of 6.023 Ã 1023 molecules in one mole, are routinely used.
Many hypotheses have been postulated to justify and elucidate their mechanisms of action. While some hypotheses such as the theory of water memory,formation of clathrates, and epitaxy are conjectural in nature, others such as those based on the quantum physical aspects of the solutions and have not been sufficiently tested, either due to complexity in validating the hypothesis or due to non-reproducible results. The ‘silica hypothesis’ is the only model that proposes the presence of physical entities such as siloxanes or silicates resulting from leaching from the glass containers. Following a dearth of credible and testable hypotheses to identify any physical entity responsible for medicinal activity, most modern scientists continue to believe that homeopathy at best provides a placebo effect.
This being all science-y and all, there should be a testable hypothesis, and apparently the authors did have what appears to be a testable hypothesis. In any case, the apparent hypothesis is that there would be structural differences in the homeopathic remedies. So our intrepid investigators went out and obtained a bunch of homeopathic remedies from various Indian manufacturers of homeopathic remedies at three different potencies (how I hate ot use that word in this context), including 6C, 12C, and 30C, all of them in 90% ethanol. They then analyzed these physico-chemical aspects:
     1.  The presence of the physical entities in nanoparticle form and their size by Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) by bright-field and dark-field imaging.
     2.  Their identification by matching the Selected Area Electron Diffraction (SAED) patterns against literature standards for the corresponding known crystals.
     3.  Estimation of the levels of starting metals by a 500-fold concentration of medicines, followed by chemical analysis using Inductively Coupled Plasma-Atomic Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-AES).
The homeopathic remedies were chosen to have been based on various metals “so chosen that the metals would not arise either as impurities or as contaminants.”
Huh?
Did the investigators think that metals couldn’t find their way into these homeopathic remedies somewhere along the way in the manufacturing process? Another problem with the paper is that the investigators used as their control HPLC-grade ethanol and Milli-Q water. How on earth did they know that the manufacturers were so fastidious as to use HPLC-grade ethanol and Milli-Q water, the latter of which is distilled, highly filtered, and then deionized to a ridiculously high electrical resistance? I use Milli-Q water all the time for molecular biology experiments because it is so pure and free of electrolytes. So, right off the bat, we see the investigators using a dubious control that isn’t equivalent to their manufactured homeopathic remedies purchased from “reputable” firms, meaning that any differences they observe can’t necessarily be attributed to the homeopathic dilutions of the metals. Not surprisingly, the investigators found differences, and, their being believers in homeopathy, they immediately made all sorts of ridiculous conclusions:
Zincum met, Aurum met, Stannum met and Cuprum met 30c and 200c were analyzed by TEM. The results are given as photomicrographs (Figure 1(a)e(p)), which clearly demonstrate the presence of nanoparticles and their aggregates. Due to extreme dilution often only a single nanoparticle or a large aggregate is seen. Hereafter, the term ‘particles’ collectively refers to the nanoparticles and their aggregates. We noted a high polydispersity of the particles in the solutions.
And this is what they saw:
Perhaps an inorganic chemist out there can tell me if I’m wrong, but there doesnt’ appear to be any thing particularly special appearing about these particles. Looking at them, it also just occurred to me that there’s another possible explanation for these particles, one in which it is the authors themselves who introduced them into the homeopathic remedies:
The residues of Cuprum met, Stannum met, and Zincum met were acidified to solubilize the particles of their respective starting metals by addition of concentrated nitric acid. Similarly, aqua regia (concentrated nitric acid and concentrated hydrochloric acid in the ratio 1:3) was added to residues of Aurum met, Argentum met, and Platinum met.
I was a chemistry major, and, even though it was nearly 30 years ago, I still remember that concentrated nitric acid contained a fair number of heavy metal impurities. For instance, it can have 5 ppm iron and 10 ppm heavy metals. That’s a lot more heavy metal than a homeopathic dose. On the other hand, the authors report that their analyses were consistent with the metals used in the starting materials. This leads them to conclude:
The confirmed presence of these crystalline species of starting materials or those derived from them (as evident from the SAED patterns) despite the ultra-high dilutions such as 30c and 200c was astounding, proving that the starting materials were retained even with extremely high dilutions.
Actually, I’m a bit less than astounded. An alternative, more plausible, explanation, particularly given the propensity for ayruvedic herbs and other “alternative” medicines produced in India to be contaminated with heavy metals is that the manufacturing plants were thoroughly contaminated with the heavy metals that were supposedly the original starting material for the homeopathic remedies that they manufacture.
Of course, I haven’t even gotten to the most howlingly hilarious flaw in the whole study is where the authors:
During our analyses we also noted the plateauing effect of the concentrations of the starting metals per se in a particular concentration range in potencies 6c, 30c and 200c, in spite of 30c and 200c potencies being 1048 and 10388 respectively more dilute than 6c. It is interesting to note that the plateau for non-noble metals showed a higher metal content than for noble metals. Our ICP-AES results suggested that the asymptote effect commences around 6c potency.
Did it ever occur to the investigators that the reason the asymptotic effect occurs is because maybe, just maybe, that’s about the level of contaminants that are naturally in the plant and/or the water being used to dilute and succuss the homepathic remedy at each step? That maybe, just maybe, it’s impossible to figure out whether those particles they detected were there all along as contaminants in the diluent water used? The authors don’t even consider that possibility, nor do they do any experiments to test for it. Rather, they simply assume that the manufacturers got it right and that these particles are truly a result of the homepathic dilution and succussion process. They speculate wildly about “nanobubbles” and “nanobubble-nanoparticle complexes” as keeping the metal particles from being diluted and succussed way to nothing through 30 100-fold dilutions. Even if this were true, there is no explanation how these particles could have any biological effect. Rather, it is merely assumed that they do and that their very existence somehow validates the woo that is homeopathy, so that the authors conclude:
We have found that the concentrations reach a plateau at the 6c potency and beyond. Further, we have shown that despite large differences in the degree of dilution from 6c to 200c (1012 to 10400), there were no major differences in the nature of the particles (shape and size) of the starting material and their absolute concentrations (in pg/ml).
I can’t help but again ask the authors if they ever considered that the reason tha tthe concentration of nanoparticles didn’t change in concentration or appearance was that they are natural contaminants of the water used to produce the homoepathic dilutions. Apparently not. In the end, it’s truly amusing how a group of homeopaths can take a result that almost certainly is nothing more than detecting heavy metal contamination in homeopathic remedies manufactured in India, a country known for having heavy metal conatmination in herbal remedies and ayruvedic medicines it manufactures and then run with it straight off the end of the plank into a sea of woo. And this is but one quackademic paper cited by Bell to justify her hypothesis. So let’s move on and see what that hypothesis is.
Nanoparticles, hormesis, and allostatic stress response networks, oh my!
I must give Iris Bell credit. She is imaginative. Of course, although imagination is a good thing in science, there is a difference between imagination and just making stuff up, and Bell’s review article definitely falls into the latter category. Given that she is a homeopath, this is perhaps not surprising. What helped me get through her article was to view it as a work of fiction, in which the wildest flight of fancy wins, particularly if one can put a nice homeopathic science-y sounding sheen on it, which Bell does with aplomb. What you need to know to understand why homeopaths have latched on to nanoparticles is that (1) even homeopaths know that physics and chemistry as we understand them render homeopathy physically impossible and (2) they need to change the game if they are to put a chink in the dam of science holding back their river of woo. In other words, having conceded that those nasty reductionist scientists are right when they point out that homeopathy is water and cannot work they way homeopaths claim, homeopaths need to reclaim plausibility, no matter how much they have to abuse other sciences to do it.
For example, after pointing out that under “conventional” science homeopathy is impossible, Bell then opines:
These points are seemingly valid, if the underlying assumptions are valid – i.e., that homeopathic medicines are ordinary, dissolved and diluted bulk-form chemical drugs in true solution that could only act pharmacologically [47] with linear dose–response relationships. However, the trituration and succussion procedures in classical homeopathic remedy preparation may actually be crude manual methods that generate “top down” nanoparticles of source material. Nanoparticles range in size from 1 nanometer (nm) on a side up to 1000 nm or more, though much nanoscience research focuses on special acquired properties of small nanoparticles below 100 nm [48]. Trituration with mortar and pestle is a manual method for mechanical grinding or milling, similar to ball milling used in modern nanotechnology [49,50]. Like modern nanotechnology methods of microfluidization [51,52], sonication [53,54], and vortexing [55], manual succussions introduce intense turbulence, particle collisions, and shear forces into solution that break off smaller and smaller particles of remedy source material as well as silica from the walls of the glass containers or vials [1]. The combined impact of these mechanical nanosizing procedures [54] would be to modify the properties of the remedy [26,30,32], generating remedy source nanoparticles [2,3], as well as silica crystals and amorphous nanoparticles [3,4,32].
Got that? According to Bell, all that grinding and succussion generates nanoparticles, and these nanoparticles do things. All sorts of things. Magical things. Like homeopathy things. They can even emit electrical signals! Oh, wait. The paper Bell cites to justify that claim is the infamous paper by Nobel Laureate Luc Montagnier, who, unfortunately, appears to have fallen prey to the Nobel Disease and become a crank. Indeed, that particular paper was roundly criticized for its poor methodology and conclusions not supported by its data, and these days Montagnier is subjecting autistic children to long term antibiotic treatment and appearing at quack conferences like Autism One, along with women who think that giving autistic children bleach enemas is a good way to treat autism. In other words, as sad as it makes me to say it, Montagnier is no longer a good scientist, and I wouldn’t trust anything he publishes these days any more than I trust what Dana Ullman publishes—or, for that matter, Iris Bell.
Let’s take a look at the four parts of Bell’s model. Here’s the first part:
Homeopathic remedies are highly reactive source and/or remedy-modified silica (or polymer) nanoparticles, not bulk-form drugs [2,3];
This is utter nonsense, as I explained when I discussed one of the papers used to support this assertion. These “nanoparticles” are almost certainly nothing more than contaminants and show no real evidence of being “highly-reactive” or “remedy-modified.” More importantly, they show no evidence of actually doing anything therapeutic.
Next up:
Remedy nanoparticles stimulate a complex adaptive response in the organism that begins in the allostatic stress response network, with cascading indirect consequences over time across the entire self-organizing organism. The homeopathic simillimum (clinically optimal) remedy nanoparticles [16] serve as low level, but highly salient novel stressors, i.e., specific biological signals for the overall organism [9];
Boiled down to its essence, this says something along the lines of: Like, the human body is really complicated, you know? And these nanoparticles do something just as complicated, you know? It’s so complicated that we don’t know what it is and can’t prove that it happens. But it sure is fun to speculate!
Then we have:
The adaptive plasticity processes that underlie the direction and magnitude of remedy effects on living systems involve nonlinear physiological phenomena such as hormesis, cross-adaptation, time-dependent sensitization and cross-sensitization/oscillation. As a low intensity stressor, remedy nanoparticles stimulate changes in the opposite direction to those of the higher intensity stressors that fostered the original development of disease [16,97,98]. The disease-related maladaptations prime the system [10,39]. Then the correct remedy in low dose elicits reversal of direction of the maladapted responses.
Did I say that the human body was complicated? I’ll say it again. It’s really, really complicated, and these homeopathic nanoparticles do things even more complicated than what I said before. For example, they don’t even do normal dose-response curves; they’re more powerful at lower doses, just like Hahnemann said! And they oscillate. Or something. Disease maladaptations (nice word, eh?) get the system ready for these wondrous particles, which can then reverse the maladaptation. All of this is a bit odd, though, given that homeopathy is explicitly designed to treat symptoms, not the underlying cause. After all, the very principle of “like cures like” is based on symptoms, not biology.
None of which stops Bell from writing:
The adaptive changes that the remedy evokes ultimately strengthen systemic resilience. The successfully treated individual can resist and rebound from subsequent challenges from higher intensity homeostatic disruptors of the organism as a complex network, at global and local levels of organizational scale [22].
Damn, I wish I could write word salad this tasty. As I read this passage, I started to wonder whether I was the victim of a Sokal-style hoax here or whether Bell wrote her paper the way that David Bowie used to like to write songs: By cutting up newspaper and magazine articles and randomly splicing the words back together. In this case, it seems as though Bell cut up a bunch of nanoparticle papers and some homeopathy literature and then threw them together to produce much of this paper.
Here’s what I mean. This whole paper sounds very impressive, but when you analyze individual passages you quickly realize that it means nothing. It’s a whole lot of blatant speculation. Now, blatant speculation in science is not necessarily a bad thing, but only when it is at least somewhat plausible and, more importantly, when its limitations are clearly acknowledged. None of this applies here. Bell claims that homeopathic remedies are an example of hormesis, which is ridiculous. She goes on at length about the phenomenon of cross-adaptation, in which widely different stressors can affect the same intermediary pathway, blithely asserting that homeopathic remedies work through cross-sensitization without presenting any convincing evidence that this is so. She does the same thing for other phenomenon, in which homeopathic remedies apparently exhibit metaplasticity and time-dependent sensitization, which Bell uses as a rationale for why “pulsing” homeopathic remedies is a good idea, concluding that these remedies somehow “strengthen systemic resilience,” whatever that means. It sounds all too much like the generic quack claim of being able to “boost the immune system.”
Perhaps the most hilarious part of the entire article is Table 1: Parallels between homeopathic and modern scientific research literatures. Examples include comparisons of the “homeopathic literature” and real science, with the real science being tortured into agreeing with the homeopathic literature. For instance, one of items states that disease is the “dynamic mistunement” of the living system (i.e., life force). In the real scientific literature, according to Bell, disease is “the current manifestation of failure to adapt or compensate for allostatic overload from convergence of biological, chemical, physical, and psychological stressors on the nonlinear adaptive stress response network, which is embedded within the larger complex network of the overall organism.” I get it! they’re totally the same! Hahnemann apparently foresaw scientific developments over two hundred years into the future!
I’ll conclude with this comparison. From the homeopathic literature:
Higher potencies (more dilution and succussion steps) have longer lasting effects on living systems [243] (succussion involves intense mechanical shaking of the solution by pounding the glass container against a hard elastic surface).
Now from the real scientific literature:
Succussion, like modern microfluidization techniques [51], introduces cycles of fluid acceleration and turbulence with repeated changes in the direction of flow, producing the potential for particle collision and shear forces to break off smaller and smaller particles. These procedures, while different from each other and from sonication as a technique for agitating solutions and producing nanoparticles, share the ability to create nanobubbles and shear forces. Nanoparticle research suggests that there are nonlinear relationships between the number of microfluidization cycles or sonication time and variations in the sizes, morphologies, and physico-chemical properties of the “same” bulk-form material substance [52,53,244].
Again, can’t you see how they’re totally the same? No? Neither can I.
She currently is still the PI on a training grant held by the University of Arizona to teach woo to medical trainees.

The “Incoherent Mess” That Is Homeopathy: Old and New Insights
Harriet Hall on May 10, 2016
Link
Back in 1943 a Dutch physician, David Karel de Jongh, wrote a PhD dissertation on homeopathy. It was based on his experience working in a homeopathic hospital and on all the published information he could find, and was highly critical of homeopathy. It was an impressive opus, with over 200,000 words. It is way too long for the average reader to wade through; and since it is in Dutch, few of us could read it even if we wanted to. Jan Willem Nienhuys, secretary of the Dutch skeptics’ organization Skepsis, has done us a great favor by summarizing its contents and updating it with information about recent developments. He has kindly had his summary translated into English and published in full on the Skepsis website. He comments “Basically Dr. de Jongh’s conclusions were that homeopathy is an incoherent mess.”
We all should know by now how monumentally silly homeopathy is (“delusions about dilutions”). I had investigated the subject and knew enough about it to have written about it repeatedly, but there is much more that I didn’t know. Nienhuys’ article is full of surprising facts and fascinating details.
It seems Hahnemann didn’t originate the idea of “similia similibus” (like treats like) after all. He borrowed it from earlier authors. And when he said he got a fever after taking cinchona bark, he was using a contemporary concept of “fever” that might have referred to other things like the effects of strong coffee.
I didn’t realize how many variants of homeopathy there were early on, including isopathy, constitution theory, complex-homeopathy and so-called “biochemistry.” Nienhuys describes all of these and more. In a variant of isopathy, they used diluted organs to treat sick organs. They used morbillin to treat measles; morbillin was obtained from sugar globules that had been held by a measles patient. Hahnemann was strongly opposed to isopathy; he said that by diluting something you change its nature and therefore you must first do provings with healthy people to establish its symptoms.
In constitutional homeopathy, symptoms are disregarded and remedies are based on the patient’s constitution, which might be hydrogenoid, oxygenoid, or carbo-nitrogenoid. In cell-salt homeopathy, highly dilute solutions of a dozen important salts were prescribed to correct the imbalances of salts in cells that were the cause of disease. Complex homeopathy used combinations of remedies in direct violation of Hahnemann’s ideas. Drainage therapy claims that homeopathic remedies magically drain away the toxins that are the underlying cause of all disease.
Nienhuys explains how Hahnemann failed to understand the concepts of blinding and experimental controls, how he never explained his switch to high dilutions or why it was necessary to shake the remedies after each dilution, and how he explained away the failure of his treatments by inventing the three universal causes of disease: syphilis, gonorrhea, and psora. He describes the silliness of the Materia Medica and the Repertory. He provides some insights into how homeopaths were (and still are) able to fool themselves. De Jongh reported fantastic explanations of the mechanisms by which homeopathy is supposed to work; Nienhuys brings the list up to date with a discussion of Benveniste, the memory of water, and other modern fantasies. He also updates the research showing that homeopathy doesn’t work.
His conclusions
…homeopathic practice does not correspond with homeopathic theory… homeopaths make their treatment decisions in a completely arbitrary way… homeopathic physicians are primitive thinkers. Their writings abound with fallacies. They are strongly inclined to ascribe any improvement of their patients to homeopathy. Actually they think medicine is too difficult, so they stick to all kinds of ‘rules’.
Nienhuys’ article is a valuable addition to the literature on homeopathy. He deserves a hearty “dank je wel.”

Clinical trials of homeopathy versus “respect for science”
David Gorski on March 9, 2015
Link
A few months ago, Steve Novella and I published an article in Trends in Molecular Medicine entitled “Clinical trials of integrative medicine: testing whether magic works?” It was our first foray together into publishing commentary about science-based medicine versus evidence-based medicine, using a topic that we’ve both written extensively about over the years on this blog and our respective personal blogs. Specifically, we discussed whether it is worthwhile to do randomized clinical trials (RCTs) testing highly improbable treatments, such as reiki and homeopathy, both of which have no physical basis to believe that they do anything whatsoever. As I’ve said many times before, reiki is simply faith healing in which Eastern mysticism is substituted for Christian beliefs, and homeopathy, as we’ve discussed many times here on SBM, is vitalistic sympathetic magic with no evidence to support its two laws.
To our surprise, that article generated a fair amount of press (for example this), with accounts of it showing up in the media in various places and Steven and I being asked to do a fair number of interviews. Part of the reason, I suspect, is that the editor made the article available for free for a month after its initial publication. (Unfortunately it’s back behind the pay wall again.) Part of the reason is that, intuitively, it makes sense to people not to waste money testing what is, at its core, magic. When I followed up that publication with an article criticizing “integrative oncology” in Nature Reviews Cancer entitled “Integrative oncology: Really the best of both worlds?“, the target was well and truly on my back. Indeed, let’s just say that the Society for Integrative Oncology and the Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine (CAHCIM) are quite unhappy with me. When both their letters to the editor are published (right now, only one is), I might even blog about them.
In the meantime, I want to deal with criticism published in an unexpected place, albeit not by unexpected critics. The reason is that this criticism relies on a common straw man caricature of what we are saying when we advocate science-based medicine (SBM) that considers prior plausibility in determining what modalities to test in clinical trials and understands Bayesian thinking in which prior plausibility affects posterior plausibility that a “significant” result is not a false positive in contrast to the current evidence-based medicine (EBM) paradigm, which relegates basic science knowledge, even well-established principles of science that show that something like, say, homeopathy or reiki is impossible under the current understanding of physics, chemistry and biology, to the lowest rung on the EBM pyramid. It’s also a criticism that comes up frequently enough that, even though it’s been addressed before in various ways by various SBM bloggers, it’s worth revisiting from time to time. In this case, that’s particularly so because one of the two critics taking Steve and me to task is currently embroiled in a controversy about testing homeopathy for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) at the University of Toronto (more details on that later). Let’s just say, the criticism of Steve and me gives me an “in” to address a story that I thought had passed me by, and I intend to take it.
Steve and I are criticized as unscientific
I mentioned that I was surprised about where this criticism of Steve and me was published; the reason for my surprise is that it was published in Focus on Alternative and Complementary Therapies (FACT), a journal edited by Edzard Ernst. This is usually a journal that is—shall we say?—not particularly hospitable to arguments like this. Not this time. Witness the article by Sunita Vohra and Heather Boon entitled “Advancing knowledge requires both clinical and basic research“. The criticism begins thusly:
Recently, Gorki [sic] and Novella [1] recommended an approach that would severely curtail one’s ability to explore novel therapies and gain new understanding about human biology. They propose that ‘science-based medicine’ replace the modern standard of ‘evidence-based medicine’ and be used to limit clinical investigation to only those therapies that have positive basic science studies.[1] This approach is a cause for concern as it is predicated on an assumption that we already understand how the world and, in particular, the human body, works. This seems to fly in the face of the basic scientific method, which starts with an intriguing observation and encourages one to ask ‘why did that happen?’ The point of science is to explore things that challenge our understanding and current paradigms of how things work. Theories need to be revised in light of available data, rather than be used to curtail the kinds of questions one can ask.
I had wondered why this article had not popped up on my Google Alerts feed before given that, in order to monitor what people are saying about me and where I’m being mentioned, I maintain such a Google Alert on my name and that the article was first published online a month and a half ago. You’ve probably heard the famous adage, “I don’t care what the newspapers say about me as long as they spell my name right.” Well, Boon and Vohra didn’t even do me the courtesy of spelling my name right, which, fallible human that I am, I must admit annoys me. What annoys me a lot more, however, is the misstatement of our position. It is, I note, a very common straw man of our position, which Vohra and Boon double down on immediately after that passage:
The arguments put forth by Gorki [sic] and Novella[1] are based on the premise that our current understanding of basic human biology is sufficient to predict which therapies will work in humans. Interestingly, the hypothetical scenario used by these authors to help the reader understand the magnitude of the problem is the same strategy used by those trying to explain how little basic science research informs clinical therapies.[2] Unfortunately, it has become well known that basic science may or may not inform how therapies work in patients, more often ‘may not’.[3, 4] This is the reason given by pharmaceutical companies to justify why prescription medicines are so expensive.[5, 6] Since so many biologically plausible compounds ultimately fail to turn into viable therapies, the very few drugs that make it to market need to be priced in such a way as to compensate for all those that failed despite promising (and biologically plausible) laboratory findings.
Have Steve and I heard this argument before many times? Why yes. Yes we have. It’s a straw man so massive that, were it to be set on fire, it would be easily visible from the International Space Station. Yet proponents of unscientific medicine can’t seem to resist trotting it out, tarting it up, and sending it out to misrepresent our position. No one, least of all Steve and I, argues that we understand enough about basic human biology to say that knowledge is sufficient to predict what therapies will work in humans. What we did argue is that there is more than sufficient evidence from basic science, including physics, chemistry, and, yes, physiology to know that modalities like homeopathy and reiki can’t work. Let me just quote from our article for your edification. Because it’s behind a paywall, I will quote fairly liberally:
It should also be noted that ‘biologically plausible’ does not mean ‘knowing the exact mechanism’. What it does mean is that the mechanism should not be so scientifically implausible as to be reasonably considered impossible. In other words, the mechanism should not violate laws and theories in science that rest on far sturdier and longer established foundations than imperfect, bias-prone clinical trials. For example, homeopathy violates multiple laws of physics with its claims that dilution can make a homeopathic remedy stronger and that water can retain the ‘memory’ of substances with which it has been in contact before [9]. Thus, treatments like homeopathy should be dismissed as ineffective on basic scientific grounds alone. That is why we propose the term science-based medicine (SBM) as opposed to evidence-based medicine (EBM). SBM restores basic science considerations to EBM and is what EBM should be.
Later in the article, Steve and I argue:
Another pernicious effect of performing RCTs on CAM and IM modalities is that it leads to clinical trials of highly implausible treatments that may have a significant potential to cause active harm, as opposed to harm from substituting ineffective for effective treatment. One example is the Trial To Assess Chelation Therapy (TACT), in which chelation therapy was tested as a treatment in patients with heart disease: a US$30 million multicenter clinical trial initially funded by the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) with virtually no preclinical scientific basis, study sites at ‘alternative’ clinics where reliability was seriously questioned, and the potential for complications due to chelation of critical minerals [10]. A decade and tens of millions of dollars later, after failure to reach accrual goals, TACT results were reported [11,12] and were negative except for one subgroup (diabetics), for which there was ample reason to question the validity of the results [13]. Another example is the trial to test an ‘alternative’ treatment regimen for pancreatic cancer that involves extreme dietary modifications, juices, large quantities of supplements, and coffee enemas. After several years, abandonment of the RCT format for an unblinded ‘patient’s choice’ design, and considerable controversy over delays in publication, the results, when finally reported [14], were disturbing. One year survival of subjects undergoing this protocol was nearly fourfold worse than subjects receiving standard-of-care chemotherapy and worse than expected based on historical controls, all associated with poorer quality of life.
So it is very clear that we were not generalizing our arguments to claim that we know enough about human physiology to know in advance which treatments will work. That is a misstatement of our position that completely misses the point. Our argument says nothing about which treatments will work; it emphasizes predicting which treatments will not work, treatments for which doing clinical trials is a pointless waste of money that potentially endangers human subjects and whose results never convince proponents of alternative medicine to abandon treatments that don’t work. Our argument is that there are some modalities that are so inherently ridiculous, so completely without even a modicum of support, from a scientific standpoint that we already have enough data and knowledge to know that they can’t work (e.g., homeopathy and reiki, not to mention pretty much all “energy medicine”). Moreover, in specific cases that we enumerated testing such modalities can be viewed as unethical, as in the TACT (which we’ve discussed here at SBM many times before), trials of homeopathy for diarrheal diseases in Third World countries (also discussed here multiple times before); and testing a treatment like the Gonzalez protocol for pancreatic cancer (yes, also discussed multiple times here before).
The second part of our argument is that EBM was “blindsided” by CAM and as a result EBM has a “scientific blind spot” because an unspoken assumption behind the EBM evidence pyramid is that treatments do not make it to the stage of RCTs without having demonstrated compelling preclinical evidence of efficacy. Yes, we acknowledge that such evidence isn’t enough to predict which treatments will work, but, again, we never argued that it was. What we argue is that we already know enough about pseudoscientific modalities like homeopathy to know they can’t work. As Kimball Atwood put it, basic science or preliminary clinical studies provide evidence sufficient to refute some health claims (e.g., homeopathy and Laetrile), particularly those emanating from the social movement known by the euphemism “CAM.” Further, Atwood argued that EBM’s founders understood the correct role of the rigorous randomized controlled clinical trial: to be the final arbiter of any claim that had already demonstrated promise by all other criteria, including ‘basic science, animal studies, legitimate case series, small controlled trials, “expert opinion,” whatever (but not inexpert opinion).’ As he argued, EBM’s founders knew that such pieces of evidence, promising though they may be, are insufficient because they “routinely lead to false positive conclusions about efficacy.”
I often add to Dr. Atwood’s discussion an additional point emphasizing that determining the exact level of prior plausibility necessary to justify a RCT is a legitimate question. A 50% chance of a positive result? 10%? 1%? Less, even? Very likely the prior plausibility of all “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) treatments that are not supplements or herbal medicines falls into that very low range. The answer to that question will actually vary by disease and treatment, not to mention the expense of doing the trial. Thus, it comes down to more or less a value judgment in which preclinical estimates of prior probability influence the decision whether or not to proceed with a clinical trial, but factors of ethics, resources, and urgency of the question, play prominent roles in the decision as well. What I would hope that we all can agree on is that we shouldn’t be subjecting human subjects to tests of therapies whose prior plausibility is so low as to be indistinguishable from zero. Certainly, homeopathy, healing touch, and reiki, among others, fit this criterion quite well. Again, no one is arguing that basic science considerations can predict which therapies will work, although we do argue that in some cases basic science considerations can predict accurately which therapies will not work. I only repeat this again because it’s a message that critics like Vohra and Boon seem willfully unable to grasp and particularly prone to make a flaming straw man out of.
Now, remember the point we at SBM have been making about CAM advocates opting for less rigorous trials when more rigorous ones don’t give them the answers they want? Vohra and Boon demonstrate this very well:
Best available data suggest the majority of patients use complementary therapies.[11-13] Evidence about which therapies may be helpful, and which may be harmful, in whom, and why, is urgently needed to guide practice and policy. Randomised controlled trials have become the gold standard for evaluating treatment effectiveness, but they are expensive and resource-intensive. Rather than arguing that gathering clinical evidence about popular therapies is a folly, we suggest consideration of other kinds of innovative trial design, such as N-of-1 trials.[14] These trials can not only inform the care of a single patient in a cost-effective evidence-based manner, they may be aggregated to inform the care of a population.[15] Comparative effectiveness trials [16] or patient-centred effectiveness research are approaches that help to determine which interventions work best for specific patients in specific circumstances. A key component of this kind of research is the concept of pragmatic clinical trials that focus on assessing effectiveness (use of therapies in real-world settings) as opposed to efficacy[17] – the goal of the traditional RCT. There are an increasing number of rigorous study designs that should be used more to generate clinically useful knowledge and to highlight where it would be most useful to invest in additional mechanistic studies.
Not how Bohra and Boon start out with the CAM advocate’s favorite logical fallacy, argumentum ad populum (appeal to popularity) and then proceed to their second massive flaming straw man, the claim that we in any way said that “gathering clinical evidence about popular therapies is a folly.” (I mean, seriously, did these two even actually read our article?) One more time: No one, least of all Steve and I, has said that “gathering clinical evidence about popular therapies is a folly.” What we have said is that doing RCTs on magic (like homeopathy, reiki and “energy medicine,” and treatments like chelation therapy for cardiovascular disease or the Gonzalez protocol for pancreatic cancer) is a waste of resources that can endanger patients and that negative results of these RCTs fail to persuade CAM practitioners to abandon pseudoscientific treatments. As for “pragmatic” trials, these are trials that are done to determine how effective modalities that have already been demonstrated to be efficacious in RCTs are in the “real world.” They are not intended for treatments whose efficacy has not yet determined. Using pragmatic trials as though they are efficacy trials is a strategy bound to result in false positives, because pragmatic trials usually have no placebo control group and sometimes no control group at all. It’s with good reason that Steve has referred to the use of pragmatic trials in CAM as “bait and switch” and Harriet Hall as referred to them as “Cinderella medicine.” (This is a known problem with pragmatic trials that isn’t limited to CAM, too.) No wonder Andrew Weil likes pragmatic studies so much!
Finally, no one here is arguing against patient-centered effectiveness research or comparative effectiveness research. However, once again, before we can compare the effectiveness of different treatments, we have to know that each of the treatment modalities being compared is actually efficacious; i.e., that there is actual effectiveness in each of the modalities to be compared and provide meaningful results. As for the “N-of-1” trial, homeopaths tend to like to propose such trials because to them “N-of-1” trials resemble homeopathic provings. Be that as it may, conducting N-of-1 trials is anything but trivial. Moreover, as the U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality puts it:
In parallel group RCTs, blinding of patients, clinicians, and outcomes assessors (“triple blinding”) is considered good research practice. These trials aim to generate generalizable knowledge about the effects of treatment in a population. In drug and device trials, the consensus is that it is critical to separate the biological activity of the treatment from nonspecific (placebo) effects. (For a broader view, see Benedetti et al.26) In n-of-1 trials, the primary aim is usually different. Patients and clinicians participating in n-of-1 trials are likely interested in the net benefits of treatment overall, including both specific and nonspecific effects. Therefore blinding may be less critical in this context. Nevertheless, expert opinion tends to favor blinding in n-of-1 trials whenever feasible.
See why CAM advocates love N-of-1 trials? After all, nonspecific effects are pretty much the main reason why patients and clinicians think that, for example, acupuncture works for anything.
Vohra and Boon then conclude:
We should encourage and celebrate basic science and discovery research as a way to learn about our universe, including the human body. We urge researchers to update their thinking: translational research should not be limited to one direction – from basic science to bedside applications. Complementary therapies are used by the majority of the population. There is a need to explore therapies that appear to offer clinically relevant benefit or harm by investigating their mechanism of action through basic research (i.e. bedside to bench). Basic science is clearly needed, but it should never be a reason to deny the opportunity to evaluate clinical therapies to assess their safety and effectiveness. Both types of research are informative, both advance the human condition, and both have their weaknesses. Together they can be immensely powerful.
This paragraph is just plain ridiculous. First of all, we never said that translational research should be one direction; so there’s the third major flaming straw man. In fact, we explicitly noted that it goes both ways in our paper. Second, complementary therapies are only used by the “majority of the population” if you include exercise, spirituality, vitamins, and diet (among other things) as being “complementary.” It’s a fallacy that we at SBM have discussed many times before, wherein modalities like diet and exercise are the “Trojan horse” that lets the pseudoscience past the walls of academia. I would, however, argue that Vohra and Boon are just plain wrong to argue that basic science “should never be a reason to deny the opportunity to evaluate clinical therapies to assess their safety and effectiveness.” If they don’t believe me, then I would invite them to participate in a double blind, randomized controlled trial of parachute usage to decrease the morbidity and mortality due to jumping out of airplanes. After all, if basic science should never be used as a reason to deny the opportunity to evaluate clinical therapies, then the basic science (physics) that says that a human body falling hundreds or thousands of feet at terminal velocity will go splat when it hits the unyielding earth and that this splatting will result in death or extreme injury—the basic science of biology, people!—shouldn’t be a consideration in assessing the effectiveness of parachute usage in preventing death from falls from high places.
A less extreme example would be testing intercessory prayer for cardiac conditions. Oh, wait. That’s been done. Never mind. That’s the problem with testing highly implausible claims with no physical basis in reality.
Like homeopathy for anything.
Homeopathy for ADHD?
Of course, Steve and I have to wonder why Vohra and Boon were so unhappy with our little editorial, which was only around 1,500 words. (Yes, Steve had a salutary effect on my brevity.) It turns out that we’ve met both Heather Boon and Sunita Vohra before. For example, Jann Bellamy and a certain “friend” of the blog have both taken her to task for advocating the use of pseudoscientific CAM treatments in children. It turns out that Vohra is Centennial Professor in Department of Pediatrics, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry at the University of Alberta who holds a joint appointment in the School of Public Health. She appears to have started out evidence- and science-based but then, as too often happens, drifted into CAM, becoming:
…founding director of Canada’s first academic pediatric integrative medicine program; founding director of first pediatric integrative medicine fellowship program in North America; founding director of the world’s largest pediatric Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) network (www.pedcam.ca); she advises Health Canada (Pediatric Expert Advisory Committee); led the University of Alberta’s membership in Consortium of Academic Health Centers for Integrative Medicine; is past Chair of the American Academy of Pediatrics Section on Integrative Medicine (2012-2014). Dr. Vohra was recognized for excellence in CAM research (Dr. Rogers Prize $250,000) and inducted as fellow of Canadian Academy of Health Sciences, one of the highest honours for any member of the Canadian health sciences community.
I suppose Steve and I should be honored to have attracted the attention of such a heavy hitter in the world of CAM. Based on her stature in CAM, you’d think her arguments would be better, but, as I demonstrated above, you’d be wrong.
I’m not so much interested in Dr. Vohra, though. Rather, I’m more interested in Heather Boon, because she’s been in the news in Canada lately regarding homeopathy. Also, Vohra and Boon have collaborated on clinical trials of homeopathy in children before. No wonder our little “Science and Society” editorial hit a nerve!
In any case, Heather Boon is a pharmacist who is Professor and the Dean for the Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Toronto. As our own Scott Gavura discussed nearly two weeks ago, she is also the principal investigator of a study of homeopathy that’s drawn criticism from scientists all over the world:
A University of Toronto study on homeopathic treatment for children with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder is being heavily criticized by scientists who claim it legitimizes a pseudoscience.
Two Nobel laureates are among 90 scientists from universities around the world who have signed an open letter calling the clinical trial into question.
“We are curious about why, given the need to investigate natural therapies that may actually have a potential for benefit, and saddled with a scarcity in funding, a Department of Pharmacy is interested in investigating a subject that has been … found wanting both in evidence and plausibility,” reads the letter addressed to Heather Boon, dean of the U of T’s Faculty of Pharmacy, who is leading the study.
Indeed.
You would think that a pharmacist would know why homeopathy is pseudoscience, but apparently Dr. Boon does not. (If she did, she wouldn’t have written the criticism of the article by Dr. Novella and myself that she did; on the other hand, she has been critical of homeopathy in the past, which makes her criticism of our article and her spearheading this trial particularly odd) In particular, Joe Schwarcz, a chemist at McGill University and friend of the blog, has been particularly scathing in his criticism, noting that:
The study is actually to be carried out at the Riverdale Homeopathic Clinic, a private institution that also offers ear candling, cranial sacral therapy and “nosodes,” which are homeopathic versions of vaccines. No public funding is involved; support comes from a foundation dedicated to alternative medicine.
Me being me and all that and in particular me being about the details of the clinical trial, I looked up Boon’s trial on ClinicalTrials.gov (identifier NCT02086864). It’s a clinical trial of homeopathy in ADHD, a developmental disorder characterized by developmentally inappropriate levels of inattention and/or hyperactive-impulsive behavior with significant impairment in at least two settings. Boon then argues that homeopathy “has been shown to be a promising intervention for ADHD” as justification of this trial, whose three aims are:
     1.  To determine if there are any specific effects of homeopathic medicines in the treatment of ADHD
     2.  To determine if there any specific effects the homeopathic consultation alone in the treatment of ADHD
     3.  To determine if there is an overall effect of homeopathic treatment (homeopathic medicines plus consultation) in the treatment of ADHD.
There are three groups:
    • Arm 1 (Verum group): a treatment arm where the participant will receive homeopathic consultation plus a homeopathic remedy
    • Arm 2 (Placebo group): a treatment arm where the participant will receive homeopathic consultation plus a placebo remedy
    • Arm 3 (No treatment/Usual care group): a wait list arm where the participant will not receive homeopathic treatment as part of the study.
The pilot trial to which the study justification refers is this pilot trial published last year (NCT01141634), which was an open label trial without a control group. Not surprisingly given that it was an open-label uncontrolled pilot study, this study was reported as positive, as judged by changes between the pre- and post-study Conners Global Index – Parent (CGI-P) T-score, a measure of ADHD severity.
In fact, I bet I can predict how Boon’s current study will most likely turn out. There will be no specific effect due to any homeopathic treatment, given that anything diluted more than about 11C or 12C has been diluted to the point where no drug is left and will therefore be water. Indeed, that is why homeopathy is pseudoscience. In addition, there might be an improvement based on the “personalized homeopathic consultation.” In other words, results observed in subjects in Arms 1 and 2 will likely be indistinguishable statistically from each other, and results in those arms will likely be better than the results in Arm 3. As I so frequently say in studies like this, there’s no need for the pseudoscience; the same sort of study could be done using standard treatment to see if longer, more personalized consultations produces a better result, no magic needed. In brief, this entire study is a pseudoscientific waste of time.
So how did Boon respond? She wrote a special article that was published in The Montreal Gazette in response to Prof. Schwarcz’s column, entitled “Why would anyone think a rigorous clinical trial is a bad idea?” It reads like a rehash of the article published in FACT, just directed at a lay audience. The question itself that is the title, reiterated near the beginning of the article, shows just how little Boon understands.
She is also, as they say, talking out of both sides of her mouth. She starts out asserting:
Our study — one of the most rigorous studies of homoeopathy to date — is being conducted because patients are using homoeopathy to treat ADHD. Previous studies on this topic have produced varying results and have been criticized for methodological flaws.
We are studying this topic for the same reason most scientists conduct studies: to discover the truth, or at least to get closer to it. As a scientist, I am committed to conducting high-quality studies that help patients and clinicians make evidence-informed choices about a wide range of popular products and therapies, and this study is no different.
She even boasts that her study had received approval from Health Canada and two Research Ethics Review Boards while expressing puzzlement how a “well-designed clinical trial legitimizes anything, as we don’t know what the study will find.” Again, Boon completely misses the point, just as she did in her criticism of our article. Her clinical trial is studying pixie dust. It’s tooth fairy science, as it is studying the efficacy of a treatment whose very premises are based on vitalistic magic. There is no scientific reason to think that homeopathy will benefit ADHD. It is water.
She then justifies her choice:
Biological plausibility is one way to choose which interventions to study, and is the most common way we bring new pharmaceutical drugs to market. Given the number of promising drug candidates that never make it to market, it is clear that biological plausibility does not always translate into efficacy or effectiveness in patients. Another way to identify interventions to study is to start with an observation — often claims from patients that a product, treatment or therapy helps them — and then set out to investigate this observation. In either approach, determining whether something ultimately “works” or not is achieved through investigation in rigorously designed clinical trials.
Again, no one is arguing that you always have to start with preclinical observations. In fact, the paradigm is often “bench to bedside to bench” or “bedside to bench to bedside.” As Steve and I pointed out in our article, clinical observations and lab observations frequently cross-pollinate. The idea is that if there is a clinical observation of an effect, then the first course is to go to the lab and try to figure out why that might be. Of course, for such an approach to work, regardless of what comes first, there has to be a convincing clinical observation, and certainly Boon and Vohra’s pilot study of homeopathy for ADHD does not qualify, nor do any studies of homeopathy, as even the “positive” ones tend to be just barely “statistically significant,” poorly designed, or fraught with potential bias. In other words, when it comes to homeopathy there’s no “there” there. For a clinical observation to have even a hope of trumping the nearly two centuries’ worth of basic science that tells us homeopathy is impossible would require unequivocal, undeniable observations on multiple fronts.
Oddly enough, Boon then backtracks a little, as if to say, “Oops! We’re not trying to determine if homeopathy works after all!” See what I mean:
Our pilot study was designed to tell us about patients’ experiences using homeopathic therapies to treat ADHD, not to assess the efficacy of those treatments. Many patients in this study felt better after visiting a homeopath. Of course, there are many possible explanations for this, which is why we have embarked on another, more comprehensive study to investigate two possible explanations. Employing a randomized, placebo-controlled three-arm study, we will be able to identify whether or not patients in the trial have a decrease in symptoms after homeopathic treatment. If patients’ symptoms decrease, we will be able to explore whether this effect appears to be related to the consultation with the homeopath or to the homeopathic medicine or a combination of both.
Except that, as I mentioned above, you don’t need to have a pseudoscientific remedy like homeopathy to do a study like this. Just do it with standard care for ADHD. It’s unethical to use a pseudoscientific and ineffective treatment like homeopathy in a clinical trial, as the most recent iteration of the Declaration of Helsinki points out, stating that “medical research involving human subjects must conform to generally accepted scientific principles, be based on a thorough knowledge of the scientific literature, other relevant sources of information, and adequate laboratory and, as appropriate, animal experimentation.” Unfortunately, ethics boards never seem to understand that homeopathy conforms to none of these things.
Boon concludes with a particularly nauseatingly sanctimonious, self-righteous rhetorical question:
We are putting homeopathy to the test and trusting in the scientific method to help us in our search for the truth.
After all, isn’t that the purpose of research?
My retort: We have already trusted in the scientific method that tells us that, for homeopathy to work, several laws of physics would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong. That scientific method tells us that there’s no point in subjecting children with ADHD to homeopathy. As scientists, we always acknowledge that there is a tiny chance those mountains of research in physics, chemistry, and biology that tell us homeopathy is impossible could be mistaken. However, for homeopathy to be shown to have plausibility distinct from zero would require basic science in favor of the principles of homeopathy on the order of quality and quantity of research since the time of Amedeo Avogadro, whose number demonstrated that homeopathy is bunk. That research doesn’t exist. Respecting science doesn’t mean subjecting human subjects in clinical trials to quackery like homeopathy in the futile hope that it will work when the research to demonstrate that homeopathy is pseudoscience has existed for over 200 years and been accepted for at least 150 years.
In reality, it is not Boon who respects science. By embracing homeopathy as a legitimate research topic, she has embraced pseudoscience. It is Joe Schwarcz and the scientists and physicians who signed his letter who do.
ADDENDUM: Steve Novella has also posted a rebuttal to Vohra and Boon entitled “Basic Science Should Inform Clinical Science.”

Delusion Update
A look at some of the years homeopathy papers on PubMed.
Mark Crislip on June 16, 2026
Link

In the race to the bottom, there is no SCAM (supplements, complementary and alternative medicine) further from reality than homeopathy. Not only are the underlying Laws goofy after minimal reflection, homeopathy is simply water. Or a drop of water placed on a sugar pill. I do not see the point in using phrases like ‘highly unlikely’ and ‘highly improbable’ to describe homeopathy any more than I would to describe the tooth fairy. Homeopathy is flat out unhinged.
Given its total separation from reality, I have long wondered why practicing homeopathy is not considered a delusional disorder. Per the DSM V delusional disorder is
characterized by persistent delusions—strong beliefs in things that are not based in reality…
These delusions, which are fixed false beliefs, stand out because they persist despite clear evidence to the contrary. Unlike other psychotic disorders, individuals with Delusional Disorder do not typically exhibit other prominent psychotic symptoms, such as disorganized thinking, hallucinations, or severely impaired functioning. …
Grandiose: Belief in having exceptional abilities, wealth, or fame…
People with Delusional Disorder often function relatively well in daily life outside of their delusional beliefs.
If the foo shits, although I expect someone will set me straight in the comments as to why this is not the case. As long as it is not a homeopath.
It raises the question if the answer to combating SCAMs would lie in treating the practitioners with
Antipsychotic drugs, antidepressants and mood-stabilising medications are frequently used to treat this mental illness and there is growing interest in psychological therapies such as psychotherapy and cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) as a means of treatment.
Probably not.
Despite the above, homeopathy continues to be inflicted on patients by homeopaths and naturopaths in lieu of useful therapy. Much to my ongoing wonder, research on the fiction continues with around 200 papers indexed on the PubMeds in the last year. Like my recent journey down the rat hole that is chiropractic, let’s see what those delusional homeopaths have been up to in the last year or so. Of course I am not going to discuss all 200 plus papers, just those of interest to me. You know, the crazy stuff.
And right of the chute, first reference, first paragraph, is gibberish in Homeopathy at a Turning Point
In the Hippocratic conception, medicine is a synthesis of technique, philosophy and humanism, but in essence it is nothing more than the expression of the living being to counter predestination. Its foundation is the dose–response relationship that a living organism expresses when perturbed by an external agent. In practice, however, this interpretation is defined by the knowledge, thought, economic means, politics and religious sentiment of the community to which the organism belongs.
The author is out of Italy and perhaps this is the best translation ChatGPT could do, although the paper does not get much more coherent. For example, what to make of
These findings lead me to define a homeopathic remedy as a “clathrate of clathrates of gas molecules”, present as nanobubbles.
I guess Otis Eugene “Gene” Ray was reincarnated as a homeopath. Anyway, if you read through the paper, the author bemoans the decline of homeopathy despite the fact he considers that the foundations of homeopathy to have a well-defined coherent scientific basis and
In summary, homeopathy is at a turning point, having failed to communicate a message that justifies its existence.
Good luck with that.
Not everyone agrees that homeopathy is a “clathrate of clathrates of gas molecules”, present as nanobubbles and there have been numerous attempts to justify the delusion by a variety of mechanisms by which water could have a therapeutic effect. Some are summarized in Mapping the Theories and Models on the Mode of Action of Homeopathy: A Scoping Review and found 72 theoretical approaches to justify homeopathy but reduced them to 14 largely nonoverlapping frameworks. Those frameworks are water structures, general physics, nanostructures, mathematical models, chemistry, quantum physics, biochemistry, weak quantum theory, hormesis, quantum analogie, biophotons, complex systems, electrodynamics, and humanities.
A tale told by a homeopath, all sound and fury signifying nothing.
But I wondered, what do biophotons have to do with homeopathy? My first hit:
The author develops the idea of exogenous homeopathy through biophotonic resonance. He describes a synthesis of cutting-edge ideas, including healing as a holographic process, that uses biological lasers powered by the piezo electric effect in liquid crystals. Such a system is so exquisitely sensitive, it can respond to the subtle effects of archetypal symbols, prayer /intention, homeopathy, sounds, odors, colors etc. The author explores the holographic universe, energy micro-traps, the light matrix and more, with plentiful photographic illustrations.
What the? I really should not have bothered. So much word salad jargon.
But the effects of homeopathy were not due to placebo:
Also of note is that the placebo argument, despite being often used to criticize homeopathy, did not appear in our findings as a well-articulated theory.
Not a well-articulated theory? Reading the paper, it seems the researchers quoted in the review neither understood nor applied the placebo as an explanation. They apparently ignored placebo effects. Explains a lot, really.
The authors focused on the two more delusional aspects of homeopathy, as if delusions can be ranked, the potentiation procedure and the principle of similars.
The most controversial topic in homeopathy is the use of often highly diluted potentized (serially diluted and shaken or “succussed”) preparations, especially when the degree of dilution exceeds the inverse of Avogadro’s number. However, at the very core of homeopathy is the Principle of Similars, which is used to determine the remedy to be applied for a specific patient. This principle states that a homeopathic remedy is to be chosen based on the best possible match of a given patient’s symptoms with those induced in healthy volunteers by a particular homeopathic preparation (similia similibus curentur, also referred to as the Principle of Similars, “let like be cured by like”).
Not addressed is the fact that homeopathy is just water and does nothing.
Nanoparticles are popular as an explanation, and I use the word explanation, like Humpty, to mean nanoparticles explain nothing. But they try, oh do they try:
Scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, energy dispersive spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, nanoparticle tracking analysis, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry, inductively coupled plasma atomic emission spectroscopy, dynamic light scattering, zeta potential, ultraviolet-visible spectroscopy, and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy are techniques that have been employed to date to explore HMs for NPs.
I thought the zeta potential was a teleportation ray developed on the planet Rann to send Adam Strange to earth. My bad. It is a real phenomenon misused by homeopaths and others to the point it could be teleportation device.
When you read these ‘explanatory’ papers, they are usually a combination of gibberish and misunderstanding of the real underlying science. Are they willfully misrepresenting the science or are they not smart enought to understant it? Not that the two are mutually exclusive.
But, no surprise, these nanoparticle studies are questionable.
Though a few studies were of good methodological quality, many presented poor design in the form of lack of control groups, deployment of a single microscopic technique alone for characterization, and sometimes insufficient limit of detection of the instruments involved.
But I would not expect the delusional to do quality studies, which would counter their delusion.
Can homeopathy cure all diseases? Subgroups of homeopathy users based on beliefs about whether and how homeopathy should be used to treat serious conditions
Well, no. And it should read can homeopathy cure any disease, but it is an interesting paper on who believes in homeopathy, and they found 4 subgroups, What was not surprising was
The subgroups that supported or were open toward the standalone use of homeopathy in serious conditions perceived science to be the most limited, corrupt, onerous, and heretical. They also cared the least about scientific evidence regarding homeopathy and indicated to believe in its effectiveness even if it is not yet scientifically proven.
The unanswered question is why and what to do about it. Probably nothing. I suspect it is the human condition for some.
Why does homeopathy fail to show efficacy in clinical trials? Not because homeopathy doesn’t work, but that
In homeopathy, however, where treatment is individualised, past and present context-sensitive, and closely related to the therapeutic encounter, RCTs cannot readily capture the core principles of practice.
or so says in Improving the Relevance of Research in Homeopathy. It suggests other, less rigorous, more pragmatic, evaluations of the delusion, since
While it’s important for us to understand how homeopathy works, it’s equally important to demonstrate that homeopathy does work
Homeopathy is the Invisible Boy from Mystery Men, who has
the power of invisibility, but it only works as long as no one (including himself) is looking at him.
Homeopathy only works as long as no one (including the practitioner), is carefully looking at it.
When I think of antidotes, I think of a chemical that reverses a poison or overdose. Homeopaths use the term differently, as reviewed in Antidotes in Homeopathy: Classical Doctrine, Clinical Relevance and Scientific Re-interpretation. In homeopathy it is used as an excuse for failure. Besides the fact they are only giving useless water. Hahneman, the first to pull homeopathy out of his, er I mean, thin air, and used antidotes an excuse when
remedies fail to act as expect or appear to be interrupted by external or internal factors…it is a dynamic disturbance of the organism’s global response to stimulation.
Nope. You didn’t give the incorrect remedy, it was the antidote that caused the failure. Must be nice to have a ready made excuse for failure.
How then do you know that the homeopathic remedy is the cause of the patient’s improvement. They use the Modified Naranjo Criteria for Homeopathy
which, as you can see, is useless for determining if the response is due to placebo, regression to the mean or the delusional water. Which is why the Modified Naranjo Criteria for Homeopathy is widely used. It appears made to prove causality, which is what a homeopath would want. It is for good reason they avoid more rigorous criteria, like Bradford Hills. Plausibility and coherence would sink that ship immediately. Homeopaths want their tools at least 12C, where not even a molecule of rigor remains.
Because if you have a rigorous study, like Homeopathy for Chronic Non-specific Low Back Pain: Randomised, Double-Blind, Crossover, Placebo-Controlled Clinical Trial Investigating the Efficacy of rigorhe Biotherapic Lumbar Vertebra (BIOVERT Trial), you find
No specific effect of the Lumbar Vertebra LM2 biotherapic was demonstrated. Improvements are likely due to non-specific effects such as the therapeutic environment, patient expectations and placebo response.
Although I could not find what the standardized homeopathic biotherapic (Lumbar Vertebra, LM2 potency) was. I was curious what was used applying the so-called Law of Similars. How does one use, say, chopping wood (gives me low back pain) as a homeopathic remedy. Not out of the question for a delusion that can prescribe moonlight. And homeopaths want to be taken seriously.
Sometimes you come across a sentence that sums it up. In Prognostic Factor Research: The Core of Homeopathy’s Scientific Identity they discussed the results of 161 cases of COVID treated with homeopathy and noted
In scientific terms, this research was far from perfect and proved nothing…
Sums up the whole homeopathic research field.
I do not think homeopaths are intentionally funny, but you have to wonder with articles like
Cystic swelling and inflammation of MCL of knee joint managed with homeopathy; a case study with literature review and diagnostic pitfalls
Following a thorough case evaluation, the patient was prescribed Ruta graveolens 200CH, followed by Thuja occidentalis 200CH. The anti-inflammatory, anti-tumor, and anti-cancer properties of both these medicines have been thoroughly demonstrated via many scientific experiments.
One in vitro paper each, both evaluating actual chemicals, would be two, so technically many. And where is the like cures like in the treatment? Also, I find
Ruta is also one of our best remedies for prolapsus of the rectum.
Normal people get prolapse if they take Ruta? Such flexibility in treatments.
We believe the positive effect is due to their alkaloids, but we have not questioned how they maintain their qualities at such high dilutions.
Of course they didn’t as at 200C
At the declared homeopathic dose of 200C, the total mass of pills that would have to be consumed to encounter a single molecule of the original substance would be billions of times greater than the mass of the Earth.
Why challenge your delusions with a bit of chemistry?
From a SBM perspective, the vaunted individual individualized treatment, often found in studies of what are usually self-limited diseases, makes purported causality of homeopathy even more problematic. If each patient gets a different treatment, from a reality-based perspective, you can make no conclusions. From a delusional perspective, it is the strength of homeopathy. Same issue with acupuncture, btw. It renders interpretation of studies like A Randomized, Double-Blinded, Placebo-Controlled Trial of Homeopathy in Acute Viral Tonsillitis in Children and Effectiveness of Homoeopathic (sic)Treatments for Sleep Disorders in Children and Adolescents A Systematic Review According to the Principles of Evidence-Based Medicine even more problematic than the fact they are giving water to treat disease. And there are many other studies with a similar design.
Some papers seem to be written to scare those attached to reality:
Integrating Traditional Medicine with Conventional Therapies to Combat Tuberculosis: A Comprehensive Review. Yeah. Let’s treat TB with homeopathy. That’s gonna work.
and
Exploring Holistic Healing of Cancer: German New Medicine (GNM) and Homeopathic Treatment Beyond Traditional Therapies And let’s treat cancer with homeopathy, since cancer is due to emotional trauma and amenable to homeopathic treatment. OH GOD, OH MAN, OH GOD, OH MAN.
And that’s what I could suffer through, er, I mean, found for homeopathy in 2025.
Oh, and here is a fun fact. Before he pulled homeopathy out of his backside, Hahnaman thought many diseases were due to coffee. And he was not a fan of chocolate.
He even goes as far as to say (in his essay of 1803) that children and babies accumulate the ill-effects of coffee from their parents and from being in the same rooms as coffee drinkers. Being convinced in his mind of the certainty of the theory apparently impelled him to then find ‘evidence’ for it, no matter how ridiculous.
The more things change, the more they stay the same.
    • 

   Quackademics

   Harvard Medical School: Veritas for Sale (Part III)
Kimball Atwood
Link
In Parts I and II of this series* we saw that from 2000 to 2002, key members of the Harvard Medical School “CAM” program, including the Director, had promoted quackery to the legislature of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. We also saw other explicit or tacit promotions by Harvard institutions and professors, and embarrassing examples of such promotions on InteliHealth, a consumer health website ostensibly committed to “providing credible information from the most trusted sources, including Harvard Medical School….”
Those points were made in an essay that I sent in the spring of 2002 to Daniel Federman, the Senior Dean for Alumni Relations and Clinical Teaching at Harvard Medical School (HMS). I also sent Dr. Federman a treatise on homeopathy, including several examples of credulous Harvard professors and misrepresentations aimed at students, patients, and the public. Much of the content of that treatise has been covered by the series on homeopathy† with which I began my stint here on SBM, so here I’ll post only the parts relevant to promotions by academic physicians, including those at Harvard. There is a bit of redundancy involving InteliHealth, but please bear with me if you’ve made it this far; the discussion will be meatier than the short summary in Part II.
………………………..
Modern Academic Promotions of Homeopathy
Dr. Holmes must be rolling in his grave. Homeopathy is now being given credence by mainstream academic ‘CAM’ programs of the best pedigrees, including Harvard’s. The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) even takes homeopathy seriously: the former Director, Wayne Jonas, is a practicing homeopath and continues to receive public funding from the NCCAM for homeopathic “research.” At a hearing of Rep. Dan Burton’s House Committee on Governmental Reform in November 2001, Jonas called for homeopathic solutions to bioterrorism threats, praising Jacques Beneviste in his prepared statement. Current Director Stephen Straus cautioned that such remedies should not be substituted for proven measures, even as he bowed to what now seems to be the polite way of discussing quackery:
The prophylactic benefits of exceedingly dilute substances are more in doubt than those of conventional vaccines.”
And, a bit later:
Even though there is some doubt that these products could be effective, we cannot prove the claims to be entirely specious….Exploration of such approaches should first involve careful studies in animals using contemporary methodologies to discern whether they hold any promise against diseases associated with biological weapons.”
Harvard Medical School
Harvard Medical School now presides over several promotions of homeopathy, both as a clinical method and as a subject of uncritical education and research. Descriptions of the practice and its basis are frequently erroneous in Harvard-based literature, as the following examples attest.
From 1997 until March 2002 InteliHealth, a joint effort of HMS and Aetna to provide web-based health information, had this to say about homeopathy:
One of the basic principles of homeopathy is that when a substance in large doses causes certain symptoms, in small doses it can help heal a person suffering from an illness that has those same symptoms. Some treatments in conventional medicine rely on this like-cures-like principle: vaccines, for instance, introduce small doses of an illness-causing agent to cure or prevent disease.
Conditions that respond well to homeopathic treatment include arthritis, migraines, asthma, eczema, attention-deficit disorder, depression, anxiety, ulcerative colitis, Crohn’s disease, chronic-fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, multiple sclerosis, back pain, gastritis, peptic-ulcer disease, ear infections, and strep infections.
To receive an information package and a directory that lists trained homeopaths in your area, send $10 to the National Center for Homeopathy, 801 North Fairfax Street, Suite 306, Alexandria, VA 22314, or use the center’s free searchable directory online at www.homeopathic.org. Contact the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians at 206-298-0125 to find a qualified naturopath in your area.
The vaccine analogy is, of course, erroneous. Vaccines do not “introduce small doses of an illness-causing agent,” since what they actually introduce are non-virulent, attenuated, or non-viable variants of such agents. Furthermore, the dose of the agent in a vaccine is substantial and determined by rational dose-response curves. The dose of the purported active agent in a homeopathic preparation is miniscule or nonexistent, and determined by homeopathic “provings,” which are invalid as a basis for therapeutic decisions.
There is no evidence for any of the therapeutic claims made in the second quoted paragraph. The “supportive research” section of the article may look impressive to the naïve reader. In fact, some of the references support the non-efficacy of homeopathy and the others are hopelessly flawed.
The third quoted paragraph consists of two advertisements.
Homeopathy, “Integrative Medicine,” and Ethics
The new InteliHealth homeopathy article is more circumspect, but still misleading. It is a good example of what now passes for a “balanced” treatment of the subject:
While homeopathy is relatively safe, it should be a complement to, not a substitute for, standard medical care.
This is a well meaning but naïve attempt, by advocates of “integrative medicine,” to coax pseudoscientific methods into the fold of rational practice. An example of the futility of this approach has already been offered above, in the case of licensed homeopaths advising parents against having their children immunized. It turns out that “standard medical care” is specifically proscribed by the most influential of all homeopathic treatises, Hahnemann’s Organon of Medicine:
§ 52 Sixth Edition
There are but two principle methods of cure: the one based only on accurate observation of nature, on careful experimentation and pure experience, the homœopathic (before we never designedly used) and a second which does not do this, the heteropathic or allopathic. Each opposes the other, and only he who does not know either can hold the delusion that they can ever approach each other or even become united, or to make himself so ridiculous as to practice at one time homœopathically at another allopathically, according to the pleasure of the patient; a practice which may be called criminal treason against divine homœopathy.
So much for homeopathy and “integrative medicine.” There is plenty of evidence that Hahnemann’s stern admonition is taken seriously by contemporary homeopaths (available upon request). Even if some disagree with his stance, it does not follow that homeopathy is thus rendered an acceptable practice. To paraphrase physicist John Farley, homeopathy is no more “complementary” to rational medicine than is alchemy to chemistry, astrology to astronomy, or creationism to evolution. It is theoretically true that if all practitioners of homeopathy also practiced, or referred patients for, rational medicine, and if no patients were seduced into substituting homeopathic preparations for rational treatment, there would be no medical disasters referable to homeopathy per se. After all, homeopathic “remedies,” at least those that are unadulterated, are inert. In reality, such contingencies can never be assured: on the contrary, they are undermined by endorsements, however well intended, from bastions of modern medicine and science.
Here is an example. The aforementioned Dana Ullman is among the most well known homeopaths in the United States today, and certainly one of the most influential in “Integrative Medicine” circles. His several popular books and his website, Homeopathic Educational Services, are recommended by many academic CAM programs, including the Rosenthal Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine at Columbia University and the Zakim Center for Integrated Therapies at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute in Boston. One of his books was recommended in the first Intelihealth article reviewed above. On his website, Ullman identifies himself as “an instructor in a course on homeopathy at the University of California at San Francisco” and states that he “serves on advisory boards of alternative medicine institutes at Harvard and Columbia schools of medicine.” Ullman is listed as a member of the advisory board of Integrative Medicine: the Worldwide Authority on Integrated Care, a position he shares with four representatives of the Harvard Medical School CAM project along with representatives of the medical schools of Johns Hopkins, George Washington University, SUNY Stony Brook, and the Universities of Arizona, Colorado, Hawaii, Maryland, and Minnesota. If the “integrative medicine” movement has embraced any homeopath, it has embraced Dana Ullman.
Yet it is difficult to imagine that his medical school patrons have read Mr. Ullman’s writings, even as they recommend them to the public. If they had, they would know that Ullman issues dire warnings to parents about “dangerous conventional medicines” and that for strep throat, for example, “you should start with homeopathic treatment” and “it is reasonable to forego antibiotics even for children since rheumatic fever is so rare today.” They might also have noticed an article in last October’s Utne Reader, for which Ullman lists himself as the “health book reviewer,” in which he recommended homeopathic “nosodes” for the prevention of anthrax (Ullman also offers an Anthrax Nosode and Accompanied Remedies Kit, for $33, on his website). Are these recommendations indicative of the benefits of “integrative medicine?” One can only hope that Harvard and the other medical schools that endorse Ullman do so out of ignorance, because the alternative explanation is even more troubling.
Another argument frequently given for the acceptance of homeopathy is the popular demand for a practice that is not intrinsically unsafe, wholly apart from its capacity to divert patients from rational medicine. If for whatever reason it makes some people feel better, the argument goes, why not welcome it? There are several answers to this. The first is that this essay addresses the appropriate role of trusted societal institutions such as medical schools and government, not the choices of a free citizenry. These institutions should be providing education, and doing so with the utmost integrity. At least some of the current demand is due to the very sorts of misleading promotions described here. The second answer is that those who seek homeopathy will always be able to find it, as they have in the past. In the U.S. it has been a tiny, fringe practice for almost 100 years, and it would behoove the public health for it to remain as such. The recent bandwagon-style
promotion of this and other CAM methods, to a large extent fueled by the misleading hyping of Dr. Eisenberg’s telephone surveys, has only served to move homeopathy closer to the popular mainstream—even as the evidence for it remains nonexistent.
Homeopathy was quackery in 1980 and nothing, other than “spin,” has changed. In any case, its capacity to appear to make some patients feel better cannot be divorced from its capacity to divert them from effective therapies. How many children reporting that their sore throats feel better after swallowing homeopathic belladonna or arsenicum, for example, would it take to justify each excess case of rheumatic heart disease?
Mainstream endorsements of irrational claims are also damaging in other ways: they are confusing to a scientifically challenged public, they waste research dollars, they help line the pockets of quacks, and they are embarrassing to the work of the great majority of physicians and medical scientists and to the reputations of the medical schools that feature “CAM” programs. Finally, if practicing homeopathy to the exclusion of rational medicine is unethical, it does not follow that “integrating” it with rational practice would make it any less so, even if it were to become technically safer. A lie is still a lie.
More Harvard Homeopathy Hype
Back to the new Intelihealth article:
It is also a highly controversial form of medicine because it lacks a scientific explanation for why its treatments might work.
Well, not exactly. Rational medical doctors know that it is a classic example of a popular delusion, and that there are perfectly good explanations for why its treatments might, at times, appear to work.
Homeopathic remedies consist of highly diluted preparations of natural ingredients. The ingredient may be diluted 30 to 50 times, sometimes to the point where no molecules of active ingredient remain.
The ingredients are actually diluted far more than 30-50 times, as correctly suggested by the second part of the sentence. Typical dilutions are 10^12-10^60 fold. There is no rational, repeatable basis for determining what might be the “correct” dilution for a given “remedy.”
But an analysis of 89 clinical trials published in a major medical journal, The Lancet, in 1997 found that the clinical effects of homeopathy are not entirely due to placebo effect.
A 1991 analysis of 105 clinical trials published in the British Medical Journal found that 81 of the studies showed positive clinical results while 24 found no positive effect from homeopathic treatment. The researchers concluded that the evidence was positive but insufficient to draw any conclusion regarding the efficacy of homeopathic treatment, and they recommended that additional well-designed studies be undertaken.
These are the kinds of equivocal reviews invariably cited by proponents of homeopathy and of further homeopathy research. Not stated in the InteliHealth article is that all such reviews find that the studies showing “positive effect” tend to be among the most methodologically flawed, whereas the better studies are more likely to show no effect. For this and other reasons such reviews actually support the non-efficacy of homeopathy, and further homeopathy research can be predicted to yield an endless cycle of equivocal results. In the meantime, the conclusions cited in the passages above—that there is some “positive” evidence and that homeopathy therefore needs further research—merely serve to give the practice an unearned appearance of legitimacy. Hence this sort of article—typical among modern, medical school based “CAM” treatises—is not really “balanced,” but implicitly promotional.
The Family Education and Resource Program of Children’s Hospital promotes homeopathy in a brochure aimed at patients and parents. Highlights of the brochure include a misleading definition of “alternative treatment” (“a kind of treatment you don’t usually receive at a regular doctor’s office or clinic”); a sub-heading (“How does homeopathy work?”) that presumes homeopathy to be effective; a misleading suggestion that homeopaths are astute clinicians (“Homeopathic practitioners wish to understand their patients well. Homeopathic remedies are very specific to the patient’s particular symptoms, daily routines and personality”) that is actually an allusion to the nosy, largely irrelevant “symptom” gathering previously described; and spurious suggestions of efficacy: “homeopathy may be helpful for people suffering from allergies, bruises and sprains and for children with diarrhea.” The brochure invites its readers to call the Center for Holistic Pediatric Education and Research at Children’s Hospital, whose national advisory board includes the president of the American Institute of Homeopathy, for “a list of pediatric homeopaths in the Boston area.”
The “information resources for consumers” webpage of the Caregroup/Harvard Medical School Center for Alternative Medicine Research and Education (CAMRE) promotes homeopathy indirectly by the following advice:
Please consult your local telephone yellow pages under these categories:
Acupuncture
Chiropractic
Holistic Practitioners
Massage – Therapeutic
Naturopathic Physicians
Homeopathy is an integral part of the practice of “naturopathic physicians,” as documented elsewhere in these materials, and is also frequently offered by others on the list.
Homeopathy Research and Education at Harvard
Modern homeopathy research is taken seriously at Harvard but, like the endorsement of Dana Ullman, it is shrouded in a veil of ignorance. After Drs. Reilly and Eisenberg had chastised the conventional straw-man at the 2001 Harvard CIM conference, Reilly likened the concept of ultra-dilute homeopathic preparations to examples of small quantities of substances known to exert a biological effect: pheromones, vitamins, and pollen desensitization regimens. These analogies are false, but Reilly was not challenged. In his own syllabus Dr. Eisenberg listed three homeopathy articles under the heading, “Articles/Consensus Reports Suggesting Efficacy,” but none under the heading, “Articles/Studies Suggesting Lack of Efficacy.” Of the three listed articles, two actually support the lack of homeopathic efficacy, and the third is misleading and uninterpretable.
The Faculty Development and Fellowship Program in Complementary and Alternative Medicine at Harvard Medical School lists a homeopath among its faculty members. Here is a quotation attributed to this homeopath:
Quoting from Edward H. Chapman, M.D., Dht, President of the American Institute of Homeopathy, and Clinical Instructor at the Harvard University School of Medicine: “For those who need support in their struggle with Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder … they can be assured from two hundred years experience using homeopathic medicines that they are safe. Your conventional doctor may be skeptical if you choose to use homeopathy. Don’t let that stop you. Seek assistance from well-trained homeopathic providers who are willing to work with you and your doctors.”
Is Harvard Medical School developing more faculty members with views such as this? Are fellows, in addition to patients, now being encouraged to think that homeopathy is a valid clinical practice or, at the very least, worthy of research? The Course Description for “Complementary, Alternative, Integrative Medicine” at HMS, which includes homeopathy on its list of covered topics, is hardly reassuring. It defines “CAM” as “refer[ring] to medical techniques not in conformity with the beliefs or standards of the conventional medical community…,” as if to suggest that knowledge has nothing to do with it. What distinguish modern medicine from homeopathy and most CAM claims are not “conventional beliefs” or even standards, but reason and facts. Isn’t this what should be stressed to medical students, fellows, and patients?
An Example of Homeopathy Research and More Ethical Mischief
Harvard’s Dr. Chapman also “uses homeopathy as the primary treatment for AOM” (acute otitis media) in children, according to a recent paper authored by himself and Dr. Eisenberg, among others. This paper is a useful example of modern “homeopathy research” in Boston and another illustration of the mischief that can result from misleading promotions of “CAM” popularity. It is a “pilot study” of homeopathic treatments of AOM in children. The authors justify this by stating that “homeopathy is a frequently used alternative therapy for AOM,” citing Dr. Eisenberg’s first telephone survey as evidence. That survey, however, involved only adults and reported that 1% of the 1539 adults queried, or about 15, had used homeopathy for any reason in the past 12 months; of these about 1/3, or a total of five, had seen a “provider.” The survey mentioned neither AOM nor any other disease in relation to homeopathy.
The homeopathy paper refers to the “principle of similars” as an “observation,” and states as fact the very claim that would seem to be at issue:
Choosing the appropriate medication for an individual patient is time-consuming and challenging, and it depends on the skill and experience of the homeopathic practitioner.”
As discussed earlier, homeopathic “symptom” gathering and “provings” are not valid clinical tools. Most troubling of all, 22 out of the 24 children in the study received nothing but homeopathic “remedies” for a disease that calls for antibiotics† (the other two received antibiotics only after 13 and 28 days, respectively). This appears to be a violation of the Declaration of Helsinki of the World Health Organization, which states, in part:
In any medical study, every patient — including those of a control group, if any — should be assured of the best proven diagnostic and therapeutic method.”
Nevertheless, the study was “approved by the Human Studies Committee at Boston Medical Center.” It would seem that “CAM” has spawned a new era in medical ethics together with its redefining of medical science.
Dr. Eisenberg, who has promised that the HMS “CAM” project will be guided by scientific integrity, seems to use science selectively when considering homeopathy. In testimony to the White House Commission on Complementary and Alternative Medicine Policy (WHCCAMP) in May 2001, he said:
I have given in your handout examples of I think the best examples we have to date, most of them from the last five years, where the evidence suggests that there is some efficacy of CAM therapies for particular conditions…Two studies, meta-analyses suggesting homeopathy as distinct from placebo… You are aware of these. These are sort of the examples of good research suggesting positive effectiveness.
Well, no. These are examples of research that is poor but nevertheless good enough, in the face of a vanishingly unlikely 200 year-old claim, to put the matter to rest once and for all. At the 2001 Harvard CIM conference Dr. Eisenberg, (mis-)quoting Carl Sagan, had declared that “exceptional claims require exceptional evidence.” Here, he seemed to have forgotten that truth.
Later in his WHCCAMP testimony Dr. Eisenberg offered a curious view of science, as it pertains to homeopathy, in responding to a question from homeopath and former NCCAM Director Jonas:
Wayne, I completely agree and I put up this slide to really humbly reflect on how the trajectory has gotten rather cockeyed, that in the absence of a robust basic science program, certainly the scientists in the medical community will continue to be irritated… So, I am agreeing with you.
I would say it a little differently, though. I think my suggestion in a positive, in a way to give a friendly amendment to what has happened, I think it has happened because it has happened. I mean, you know, if the first study was a basic science study of the mechanism of homeopathy, we would have a very different trajectory, but that didn’t happen.
Except that basic science did happen, as irritated scientists know. They might remind Dr. Eisenberg that there is an abundance of basic science pertaining to the “mechanism” of homeopathy: physics (the second law of the universe and no basis for “water memory”); chemistry (molecular theory and Avogadro’s number); biochemistry, physiology and pharmacology (pharmacokinetics, dose-response curves, the law of mass action, molecular receptors); pathology and pathophysiology (the natural history of disease and the classification of diseases according to real biological phenomena, as opposed to treatments based on irreproducible, subjective interpretations of “symptoms”).
A scientific study of the “mechanism” of homeopathy must also consider psychology and experimental design and interpretation for an appreciation of bias, cueing, selective attention, practitioner expectation, patient expectation, confirmation bias, the “Stockholm effect,” cultural predilections, the placebo effect, inadequate controls, error, fraud, chance, statistical pitfalls, publication bias, and more. These are the myriad reasons, i.e., “mechanisms,” by which any dogmatic therapeutic claim with little or no basis in nature can be expected, when subjected to clinical trials, to yield equivocal—as opposed to consistently negative—results.
As for the naïve assertion that even wholly negative results would dissuade true believers of homeopathy or any other magical healing “system,” which is the standard highbrow justification for the existence of the NCCAM, the HMS CAM project, and for the collective acquiescence of all who should know better, the last word must go to the good Dr. Holmes:
… it is impossible not to realize the entire futility of attempting to silence this asserted science by the flattest and most peremptory results of experiment. Were all the hospital physicians of Europe and America to devote themselves, for the requisite period, to this sole pursuit, and were their results to be unanimous as to the total worthlessness of the whole system in practice, this slippery delusion would slide through their fingers without the slightest discomposure, when, as they supposed, they had crushed every joint in its tortuous and trailing body.
………………….
† American Academy of Pediatrics. Judicious Use of Antimicrobial Agents. In Redbook 2000: Report of the Committee on Infectious Diseases, 25th edition. pp. 647-648. I am aware that subsequent to that time, new guidelines provide for a period of observation without antibiotics in some cases of acute otitis media. These were not in place at the time of the homeopathy trial, nor would they have applied to most of the experimental subjects in that trial. The children in the homeopathy trial, moreover, were also not given analgesics and antipyretics.

   The Dull-Man Law
Kimball Atwood 
Link
Kimball Atwood is obviously trying to throw mud at Harvard and at homeopathy, but when you throw mud, you get dirty…
(Sigh) So little time, so much misinformation. Hence the Dull-Man Law:
In any discussion involving science or medicine, being Dana Ullman loses you the argument immediately…and gets you laughed out of the room.
This will be the last time that I don’t invoke that law, because it is the perfect opportunity to explain why it is such a useful shortcut. The occasion is the current series about my alma mater, Harvard Medical School (HMS), and its regrettable dalliances with quackery.† The series consists mostly of correspondence that occurred between Dean Daniel Federman and me in 2002. Some of it refers to homeopathy.*
Mr. Ullman, a self-styled expert on homeopathy who lacks any medical training, is a darling of the ‘integrative medicine’ movement, as explained here. He has posted several comments objecting to my assertions in the HMS series. Other commenters have skillfully refuted some of his arguments. Some have been left unchallenged, however, and it’s possible that a naive reader could therefore assume that they are valid. They are not, but explaining why takes time and a modest acquaintance with the topic. Other than to clarify the issues for the uninitiated, then, such time would be wasted. Henceforth, let it not be so: From now on, this post can be cited by anyone wanting to avoid the drudgery of refuting Mr. Ullman’s claims.
First, this comment by Mr. Ullman:
One cannot help but notice how little research is referenced.
Ullman then cited Linde, Clausius, Ramirez, Jonas et al., (1997), Jonas, Kaptchuk, Linde (2003), Jacobs, Jonas et al (2003), and later the David Reilly series on allergic rhinitis, implying that I’d missed the boat by failing to cite these wonderful papers. Regarding the Linde/Jonas 1997 review, whose conclusion had been, “The results of our meta-analysis are not compatible with the hypothesis that the clinical effects of homeopathy are completely due to placebo,” Mr. Ullman wrote:
Even a leading skeptic who wrote an editorial in this issue of the Lancet referred to this meta-analysis as “completely state of the art.” No other meta-analysis on homeopathy has been acclaimed by both sides of the fence.
Ullman must have overlooked this statement in my post:
Much of the content of [the homeopathy] treatise has been covered by the series on homeopathy with which I began my stint here on SBM, so here I’ll post only the parts relevant to promotions by academic physicians, including those at Harvard.
That series (and my entire essay for Dr. Federman) covered, among other reports, the Linde/Jonas 1997 meta-analysis, the 1994 Jacobs childhood diarrhea paper, and the Reilly allergic rhinitis series. It showed that each of these projects has not survived methodologic scrutiny. Several re-analyses of the Linde/Jonas 1997 data, in particular, have demonstrated that they were, well, compatible with the clinical effects of homeopathy being completely due to placebo. Two of those re-analyses were done by Linde and Jonas themselves (!), a point that Mr. Ullman failed to make. Either he knows this (in which case his comment was dishonest) or he does not (in which case he relinquishes his claim to being an expert on the topic).
But wait a minute: Ullman must know these things, because this was only one of several times that he has graced the comments of this blog with his sophistry, including responses to my previous citings of…Linde/Jonas 1997, Jacobs 1994, and Reilly’s allergic rhinitis series. I answered him there in some detail, as did other commenters, and I enlarged on that answer in the post that followed. Mr. Ullman might also consider that in 2002, when I wrote to Dr. Federman at HMS, I could not have cited papers published in 2003—not that it matters, for reasons previously explained.
Atwood considers any comparison between homeopathy and vaccination to be inappropriate. And yet, it was none other than Emil Adolf von Behring (1854–1917) who was one of the early scientists to make this assertion. Behring broke from orthodox medical tradition by recognizing the value of the homeopathic law of similars:
And by what technical term could we more appropriately speak of this influence [ie, smallpox vaccination], exerted by a similar virus than by Hahnemann’s word “homeopathy”?
What I wrote was: “the vaccine analogy is erroneous.” That is correct: the active ingredient in a vaccine is real, measurable, and works because its antigenicity, ie, its ability to elicit a specific immune response, is similar to that of the infectious agent that causes the disease in question—but not because of some fanciful ‘similarity’ of ‘symptom’ production. A vaccine’s dose, moreover, is determined by rational dose-reponse trials, and every competent physician and biologist knows that if it were diluted into non-existence its effect would also become non-existent.
The word “similar” above gives homeopaths an irresistible urge to claim some profound insight into immunology and pharmacology, but it does nothing of the sort. Even looked at solely from Ullman’s superficial, linguistic point of view, where his hero Behring also apparently stood—ignoring, that is, the molecular basis for the immune response and the absurdity of infinitesimals—the technical term most applicable to immunization is isopathy, not ”Hahnemann’s word ‘homeopathy’.” But then Ullman, in his Heinous Hyping of the Hogwash that is Homeopathy, regularly Appeals to Irrelevant Authority, including the Holy See itself.
Hahnemann, of course, knew nothing of the immune system (nor did anyone else at the time), and famously railed against anything that could have suggested even the possibility of infectious vectors. For Hahnemann, diseases were “purely dynamic deranging irritations of the vital force,” and “to regard those diseases that are not surgical as a peculiar distinct thing residing in the human frame is an absurdity which has rendered allopathy so pernicious.”
Ullman again:
Even the British Medical Journal (BMJ) named my website their “website of the week” on August 19-26, 2000.
Too bad for the British Medical Journal and for the level of scientific discourse in what now passes for academic medicine. That is the whole point of the HMS series and of Science-Based Medicine in general.
I was, however, surprised that you chose to make reference to a popular magazine (the Utne Reader) as some type of unimpeachable source…are you next going to quote the National Enquirer without fact-checking?…Ironically, the editor of FASEB also chose to use this same error of fact that was printed in this magazine…When I was granted the right of reply, I chose to reply to sustentative [sic] issues on homeopathy rather than specious personal attacks against me. I will simply say that the Utne Reader mis-reported and has appropriately withdrawn that story from their website.
Hmmm. The article in question appeared during the anthrax scare of 2001 that followed closely on the heels of ’9/11′. Its every statement is consistent with other claims by Ullman; several are direct quotations. That Ullman offered “homeopathic anthrax treatments” for sale on his website is corroborated here. What, then, is the “error of fact,” and how might I have “fact-checked” if, as he admits, he failed to explain it at the time? Does Ullman not really believe that homeopathic ‘nosodes’ can prevent or treat anthrax? If so, we’d love to hear it.
In a sidebar to the Utne Reader article is this:
Dosage
The pills used in homeopathic medicines can vary in size from an aspirin down to the size of poppy seeds. While Dana Ullman says it is generally recommended to take one to five pills per dose, the amount of dose changes depending on the size of pellets. If the pills are aspirin-sized, one or two should be taken per dose. If the pellets are poppy seed-sized, five pills should be taken per dose.–Kate Garsombke
Ah, perhaps that is the ‘error of fact’: surely, according to ‘potentization,’ Dana Ullman must have told Ms. Garsombke that the smaller the pill, the fewer should be taken. Otherwise the patient would risk an overdose.
Also, for the record, I was the [Utne Reader] health book reviewer about 15 years ago and have not held that position since then. It would be nice if you made a little effort in your own fact-checking.
OK, here was my fact-checking. I went to Mr. Ullman’s website, archived in 2002 (when I wrote what I wrote); I clicked on About Dana Ullman, MPH; I scrolled down to the very last paragraph, where I read:
Dana Ullman is the health book reviewer for the Utne Reader.
It must depend on what your definition of “is” is.
Atwood also made reference to Edward Chapman, MD, a homeopath who formerly was an instructor at Harvard. It might have been nice for you to have completed a little homework, for you would have discovered a trial that he conducted at a Harvard-affiliated hospital…
I am well aware of Chapman’s report on “Homeopathic Treatment of Mild Traumatic Brain Injury,” yet another example of a silly, small clinical trial being incompatible with how the universe works, and thus another embarrassment to Harvard Medical School and to academic medicine in general.
Regarding homework, if Mr. Ullman had done his own he might have discovered this entry in a 2003 press release from the Massachusetts Board of Medicine:
In the first matter, in a Final Decision and Order, the Board revoked the medical license of Dr. Edward H. Chapman, a board-certified family practitioner from Newton. The Board found that Dr. Chapman had engaged in numerous boundary violations with two patients and had engaged in conduct that calls into question his competence to practice medicine. The Board also concluded that Dr. Chapman was guilty of malpractice and of conduct that undermines public confidence in the integrity of the medical profession. The revocation will go into effect on August 15, 2003, to allow for appropriate termination and transfer of patients. Prior to that date, Dr. Chapman’s practice will be subject to the terms of a monitoring agreement.
Ouch. (Funny: Harvard Medical School didn’t mention that, either.)
Finally, I am forever amazed that Atwood uses O.W. Holmes as his hero. My comments about his unscientific attitude towards homeopathy and his questionable ethics were previously provided in Part II of your recent series on Harvard.
Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr. (the father of the Supreme Court Justice) is a hero of the Harvard Medical School, of American medicine, and of the human race as a whole, for numerous reasons. The most important is that he proposed, even prior to Ignaz Semmelweis, that puerperal fever was contagious. He published his paper on the topic in 1843 when, according to Mr. Ullman, he shouldn’t have been taken seriously because “he was a medical ‘adolescent’.” His public lecture of the prior year, “Homeopathy and its Kindred Delusions,” was a systematic dismantling of the tenets of homeopathy (as promulgated by Hahnemann himself), and was as scientific as current knowledge allowed in its criticism of the utterly unscientific homeopathy. It still stands as an eloquent, learned criticism, although it was composed prior to an understanding of Avagadro’s number, modern biochemistry, physiology, pharmacology, microbiology, genetics, diagnostics, and everything else that would propel medicine into the modern era.
In the just-linked comment, Ullman repeatedly referred to the “errors” in Holmes’s homeopathy lecture, but the only example he gave was this:
Dr. Holmes got his calculations confused, and he incorrectly assumed that the homeopathic manufacturer had to have 10 times or 100 times more water than in the previous dilution. Dr. Holmes estimated that the ninth dilution would require ten billion gallons of water and the seventeenth dilution required a quantity equal to 10,000 Adriatic Seas.
Well, OK, let’s see exactly what Holmes wrote (emphasis added):
So much ridicule has been thrown upon the pretended powers of the minute doses that I shall only touch upon this point for the purpose of conveying, by illustrations, some shadow of ideas far transcending the powers of the imagination to realize. It must be remembered that these comparisons are not matters susceptible of dispute, being founded on simple arithmetical computations, level to the capacity of any intelligent schoolboy. A person who once wrote a very small pamphlet made some show of objecting to calculations of this kind, on the ground that the highest dilutions could easily be made with a few ounces of alcohol. But he should have remembered that at every successive dilution he lays aside or throws away ninety-nine hundredths of the fluid on which he is operating, and that, although he begins with a drop, he only prepares a millionth, billionth, trillionth, and similar fractions of it, all of which, added together, would constitute but a vastly minute portion of the drop with which he began. But now let us suppose we take one single drop of the Tincture of Camomile, and that the whole of this were to be carried through the common series of dilutions.
A calculation nearly like the following was made by Dr. Panvini, and may be readily followed in its essential particulars by any one who chooses.
For the first dilution it would take 100 drops of alcohol.
For the second dilution it would take 10,000 drops, or about a pint.
For the third dilution it would take 100 pints.
For the fourth dilution it would take 10,000 pints, or more than 1,000 gallons, and so on to the ninth dilution, which would take ten billion gallons, which he computed would fill the basin of Lake Agnano, a body of water two miles in circumference. The twelfth dilution would of course fill a million such lakes. By the time the seventeenth degree of dilution should be reached, the alcohol required would equal in quantity the waters of ten thousand Adriatic seas. Trifling errors must be expected, but they are as likely to be on one side as the other, and any little matter like Lake Superior or the Caspian would be but a drop in the bucket.
Swallowers of globules, one of your little pellets, moistened in the mingled waves of one million lakes of alcohol, each two miles in circumference, with which had been blended that one drop of Tincture of Camomile, would be of precisely the strength recommended for that medicine in your favorite Jahr’s Manual, against the most sudden, frightful, and fatal diseases!
Does Ullman not know the meaning of “let us suppose,” or that the subjunctive “were” refers to something that is not, in fact, the case? Ullman, unwittingly, is playing the same fool for us as the “person who once wrote a very small pamphlet” played for Holmes. Holmes, of course, used the exercise to illustrate how implausible the ‘law of infinitesimals’ was, considering the vast improbability that the original, “active” ingredient could exert any effect, much less a ‘potentized’ one, when the “seventeenth degree of dilution” was the equivalent of it having been dropped into a quantity of water the volume of “ten thousand Adriatic seas.” In the years before Avagadro’s number was known, this was about as rational and rigorous a critique of homeopathic ‘infinitesimals’ as one could hope to find. It is Ullman who has made incorrect assumptions, and in so doing has betrayed his inability to decipher well-written English.
Ullman’s claim that Holmes was a racist (at a time when nearly all white Americans were), whether true or not, is obviously irrelevant to Holmes’s or anyone else’s arguments against homeopathy, as are Ullman’s implications that 19th century homeopaths were somehow politically progressive in the late 20th century sense.
The above is more than enough to justify the Dull-Man Law, but here’s the dessert:
I don’t know why my name would be a part of any writing you may do on Harvard. If you are getting your information from wikipedia, you are not standing on firm ground (wikipedia is notorious for not having reliable information). If veritas is your goal, my name should not have any role in an article about Harvard because I have no affiliation with them, and the one short affiliation that I had was one which can be described as extremely tangenial at best.
I didn’t get my information from Wikipedia; I got it from Mr. Ullman himself:
Dana Ullman has served as an instructor in a course on homeopathy at the University of California at San Francisco for three years. He will also be a member of the Advisory Council of the Alternative Medicine Center at Columbia University’s College of Physicians and Surgeons and is a consultant to Harvard Medical School’s Center to Assess Alternative Therapy for Chronic Illness.
There’s that old ‘is’ word again. Is Mr. Ullman now confessing that he, er, exaggerated his affiliation with Man’s Best Medical School?
Ergo,
In any discussion involving science or medicine, being Dana Ullman loses you the argument immediately…and gets you laughed out of the room.
Q.E.D.

   “Urban Zen” and homeopathy at Beth Israel Medical Center, or: Dr. Gorski destroys his chances of ever being invited to join the faculty at BIMC or the Albert Einstein College of Medicine
David Gorski 
List
I guess I never really wanted to work in Manhattan anyway. At least, that’s what I keep telling myself.
I mean, why on earth would I want to? What’s the attraction? Living in the heart of it all, all those shows and all those amazing cultural activities, all those world-class restaurants? Being close to Boston, Philadelphia, and other cool East Coast cities, which are all just a quick Acela train ride away? Who cares about those things, anyway?
Apparently I don’t, because I’m about to destroy my chances of working at what has been considered one of the premiere academic hospitals in New York City, specifically Beth Israel Medical Center, an academic affiliate of the Albert Einstein College of Medicine. It’s possible for me to have been ignored when I first included the Albert Einstein College of Medicine and its affliated Continuum Center for Health & Healing in my roll call of shame as a medical center that has not just added woo to its offerings, but actively embraced it. At the time I originally discovered it, though, its offerings seemed limited to fairly mild woo, the usual stuff like acupuncture, what I like to call “gateway modalities” that centers embrace first because they’re relatively tame and commonplace. All too commonly, though, dabbling in gateway modalities leads to the “hard stuff,” outright quackery with zero scientific basis like homeopathy, reflexology, and craniosacral therapy. Such is the pathway an academic medical center follows when it degenerates from science-based medicine to what Dr. R. W. famously dubbed “quackademic medicine,” usually driven by a few famous true believers, which, alas, is exactly what happened at fearless leader Steve Novella’s institution of Yale, thanks to Dr. David Katz and his “more fluid concept of evidence.”
In any case, last week, I realized that I’ve been completely neglecting the aforementioned roll call of shame. Perusing it, I now realize that it’s been over five months since I did a significant update to it. You just know that, given the rate of infiltration of unscientific medical practices into medical academia as seemingly respectable treatment modalities that there must be at least several new additions to this roll of shame. Alas, even today, having been shamed myself by the realization of my failure to keep the list updated, I’m not going to do the full update and revamping that the Roll Call of Quackademic Medicine cries out for. However, that doesn’t mean I can’t do a piecemeal addition here and there. That doesn’t mean I can’t point out new additions as they pop up, even if it takes me a while to find the time to give the list the facelift it cries out for. It doesn’t mean I can’t call out hospitals like Beth Israel when they fall into woo, especially when they dive into quackademic medicine in a big way for cancer patients.
The first thing to know about this degeneration of a once great academic powerhouse is that, as is the case for many centers of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or of “integrative medicine” (IM), when looking for the reason why physicians ostensibly dedicated to scientific medicine would embrace cult medicine, look for the financial motive. Indeed, as has been extensively documented by my cobloggers and myself, the National Center for Complmentary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and the Bravewell Collaborative, spearheaded by extremely wealthy believers in unscientific medicine, are pouring millions upon millions of dollars to fund “research” and “training” (read: prosletyzing) for “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), a.k.a. “integrative medicine” (IM). In this case, the financial incentive comes from Donna Karan, founder of the famous DKNY line of clothing. In search of her dollars, Beth Israel has turned over an entire cancer treatment floor to woo:
Medical advances sometimes happen in strange ways. Someone finds a fungus in dirty lab dishes and — eureka! — penicillin is born. Now a premier Manhattan hospital is turning a cancer-treatment floor over to a world-famous fashion designer in the hope that serendipity, science and intuition will strike again.
A foundation run by Donna Karan, creator of the “seven easy pieces” philosophy of women’s wardrobes and founder of the much-imitated DKNY line of clothing, has donated $850,000 for a yearlong experiment combining Eastern and Western healing methods at Beth Israel Medical Center. Instead of just letting a celebrated donor adopt a hospital wing, renovate it and have her name embossed on a plaque, the Karan-Beth Israel project will have a celebrated donor turn a hospital into a testing ground for a trendy, medically controversial notion: that yoga, meditation and aromatherapy can enhance regimens of chemotherapy and radiation.
I can’t help but wonder here whatever happened to the days when a wealthy donor would be happy just to have her name on a building or on a floor. I guess those days never truly existed. Wealthy patrons frequently want more than just their names to live on in the form of a building or patient wing and always have. It’s the same reason they funded great artists hundreds of years ago. That’s not to say that such patrons don’t do truly great things with their money and influence. Certainly they can and do, as Evelyn Lauder has done in creating and running the Breast Cancer Research Foundation, which funds science-based research without giving in to the temptation to be trendy and fund research into unscientific modalities, largely thanks to Dr. Larry Norton, who is Chairman of its Executive Board of Scientific Advisors. In addition, my scientific hero, the late Dr. Judah Folkman, was funded by the BCRF for many years. (Full disclosure: I, too, am currently doing research funded by the BCRF. However, that aside, the more I’ve learned about the organization the more it impresses me. Just search the website for their research projects; you’ll be very hard-pressed to find even a hint of dubious research.)
All too often, unfortunately, wealthy patrons have a tendency to fund projects that serve to reinforce their own personal and non-science-based beliefs. Such is the case with Donna Karan funding this new oncology floor at BIMC. It’s truly depressing to see a former academic powerhouse accommodate such wishes just because they’re trendy, because a wealthy donor is willing to fund them, and because, no doubt, hospital administrators perceive it as good publicity and a potential draw for credulous patients. I wish I could view this as merely a cynical ploy to add a spoon full of woo to make the real scientific medicine go down easier, but somehow I fear that it’s more than that. There’s a big element of real belief in CAM and “spirituality” there. Indeed, it appears to be no different than what was discussed by Harriet Hall last week: An attempt to inject “spirituality,” which, let’s face it, when used in this context is almost always nothing more than a code word for trying to get medicine to endorse religion as a scientifically valid adjunct or primary treatment for various conditions. In other words, it’s the injection of religious belief into into medical practice in an inappropriate manner. The only difference is that, instead of “mainstream” Christian religion, in this case it’s Eastern mysticism in the form of yoga, which is composed not just of potentially useful low impact exercise but also a large amount of religious and spiritual beliefs. In the U.S., you can get your yoga relatively “spirituality”-free (most people do), but that’s not what Donna Karan appears to intend here, as you will see. In her proposed program, the “spiritual” elements of yoga are front and center.
There’s an old saying, though, that’s so famous and overused that it’s become a cliché, and that’s that the road to Hell is paved with good intentions. This is an excellent example of just that. Donna Karan hopes that her new “Urban Zen” center at BIMC will help patients deal with the side effects of chemotherapy, a worthy goal, to be sure. There’s no doubt that, depending on the specific regimen and patient, chemotherapy can cause very unpleasant side effects, and the alleviation of those side effects is an active and major area of research in scientific oncology, because not only are these side effects extremely distressing but they are sometimes so distressing that patients decide not to continue chemotherapy, thus reducing their chances of long term survival. Targeted chemotherapeutics with much lower toxicity and measures to alleviate chemotherapy-induced symptoms are right up there, close to being the Holy Grail of cancer research. Consequently, it’s hard to argue against trying yoga out for such an indication without seeming harsh and close-minded. I would argue that it’s bad to be so open-minded that your brains fall out.
To see why, observe what the program will involve:
Fifteen yoga teachers will be sent to Beth Israel’s ninth-floor cancer ward starting in January to work with nonterminal patients, and nurses will be trained in relaxation techniques. Their salaries, as well as a cosmetic overhaul of the ward, are being paid for by Ms. Karan’s Urban Zen Foundation, created after her husband and business partner, Stephan Weiss, 62, died of lung cancer in 2001.
While other hospitals in New York and across the country have dabbled in yoga, the new Beth Israel project is broader, better financed and more integrated into the medical protocol, and because of Ms. Karan’s concern that it might be dismissed as touchy-feely nonsense, it includes a research component. Ms. Karan hopes to prove that the Urban Zen regime can reduce classic symptoms of cancer and its treatment, like pain, nausea and anxiety (thereby cutting hospital stays and costs) and serve as a model for replication elsewhere.
In a couple of online discussions of this program, I’ve seen it asked: Wouldn’t that money be better spent funding the salaries of 15 RNs for the oncology unit? Almost certainly it would. But, as is the case with virtually all such efforts, this is about proselytization, not science-based medicine. Donna Karan is a believer, and she is looking for evidence to support her belief in order to justify further proselytizing of her Urban Zen program to other hospitals. It’s all very much like a religion, so much so that we’re hearing the usual excuses that that evil reductionistic “Western” medicine can’t adequately study whether yoga can do what is claimed for it:
But Dr. Benjamin Kligler, the research director in integrative family medicine for the Beth Israel-affiliated Continuum Center for Health and Healing and the research project’s principal investigator, acknowledged that the experiment of yoga teachers and their interaction with patients did not lend itself to the random, double-blind placebo trials favored in the medical world.
“The truth is, from a very traditional research perspective, that’s a problem,” Dr. Kligler conceded, adding that it might be time for the medical establishment to consider a new research model for what he called “lifestyle interventions.”
Poppycock.
Even though a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial can’t be done in the classical sense, in most cases that’s nothing more than a convenient excuse used by true believers for not doing the most rigorous studies possible given the limitations placed by the specific modalities under consideration on what studies can be done. A classic example of this was published in the medical literature about a year and a half ago. It involved a study of Tai Chi as an immune booster. In fact, when looked at dispassionately and with a science-based eye, the study itself was not really a study of Tai Chi per se but rather a study of mild exercise versus no exercise in the elderly and whether mild exercise in the form of Tai Chi increased vaccine-stimulated levels of cell-mediated immunity (CMI) to varicella zoster virus in older adults. The results were predictable; it did. Of course, the positive results from that trial were attributed to the Tai Chi, rather than to mild, low impact exercise in general. After all, when stripped of all its Eastern mysticism, that’s all Tai Chi really is: low impact exercise. The huge, gaping hole in the study was that the only two groups in the study were the Tai Chi group and a group receiving passive health education. There was no additional no control group in which patients participated in another form of mild, low impact exercise without all the “spiritual” trappings to see if that had a similar effect. Ironically enough, yoga might have been a reasonable additional group, but any form of low impact exercise of the same intensity as the Tai Chi regimen used in this study would have been acceptable. It wasn’t there, and the authors didn’t seem to comprehend why their study didn’t show what they thought it did.
I’m expecting to see the same sort of studies coming out of Urban Zen at BIMC.
Of course, it’s not entirely unreasonable to hypothesize that low impact flexibility exercise might make people undergoing chemotherapy feel better, just as exercise makes people feel better, through whatever mechanism, be it distraction or a physiological effect attributable physical activity. Indeed, the scientific literature already contains studies suggesting that exercise speeds recovery from the adverse effects of chemotherapy and that it can reduce fatigue in patients undergoing chemotherapy. Whatever studies performed at Urban Zen are almost virtually assured to be “positive” simply because they encourage mild exercise in patients undergoing chemotherapy. However, this particular form of flexibility exercise, yoga, is overlaid with all sorts of “Eastern” mysticism that credulous CAM aficionados love so dearly, and it is the mysticism that Donna Karan believes in and wants to sell, not just mild exercise. It’s a classic “bait and switch,” although I’m guessing Karan has no idea that that’s what it is. She appears to believe, but belief is not science. It’s also depressing to think that a large part of what drives movements like this comes from the failure of our hospitals practicing science-based medicine to provide patients with a sufficient degree of human warmth and encouragement; I often think that the attraction of these touchy-feely non-science-based modalities would be much attenuated if we were able to provide more emotional support and our time to listen to patient concerns. Purveyors of woo are doing nothing more than seeing an opening and rushing in to fill it. The problem is that it’s not necessary to embrace religion or pseudoscience to fill this hole, and all the mystical and pseudoscientific baggage that accompanies such woo represents a profound threat to science-based medicine.
In any case, the “problem” that Dr. Kligler laments about testing yoga for this indication is really not nearly as big a problem as he makes it sound, certainly not big enough that we need a new paradigm to test CAM modalities scientifically. True, blinding is impossible for a study of the effect of exercise on chemotherapy-induced side effects, but we surgeons do unblinded randomized experiments in surgery all the time. After all, it’s rarely possible or practical to blind surgeons to the surgical procedure performed, nor is a sham surgery control group usually feasible. It’s a bit more difficult to get usable scientific data from clinical trials under such circumstances, but by no means anywhere near impossible. It just takes more effort to be rigorous elsewhere, and it usually takes more studies carried out at different institutions, to be sure to eliminate institutional and investigator biases as much as possible. Certainly, it’s not so difficult that we should consider jettisoning current clinical trial methodology, as Dr. Kligler seems to imply that we should.
Of course, it’s highly doubtful that Donna Karan would have tried to sell her yoga program to an institution not likely to be receptive to it, and, boy, oh, boy does BIMC qualify as being “open” to such ideas. Just get a load of its Continuum Center for Health & Healing. Peruse its webpage, and it’s a veritable cornucopia of woo and unscientific medical modalities. It’s all there. There’s reiki, Rolfing, prayer, Therapeutic Touch, traditional indigenous healing therapies, acupuncture, even that woo of woo, that One Quackery To Rule Them All (apologies to J.R.R. Tolkien), homeopathy:
As a pediatrician Dr. Stern finds that homeopathic medicines, which are safe and efficacious, are particularly well suited for the care of children’s common ailments. In her practice Dr. Stern uses homeopathy not only to treat acute problems such as upper respiratory infections and acute ear infections but also to treat more chronic conditions. For children suffering from conditions such as asthma, recurring ear infections, eczema and behavioral problems homeopathy has helped reduce or eliminate daily doses of antibiotics and steroids which are often required for symptomatic control.
Quackery such as homeopathy has no place in an academic medical center–or any medical center, for that matter. (There, I said it.) Worse, this quackery is being administered to children, and belief in homeopathy has led to unethical clinical trials with children as subjects. Homeopathy is water. Period. Diluting a substance does not render it more potent, nor does shaking it. Period. There is no plausible physiological mechanism by which homoepathy could work, and homeopathy goes against well-established science. Period. Barring incredibly compelling evidence for its efficacy in non-self-limited diseases, there is no reason to suspect that whatever effects are attributed to homeopathy are due to anything more than the placebo effect, regression to the mean, the expectation effect, confirmation bias, or a combination thereof. Period. Yet homeopathy is being offered at Beth Israel as though it’s on par with scientific medicine. Worse, its being promoted by true believers. Don’t believe me? Then consider this detailed and credulously positive description of homeopathy. I just about spit up my drink when I saw Samuel Hahnemann’s homeopathic provings as “meticulously executed experiments” (for an antidote, read Kimball Atwood’s post on “provings”) and indulged in appeals to ancient knowledge:
Although Hahnemann was the first to clearly formulate the law of similars and first began to use its principals in a systematic way, he clearly states that a number of people before him had very similar ideas. The “Law of Similars” has a very rich historical basis. Hippocrates (VI century, B.C.) wrote: “through the like, disease is produced, and through the application of the like it is cured”. Celsus and Paracelsus are known to have used the Law of Similars in their practice. The Delphic Oracle proclaimed:” That which makes sick shall heal”. In one of the ancient Jewish writings, called Mekilta, we read: “Man does not heal with the same thing with which he wounds, but he wounds with a knife and heals with a plaster. The Holy One, blessed be He, however is not so, but He heals with the very same thing with which he smites.” Modern medicine uses this principle daily. The “father” of immunology , Dr. Emil Adolph von Behring, wrote about the origins of immunology: “By what technical term could we more appropriately speak of this influence than by Hahnemann’s word “homeopathy”? Desensitization techniques used by conventional allergologists utilize very small doses of allergens to stop a pathological response in the patient.
If ancient knowledge is so great, I always ask whether believers in these ancient modalities would like to go back to the medical systems that existed thousands, or even 200 years ago (the time of Samuel Hahnemann) and see how well it worked compared to today’s scientific medicine. Right on cue after appeals to ancient knowledge are also appeals to popularity:
In England, Australia, New Zealand, India, Russia, Brazil and many other countries homeopathy is recognized as a valid mode of treatment. In the United Kingdom, around 42% of physicians refer patients to homeopathic practitioners, and homeopathic training is the most popular post-graduate training program. In France, approximately 36% of the public and 32% of the physicians use homeopathic remedies. Moscow, Russia, has a homeopathic hospital with a large homeopathic outpatient clinic and many homeopathic pharmacies with many people using various homeopathic preparations daily. India has approximately 125 four- and five-year homeopathic medical colleges with over 100,000 homeopathic doctors practicing around the country.
If you really want to throw up (homeopathically, of course), read another homeopathy article entitled Homeopathy — How it works and when to use it. The deconstruction of this article is left as an exercise for the reader. (“Decontruction”? How postmodernist of me!) I know you can handle such a task just fine. While you’re at it, feel free to take on the other woo on the Continuum Center for Health & Healing website. Suffice it to say it’s–shall we say?–a very, very “target-rich environment” for skeptics–depressingly so, in fact. It’s profoundly disturbing to find an academic medical center willing not merely to embrace such unscientific medicine but to actively promote it as science-based without a shred of evidence that any critical thinking whatsoever was applied to writing the material on the website touting its benefits.
Of course, no true floor dedicated to the “integration” of yoga and Eastern mysticism into our nasty, reductionist science-based medicine would be complete without real “integration” plus feng shui:
“A lot of other hospitals have integrative medicine, but it’s kind of stuck away in the basement,” said Dr. Merrell, who, not coincidentally, is Ms. Karan’s internist. “People like to think it’s not there.” Starting in November, the cancer ward will be renovated by Ms. Karan, the architect David Fratianne and Alex Stark, a feng shui master. The dull beige walls and green linoleum tile floors will be replaced with bamboo wallpaper and cork floors. Nooks and crannies now used for brown-bag lunches and naps and crammed with a desultory selection of dusty books will be turned into yoga, prayer and meditation retreats for patients, their families and nurses.
As I said before, this is religion–excuse me, “spirituality”–not science. And, true to most “alternative” medicine, it relies on testimonials. In this case, it’s the story of Lynn Kohlman, a photographer, model and DKNY fashion director who inspired Donna Karan with her battle against cancer. In fact, a quote by Karan is most revealing as to the true motivation for the Urban Zen center:
She [Kohlman] intensified her yoga. “She asked for it in the hospital,” said Ms. Karan, who practices yoga daily. “She needed it, she wanted it.
“This works,” Ms. Karan insisted. “Now we have to prove it in the clinical setting.”
That’s exactly the problem. Karan intensely believes that yoga “works” (although what “works” means in this context is not entirely clear), and she’s looking for evidence to support her belief, not to see if her belief stands up to experimental testing that could falsify it. There’s no malignant intent in her championing of yoga; after all, she thinks it will help people. However, her attitude of looking for evidence to support her preexisting belief rather than testing her belief, trying to falsify it, to see if it stands up to scrutiny is one key difference between scientific medicine and pseudoscientific medicine. Given Karan’s attitude, think about this: If the results of the “clinical trials’ being carried out at Beth Israel fail to bear out her belief, how long do you think her generosity will continue? CAM boosters frequently criticize trials of what they disparagingly call “conventional” pharmaceuticals because of perceived conflicts of interest due to the funding source. Make no mistake, this is indeed a serious problem in the research underpinning of science-based medicine, as I’ve pointed out before twice recently. However, with respect to programs such as Urban Zen, that argument cuts both ways. Don’t think that doctors running the “studies” of yoga at Urban Zen don’t know what their wealthy patron hopes that they will find in their “studies” of yoga and the relief of chemotherapy symptoms. Of course, any possible conflicts of interest may not matter. After all, they, like Karan, are true believers as well; so they want to find that yoga “works,” too.
I’m not opposed to patients using yoga because it makes patients feel better, and I’m certainly not opposed to using yoga as a form of mild (or even not-so-mild) exercise that may help ease recovery from the effects of chemotherapy. Exercise is good; exercise very likely helps patients who can do it deal with the side effects of chemotherapy. Remember, though, at its core that’s not really what the Urban Zen program is about, no matter how much Donna Karan and the boosters of quackademic medicine who have latched onto her belief and largesse at Beth Israel try to argue otherwise. I wish it were, but it’s not. No, in reality at its very heart it’s about the rejection of science in favor of a specific flavor of “spirituality” and the injection of that spirituality into the heart of the practice of oncology. It’s about the embrace of testimonial evidence over scientific evidence, and the abandonment of science and reason in medicine–or, even worse, their subversion to serve the beliefs of the people promoting these modalities. Again, none of this is because Donna Karan is evil or stupid. She truly believes she is doing good, but science doesn’t work the way she thinks it does. Worse, there are several enablers unwilling to disabuse her of her misunderstanding of science because to a greater or lesser extent they share her misunderstandings. To bring it all back home to the Urban Zen program, I’ll just say that, if you don’t believe me, take a look at the section on yoga on the Center for Health & Healing website:
What is Yoga? Most people think of Yoga as a physical practice of stretching the body in different ways. To some, Yoga evokes images of seemingly impossible contortions accomplished only by the adept. But the physical practice of Yoga is only one facet of a holistic system that addresses all aspects of our experience. The Sanskrit word Yoga literally means to yoke, bind, focus one’s attention; it also means union or communion. The ancient Yogis sought to experience our essential nature, beyond the bounds of body and mind. Through practice and discovery using the instruments of our very existence- the body, breath, senses and mind- they reconnected with the universal of which we are all an expression. This is the essence of Yoga. By moving into stillness through the layers of the body, emotions and thoughts, we find at our core a sense of deep peace and connection.
The science of Yoga is a guide to that peace. Recognizing the multifaceted nature of human beings, the system of Yoga addresses our complex relationship with the external and internal worlds. This system, called Astanga Yoga or the Eight-Limbed Path, encompasses Yama (ethical observances), Niyama (personal disciplines), Asana (physical postures), Pranayama (control of the breath), Pratyahara (drawing in of the senses), Dharana (concentration), Dhyana (meditation) and Samadhi (higher consciousness). These Eight Limbs are like rungs on a ladder; each one is an important step on the path and leads naturally to the next.
And this is how the practitioners at BIMC claim that yoga “works”:
In the Yogic view, disease is the result of imbalance. Yoga approaches dis-ease by restoring ease. To understand the benefits of Yoga it’s helpful to first look at one of the roots of dis-ease-stress. Sometimes in the absence of an identifiable cause of a condition, we assume “it must just be stress.” But the effects of chronic stress are quite specific and in a very real way lead to illness if unchecked.
What is stress? The stress response (“fight-or-flight”) is a survival mechanism that enables us to respond quickly to dangerous situations. In the face of a perceived threat, a cascade of physiological events takes place that prepares the body to get itself out of trouble. Stress hormones are released, heart rate and breathing rate increase, blood vessels constrict, blood pressure increases, muscle tension increases, resting processes such as digestion and repair cease, immune function is impaired, fats and sugars are released into the bloodstream, and insulin production increases. Fight-or-flight is carried out by the sympathetic nervous system, part of the autonomic nervous system.
Ideally when the emergency is resolved, the body returns to its natural state of balance. But because the stress response is nonspecific, it may be set off by events, thoughts and feelings on a daily basis. Without relief, without restoring balance, the state of stress can become a chronic condition and we become vulnerable to illness.
Aside from all the “balance” blather, a good rule of thumb is that whenever you see the word “disease” spelled as “dis-ease” you can be quite confident that you’re dealing with grade A, top-notch woo. Snark aside, though, no wonder Donna Karan saw the faculty at BIMC as kindred “spirits” and decided to shower her patronage on them, who in turn were apparently more than happy to accept her largesse and run with it. No doubt in future years, there will be a series of publications arising from BIMC and the Albert Einstein College of Medicine touting the benefits of yoga for chemotherapy-induced nausea and other symptoms. No doubt they will fail to include critical controls, just as the Tai Chi study I discussed did. And no doubt they will be uncritically trumpeted in the press, particularly given the publicity engendered by the well-meaning but unscientific benefactor of the Urban Zen effort, Donna Karan. Albert Einstein, if it were possible for him to know what sort of pseudoscience is being perpetrated by members of the faculty at the medical school bearing his name, would proceed to do backflips in his grave.
And, no, I guess I don’t want to live in New York that badly after all. In fact, I’m quite happy with my current position, and I wouldn’t fit in with the “holistic” approach at BIMC anyway. Besides, in the unlikely event I ever became disenchanted with my current job and decided to relocate again, I’d much rather move to Chicago than New York anyway. I’m a Midwest guy at heart.

   ““It’s just a theory”
Mark Crislip
Link
I am afraid that the experiments you quote, M. Pasteur, will turn against you. The world into which you wish to take us is really too fantastic.
La Presse, 1860
It’s just a theory. Not evolution. Germ theory. Just a theory, one of many that account for the etiology of diseases.
I should mention my bias up front. I am, as some of you are aware, an Infectious Disease doctor. My job is simple: me find germ, me kill germ, me go home. I think there are three causes of disease: wear and tear, genetic, and germs. Perhaps a bit of an exaggeration, but not much. My professional life for the last 22 years has been spent preventing, diagnosing, and treating the multitudinous germs that a continually trying to kill or injure us. It is a fundamentally futile job, as in the end I will be consumed by the organisms I have spend a lifetime trying to kill.
I would have though that the germ theory of disease was a concept that was so grounded in history, science and reality that there would be little opposition to the idea that germs (a broad term for viruses, bacteremia, fungi, parasite etc) cause infections and some other diseases.
Wrong. There are people who deny the validity of germ theory. Add there are people who deny gravity. And evolution.
Opponents of germ theory come in two flavors:
Germ theory deniers.
Those who propose alternative mechanisms of disease.
There is great overlap between the two categories, and the division serves more as a literary device for the sake of exposition than a true description of reality.
Germ Deniers
The germ deniers put forth as their patron Saint Antoine Bechamp, a contemporary of Louis Pasteur. Bechamp lived from 1816 to 1908, the dawn of modern medicine and the beginning of microbiology. No one had a clue in the 1800′s as to the cause and treatment of diseases and there were many speculations and experiments performed in an attempt to understand and treat diseases. Most people had a life expectancy less than 50 years and the predominant cause of morbidity and morality was infectious. Since we do not die young of infections and we get to live long enough to die of cancer, heart and vascular disease. Before the 1900′s, if you could understand what caused infections, you could understand most diseases.
The foundations of microbiology and infectious diseases are based on the work of Pasteur and Robert Koch. Like Darwin, the insights of Pasteur and Koch are not the end of understanding of infectious diseases, but the beginning. The world is far more complicated and subtle than Pasteur and Koch could appreciate with the scientific tools of the time.
Pasteur, of course, performed the experiments that proved that germs existed and were a cause of some diseases. His name is well known and lives on in pasteurization, the heating of milk to kill microorganisms and prevent the spread of disease, one of many contributions he made to medical sciences. His insights, which lead to antibiotics, hygiene, and vaccines have undoubtedly prevented more morbidity and mortality than any human in history.
Another contemporary of Pasteur was Robert Koch, who, among many accomplishments formulated Koch’s postulates, conditions that were to be met to prove the infectious cause of disease:
The organism has to found in all cases of the disease
The organism has to prepared and maintained in a pure culture
The organism had to be capable of producing the original infection, even after several generations in culture
The organism retrievable from an inoculated animal and cultured again.
Modern biochemistry and molecular techniques have refined Kochs postulates. We can’t always grow the organism but we can isolated its DNA. Given the species specificity of some germs, we cannot always infect animals to prove causation. I doubt anyone would want to prove the cause of Ebola by re-inoculating a human with cultured virus. Also, there is great variability in the ability of many germ strains to cause disease and great variability in the hosts immune system to combat diseases. Some germs are more virulent than others. Some people are some or less susceptible to disease, and the last 10 years have seen an explosion in understanding of the variability in the human immune system (polymorphism’s) that explain why some people get ill from a given pathogen and others do not.
The combination of germ theory and Koch’s postulates, improved and refined by biotechnology, are still the cornerstones of infectious diseases. Pasteur, Koch and their contemporaries began the science of infectious diseases and microbiology, a field that has lead to more benefits to mankind than perhaps any other.
What do the germ deniers offer as a alternative to Pasteur et. al.? The theory of Antoine Bechamp and others called pleomorphism (1).
CELLULAR THEORY (BECHAMP)
Disease arises from micro-organisms within the cells of the body.
These intracellular microorganisms normally function to build and assist in the metabolic processes of the body.
The function of these organisms changes to assist in the catabolic (disintegration) processes of the host organism when that organism dies or is injured, which may be chemical as well as mechanical.
Microorganisms change their shapes and colours to reflect the medium
Every disease is associated with a particular condition.
Microorganisms become “pathogenic” as the health of the host organism deteriorates. Hence, the condition of the host organism is the primary causal agent.
Disease is built by unhealthy conditions.
To prevent disease we have to create health.
Bechamp’s hypothesis was, at the time, no more or no less reasonable than other ideas. Unfortunately for him, a century and a half of research has demonstrated that there he was wrong on all the particulars of his ideas, except for 7 and 8. Postulates 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6 are all flat out false. From 1950 to November 2nd 2008 at 9:50 am PST, there were 909, 599 citations on Pubmed relating to infections. How many papers and experiments were done in the 100 years prior to 1950 I do not know, but it is a safe bet that germ theory is supported by over a million studies and experiments. A Pubmed for terms to support pleomorphism finds zero references. Germ theory is as confirmed a concept as science can offer. Cellular theory lost the battle to experiment. Reality and science supports the ideas of Pasteur, not Bechamp.
Alternative practitioners are drawn to the concepts of Bechamp because the reason for disease is that the body fails. Alternative providers are all about supporting health to allow the body to heal itself. Bechamp lends credibility to many alternative practices.
Here is where it gets weird.
Rather than look at the mountains of evidence to support germ theory and the complete lack of evidence to support pleomorphism as the reason for the dominance of germ theory, they resort to paranoid sounding conspiracy theories.
The Whale is a good source for this kind of thinking and is representative of what you will find if you browse the web:
How did Pasteur’s ideas become the foundation of organized medicine? Politics. Pharmaceutical economics.
Early in his career, Pasteur was decorated by the Emperor Napoleon. His position as a scientist was thereby secured, even though he was only a chemist and had no credentials at all in medicine or physiology…..
For the first time in history, things were coming into focus. Discoveries were being made about fundamental issues, but in a piecemeal fashion. It was perfect timing for an opportunist to take advantage of the general uncertainty and lack of understanding and to claim that he understood all the issues involved, and furthermore had thought of them first. Pasteur was noted for his habit of playing both sides of the fence on issues he didn’t understand, and then later, to quote the parts of his earlier writing that supported the later finding, always with the claim that he had been there first. Only the scientists understood the complexities of these emerging ideas. The royal court and the press just knew that something was going on, and though they didn’t know what, were going to act as though they did. And for them, a chameleon like Pasteur was the perfect frontman.
Politics never changes. The same type of thinking that imprisoned Galileo long ago for discovering that the earth went around the sun, the rulers’ eternal attempt to control the minds of their subjects, these are the forces that cast Pasteur, an ambitious opportunist, into a position he may not have deserved – the supposed Trailblazer in the science of modern biomedicine.
Funny how things often don’t really get “discovered” until the commercial aspects of that discovery have been worked out.
or
Béchamp’s research revealed that the inner condition of a person’s cellular terrain determined whether disease would manifest or spread in the body. He proved through rigorous scientific method that disease was not due to germs attacking the body from the outside as Louis Pasteur later convinced the world. What you eat, breathe, drink, and bathe in are the primary factors that determine your body’s inner condition.
Instead of incorporating Béchamp’s discoveries to bring about a health revolution in the world and save countless lives, greedy, power hungry industrialists decided to ostracize his work and put their dollars behind Louis Pasteur’s “Germ Theory of Disease” because it was a way for them to build a colossal pharmaceutical/medical empire for profit. No pharmaceutical company in the world today cares one iota about curing disease. They want to control disease and focus on symptom suppression so they can make huge profits by getting you to become a lifelong user until you die from their poison. That’s why they go to war against disease with all their “anti” this and “anti” that medications instead of addressing the inner condition of a patient and re-establishing homeostasis in the body. (2)
This is weird not only because it denies over a million interrelated studies that confirm germ theory, but Pasteur’s fundamental ideas were confirmed about 60 years before the discovery of penicillin. That is just how subtle and clever big Pharma is: they suppressed a theory because they knew that 60 years in the future they would make a fortune selling antibiotics. Someone needs to send Big Pharma the JREF million dollar prize.
Then there are HIV deniers, who live in a bizarro world of their own. My medical career started with the onset of the HIV epidemic. I have seen HIV go from zero understanding about the disease and a 9 month life expectancy to amazing detail about the biochemistry and pathophysiology of HIV and an almost normal life expectancy for many AIDS patients. There are 191,000 plus articles on Pubmed concerning HIV research. The astounding accumulation of data to support HIV as a cause of AIDS and the benefits of applying that understanding to the treatment of AIDS is triumph of the modern medical-industrial complex. It is why I have one AIDS patient die this century after a decade of AIDS deaths. Application of germ theory saves lives. Millions and millions of lives.
Of course, that is just what they told me to say.
Alternative mechanisms of disease
There are a multitude of alternative mechanisms of disease: blocked chi in acupuncture, blocked innate intelligence in chiropractic, toxin build up in the colon, etc etc. What these alternative therapies share is a lack of appreciation or understanding of germ theory. Since germs cannot be seen, and since it is not germs but their alternative theory that causes disease, why would you expect alternative providers to behave as if germs exist? The result of believing that germs do not exist is infections. The germs will always win.
Acupuncture and Infections
Acupuncture is unique compared to most alternative practices in that it is invasive and because acupuncturists actually do something to accomplish nothing. Stick needles into people and you can drag in all kinds of germs. I have a healthy respect for needles and the damage they can cause by practitioners who understand germ theory. A review of adverse events associated with acupuncture demonstrated that “Infection accounted for 204 primary reports and 91 secondary reports. Over 60% of these cases were hepatitis B. The next most common infection was of the external ear, as a complication of auricular acupuncture (3).”
Cellulitis, bacteremia, endocarditis, empyema, osteomyelitis, endophthalmitis, abdominal abscesses, epidural abscesses and infected joints are well described complications of acupuncture. Blood borne pathogens such as HIV, hepatitis C and hepatitis B are associated with acupuncture. Mycobacterium abscesses and Mycobacterium chelonae outbreaks have occurred due to acupuncture. Needles are dangerous, and while the body has good defenses against infectious complications of minor trauma, the defenses fail on occasion.
One would think acupuncturists would clean the skin before needle insertion, but a review of skin disinfection for acupuncture states: “Disinfection of clean skin before injection is not generally considered necessary and observations of lack of infection following injections without prior skin disinfection support this (4).” Another review suggests that “none the less, good infection control is essential” but that assumes the practitioner understands and appreciates germ theory as a cause of infectious diseases. Infection after penetrating trauma is uncommon, a rare event under most circumstances. I would guess that many reading this have evidence of minor skin trauma right now and are not infected. It is what the immune system is for.
One of the lessons you learn in medicine is there is a difference between what one can get away and what is the best practice for all patients. Most of the time you do not need to wash your hands or prep the skin or do any of the procedures that decrease the risk of infections. Most of the time you can get away with being sloppy. But the more you practice infection control procedures, the greater the odds that the patient will avoid infection. Of course, there is the underlying assumption that you think germs cause disease. If not, why bother? There are a smattering of infections treated with acupuncture (UTI, skin infections, arthritis) in the medical literature; one can only wonder why. I suppose the acupuncture will support immune health a foster the innate healing process. I would rather kill bacteria. But then, I would.
Chiropractic and Infections
Two studies have cultured chiropractic exam tables and found pathogens, including methicillin resistant staphylococcus. Apparently chiropractors are not particularly fastidious at disinfecting their exam tables. Why would they? Germs are not necessarily the cause of disease in their world view.
I am particularly drawn to one of the conclusions: “Rudimentary behavioral changes to improve chiropractic clinic infection control are needed.” Rudimentary. Not an enthusiastic vote that the education chiropractors received in school was in infection control. I note chiropractic schools offer microbiology, and again I wonder why. It would not appear to be for the purpose of learning rudimentary infection control. But why should they feel inclined towards good infection control practices? The cause of disease is not germs, it is due to blocked innate intelligence.
It maybe less of an issue currently, but chiropractors long opposed germ theory and a google using chiropractor and germ theory as search terms finds no shortage of chiropractors who oppose the concept of germs causing disease. Given the huge variability in chiropractic practice, it is difficult to know if such lack of understanding of germ theory is typical of the field or not.
Other practices
There was an outbreak of colonic amoebiasis associated with colonic irrigation. Thirty six people developed the disease and 10 required colectomy. “Tests of the colonic-irrigation machine after routine cleaning showed heavy contamination with fecal coliform bacteria. The severity of disease in this outbreak may have been related to the route of inoculation.” Colonic irrigation is done to cleanse the colon of toxin build up that causes disease. It is an idea for the cause of diseases that has no bearing on reality and colonic irrigation is useless for removing toxins or curing diseases. Why concern yourself with germs and their transmission to others, since they are not a cause of disease. It is no surprise that the cleaning was not optimal
Moxibustion has been associated (and yes I know association is not causation) with a spinal epidural abscess and with a Pasturella abscess. The other complication of moxibustion is burn injury, which is fertile soil for infections. It is no surprise that this procedure would be associated with infection.
Naturopathic care is associated with a case of prosthetic valve endocarditis with P. acnes after unnecessary vitamin injections.
Other alternative modalities have fewer or no reported infections associated with them probably because they do not do anything. The recent 50 facts about homeopathy suggested “The chances of contracting MRSA or C. Difficile at a Homeopathic Hospital are extremely rare.” Of course it is. An intervention that does nothing cannot have an infectious complication. Doing nothing results in nothing.
What unites many alternative practitioners is their opposition to vaccines. Germs don’t cause disease, so why prevent infections with vaccines? Like many practices with alternative medicine practitioners, it is difficult to know how pervasive anti-vaccine sentiments are.
CAM also lends support to the “anti-vaccination movement. In particular, sections of the chiropractors, the (non-medically trained) homoeopaths and naturopaths tend to advise their clients against immunization. The reasons for this attitude are complex and lie, at least in part in the early philosophies which form the basis of these professions (5).” In other words belief in magic prevents understanding of infectious diseases and germ theory.
Chiropractors often advise against vaccination and do not vaccinate their own children. There is a contingent chiropractors of who are against vaccines, but to what degree they represent chiropractors as a whole I cannot say. Since Chiropractors are not required to use evidence to base their practice, there appears to be fewer standards and greater variability as to what what constitutes chiropractic practice. Attitude by health care professionals can influence decisions to vaccinate, and 27% of chiropractors in one survey advised against childhood vaccination (7). In another series where a fictitious patient asked for vaccination advice on the internet, of 93 homeopaths and chiropractors, “no homeopath and only one chiropractor advised in favor of the MMR vaccination (8).”
Advice from chiropractors, homeopaths, naturopaths and other alternative practitioners against vaccinations abounds on the web, it is difficult to tell from the published studies if this dangerous advice is the norm for these practitioners or the deviant recommendations of the more extreme of the already irrational. The studies are few and small in number, but disturbing in their implications. Chiropractors and naturopaths are pro childhood infection.
Anti-vaccination is often spun as an issue of choice “Concerning immunization information, a much higher proportion of faculty (91%) and students (80%) than practitioners (62%) felt chiropractors should provide both pro and con information to patients (6).”
It may be that the biggest source of infections from alternative medicine practitioners is not what they do but what they do not do. The only studies I can find on vaccine refusal concerns religious exemptions. I wonder how many who refuse vaccinations do so because of information obtained from chiropractors, homeopaths, naturopaths and other alternative practitioners.
I looked for, and could not find, studies that examined how compliant various alternative providers are with rudimentary hand hygiene and other infection control recommendations. In science based medicine, where germs are an accepted etiology of disease, compliance with hand hygiene has historically been poor. Rates for hand washing have typically been less than 50% in a group of people who allegedly think germs exist. Thanks to intensive education and focus this century, hand hygiene rates have gone up at all my hospitals. It has been gratifying to see as the compliance with infection control has increased, the rates of hospital acquired infections have dropped. The last 19 years that I have been the Chair of our Infection Control committee has seen the continuous and relentless decline in infections at all my hospitals. That is one of the side effects of applying evidence based medicine and germ theory to the hospital: infections decrease.
Any useless anecdotes from readers? Did your chiropractor wash her hands? Your naturopath? Your primary care doc? If not, you should perhaps seek care elsewhere.
All of the infections associated with alternative medicine modalities are unusual. I also suspect that the infectious complications associated with alternative medicine are under reported because it takes time and effort to report cases. I have seen a handful of infections (and other complications) associated with alternative therapies and have neither the time nor inclination to report them formally to a journal.
I am certain someone will mention in the comments all the morbidity and mortality us real doctors cause on a regular basis. Health care is not, unfortunately, risk free, and I know all too well the improvements that could be done to improve patient safety. I also know the enormous strides we have made in preventing hospital acquired infections during my career. I used to be able to make a living off hospital acquired infections and the last 19 years have shown a steady decrease in nosocomial infections at my hospitals to the point where some have not had a nosocomial pneumonia in over a year.
In medicine we have to weigh the risks of what we do with the benefits we hope to gain. In the world of alternative medicine, there is all risk with no benefit. See http://whatstheharm.net/ for more anecdotes (not data).
Beliefs in disease causation have consequences. Believing that germs do not cause disease doesn’t affect the germs. They are out there waiting for the opportunity to invade and try and kill you. Job security.
References
(1) http://whale.to/p/bechamp.html
(2) http://www.healthtruthrevealed.com/full-page.php?page=article&&id=11421316206
http://whale.to/v/bechamp1.html
Acupuncture references:
(3) Acupunct Med. 2004 Sep;22(3):122-33. A cumulative review of the range and incidence of significant adverse events associated with acupuncture.
(4) Acupunct Med. 2001 Dec;19(2):112-6. Skin disinfection and acupuncture.
Outbreak of invasive methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus infection associated with acupuncture and joint injection. Infect Control Hosp Epidemiol. 2008 Sep;29(9):859-65. PMID: 18684094.
Acupuncture-associated Listeria monocytogenes arthritis in a patient with rheumatoid arthritis. Joint Bone Spine. 2008 Jul;75(4):502-3. Epub 2008 May 2. PMID: 18455948
Outbreak of acupuncture-associated cutaneous Mycobacterium abscessus infections.J Cutan Med Surg. 2006 Jul-Aug;10(4):166-9.PMID: 17234114
[Risk of hepatitis C related to traditional medicine: a case control study in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam] Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique. 2007 Apr;55(2):107-12. French. PMID: 17 442516
Paraplegia caused by spinal infection after acupuncture.Spinal Cord. 2006 Apr;44(4):258-9.PMID: 16151454
Multiloculated pleural empyema following acupuncture.Infection. 2005 Aug;33(4):297-8. PMID: 16091905
HIV infection after Chinese traditional acupuncture treatment.Complement Ther Med. 2003 Dec;11(4):272. PMID: 1496979
Soft tissue abscess and osteomyelitis secondary to acupuncture.ANZ J Surg. 2003 Sep;73(9):770. PMID: 12956798
Group B Streptococcus endogenous endophthalmitis : case reports and review of the literature.Ophthalmology. 2002 Oct;109(10):1879-86. Review. PMID: 12359609
Chiropractic References
Chiropr Osteopat. 2007 Jun 7;15:8. Assessment and risk reduction of infectious pathogens on chiropractic treatment tables.
Am J Infect Control. 2006 Apr;34(3):155-7. The role of chiropractic adjusting tables as reservoirs for microbial diseases.
Chiropr Hist. 1996 Jun;16(1):72-87 Chiropractic’s tension with the germ theory of disease.
Other Practices
N Engl J Med. 1982 Aug 5;307(6):339-42.Links An outbreak of amebiasis spread by colonic irrigation at a chiropractic clinic.
Spinal epidural abscess associated with moxibustion-related infection of the finger. J Spinal Cord Med. 2008;31(3):319-23. PMID: 18795486
Pasteurella multocida infection of the calf in a patient who had moxa cautery treatment for degenerative arthritis. Yonsei Med J. 1982;23(1):65-70
Tidsskr Nor Laegeforen. 1991 Sep 20;111(22):2741-2. [Bacterial endocarditis after treatment by a natural healer]
Vaccines and alt med
(5) Vaccine. 2001 Oct 15;20 Suppl 1:S90-3; discussion S89. Rise in popularity of complementary and alternative medicine: reasons and consequences for vaccination.
(6) J Manipulative Physiol Ther. 2004 Jun;27(5):287-98. A survey of US chiropractors on clinical preventive services.
http://www.chirobase.org/06DD/chiroimmu.html
(7) Vaccine. 2004 Dec 2;23(3):372-9. here to read Beliefs and behaviours: understanding chiropractors and immunization; Association between Health Care Providers’ Influence on Parents Who Have Concerns about Vaccine Safety and Vaccination Coverage.: Smith PJ, Kennedy AM, Wooten K, Gust DA, Pickering LK.Pediatrics, November 2006; 118(5):e1287-e1292
(8) Vaccine. 2003 Mar 7;21(11-12):1044-7. MMR vaccination advice over the Internet.

Georgian College’s Homeopathy Program: Magical Thinking Presented as Fact
Georgian College in Ontario, Canada is now offering a 3-year advanced diploma in the pseudoscience of homeopathy.
Scott Gavura on January 25, 2018
Link

[Update as of February 9: Georgian College has cancelled its homeopathy program.]
When academic institutions teach nonsense, students suffer the most – not only have they wasted their tuition, but they’ve wasted their time. Georgian College is a community college in Ontario, Canada with over 11,000 students. It recently announced plans to offer a three-year diploma program in homeopathy. This announcement has understandably raised questions from critics about Georgian College’s educational standards. That’s because homeopathy as a health practice is pseudoscience, where the “treatments” lack any medicine at all. It is the air guitar of medicine: It goes through the motions of health care, and looks a bit like medicine, but actually accomplishes nothing at all.
Science and evidence is the basis of medicine today
Evidence-based medicine is a (relatively) new model for health care delivery. Medicine was very different just 100 years ago. Formal medical education had varying standards before 1910. That changed when the American Medical Association commissioned Abraham Flexner to evaluate American and Canadian medical education and make recommendations on their improvement. Flexner was highly critical of the education standards he observed, and recommended consolidating schools, increasing education prerequisites, enhancing the scientific rigor, and embedding the role of research in education. Flexner was also highly critical of dubious “alternative medical practices” and recommended the closure of under-performing institutions that continued to offer education and training based on principles other than science.
The effects of the Flexner report on medical education and the practice of medicine (and affiliated health professions, like pharmacy) can’t be overstated. Medical education became grounded in a rigorous foundation of science, and schools abandoned unscientific practices like naturopathy, homeopathy, chiropractic, and osteopathy. The result is the medical education and the medical standards you see today. Of course, the purveyors and supporters of these now-rejected practices never fully disappeared. They retreated, regrouped, and fought back, continuing to seek the public legitimacy and credibility now offered to medicine and its related health professions. Over time, these practices became known “alternative” medicine, and eventually, “complementary and alternative” medicine (CAM). Today, CAM is often called “integrative” medicine. The branding of alternative medicine as “integrative” or “holistic” is a marketing tactic, but the reality hasn’t changed. There is still no need to adopt or accept practices into medicine that are not grounded in high-quality science, as this (still current) 1998 editorial pointed out:
There is no alternative medicine. There is only scientifically proven, evidence-based medicine supported by solid data or unproven medicine, for which scientific evidence is lacking. Whether a therapeutic practice is “Eastern” or “Western,” is unconventional or mainstream, or involves mind-body techniques or molecular genetics is largely irrelevant except for historical purposes and cultural interest. We recognize that there are vastly different types of practitioners and proponents of the various forms of alternative medicine and conventional medicine, and that there are vast differences in the skills, capabilities, and beliefs of individuals within them and the nature of their actual practices. Moreover, the economic and political forces in these fields are large and increasingly complex and have the capability for being highly contentious. Nonetheless, as believers in science and evidence, we must focus on fundamental issues—namely, the patient, the target disease or condition, the proposed or practiced treatment, and the need for convincing data on safety and therapeutic efficacy.– Phil B. Fontanarosa & George D. Lundberd
Dilutions of grandeur: The history of homeopathy
I’ve discussed homeopathy several times before, and will refer curious reader here if you want more. Among all the forms of alternative medicine, homeopathy is possibly the most implausible of them all. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like is simply sympathetic magic, a pre-scientific belief that was first described by anthropologist Sir James George Frazer in his 1890 book, The Golden Bough. In the book, Fraser outlined the two components of sympathetic magic:
If we analyse the principles of thought on which magic is based, they will probably be found to resolve themselves into two: first, that like produces like, or that an effect resembles its cause; and, second, that things which have once been in contact with each other continue to act on each other at a distance after the physical contact has been severed. The former principle may be called the Law of Similarity, the latter the Law of Contact or Contagion.
The so-called “Law of Contagion” underlies societal preoccupations with pseudoscientific ideas such as “detox” and “eating clean“. Sympathetic magic is the entire basis for the homeopathic belief system:
    • Like-cures-like: in homeopathy, a substance that is believed to cause a symptom, is diluted to treat that same symptom. Any substance is thought to be an effective remedy if it’s diluted enough: cancer, boar testicles, crude oil, oxygen, skim milk, even vacuum cleaner dust or moonlight can be a homeopathic remedy. Deciding which substances will cure which symptoms is determined by a process called a “proving” which is equally without any scientific basis. (Here are homeopathic provings for the Berlin Wall remedy and also sunlight reflected off the planet Saturn, to give you an example of the how the remedies are created by homeopaths.)
    • Water has a memory: the more you dilute the substance, the more powerful its effect. And when I say dilute, I mean dilute. The 30C “potency” is a common dilution used in homeopathy – that’s a dilution of 10-60. You would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original, pre-diluted material. The result is that most homeopathic remedies are completely inert, and don’t contain a single molecule of what’s on the label. Whether bottled as a liquid or dripped onto lactose and sold as tablets, they are pure placebo.
Samuel Hahnemann invented the practice of homeopathy, based on the ideas of sympathetic magic, in the early 1800s. Hahnemann attempted to position homeopathy as a separate and more effective form of medicine compared to conventional medical practices. Given homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, homeopathy probably was safer than medical practice at the time, which was still based around the idea of the four humors and was referred to as “heroic medicine” because of the dramatic treatments used and effects they caused. Eventually, germ theory emerged, ideas of humors disappeared, as did the elements of vitalism and magic, and medicine slowly turned towards a scientific model based on objective observations. Homeopathy, on the other hand, has never progressed or evolved based on evidence, because it was never based on evidence to begin with. Its practices today are frozen in the same beliefs from the 1800s.
Homeopathy is ineffective
Despite the implausibility of homeopathy, and its ejection from the practice of medicine, it retained some popularity over time, with a resurgence in the past few decades as an “alternative” medical system. Rigorous clinical trials confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. While there are plenty of clinical trials that show homeopathy is associated with positive clinical effects, they are always small, poorly controlled, and often biased. Two of the more recent comprehensive reviews of the evidence are the 2010 Evidence Check from the United Kingdom’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee and the 2014 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council review, the latter of which made the following conclusion:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness. People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner and should keep taking any prescribed treatments. The National Health and Medical Research Council expects that the Australian public will be offered treatments and therapies based on the best available evidence.
That’s not all. Edzard Ernst has compiled a list of twelve different statements on homeopathy from international or national organizations, all of which make a similar point: Homeopathy lacks plausibility, and has not been shown to be effective.
Georgian College’s homeopathy program
With this in mind, you might wonder how a post-secondary community college like Georgian College can possibly justify a three year diploma program what is essentially magical thinking. Yet it does:
The graduate has reliably demonstrated the ability to:– practice in a professional and competent manner within the defined scope of practice and consistent with the current legislations and standards of practice;– critically analyze and administer treatment using established homeopathic principles, theories and methodologies;– select, formulate and dispense homeopathic medicines in accordance with homeopathic principles, practices and regulatory criteria;– implement safe and effective client care and practice management consistent with the ethical and professional standards;– integrate interdisciplinary knowledge for the effective provision of client care and promotion of interprofessional collaboration;– communicate effectively in educating clients, families, the community and the broader healthcare field about the benefits and efficacy of homeopathy;– provide respectful and culturally sensitive care to clients in the homeopathic clinical setting;– implement and advocate environmental sustainability and best practices relevant to the profession;– establish a plan for lifelong learning and professional development;– apply entrepreneurial strategies to create and respond to new opportunities.
The entire three-year curriculum is posted:
Mandatory CoursesBIOL1036 Human Health Systems and BiochemistryBIOL2008 Human PathophysiologyBUSI3007 Business Principles for the Regulated ProfessionalHLTH1005 Holistic NutritionHLTH1006 Holistic Nutrition and Lifestyle ManagementHOMP1000 Foundations of HomeopathyHOMP1001 Professional Practice and JurisprudenceHOMP1002 Introduction to Materia MedicaHOMP1003 Introduction to Case TakingHOMP1004 Homeopathic RepertoryHOMP2000 Materia Medica 2HOMP2001 Physical Examination and Emergency MedicineHOMP2002 Repertorization and Case AnalysisHOMP2003 Homeopathy Therapeutics 1HOMP2005 Conventional and Herbal MedicinesHOMP2006 Materia Medica 3HOMP2007 Homeopathic DispensaryHOMP2008 Homeopathy Therapeutics 2HOMP3000 Homeopathy Therapeutics 3HOMP3001 Homeopathy Therapeutics 4HOMP3002 Homeopathy Practice ManagementHOMP3003 Environmental MedicineHOMP3005 Contemporary Integrative MedicineHOMP3006 Research MethodologiesHOMP3007 Preparation for Provincial RegulationPSYL1001 Introduction To Psychology
ClinicalsHOMP1005 Clinical ObservationsHOMP2004 Clinical Grand RoundsHOMP2009 Clinical Case ManagementHOMP3004 Clinical InternshipHOMP3008 Clinical Internship Advanced
The curriculum embraces homeopathy’s root principles:
HOMP1000 Foundations of Homeopathy 84.0 HoursIn this course, students are introduced to the philosophy, fundamental principles and theories of classical homeopathy. Samuel Hahnemann’s Organon of the Medical Art forms the basis of discussion and analysis. A historical overview of homeopathy highlights significant contributions by prominent figures in the profession. Foundational concepts – including the law of similars, totality of symptoms, provings, minimum doses, miasms, direction of cure and potentization – provide the framework for the remainder of the program.
Emphasis added.
It appears the curriculum will give students the impression they can use homeopathy to treat acute conditions, as well as trauma:
HOMP2003 Homeopathy Therapeutics 1 42.0 HoursIn this course, students examine the etiology, pathogenesis, symptomatology and therapeutics associated with traumatology, acute conditions, dermatology and musculoskeletal disorders. Homeopathic medicines are examined and compared in the context of their clinical application in relationship to specific diseases. Polycrests as well as smaller remedies are studied. The concept of prophylactic homeopathy is discussed. Rubrics, modalities and approaches for differential diagnoses are reviewed.
There’s that strange term, “homeopathic medicines”.
And yes, the curriculum include homeopathic nosodes, which are efficacy-free products sold as “alternatives” to vaccines but offer no protection from infection.
HOMP3001 Homeopathy Therapeutics 4 42.0 HoursIn this course, students study mental and emotional health issues, palliative care, epidemics and the emergence of modern society’s environmentally generated diseases. The role of the homeopath in interdisciplinary and complex care is examined. Special attention is given to guidelines, communication strategies and safety precautions associated with the treatment of these specialty areas. The role of nosodes is discussed.
Let’s hope it’s made clear to these students that there is no “role” for nosodes, which are not a substitute for actual vaccination. Regrettably, anti-vaccine homeopaths are not uncommon.
I could easily go through the entire syllabus course-by-course, but there’s no need for a trip down that rabbit hole. It’s remarkable that it will take Georgian College three years to fully train students to be ill-equipped to deliver health care.
Conclusion: Wasted time and dollars on homeopathy
It’s disappointing to see academic institutions like Georgian College offer programs in homeopathy, where student might be led to believe homeopathy has something meaningful to offer patients and the broader community. Ignoring the evidence, it has created a three year course in what is essentially magical thinking, with a curriculum based on ideas that have no basis in fact. Every dollar spent by Georgian College students on its homeopathy diploma program will be a dollar wasted, that could have been otherwise directed towards a more meaningful and credible health career. It’s easy to ignore and even dismiss endeavors like this one as fringe activities offered by colleges putting revenue ahead of evidence. But programs like this will create graduates ill-equipped and potentially without the insight to recognize they’ve been taught nonsense. People like ex-naturopath Britt Marie Hermes, who recognized her education hadn’t prepared her to provide credible health care, are rare. Let’s hope that prospective students do their due diligence and show more critical thinking than Georgian College has.

Homeopathy Embarrassing to Integrative Medicine
Homeopathy is the most embarrassing form of alternative medicine, and the easiest to refute. There has been long series of skeptical wins around the world over the past year – including University of California, Irvine’s decision to scrub its mention from the homepage of its latest integrative medicine center. Hopefully, if we can keep up the pressure the trend will continue!
Steven Novella on September 27, 2017
Link

Homeopathy has been taking a lot of hits for the last decade. I like to think this is at least partly due to our efforts. We did explicitly decide that homeopathy was the most vulnerable of the medical pseudosciences, and that we should keep up the pressure as much as possible.
Part of homeopathy’s vulnerability is that it thrives on ignorance. Many people simply do not know what it is – they think it is herbs and natural treatments. They are often doubtful, and then scandalized, when informed that it is based on silly notions of sympathetic magic and water remembering the “essence” of substances that have long been diluted out of existence. So all we really have to do to fight homeopathy is just explain to people exactly what it is.
Many governments have somewhat opened their eyes as well. There have now been multiple independent government-sponsored reviews of the homeopathy literature, all coming to roughly the same conclusion. In 2010, the UK’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee published a withering report on homeopathy, dismissing it as witchcraft and recommending that the UK not waste another dime on this nonsense. In 2013 the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) published their report, concluding that the scientific evidence shows homeopathy does not work for any indication. They later recommended that it be removed from pharmacies.
In the US the FTC reviewed their regulation of homeopathy, and in 2016 decided to tighten their regulation of homeopathic products by requiring actual evidence to support any clinical claims made. The FDA is still reviewing their homeopathy regulation. The Russian Academy of Science jumped on the bandwagon earlier this year.
The only outlier in terms of recent government-sponsored reviews is Switzerland. However, the Swiss report also reveals how vulnerable homeopathy is. Initially the Swiss also concluded that homeopathy does not work, but Swiss homeopaths were unhappy. They managed to engineer a follow up review, packed with homeopaths. A published analysis of the Swiss review concluded:
This paper analyses the report and concludes that it is scientifically, logically and ethically flawed. Specifically, it contains no new evidence and misinterprets studies previously exposed as weak; creates a new standard of evidence designed to make homeopathy appear effective; and attempts to discredit randomised controlled trials as the gold standard of evidence. Most importantly, almost all the authors have conflicts of interest, despite their claim that none exist. If anything, the report proves that homeopaths are willing to distort evidence in order to support their beliefs, and its authors appear to have breached Swiss Academies of Arts and Sciences principles governing scientific integrity.
Interestingly, even the highly biased Swiss report could not argue that the scientific evidence shows homeopathy works. So instead they desperately tried to redefine scientific evidence. This strategy is standard procedure for alternative medicine apologists, so it was not surprising.
As of this year we have one more review to add to the list – the European Academies Science Advisory Council. Here is a summary of their main conclusions:
Scientific mechanisms of action—where we conclude that the claims for homeopathy are implausible and inconsistent with established scientific concepts.
Clinical efficacy—we acknowledge that a placebo effect may appear in individual patients but we agree with previous extensive evaluations concluding that there are no known diseases for which there is robust, reproducible evidence that homeopathy is effective beyond the placebo effect. There are related concerns for patient-informed consent and for safety, the latter associated with poor quality control in preparing homeopathic remedies.
Promotion of homeopathy—we note that this may pose significant harm to the patient if incurring delay in seeking evidence-based medical care and that there is a more general risk of undermining public confidence in the nature and value of scientific evidence.
Translated into plainer language – homeopathy can’t work, homeopathy doesn’t work, and misleading patients about these simple facts can cause demonstrable harm. Essentially we can conclude with the highest degree of scientific confidence that homeopathy is utter nonsense and has no clinical efficacy. Any regulatory body that allows homeopathic products to be promoted as medicine is failing their citizens. Any health care professional who practices homeopathy is a quack.
Homeopathy and integrative medicine
Because of the obvious status of homeopathy as quackery, it presents a difficult problem for proponents of so-called “integrative” medicine. They desperately pretend to be science-based, but being based on science is fundamentally at odds with the very concept of integrative medicine. In other words, science-based (or even the weaker standard of being evidence-based) integrative medicine is an oxymoron.
As my colleagues and I have often pointed out – what are they integrating? They mostly rebrand diet and exercise as if it is alternative (it isn’t) and add a generous helping of outright quackery. Integrative medicine brings nothing new to the table that is not pseudoscience, which makes integrating pseudoscience into mainstream medicine their raison d’être.
But of course proponents desperately deny this. They insist that they are evidence-based, and simply want to expand the repertoire of options for patients. This is where homeopathy comes in. The claim of integrative medicine proponents of being evidence-based is on thin-ice to begin with. When it comes to homeopathy, they plunge into the frigid waters. They know they can’t maintain their facade of being scientific when it comes to homeopathy. The game is basically up. So what do they do?
Sometimes they sacrifice homeopathy on the altar of seeming scientific. The NCCAM did this – when we had a meeting with them in 2010, of course we asked them directly about their policy towards homeopathy. The director would only say that they are not currently funding any studies in homeopathy (but would not commit to never funding homeopathy going forward).
Sometimes they just try to hide their use of homeopathy from the public. The most recent example of this is the integrative medicine center at UC Irvine (which I wrote about just last week). The Samuelis, who are apparently big believers in homeopathy, donated $200 million to UC Irvine to establish and integrative medicine center there. UC Irvine insists this center will be evidence-based (no, no pseudoscience here). But right there on their website they mention that they offer homeopathy – which is blatant pseudoscience.
So they had a choice. They could try to defend homeopathy, which I guess they decided they could not do. They could declare homeopathy pseudoscience and not part of legitimate integrative medicine, which they apparently did not have the moral courage or scientific insight to do. Or they could quietly scrub the word “homeopathy” from their website, which is what they did.
The LA Times reports on this update – in the face of significant criticism of their new center for pseudoscience in medicine, UC Irvine made some cosmetic changes to their website to at least remove the quackery that currently has the worst PR. Of course, the internet remembers, and the prior listing of homeopathy is archived. It is unclear if they no longer offer homeopathy, or if they just did not want to advertise this fact. Further, they still incorporate naturopaths in their center, and homeopathy is central to naturopathic practice. You don’t have one without the other, and sure enough one of their naturopaths still advertises homeopathy on their page.
Homeopathy, however, represents more than just a PR inconvenience to proponents of integrative medicine – it undercuts their entire philosophy. Their real dilemma is that the scientific basis for anything they are trying to do is not really any better than homeopathy. How can they condemn homeopathy (even just by scrubbing any mention of it) while accepting acupuncture, energy medicine, worthless or harmful herbs, and other nonsense?
The scientific basis for acupuncture is no better than for homeopathy – after thousands of clinical studies it is very clear that acupuncture simply does not work. It just has better PR than homeopathy. I strongly suspect that acupuncture has been so successful in hoodwinking medical professionals who are not paying close attention because it has a better placebo effect. Sticking needles into the skin is more invasive, and more invasive interventions have a larger placebo effect than just taking pills. That is really the only advantage to acupuncture – it is harder to properly blind and easier to present a negative study as if it is positive. It is just as worthless as homeopathy, however.
We will have to continue to hold UC Irvine’s feet to the homeopathy fire. They should not be allowed to quietly hide from the truth that they have welcomed a center for quackery and pseudoscience into their medical school. Making cosmetic changes to their website will not be enough. Further, it takes more than just getting rid of homeopathy (if they are even really doing that) to be truly science-based.

Homeopathy Awareness Week shows that homeopathy is still a problem
Homeopathy Awareness Week might be almost over, but The One Quackery To Rule Them All wastes resources and endangers patients year round, and a recent French criticism of homeopathy has provoked another case of legal thuggery by homeopaths.
David Gorski on April 16, 2018
Link

As I was contemplating over the weekend what to write about, it struck me. Today is the last day of World Homeopathy Awareness Week, and somehow no one at SBM has written about it. It’s also rather convenient in that I’m currently out of town imbibing real science at the annual meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) in Chicago, meaning that I haven’t had a lot of time to write up one of my typical epic posts. Fortunately, however, because I write elsewhere, I always have material that I can revise and repurpose for SBM in situations like this when I don’t have enough time to compose one of my 5,000 word magnum opuses. Acknowledging Homeopathy Awareness Week before it’s over seemed like a good idea.
I like to refer to homeopathy as The One Quackery To Rule Them All, so much so that I ought to copyright it. There are, of course, very good reasons for that, and, although I sometimes refer to reiki or “energy medicine” or “energy healing” as contenders for the title of The One Quackery To Rule Them All, because the idea that humans can channel “healing energy,” be it the patient’s own or from a “universal source,” is arguably equally ridiculous to the notion that diluting a substance to nonexistence produces stronger remedies, thanks to the “memory of water.” Still, for the sheer ridiculousness of its precepts, I still give the nod to homeopathy, albeit just barely, because of the contortions and distortions of science and logic engaged in by homeopaths to justify their quackery. Also, homeopaths have Dana Ullman.
The sheer ridiculousness of homeopathy is one reason why I view Homeopathy Awareness Week as being even more ridiculous. After all, if homeopathy is The One Quackery To Rule Them All, then Homeopathy Awareness Week, which concludes today, must be the biggest waste of a perfectly good week as I can think of. The reason Homeopathy Awareness Week starts on April 10 is because Samuel Hahnemann, the founder of homeopathy, was born on April 10, 1755. The official website of World Homeopathy Week describes it this way:
In celebration of all those who have healed with Homeopathy, homeopaths and supporters share education and accessibility of homeopathy around the world, beginning on Dr. Samuel Hahnemann’s Birthday every year.
During World Homeopathy Awareness Week (WHAW) free public events such as lectures, media interviews, volunteer first-aid at sports events, free & reduced clinics, written materials, pieces on Twitter and Facebook, publication articles and much more are shared in over 40 countries.
Through more awareness and access to homeopathy resulting in profoundly improved health, the paradigm in the understanding of healing and healthcare can truly shift.
Join us! April 10th – April 16th every year. This year April 2018 we are celebrating our 14th World Homeopathic Awareness Week.
Each year, World Homeopathy Week has a theme. Some of them are quite disturbing:
2006: Homeopathy for Children2007: Homeopathy for Women’s Health2008: Homeopathy in Sport’s Medicine2009: Homeopathy and Allergies2010: Homeopathy for Mental Well-Being2011: Homeopathy and the Musculoskeletal System2012: Homeopathy for Infertility2013: Homeopathy for Trauma & Disasters2014: Homeopathy for Men’s Health2015: Homoeopathy for Infectious Diseases2016: Homeopathy as Preventative Medicine.2017: Homeopathy For Elderly
And this year:
The theme for 2018 is ‘Homeopathy for Pregnancy and Childbirth’. Some of you might not be aware of homeopathy, or its benefits. But throughout this special week you’ll learn loads more! Homeopathy can offer effective help to those personally affected by crises. In such times the right homeopathic remedies can help treat individual and long term experiences.
Homeopathy for pregnant women and childbirth? The thought is horrifying. However, consistent with the theme of this year’s “celebration,” you just know that I had to do some Googling for webpages related to this year’s theme, and Google I did. Sadly, there were a lot of articles to choose from, a disturbingly large number.
A homeopathic case report
Here’s the “case report” that I found for homeopathy in induction of normal labor and preventing caesarean section. The report comes to us courtesy of Sapna Gupta and Dr Parul G Wadhwani, BHMS MD of the Nehru Homoeopathic Medical College and Hospital.
The case is presented thusly:
A 25 year old primigravida, consulted on 29 January 2017 for delayed engagement. In her last visit to Obstetrician on 28/1/17, the doctor told her that there is already a delay in descent of child into the uterus and cervix was thick and not effaced, which should have taken place by this time of gestation in a primigravida and if the same does not happen within 3-4 days, Caesarean section shall be required.
Her last menstrual period was on 2/5/16 and as per ultrasound report dated 8/1/17, her expected date of delivery was 26.1.17 +_2 weeks. Her antenatal period had been uneventful except that she suffered from dry cough during her pregnancy.
Apart from above findings, she also complained of pain in vagina since last 4 days which aggravated in the evening and was worse turning in bed and first motion. It was better by continued motion and warm fomentation. She used to go for long evening walks which relieved her pain. Also, there was pain in left leg.
OK, so we have a young woman expecting her first child. Her estimated due date was 1/26/27, but she presented three days after her expected date, with her fetus not having descended into the true pelvis. This process is known as “lightening” or, in lay terms, “dropping,” and it’s a sign of impending labor, as the fetal head drops into the pelvis and becomes engaged within the pubic bones. The authors note that in first time mothers, dropping usually occurs between three to four weeks before deliver, but it can happen earlier. In women who have already had children, it might not happen until right before labor begins. In their view, this woman was in danger of requiring a Caesarian section.
You can see where this is going, of course. The homeopaths treated the patient with homeopathy:
29/1/17 (1 PM): Pulsatilla 200/ three doses/ 30 minutes interval.
30/1/17: On waking in the morning, patient felt a sense of relief on her chest, a symptom suggestive of engagement, and also felt as if the uterus has come down. BY 1 PM, labor pains started and at 5: 30 pm , she was admitted to hospital. Obstetrician confirmed that the cervix was dilated and effaced. At 10:30 PM, she delivered a healthy baby boy by normal labor.
So what, exactly, is pulsatilla? Basically, it is the diluted extract of pulsatilla nigrans, described by the British Homeopathic Association as “one of our oldest and most useful homeopathic medicines” and that it was “proved by Samuel Hahnemann in 1805 and was extensively used by him to treat many hun­dreds of patients.” Recall the Two laws of homeopathy, first the idea that, to treat a symptom you must use something that causes that symptom in asymptomatic patients (a principal with no basis in science or even clinical observation) and, second, that serial diluting a compound, with vigorous shaking (succussation) at each dilution step to “potentize” it makes a homeopathic remedy stronger. Never mind that diluting anything beyond 12C (twelve 100-fold dilution steps) is unlikely to leave any molecules of residual starting material, at least in an ideal world. In the real world, there might be a tiny amount of starting compound that carries through dilution steps by sticking to the glass vials used to dilute the homeopathic remedy, but even then that’s doubtful given the number of dilution steps.
In any case, pulsatilla is more commonly known as the whole meadow anemone, also known as the pasqueflower or windflower, a member of the Ranunculaceae or buttercup family. The BHA describes it as “soft and beautiful with pendulous bell­shaped flowers, purple petals and a gold heart.” The BHA further describes pulsatilla as “predominantly a female remedy,” and, no, the complete description is not sexist at all (not):
It is classically thought to suit blonde, blue­eyed females of a mild, shy and tearful disposition. Yet there is often much more to these fair types, for they are usually quite paradoxical in virtu­ally all areas of their life.
The image they project often belies what they feel inside. Although they tend to be good­natured yet they can hide their indignation about some slight they may have received. They tend to bottle things up and hold onto emotions. On the other hand they can certainly be weepy. Indeed, they will tend to weep when they describe their symptoms and their upsets, but they will also be moved to tears when listening to music, watch­ing a romantic film or even seeing distressing news on the television. They can be hopeless romantics and will prob­ably be moved to weep when shown kindness or given a present. The emotions they hold onto can also be very nega­tive ones. They can hold grudges and classically they feel peeved. They can become quite jealous, quite sorrowful, depressed and very anxious.
They can also hold firmly to their views, in that they can be deeply reli­gious, or dogmatic about things that they hold dear. Their views can be held so rigidly that any slight personal mis­demeanour, especially if of a sexual nature, can be regarded as a great sin and they hold onto guilt. And figura­tively speaking they can beat themselves up with this guilt, just as they can with any of the other negative emotions. Pulsatilla types are full of fears. They can fear the dark, illness, death, ghosts, doctors, dentists and appointments. Sympathy always helps them. A cuddle or a hug may make them weep, but it will usually help. It is that touch, that comfort that is important.
So what do homeopaths think that pulsatilla is good for? The BHA describes it as being useful for grief and bereavement, painful periods, premenstrual syndrome, vaginal discharge, menopause, venous problems, and wandering pains. The BHA also gamely notes that it’s “not just women,” but that pulsatilla “often works well when men have a problem with their testicles,” such as mumps orchitis (which you’re going to see a lot of if homeopaths, who are generally antivaccine, had their way.) Oddly enough, failure of the fetal head to engage or delayed labor is not listed as a use for pulsatilla. It is, however, listed elsewhere as a treatment for delayed labor. For instance, this article by a woman named Piper Martin who offers a training course she calls—shudder—the Homeopathic Midwife, Pulsatilla 200C – when and why to use this remedy, tells you when to use this homeopathic remedy to “augment” labor. Remember that a 200C dilution is two hundred 100-fold dilutions or a 10-400 dilution. As I like to mention whenever discussing homeopathy, there are only estimated to be around 1080 atoms in the known universe. So Pulsatilla 200C is basically water, and that’s what our intrepid homeopath is using in the case review I started with.
Circling back to that case review, I’m not an obstetrician (obviously), but it didn’t take me long to find evidence that the authors were also acting a bit precipitously. For instance, contrary to the view that in nulliparous women (women with no children) the fetal head is engaged 1-2 weeks before labor, one study suggested that in 75% of nulliparous women the head was not engaged until labor and that there was no statistical difference between the unengaged-head group and the engaged-head group was determined for incidence of vaginal delivery, cesarean section for cephalopelvic disproportion, midforceps delivery, mean and low Apgar scores, and birth weight. It’s also been noted that, even in some primigravida mothers, the head doesn’t engage until labor starts, and that this is within the range of normal.
So basically, a young primigravida woman presented to them three days after her estimated due date (for which an error range of ±two weeks was cited), her baby’s head not having engaged. They gave her three doses of pulsatilla, and she went into labor a day later. Who can argue with that? I can. It’s almost certainly coincidence, given that, even if pulsatilla had any effect at all inducing labor, what they gave her was diluted to nonexistence. Also, there is actually a Cochrane Review on homeopathy for the induction for labor. Its results are negative, although, just like nearly all Cochrane reviews, it describes the data as there being “insufficient evidence to recommend the use of homoeopathy as a method of induction” and that “rigorous evaluations of individualised homeopathic therapies for induction of labour are needed.” No, they are not. That’s because, even if the herbal and plant-based remedies used as the starting solution for dilution had medicinal value for the condition being treated, homeopathic dilutions like pulsatilla 200C cannot work because there is no active drug in them.
None of this, of course, stops homeopaths from providing laundry lists of homeopathic remedies to assist with labor and delivery, be it the ubiquitous Arnica montana for “soft tissue damage (perineum or abdomen) following birth or caesarian section” (though it seems to be good for everything!) or Cocculus for “tremendous tiredness because of breastfeeding and the nights of broken sleep.” One site notes that “200C often works well during and after labor.” Again, 200C is the most watery of homeopathic remedies. Well, not quite. There do exist dilutions beyond 200C, as incredible as that sounds.
Science-based medicine versus homeopathy in France
While on Twitter, I saw something about “fake médicine”:
started to launch lawsuit against them, one by one. My skeptic fellows @Ascl_Pios , @ContactPrimum and @p_gral0 are among those 124. I think this story is sufficiently crazy to be echoed oversea… 2/2
— La Théière Cosmique (@Plasmodioum) April 11, 2018
Yes, this story is from France. It reminded me of another story I discussed from France a while ago, in which Nobel Laureate turned antivaccine and pro-homeopathy crank Luc Montagnier made an appearance in which he tried to argue that vaccines could cause sudden infant death syndrome. This time around, it’s more about homeopathy. Unfortunately, like the story about Montagnier, there is very little in the way of English language reporting on this story. That always makes me leery of taking on a story, because I fear that I’ll miss something important and get the story wrong. On the other hand, I have a great antipathy towards quacks who try to silence critics with legal thuggery, as my posting history makes plain. Also, even after 30 years I can still read and speak French well enough to get the gist of most articles I read without using Google Translate. So I decided to dive in and see if I could figure out what’s going on.
It didn’t take me long to come across at least one interesting Tweet:
"Si ça continue à être bénéfique, sans être nocif, ça continuera à être remboursé"➡ @agnesbuzyn ministre des Solidarités et de la Santé#BourdinDirect #Santé #homeopathie pic.twitter.com/OsfsmbG5yP
— RMC (@RMCinfo) April 12, 2018
This is Agnès Buzyn, ministre des Solidarités et de la Santé (Minister of Solidarity and Health), stating support for homeopathy, specifically, “If it continues to be beneficial, without being harmful, it will continue to be reimbursed.” This is a pretty damned irresponsible thing for any minister of health in any country to say. Twitter was not pleased:
pic.twitter.com/xPSMG93iJn
— DocZombie (@Zombi_Doctor) April 12, 2018
But what is this all about? It didn’t take me long to find a website called fake médicin, which contains a statement by 124 French doctors condemning alternative medicine and homeopathy in particular and calling on the French government to stop funding homeopathy and other alternative medicines. There’s an English version there too, but the statement is still worth citing fairly extensively. The doctors behind this statement begins by invoking the Hippocratic Oath as one of the oldest known ethical commitment that “requires a physician to provide the best possible care to his patients, in the most honest way,” noting that these two obligations “require a physician to continually seek to improve his or her (medical) knowledge and to inform his patients about what he can reasonably offer, as well as what treatments are unnecessary or contra-indicated.” It also cites French law:
…they forbid charlatanism and deception, impose the prescription and distribution of treatments for which the efficacy was established. They also proscribe the use of obscure remedies or remedies which do not clearly list the substances that they contain.
You can see where this is going with respect to homeopathy. The statement goes on to point out that the French General Medical Council is responsible for ensuring that its members “do not use their credentials to promote practices for which science was unable to demonstrate their usefulness or practices which can even be dangerous” and “do not become sales representatives of unscrupulous industries.” Here’s where the hammer falls, when the statement points out that the General Medical Council still tolerates practices that “are at odds with its own code of ethics” and that “public bodies organise or even contribute to the financing of some of these practices.”
Before I get to the meat of the statement, I was wondering just who was behind the fake médicine website. The site’s authors describe themselves as:
We are a group of health professionals with a wide variety of specialties and methods of practice. Our common viewpoint is that medicine must adapt its practices to the facts and seek to disseminate these facts by popularizing via Youtube videos, blogs, or through social networks.
We are not an association, we are perfectly apolitical and we are not driven by a conflict of interest, except perhaps the promotion of critical thinking.
In the era of “fake news”, fashionable term but serious issue, we have long noticed the activism of pseudo-medicines on the internet, trying to discredit our discipline to better sell theirs. We have also seen the damage that such speech can produce in the health field, such as anti-vaccine movements, or other conspiracy movements.
Yes, support for science-based medicine is important, and this group has it. The authors note:
The so-called “alternative” therapies are ineffective beyond any placebo effect and can even prove to be dangerous.
    • They can be dangerous because they treat irrelevant symptoms and over-medicalise populations, giving the illusion that any situation can be solved with a “treatment”.
    • They can be dangerous because they fuel and rely on a fundamental distrust of conventional medicine as shown by the unjustified polemics surrounding vaccines.
    • Finally, They can be dangerous because their use delays the diagnoses and necessary treatments, sometimes leading to dramatic consequences, especially in the treatment of serious diseases such as cancers.
I couldn’t have said it better. It’s also noted that support for pseudomedicines (i.e., quackery) is also a waste of money that taxpayer euros should not be spent on. Indeed, in France, homeopathic products can be reimbursed at a rate of 30% (but up to 90% in the Alsace-Moselle region) and benefit from a preferential status that exempts their manufacturers (like Boiron, a French multibillion dollar company) from having to demonstrate their efficacy.
So here’s what fake médicine calls for:
We urge the French General Medical Council and the French public authorities to make every effort to:
    • No longer allow physicians or healthcare professionals to continue to promote these practices using their professional credentials.
    • No longer recognise in any way homeopathy, mesotherapy or acupuncture diplomas as medical university degrees or qualifications.
    • Ensure that Medical Schools or institutes which deliver health trainings, may no longer issue diplomas covering medical practices for which the efficacy was not scientifically demonstrated.
    • No longer reimburse health care, medicines or treatments from disciplines which refuse to subject themselves to a rigorous scientific assessment.
    • Encourage initiatives aimed at delivering information on the nature of alternative therapies, their deleterious effects, and their real efficacy.
    • Require all caregivers to abide to the deontology of their profession, by refusing to deliver useless or ineffective treatments, by offering care in accordance with the recommendations of learned societies and the most recent scientific evidence and by demonstrating pedagogy and honesty towards their patients and offering an empathic listening.
Each and every one of these demands is something that I can get behind totally. Some of them are even applicable to the US.
So far, as of my writing this, there are 1,929 signatories:
of which 822 are in medicine, 111 are in care, 99 are in pharmacy, 75 are in physiotherapy, 229 are in education or research, 253 are in engineering or computer science, 7 are in dental, 5 are in midwifery, and 329 in many other fields who feel concerned.
The complete list of signatories is here.
It also didn’t take me long to find out that there’s a hashtag created by these same French physicians, #fakemed. The activity on this hashtag has not gone unnoticed:
Eye opening reading all these #FakeMed tweets how big homeopathy is in France. It sounds like they're worse than in the UK. Although we're not that great here either… pic.twitter.com/w3Db5SbXUQ
— Medlife Crisis (Rohin) (@MedCrisis) April 12, 2018
More importantly:
Et il advint qu'en l'absence de toute argumentation scientifique, des "représentants" de l'homéopathie tentèrent d'instrumentaliser le code de déontologie pour faire taire les critiques #Confraternité15CH #EBM30CH#fakemed https://t.co/i5lRNGpmRO
— Christian Lehmann (@LehmannDrC) April 11, 2018
And:
Espérant semer la panique dans les rangs des signataires et les amener à se désolidariser en menaçant d'en attaquer deux au hasard tous les quinze jours en l'absence d'excuses abjectes #PointGodwin15CH #EffetStreisand30CH pic.twitter.com/BMw8czdlNg
— Christian Lehmann (@LehmannDrC) April 11, 2018
And:
"A day may come when the courage of men fails, when we forsake our friends and break all bonds of fellowship,but it is not this day." #FakemedEt donc, en résumé, pathétiques dinosaures, nous disons: pic.twitter.com/poIWm82YzJ
— Christian Lehmann (@LehmannDrC) April 11, 2018
And:
C'est qu'ils sèment la PANIQUE, le CHAOS. Tu comprends. À rejouer l'hérésie d'Horus, faut bien qu'ils se prennent la #fakemed inquisition.
— Agrume ☤ (@Kinagrume) April 11, 2018
Just click on the Tweets and hit the “translate” button if you don’t know enough French to figure out what is being said.
And:
C'est qu'ils sèment la PANIQUE, le CHAOS. Tu comprends. À rejouer l'hérésie d'Horus, faut bien qu'ils se prennent la #fakemed inquisition.
— Agrume ☤ (@Kinagrume) April 11, 2018
It turns out that the statement caused a major kerfuffle in France, as alluded to in the first Tweet I cited above. I looked for an English language story about the dustup, but basically failed to find a good one. I did, however, find a story in the French version of Slate, Fake médecines, vraies questions de société, or Fake medicines, real issues for society. Here’s what’s been happening.
On March 18, the fake médicine text was published in a column in Figaro. Addressed to the National Council of the College of Physician, the initiative and statement were spearheaded by doctors who are active on YouTube and other social media, François, author of the Youtube channel Primum non nocere and Jérémy Descoux, of Asclepios. The reaction was swift and nasty (translation a combination of Google Translate and myself changing the wording when I can to make it less clunky English):
The next day, reactions were quick. On March 19, Jérémy Descoux was invited on the set of LCI to defend the terms used in his statement. Its opponents unanimously condemned the approach: The benefits of popular medicines would be misunderstood; the practices of these by medical doctors would protect against the risks of abuse; and we should not risk undermining the flourishing French homeopathy industry. On March 20, it was the turn of science journalist Mathieu Vidard, host of the radio show La tête au carré, to express in an editorial his disagreement with the terms of the platform: according to him, this one would continue the chimeric ideal of a purely rational medicine.
Those of you who pay attention to these things will recognize the sorts of logical fallacies, bad arguments, and misinformation used by Vidard. First, Vidard accused the doctors of “arrogance”:
Riding the theme of fake news, our doctors disguised as white geese drape themselves in the arrogance of their scientific respectability to knock – I quote – these false therapies with illusory efficacy.
Then there was the predictable appeal to popularity:
If this statement was not frankly insulting to practitioners as well as to the 40% of French people who use alternative medicine, we would have fun arguments of these fathers of morality.
I like to respond to this by saying that the fact that one third of Americans believe in ghosts doesn’t mean that ghosts are real. The same is true of homeopathy. That 40% of the French public has used homeopathy doesn’t mean homeopathy works.
There was an invocation of the “magic” of placebos (with a dash of tu quoque):
…no serious study has proven so far any effectiveness of [homeopathy]. The scientific content of alternative medicines is empty. Nothing but the placebo effect. So what?
Can all the allopaths boast of being able to treat each disease rationally? No, of course not.
So is not it possible to admit that there is sometimes a part of magic to cure?
At least he admits there’s no science behind homeopathy and alternative medicine.
Next up, the appeal to “holism” and the “human touch”:
In the conclusion of their statement, the 124 demand that all caregivers respect ethics and that they offer to their patients a benevolent ear. How dare we! It is precisely because of dehumanized conventional medicine that patients who are tired of being considered as mere limbs turn to practitioners who can spend time with them and listen to them.
As I like to say, if the problem in modern medicine is insufficient empathy and not enough time to give the patients a “benevolent ear,” the solution is not to farm that function out to quacks. It is to train doctors to do better and change the financial incentives in the system to value face-to-face time with patient far more than our current reimbursement system does. Hilariously, right after this passage, Vidard claims that attacking the “humanistic function” of homeopaths and doctors using alternative medicine, the 124 risk driving patients into the arms of real quacks. Yes, I’ve lost track of how many fallacy-filled articles like Vidard’s I’ve deconstructed over the years, just in English.
Helpfully, Beatrice Kammerer, the author of the Slate.fr article, lists the fallacies used by defenders of homeopathy and gives several examples. Here are the fallacies:
     1.  “Medicine is not only rational.” My response: True, but that does not mean medicine should embrace the irrational and pseudoscientific.
     2.  “Scientific medicine is cold and dehumanized.” See my response above.
     3.  “The doctor’s role is not to tell me what to believe in.” My response: No one says that it is, but a doctor’s role is to recommend therapies and treatments with scientific evidence supporting their efficacy and safety. Homeopathy fails on that account.
     4.  “If doctors are forbidden to prescribe homeopathy, people will rush to charlatans!” See my response above.
     5.  “Just because science does not understand how unconventional medicines work does not mean that they are ineffective.” My response: This is putting the cart before the horse. Show compelling evidence of efficacy, then we’ll talk. Many of these medicines are claimed to work through impossible mechanisms and homeopathy is an excellent example of this. For homeopathy to work, several well-established laws of physics and chemistry would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong.
     6.  “Homeopathy may not cure, but it is good for many people.” My answer: The only people homeopathy is good for are homeopaths, the stockholders of Boiron, and the owners of companies manufacturing homeopathic remedies.
Of course, homeopaths being homeopaths, the entirely predictable result of a serious threat to homeopathy has resulted in complaints to the College of Physicians about some of the doctors behind the fake médicine site:
Certains des médecins signataires d'une tribune contre les médecines alternatives sont visés par des plaintes à l'Ordre des médecins. #FakeMed pic.twitter.com/19dn2Caejr
— Nawak (@NawakNawak) April 13, 2018
Here’s a story in Le Monde telling the tale:
Tension hasn’t decreased among doctors after the publication of a statement signed by more than 120 health professionals, March 19 in Le Figaro, against homeopathy and other alternative medicines. Following this statement, the newspaper confirmed on Thursday, April 12, that trade unions of homeopathic doctors, mesotherapists or accupuncturists have filed a complaint with the council of the order of the profession against 10 of 124 signatories – five doctors who expressed themselves in the media after the publication of the statement, and five others who signed it.
The statement criticized in particular “practices neither scientific nor ethical, but very irrational and dangerous” and spoke of “fake medicine” (“false medicine”). The signatories asked the Council of the Order, “not to allow doctors or health professionals who continue to promote [these practices] to use their title”.
The unions criticized these remarks as “offensive, defamatory and even insulting” and “contrary to the ethical principles of confraternity, and professionalism”, reports Le Figaro. They demand a “public apology.”
When a complaint is lodged with the Medical Association, the first step is an attempt at conciliation. If the mediation fails, “we will then draw lots of doctors from the list of [the signatories] every fortnight for new complaints,” warns Dr. Meyer Sabbah, the source of the complaint.
This is, of course, typical thuggery that homeopaths engage in. It reminds me of the time that Andy Lewis, a.k.a. Le Canard Noir, who ten years ago endured similar threats after he wrote a brilliant article, “The Gentle Art of Homeopathic Killing,” which showed that such claims actually violate homeopaths’ own code of ethics, resulted in a legal threat from the Society of Homeopaths. I’ve also documented similar types of legal thuggery from quacks directed at other skeptics speaking out. Many have been victims, ranging from Paul Offit to Brian Deer to Ben Goldacre to Simon Singh to Rhys Morgan to Steve Novella, all of whom have had legal threats directed at them or been sued outright. The most recent example is a naturopath quack (but I repeat myself) who is suing ex-naturopath and current skeptic and scientist Britt Hermes. This is what homeopaths and other quacks do when criticized. Add to this the likelihood that the statement by the 124 French doctors threatened a huge French company (Boiron), business considerations and national pride probably amplified the usual thuggish reaction.
It is to the credit of the 124 French doctors who spoke out about The One Quackery To Rule Them All. Their statement needs to be publicized far and wide, not just during Homeopathy Awareness Week, but going forward. Homeopaths like to portray themselves as a persecuted minority, but in France (and elsewhere), homeopathy is big business.

   Clinical Trials

Homeopathy and Pre-Registered Trials
Preregistering clinical trials is a great idea, but we have to actually track registration.
Steven Novella on May 18, 2022
Link

One way to summarize the core philosophy of science-based medicine (SBM) is that we favor raising both the ceiling and the floor on the quality of scientific evidence used to inform our healthcare decision making. Mainstream medicine endeavors to be scientific, but that has always been an aspirational goal. Doing rigorous science is hard, and applying it to something as complex and varied as medicine is even harder. There are countless pitfalls, many explored here at SBM. While we are trying to increase the overall quality of science in medicine, we pay particular attention to the low end of the spectrum, where the abused and errors are more flagrant. There are also those who are attacking the scientific basis for medicine in principle, and we feel it is especially important to take on such attacks vigorously.
In many ways the challenges to SBM has been increasing, standards have weakened, and regulations watered down. Ironically it seems that while the ceiling of high quality has been constantly and incrementally rising, the floor has fallen out beneath us. We obsess over nuances like where to set the P-value and the effects of citation bias, while at the bottom, rank magic and pseudoscience is gaining a foothold. Today I am going to write about both ends of the spectrum at once, highlighting what has arguably been one of the best trends in scientific medicine in the last two decades – preregistering clinical trials.
This idea was first floated in 1986, but gained steam around the turn of the millennium. The first US federal law requiring trial registration was in 1997, the Food and Drug Administration Modernization Act of 1997 (FDAMA). This act included a provision requiring clinical drug trials approved under the investigational new drug application to register their trials with the government. In 2000 the NIH created the clinicaltrials.gov website, providing a place for companies to register their trials. Since then the benefits of pre-registration have become increasingly clear.
Prior to preregistration, most scientific studies were conducted essentially in secret. Only the people directly involved in the research or its funding were likely to be aware of it. This meant that there was not way to ensure that the study was conducted as originally planned, or that the results would ever be published. Pharmaceutical companies, for example, could theoretically conduct five studies looking at the efficacy of their drug, and only publish the two that showed a positive effect while sweeping the other three under the rug. They even argued that they owned the data of the trials that they funded and conducted, so they could do with it what they wanted. They could even hide studies by conducting them overseas. This was the initial impetus for registering trials.
But this is just a slice of a systemic problem within science, called publication bias or the file-drawer effect. Studies that show more positive effects are more likely to ever be published, are published earlier, and are cited more often. If we perform a systematic review of published studies, therefore, we are seeing a biased sample, which distorts the answer. Publication bias alone can make a worthless treatment seem effective.
A more subtle problem with clinical trials is P-hacking, which we have discussed previously on SBM. In brief, P-hacking may occur whenever the details of how a study is conducted and the data analyzed are determined after results are seen. This creates the potential, whether conscious or not, of tweaking the methods in order to produce statistically significant results. It’s actually not hard to do – let’s just collect another 20 samples and then reanalyze the data. Deciding when to stop collecting data, which outcome measures or comparisons to use, and which statistical analysis to use can all alter the significance of the outcome. Preregistering trials prevents P-hacking, because you have to spell out the exact methods that will be used. At least, if the researchers change the methods mid-stream, it will be obvious.
Preregistering clinical trials is therefore an extremely effective method of improving the quality of scientific data. However, in order to fully realize the benefits of registration we need to completely close the loop – we need to include in any systematic review an analysis of which studies were preregistered and if any alterations were made post registration. A recent study looking at homeopathy trials illustrates this.
Homeopathy, for any readers who may be unaware, is 100% pure pseudoscience. Homeopathic potions are essentially magic water, in which fanciful substances are diluted out of existence in the hopes that their “essence” will remain. As medicine, they are worthless, and a century of research shows this to be true. Because there is so much research into homeopathy, however, this does create a useful opportunity for SBM. We can ask – what does the medical literature look like when it involves an intervention that we know for certain (as much certainty as we can have in science) has no effect? The homeopathic literature gives us a detailed answer, and now we have one more example to add to the list.
A 2022 BMJ study looked at homeopathy clinical trials with respect to their registration status. They found:
Since 2002, almost 38% of registered homeopathy trials have remained unpublished, and 50% of published randomised controlled trials (RCTs) have not been registered. Retrospective registration was more common than prospective registration. Furthermore, 25% of primary outcomes were altered or changed compared with the registry. Although we could detect a statistically significant trend toward an increase of registrations of homeopathy trials (p=0.001), almost 30% of RCTs published during the past 5 years had not been registered.
More than a third of registered trials were never published, and half of published trials were never registered. Further, most registered trials were not preregistered, but only after the fact. Finally, in 25% of the registered trials significant changes were made to the methods after registration. Essentially, the homeopaths are doing it wrong, undermining the entire point of preregistering trials. But, the fact that some trials are registered does give us the opportunity to explore the effect of registration:
A meta-analysis stratified by registration status of RCTs revealed substantially larger treatment effects of unregistered RCTs (SMD: −0.53, 95% CI −0.87 to −0.20) than registered RCTs (SMD: −0.14, 95% CI −0.35 to 0.07).
As predicted – unregistered trials show a larger effect, likely because of publication bias and P-hacking. The effect would likely be even more dramatic if only preregistered (not post-registered) trials were included, and only those that did not change their methods from what was registered. What does all this mean?
Again, it is consistent with the fact that homeopathy is worthless and its potions ineffective. More importantly this has implications for all clinical research. It is perfectly reasonable for medical journals to require preregistration for any study they publish. Further, no systematic review should be considered complete if it does not consider the registration status of each study it examines. Registration does not mean anything if we don’t use the data – closing the loop. If this becomes not only standard but universal, then we will realize the full benefits of an idea first proposed 36 years ago.

   Homeopathy – Failing Randomized Controlled Trials Since 1835
Joseph Albietz
Link
I’m sad to say that this is the last day of World Homeopathy Awareness Week. We’ve tried to give homeopathy its due honor, providing it the attention its practitioners clearly desire, while continuing to cover pertinent news in the world of homeopathy and providing a somewhat more sober, rational discussion of it on our homeopathy reference page.
Of course, most of this has not been news in the literal sense of the word. There hasn’t been anything truly new in homeopathy since its invention (no, not discovery; discovery implies that something actually exists to be found) by Hahnemann in 1796.
Well, perhaps that’s not quite fair. As our knowledge of reality (medicine, pharmacology, chemistry, physics, etc) has steadily improved, homeopathy’s plausibility has dwindled to the point of being indistinguishable from the roundest of numbers (0). And I suppose the recent contortions of logic, abuses of legitimate science, and pure magical thinking put forth to protect homeopathy from the relentless assault of science are far more impressive than that laid out by Hahnemann. So that’s news of a sort.
There’s also homeopathy’s long and rich tradition of abject failure in randomized controlled trials to consider. The overwhelming mountain of evidence showing homeopathy to have no effect beyond placebo is impressive and definitive. That’s data Hahnemann didn’t have, so that’s news too.
Each of these properly conducted studies and analyses demonstrates the scientific method’s utility to help us understand reality and protect us from our own delusions, but frankly, at this point they are about as exciting and useful as proving that the sun will rise in the east tomorrow morning. News? Not so much.
Nuremberg’s Less Famous Trial
I found myself wondering how far back this trail of negative trials goes; how long we’ve been having the identical argument. Pubmed’s earliest mention of homeopathy was in 1906, and the first RCT I found in its database was in 1980. However, the oldest double-blind RCT of which I found record was conducted in 1835 in Nuremberg, Bavaria, and subsequently described in an editorial in 2006 entitled “Inventing the randomized double-blind trial: The Nuremberg salt test of 1835.” Though the trial has its flaws, it was of sufficient quality to satisfy my historical curiosity with a thoroughly depressing answer: 175 years.
The local physicians and public health officials of Nuremberg held an understandably dim view of homeopathy, and as it gained popularity in Nuremburg they became more vocal, and more public, in their opposition:
Von Hoven accused homeopathy of lacking any scientific foundation. He suggested that homeopathic drugs were not real medicines at all and alleged homeopathic cures were either due to dietetic regimens and the healing powers of nature, or showed the power of belief. He called for an objective, comparative assessment by impartial experts. If, as he expected, homeopathic treatment proved ineffective, the government would need to take drastic measures to protect the lives of deceived patients.”
Sounds familiar, doesn’t it? Nuremburg’s resident homeopath Karl Prue’s defense should as well:
[Prue] pointed out that even children, lunatics and animals had been successfully cured. Based on Hahnemann’s assertions, he challenged Wahrhold/von Hoven to try the effects of a C30 dilution of salt on himself. The odds were 10 to 1, he claimed, that his opponent would experience some extraordinary sensations as a result – and these were nothing compared to the much stronger effects on the sick.”
Eventually a trial was designed and agreed upon by both parties to test the effect of a 30C dilution of salt. The trial design was surprisingly good, as it was:
    • Randomized: participants had an equal chance of being in either the control or experimental group
    • Controlled: participants not given the experimental therapy were given an indistinguishable and inert placebo
    • Blinded: participants didn’t know if they received the homeopathic dilution or placebo
    • Double-blinded: the experimenters didn’t know which participants received the homeopathic dilution or placebo, as the placebo and homeopathic dilution were prepared and the vials containing them randomized and coded by people independent from the experimenters.
    • Well Powered: the trial contained enough participants so that if, as Prue claimed “the odds were 10 to 1… to experience some extraordinary sensations” that it could detect a difference between the two groups.
    • Transparent: The design, hypothesis, methods and outcomes were agreed upon beforehand and explained in detail to all participants, conducted publicly (in a literal Pub in fact; these people were full of good ideas), results were published quickly, and any deviation from protocol was acknowledged.
Of the 54 people they managed to enroll, 50 completed the study three weeks later by reporting what, if any, “extraordinary sensations” they had experienced following ingestion of their vial. 5 people reported sensations in the homeopathic group, 3 in the control, which was statistically insignificant. Homeopathy had failed the first of many RCTs.
I am not putting this trial forward as the final (though perhaps it could be considered one of the first) nail in homeopathy’s coffin. The trial design had areas of potential bias, most notably that the symptoms which qualified as “extraordinary” are not well defined (though a glance at the homeopathic proving of “Natrum Muriaticum” or “table salt” provides some insight into this particular problem), and the fact that it relied upon participants to honestly report all symptoms; a hostile or imperceptive set of participants could easily confound the study. Nevertheless, on the whole it was solidly designed and executed, particularly when one considers that this is one of the first double-blind, randomized controlled trials ever documented.
Time To Move On
Here we are in 2010, 175 years after the first of legion negative RCTs of homeopathy, yet it persists with the same tired old arguments. Is there anything to gain from investing more time, money, resources, and ignoring the highly dubious ethics of subjecting human subjects to a trial that has no hope of benefiting them or humanity, just to prove one more time that homeopathy is an utter failure? No, and here’s why.
I look at the current debate surrounding homeopathy, and I see three primary groups. The first accepts the last two centuries of scientific progress and evidence and concludes that homeopathy is a delusion unworthy of further study. They don’t need another trial.
The second believes in homeopathy in spite of the gargantuan volume of evidence; further evidence will do nothing to change their minds. They don’t need another trial.
The final group is comprised of people who are unaware of the nature of homeopathy or the evidence that already exists. This final group requires exposure and education; they require World Homeopathy Awareness Week (SBM edition). They don’t need another trial

Another Review Finds Homeopathy Worthless
Australia has published a report on the evidence supporting homeopathy – and concluded rightly that there is no convincing evidence. It joins a number of other nations that have conducted similar reviews, and reached the same conclusion. Homeopathy is not effective, not medicine, and not worthwhile.
Steven Novella on March 11, 2015
Link

It is long past time to close the door on homeopathy. After thousands of studies, homeopaths are still unable to produce convincing evidence that homeopathy works for any indication. Multiple reviews of the evidence have come to this conclusion, and now we have one more to add to the pile – the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) just published their report after reviewing the clinical evidence and have concluded that homeopathy doesn’t work for anything.
Homeopathy is a prescientific medical philosophy based upon the fanciful notions that like cures like (which is really an expression of sympathetic magic) and that extreme dilutions of a substance can retain the magical essence of the substance. These ideas were silly two centuries ago when they were invented. The scientific advances we have made since them have only deepened this conclusion. Homeopathy should have been tossed onto the scrap heap of history along with phrenology, humoral theory, mesmerism, and other quaint ideas. Its persistence is testimony to the power of cultural inertia.
Despite the fact that homeopathic potions have essentially zero scientific plausibility (as close to zero as we can get in science), a great deal of resources have been wasted testing homeopathy clinically. The recent NHMRC review identified more than 1,800 studies, of which 225 were of sufficient size and rigor to include in the review. They report:
The review found no good quality, well-designed studies with enough participants to support the idea that homeopathy works better than a placebo, or causes health improvements equal to those of another treatment.
Although some studies did report that homeopathy was effective, the quality of those studies was assessed as being small and/or of poor quality. These studies had either too few participants, poor design, poor conduct and or [sic] reporting to allow reliable conclusions to be drawn on the effectiveness of homeopathy.
According to CEO Professor Warwick Anderson, “All medical treatments and interventions should be underpinned by reliable evidence. NHMRC’s review shows that there is no good quality evidence to support the claim that homeopathy works better than a placebo.”
In 2013 the NHMRC published a review (that link will automatically download a PDF of the 2013 report) of the clinical evidence for homeopathy, and they broke this down by medical condition. Of the 68 medical conditions they examined, for 7 of them there was no quality evidence from which to draw any conclusions. For 61 of the conditions there was evidence for lack of efficacy – not just a lack of evidence showing that homeopathy works, but evidence showing that homeopathy does not work. 
The NHMRC was not the first to review the evidence or come to this conclusion. In 2010 the UK House of Commons Science and Technology Committee published their own report, concluding:
In our view, the systematic reviews and meta-analyses conclusively demonstrate that homeopathic products perform no better than placebos. The Government shares our interpretation of the evidence. We asked the Minister, Mike O’Brien, whether the Government had any credible evidence that homeopathy works beyond the placebo effect and he responded: “the straight answer is no”.
In 2010 Edzard Ernst published a systematic review of systematic reviews of homeopathy and concluded:
The findings of currently available Cochrane reviews of studies of homeopathy do not show that homeopathic medicines have effects beyond placebo.
The Swiss also reviewed the evidence for homeopathy and came to a somewhat different conclusion. Their report requires some explanation, however. The review board was packed with homeopaths and conflicts of interest, and their review was obviously biased. However, it should be noted that they, in fact, also concluded that the clinical evidence does not demonstrate that homeopathy works. They therefore had to argue for a change in the rules of evidence. Shaw, who critically reviewed the report, concluded:
This paper analyses the report and concludes that it is scientifically, logically and ethically flawed. Specifically, it contains no new evidence and misinterprets studies previously exposed as weak; creates a new standard of evidence designed to make homeopathy appear effective; and attempts to discredit randomised controlled trials as the gold standard of evidence. Most importantly, almost all the authors have conflicts of interest, despite their claim that none exist. If anything, the report proves that homeopaths are willing to distort evidence in order to support their beliefs, and its authors appear to have breached Swiss Academies of Arts and Sciences principles governing scientific integrity.
This pattern is now clear – gold standard clinical evidence shows that homeopathy does not work. Homeopaths do not respond by either producing high quality evidence of efficacy or by changing their views to account for the evidence. Rather, they whine about the game being rigged against them and try to change the rules of evidence, so that weak studies that are almost guaranteed to be false positive are used, or studies that are not even designed to test efficacy.
The response to this latest systematic review has been true to form. Australian Homoeopathic Association spokeswoman Ana Lamaro has already condemned the report as biased. She says:
We’re applying the prism of [a] very, very narrow, restricted format of research that applies well to situations where you’re testing one drug against one pathological state…Homeopathy is a holistic form, meaning we are taking into account the psychosocial, the physical, the emotional state of the person in assessing what they might need medicinally.
This is nothing but special pleading. If homeopathic potions worked, then placebo-controlled trials should demonstrate it. Homeopaths have also had plenty of opportunity to conduct trials in which treatments are individualized, but still have not been able to come up with evidence that homeopathy works. After 200 years and hundreds of studies, homeopaths have not been able to demonstrate that any of the fundamental principles of homeopathy are true, or that homeopathic treatments have any effects beyond placebo. How much more time and resources do they want to suck out of our civilization before it’s enough?
Let’s also examine Lamaro’s statement a bit more. She is referring to the fact that the philosophy of homeopathy doesn’t really even recognize diseases, or standard knowledge about biology and pathophysiology. It is not based upon our modern understanding of how the body works and the nature of specific diseases. It is based upon a prescientific philosophy that is nonsensical to its core. Illness, according to homeopathic philosophy, has to do with the personality type of the patient. Do they cry when they hear classical music?
Here is a homeopathic questionnaire, containing such medically relevant questions as the shape of your face, the shape of your stool, and your personality disposition. This is tooth fairy science – it gives the impression of being thorough, but there is no rationale or evidence to any of it. This, however, is supposed to inform which remedy gets diluted out of existence before you are given an expensive sugar pill. Just like no two astrological readings are the same, no two homeopathic consultations are the same – there is no established standard, and the “experts” cannot agree with each other, because it is all subjective nonsense.
I also find it interesting that whenever clinical studies show that homeopathic potions are just expensive placebos, homeopaths immediately throw the homeopathic products industry under the bus. What Lamaro is saying is that homeopathic products do not work by themselves, they need to be part of a homeopathic consultation. She is therefore saying that every over-the-counter homeopathic product is fraudulent. I wonder what Boiron (the major homeopathic product producer) thinks about that.
Conclusion
Homeopathy cannot work. That is as reliable a scientific statement as any we can make. In other words, if homeopathy did work, we would have to rewrite major parts of basic science textbooks, including physics, chemistry, and biology.
When tested clinically, despite their utter lack of plausibility, homeopathic potions are shown to lack efficacy. So not only should they not work, they in fact don’t work.
Yet proponents of homeopathy would have the world believe that one man, Samuel Hahnemann, stumbled upon a fantastic secret two centuries ago (actually, multiple secrets) that defy scientific explanation, have been ignored by 200 years of scientific progress, and yet to this day would turn our scientific understanding of the world upside down. For some reason, however, believers just can’t seem to produce any convincing evidence for any of it, not even that homeopathic products have any properties at all, let alone clinical efficacy. After 200 years all they can produce are endless excuses and demands for more research.
For some reason we cannot summon the political will to do what reason demands (and what multiple systematic reviews by government bodies have recommended) and finally expel homeopathy from modern health care.
Still there are researchers, either because they are true believers or just naive, calling for yet more research into homeopathy, such as the proposed Toronto study of homeopathy for ADHD. The demand for more research will never end. The public, however, should no longer support this profound waste of resources.

A systematic review about nothing
Scott Gavura on June 30, 2016
Tweet
There is dubious content in PubMed that you won’t find unless you look for it, or stumble across it inadvertently. It’s the entire field of alternative medicine which is abstracted and complied along with the actual medical literature. In this world, the impossible is accepted as fact, and journal articles focus on the medical equivalent of counting angels on pinheads. I’ve been trying to avoid blogging about alternative medicine practices like homeopathy lately because the practice itself is a scientific dead end. There is no emerging evidence or interesting research to describe, because there is no science to build on. But research on homeopathy is interesting if one wants to understand how placebo effects can appear to be real. Importantly, research and clinical trials of homeopathy allow us to see the underlying (baseline) challenges, flaws, and biases in evaluating real medicine more clearly. Today I want to review a newly-published systematic review of, adverse effects attributed to homeopathy. The casual reader might not see the multiple problems with this type of research. But once you understand the basis of homeopathy, the conclusion that one can draw is quite different from that of the author’s. And if inert sugar pills can appear to have medicinal effects, and even adverse effects, then we can better adjust for these biases when we’re studying actual medicine. 
Homeopathy: the voodoo doll of medicine
Among all the forms of alternative medicine, homeopathy is the most implausible of them all. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like is simply sympathetic magic, a pre-scientific belief that was first described by anthropologist Sir James George Frazer in his 1890 book, The Golden Bough. In the book, Fraser outlines the two components of sympathetic magic:
If we analyse the principles of thought on which magic is based, they will probably be found to resolve themselves into two: first, that like produces like, or that an effect resembles its cause; and, second, that things which have once been in contact with each other continue to act on each other at a distance after the physical contact has been severed. The former principle may be called the Law of Similarity, the latter the Law of Contact or Contagion.
I’ve discussed the “Law of Contagion” before, which underlies our current preoccupations with pseudoscientific ideas such as “detox” and “eating clean“. Sympathetic magic is the entire basis for the homeopathic belief system:
    • Like-cures-like: a substance that causes a symptom is diluted to treat that same symptom. Any substance is thought to be an effective remedy if it’s diluted enough: cancer, boar testicles, crude oil, oxygen, skim milk, even vacuum cleaner dust or moonlight. Deciding which substances will cure which symptoms is determined by a process called a “proving” which is equally without any scientific basis. (Here are homeopathic provings for the Berlin Wall remedy and also sunlight reflected off the planet Saturn, to give you an example of the science underlying this practice.)
    • Water has a memory: the more you dilute the substance, the more powerful its effect, even when there mathematically won’t be one molecule remaining. And when I say dilute, I mean dilute. The 30C “potency” is common – that’s a dilution of 10-60. You would have to give two billion doses of homeopathy per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original material. The result is that most homeopathic remedies are completely inert. Whether bottled as a liquid or dripped onto lactose tablets, they are a pure placebo.
The growth of homeopathy: Dilutions of grandeur
Samuel Hahnemann invented the practice of homeopathy in the early 1800s. Hahnemann attempted to position homeopathy as a separate and more effective form of medicine compared to conventional medical practices. Given homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, homeopathy probably was safer than medical practice at the time, which was still based around the idea of the four humors. Eventually, germ theory emerged, ideas of humors disappeared, as did the elements of vitalism and magic, and medicine slowly turned towards a scientific model based on objective observations. Alternative medicine practices like homeopathy have never progressed or evolved from their vitalistic roots. And how could they? They are not based on a scientific standard, so actual scientific evidence has no bearing on the belief in its efficacy.
Despite the implausibility of homeopathy, it has enjoyed modest popularity since its invention, with a resurgence in the past few decades as an “alternative” medicine system that is marketed and “gentle” and “more holistic” that evil Big Pharma with its harsh chemicals. It goes without saying that if homeopathy works in the way envisioned by Hahnemann and homeopaths, than the rest of medicine cannot. And that’s exactly what the evidence shows. Rigorous clinical trials confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. While there are plenty of clinical trials that show homeopathy is associated with positive clinical effects, they are always small, poorly controlled, and often biased. The two most comprehensive reviews of the evidence are the 2010 Evidence Check from the United Kingdom’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee and the 2014 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council review, the latter of which made the following conclusion:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness. People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner and should keep taking any prescribed treatments. The National Health and Medical Research Council expects that the Australian public will be offered treatments and therapies based on the best available evidence.
Adverse effects from sugar pills?
Accepting that sugar pills have no medicinal effects, you might understandably be curious how there could possibly be adverse effects from homeopathy. But homeopathy can harm in different ways:
    • Through insufficient dilution of the base substance. The “homeopathic” cold remedy Zicam was found to cause permanent loss of smell because it contained zinc and was insufficiently diluted to reduce the toxic effects when applied directly on nasal passages. It wasn’t “homeopathic” at all.
    • Through accidental contamination or deliberate adulteration introduced in the manufacturing process. Homeopathic “alternatives” to antibiotics have been recalled because they contained, yep, antibiotics. Even low-level exposure to antibiotics can cause allergic reactions in people with anaphylactic allergies. Sloppy manufacturing practices have been identified with other manufacturers of homeopathic remedies, raising questions about the quality and safety of these products.
    • Finally, homeopathy can indirectly harm through the substitution of homeopathy for more effective treatment. One need only recall the tragedy of the Calgary, Alberta child who died of strep throat because his mother chose homeopathy over medicine. Or the death of infant Gloria Thomas in Australia who died of eczema (eczema!), simply because her parents refused medication, and relied on homeopathy. Her father, a homeopath, and her mother, were eventually convicted of manslaughter.
It’s the last category where most of harms occur from homeopathy. Edzard Ernst, discussing his systematic review of the risks of homeopathy, noted:
So, how can a therapy that usually relies on nothing more than placebos cause harm? Many of the patients that experienced harm did so because the use of homeopathy meant that effective treatments were given too late or not at all. In our book TRICK OR TREATMENT, we describe the case of a homeopath who collaborated with my research team while conducting a clinical trial of homeopathy; before the trial had been completed, she died of cancer simply because she self-treated it with homeopathy and thus lost valuable time for proper therapy which might have saved her life. I have said it often and I say it again: if used as an alternative to an effective cure, even the most “harmless” treatment can become life-threatening.In other cases, adverse effects can occur when remedies are not highly diluted. Most but not all homeopathic remedies are devoid of active molecules. Homeopaths prescribe treatments like arsenic and other highly poisonous substances; if such a remedy is not administered in a much diluted form, it can easily kill whoever is unfortunate enough to take it.
How sugar pills can appear to help (or harm)
Homeopathy can also appear to cause harms which are not due to the remedy itself. Homeopaths have noted that patients may do worse before they appear to improve after starting homeopathic remedies. This is termed an “aggravation” and homeopaths assure us it is normal. From one homeopath’s website:
An aggravation is the temporary appearance of new symptoms, or a temporary intensification of existing symptoms, following a dose of a homeopathic remedy. Aggravations are harmless, usually mild, and short-lived. They sometimes occur following the first dose of a remedy as part of the initial rebalancing effect, or when the remedy has been taken more often than needed, or if the person is unusually sensitive to that particular remedy.
But there is a much simpler and obvious explanation for the homeopathic aggravation. Consider an example of someone that wants something to help with mild but chronic pain, like osteoarthritis. In the diagram below I’ve illustrated how someone might report pain on a visual analog score over time. You can see that there’s always some pain, but its intensity changes day-to-day.
Imagine the patient has a surge of pain at t1 and then decided to take a homeopathic remedy. Suddenly the pain appears have been alleviated. This might be attributed to the homeopathy. But what if the patient had waited until t2 to start the homeopathy? There were two pain episodes in the period that follows, though not as bad as the period around t1. This might be described as a “homeopathic aggravation,” as the symptoms appeared to worsen. What the patient doesn’t know is if the homeopathic remedy had any effect at all on the natural fluctuation in the pain. The only way to understand if homeopathy has an effect would be to compare it to placebo in a randomized controlled trial.There’s also the potential for any intervention to induce nocebo effects, where a substance with no biological effect appears to cause unpleasant symptoms. Commonly observed in randomized controlled trials with real drugs, their existence means that the side effects of the actual drug are considered to be those unwanted effects that do not also appear in the placebo arm. Yet it can be remarkable how many adverse effects (some of which may be felt to be serious) might be observed in the placebo arm.
What do we know about homeopathy? We know enough
With all this background in mind, let’s now look at the paper, entitled “Adverse effects of homeopathy, what do we know? A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.” Its author is Trine Stub, and the paper is published in the CAM journal Complementary Therapies in Medicine. The objective of the paper was to investigate how adverse effects and aggravations from homeopathy were reported in the literature, to classify the reports according to commonly-accepted criteria, and finally, to compare the risks for patients compared to controls.
1,129 RCTs were initially identified. After screening and filtering, 41 RCTs with 6,055 patients were included. Of the 41 trials, only 68% reported adverse effects. More than two third of these events were classified as “minor” and one third as moderate or severe/significant. Adverse effects were physician- or patient-reported and in 3 trials, causality was discussed. Five RCTs specifically reported “aggravations”. As per the paper:
Homeopathic aggravations were reported as worsening of the patients’ symptoms, such as exacerbation of allergy, asthma, eczema, headache and hot flushes.
In terms of frequency of adverse effects and aggravations, the following was noted:
    • Homeopathy versus overall control: An overall comparison was made between homeopathy and control. Thirty-nine trials (5,902 participants) made this comparison and no significant difference was found between homeopathy and control (426/2,947 versus 264/2,955), with OR 0.99, 95% CI 0.86 to 1.14
    • Homeopathy versus placebo: A comparison was made between homeopathy and placebo. Thirty-one trials (4,836 participants) made this comparison and no significant difference was found between homeopathy and placebo.
    • Homeopathy versus conventional medicine: There was no significant difference between homeopathy and conventional medicine in a meta-analysis of five trials (43/355 versus 71/401), with OR 0.82, 95% CI 0.56 to 0.1.21.
Conclusion: Placebo versus placebo?
The authors of the systematic review conclude:
Adverse effects including the concept of homeopathic aggravations are commonly reported in trials. The meta-analysis demonstrated that the proportion of patients experiencing adverse effects to be similar for patients randomized to homeopathic treatment compared to patients randomized to placebo and conventional medicine.
The explanation they offer has a much more obvious answer. Sugar pills are going to be associated with adverse events because of the natural history of any condition, and the tendency to given credit for improvement to (or blame for negative effects on) the treatment chosen. The review’s findings are exactly what we would expect if we were giving patients sugar pills. There is no such thing as a “homeopathic aggravation” any more than homeopathy can induce a real adverse effect. This systematic review confirms that homeopathy holds the dubious position as the air guitar of medicine.

Another Damning Homeopathy Report
Steven Novella on April 9, 2014
Link
What will it take? That is the lingering question, one that has significant implications for the legitimacy and effectiveness of our professional and regulatory institutions.
Homeopathy is 100% pure nonsense. It is one of the so-called “alternative” medical systems that has absolutely no basis in reality. It is magic-based medicine. It is based on two-centuries-old pre-scientific ideas, bad guesses that turned out to be wrong.
The notion behind homeopathy is that illness is caused by a problem with the essence or life energy. Based on the idea of “like cures like” the homeopath must find a substance that is the match for the totality of symptoms, including personality traits and superficial details like eye color, and then give a magic potion which is created by diluting the matched substance out of existence – but the essence remains.
Homeopathy has no basis in medicine, physiology, chemistry, or even physics. It is one of the few claims about which I am willing to say, it cannot possibly work.
Unsurprisingly, when homeopathic products are tested in rigorous clinical trials, they don’t work. A review of systematic reviews of homeopathy concluded:
The findings of currently available Cochrane reviews of studies of homeopathy do not show that homeopathic medicines have effects beyond placebo.
The simple fact is that even after two centuries, and a renewed interest in research in the last few decades, homeopathy has not been demonstrated to work for any indication.
The only possible rational response to this state of affairs is to conclude that homeopathy is worthless and should be completely abandoned, relegated to the history of pseudoscience. Culture, belief and institutions, however, have inertia, and much like Sauron, even after scientific defeat, homeopathy was allowed to endure.
The worthlessness of homeopathy is not just my opinion or that of SBM. There have been exhaustive reviews of homeopathy that came to the same or similar conclusion. The best was the UK’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee report: Evidence Check 2: Homeopathy. After an extensive investigation, and allowing homeopaths to make their best case, the committee concluded that homeopathy could not work, does not work, and should be completely abandoned.
There was also a later Swiss report that came to a different conclusion, that there is some evidence homeopathy works. The Swiss report, however, was a reaction to a previous Swiss decision against homeopathy. The committee was packed with homeopaths, and not surprisingly they put a positive spin on the review.
If you analyze the review you find that actually they came to the same conclusion about the data – that high quality studies show that homeopathy does not work. Then, however, they pulled a trick. As I previously reported:
The Swiss study looked at the same data, but apparently wanted to come to a favorable conclusion. So they argued for a change in the normal rules of evidence, a common strategy among CAM proponents. They decided to rely more on “real-world effectiveness,” which is just CAM newspeak for “poorly controlled studies.” In the real world we cannot control for variables and blind subjects – those are artificial conditions of rigorous trials.
The Swiss report was rigged and biased, and yet they still could not conclude that the data shows homeopathy works. They had to pull the “placebo medicine” gambit and claim that it sort of “works” even though there is no real effect from homeopathic products. Only homeopaths were apparently fooled by this ploy.
Australian Government National Health and Medical Research Council
Now we have a new report, this one from Australia: Effectiveness of Homeopathy for Clinical Conditions: Evaluation of the Evidence. They concluded:
There is a paucity of good-quality studies of sufficient size that examine the effectiveness of homeopathy as a treatment for any clinical condition in humans. The available evidence is not compelling and fails to demonstrate that homeopathy is an effective treatment for any of the reported clinical conditions in humans.
In other words – homeopathy does not work. They also concluded that much of the homeopathy literature of very poor quality. The good quality studies, however, showed no effect. This is a 301-page exhaustive review, which came to the same conclusion as all other scientific reviews (adjusting for editorial spin).
They looked at 57 systematic reviews involving 68 conditions. For seven of those conditions there were simply no quality studies. For the other 61 there was evidence of lack of efficacy.
Conclusion
Homeopathy is based on magical thinking. It does not have even the barest toe-hold in science or reality. In spite of this it has been extensively researched for its clinical effects. While most of this research is of poor quality, there is some reasonably high-quality research, which consistently shows that homeopathy does not work.
The extremely low prior probability combined with the negative clinical evidence is devastating to homeopathy. There is simply no rational justification for further investment in this pre-scientific and disproved notion. We do not need further research. No government should fund homeopathy, pay for homeopathic treatments, fund research, or even approve homeopathy in any official capacity. This means that homeopaths should not be licensed, and homeopathic products should not be approved.
And yet homeopathy still enjoys the support of most governments. This is largely based on a misunderstanding among the general public as to what homeopathy is, combined with lobbying by homeopaths and supporters of unscientific medicine.
Science clearly needs a stronger lobby.

   Fun with homeopaths and meta-analyses of homeopathy trials
David Gorski
Link
Homeopathy amuses me.
Well, actually it both amuses me and appalls me. The amusement comes from just how utterly ridiculous the concepts behind homeopathy are. Think about it. It is nothing but pure magical thinking. Indeed, at the very core of homeopathy is a concept that can only be considered to be magic. In homeopathy, the main principles are that “like heals like” and that dilution increases potency. Thus, in homeopathy, to cure an illness, you pick something that causes symptoms similar to those of that illness and then dilute it from 20C to 30C, where each “C” represents a 1:100 dilution. Given that such levels of dilution exceed Avagaddro’s number by many orders of magnitude, even if any sort of active medicine was used, there is no active ingredient left after a series of homeopathic dilutions. Indeed, this was known as far back as the mid-1800′s. Of course, this doesn’t stop homeopaths, who argue that water somehow retains the “essence” of whatever homeopathic remedy it has been in contact with, and that’s how homeopathy “works.” Add to that the mystical need to “succuss” (vigorously shake) the homeopathic remedy at each dilution (I’ve been told by homeopaths, with all seriousness, that if each dilution isn’t properly succussed then the homeopathic remedy will not attain its potency), and it’s magic all the way down, just as creationism has been described as “turtles all the way down.” Even more amusing are the contortions of science and logic that are used by otherwise intelligent people to make arguments for homeopathy. For example, just read some of Lionel Milgrom‘s inappropriate invocations of quantum theory at the macroscopic level for some of the most amazing woo you’ve ever seen, or Rustum Roy‘s claims for the “memory of water.” Indeed, if you want to find out just how scientifically bankrupt everything about homepathy is, my co-blogger Dr. Kimball Atwood started his tenure on Science-Based Medicine with a five part series on homeopathy.
At the same time, homeopathy appalls me. There are many reasons for this, not the least of which is how anyone claiming to have a rational or scientific viewpoint can fall so far as to twist science brutally to justify magic. Worse, homepaths and physicians sucked into belief into the sorcery that his homeopathy are driven by their belief to carry out unethical clinical trials in Third World countries, even on children. Meanwhile, time, resources, and precious cash are wasted chasing after pixie dust by our own government through the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM). So while I laugh at the antics of homeopaths going on and on about the “memory of water” or quantum gyroscopic models” in order to justify homeopathy as anything more than an elaborate placebo, I’m crying a little inside as I watch.
The Lancet, meta-analysis, and homeopathy
If there’s one thing that homepaths hate–I mean really, really, really hate–it’s a meta-analysis of high quality homeopathy trials published by Professor Matthias Egger in the Department of Social and Preventative Medicine at the University of Berne in Switzerland, entitled Are the clinical effects of homoeopathy placebo effects? Comparative study of placebo-controlled trials of homoeopathy and allopathy.
What Shang et al did in this study was very simple and very obvious. They applied the methods of meta-analysis to trials of homeopathy and allopathy. (I really hate that they used the term “allopathy” to distinguish scientific medicine from homeopathy, although I can understand why they might have chosen to do that for simple convenience’s sake. Still, it grates.) In any case, they did a comprehensive literature search for placebo-controlled trials of homeopathy and then randomly selected trials of allopathy matched for disorder and therapeutic outcome. Criteria used for both were controlled trials with a randomized parallel design and a placebo control with sufficient data presented in the published report to allow the calculation of an odds ratio. These studies were assessed for quality using measures of internal validity, including: randomization, blinding or masking, and data analysis by intention to treat or other. Standard measures of how good the randomization and blinding techniques used in each study are. To boil down the results, the lower the quality of the trial and the smaller the numbers, the more likely a trial of homeopathy was to report an odds ratio less than one (the lower the number the more “positive”–i.e., therapeutic–the effect). The higher the quality of the study and the greater the number of subjects, the closer to 1.0 its odds ratio tended to be. The same was true for trials of allopathy as well, not surprisingly. However, analysis of the highest quality trials showed a range of odds ratios with a 95% confidence interval that overlapped 1.0, which means that there was no statistically significant difference between them and 1.0; i.e., there was not detectable effect. For the very highest quality trials of allopathy, however, there was still an odds ratio less than 1.0 whose confidence level did not include 1.0. The authors concluded:
We acknowledge that to prove a negative is impossible, but we have shown that the effects seen in placebocontrolled trials of homoeopathy are compatible with the placebo hypothesis. By contrast, with identical methods, we found that the benefits of conventional medicine are unlikely to be explained by unspecific effects.
The problems with meta-analysis notwithstanding, as an exercise in literature analysis, Shang et al was a beautiful demonstration that whatever effects due to homeopathy “detected” in clinical trials are nonspecific and not detectably different from placebo effects, exactly as one would anticipate based on the basic science showing that homeopathy cannot work unless huge swaths of our current understanding of physics and chemistry are seriously in error. After all, homeopathic dilutions greater than 12C or so are indistinguishable from water. It’s thus not surprising that homeopaths have been attacking Shang et al beginning the moment it was first published. Indeed, they’ve attacked Dr. Egger as biased and even tried to twist the results to claiming that homepathy research is higher quality than allopathy research. Shang et al may not be perfect, but it’s pretty compelling evidence strongly suggesting that homeopathy is no better than placebo, and the interpretation that, just because more of homeopathy studies identified in the study were of higher quality does not mean that homeopathic research is in general of higher quality than scientific medical research.
Shang et al “blown out of the water”?
Recently, a certain well-known homeopath who’s appeared not only on this blog to defend homeopathy but on numerous blogs has reappeared. His name is Dana Ullman, and he’s recently reappeared on this blog to comment in a post that is several months old and happens to be about homeopathy trials in Third World countries. Indeed, I sometimes think that periodically Mr. Ullman gets bored and decides to start doing blog searches on homeopathy, the better to harass bloggers who criticize his favored form of pseudoscience. No doubt he will appear here as a result of this post, mainly because he’s lately been crowing about another study that he believes to show that Shang et al has been “blown out of the water,” as he puts it.
That’s actually a rather funny metaphor coming from a homeopath, given that homeopathy is nothing more than water. Suffice it to say that our poor overwrought Mr. Ullman is becoming a bit overheated, as is his wont. The guy could really use some propranolol to settle his heartrate down a bit. In any case, the study to which he refers, entitled The conclusions on the effectiveness of homeopathy highly depend on the set of analyzed trials and coming from a clearly pro-homeopathy source, Dr. Rutten of the Association of Dutch Homeopathic Physicians, it’s hot off the presses (the electronic presses, that is, given that this is an E-pub ahead of print) in the October issue of the Journal of Clinical Epidemiology. Suffice it to say that, as always, Mr. Ullman is reading far more into the study than it, in fact, actually says.
The first thing that anyone who’s ever read or done a meta-analysis will already know is that the title of this study by Lüdtke and Rutten is about as close to a “Well, duh!” title as there is. Of course, the conclusions of a meta-analysis depend on the choice of trials used for the analyzed set. That’s exactly the reason why the criteria for choosing trials to include in a meta-analysis are so important and need to be stringently decided upon prospectively, before the study is done. If they aren’t, then investigators can cherry pick studies as they see fit.. That’s also exactly why the critieria need to be designed to include the highest quality studies possible. In fact, I’d be shocked if a reanalysis of a meta-analysis didn’t conclude that the results are influenced by the choice of studies. That being said, the results of Lüdtke and Rutten do not in any way invalidate Shang et al.
One thing that’s very clear reading Lüdtke and Rutten is that this study was clearly done to try to refute or invalidate Shang et al. It’s so obvious. Indeed, no one reanalyzes the data from a study unless they think the original conclusions from it were wrong. No one. There’s no motivation otherwise. Otherwise, why bother to go through all the work necessary? Indeed, Lüdtke and Rutten show this right from the beginning:
Shang’s analysis has been criticized to be prone to selection bias, especially when the set of 21 high quality trials was reduced to those eight trials with large patient numbers. In a letter to the Lancet, Fisher et al. posed the question: ‘‘to what extend the meta-analysis results depend on how the threshold for ‘large’ studies was defined [3]. The present article addresses this question. We aim to investigate how Shang’s results would have changed if other thresholds had been applied. Moreover, we extend our analyses to other meaningful subsets of the 21 high quality trials to investigate other sources of heterogeneity, an approach that is generally recommended to be a valuable tool for meta-analyses.
Again, this is a “Well, duh!” observation, but it’s interesting to see what Lüdtke and Rutten did with their analysis, because it more or less reinforces Shang et al‘s conclusions, even though Lüdtke and Rutten try very hard not to admit it. What Lüdtke and Rutten did was to take the 21 high quality homeopathy studies analyzed by Shang et al. First off, they took the odds ratios from the studies and did a funnel plot of odds ratio versus standard error, which is, of course, dependent on trial size. The funnel plot showed an assymetry, which was mainly due to three trials, two of which showed high treatment effects and one of which was more consistent with placebo effect. In any case, however, for the eight highest quality trials, no assymetry was found.
What will likely be harped on by homeopaths is that for all 21 of the “high quality” homeopathy trials, the pooled odds ratio from random effect meta-analysis was 0.76 (confidence interval 0.59-0.99. p=0.039). This is completely underwhelming, of course. Even if real, it would likely represent a clinically irrelevant result. What makes me think it’s not clinically relevant is what Lüdtke and Rutten do next. Specifically, they start with the two largest high quality studies of homeopathy and then serially add studies, from those with the highest numbers of patients to those with the lowest. At each stage they calculated the pooled odds ratio. At two studies, the odds ratio remained at very close to 1.0. After 14 trials, the odds ratio became and remained “significantly” less than 1.0 (except when 17 studies were added). The graph:
However, when the authors used meta-regression, a different form of analysis, it didn’t matter how many studies were included. The confidence interval always spanned 1.0, meaning a result indistinguishable statistically from an odds ratio of 1.0:
In other words, if a random effect meta-analysis is used, one can torture marginally significant odds ratios out of the data; if a meta-regression is used, one can’t even manage that! In other words, this study actually shows tht it doesn’t really matter too much which high quality studies are involved, other than that adding lower quality studies to higher quality studies starts to skew the results to seemingly positive values.
Exactly as one who knows anything about meta-analysis would predict.
The amazing thing about Lüdtke and Rutten’s study, though, is just how much handwaving is involved to try to make this result sound like a near-refutation of Shang et al. For example, they start their discussion out thusly:
In our study, we performed a large number of meta-analyses and meta-regressions in 21 high quality trials comparing homeopathic medicines with placebo. In general, the overall ORs did not vary substantially according to which subset was analyzed, but P-values did.
That is, in essence, what was found, and the entire discussion is nothing more than an attempt to handwave, obfuscate, and try to convince readers that there is some problem with Shang et al that render its conclusions much less convincing than they in fact are. Indeed, I fear very much for them. They’ll get carpal tunnel syndrome with all that handwaving. We’re talking cherry picking subset analysis until they can find a subset that shows an “effect.” More amusingly, though, even after doing all of that, this is the best they can come up with:
Our results do neither prove that homeopathic medicines are superior to placebo nor do they prove the opposite. This, of course, was never our intention, this article was only about how the overall resultsdand the conclusions drawn from themdchange depending on which subset of homeopathic trials is analyzed. As heterogeneity between trials makes the results of a meta-analysis less reliable, it occurs that Shang’s conclusions are not so definite as they have been reported and discussed.
I find this particularly amusing, given that Shang et al bent over backwards not to oversell their results or to make more of them than they show. For example, this is what they said about their results:
We emphasise that our study, and the trials we examined, exclusively addressed the narrow question of whether homoeopathic remedies have specific effects. Context effects can influence the effects of interventions, and the relationship between patient and carer might be an important pathway mediating such effects.28,29 Practitioners of homoeopathy can form powerful alliances with their patients, because patients and carers commonly share strong beliefs about the treatment’s effectiveness, and other cultural beliefs, which might be both empowering and restorative.30 For some people, therefore, homoeopathy could be another tool that complements conventional medicine, whereas others might see it as purposeful and antiscientific deception of patients, which has no place in modern health care. Clearly, rather than doing further placebo-controlled trials of homoeopathy, future research efforts should focus on the nature of context effects and on the place of homoeopathy in health-care systems.
This is nothing more than a long way of saying that homeopathy is a placebo. However, all the qualifications, discussions of “alliances with patients, and reference to cultural beliefs represent an excellent way to say that homeopathy is a placebo nicely rather than in the combative way that I (not to mention Dr. Atwood) like to affect. One thing I can say for sure, though, is that whatever it is that Lüdtke and Rutten conclude in their study (and, quite frankly, as I read their paper I couldn’t help but think at many points that it’s not always entirely clear just what the heck they are trying to show), it is not that Shang et al is invalid, nor is it evidence that homeopathy works.
Indeed, the very title is misleading in that what the study really does is nothing more than to reinforce the results of Shang et al, looking at them in a different way. Indeed, the whole conclusion of Lüdtke and Rutten seems to be that Shang et al isn’t as hot as everyone thinks, except that they exaggerate how hot everyone thought Shang et al was in order to make that point. That’s about all they could do, after all, as they were about as successful at shooting down Shang et al through reanalysis of the original data as DeSoto and Hitlan were when they “reanalyzed” the dataset used by Ip et al to show no correlation between the presence of autism and elevated hair and blood mercury levels and then got in a bit of a blog fight over it. Again, whenever one investigator “reanalyzes” the dataset of another investigator, they virtually always have an axe to grind. That doesn’t mean it isn’t worthwhile for them to do such reanalyses or that they won’t find serious deficiencies from time to time, but you should always remember that the investigators doing the reanalysis wouldn’t bother to do it if they didn’t disagree with the conclusions and weren’t looking for chinks in the armor to blast open so that they can prove the study’s conclusions wrong. In this, Lüdtke and Rutten failed.
The inadvertent usefulness of homeopathy trials to science-based medicine
Viewing the big picture, I suppose I can say that there is one useful function that trials of homeopathy serve, and that is to illuminate the deficiencies of evidence-based medicine and how our clinical trial system works. Again, the reason is that homeopathy is nothing more than water and thus an entirely inert placebo treatment. Consequently, any positive effects reported for or any positive correlations attributed to homeopathy must be the result of chance, bias, or fraud. Personally, I’m an optimist and as such tend to believe that fraud is uncommon, which leaves chance or bias. Given the known publication bias in which positive studies are more likely to be published and, if published, more likely to be published in better journals, I feel quite safe in attributing the vast majority of “positive” homeopathy trials either to bias or random chance. After all, under the best circumstances, at least 5% of even the best designed clinical trials of a placebo like homeopathy will be seemingly “positive” by random chance alone. But it’s worse than that Dr. John Ioannidis’ groundbreaking research tells us is that the number of false positive trials is considerably higher than 5%. Indeed, lower the prior probability that a trial will show a positive result, the greater the odds of a false positive trial become. That’s the real significance of Ioannidis’ work. Indeed, a commenter on Hawk/Handsaw put described very well how homeopathy studies illuminate the weaknesses of clinical trial design, only not in the way that homeopaths tell us:
…I see all the homeopathy trials as making up a kind of “model organism” for studying the way science and scientific publishing works. Given that homeopathic remedies are known to be completely inert, any positive conclusions or even suggestions of positive conclusions that homeopathy researchers come up with must be either chance findings, mistakes, or fraud.
So homeopathy lets us look at how a community of researchers can generate a body of published papers and even meta-analyze and re-meta-analyze them in great detail, in the absence of any actual phenomenon at all. It’s a bit like growing bacteria in a petri dish in which you know there is nothing but agar.
The rather sad conclusion I’ve come to is that it’s very easy for intelligent, thoughtful scientists to see signals in random noise. I fear that an awful lot of published work in sensible fields of medicine and biology is probably just that as well. Homeopathy proves that it can happen. (the problem is that we don’t know what’s nonsense and what’s not within any given field.) It’s a warning to scientists everywhere.
Indeed it is, and it applies to meta-analysis just as much as any study, given that meta-analysis pools such stucies. It’s also one more reason why we here at Science-Based Medicine emphasize science rather than just evidence. Moreover, failure to take into account prior probability based on science is exactly what we find lacking in the current paradigm of evidence-based medicine. We do not just include trials of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) in this critique, either. However, trials of homeopathy are about as perfect an example as we can imagine to drive home just how easy it is to produce false positives in clinical trials when empiric evidence is valued more than the totality of scientific evidence. There may be other examples of CAM modalities that have specific effects above and beyond that of a placebo (herbal remedies for example, given that they are drugs). There may be. But to an incredibly high degree of certainty, homeopathy is not among them. Homeopathic remedies are, after all, nothing but water, and their efficacy only exists in the minds of homeopaths, who are, whether they realize it or not, masters of magical thinking, or users of homeopathy, who are experiencing the placebo effect first hand. Studies of homeopathy demonstrate why, in the evidence-based medicine paradigm, there will always be seemingly positive studies to which homeopaths can point, even though homeopathic remedies are water.
REFERENCES:
1. A SHANG, K HUWILERMUNTENER, L NARTEY, P JUNI, S DORIG, J STERNE, D PEWSNER, M EGGER (2005). Are the clinical effects of homoeopathy placebo effects? Comparative study of placebo-controlled trials of homoeopathy and allopathy The Lancet, 366 (9487), 726-732 DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(05)67177-2
2. R LUDTKE, A RUTTEN (2008). The conclusions on the effectiveness of homeopathy highly depend on the set of analyzed trials Journal of Clinical Epidemiology DOI: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2008.06.015

Homeopathy’s Recent Woes
Steven Novella on August 22, 2012
Link
Be careful what you wish for. In the last few decades purveyors of dubious medical treatments and products have been trying to go mainstream, and they have had some unfortunate success. They asked for serious scientific investigation into their claims – and they got it. They asked to be treated like real medicine (but not really, they only want the trappings of legitimacy, not the substance), and when they actually are treated with the standards similar to science-based medicine, they cry foul.
The response of the fake-medicine lobby is not to alter their claims to fit the evidence, or to carry out better studies, or to clean up their act when problems are brought to their attention – but to attack their critics.
Homeopathy is perhaps the best example of this behavior. Homeopathy’s biggest marketing advantage is that most people don’t know what it really is. They think it’s “natural” medicine or herbs. That is why, during homeopathy awareness week, I was happy enough to oblige. I want people to know exactly what homeopathy is – sugar pills. They are placebos on which the equivalent of a magical ritual has been cast. Active ingredients, which themselves are as fanciful as fairy dust, are diluted into non-existence.
Not surprisingly, when tested in well-designed double blind placebo controlled trials, homeopathic placebos are indistinguishable from regular placebos. Homeopathy, put simply, doesn’t work.
Edzard Ernst, until recently a professor of complementary medicine at Exeter University, published a systematic review of systematic reviews of homeopathic products. He honestly asked a very important question – Homeopathy: what does the “best” evidence tell us? The answer he found:
The findings of currently available Cochrane reviews of studies of homeopathy do not show that homeopathic medicines have effects beyond placebo.
He is not the only one to have looked at the evidence and come to this conclusion (remember – his review was of other reviews). For example, a recent systematic review of homeopathic treatments for dermatological conditions concluded:
Reviewed trials of homoeopathic treatments for cutaneous diseases were highly variable in methods and quality. We did not find sufficient evidence from these studies that homoeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single dermatological condition.
In fact, the evidence does not support the conclusion that homeopathy is effective for anything.
Ernst began his career in a homeopathic hospital and is highly familiar with the practice of homeopathy. He set out to see what the evidence for CAM modalities actually showed. For his trouble he has become a pariah of the CAM world, who have attacked him personally for simply reporting the evidence. It has recently come to light, in fact, that a consortium of German homeopathic companies have been paying a blogger to attack Ernst, and other critics of homeopathy.
Journalist Jens Lubbadeh published his findings in the German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung, but agreed to publish an English translation on the website Quackometer. He reports:
(Claus) Fritzsche himselfs openly admits the “sponsorship” of his CAM-Media.Watch-blog (www.cam-media-watch.de) by the manufacturers. In august 2011 he wrote for the sake of “transparency”: “The companies Deutsche Homöopathie-Union (DHU) [the biggest German pill manufacturer] and Biologische Heilmittel Heel (www.heel.de) support CAM Media.Watch financially”. Other sponsors include: Staufen Pharma (www.staufen-pharma.de), WALA Heilmittel (www.wala.de/english/), Weleda (www.weleda.com), Hevert (www.hevert.de/_#/). In total, Fritzsche receives 43.000 Euro annually from these six manufacturers of homeopathic products.
The irony in this is profound. Defenders of dubious medical claims are quick to accuse promoters of science-based medicine of being “pharma shills” (what David Gorksi calls the “pharma-shill gambit”). I am the target of this accusation on a regular basis. It seems that within the CAM community it is just assumed that any critics of pseudoscience in medicine are being paid off by “Big Pharma.” This is simply not true. SBM is not sponsored by any company and we have no ties to the pharmaceutical industry. The site is completely paid for by The New England Skeptical Society, which is a non-profit educational organization (meaning the bandwidth is covered by the NESS, authors and editors are unpaid volunteers). We are also sponsored by the James Randi Educational Foundation, also a non-profit educational organization which shares our views.
This is not to say that pharmaceutical companies are not guilty of shenanigans. There have been many high profile judgments and fines against pharmaceutical companies, and we are quick to criticize them for trying to distort science and the communication of science in their favor. As far as I know, however, they don’t directly pay journalists to attack their critics. These homeopathic companies, however, admit that they do pay a journalist who happens to viciously attack critics of homeopathy. Strangely, the usual internet CAM proponents have been silent on this issue.
Perhaps the proponents of homeopathy are getting desperate. Homeopathy is like a mushroom, it thrives in the dark. It is withering a bit in the light of the attention that it has drawn upon itself. In 2010 the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee (STC) released a report, Evidence Check 2: Homeopathy, in which they recommend that the NHS stop funding homeopathy. They concluded that homeopathy can’t work, doesn’t work, and is essentially witchcraft.
Homeopaths tried to counter with a Swiss report on homeopathy – trumped up by homeopaths – but that reports has been exposed as flawed and biased.
Now homeopathic products are coming under fire in the Eurozone. It seems that many homeopathic products are illegal – they are in violation of existing regulations because they are making unsupported claims. The Guardian reports:
Faced with an MHRA crackdown on unlicensed medicines, one of Britain’s leading manufacturers of homeopathic remedies has indicated it would be prepared to relabel its products ‘confectionery’ to circumvent regulation.
So they will start selling sugar pills as sugar, rather than medicine, as long as they can keep them on the market.
Homeopathic products have an easier time in the US, where they are automatically approved as drugs and regulated by the FDA. This is a scandal that needs to be reversed, but meanwhile the FDA still can regulate the quality of homeopathic manufacturing. The result is a bit surreal – the FDA ensuring that fairy dust is properly handled, but the results can still be illuminating. For example, when examining the manufacturing process at a large UK homeopathic manufacturer, A Nelson & Co., Ltd., they found a number of violations.
They discovered that glass was finding its way into the product. The company was not sufficiently clearing broken glass from the assembly line. They also found that their instruments were not being calibrated as sufficient intervals. These are generic quality assurances that have nothing to do with whether or not homeopathy actually works. It is important to keep glass shards out of pills, but it’s hard to think of anything less important than the calibration of a gas chromatograph in a homeopathic factory. That’s like saying the design problem with the Titanic was that the deck was not varnished properly.
More interesting is that the FDA inspectors found:
“b. The investigator also observed for Batch #36659 that one out of every six bottles did not receive the dose of active homeopathic drug solution due to the wobbling and vibration of the bottle assembly during filling of the active ingredient. The active ingredient was instead seen dripping down the outside of the vial assembly. Your firm lacked controls to ensure that the active ingredient is delivered to every bottle.”
One in six bottles didn’t get their dose of nothing, I mean “active ingredient.” Homeopaths did not seem to notice this manufacturing defect.
Conclusion
I may sound like a broken record, but it needs to be said often – homeopathy is pure pseudoscience. There is nothing in homeopathic products and they are completely ineffective as medicine. In my opinion the conclusion is ineluctable – homeopathy is a fraud being perpetrated on the public worldwide. Governments and regulatory agencies that are supposed to protect the public from medical fraud have failed to do so. Those, like Edzard Ernst, who are pointing out this blatant reality – that sugar pills are not effective medicine – are being attacked for their troubles.
All we want is what homeopathy proponents say they want, and honest look at the science and the evidence and letting that dictate practice and regulation. At the very least the public needs to have proper informed consent about what homeopathy is and what the best evidence shows.

   Homeocracy
Wallace Sampson
Link
Recent comments on homeopathy again resulted in references to the 1994 Pediatrics paper by Jacobs et al on use of homeopathic remedies for childhood diarrhrea. The authors of that paper concluded from their blinded study that homeopathic remedies, tailored to the individual infants and children, were effective in reducing the number of diarrhea stools and thus in shortening the illness. The paper has been widely referenced and reported to have proved homeopathy efficacy, and the critiques have been argued by homeopaths as irrelevant, as has been done by Mr. Ullman.
In this short series I want to recount my experience with the report, its predecessor, and its two major sequellae, as well as its effect on systematic reviews of homeopathy. I will begin with a description of the first two studies, concentrating on their methods. Then I will discuss the results of the 1994 Pediatrics report and the authors’ interpretation of the results. Then (I hope last) I will discuss the third paper which the authors claimed supported findings of the first two and the meta-analysis which combined data from all three. If you are imagining why this series interests me, and imagining the worst, you are probably right. The sequence will help to reveal how some of the information in “holistic” and “alternative” systems become published, and despite critiques and disproofs through a sort of systematic deconstructions, still develop wheels of their own and enter the fund of general knowledge seemingly forever. Or, at least for several decades, until a social belief switch is finally turned off.
These effects have in turn, political and economic effects, that are of more urgent concern now as promoters lobby to have sectarian methods covered under insurance and federal medical plans. Probably as important, is that these reports will illustrate a different way of looking at the literature of implausible propositions. To destroy the suspense and let you in on the idea, the idea goes something like this: We usually look at positive reports on quacky methods to find falsification or fatal errors or hidden or absent data that disprove the thesis. Those are satisfying when present. But there is an alternate route; disqualify or at least diminish the meaning of a study because of the way it was set up, carried out, and/or reported, and the way that the worthless outcome data were subsequently used (the garbage in side.) The garbage pile as it accumulates, results in higher degrees of unbelievably – as it lacks both authenticity and validity. The focus must then turn to the statistical methods and how they are used to (mis)interpret the pile of data.
What often happens here is that the authors apply statistics designed to analyze data that are collected from experiments that are carried out in uniform ways, with reliable methods and instruments, in order to distinguish or characterize plausible and measurable phenomena. When one measures imaginary phenomena, then the results do not tell anything about the phenomena, but about the experiments themselves – and the errors in the experimental and measuring system. That is where I’m going with this. My analysis will show that the data collected were so heterogeneous and random, and the measuring so subjective, that the results were meaningless (also garbage.)
The affair began with Jacobs’s report of a pilot study published in the British Homeopathic Journal in 1993 (1). I was unaware of this report until I read the next one in Pediatrics, 1994. (2). I, with co-author Bill London, a health educator with the Natl. Council against Health Fraud wrote a five page analysis of the second paper. That came about when a nursing educator in the Pharmacy dept. at the teaching hospital where I taught medical oncology caught me in a hallway and asked me to examine the report which concluded that homeopathy worked for childhood diarrhea. She and our head pharmacist knew of my interest in medical quackery,. She did not know how to explain the report to her students. So I bit on it.
It was more difficult than I thought, for several reasons. First, I was familiar with homeopathy, but not as familiar with its modern practice. I learned that homeopaths use a computerized system for selecting remedies. More problems came after those.
I contacted the editor and asked if he would consider publishing a critique, considering the potential impact – treatment of millions of children in underdeveloped nations, and the implausibility that homeopathy worked. The editor was prompt, replying yes, partly because – as we later learned – he felt his job was on the line for having accepted the Jacobs manuscript, so vigorous was the negative response from readers.
As for the trial setups, we assumed they were the same for all three trials, although the amount of details reported varied. We found unanticipated problems. The diagnoses – other than diarrhea – on which remedies were selected were criteria based on symptoms only. Here are sample criteria from the table. They were divided into those of “mind,” “general,” and “stool” (quality).
Mind: Great anxiety and restlessness, fearful,
Capricious; irritable; quarrelsome, nothing p[leases, striking out, moaning, frenzied…
Slow, lethargic, weakness of memory (in a 1-2 year old?)
Diarrhea after mental excitement. Fidgety and restless.
Irritable, indifferent, weeping.
Stools: Acrid, burning, excoriating, worse after midnight,
Green, slimy, offensive, chopped grass, … smelling like rotten eggs, …
Slimy, scanty, lienteric, bloody. Acrid, corrosive, frothy, yellow. Sour odor.
Profuse, frequent, gushing, painless, watery. Bloody with green mucus, offensive. Rectal
prolapse. Exhaustion after stool…
Worse at night, after milk, involuntary, sudden expulsion. Worse 5 AM (sic) Red ring around
anus. Offensive, acrid stools. Painless, sour; thin; watery. Odor of rotten eggs.
General: [only the first criterion for each collection of criteria for brevity)
Prostrate,
one cheek red, the other pale;
Chills/heat;
gagging/ retching;
Cold sweat face and feet
Each combination (of each category – first to fifth – of the above called for a different homeopathic remedy.
Not mentioned was how each criterion combination / remedy was determined. Apparently by prior “provings.” But “proving” have never been proved to our knowledge, by repeated trials – blinded or not. So already we are in deep trouble. The criteria overlap, are subjective and made by a second party – often a relative – in answer to specific questions. Each answer depends on memory for the prior 1-2 days, powers of observation, sense of small, frequency of diaper change, and so forth.
Thus we have:
     1.  A glut of information, all highly subjective and subject to multiplicity of error sources.
     2.  A data base not proved for validity or consistency.
     3.  Overlapping criteria (admitted by the authors).
The next problem is the selection of timing. The initial visits, had to have been after 2 days of illness, but there was no specification of at which point the questions were asked. Thus, the quality of the stools, the state of “mind“ and the general appearance could have been at any time after the inclusion period. Given the large variation in those qualities from hour to hour and day to day, the chosen remedy was based also on the time of the answer, a “snapshot in time” upon which the next few days’ remedies were chosen and given. One can imagine the wide descriptive differences obtained, yet all were treated as homogeneously obtained. Yet these data were treated with statistics as if those descriptions and remedies were tightly controlled.
The potency of all selected remedies was 30C…that is, 1X 10/\ -300. How come? We have not even begun to deal with the problem of the homeopathic dosage system yet. Don’t need it for this part of the discussion. In order to grasp the significance of what the homeopaths did in these clinical trials, I got the idea yesterday to analogize the problem in physics terms. With apologies to my physics profs and associates, I tried it this way (and please feel free to critique this as I have not run this by anyone else…instant peer review!)
I imagine a physics experiment done under similar conditions. Test the influence of variable doses of electricity on a series atomic particles – electrons, protons, whatever – with their energies and “spins” varying to hundreds of variations, with the “dose” of the electric field chosen from a previously set of criteria which had been tested only once or twice for effects on a different set of particles – the effects recorded and entered into a book (The Organon) and a modern computer data base. Then select a random “dose” or power, charge, etc., to be applied to each test particle at random times after the particle had traveled a minimum distance from its source. Then measure the effect on each particle at four defined times, record all of the values as a group at each time, then analyze them with a statistic. If a pattern shows up, would it mean anything?
I guess homeopaths are right in a sense when they claim that standard science cannot measure what homeopathy does. Nothing can. Especially as their computer cannot organize the data, laden with close to randomized bits.
Homeopaths are caught on the point of their own petard here. They claim to be able to select remedies based on previous proving as recorded in “The Organon” in its several iterations, and the information placed in a computer program based on that information. The information going in is in reality “disorganized” or “unorganized” to play on a few words, and no amount of excusing or rationalization can organize it.
Thus, the outcomes are nothing more than random bits of information, even if carefully measured. And therefore, any emerging patterns do not indicate efficacy or harm, but only normal variations of random patterns. They measure only the noise in the system.
Enough mental exercise for this time. Next I’ll look at the second paper’s outcome data and what the authors did with it, and move on to the third paper’s adventure in the journal system, then on to the meta-analysis.
REFERENCES:
Jacobs J, et al, Homeopathic treatment of childhood diarrhea. Brit Homeop J, 1993;82(2):83-86.
Jacobs J et al. Treatment of Acute Childhood Diarrhea with Homeopathic Medicine: A Randomized Clinical Trial in Nicaragua. Pediatrics, 1994;93(5):719-724.

   Homeocracy II
Wallace Sampson
Link
This is the second installment analysis of a three (and now 4) part series of articles on effects of homeopathy on childhood diarrhea. This second installment elaborates on our findings on data from the second clinical trial in Nicaragua. (1)
I should first explain the title. In order for homeopathy to operate as a base or operating system for medicine “for the 21st century,” the entire system of measurement and of course all physical laws would have to be changed. In analogous political terms, it would be similar to – but more massive a change than – changing a nation from a democracy to a completely different system such as a theocracy with completely different laws and behavior expectations. So…well, it was the best I could think up at the time.
Last time I recounted how the Jacobs ll trial setup was incoherent and unable to produce results that could prove efficacy – unless the differences between treatment and controls were quite large, greater than just barely significant. Most patients were treated differently from others, with multiple preparations (that were in reality the same: pill filler) at differing times during the illness, with each preparation selected according to symptoms that likely varied by the hour, and influenced by memory, well known to be faulty in medical studies.
In fact, given the lack of homogeneity in the trial diagnoses and treatments, outcomes should not have made sense at all. Now I must admit that the thought did not occur to us at the time we undertook the review, nor during the review. If it had, our job would have been easier and the paper shorter.
First, we saw that children with severe dehydration were hospitalized, placed in IV fluids, and not entered in the trial. Milder cases were continued on diet and given standard oral rehydration therapy. They were assessed by homeopathic interviews regarding stool quality, general condition, and emotional states, then randomized to treatment and control groups. The major outcome was stated to have been determined beforehand as the mean number of days to fewer then 3 unformed stools on two consecutive days.
We looked at tables and graphs and saw that the treatment-control differences seemed to be significant and consistent at all days measured.
The primary outcome was: treated, mean of 3.0 days, and for untreated, 3.8 days (P<.05). And, there was a difference at 24, 48, and 72 hours after starting treatment Four other diarrhea indicators showed P=.048, .036, .054, .037.
But the results were actually illustrations of the difference between statistical significance and clinical significance. At 72 hrs, the point of maximum difference (P<0.5,) the difference was between 3 stools per day and 2 per day. The differences on the other days were all less than 1 per day.
We looked further and found recording and computation errors in several tables. None alone seemed large enough to account for the statistical findings, but suggested that enough other errors might lie hidden in the record to account for the possibility.
The most significant finding was the result of culturing the stools. All subjects had stools cultured. Children in the homeopathy treatment group had half again as many positive stool cultures for bacterial pathogens as did the controls. This led us to the possibility that all or many of the children might have been given antibiotics, either through adulterated homeopathic preparations, or at some time outside of the researchers’ observations. A few such patients could have accounted for the difference.
The data were presented as the mean values without data points for all patients. In such presentation, there is a possibility that one or two outliers might have existed in either group or both to have resulted in the differing means. Without the raw data, we don’t know.
Then, as mentioned last time, the data were the results of heterogeneous entry data to which were applied statistics that assume data have some degree of homogeneity. Another problem casting doubt on the meaning of the outcome.
Added to all the irregularities and lack of clinical significance were the claims and language of the authors. The authors referred for authority of homeopathic validity to the discredited Benveniste study in Nature (1998.) That study, if it were valid and authentic, actually disproved the major thesis of homeopathy and showed the selection of dilutions to be arbitrary and effects unpredictable.(2)
The Jacobs paper authors inflated the significance of their findings with phrasing like: “Acute diarrhea is the leading cause of pediatric morbidity and mortality world-wide. In the developing world there are 1.3 billion episodes of diarrhea and 5 million deaths each years from this illness..” But a public health impact is not suggested by this study. Children with severe diarrhea – the ones likely to die – were not included, and sent to a hospital. There was nothing about homeopathy in children with severe diarrhea.
Then they stated, “ Acute childhood diarrhea [is] ideal for …homeopathic trial because …no standard allopathic [sic] treatment would have to be withheld and … the public health importance … is great.” But the trial used children with mild diarrhea. It is hard to imagine a great public health importance for a method that shortens by less than a day a self-limited illness that resolves spontaneously in four days.
We ended up with enough findings to conclude that the study was devised in a way as to render its results nul, to suspect its authors of hyping an idea, and with enough errors to suspect that even more lay hidden in the raw data.
Next time I will explore its sequel, a repeat of the study in… oh, yes, Nepal. Of course. And then on to the pinnacle of the quartet, the meta-analysis.
REFERENCES:
Jennifer Jacobs, Stephen S. Gloyd, James L. Gale, L. Margarita Jiménez, & Dean Crothers (1994). Treatment of Acute Childhood Diarrhea With Homeopathic Medicine: A Randomized Clinical Trial in Nicaragua Pediatrics, 93 (5), 719-725. PMID: 8165068
Sampson W. When not to believe the unbelievable. Skeptical Inquirer 1989;14:90-91.

   Homeocracy 3
Wallace Sampson
Link
The previous post of this series analyzed the results of the 1994 Pediatrics paper purporting to show a statistically significant effect of homeopathic preparations on acute childhood diarrhea in a population in Nicaragua. That clinical trial followed a pilot study that also had shown a small but statistically significant effect of homeopathic remedies.
A moment here for explanation as to why I am going through these old studies. Reports like the four or five in this series made headlines. They are also so well cloaked in manipulated data and overdrawn conclusions that press and even academicians accept their conclusions – and even overdraw more. This is still going on.
Over the past thirty years some of us informally and gradually developed semi-systematic ways of analyzing these increasingly scientific-appearing claims of sectarians (sCAMmers.) Errors, inconsistencies and falsifications we recognize now were not so obvious decades ago. SCAMmers developed imaginatively new methods as their fields progressed. We in the science-based or knowledge based medicine field have been trailing along, detecting their tricks and twists as they developed, and like street sweepers behind horses, picking up their excrement (metaphor to force attention.) Yesterday’s lucid post on the latest acupuncture study by Steve Novella exemplifies this expertise (no offense intended.)
In summary, what the previous posts recounted was our response to the first pediatrics article, pointing out the heterogeneity of the trial data and the misapplication of statistics, and the invalid treatment selection process.
This third clinical trial (Jacobs J, Jimenez , Malthouse S,
Chapman E, Masuk M, Jonas W. Homeopathic Treatment of Acute Childhood Diarrhea: Results from a Clinical Trial in Nepal. J Altern Compl Med,2000;6(2):131-139.) was claimed by the authors to have added verification to the first two. The Nepal trial had the same trial setup and subject assignment, the same treatment selection method, and same treatment schedule.
The trial was stated to be carried out months before publication of the second trial, as a replication, and to correct for certain odd findings in the second trial. One objection we raised to the second Nicaragua trial was that most of the difference found between the treatment and control groups might have been due to finding more stool exams testing positive for bacterial or protozoal pathogens in the homeopathic treatment group than in the placebo group. If a significant number of subjects had been treated extraneously with antibiotics (common in Latin America), that action could have been responsible for the difference in diarrhea resolution between the two groups.
In this third trial, all subjects’ stools were cultured at entry, and the infection/infestation rates were reported as nearly equal. In addition, “Infrared spectroscopic analysis of bottles chosen randomly from both groups showed no evidence of contamination of samples by inorganic or organic substances.” The number of bottles tested was not stated. But since the identified infection rate was equally distributed, presence of antibiotics would not likely have been significant.
But…there seemed to be a difference between the reported end points of the two studies. The Nepal study abstract stated two end points under results - at least the wording and the text graph presentation were not identical. In the abstract and the methods section, is found the following wording: 1) The mean number of stools per day over the entire 5-day treatment period was 3.2 for the treatment group and 4.5 for the placebo group (t = 2.30, df = 123, P =.023; and 2) A Kaplan Meyer survival analysis of the duration of diarrhea, which included data from all patient visits, showed an 18.4% greater probability that a child would be free of diarrhea by day 5 under homeopathic treatment (P =.036.)
In the methods section authors stated, ”The duration of diarrhea was predefined as the time until there were two consecutive days with fewer than three unformed stools, the same primary outcome measure as in our previous [Nicaragua] study. Re-examination of the Nicaragua study’s end point showed the same wording. However, in the Nepal study, because about ten percent of the subjects (five in each group) did not complete this study, an intention-to-treat analysis (Kaplan-Meyer) curve was constructed, showing the likelihood of the primary outcome at points in time (daily in this case.) Although a small difference was again obtained in this study, the data were treated differently and the end point was not really the same.
One easy way to see this difference – sorry I could not transfer the actual graphs from the PDF - is to state what was plotted on the coordinates. In both studies the abscissa was the number of days, (0-5). In the Nicaragua study the ordinate was mean number of unformed stools each day. In the Present Nepal study, the ordinate was the “Probability of Diarrhea.” These are not the same, although the graphs appear similar, the data were treated differently. In the Nicaragua study, the difference between arms could be seen to be clinically insignificant even though statistically significant because at maximum difference, the difference amounted to one unformed stool per day (3 vs.2., equal to one stool every 12 hrs opposed to one stool every 8 hrs. ) That difference would not have been enough to warrant adding homeopathy materials to the treatment of childhood diarrhea.
In this Nepal study, the homeopathy and placebo groups were equivalent for the first 3 days when diarrhea stools were most frequent. The curves broke at 4 and 5 days, at which the differences were about 20 percent (40 percent vs. 60 percent) different; the homeopathy group would have been 20 percent more likely to be free of diarrhea at the specified time. Not much difference – and late, when it counted least…that is, if the results were not due to chance or some extraneous factors.
In the previous Nicaragua study, authors listed three other secondary outcomes (days to 50% improvement, days to first formed stool, mean diarrhea index) that were not listed in the Nepal study. In the Nepal study, at least one other secondary end point was listed that was not listed in the Nicaragua study (mean number of stools per day over the entire 5-day period – 3.2 for the treatment group and 4.5 for the placebo group.) The different presentations made it difficult to compare the two studies.
In summary, although the results were found to have positive outcomes for the homeopathy treatment group in both studies, the primary end points were calculated and presented differently, and secondary end points of both studies were not the same.
Yet another problem did not require statistical expertise to see. Despite randomized assignment, there was a significant age, height, and weight difference between the two groups (P = .07, .03, .05, respectively.) The assignment procedure resulted in older, taller, and heavier subjects assigned to the homeopathy group than to the placebo group, and the difference was statistically significant. Age is significant because older, larger children recover from diarrhea more quickly than do infants and smaller children. The difference in assignment was described as inadvertent, and a regression analysis correction was applied.
The results were obscure to me but here is the point. If a random assignment could result in a significant imbalance for age (weight, height) and that difference is assigned to chance, then why is a similar statistically significant difference in treatment outcome due to the treatment, and not to chance? The size of the assignment difference was of a similar order of magnitude in both instances. Nevertheless, the authors claimed, as they had done in the Nicaragua studies, efficacy from administration of homeopathic preparations in childhood diarrhea.
As in the prior study, the difference may not have been from effectiveness of the remedy, but from the vagaries inherent in doing clinical trials on ineffective remedies with diagnoses and end points that are as subjective as objective. There was just too much noise in the system.
One can still find references to these studies as positive in homeopathy commentaries. Not only were the trial setups done in a way to invalidate any but quite large differences in study arms, but the results were claimed to be a public health benefit in severe diarrhea despite the fact that severe diarrhea subjects were excluded from the studies.
Another sour note. A few years before this publication, I reviewed a similar paper that claimed similar results but that reported a positive end point that was negative in the Nicaragua report, and that reported as negative the end point reported as positive in the Nicaragua report. In other words, the end points cancelled each other, yet the authors (same? different?) reported the results as confirming the Nicaragua trial. I cannot be sure this Nepal study is the same, but the paper was rejected by at least one major journal. This one with a different end point presentation showed up in a sectarian journal. Just wondering.
I see eyelids that are still open are drooping, so the analysis of the authors’ meta-analysis of the three studies will wait until next posting. That will likely be shorter, as there will be fewer points made. The fourth study, diarrhea in Honduras, was already adequately done by David Gorski.

   Homeocracy IV
Wallace Sampson 
Link
In the three prior posts of this series I tried to analyze some of the defects in the randomized clinical rials (RCTs) of homeopathic remedies for childhood diarrhea. The first entry showed that the first two RCTs’ (done in Nicaragua) methods could not produce a meaningful result because of the way the RCTs were set up (methods.) The second entry showed that the results obtained in the first two trials were meaningless clinically even if assumed to have resulted from more legitimate methods. The same applied to the third trial in Nepal, analyzed in the third entry.
This entry will suggest that the authors’ fourth paper (Jacobs J, Jonas WB, Jimenez-Perez M, Crothers D. Homeopathy for childhood diarrhea: combined results and metaanalysis from three randomized, controlled clinical trials. Pediat Inf Dis J, 2005;22:229-234.)- a meta-analysis (MA) of the data from the three RCTs resulted in conclusions equally as meaningless as those of the three trials.
The MA authors – several of the same workers from the three RCTs – begin by agreeing that the data from the RCTs, taken individually, were of borderline significance:
In our previous three studies, we evaluated the use of individualized homeopathic treatment of childhood diarrhea … The results of the two larger studies (n = 81, n = 116) were just at or near level of statistical significance. Because all three studies followed the same basic study design , […] we analyzed the combined data from these three studies to obtain greater statistical power. In addition we conducted a meta-analysis of effect-size difference […] to look for consistency of effects.
MAs and systematic reviews (SRs) are the two consensus methods for summarizing data from multiple individual studies. The inclusion and search methods of RCTs for SRs and MAs are similar, but the objectives of the two are a bit different, as are the forms of the reports. In SRs, the results are summarized in more in narrative form, whereas in MAs the data are treated mathematically and the results are defined in statistical terms. Thus authors of SRs are freer to speculate on the degree of confidence that a method is effective based on what is shown by the numbers of positive and negative RCTs collected. Authors of MAs usually limit their comments to what the mathematical formulation of the summarized data show.
I am not a statistician, and will not comment so much on the mathematical aspects of the MA in question here, but will point out that 1) themethods used were standard and reported credibly, and 2) the problems found in the RCTs contribute to invalidating the conclusions of the MA. A common warning to authors of MAs is that the outcome of any MA depends directly on the reliability of the individual RCTs.
But what did this MA show? The primary outcome measure was the number of days from entry until the presence of no more than 2 stools per day for 2 days. 247 subjects entered the study and 230 completed the study through to the final end point (nearly equal numbers in each arm dropped out or had incomplete data.) There was an overall 18.5 percent difference between the homeopathic treatment and the placebo control groups, with the reduction from 3.8 days in the control group to 3.1 days in the treatment group. (P=0.008). The P value appears to impart a high significance to the result. But similar problems that played out in the RCTs played here in the MA as well.
Examination of the Kaplan-Meier plot showed that at each day after day 0 the homeopathy group showed a less likely presence of diarrhea than the control group. (Kaplan -Meier curves are constructed to show probabilities, not actual events.) But at day 1 (24 h) the difference was about 15percent, the same at day2, but at 3 to 4 days, the period of the primary measure, the difference was greatest at about 25-30 percent. By the fifth day the difference between the two groups was down to about 10 – 15 percent. In other words, the greatest statistically significant period in the study happened to occur at the time of the selected end point, but was much less at the other points. There is no evidence of data manipulation here, just an odd finding. I cannot account for it unless that difference is a normal characteristic of such studies. Odd.
But shedding the arithmetic and statistical wording, and describing what actually occurred, even at maximum difference between homeopathy and controls, was a difference between having 3 (or slightly more) stools per day and no more than 2 stools per day for 1 day or so at only one of four measured periods of the study. The calculated difference in terms of days to the end point was slightly more than a half a day. Most patients and most family members would hardly be aware of such a small difference. A sort of homeopathic difference.
In addition, the authors sought to find any differences between the groups that could affect outcome such as age, size, that occurred during assignment or randomization, and found that there was a difference in assignment that favored the homeopathy groip (P = .025.) Not a great difference, but an indication of how much chance differences can contribute to study outcomes, that combining studies and increasing numbers does not always even out random imbalances. This difference also suggests that sometimes there can be hidden biases in apparently well carried-out studies.
So the MA showed the same kinds of outcomes as the three individual studies did, but with a smaller P value from the larger number of subjects via the combining of the data. Pretty much what would have been expected. But for a minor symptom, and for results that should not be extended to the general population, since the most severely affected children were hospitalized and excluded from the study.
However, in the political system of homeocracy, rules change at the power of thought, scientific method bcomes a “living, breathing document”, the principles of which are malleable to fit circumstances. Thus, despite the minimal findings from this series of studies, the minimal boost in significance from the MA, the authors conclude again that homeopathy might be added to the therapy of childhood diarrhea because although the advantage is small, the treatments are harmless, the world-wide clinical problem is great, and so homeopathy would be an advantage to public health.
One can still wonder how papers with such comments pass editorial and peer review – but then, papers with famous names tend to get attention (Wayne Jonas is former Director of the Office of Alternative Medicine and a homeopath.)

   On the ethics of clinical trials of homeopathy in Third World countries
David Gorski
Link
I’m on the record multiple times as saying that I reject the entire concept and nomenclature of “alternative medicine” as being distinct from “conventional” medicine as a false dichotomy, when in reality there should be just “medicine.” Indeed, if there is one major theme to which this blog is dedicated it’s that medicine should be as much as possible science-based, a concept that takes into account not just clinical trials, which are prone to all sorts of false-positive results in the case of modalities that have no plausibility from a scientific perspective. In essence, I advocate treating “alternative” medicine the same as “conventional” medicine subjecting it to the same scientific process to determine whether it has efficacy or not, after which medicine that is effective is retained and used and medicine that fails the test is discarded. Where it comes from, the “alternative” or the “conventional” medical realm, matters little to me. All that matters is that it is based on sound science and that it has been demonstrated to have efficacy significantly greater than that of a placebo.
Given that, you’d think I’d be all in favor of subjecting alternative medicine, be it woo or more credible, to rigorous scientific testing. In many cases, you’d be right. My sole caveat is that, when testing alt-med, priority should be given to modalities that have at least a modicum of scientific plausibility, even if a bit tenuous. Herbal remedies would thus be at the front of my line to be tested, while obvious woo whose core principle on which it is based is so utterly ridiculous and scientifically implausible (like homeopathy, for instance) would be relegated to the back of line, if it’s ever tested at all. More implausible modalities that might work (albeit by a method that has nothing to do with the “life energy” manipulation that is claimed for it) like acupuncture would be somewhere in the middle. It’s a matter of resource prioritization, in which it makes little sense to test blatant woo before more plausible therapies are examined. Indeed, it’s arguable whether blatant woo like homeopathy should even have resources wasted testing it at all, given its extreme scientific improbability. Finally, regardless of what modality is being tested in scientific and/or clinical trials, it has to be done according to the highest ethical standards, on adults fully cognizant of or able to be taught about the questions being asked, the issues involved, and the potential risks who are thus able to give truly informed consent.
Given Dr. Atwood’s recent post about the dubious ethics of certain CAM trials funded by the NIH, I thought I’d discuss one such trial that I first came across about about a year and a half ago that demonstrates many of the ethical problems that come with testing unscientific medicine. In this case, the unscientific medicine is homeopathy, and the research subjects are children in a Third World Country. The study was trial of homeopathy published in October 2006 in The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine:
Homeopathic Combination Remedy in the Treatment of Acute Childhood Diarrhea in Honduras
Jacobs J, Guthrie BL, Montes GA, Jacobs LE, Mickey-Colman N, Wilson AR, DiGiacomo R.
Department of Epidemiology, School of Public Health and Community Medicine, University of Washington, Seattle, WA.
BACKGROUND: Despite the widespread availability of oral rehydration therapy, diarrheal illness remains a major cause of morbidity and mortality around the world. Previous studies have shown individualized homeopathic therapy to be effective in treating childhood diarrhea, but this approach requires specialized training. OBJECTIVE: A homeopathic combination medicine, if effective, could be used by health personnel on a widespread basis. 
METHODS: A double-blind randomized controlled trial was conducted in Honduras to evaluate the effectiveness of a homeopathic combination therapy to treat acute diarrhea in children. A total of 292 children with acute diarrhea was recruited; 145 were randomized to the experimental group and 147 to the placebo group. Tablets containing a combined preparation of the five most common single homeopathic remedies used to treat diarrhea or placebo were administered by a parent after each unformed stool. Children were followed up daily for 7 days or until symptoms resolved, whichever occurred first. Time until resolution of symptoms, daily rate of unformed stools, and total number of unformed stools were compared between the two groups. 
RESULTS: There was no significant difference in the likelihood of resolution of diarrheal symptoms between the treatment and placebo groups (hazard ratio = 1.02, 95% confidence interval: 0.79-1.32), with a median time until resolution of 3 days for both groups. Children in the treatment group had an average of 2.6 unformed stools per day compared to 2.8 among those in the placebo group; this difference was not significant (p = 0.43). The median number of unformed stools was 7 among children in the treatment group and 8 among those in the placebo group (p = 0.41). 
DISCUSSION: The homeopathic combination therapy tested in this study did not significantly reduce the duration or severity of acute diarrhea in Honduran children. Further study is needed to develop affordable and effective methods of using homeopathy to reduce the global burden of childhood diarrhea.
I will give the Journal props for one thing in this one instance: It actually published a completely negative study of homeopathy. If you peruse the archive of its past issues, you will find precious few instances of totally negative studies on favored “complementary and alternative” therapies (or so-called “CAM” therapies) like homeopathy being published. Basically, the study above found that the homeopathic “remedies” used above didn’t provide any detectable benefit for diarrheal illness in these unfortunate children in Honduras. Of course, given the utter scientifically implausibility of homeopathy, that’s pretty much a “well, duh!” conclusion. Indeed, it would have been far more surprising if the investigators had found an an obvious treatment effect due to homeopathy that was due to anything more than placebo effect or poor experimental design. However, this study is a beautiful case study of how, no matter how negative the data is, CAM advocates will try to spin it as being something other than it is, as the authors do here:
Although individually prescribed homeopathic therapy by a trained practitioner reduced the duration and severity of acute diarrhea in three previous studies, the combination homeopathic medicine used in this study showed no evidence of efficacy. There was also no evidence that efficacy differed between subgroups defined by demographic or baseline clinical characteristics or category of pathogenic agent detected.
A number of factors could account for the ineffectiveness of the homeopathic combination therapy. Although the homeopathic remedies included in the combination therapy were those most commonly prescribed in the previous studies, it is possible that these remedies would not have been prescribed individually in this population and/or that a different combination medicine would have been more effective. There is also a possibility that the remedies included in the combination therapy counteracted each other in some way, rendering the individual remedies ineffective. Other factors could be that the therapy was not administered correctly by parents in this study, or that it had lost its potency because of improper storage or handling before it was administered.
I cannot help but chuckle at that last sentence. How does a placebo whose allegedly active ingredient has been diluted to a homeopathic dilution of 30C, (which is the equivalent of a 1:1060), a point where it is incredibly unlikely that even one molecule of “active ingredient” remains, “lose its potency”? In fact, to find a single molecule of the “active substance” would require a container over 30 billion times the size of the earth. “Lose its potency,” indeed. It never had any potency to begin with. In essence, the author is suggesting that, somehow 87% alcohol could inactivate 87% alcohol or water could inactivate water!
Another possibility is that the pathogens infecting children in this study were less susceptible to homeopathic therapy in general or to this specific combination therapy in particular.
Which begs the question of how any pathogens could be susceptible to homeopathy at all!
But as much fun as it is to enjoy the discomfiture of the study authors as they try to explain in one of the woo-iest “scientific” journals there is why they found no treatment effect due to homeopathy without stating the glaringly obvious (that homeopathy is nothing more than an elaborate placebo containing no active ingredient), I’m more interested in the ethics of this study. First off, this study gives off an unpleasant whiff of exploitation. Think about it. Here we have comfortable academics from a wealthy nation heading to a country where diarrheal diseases in children, although still mostly self-limited, still cause considerable morbidity and mortality (world-wide around 1.5 million children die every year of such diseases). True, oral rehydration therapy, which has become more widespread, has greatly decreased the death rate. Nonetheless, in spite of this, these diseases still cause considerable morbidity due to malnutrition, mainly because babies suffering from them are unable to eat properly or absorb the nutrients during the course of the illness in whatever milk, food, or formula that they can manage to eat. In our wealthy nation, we rarely, if ever, see the devastation these diseases routinely wreak in impoverished areas like the ones where the study population lives, as described by the authors:
Subjects were drawn from two municipal clinics in the Metropolitan Health District of Honduras. The clinics serve an impoverished population of approximately 80,000 people, with no municipal water, electric, sewage, or garbage disposal services. Educational opportunities are low and unemployment is common…Among the clinic patients, there was a high incidence of childhood diarrhea; in 2001, there was an estimated incidence of 23 cases of diarrhea per 1000 children 5 years old.
Now, let’s look at the specifics of the homeopathic remedies used:
The homeopathic combination medicine was composed of the five most common single remedies, which were prescribed for the treatment of 80% of cases of childhood diarrhea in previous studies.12,13 These included Arsenicum album, Calcarea carbonica, Chamomilla, Podophyllum, and sulphur. The homeopathic remedies were prepared in the United States using standard methods.18 The combination therapy was prepared by a homeopathic pharmacist by impregnating pellets made of 85% sucrose and 15% lactose with a liquid homeopathic dilution in the 30C potency (the active substances diluted 1:100 in an 87% alcohol solution 30 times for a final concentration of 1 x 10-60). Placebo was prepared in the same manner using 87% alcohol instead of the homeopathic dilution. Treatment and placebo preparations were identical in taste, odor, and appearance.
Arsenic. Podophyllin. I wonder if the IRB knew that these were the ingredients being used. Granted, they are so dilute that there is nothing left, but there was no data presented to show that these components had actually been diluted that much and therefore posed no threat to the study subjects. Think of it this way. If the remedy has any active ingredients, it’s potentially toxic. If it is truly homeopathic, then it’s nothing more than 87% ethanol and sugar. How is it ethical to give this to anyone in a clinical trial, other than in a placebo control arm?
Here’s another consideration. The study subjects were children. The Common Rule that covers all federally funded human subjects research makes it very clear that special care must be taken when vulnerable populations are the subjects of a study. Depending on the age of the child, informed consent must be obtained from the subject himself. If the child is too young, then both parents must assent, unless one is dead or unavailable. In any case, the ethical considerations of research on children are very difficult. Now, in the light of the fact that children are considered vulnerable populations who require special protection above and beyond that given adults and that, more than that, they are not American and live in the slums of a Third World nation, think about how these investigators would have signed up patients in Honduras. It’s obvious from the writing in this paper that they are true believers in homeopathy. They probably told parents that they would be randomized to a placebo or to a remedy that might help their child and weren’t lying when they said it–because they truly believed it. Even so, to sell this trial they would have been spreading misinformation, namely that anyone in the study would receive anything that might actually have a therapeutic benefit.
Finally, given the conditions of the areas in which the study population live, it’s not unreasonable to presume that the people living there are mostly not well educated. This brings up the question of whether the parents were in fact able to give truly informed consent. The answer: Almost certainly not. Now, don’t get me wrong. One ethical principle that would be violated in withholding the benefits of a clinical trial from the poorly educated is that such benefits should not be limited only to the well-off or highly educated. However, communicating the risks and benefits of any trial to uneducated people unsophisticated people takes a special effort. It’s a lot of work. Did the investigators make that effort? Maybe I’m being cynical, but I tend to doubt it. In fact, to do this study in the first place, they would by definition of homeopathy have to be giving the parents of the study subjects misinformation. There’d be no way around it.
How this study ever passed muster at the Institutional Review Board at the University of Washington, the home institution of the investigators, I’ll never know. This IRB should have viewed its charge as protecting these Honduran children from being included in an dubious study that could not possibly do study participants any good and at best wouldn’t harm them. I’m guessing that the reason for this is that the members of the IRB had no clue about what homeopathy actually is, why it’s so scientifically ridiculous, and why the above study is highly dubious ethically. Indeed, I wonder if it is a general problem with IRBs that few of their members know exactly what it is that is in so-called “CAM” remedies like homeopathy. One other possible reason in this case is that the investigators probably cited a 13-year old study done using essentially the same methodology in Nicaragua and published in Pediatrics in 1994. This study purported to show a treatment effect, although it was small and arguable whether, even if real, it would be clinically significant. It also used a slightly different bunch of homeopathic remedies, one of which included mercury, of all things. In addition, this study was riddled with methodological difficulties, including failure to control for diet (diet can, as you would imagine, have a considerable impact on diarrhea in these illnesses); the level of dehydration (the treatment group where an effect was allegedly observed suffered from milder dehydration); and previous treatment interventions (patients in the treatment group were more than twice as likely to have received treatment before starting homeopathy). Finally, they did not use optimal recommended methods for quantifying diarrhea output
I truly wonder if the UW IRB would have approved this sort of study twice–or even once–if the study population had been American. I’m not sure which would be worse: If it wouldn’t have–or if it would have.
Finally, looking back at this trial again a year and a half later, I wondered if more such trials had been published in the interim. I was quite relieved to be unable to find any. Indeed, searching PubMed, all I could find were two articles. The first was a systematic review of homeopathy for pediatric and adolescent ailments that concluded that the “evidence from rigorous clinical trials of any type of therapeutic or preventive intervention testing homeopathy for childhood and adolescence ailments is not convincing enough for recommendations in any condition.” The second was a survey that starts out with the assumption that homeopathy is effective in childhood diarrhea and surveys pediatricians about whether they are using homeopathy for such diseases. To my relief, only 3% reported that they were using homeopathic antidiarrheal agents. To my amusement, the authors bemoaned this very low number and proposed means of increasing it:
We conclude that homeopathic antidiarrheal agents have garnered little support among pediatric health care providers. The lack of correlation between adoption and individual innovativeness suggests that adoption will not increase barring intervention. Survey methods have allowed us to identify specific barriers to adoption. Remediation would include improving the evidence base for this innovation to the degree possible, increasing awareness, and providing means of improving experiential knowledge of these agents.
In other words, even though homeopathy doesn’t work for pediatric diarrheal diseases, we propose increasing awareness and getting people “hands-on” experience with it. Of course, the most tortured conclusion is suggesting “improving the evidence base for this innovation as much as possible.” Apparently the authors don’t realize that the evidence base for this “innovation” (how one can call a 200 year old bit of magical thinking based on prescientific ideas on vitalism and sympathetic magic an “innovation” I’ll never know) is as “good” as it’s ever likely to get.
One thing you can be sure of, though, is that homeopathy advocates won’t give up. They will keep trying to carry out ethically dubious trials such as the one described above. Thanks to the existence of the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, sadly, you and I will likely keep paying for them too.
REFERENCES:
Jacobs, J., Guthrie, B.L., Montes, G.A., Jacobs, L.E., Mickey-Colman, N., Wilson, A.R., DiGiacomo, R. (2006). Homeopathic Combination Remedy in the Treatment of Acute Childhood Diarrhea in Honduras. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, 12(8), 723-732. DOI: 10.1089/acm.2006.12.723
Altunç, U., Pittler, M.H., Ernst, E. (2007). Homeopathy for Childhood and Adolescence Ailments: Systematic Review of Randomized Clinical Trials. Mayo Clinic Proceedings, 82(1), 69-75.
Pappano, D., Conners, G., McIntosh, S., Humiston, S., Roma, D. (2007). Why Pediatric Health Care Providers Are Not Using Homeopathic Antidiarrheal Agents. The Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, 13(10), 1071-1076. DOI: 10.1089/acm.2007.0651

   The Montagnier “Homeopathy” Study. 
Harriet Hall
Link
A recent study is being cited as support for homeopathy. For instance, the Homeopathy World Community website says
Luc Montagnier Foundation Proves Homeopathy Works.
Dana Ullman cites it in the comments to this blog
And I assume that you all have seen the new research by Nobel Prize-winning virologist Luc Montagnier that provides significant support to homeopathy. 
Nope. Sorry, guys. It doesn’t. In fact, its findings are inconsistent with homeopathic theory.
The study has nothing whatsoever to say about homeopathy. Its abstract concludes:
This opens the way to the development of highly sensitive detection system for chronic bacterial infections in human and animal diseases.
Homeopaths are grasping at straws when they cite this study. It involved dilution and agitation: that’s the only possible hint of anything homeopathic and it is nothing but a false analogy.
The study is “Electromagnetic signals are produced by aqueous nanostructures derived from bacterial DNA” by Luc Montagnier, Jamal Aissa, Stephane Ferris, Luen-Luc Montagnier and Claude Lavallee. The pdf of the article is available here.
While not necessarily impacting the validity of the study, its publishing details raise some concerns. It was not published in an established, respected journal. It appeared in the first volume, second issue of a new journal, Interdisciplinary Sciences–Computational Life Sciences. The article is not written in the usual scientific format – it lacks separate sections for Methods, Results, etc. There are numerous typos and language errors that should have been caught by any proofreader even if the peer reviewers missed them. The editor in chief is in Shanghai, and four of the other editors are in various Chinese cities, while the other two are US based but have Chinese names. Montagnier is on the editorial board. It says it is peer-reviewed, but the speed of the process is worrisome: the Montagnier article was received 3 January 2009, revised 5 January 2009 and accepted 6 January 2009.
In preliminary observations, they discovered that when they filtered 300 nM Mycoplasma with a 100 nM filter, the resulting sterile fluid
was able to regenerate the original mycoplasma when incubated with a mycoplasma negative culture of human lymphocytes within 2 to 3 weeks.
This alone is intriguing, suggesting that disrupted particles of DNA can re-create the original bacterium in cell culture. If true, it would have all sorts of interesting implications, especially for sterilization by filtration. The evidence for this was referenced merely as a “personal communication.” I wonder why they didn’t publish it.
They say that
In the course of investigating the nature of such filtering infectious forms, we found another property of the filtrates… their capacity to produce some electromagnetic waves of low frequency in a reproducible manner after appropriate dilutions in water.
They do not explain what rationale prompted them to measure EMS or to dilute their samples. It was this electromagnetic phenomenon that they proceeded to investigate in the present study.
The study detected electromagnetic signals from diluted, agitated, and filtered solutions of Mycoplasma and E. coli bacteria. They postulate that some DNA sequences emit electromagnetic waves after excitation by the ambient electromagnetic background. Extracted DNA produced EMS signals similar to those produced by intact bacteria. DNAse treatment abolished the effect. They postulate a network of DNA nanostructures organized in a gel-like liquid crystal. Puzzlingly, they found no effects in low dilutions – but they came up with tortuous rationalizations as to why that might be (Self-inhibition? Interference? Inability to vibrate?). The effect was transferable to other lower dilutions of the same bacteria when the two solutions were shielded and kept close to each other for 24 hours.
There was a lot of background noise, but they say that positive signals could be differentiated over the background by higher frequency peaks. The measuring system they used does not immediately inspire confidence, since it was designed by Benveniste, infamous for winning two Ig Nobel prizes, the second one for allegedly sending the electromagnetic signatures of homeopathic water memories over telephone lines and the Internet. I don’t have the expertise to critique the physics or the methodology; but even assuming the results are valid, they tend to discredit homeopathy, not support it:
     1.  By filtration, they were able to determine the particle size of the components that were associated with positive results. There were particles of DNA present, in contrast to high homeopathic dilutions where no molecules of the original substance remain.
     2.  Homeopathy postulates effects at most dilutions, with increasing effects as the dilutions become greater. In this study, there were no effects at low dilutions. There were a series of positive effects at high dilutions but the effect size did not increase progressively as the dilution increased. At the highest dilutions, the effect vanished.
     3.  They talk about water structures and polymer formations, but acknowledge that these associations appear to be very short-lived. In this study they found that the effects lasted for several hours, sometimes up to 48 hours – but not longer. Homeopathic remedies are not administered within hours of their preparation. They supposedly remain effective for long periods. Most homeopaths say that homeopathic remedies do not require expiration dates and will remain effective indefinitely as long as they are properly stored.
The authors claim that the effects were only found in pathogenic bacteria, not in beneficial bacteria like probiotics. Maybe. It would be surprising if one physical phenomenon rather than several different physiologic ones could discriminate between pathogenic and non-pathogenic bacteria.
The authors engage in further unwarranted speculation:
we have detected the same EMS in the plasma and in the DNA extracted from the plasma of patients suffering of Alzheimer, Parkinson disease, multiple Sclerosis and Rheumatoid Arthritis.
This statement is given without any supporting references. The data have apparently not been published. One wonders why.
They go on to say
This would suggest that bacterial infections are present in these diseases.
It would suggest to me that they really don’t know the significance of what they are apparently measuring.
The study can only be categorized as a preliminary study. It raises a lot of questions and will require independent replication (preferably studies of high enough quality to merit publication in a more prestigious journal with high standards and rigorous peer review) before we can place any confidence in its results.
Anyway, in vitro findings by themselves can’t ever validate homeopathy, even if they could demonstrate that water can remember what molecules were diluted out of it. They would still have to show that such memory translated to specific therapeutic effects on human physiology. Homeopathy is a system of clinical treatment that can only be validated by in vivo clinical trials. Homeopaths who believe Montagnier’s study supports homeopathy are only demonstrating their enormous capacity for self-deception.

   Homeopathy and Sepsis
Mark Crislip
Link
It had once been suggested in the comments section of the blog that homeopathy is useful in the treatment of diseases that are not self limited. Homeopathy is effective therapy for diseases that do not get better on their own, that homeopathy has a real effect on real diseases.
One example given was for the treatment of sepsis.
“Frass M, Linkesch, M, Banjya, S, et al. Adjunctive homeopathic treatment in patients with severe sepsis: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in an intensive care unit. Homeopathy 2005:94;75–80. At a University of Vienna hospital, 70 patients with severe sepsis were enrolled in a randomized double-blind, placebo-controlled clinical trial, measuring survival rates at 30 days and at 180 days. Those patients given a homeopathic medicine were prescribed it in the 200C potency only (in 12 hour intervals during their hospital stay). The survival rate at day 30 was 81.8% for homeopathic patients and 67.7% for those given a placebo. At day 180, 75.8% of homeopathic patients survived and only 50.0% of the placebo patients survived (p=0.043). One patient was saved for every four who were treated.”
I am, as I have mentioned before, but I mention again for those who might be new to the blog, an Infectious Disease physician. My job is to diagnosis and treat infectious diseases and sepsis is up there at the top of the list of diseases I take of. Sepsis butters my bread, and I consider myself knowledgeable about sepsis.
And I had never heard of this study. A therapy that saves one in four patients would be an astounding intervention for an often fatal disease, and I have never come across it all my reading. Maybe its because there are so many articles and so little time. Maybe it hasn’t been publicized. Or maybe it is a lousy article.
Sepsis is not a single disease, but a syndrome. Bacteria invade an organ, like the lung to cause pneumonia or the kidney to cause pyelonephritis. Then the bacteria enter the blood stream and cause a massive inflammatory response that results in most or all the patients organs shuting down and they die. Rapidly. The inflammatory response in sepsis is mind numbingly complicated. The medical interventions used to treat sepsis are equally complicated and multifaceted.
Sepsis is as non-self-limited a disease as one could want. Untreated, almost everyone dies. Under the best current treatment, a minimum of 30% die, but depending on the underlying medical conditions and the infecting organisms, some causes of sepsis have almost 100% mortality rates. Any therapeutic intervention that decreases the mortality of this syndrome, even a little, would be welcomed.
So why I had never heard of this study, which decreased mortality a whopping 25%? That is an impressive result, if true. If true.
Now I will admit my bias is that the underlying premise for homeopathy is ludicrous, so I would not expect any homeopathic nostrum to be effective. But who knows, maybe this is the study that will revolutionize all of medicine and prove that homeopathy alters the course of one of the most difficult to treat syndromes in medicine.
So lets go over the article and see if there is a there there.
70 patients admitted to the ICU at the University of Vienna with sepsis were included in the study.
The criteria for sepsis were reasonable:
“Patients with a known or suspected infection on the basis of clinical data at the time of screening and three or more signs of systemic inﬂammation (temperature <= 36 or >= 38 1C, respiratory rate >= 20/min, heart rate >= 90/min, leukocytes >= 12 G/L) and sepsis-induced dysfunction of at least two organ systems that lasted no longer than 48 h were included.”
The two groups were well matched by clinical criteria. Same number of underlying diseases, same distribution of infections and infecting organisms. So far, so good.
Then in a double blind, placebo trial, patients received, within 48 hours of admission to the ICU, either placebo or an individualized homeopathic nostrum.
As I gather from the study, one homeopathic practitioner, but perhaps more, evaluated the patient and determined which nostrum best suited the patient. It was then dispensed by another who did not know if they were dispensing placebo or homeopathic nostrum. All the nostrums were 200C. That’s 1 part in
1000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000.
The known universe is not large enough to dilute one atom to that degree.
They were then given 5 globules of either placebo or the homeopathic nostrum twice a day until death or resolution of the sepsis.
What were the nostrums given? Here are the nostrums, with the indication for which it was given.
Apis melliﬁca: Oedema, Extreme dyspnoea.
Arsenicu malbum: Weakness, exhaustion Cardiovascular compromise, Anxiety, restlessness Cachectic appearance.
Baptisia: ARDS, Sepsis, Hot skin.
Belladonna: High temperature with sweat, Red discolouration, face.
Bryonia: Pneumonia, esp. right lung, Stitching pain in chest.
Carbo vegetabilis: Respiratory insufﬁciency, ARDS.
Crotalus horridus: Purpura haemorrhagica, Haemorrhages.
Lachesis muta: Septic shock, Haemorrhage High temperature, Embolism, Discolouration blue, purple.
Lycopodium clavatum: Fever, afternoon, Distension, abdominal.
Phosphorus: Pneumonia, esp. right lower lobe, Haemorrhage, Purpura haemorrhagica.
Pyrogenium: Septic fever, Offensive odour.
It is amazing, given the multitudinous signs and symptoms that you have to recognize and treat in sepsis, that the homeopath would choose offensive odor as the basis of therapy. Or hot skin. Or anxiety.
Yes, E. coli is in your blood stream, your lungs and kidneys are failing, your blood pressure cannot be maintained, you are on a respirator and dialysis and the most important symptom upon which to base the life saving therapy is offensive odor. It suggests a profound intellectual ignorance in the understanding of a severe infection.
There are several precepts underlying homeopathy. One, of course, is like cures like.
Lachesis muta is snake venom and, as best as I can tell, does not mimic septic shock. Septic shock in no way resembles death from snake venom except at the most superficial level. Carbo vegetalis is vegetable charcoal. It, as best as I can tell, does not mimic ARDS. Baptisia is derived from Wild indigo plant, and as best I can tell, when ingested does not mimic ARDS.
Prior to this study, I can find no references that ANY of these nostrums were ever used for these symptoms before, probably because without modern medical therapy everyone died before they could be tested.
Also key to homeopathic nostrums is the concept of provings. The nostrums are tested on healthy people to insure it causes the symptoms it allegedly treats. I cannot find that any of these remedies were tested with proving’s and, given the severity of the symptoms of sepsis, a proving would be fatal.
As best I can tell from perusing the homeopathic writings, there is little if any homeopathic justification (within their therapeutic paradigm) for using these remedies under these circumstances. One wonders whether the IRB at the University of Vienna knew not only that the it was an experiment to see if homeopathy was effective, but that each remedy was being tried for the first time for these indications.
The one feature about all these nostrums is how they ignore the underlying problem and only treat the symptoms, evidently with a complete disregard of the underlying pathophysiology of sepsis. Sepsis is fundamentally due to infections in the blood. If you don’t treat the infection, you do nothing. The basis of chosing a homeopathic nostrum in sepsis is worse than applying a band-aid to a multiple trauma victim.
All patients were receiving standard care in addition to homeopathic nostrums. But it suggests a certain intellectual bankruptcy that when someone is admitted with bacteria in their blood stream and all the organs shutting down, actively trying to die, that the practitioner focuses on stitching pain in the chest as the diagnostic sign of importance in choosing an intervention.
The study had two end points: 30 day mortality and 180 day mortality.
30 day mortality is a standard endpoint in sepsis studies.
In this study there was a not a significant difference in 30 day mortality between the placebo and treatment groups (verum 81.8%, placebo 67.7%, P = 0.19), although the percentages look markedly different. Given the small numbers of patients in each wing of the study, I would expect insignificant differences between the two groups to show up looking greater than they are. A difference in one or two deaths would make a huge difference in the percentages. One more death in the placebo and one less in the homeopathic group and the both would be in the 70′s. With a mere 32 patients in each group, there is an insufficient number of patients to find any real significant differences. Small numbers of patients are much more likely to show spurious, random results that are clinically insignificant even if statistically significant.
Then the study becomes risible.
People die from sepsis. They die in the first day or so from the acute infection. They come in too sick to be saved. They die in the first week or so from progressive multi-organ system failure. They die in the first month from complications of medical care or underlying medical diseases. But if they make it to 30 days, they made it. If they die, it is usually not related to the sepsis.
Sepsis is, above all, a transient and completely reversible process. Once the bacteria are killed off and the immune system mops up the endotoxins, there is no disease left. The patient is cured; the disease eradicated. No further disease pathophysiology is present. It is not like other processes, for example coronary artery disease, where the underlying disease persists.
180 days. 6 months. To think that a few days of any therapy for sepsis is going to make a difference in mortality at six months is ludicrous. It would rely upon an understanding of causality and the pathophysiology of sepsis the elude me. How a treatment of sepsis for a few days leads to a decrease in mortality months later beggars the imagination.
But that is the endpoint and they found a significant difference for mortality at 180 days.
“On day 180, survival was statistically significantly higher with verum homeopathy (75.8% vs 50.0%, P = 0.043). “
Most studies use 0.05 as the point where it is statistically significant. A p = 0.05 means that the odds are 1 in 20, or 5 % that the results are not correlated. Statistically significant does not mean clinically significant and also does not necessarily mean real. With small numbers in a trial, random variation can look significant. A change of one death in each group would have made the p value no longer significant.
And p value is not all that significant. Why did they die? Not known. Why 6 months later as an end point? Not known. Why did homeopathy lead to an increased survival at six months, which if really true would be an important advance in sepsis? Not even hinted at in the discussion. Somehow, a few days of a 200C homeopathyic nostrum exerted some powerful medical effect on their offensive odour, increasing their chance of survival six months later.
In comparison, the biggest and best study for sepsis was the activated protein C study in the NEJM in 2001.
“A total of 1690 randomized patients were treated (840 in the placebo group and 850 in the drotrecogin alfa activated group). The mortality rate was 30.8 percent in the placebo group and 24.7 percent in the drotrecogin alfa activated group. On the basis of the prospectively defined primary analysis, treatment with drotrecogin alfa activated was associated with a reduction in the relative risk of death of 19.4 percent (95 percent confidence interval, 6.6 to 30.5) and an absolute reduction in the risk of death of 6.1 percent (P=0.005).”
This huge, multicenter study it altered how patients with severe sepsis are treated.
Note the smaller difference in effect and a much greater p value.
And they included the morality curves over time:
The discussion is of interest in that only two paragraphs are devoted to the study, mostly to comment that there are not enough homeopaths to provide the needed care for septic patient.
“Our data suggest that adjunctive homeopathic treatment may be beneficial for the survival of critically ill patients. Short-time survival showed a non-statistically significant trend in favour of homeopathy; however, this may be due to the relatively small sample size. The lack of adverse effects is an important advantage of homeopathic treatment. As a further advantage, there is no interference with traditional treatment. Dosing via the oral route is easy and possible also in intubated patients orally and patients with oral or nasal feeding tubes. Furthermore, homeopathic medicines are low cost. One constraint is the small number of trained homeopathic doctors available in this setting.
Confounding factors include that placebo patients were more seriously affected in terms of heart rate and leukocyte count. However, there was no significant difference in the means of these variables. All patients received antibiotic therapy. “
Whether it was appropriate antibiotic therapy we are not told, but why why why did it work? No thoughts from the authors.
The rest of the discussion is a superficial tutorial on the various real ways to treat sepsis. I am guessing the average reader of Homeopathy has no understanding of sepsis, and probably no real experience treating the disease.
Its almost as if they knew that their result was bogus.
Does homeopathy increase survival in sepsis? Only if you think that a sip of water today will decrease your chance of dying in 6 months.
This is not a lousy study; it is a joke.
REFERENCES:
1. FRASS, M., LINKESCH, M., BANYAI, S., RESCH, G., DIELACHER, C., LOBL, T., ENDLER, C., HAIDVOGL, M., MUCHITSCH, I., & SCHUSTER, E. (2005). Adjunctive homeopathic treatment in patients with severe sepsis: a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in an intensive care unit Homeopathy, 94 (2), 75-80 DOI: 10.1016/j.homp.2005.01.002
2. Gordon R. Bernard, Jean-Louis Vincent, Pierre-Francois Laterre, Steven P. LaRosa, Jean-Francois Dhainaut, Angel Lopez-Rodriguez, Jay S. Steingrub, Gary E. Garber, Jeffrey D. Helterbrand, E. Wesley Ely, & Charles J. Fisher (2001). Efficacy and Safety of Recombinant Human Activated Protein C for Severe Sepsis NEJM, 344 (10), 699-709

Some Sepsis Stuff
Sepsis interventions. Some don’t work and some don’t work.
Mark Crislip on October 20, 2022
Link

Sepsis. Bad stuff. Sepsis is when an infection, and occasionally other medical conditions, set off a cascade of out of control inflammation, damaging or destroying any number of organs and often leading to death.
As I said, bad stuff. Sepsis, in all its manifestations, has been one of the mainstays of my practice. Sepsis can be transient and respond rapidly to antibiotics and modern ICU supportive care. It can also be a relentless crash and burn, a rapid and uncontrolled spiral into death.
I have seen a few young meningococcal patients who were fine at breakfast and dead by dinner. Bad stuff.
For whatever reason, patients have recently been made aware of sepsis. For the past few years, it has not been unusual to have been asked by families if the patient was septic.
We have improved the management of sepsis over the years, mostly as we are better and more aggressive at supporting failing organs. But the basic approach has been the same for the 36 years I have been in infectious diseases: antibiotics, supportive care, and a gobbet of good luck.
Why some die and some survive is often a mystery. There is always variation in both the infecting organism and the host. All E. coli are not the same, for example, where different strains infecting identical mice will have different mortality rates. Conversely, the same E. coli strain will have different mortality rates in different strains of mice.
There are innumerable variations in the immune system that increase or decrease the risk of acquiring or dying from a variety of infections. My personal favorite is how variations in snot can increase the risk of meningococcal disease. As the Bard said, “The Sepsis, dear Brutus, is not in our stars / But in ourselves”. I will be long retired (3 months, 9 days, 2 hours, 11 minutes as I write this, but who is counting?) before we can scan the genome of a patient with a tricorder and point to the polymorphism that increased, or decreased, the chance of infection and death.
Vitamin C
Every once in a while a patient does survive sepsis who really should not have. It always fries my bacon when the family credits God with the save. They have no idea of the work and training the ICU team had accomplished to produce the ‘miracle’. Give credit where credit is due.
I have been around long enough to see many an adjunctive therapy come and go for sepsis. Xigris, steroids, and others. It is common in the ICU, perhaps more often for processes in which our interventions often fail and death is common, for doctors to glom onto therapies that appear to work based on suboptimal trials.
I have referred to it in the past as medical cold fusion: an effect that makes little sense, if any, when compared to known reality. What follows is a flurry of explanations about how the effect could be the real deal, some enthusiastic embracing of the intervention, slow discouragement, finally ending in better clinical trials that show, nope, the intervention did not do anything at all.
Sherman, set the Wayback machine to March 31, 2017, when you will find my last entry of the first series of my SBM bloggin’, “Vitamin C and Sepsis. All Sound and Fury? Much Ado About Nothing?”
At the time I was, for lack of a better word, skeptical (me? Hardly.) that intravenous vitamin C and thiamine were actually effective in decreasing mortality in sepsis. But I noted at the time:
Never go in against vitamin C when death is on the line!
So the study was grudgingly embraced by our intensivists. For a while. You could not tell at the time if the intervention made any impact on outcomes. It did drive up the price of both IV vitamin C and thiamine. A lot. And then there were more clinical trials.
What had been impressive was the decrease in mortality in the vitamin C/thiamin study I evaluated last decade. From 40% to 8.5%. I mean, wow. That seemed too good to be true. And you know what follows. Was that result replicated?
Of course not. Based on eleven studies:
In this meta-analysis, the use of IV high-dose vitamin C in patients with sepsis was not associated with lower short-term mortality.
And:
A total of 17 studies including 3133 patients fulfilled the predefined criteria and were analyzed. Pooled analysis indicated no mortality reduction in patients treated with vitamin C when compared to reference.
So another one bites the dust.
There were a few minor potential beneficial effects, which often show up in these studies. And they are likely meaningless, the usual background noise seen in complex medical interventions that looks promising in subgroup analysis or secondary endpoints. It’s usually crap:
…although it was associated with significantly shorter duration of vasopressor use and greater decline in the Sequential Organ Failure Assessment score at 72–96 hours.
And:
…subgroup analyses revealed an improved survival if vitamin C treatment was applied for 3–4 days
Subgroup analysis is a Latin term used by statisticians for ‘likely bullshit’. Subgroup analysis invariably leads to nothing in later studies. I long ago learned to ignore subgroup analysis.
It was noted that:
…interestingly, six studies reported no adverse events related to the intervention, while three studies documented more frequent adverse events in patients treated with intravenous vitamin C (hypernatremia n= 24, hospital-acquired infections n= 14, hyperglycemia n= 13, gastrointestinal bleeding n= 3, and fluid overload n= 1).
Interesting? Naw. The usual noise in clinical trials.
Perhaps more interesting was the NEJM trial, published after the above meta-analyses:
In adults with sepsis receiving vasopressor therapy in the ICU, those who received intravenous vitamin C had a higher risk of death or persistent organ dysfunction at 28 days than those who received a placebo.
Oops. The numbers:
At day 28, 191 of 429 patients (44.5%) in the vitamin C group had died or had persistent organ dysfunction, as compared with 167 of 434 patients (38.5%) in the placebo group (risk ratio, 1.21; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.04 to 1.40; P=0.01).
I have been convinced that a p needs to be at least .005 to perhaps represent a ‘real’ effect. So really? Vitamin C was no different than placebo. All the effects, good and bad, noted in these trials are, I would bet, just noise. More sound and fury, signifying nothing.
I mean, they didn’t even bother to collect “information regarding specific pathogens and the appropriateness of antimicrobial therapy”.
And that is a finding across all the studies that I could hunt down. No one cared about the microbiology, the source of infection, the host (for example, while transplant patients have more bacteremia, they may die less often) or the appropriateness of antibiotics. All of which make a difference in outcomes.
From the perspective of an ID doc, it renders all the studies of marginal applicability. Not all sepsis is the same, a concept apparently only an ID doc cares about. Perhaps why every study has demonstrated that ID involvement with infections of all kinds, including sepsis, improves outcomes: less morbidity and mortality. Odd how having someone who actually knows that they are doing improves care. Of course, since most of these studies were done by self-serving ID docs, well, go to Midas, get a muffler.
But it probably doesn’t matter. Vitamin C has a long history of no practical benefit for any process outside of scurvy, because there is no reason it should. Add sepsis to that list.
NRLM
As mentioned above, having healthcare providers who know what they are doing improves care. What a concept. It makes me wonder how the opposite end of the spectrum impacts healthcare. Not just knowing nothing about diseases but having your medical approach is based on the nonsensical ravings of a lunatic mind (NRLM) cannot be good.
Great Britain at one time had 5 homeopathic hospitals, one as recently as 2018. I cannot tell if these institutions operated like real hospitals or not.
The Bristol Homeopathic Hospital continued to provide a full range of services.
Whatever those services that might cover. I can’t imagine presenting at a homeopathic hospital with sepsis where all they had to offer is nothing.
No one would rely solely on homeopathy for sepsis, or so one would hope. Homeopathy has been used as an adjunctive therapy, with no benefit. Much to my surprise, I discussed homeopathy and sepsis in 2009. The things I have done for which I have no memory. Sigh.
Despite being an “excellent piece of work on the role of homeopathy in critically ill patients“, at least according to a homeopath, there has been little research since I wrote that blog entry.
Part of the problem is the inability of septic patients to provide the bizarrely detailed and pointless history that guides the selection of homeopathic nostrums. Fear not. There is now, in caps:
…the Protocol for Objective Homeopathic Semiology for patients with an altered state of consciousness.
The Protocol is available online, but I will confess after reading the paper upon which it is based, I have no clue how one would apply it. The author’s website, in Portuguese, has no explanation I can find. “[S]eeking the actual characteristic symptomatic totality, with the hierarchization of homeopathic symptoms” is, I fear, beyond me.
The author goes on to demonstrate how the protocol was applied to a series (three) of septic patients:
Choice of patients for homeopathic intervention was based upon recognition that they were not responding satisfactorily to conventional treatment as judged by the attending ICU medical team.
This was followed by the application of 5 drops of a 30 C or 200 C homeopathic nostrum. A perforated gastric ulcer, a meningococcemia, and a pneumonia, all of whom survived. The conclusion?
The practice of homeopathy may effectively be extended beyond treating chronic cases toward the less familiar but highly important frontiers on the verge of life and death.
They actually thought homeopathy added to care of the patients. I keep wondering why the practice of homeopathy is not considered a DSM-IV delusional illness. NRLM indeed.
Acupuncture
One meta-analysis notes:
Acupuncture has been used for various diseases, including severe infection, in China for more than 2,000 years.
That is true. There are multiple reports of infection and sepsis caused by acupunc… oh wait. This is acupuncture used to TREAT infection and sepsis. That’s different. Nevermind.
Supposedly,
Previous studies reported that acupuncture at Zusanli (ST36) might be effective in treating sepsis
The point is just below the knee and lateral.
It is quite the point, stimulation of which has wide-ranging effects besides treating sepsis. In animal models,
…acupuncture at ST36 could be useful in reducing sepsis-induced injuries in heat, lung, kidney, liver, gastrointestinal tract, and immune system. Moreover, its potential mechanisms for antisepsis might include decreasing oxidative stress and inflammation, improving microcirculatory disturbance, and maintaining immune balance during sepsis.
I mean wow, truly the wonder drug that works wonders despite:
Poor methodological quality and publication bias exist.
How about in humans? And here we have a problem. I can’t access most of the original data from the review “Efficacy and safety of acupuncture as a complementary therapy for sepsis: a systematic review and meta-analysis” that purports to show a mortality benefit to adding acupuncture to standard care.
All the studies are from China, and as a result, are unfortunately suspect as has been mentioned before. As is always the case, a were included in the review, so there was no one acupuncture intervention that ‘worked’ – it is the concept that is effective.
The same issue, by the way, was in the meta-analysis that demonstrated decreased mortality in sepsis with Traditional Chinese Pseudo-Medicine: each trial in the series had a different treatment intervention but the collected data showed:
Addition of TCM has better effects in participants with sepsis.
It just does not matter the specific form of TCPM. I find that so…weird that these meta-analyses include very different interventions as if they were all the same. Meta-analyses are supposed to compare apple and apples, not dog shit and cow pies.
For the acupuncture trials:
Most included studies had an unclear risk or high risk of bias in allocation concealment and blinding of participants. In addition, included studies were mostly small sample single-center RCTs. Therefore, the degree of certainty around our findings is low to very low.
My certainty is high that acupuncture does nothing for any process so why would it alter the course of sepsis?
I went through the bibliography seeing if I could glean much from the titles and abstracts. Nope. More than a few dead links. None of the articles appeared to be evaluating mortality as a primary outcome, mostly looking at lab parameters or effects on the GI tract, such as “Electroacupuncture Improves Intestinal Dysfunction in Septic Patients: A Randomized Controlled Trial“, which found:
However, there were no significant differences in the days on MV, length of stay in ICU, and 28d mortality between two groups ( P>0.05).
And Yang et al., noted in the references, demonstrated that:
There was no significant difference of mortality in the 28th day between the two groups, with 5 deaths of 29 patients in the intervention group (17.2%) and 9 of 29 in the control group (31.0%).
But not included in the mortality section of the meta-analysis. Odd.
So in the end I can’t make detailed analysis of the meta-analysis, but that always begs the question: why bother to apply the concepts of reality to fiction?
Because it is what we do at SBM.

   Homeopathy in the ICU?
David Gorski
Link
Regular readers of this blog are probably familiar with a certain homeopath named Dana Ullman. So persistent is he in his pseudoscientific arguments for the magic that is homeopathy that fellow SBM blogger Kimball Atwood once postulated a humorous law he dubbed the Dull-Man Law:
In any discussion involving science or medicine, being Dana Ullman loses you the argument immediately…and gets you laughed out of the room.
Kimball then pointed to a number of studies that Ullman likes to cite ad nauseam that supposedly “prove” the efficacy of homeopathy. One study Kimball didn’t mention, however, is a favorite of Ullman’s, one he likes to trot out time and time again. Specifically, it’s a study of homeopathy in the ICU that was published, in all places, in Chest, a respectable journal that, as you might expect, is dedicated to research on diseases of the chest, such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), cardiac disease, and basically any disease that manifests its pathology in the chest, although it primarily deals with critical care. I first learned of this study way back in 2007 from Dr. R. W., who at the time commented quite aptly that the article impressed him with just how far into the medical mainstream woo has penetrated, while retired doc also expressed his dismay.
Although I do feel a bit guilty not providing you with more original peerless prose pontificating on medical pseudoscience that you know and (hopefully) love, this article is constantly trotted out by homeopaths, even five years later, and that makes it worth updating an older post from another source. So here’s the abstract:
Influence of Potassium Dichromate on Tracheal Secretions in Critically Ill Patients.
Michael Frass, MD; Christoph Dielacher, RN; Manfred Linkesch, MD; Christian Endler, PhD; Ilse Muchitsch, PhD; Ernst Schuster, PhD and Alan Kaye, MD. Chest. 2005;127:936-941.
* From the Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Homeopathy (Drs. Frass, Endler, and Muchitsch), Vienna, Austria; II Department of Internal Medicine (Mr. Dielacher and Dr. Linkesch); Department of Medical Computer Sciences (Dr. Schuster), University of Vienna, Vienna, Austria; and Department of Anesthesiology (Dr. Kaye), Texas Tech University Lubbock, TX.
Background: Stringy, tenacious tracheal secretions may prevent extubation in patients weaned from the respirator. This prospective, randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled study with parallel assignment was performed to assess the influence of sublingually administered potassium dichromate C30 on the amount of tenacious, stringy tracheal secretions in critically ill patients with a history of tobacco use and COPD.
Methods: In this study, 50 patients breathing spontaneously with continuous positive airway pressure were receiving either potassium dichromate C30 globules (group 1) [Deutsche Homöopathie-Union, Pharmaceutical Company; Karlsruhe, Germany] or placebo (group 2). Five globules were administered twice daily at intervals of 12 h. The amount of tracheal secretions on day 2 after the start of the study as well as the time for successful extubation and length of stay in the ICU were recorded.
Results: The amount of tracheal secretions was reduced significantly in group 1 (p < 0.0001). Extubation could be performed significantly earlier in group 1 (p < 0.0001). Similarly, length of stay was significantly shorter in group 1 (4.20 ± 1.61 days vs 7.68 ± 3.60 days, p < 0.0001 [mean ± SD]).
Conclusion: These data suggest that potentized (diluted and vigorously shaken) potassium dichromate may help to decrease the amount of stringy tracheal secretions in COPD patients.
Holy homeopathy, Batman! Does this study mean that homeopathy actually works for critically ill patients in the ICU? Not so fast there, Robin. Let’s take a look.
First off, the title is interesting. Note how the word “homeopathy” or “homeopathic” does not appear. In fact, no derivative of the word “homeopathy” appears anywhere in the abstract. True, the Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Homeopathy is mentioned in the institutional affiliations, but that would be easily missed by someone perusing the abstract. It’s almost as though the writers were trying to get this in under the radar. After all, most doctors don’t know much about homeopathy, which means that they don’t know much about what a “30C” dilution is or that such a dilution dilutes a substance to the point where there almost certainly isn’t a single molecule left.
First a word about the methods: Apparently in homeopathy lore, potassium dichromate is useful for treating thick respiratory secretions. On what basis, I don’t know. From where I come from, potassium dichromate is a nasty chemical; it’s a powerful oxidizing agent. Indeed, it’s sometimes used to clean laboratory glassware, although I never used it for that. It’s also used in photography and screen printing. It’s pretty toxic stuff and can cause a nasty dermatitis. Given all that, it’s a good thing that this stuff was diluted to nonexistence before being administered to patients sublingually (under the tongue)! If it weren’t, it could have caused some damage.
This all makes me wonder how this study ever got past the Institutional Review Board (IRB). After all, if there’s active ingredient left over, then the study would be proposing to give a toxic substance to patients on ventilators in an ICU. If the investigators made it very clear to the IRB that the dilution would be such that there would be no potassium dichromate left, then the IRB should have asked about the ethics of giving both experimental groups what is, in essence, a placebo. More disturbing is that the investigators stopped the administration of β-agonist bronchodilators to these patients before they were started on placebo or treatment, in order “to avoid any potential influence and/or interaction.” Again, if there is potassium dichromate in the homeopathic remedy, then why did the IRB allow the investigators to administer it in the first place with no supporting evidence, either in clinical or animal models, that it might have an effect? If there is no potassium dichromate in the homeopathic remedy, then stopping effective medications in both study groups strikes me as unethical. In fact, the investigators essentially admit that it is diluted to nothing:
In homeopathic concentrations, potassium dichromate acts primarily by its mucolytic properties. In this study, we used a preparation of C30, which is equivalent to a potentiation of 30 dilutions, in which each of the 30 dilution steps is followed by subsequent vigorous succussions. Therefore, the above-described toxic effects were eliminated. In addition, the original orange-red color disappeared during the preparation. Onset of action may vary from patient to patient but is generally observed within 24 to 48 h.
What “above described toxic effects,” you ask? None, really. The investigators didn’t describe any potential toxic effects from potassium dichromate until the discussion section. Apparently, the reviewers didn’t read this study too carefully (which is, of course, one possible explanation for such woo making it into a journal with an impact factor of 4.008). Be that as it may, let’s look at the patient characteristics, shall we?
First, there were only 25 patients in each group, which is a pretty small number for anything other than a pilot study. You have to remember that, when studies are small, spurious results are more likely to occur. At first glance, the patient characteristics in this table appear pretty well balanced. At first glance. Actually, this is a good example of when statistical nonsignificance doesn’t necessarily mean clinically nonsignificant. For one thing, the stage of COPD in the control group was higher than that of the treatment group (1.20 ± 0.5 versus 1.08 ± 0.4, p=0.178). This seems very odd, because both groups are listed as having mild COPD by this criteria, given that the COPD stages run from 0 to 3, with 0 being normal lung function and 1 being the least severe. If the average COPD stage for each group was close to 1, then why did the patients have such difficulty coming off the ventilator? Something’s odd there, since the mean FEV1 (forced expiratory volume in 1 second) was 54.0 ± 5.3% in the potassium dichromate group and 52.4 ± 5.5% in the control group, both of which are very close to the range of stage 2 COPD (FEV1 between 35% and 49%). In other words, it would seem that most of the patients were bad stage 1 patients.
A more interesting difference, however, and potentially more likely to influence the results of the study comes when you look at the number of patients who were on home oxygen before being hospitalized and developing respiratory failure. In the control group, 9/25 patients were on chronic home oxygen, whereas in the potassium dichromate group, only 5/25 were on home oxygen. Leaving aside that both numbers seem very high for two groups whose COPD scores are 1.2 or below given that it’s usually patients with stage 3 COPD who require home oxygen, it is clear that the control group had nearly twice the number of patients who were on home oxygen before admission. This seems inconsistent with a small difference in the COPD score, and the low COPD scores seem inconsistent with such severe exacerbations. After all, the definition of stage 1 COPD is:
Often minimal shortness of breath with or without cough and/or sputum. Usually goes unrecognized that lung function is abnormal.
Essentially no patients with stage 1 COPD need home oxygen. Ditto stage 2 COPD, which is defined:
Often moderate or severe shortness of breath on exertion, with or without cough, sputum or dyspnea. Often the first stage at which medical attention is sought due to chronic respiratory symptoms or an exacerbation
By the measurements listed, the average patient in both groups had at worst slightly worse than stage 1 COPD, which makes it odd indeed that 36% and 20% of the control and potassium dichromate groups, respectively, were on home oxygen. Let’s just put it this way. Needing home oxygen is a good marker for one of two things: either more severe COPD or other concurrent lung conditions. Those four extra patients on home oxygen could potentially account for the longer time to extubation and longer length of stay in the hospital in the control group. We can’t tell if they do or not because the data isn’t presented in such a way to allow us to do so. It’s possible that the differences in patients on oxygen before admission made a difference. It’s also possible that this is just a spurious result from a relatively small study. Or, it’s possible that it might be correct and there might really be an effect, but this latter scenario is unlikely given the flaws in the study and the fact that no homeopath has yet explained a mechanism by which something like homeopathic potassium dichromate might do a single thing to eliminate secretions–or anything else, for that matter.
The bottom line is that, contrary to Dana Ullman’s representation of this study as slam-dunk evidence of the efficacy of homeopathy, it’s nothing more than a very questionable study in which it is unclear whether the treatment and control groups were truly comparable. The homeopaths’ conclusion would be hilarious were it not so sad that such woo has found its way into otherwise reputable journals:
The present study suggests that potassium dichromate C30 may be able to minimize the amount of tracheal secretions and therefore to allow earlier extubation when compared to placebo. Since the potentiation (dilution and vigorously shaking) of the study drug beyond the Avogadro number imposes no interaction with the patient’s metabolism, and due to the low cost of the drug, its use in the ICU may be beneficial, minimizing morbidity and mortality. Studies give some insight into the potential way of action of homeopathically prepared drugs. Cluster-cluster aggregation phenomena in aqueous solutions of fullerene-cyclodextrin conjugates, β-cyclodextrin, sodium chloride, sodium guanosine monophosphate, and a DNA oligonucleotide revealed that there are larger aggregates existent in dilute aqueous solutions than in more concentrated solutions.20 In another study, ultra-high dilutions of lithium chloride and sodium chloride (10-30 g cm-3) have been irradiated by x-rays and gamma-rays at 77 K, then progressively rewarmed to room temperature. During that phase, their thermoluminescence has been studied and it was found that, despite their dilution beyond the Avogadro number, the emitted light was specific of the original salts dissolved initially.
This is the first scientific study of the effect of potassium dichromate on tracheal secretions. While the mechanism of potentized (diluted and vigorously shaken) drugs still remains subject to research, several articles describe its clinical usefulness. The effect may be best explained by cybernetics, which means that the information of the homeopathic drug acts consensually on the regulator. Thereby, the body regains its original property to regulate physical parameters.
First off, it’s nice to see that the investigators essentially admit that diluting above Avogadro’s number eliminates any trace of the compound. It is, however, unclear why they brought up ultrahigh dilution solutions irradiated at 77 Kelvin (or -196° C) and then rewarmed. First off, 10 to 30 molecules per cc is an incredibly concentrated solution in homeopathic terms. Second, homeopaths don’t cool their solutions down to the temperature of liquid nitrogen, irradiate them, and then slowly rewarm them, making me doubt very much the relevance of the experiment to anything that homeopaths do. But the part about cybernetics cracks me up. That one was clearly pulled out of someone’s hat (or perhaps out of their nether regions); yet it got by the reviewer.
As much fun as I have deconstructing such studies, hoping in vain for a good study but inevitably being disappointed, it is still disconcerting to see this sort of study published in Chest. More disturbing still is that an IRB allowed such a study of a useless medication on intubated ICU patients with COPD. It just goes to show that peer review is not perfect. It may remain the best bulwark against pseudoscience, but it’s only as good as the reviewers, and it’s not a foolproof guarantee against pseudoscience. As you can see from this study, it’s making its way into even the ICU, which is one place where evidence-based medicine should rule supreme and in which there should be no place for woo or quackery. What I fear is that, as more and more pseudoscience and non-evidence-based woo invades medical school, the dividing line between evidence-based medicine and woo will blur even more, and, as the older generations of physicians retire, the newer generation, who has been exposed to woo in medical school, will be less willing or able to call a duck a duck when they see it. Quack quack.
REFERENCE:
Frass, M. (2005). Influence of Potassium Dichromate on Tracheal Secretions in Critically Ill Patients Chest, 127 (3), 936-941 DOI: 10.1378/chest.127.3.936

   Homeopathy for fibromyalgia: The Huffington Post bombs again
David Gorski
Link
Over the weekend, my wife and I happened to be in the pharmacy section of our local Target store. We happened to be looking for one of our favorite cold remedies, because both of us have been suffering from rather annoying colds, which have plagued both of us for the last week or two. As we perused the Cold and Flu section of the pharmacy, we were struck at how much shelf space was taken up by Airborne (which was “invented by a schoolteacher“). Nearly three years ago Airborne had to settle a case brought against it alleging false advertising to the tune of $23 million. Despite that, Airborne is still being sold, and there are even a whole bunch of knock-off products copying it. Then, as we continued to look for our favored cold remedy, we noted that, sitting right next to the extensive shelf space devoted to the various flavors and types of Airborne supplements, I saw Boiron’s homeopathic remedy for colds containing oscillococcinum, which is derived from duck liver and heart and diluted to 200C (a 10400-fold dilution).
Yes, I was a bit depressed after that. Now I know what my skeptical friends in the U.K. go through every time they walk into a Boots pharmacy.
Still, even though homeopathy is not as popular in the U.S. as it is in the U.K. and the rest of Europe, it’s obviously making some inroads if it’s being sold in Target. Steve Novella made a point at a panel at TAM8 in July to point out that it’s also being sold in Walmart, but since I rarely, if ever, shop at Walmart, I hadn’t noticed, although I had noticed various dubious concoctions being sold at Walgreens and CVS, two large pharmacy chains here in the U.S. Its relative popularity in different parts of the world aside, ever since I learned what homeopathy is and what its precepts are, I’ve always been fascinated how it can possibly be taken seriously. After all, a 200C homeopathic dilution is approximately 10377-fold more of a dilution than Avagadro’s number, meaning that it’s incredibly unlikely that such a remedy has even a single molecule of active ingredient in it. Homeopathy is water, nothing more, but that makes it the perfect form of quackery to examine when looking for reasons why people still believe it works. I’ve pointed this out, and Kimball Atwood has repeatedly pointed this out, arguing that homeopathy is the best “complementary and alternative medicine” modality to show the deficiencies in randomized clinical trials (RCTs) because, except in the case of adulterated remedies (which are all too common) or low dilution remedies less than approximately 12C (where there might actually be an incredibly tiny amount of active ingredient left), homeopathy is nothing more than water and sugar.
With these thoughts running through my head, not long after I got home, I noted an e-mail from a reader, who had forwarded me a link about homeopathy. My first thought was: Homeopathy? Not again. However, every so often I find it of value to examine the very best arguments that homeopathy apologists can put forth for their magic water and (hopefully) thereby understand a bit more how people can be persuaded that a system of “medicine” so unbelievably implausible from a basic science point of view that it is as close to being impossible as we can imagine in science can be so attractive to so many people. Also, it’s always fun to take on Dana Ullman particularly after having kept it rather serious over my last few turns here on SBM. I realize that some will criticize me for “slumming” here, but throw me a bone every once in a while. I have to have some fun every now and then. In any case, on Friday, everybody’s favorite clueless homeopathic apologist posted an article on–where else?–that wretched hive of scum and quackery, The Huffington Post, entitling it Exploring the Research on Homeopathic Treatment for Fibromyalgia. It is, as we like to say, a “target-rich” environment.
FIBROMYALGIA: A WOO MAGNET
Ullman likes to try to impress his readers with a boatload of “science-y” talk before he delves into the woo that is homeopathy, and in this case he starts out with a relatively straightforward description of what fibromyalgia is; that is, after he asserts that “the three to six million Americans who suffer with fibromyalgia will be pleased know that several studies published in leading medical journals have found outstanding results from homeopathic treatment.” Not so fast there, Dana, as we will soon see.
Basically, fibromyalgia is a somewhat amorphous syndrome, labeled a syndrome rather than a disease because we don’t have a good handle yet on the mechanisms resulting in the condition and there are no characteristic diagnostic tests that nail down the diagnosis. In brief, fibromyalgia is a condition of chronic pain and allodynia, which is a heightened painful response to a stimulus that doesn’t normally cause pain. In the case of fibromyalgia, that stimulus is pressure. Other symptoms can include tingling of the skin, muscle spasms, limb weakness, nerve pain, muscle twitching, palpitations, bowel disturbances, and sleep disturbances. Because of the plethora of symptoms that can fall under the mantle of a fibromyalgia diagnosis and the lack of scientific consensus on its cause or specific physical findings or lab abnormalities that define the disease, there are some physicians who do not accept fibromyalgia as a defined syndrome. In my own anecdotal experience, this number seems to be decreasing. Most physicians appear to accept fibromyalgia as a syndrome, even though most don’t know how to treat it.
As you might be able to guess, because fibromyalgia is a syndrome of unclear etiology with a wide variety of physical complaints, widely varying severity, and a clinical course that waxes and wanes, it is a woo magnet. Indeed, many conditions that scientists do not yet understand well and/or for which we do not yet have particularly good treatments are woo magnets. As I pointed out back in August when I described a deceptively framed study of tai chi in fibromyalgia:
These sorts of conditions are the most frustrating of conditions to deal with, particularly for patients but also for doctors. After all, no one goes into medicine to tell patients that there’s not much he can do for them; yet that’s what doctors all too often end up having no choice but to tell fibromyalgia patients. Not surprisingly, patients are neither happy nor satisfied with this, nor should they be. They’re suffering, and they want relief. Also not surprisingly they’re willing to try almost anything, including the rankest forms of quackery peddled by unscrupulous quacks.
Enter homeopathy.
“CONVENTIONAL MEDICINE DOESN’T WORK WELL, SO USE HOMEOPATHY”
Before delving into the “evidence” (such as it is) for homeopathy in fibromyalgia, Ullman catalogs the lack of efficacy of many of the pharmacological and other treatments currently used for fibromyalgia. It’s hard to disagree that the current treatments we have for fibromyalgia basically, to put it bluntly, suck, nor is it my intention to try to argue that they are better than they are. On the other hand, Dana misrepresents an editorial as a review article, and that’s not cool:
In 2010, a systematic review of the most recently used conventional drugs for fibromyalgia was published in a leading scientific journal (Clauw, 2010). Although some drugs had beneficial effects, the author acknowledged the significant limitations of these benefits and the need to utilize other treatment options. He wrote, “Because of the modest overall analgesic efficacy seen with any class of analgesic drug in any chronic pain state, we should be particularly aggressive about using more non-pharmacological therapies in treating patients with chronic pain.”
The article cited by Ullman was indeed published in Nature Reviews Rheumatology. However, the article by Daniel Clauw was in actuality describing a study published in a less prestigious journal, The Journal of Pain. What Dana cited was the commentary, not the original study. Dana also cherry-picked some quotes from Dr. Clauw’s commentary, leaving out, conveniently enough, passages like this:
The authors concluded that the three drugs were superior to placebo for all outcomes noted above, with the exceptions of duloxetine for fatigue, milnacipran for sleep disturbance, and pregabalin for depressed mood.
And:
An important lesson from these studies is that these first three approved drugs are likely to be working at the root pathogenic cause of symptom expression in fibromyalgia, rather than just ‘covering up’ a particular symptom such as pain. When individuals have a favorable response to any of these drugs, they typically improve across many symptom domains.
D’oh! How’s that for SBM “only treating the symptoms?
This is, of course, just Dana being Dana. It is also undeniably true that, advances over the last decade or so notwithstanding, we still have a long way to go in developing effective and safe treatments with few side effects for fibromyalgia patients. But does our current lack of highly effective treatments imply that we should be open to using homeopathy to treat fibromyalgia?
Not so fast, there pardner.
HOMEOPATHY AND FIBROMYALGIA
Before I move on to the discussion of the best evidence that Dana can produce for the use of homeopathy in fibromyalgia, I always find it instructive to see how a homeopath defines homeopathy, as Dana does here:
Homeopathic medicine is a 200+-year-old system of medicine that utilizes specially prepared doses of medicines made from various substances of the plant, mineral or animal kingdom. Each medicine is prescribed for its capacity to cause, if given in overdose to healthy people, symptoms similar to those that the sick person is experiencing. Because basic physiology recognizes that symptoms represent defenses of the body (and mind) in its efforts to fight infection and/or adapt to stress, a homeopathic medicine is selected for its capacity to mimic a person’s own symptoms, thereby augmenting their own defensive response.
Just as vaccines and allergy treatments are in part based on this same premise — whatever a substance causes in overdose, it will elicit an immune response when taken in small doses — homeopathic medicines are a system of helping the “wisdom of the body” defend and heal itself.
In other words, it’s the same nonsense that homeopaths have been saying for 200 years, with the added nonsense of comparing homeopathy to vaccination. Fortunately, Dr. Crislip just covered that very topic so that I don’t have to again. Perhaps most gratifying of all, Ullman admits:
In homeopathy, ALL ailments are considered “syndromes,” that is, all disease is a constellation of physical and psychological symptoms, and each patient has his or her own subtly different syndrome of a disease. The fact that people with fibromyalgia tend to have sometimes slightly or overtly differing symptoms from each other is no significant problem for homeopathic treatment. In fact, homeopathic treatment tends to be easier when patients have idiosyncratic or unusual symptoms.
Actually, I’ll buy that last sentence, but not for the reasons Ullman gives. The real reason that homeopathic treatment appears to “work” better for patients with idiosyncratic or unusual symptoms is not because homeopathy “works” for anything beyond placebo effects. Rather, it’s because such patients tend to have syndromes, conditions, or diseases that SBM currently can’t treat very well.
Conditions like fibromyalgia.
So let’s look at the evidence. Before we do, one should note that, as Kimball Atwood has pointed out time and time again, RCTs can be wrong. Indeed, in an ideal world, even a perfectly conducted RCT has a 5% chance of producing a false positive result by random chance alone. Add the factors described by John Ioannidis and the observation that, the more implausible the hypothesis being tested, the more likely there are to be false positive results in RCTs, it’s quite possible to find a clinical trial that appears to show efficacy for homeopathy. The key word is appears.
The first study (PDF here) cited by Ullman is actually somewhat interesting. It tested a 6C dilution, which is only a 1012-fold dilution, of Rhus toxicodendron. That means that, unlike most homeopathic remedies, there is actually some active substance left, which makes it possible, albeit unlikely, that whatever extract was in the homeopathic remedy might actually have a pharmacological effect. It was also a very small study (30 patients), which are exactly the sorts of studies that are most likely to have a false positive result. Moreover, it was done more than 20 years ago, which was an era when the diagnostic criteria for fibromyalgia hadn’t been firmed up. More importantly, Dana left out a huge bit of information, namely that David Colquhoun reanalyzed the data of Fisher et al and found that “this re-analysis shows that the trial of Fisher et al provides no firm evidence for the efficacy of homeopathic treatment for fibrositis.” In other words, Fisher’s trial is not compelling evidence–or even good evidence at all–for a specific effect due to homeopathy on fibromyalgia.
Next, Ullman cites four papers by Bell et al at the University of Arizona. Two of the studies were published in real journals (here and here), two in the woo journal Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, whose history of publishing dubious CAM research makes it an unreliable source, at best. These studies are also fairly underwhelming, as is the trial by Relton et al published last year. For one thing, all the studies by Bell et al suffer from low numbers of patients, as usual. For another thing, Bell hasn’t published anything on fibromyalgia since 2004. Whenever someone like Dr. Bell publishes a flurry of papers in a single year and then nothing for six years after, it always raises red flags. Specifically, it makes me wonder whether Dr. Bell couldn’t replicate her own results in order to move on. Also, in the Rheumatology paper, I notice several flaws in the randomization in characteristics that are important disease endpoints, which means that the two groups aren’t the same when it comes to severity. Moreover, the treatment group and placebo group differed in the number on antihistamines; the authors claim this didn’t make a difference but present no evidence to show that this is so. Finally, in Table 2, one notes that there are no differences in any of the endpoints for the study groups until the results are “adjusted,” which always sends up red flags for me.
In the end, all Ullman has are a handful of studies, all of them relatively small, all of them with not particularly convincing results. As Edzard Ernst put it in his recent systematic review of homeopathy for the treatment of fibromyalgia, which includes a discussion of each of the RCTs cited by Ullman:
Even though our searches were thorough, we cannot be sure that all relevant RCTs were located. Negative studies tend to remain unpublished [24]. This bias could therefore have distorted the overall picture. All the four RCTs tested different homoeopathic treatments or approaches; this means that no independent replication of any of the tested approaches exists. The paucity and, at times, disappointing quality of the available RCTs render firm conclusions problematic.
In summary, the findings of the four existing RCTs all favour homoeopathy over controls. Yet none of the studies is sufficiently rigorous to provide a definitive answer. Future studies should minimise bias more effectively than did the trials available so far.
Another point is that, with the exception of the last study in which homeopaths could choose whatever remedies they wish, all of these studies used rather “weak” dilutions of the homeopathic remedy, usually on the order 6C. At such a dilution, it is quite possible that there remains a significant amount of remedy left in the homeopathic concoction, although it’s unlikely to be a pharmacologically relevant amount because it’s diluted 1012 times.
More to the point, Ernst writes:
When evaluating the evidence for or against homoeopathy one should briefly comment on the plausibility of this treatment. Homoeopathy is based on two main principles. The Law of Similars claims that, if a substance causes symptoms in healthy volunteers, it can be used to treat these symptoms effectively when they occur in patients. The law of the infinitesimal dose holds that, if a substance is serially diluted in the homoeopathic way, it becomes not weaker but stronger, even if the dilution is beyond Avogadro’s number. Currently, there is little scientific evidence to support these theoretical principles. It is therefore difficult to accept that homoeopathy is biologically plausible.
Actually, Ernst is actually understating the point. Perhaps the reviewers forced him to tone it down. As I’ve said before, homeopathy is beyond just “biologically implausible.” It’s so implausible from a basic science standpoint alone that, for homeopathy to work, huge swaths of our current understanding of physics, chemistry, and biology would have to be not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong. Huge sections of science textbooks would have to be rewritten. Of course, as a skeptic, I have to concede that it is possible that this is so. However, given the mountains of evidence that show that homeopathy can’t work, it would take mountains of evidence of similar size and rigor to make scientists start to think that homeopathy can work.
Believe it or not, I’d be perfectly willing to reconsider my skepticism of homeopathy if homepaths could produce in support of their woo 1% of the evidence that currently exists to show that homeopathy doesn’t work. Small clinical trials don’t count, particularly given their flaws and the very real possibility of publication bias, in which positive trials are far more likely to be published than negative trials. Couple that with the very nature of the condition upon which homeopathy was tested, and the results of these handful of trials are even less convincing. After all, fibromyalgia is very prone to placebo effects, regression to the mean, and confirmation bias when assessing therapies. Personally, I find the study testing tai chi on fibromyalgia to be far more convincing than any of the trials of homeopathy here. Of course, in that case, I also didn’t see any compelling evidence why tai chi would be any more effective than any other similar gentle exercise.
NASTY SKEPTICS
Apparently burned by past criticism, Ullman concludes his post with a hilarious “note to and about skeptics of homeopathy.” Dana being Dana, it’s an amusing bit of woo-ful weasel words. I find it particularly appropriate that, in light of recent posts by both Kimball and myself, Dana decides to pull out this hoary alt-med argument for homeopathy:
These fundamentalists also love to assert that “there is no plausible mechanism” for how homeopathic medicines work. Such statements display a serious ignorance of medical history because people who say this ignore the fact that it was only relatively recently did physicians understood how aspirin worked, and yet, no doctor (or patient) chose to not use this drug simply because the mechanism of action was not adequately understood.
Can you say “straw man” argument? Sure, I knew you could. Just read Kimball‘s and my posts if you don’t believe me. As Kimball so eloquently put it, “Plausibility ≠ Knowing the Mechanism.” The point is not that we have to know in detail the biological and chemical mechanisms by which any given treatment to be tested is thought to work. The point is that any proposed mechanism or mechanism that would have to be in force if a treatment worked, whether that mechanism is proposed or not, should not violate known physical laws whose foundation rests on, as Kimball put it, “far more solid ground than any number of equivocal, bias-and-error-prone clinical trials could hope to overturn.” Or, as I put it earlier in this post, implausibility is the key. If, based on well-established science, a therapy’s mechanism is so implausible that multiple well-established laws science would have to be totally wrong, then that particular therapy will require an equivalent amount of evidence in its favor to make us begin to doubt those physical laws. As Carl Sagan put it, extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, and homeopathy makes some doozies of extraordinary claims.
Dana pulls out some true howlers in his criticism of “skeptics” as well. For instance:
Some “deniers” are audacious enough to suggest that the “weight of evidence” evaluating homeopathy shows that these medicines do not have any benefit beyond that of a placebo. Was Thomas Edison’s discovery of electricity false because 999 experiments failed to produce electricity and only one that was successful? Is the weight of evidence that he failed?
Deniers will inevitably assert that Edison’s discovery is proven every day, and yet, homeopaths likewise will say that homeopathy is proven every day by the hundreds of millions of its users worldwide, including many of the most respected scientists, physicians, corporate leaders, political leaders, clergy and spiritual leaders, literary greats, sports superstars, and every day average people.
Thomas Edison’s work didn’t violate known physical laws, and, more importantly, the proof was undeniably in the pudding. His lights worked. Of course, to Dana homeopathy works, but I’d point out that it’s undeniable that lightbulbs work. It’s quote deniable that homeopathy does, even under the best circumstances. (Show me homeopathy curing a case or two of a deadly disease rather than conditions with waxing and waning symptoms prone to placebo effects–pancreatic cancer, for example–and I might reconsider.) It’s also amusing to see Dana, after having criticized skeptics for not knowing history, falsely attribute the discovery of electricity to Thomas Edison. Edison did some fantastic work with electricity and did invent the a practical electrical lightbulb that came to be the standard bulb used for over a century, but he didn’t discover electricity.
Ullman also can’t resist a couple of his favorite gambits. First, there’s special pleading, in essence, the claim that “you can’t study my woo in RCTs.” Then, of course, there’s the infamous pharma shill gambit, which Ullman applies with gusto:
Sadly, many people who claim to be skeptics are simply representatives of Big Pharma. In England, the leading anti-homeopathy organization, Sense about Science, is led by a former public relations expert who has a long history of representing Big Pharma companies (SourceWatch.org – see link in References).
Even if that were true, it would not change the fact that homeopathy is nothing more than sympathetic magic, combining the law of similars and the law of contagion. It’s magical prescientific thinking.
There’s a reason why homeopathy endured for nearly a hundred years as a “respectable” bit of medicine, even despite the knowledge among scientists that it was bunk dating back to the early 1800s. It’s because the “allopathic” medicine of the time frequently used remedies that were worse than useless; some were actively harmful, such as bleeding and purging with toxic metals like mercury and cadmium. In comparison, homeopathy could easily appear to do better, because, well, it’s water and therefore at least didn’t do any active harm. Many diseases would resolve spontanously for a significant fraction of patients anyway. However, as medicine became more science-based, it started to be able to offer actual treatments that did some good, and homeopathy had nothing to offer but magic.
Still, there are a lot of people who still believe in magic. Because RCTs are complicated and there are many conditions and diseases that are difficult to diagnose and treat, it will always be possible for people like Dana Ullman to use science-y-sounding language and cherry-picked studies to make it sound as though homeopathy is anything more than witchcraft (choice of words intentional).
And it will be possible for wretched hives of scum and quackery like HuffPo to give people like Ullman a platform.

   Ososillyococcinum and other Flu bits.
Mark Crislip
Link
Osillococcinum
I keep half an eye on the medicine displays in stores when I shop, and this year is the first time I have seen Oscillococcinum being sold. Airborne as been a standard for years, but Airborne has been joined by Oscillococcinum on the shelves. Dumb and dumber. It may be a bad case of confirmation bias, but it seems I am seeing more iocane powder, I mean oscillococcinum, at the stores.
On a recent podcast I was listening to one of the hosts suggested a homeopathic remedy for flu symptoms, and then specifically suggested osillococcinum. This is a technology podcast, the 404, and the hosts are certainly bright, educated people. Why would he suggest osillococcinum? Probably because he unaware of how oh so silly the product is.
Look at the box. Seems impressive.
It is non sedating, no drug interactions, no side effects. It also has no cholesterol and no radon. It is, I have heard, the biggest emitter of N-rays ever discovered. It is “officially included in the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia of the United States”, and we know from yesterdays post how worthless that designation is.
The active ingredient is listed as anas barbarae hepatis et cordis extractum 200C.
Whoa. The power of Latin, like a Harry Potter curse. I bet the product has been imbued with the Confundus charm, which may explain why it is “used by millions of people and is recommended by doctors around the world.”
What is the active ingredient, this anas barbarae hepatis et cordis extractum?
In the 1919 flu epidemic a physician who did not understand that artifacts on the slide, probably bubbles, move randomly due to Brownian motion. Looking at the tissues of flu patients with a microscope, he found what he thought was not only the cause of influenza, but the cause of all diseases: small cocci (round balls) that oscillated under the microscope. He found these wiggling bubbles in all the tissues of all the ill people he examined and thought he discovered the true cause of all disease. Sigh. Yet another cause of all illness. He is the only person, before or since, to see these oscillating cocci. Hence the name.
Subsequently, for obscure reasons, he became of the opinion that the heart and liver of the Muscovy Duck were the most concentrated source of these oscillating cocci. I have found the suggestion that it was because duck liver and heart is a source of influenza, but the product predates the discovery of the influenza, so that would be an oh so silly explanation.
So how best to to treat disease? Turn the oscilliococinum into a homeopathic nostrum:
Into a one litre bottle, a mixture of pancreatic juice and glucose is poured. Next a Canard de Barbarie is decapitated and 35 grams of its liver and 15 grams of its heart are put into the bottle. Why liver? Doctor Roy writes: “The Ancients considered the liver as the seat of suffering, even more important than the heart, which is a very profound insight, because it is on the level of the liver that the pathological modifications of the blood happen, and also there the quality of the energy of our heart muscle changes in a durable manner.”
After 40 days in the sterile bottle, liver and heart autolyse (disintegrate) into a kind of goo, which is then “potentized” with the Korsakov method where the glass containing the remedy is shaken and then just emptied and refilled, and the dilution factor is assumed to be 1:100.
Go to Starbucks tomorrow and get your Americano at 200C made with the same method as oscilliococinum. They will make your drink. Pour it out and fill the cup with water and shake it. Then pour it out, fill it up with water and shake it again. Pour it out etc.. And so on 200 times, the ultimate rinse, lather, repeat. And that should potentize the drink such that you will never sleep again.
By the time they are done, the duck goo can be found at one part duck goo in 102000 water molecules, which is damn impressive since there are only about 1080 (+/- 3) total atoms in the entire observable universe. Then one drop is placed on a bunch of tiny pills and sold for about a dollar a vial in the US. I bitch that linezolid is 50 dollars a pill, but at least there is something useful, 600 mg in fact, in the pill.
And that is the active ingredient. Active. I do not think it means what you think it means. Is here anyone of sound mind who reads the above who thinks oscilliococinum has any potential to treat flu? Really? I have a bridge in Brooklyn I would like to sell you. How this nostrum is supposed to alter the course of influenza is a delusion understood only by homeopaths. Anyone who understands the life cycle of influenza, the immune response to infection would find this concoction mystifying as a treatment for flu or its symptoms.
Oscilliococinum is popular over the world, and many of the testimonials on the interwebs suggest it is effective as both a preventative and a therapy, a stark example of why anecdotes are considered a suboptimal form of evidence.
There is no better example of the disconnect between EBM and SBM than oscilliococinum used for the treatment of flu, since the Cochran reviews have evaluated oscilliococinum and suggests that while it is useless for a prevention, it shortens symptoms by 0.28 days. For reasons I cannot discover, the Cochrane review on homeopathy was withdrawn. Embarrassment would be my guess. Other reviews have found no effect of oscilliococinum on flu symptoms.
Think about it. .28 days is about 6 hours. Have you ever had the flu or other viral illness and could say yes, now, at 3 pm, I am symptom free and no longer ill? Viral illnesses don’t die, they fade away. Given the nature of oscilliococinum, it is far more likely that the 6 hours from the studies was the random variation seen in clinical trials. There is zero reason, based on the known pathophysiology of influenza and the known origin of oscilliococinum, that the latter would have any effects on the former. And yet, while subsequently withdrawn, the folks at the Cochrane reviews felt it was a reasonable to perform a meta-analysis on nonsense.
Cochrane Reviews and the Flu Vaccine
Fortunately no one needs to go one on one with Death with oscilliococinum as your wingman. It has been a very quiet flu season. Much better than last year, when, thanks to H1N1 we were maxed out in the ICU.
There is a better way to prevent the flu than dilute, liquified duck innards. The flu vaccine. The Cochrane folks put out an update of their systematic review for the effectiveness of influenza. And their conclusions? It is not the greatest vaccine but effective.
In the relatively uncommon circumstance of vaccine matching the viral circulating strain and high circulation, 4% of unvaccinated people versus 1% of vaccinated people developed influenza symptoms (risk difference (RD) 3%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 2% to 5%). The corresponding figures for poor vaccine matching were 2% and 1% (RD 1, 95% CI 0% to 3%). These differences were not likely to be due to chance. Vaccination had a modest effect on time off work and had no effect on hospital admissions or complication rates. Inactivated vaccines caused local harms and an estimated 1.6 additional cases of Guillain-Barré Syndrome per million vaccinations. The harms evidence base is limited.
AUTHORS’ CONCLUSIONS: Influenza vaccines have a modest effect in reducing influenza symptoms and working days lost.
You get the feeling it pains them to admit the flu vaccine has efficacy, what with the caveat “In the relatively uncommon circumstance of vaccine matching the viral circulating strain and high circulation” in the conclusion.
And then, the weirdness in the abstract:
WARNING: This review includes 15 out of 36 trials funded by industry (four had no funding declaration). An earlier systematic review of 274 influenza vaccine studies published up to 2007 found industry funded studies were published in more prestigious journals and cited more than other studies independently from methodological quality and size. Studies funded from public sources were significantly less likely to report conclusions favorable to the vaccines. The review showed that reliable evidence on influenza vaccines is thin but there is evidence of widespread manipulation of conclusions and spurious notoriety of the studies. The content and conclusions of this review should be interpreted in light of this finding.
Fine. Who pays for the study can subtly bias the outcomes. I have written about that before. It does not necessarily discredit a study, but you do have to read and interpret the studies carefully and take the conclusions with a bit of salt substitute.
That is where, I thought, a meta-analysis comes in. Someone like Cochrane reviews the data with no concern about the quality of the journal or notoriety of the references. The Ccochrane reviews, I thought, looked at the numbers unbiased by the spin in the conclusions or where it was published.
So I can only think of two reasons why this warning was published.
1) The authors do not like the conclusions from the data, and are undermining the result, spinning the abstract to try and sway the message casual readers will take away from the review.
or
2) The authors are saying they are biased by the conclusions in the papers and the notoriety of some studies and as a result their analysis of the numbers is not to be trusted. In other words, they are incredulous rubes who just fell off the turnip truck and were sold a bill of goods by those city slickers with their manipulated conclusions and spurious notoriety. Sad either way.
The discussion is odd, with the authors saying that everyone misuses their meta-analysis and ignores the data.
Both generalizations are not supported by any evidence and seem to originate from the desire to use our review to support decisions already taken. The misquotes appear to be based on both the abstract and Plain language summary (which is what you would expect from a superficial reading of the review by people with a specific agenda).
They also use significant column inches to demonstrate just how the ACIP misquoted them.
and
The CDC authors clearly do not weight interpretation by quality of the evidence, but quote anything that supports their theory.
What a weird, petulant little potshot at the CDC. I could see a statement like that maybe in an editorial, definitely in a blog entry, but in the text of a major review? It makes me wonder if the Cochrane reviews have any editorial oversight for their content. If they do, then their editors have some splainin’ to do as to how a major evidence based review could revert to ‘Mommy, mommy, I don’t like the way the CDC is playing with my ball and they are calling me names. Make them stoooopppp.’
It is like reading a review of gold mining efficacy and the purity of the mined gold, and the author noting that some of the mines are near Las Vegas, a den of sin and that gold miners discuss mining at the roulette tables and sometimes the gold in made into baubles that decorate painted women, so the content and conclusions of the mining review should be interpreted in light of these findings. So weird.
It is probably projection on my part, but I find the Cochran reviews on influenza vaccination to be biased against the flu vaccine in a subtle way that I do not see in the other reviews. The oscillococcinum review, while fundamentally stupid given the nature of the intervention, brainlessly followed the data, even though there was no plausibility for the intervention.
The choice of adjectives used by the authors seem designed to cast doubt on vaccine efficacy. Now I am a vaccine proponent, and I could very well be reading into the text something that is not there. For an example, the plain language summary says
Inactivated influenza vaccines decrease the risk of symptoms of influenza and time off work, but their effects are minimal, especially if the vaccines and the circulating viruses are mismatched.
Minimal: of a minimum amount, quantity, or degree;
The data says
In the relatively uncommon circumstance of vaccine matching the viral circulating strain and high circulation, 4% of unvaccinated people versus 1% of vaccinated people developed influenza symptoms.
In a country the size of the US, that is the difference between 12 million and 3 million getting flu if everyone were vaccinated (yes, I know, all 300,000,000 Americans are not healthy adults). Worst case, it would be 6 million vrs 3 million. Still, across the whole population of the country, that would not be a minimal effect.
Or the number needed to treat:
The combined results of these trials showed that under ideal conditions (vaccine completely matching circulating viral configuration) 33 healthy adults need to be vaccinated to avoid one set of influenza symptoms.
In comparison, there are 250,000 new cases of Hepatitis B each year in the US and maybe 4000 HPV related cancer deaths a year in the US. Are the effects of the flu vaccine minimal in preventing these diseases? Maybe. But that is a judgement call, not a medical call.
Flu vaccine seems good intervention, a reasonable bang for the buck. I would say it is a moderately effective vaccine with widespread health benefits beyond the prevention of acute influenza (see below). The cost effectiveness of flu vaccination is debatable and is ultimately a value judgment. In medicine they try an calculate the quality-adjusted life-year of an intervention to see if it is worth it to society.
It is form of evaluation that makes my brain hurt and I lack the knowledge to do much except to take them at face value. The outcome of cost-effectiveness evaluations depends on the assumptions made. For the elderly, you get conclusions like this:
Vaccination was cost saving, i.e., it both reduced medical expenses and improved health, for all age groups and geographic areas analyzed in the base case. For people aged 65 years and older, vaccination saved $8.27 and gained 1.21 quality-adjusted days of life per person vaccinated. Vaccination of the 23 million elderly people unvaccinated in 1993 would have gained about 78 000 years of healthy life and saved $194 million. In univariate sensitivity analysis, the results remained cost saving except for doubling vaccination costs, including future medical costs of survivors, and lowering vaccination effectiveness. With assumptions most unfavorable to vaccination, cost per quality-adjusted life-year ranged from $35,822 for ages 65 to 74 years to $598,487 for ages 85 years and older.
In the US a cost per quality-adjusted life-year of around $50000 is considered acceptable for an intervention.
It appears to me that the authors of the Cochrane reviewers think flu vaccination is not a worthwhile public health intervention, which is fine, but quit being a weasel and hiding behind words like minimal and complaining that people misuse your reviews for their own ends. The get close to admitting this in the discussion:
Given the limited availability of resources for mass immunization, the use of influenza vaccines should be primarily directed where there is clear evidence of benefit.
If I waited for clear evidence in medicine I would treat no one. However, the preponderance of data from basic principals to epidemiology to clinical trials leads me to conclude that the flu vaccine is moderately effective and cost effective. Someday, I hope, they will develop the universal flu vaccine and then, with universal vaccination, we will get rid of flu morbidity and mortality. But, to quote Rumsfeldt, I have to fight the wars with the weapons I have.
The Cochrane reviewers appear to be whiny, little babies. BTW. It is not an ad hominem since I do not think the review is wrong or flawed because they are crybabies. The substance is fine, the style is whiny crybaby. Boo frigity who. Got an issue? Here’s a tissue.
Either way, the confidence I have in the Cochrane reviews, at least as far as influenza vaccine goes, is now at an all time low.
A Cherry Picked Study.
There are multiple potential benefits from the flu vaccine:
1) You do not get the flu this year.
1a) You have a milder case of flu.
b) You do not pass the flu to others.
iii) You do not die of flu.
IV) You do not die of short term complications of flu.
FIve) You do not die of long term complications of flu.
6) You may not get the flu in the future with other strains. It would appear that those who had the 1976 swine flu vaccine has some protection against the 2009 strain and since strains of flu keep returning, if there is a mismatch in the flu and the vaccine this year, it may give you benefit in the future.
One of the arguments against the efficacy of the flu vaccine as a preventative against death is the fact that those who get the vaccine have decreased mortality when there is no circulating flu. It is suggested that the decreased mortality is not due to the flu vaccine, but that those who get the vaccine are healthier.
Could there be an alternative explanation?
There are two ongoing themes in the ID literature that have yet to overlap. One is people who get severe infections that require hospitalization not only have increased short term mortality, but long term mortality as well. Why they die is not as well worked out, but in those who die after pneumonia have increased inflammatory markers at discharge.
The other theme is that inflammation is a prothombotic state and patients with acute infections are more likely to have strokes, heart attacks and pulmonary embolisms and that risk of vascular events can be elevated for up to a year. Even an aggressive tooth cleaning increases the risk for a vascular event.
The rate of vascular events significantly increased in the first 4 weeks after invasive dental treatment (incidence ratio, 1.50 [95% CI, 1.09 to 2.06]) and gradually returned to the baseline rate within 6 months.
I have said before that if probiotics could really boost your immune function, they should also increase vascular events like stroke and heart attack.
Infection leads to inflammation leads to clot leads to vascular events. If you could stop that cascade, say with a vaccine, you could conceivably decrease the number of deaths. And so it does with a combination of the flu and pneumococcal vaccine.
Of the 36,636 subjects recruited, 7292 received both PPV and TIV, 2076 received TIV vaccine alone, 1875 received PPV alone, and 25,393 were unvaccinated, with a duration of follow‐up of 45,834 person‐years. Baseline characteristics were well matched between the groups, except that there were fewer male patients in the PPV and TIV group and fewer cases of comorbid chronic obstructive pulmonary disease among unvaccinated persons. At week 64 from commencement of the study, dual‐vaccinees experienced fewer deaths (hazard ratio [HR], 0.65; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.55–0.77]; P<.001) and fewer cases of pneumonia (HR, 0.57; 95% CI, 0.51–0.64; P<.001), ischemic stroke (HR, 0.67; 95% CI, 0.54–0.83; P<.001), and acute myocardial infarction (HR, 0.52; 95% CI, 0.38–0.71; P<.001), compared with unvaccinated subjects. Dual vaccination resulted in fewer coronary (HR, 0.59; 95% CI, 0.44–0.79; P<.001) and intensive care admissions (HR, 0.45; 95% CI, 0.22–0.94; P=.03), compared with among unvaccinated subjects.
Note: the beneficial effects occurred up to 64 weeks after receiving the vaccines; influenza vaccine could conceivably protect from death outside of flu season because vaccination prevents the sustained detrimental inflammatory effect of infections.
This result does not hold true in every study, but the data suggests that the beneficial effects of preventing influenza are wide-ranging and not limited to avoiding an acute viral pneumonia. The effects of both influenza and the vaccine are more complicated than a simple flu vaccination prevents flu.
Two Statements
There are two statements that pretty much insure that the writer is an influenza goof.
One is that the H1N1 pandemic last year was no big deal. I do not know what planet they were on, but H1N1 brought my hospitals right to the edge of the volume of severe illness we could handle. In my system we also had around 10 deaths, several in pregnant females and all in young people. In 25 years I had never had a young person die of acute influenza until last year, and I do not want to repeat the experience.
One of our hospitals is a Trauma Center and we able to save a few patients who would have otherwise died because we offer ECMO. While the epidemic was not particularly virulent compared to historical disasters like the 1919 pandemic, it was the worst flu season I have experienced.
The other statement is that the CDC is “backing off” the claim that influenza kills 36,000 people a year, as if the prior estimates were a lie.
The problem with medicine is we develop better methodologies and techniques to try to answer difficult questions. How many people die of influenza? For years the answer has been around 36,000 and I have discussed the paper that resulted in that number. It was, like all epidemiologic studies, imperfect, but was the best at the time. Now they have a better study.
For H1N1 in 2010, the estimates for total direct and indirect deaths is ~12,470, with a range from ~8,870 to ~18,300. Certainly less than 36,000. How about other years? Turns out that, like much of medicine, the answer is complicated and depends on the year and the circulating strain of flu. Some years are better than others. Estimated number of annual influenza-associated deaths with underlying pneumonia and influenza by age group — United States, 1976–77 through 2006–07 influenza seasons cause was 6,309 deaths a year, with a minimum of 961 and a maximum of almost 15,000 deaths, plus or minus the usual margin of error.
The estimated number of annual influenza-associated deaths with underlying respiratory and circulatory causes, by age group — United States, 1976–77 through 2006–07 influenza seasons was an average of 23,000 deaths with a minimum of 3000 and a maximum of 48,000.
Like so much in medicine the answer hinges on the phase ‘it depends.’ The CDC used more sophisticated techniques and came up more nuanced numbers. When someone asserts that the CDC is backing away from prior numbers, you know they have no understanding of medicine or epidemiology and the constant urge to improve. Unlike most SCAM’s, which have made almost no substantive improvements since their founding. Of course you cannot improve on perfection. Or increase by multiplying something by zero.
So get the vaccine and avoid the o-so-silly-o-coccinum.

How rabid dog saliva became an approved and endorsed remedy in Canada
A recent blog post by a British Columbia naturopath is raising questions from health professionals about the practice of naturopathy, and the use of homeopathic remedies to treat children with serious behaviour problems.
Scott Gavura on April 19, 2018
Link

A recent blog post by a British Columbia naturopath is raising questions from health professionals about the practice of naturopathy, and the use of homeopathic remedies. Anke Zimmerman, a Victoria-based naturopath, wrote a blog post on how she treated a child’s behavioural problems with a remedy made from a rabid dog’s saliva. (UPDATE 4/21: The original post has been pulled down, but a PDF as it existed on April 18 may be found here.) This led to letters from British Columbia’s public health officials to the federal regulator, Health Canada, asking how this remedy could have come to be approved for sale in Canada. As per the CBC:
A B.C. naturopath’s claim that she treated a small child’s behaviour problems with a homeopathic remedy derived from rabid dog saliva has prompted a letter to the federal government from the province’s senior public health official. Provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry said she will be writing to Health Canada to protest its approval of a treatment known as lyssinum after reading a blog post written by naturopath Anke Zimmermann of Victoria. Henry wasn’t aware of the substance before reading Zimmermann’s post, but said she has already expressed concerns to the federal government about the regulation of homeopathic products.
Zimmermann is a licensed naturopath in British Columbia, and she’s using a product that has been approved by Health Canada. How did it come to this?
Naturopathic doctors are not medical doctors
Naturopathy has been described at SBM as a chimera, something that’s imagined, but in reality is illusory or impossible to achieve. That’s an apt description, as the practice is a strange assortment of unorthodox, discarded, and disparate alternative health practices, linked by a philosophy based on pre-scientific ideas of medicine. “Naturopathic Doctors” promote themselves as health professionals capable of delivering primary care, akin to medical doctors. However, there is little in common between medical doctors and “naturopathic doctors”. Naturopathy is actually an alternative medicine practice that encompasses a variety of modalities including homeopathy, herbal medicine, and Traditional Chinese Medicine.
Naturopaths may use conventional medicine as part of their practice, but this tends to occur only when its use aligns with the naturopathic belief system. What makes a treatment or intervention “naturopathic” is based on the belief in vitalism, the idea that living beings have a “life force” not found in inanimate objects. While vitalism was disproved by Wöhler in 1828, this idea remains the central dogma of naturopathy and informs much of its practice.
The naturopathic curriculum is filled with pseudoscience, and there is no convincing evidence to show that naturopathy offers anything that is uniquely useful or incrementally better than “conventional” medicine.  Britt Hermes is a former naturopath and has written extensively about naturopathy, and her perspective is clear: There are no naturopathic standards of care and naturopathic training is very different than what naturopaths claim. She argues that naturopathy has too much quackery and that what actually makes naturopathy unique is its embrace of pseudoscience. Despite this, naturopaths are regulated and registered in British Columbia. The British Columbia Naturopathic Association even describes naturopaths as “medically trained”:
Given there is a lack of objective evidence that determines what naturopaths offer, concerns have been raised about the naturopathic standard of care. A letter published in Allergy, Asthma, & Clinical Immunology documents the concerns about naturopathy in Canada and any naturopathic alignment to science-based methodologies. Timothy Caulfield and Christen Rachul found that the most widely advertised practices in Alberta and British Columbia lacked a sound evidence base. They concluded:
A review of the therapies advertised on the websites of clinics offering naturopathic treatments does not support the proposition that naturopathic medicine is a science and evidence-based practice.
Among the interventions promoted by naturopaths were homeopathy, chelation, acupuncture, and hydrotherapy, none of which have any credible science to back them up. But homeopathy deserves special mention in the array of treatments used by naturopaths, as it’s the one Zimmermann endorses for the treatment of behavioural issues in children.
Naturopathy and homeopathy
As scientific principles became the framework for determining what works (and what doesn’t) in medicine, we’ve seen a steady progression towards more science-based, evidence-based care. Yet some unscientific practices still exist, even when we know they don’t work. It might surprise you to learn that some people believe sugar pills can prevent and heal disease. This belief system, called homeopathy, is a multi-billion dollar industry worldwide. Homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, based on the idea that “like cures like” (which is simply a form of magical thinking) involving successive dilutions of products in water, like Berlin Wall, “Mobile Phone (900mHz)“, and even the light reflecting off Saturn. These substances are believed to have medicinal effects, and the dilutions are believed to increase, not decrease, the potency of the final product. But the dilutions in homeopathy are so great you’re usually not even getting any Berlin Wall. Think of putting one drop of a substance into a container of water. Only that container is 131 light-years in diameter. That’s the equivalent of the common “30C” dilution. Homeopaths believe that the water molecules retain a “memory” of the original substance (while conveniently forgetting all the other products it has come in contact with.) The final remedy is diluted so completely that most products on store shelves don’t contain a single molecule of the ingredient listed on the label. After all that dilution, the water is dripped on tablets of sucrose and lactose: They are, as a final product, sugar pills. Chemically indistinguishable, and as medicinal as a box of candies.
While there is no convincing evidence to demonstrate that homeopathic treatments are more effective than a placebo, many consumers and alternative health providers like naturopathy accept homeopathy as a legitimate health treatment. (It’s actually considered “core clinical science” within the practice of naturopathy.) Responding to the perceived consumer demand for these products, government regulators have had a difficult decision to make: They could ignore homeopathy as a health practice, treating it like we might think of astrology: firmly outside of medicine, and for entertainment purposes only. Or they could choose some form of regulation, targeting the providers (homeopaths and naturopaths) or the product (homeopathy), possibly with the goal of managing its use, or perhaps limiting harms to consumers. The risk of regulating nonsense is the perceived legitimacy that recognition and regulation implies. Regrettably, regulation in many countries has had that exact effect. There are now hundreds of indistinguishable homeopathic remedies that have been reviewed and approved by Health Canada, based what turns out to be an astonishingly low evidence bar. Health Canada will even allow references to homeopathy textbooks written in the 1800s as “evidence” of a product’s efficacy. There is no requirement for any randomized controlled trial or any other form of evidence that could actually show efficacy.
Health Canada’s low evidence standard was demonstrated by the television show CBC Marketplace back in 2015. Having previously described how homeopathic remedies lack any medicine at all, they went one further, and decided to test Health Canada’s own licensing process. They applied for approval to market a homeopathic remedy they named “Nighton” (an anagram of “nothing”) to be used to treat fever and pain in infants and children. For evidence, they submitted a few pages photocopied from an old homeopathy textbook. No trials were conducted and no safety data was provided. Just some forms, a few photocopies and a fee. Without any questions, their product was approved and licensed as a “natural health product”, and for a time, was listed in the national database of health products Health Canada declared were “safe, effective, and of high quality.”
Homeopathy for behaviour problems?
Naturopath Anke Zimmermann describes in a sort of “case study” how she came to use a remedy made from the saliva of rabid dog:
This is a 4-year-old boy who is suffering from an inability to fall asleep at night, a fear of the dark, of wolves, werewolves, ghosts and zombies and who frequently hides under tables and growls at people. He is overly excitable and has a tendency to defiance. He was normal as a baby, not affected by sleep or temper problems. There is a history of a dog bit [sic] which drew blood. I decided to give a homeopathic remedy made from rabies. The dog that bit him may have recently been vaccinated with the rabies vaccine or the dog bite in and of itself may have affected the boy with the rabies miasm. Either is possible and the phenomenon is welll-known in homeopathy.
A bite from an animal, with or without rabies vaccination has the potential to imprint an altered state in the person who was bitten, in some ways similar to a rabies infection. This can include over-excitability, difficulties sleeping, aggression and various fears, especially of dogs or wolves. This child presented a perfect picture of this type of rabies state. Most homeopaths would have easily recognized the remedy required in this case.
And she continues:
Within a minute or two of giving him the remedy Jonah smiled at me very broadly and beautifully, as if all the lights had just gone on. We said our good-byes and I felt a warm feeling of hope for this boy.
The case study goes on to describe a series of behaviours that seem to wax and wane, but Zimmermann feels the homeopathy is working:
The plot thickens, we were on the right track with the remedy. Jonah was obviously in a dog state, a slightly rabies-flavoured dog state to be more precise. Jonah’s mother told his Dad what happened in our visit and about my dog-bite analysis. Turned out that he had been bitten many times by dogs as a child and in fact, his grandfather’s dog was put down for biting him so often. Perhaps this was an added contributing factor in this case, an epigenetic predisposition.
Epigenetics? While this child seems to appear to need a medical assessment, he continued to be treated by the naturopath with the homeopathic remedy. After three weeks:
I contacted Jonah’s mother to see how he was doing and she wrote: “Though his fears at nighttime and growling still seem to have been greatly reduced, unfortuately [sic], this past week was tough for Jonah behaviourally. At school he had many seemingly unprovoked violent and aggressive outbursts towards other children. At home, he was not aggressive but certainly seemed very tightly-wound and slightly manic. He was having difficulty focusing and following any type of direction.” I had given his mother an extra dose of the remedy to take home in case of just such a need and instructed her to administer it to him.
After a few more months, Zimmermann continued to believe the homeopathy was effective:
It is obvious that the remedy worked very well for Jonah and he has been quite well for over two months. Now he is starting to relapse, which is expected. Children usually need several doses of the correct remedy over a period of months to years to completely recover. The mother shared some useful additional information about our little puppy dog boy, including that he only shows real affection with dogs and his father was also repeatedly bitten by a dog, which may have contributed to Jonah’s state as well.
I gave a dose of Lyssinum 10M.
And Lyssinum is a Health-Canada-approved homeopathic remedy. Zimmermann’s conclusion was that homeopathy was effective:
Bottom line: Homeopathy can work wonders for children with behavioural disorders if the remedy can be clearly perceived. I have seen a number of similar cases over the years which helped me to recognize the remedy in this case so quickly. Lyssinum aka Hydrophobinum is only one of many remedies that can be helpful for children with rage, aggression and various behavioural disorders. There are many others. Treatment always needs to be individualized.
I invite you to read the other cases on my website and if you know of anyone who might benefit from homeopathy, please let them know about this. Why let a child suffer needlessly when there is simple, inexpensive (the remedy cost about $15 so far) and logical solution to the problem!
I have only provided small excerpts of the entire case history above. It is well worth reading through in its entirety if only to understand the naturopatic thinking and reasoning process. It is so far removed from an evidence-based, science-based methodology, it’s remarkable.
The reaction
Health official Dr. Bonnie Henry, quoted by the CBC, has written to Health Canada, asking how this remedy could be approved. But as noted above, approval of ineffective treatments is the intent of Health Canada’s Natural Health Products regulatory scheme – not a bug. Notably, British Columbia’s naturopathic regulator is standing behind Zimmermann’s approach:
“There’s no common consensus about how the remedies work, but that they work is pretty clear. There are literally hundreds of millions of people around the world using homeopathy,” Zimmermann said. She has the support of the regulatory body for B.C.’s naturopathic doctors. According to the College of Naturopathic Physicians of British Columbia, lyssinum as an acceptable treatment. “Homeopathy, which includes the use of substances such as lyssinum, is a traditional modality with a long history in the naturopathic scope of practice; it is still used by some naturopathic doctors today,” deputy registrar Phillipa Stanaway wrote in an email.
Laughably, Health Canada says it takes safety “very seriously” despite implementing a licensing system that is doing exactly what it was designed to do.
Conclusion: Licensing magic doesn’t make it work
In Canada there have been limited attempts to regulate products like homeopathy or alternative medicine providers like naturopaths to scientific standards. In the absence of clear regulations that put science and patient safety first, it should not be surprising to see alternative medicine providers using pre-scientific practices to treat real medical issues. As long as regulators continue to allow these sorts of double-standards for these “alternative” practices, it is patients who will always, ultimately, pay the price.

Homeopathy, rabid dogs, and naturopathic propaganda
Last week, a story of a bizarre homeopathic remedy used by a Canadian naturopath made the news. Today, American naturopaths are in Washington, DC lobbying for increased prescribing power, including for controlled substances. Lawmakers should be reminded of the quackery at the heart of naturopathy.
David Gorski on April 23, 2018
Link

While contemplating what to write about this week (and, unfortunately, doing so much later than usual because my entire weekend was taken up by a strategic planning retreat for my cancer center), I came across this Tweetstorm by an old friend of the Science-Based Medicine, Britt Hermes. Britt, as you might recall, is a former naturopath who realized that she had become a quack and as a result of that realization did a very difficult thing. She gave up naturopathy and started training to become a real scientist. In any case, here’s her Tweetstorm (click to see the entire ten Tweet series):
I am NOT vaccine hesitant. But as a former #naturopath I used to be afraid of vaccines. I was taught to be afraid of vaccines and not to trust the scientific consensus regarding vaccine safety (2/10)
— Britt Marie Hermes (@NaturoDiaries) April 22, 2018
What Britt is referring to later in the series of Tweets, besides the indisputable fact that the vast majority of naturopaths are antivaccine and that pro-vaccine naturopaths are rare, is something called the DC Federal Legislative Initiative (DCFLI). Basically, organized by the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians, a bunch of naturopaths and naturopathic students descended upon Washington, DC on Saturday for a “leadership” conference and plan to cap it off with a day of lobbying legislators today. They have a number of “asks” that they intend to lobby for. One example is the “Preserving Patient Access to Compounded Medications Act” (H.R. 2871), which would weaken FDA oversight over compounded medicines of the sort that naturopaths like to have mixed up for them. Also, of course, naturopaths claim that their methods are part of the solution of the opioid addiction crisis. Oddly enough, however, they want access to prescribing authority to treat opioid addiction:
PROBLEM: ENSURING PATIENT ACCESS TO MEDICATION-ASSISTED TREATMENTOnly one in 10 people in the U.S. with an addiction receive treatment. According to the Pew Charitable Trusts, that’s in large part because of a shortage of trained medical providers, especially ones who can prescribe buprenorphine.4
Section 303 of CARA was previously amended to allow physician assistants and nurse practitioners to prescribe buprenorphine under the direction of a qualified physician, and is set to sunset in 2021.
S. 2456 makes a permanent addition of nurse practitioners and physicians assistants as “Qualifying Other Practitioners” who can prescribe buprenorphine. H.R. 5311 would add a variety of other nurses as well as physicians assistants to the list of “Qualifying Other Practitioners.”
Licensed naturopathic doctors receive more training and education than both physician assistants and nurse practitioners, and several states authorize naturopathic doctors to prescribe the DEA schedules necessary for Medication-Assisted Treatment like buprenorphine.
Many naturopathic doctors treat patients with addiction involving opioid use, and should be added to H.R. 5311 and S. 2456. Otherwise patients of NDs will be denied access to this life-saving treatment option, at a time of crisis when we need all available providers to practice to the full extent of their scope and education.
So what do naturopaths want? You guessed it! They want to be included with physicians assistants and advanced practice nurses to able to administer controlled substances, specifically buprenorphine, which is not uncommonly used in medication-assisted addiction treatment. Buprenorphine is a semisynthetic opioid that acts as a partial opioid agonist and also has antagonist activity (which activity predominates depends on the specific opioid receptor and the dose). What that means is that the drug can produce typical opioid effects (and side effects), but at a lower intensity and also can block the binding of other opioids to opioid receptors. Basically, without getting into the weeds too much, I’ll just mention that buprenorphine can produce enough agonist effect to enable opioid-addicted patients to discontinue their use of opioids like morphine, fentanyl, heroin, and the like without experiencing withdrawal symptoms. The dose of buprenorphine can then be titrated downward without withdrawal symptoms as severe as going cold turkey. Of course, whenever I see naturopaths wanting access to such powerful medications, it scares the crap out of me, as well as making me wonder why, if naturopathy is so great for treating chronic pain and opioid addiction, naturopaths would even want the power to use medications like buprenorphine. Presumably, they’d also want to use other opioid partial agonists than buprenorphine or even opioid antagonists like naltrexone.
Of course, Britt has spent extensive time countering the talking points used by naturopaths to try to deceive lawmakers into thinking that they are the equivalent of MDs and fact-checking the sorts of claims naturopaths make every year at the DCFLI. The naturopaths in DC promoting more favorable legislation for their quackery are part of a larger push by naturopaths to make themselves in the eyes of the law the equivalent to MDs. For instance, in addition to today’s lobbying push in DC and the general campaign to be licensed in every state in the US by 2025, naturopaths in Alaska are lobbying for the authority to prescribe medicine. More on that later.
What I wish I could tell legislators who are listening to the blandishments of naturopaths is just how deep the quackery runs in the “profession” of naturopathy by its very nature. One way to do that is to note that you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy. Naturopathy, by its very nature, incorporates homeopathy into its education, with many hours of homeopathy in the curricula of naturopathic schools. Homeopathy is even an integral part of the NPLEX, the licensure examination that states in which naturopaths are licensed use.
Indeed, Scott Gavura recently described an incredible example of what happens when quack naturopaths use The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy, in a post he so aptly entitled “How rabid dog saliva became an approved and endorsed remedy in Canada.” It’s about a naturopath named Anke Zimmermann, who treated behavioral problems in a four year old boy with a homeopathic remedy known as Lyssinum, which is made from, yes, saliva from a rabid dog; that is, if you believe homeopaths’ characterization of the source material that was diluted to 200C, or two hundred 100-fold dilutions, or by a factor of 10400. If you consider that the estimated number of atoms in the known universe is on the order of 1080, the chances of there being a single viral particle of rabies left is near zero. Thankfully. Of course, this is no obstacle in the mind of a homeopath, since they claim their remedies work due to the “memory of water” or some other form of magic.
I realize that Scott did his usual excellent job discussing Zimmermann and how she treated a boy with a truly bizarre homeopathic treatment (even for homeopathy). However, it’s worth giving my take (I hope) on this same case. The reason is that Scott dwelled mostly on how Health Canada could allow such nonsense, while I can’t help but discuss the case from my point of view. At least, I want to add my point of view to the discussion of the case without being too repetitive (I hope).
The rabies miasm and homeopathic rabid dog spit
Scott described the case treated by Not-A-Doctor Anke Zimmermann in depth, as well as how in Canada such a treatment (Lyssinum, which is supposedly derived from the saliva of a rabid dog) can be completely legal as a treatment in Canada. This child basically had behavioral problems that included aggression at school, pretending that he was a dog, and a fear of werewolves (I kid you not). Because she is a naturopath, Zimmerman decided to treat the boy with homeopathy, because homeopathy is a major part of the armamentarium of naturopaths. What caused the ruckus was that she posted her “case report” on her blog. The original version of that case report has been taken down, to be replaced with all sorts of defenses of her treatment and rants against big pharma. However, the Internet never forgets, and thanks to the almighty Wayback Machine the original version of the post still exists:
This is a 4-year-old boy who is suffering from an inability to fall asleep at night, a fear of the dark, of wolves, werewolves, ghosts and zombies and who frequently hides under tables and growls at people. He is overly excitable and has a tendency to defiance. He was normal as a baby, not affected by sleep or temper problems.
There is a history of a dog bit which drew blood. I decided to give a homeopathic remedy made from rabies.
The dog that bit him may have recently been vaccinated with the rabies vaccine or the dog bite in and of itself may have affected the boy with the rabies miasm. Either is possible and the phenomenon is welll-known [sic] in homeopathy.
What is rabies miasm? At first, I was a bit confused and assumed that Not-A-Doctor Zimmermann was referring to miasma theory. You might recall that miasma theory was an old medical notion that predated germ theory and purported to explain why diseases were communicable. After all, even before scientists knew anything about bacteria or viruses, it was obvious that certain diseases appeared to be communicated from one person to another. Miasma theory postulated that such diseases were caused by a miasma (μίασμα, ancient Greek: “pollution”), a form of “bad air.” Homeopaths, however, appear to have a different definition of “miasma”. For instance, this veterinary homeopathy (yes, unfortunately they exist) describes miasma as “when the body/mind/emotions of an individual manifest signs of the disease without actually having the disease.”
The National Center for Homeopathy quotes the originator of homeopathy, Samuel Hahnemann, as saying, “Chronic diseases arise from dynamic infection by a chronic miasm.” That, of course, doesn’t help, but miasms are actually a cornerstone of homeopathy:
A shorthand definition of a miasm is that it is a force within a person or an animal, creating a predisposition to certain kinds of illness. The miasm defines our susceptibility. Long before modern science identified genetically-linked diseases, Hahnemann noted that certain families tended to develop certain illnesses. Moreover, he observed that certain illnesses were related to each other, so that even if family members did not mimic each other’s diseases exactly, their illnesses shared similar characteristics and patterns. He also noticed that some diseases, even if “cured” by medicines and other treatments, left people ever after vulnerable to particular clusters of afflictions—families of ailments that, while seemingly unrelated, could be traced to a common root in that “cured” disease. These observations led to his understanding of the miasms, the forces that create particular disease characteristics.
Hahnemann described three miasms, psora, syphilis, and sycosis, and his disciples described two more, tubercular and cancer miasms. Now, here’s where it gets even more ridiculous. Miasms are named for diseases, but bear only a “loose relationship” to the diseases for which they are named. Even more bizarre, homeopaths say that miasms do not predict the disease. To show you how utterly divorced from logic, medicine, and science the concept of miasms is, I think it worth citing this rather long passage in full:
For those who are under homeopathic treatment, it is important to remember that having a particular miasm does not predict that you will develop any particular disease. It may be frightening, for instance, to be told that you harbor the cancer miasm, until you understand that this is merely a name and not a reflection of any predisposition to that disease. Miasms are named for diseases from which they originated and with which they share some characteristics, but they are not the disease itself.
Moreover, having a particular miasm does not mean that you have ever had the disease associated with it. Few people today, for instance, have had active syphilis, but the syphilitic miasm is very common in our population. This is because the miasm can be established in the ways I described above. The syphilitic miasm can appear in someone who has an ancestor who suffered from syphilis, or an ancestor who was treated for another disease in the same way as syphilis was treated at the time, or an ancestor who was married to someone with those experiences. It has no moral meaning and no implications about the individual person.
To confuse matters further, every miasm can create susceptibility to any disease. Miasms express themselves not in the identity of the disease but in its characteristics. Cancer, for instance, comes in many different forms; it can be slow-growing or aggressive, it can be combined with a vast variety of other complaints, and it can affect any part of the body. Any miasm can produce cancer, and only the individualizing characteristics of the particular case can express the miasmatic basis for the disease in that person.
Got that? Not only do miasms not predict that any given individual will develop any given disease, you can acquire them from an ancestor who had the disease or was treated for another disease in a manner similar to how that disease is treated, or an ancestor who was married to someone with the disease. Moreover, any miasm can create susceptibility to any disease! And here I had thought that the ideas that you treat symptoms by using something that causes those symptoms and that you make a homeopathic remedy stronger by serially diluting it away to nothing. Indeed, I’ve referred to how homeopathy is based on magic, citing Sir James George Frazer’s Law of Similarity as described in The Golden Bough (1922) as one of the implicit principles of magic. If anything, though, miasms are clearly representative of another law of magic, the Law of Contagion, which is basically what homeopaths are invoking when they claim that water has “memory” of what it’s been in contact with. Basically, miasms are the Law of Contagion put on massive doses of steroids, so that even ancestors who lived decades or longer ago can have bestowed on you a miasm without even having to have transmitted it through inheritance. Of course, homeopaths make miasms sound so very, very complicated, such that you can’t just learn how to treat them in a book. Amusingly, even though they can’t seem to tell you how any given miasm (if you even accept that miasms exist, which you should not) will produce any given disease, they invoke miasms as a reason why home homeopathic treatment might not work and why you should consult “an experienced professional who “can set things right by identifying the miasmatic basis of the problem and finding an appropriate remedy.”
In the case of dogs and the rabies vaccine, it’s a common claim among homeopaths who treat animals that rabies vaccines cause aggression in dogs (even though there is no evidence to support that claim), and that the rabies miasm, transmitted from the rabies vaccine, causes that aggression.
So that’s the background of Not-A-Doctor Zimmermann’s conclusion that this child must have rabies miasm:
A bite from an animal, with or without rabies vaccination has the potential to imprint an altered state in the person who was bitten, in some ways similar to a rabies infection. This can include over-excitability, difficulties sleeping, aggression and various fears, especially of dogs or wolves. This child presented a perfect picture of this type of rabies state. Most homeopaths would have easily recognized the remedy required in this case.
Plan: Lyssinum 200CH, 2 pellets. (Please note, this is a homeopathic remedy, prepared by a licensed homeopathic pharmacy in the UK, Helios Homeopathy.)
Yes, Helios does claim to make Lyssinum 200C.
Not surprisingly, what people have been focusing on in this story is whether or not the Lyssinum really did come from saliva from a rabid dog. If we’re to believe homeopaths, the first saliva obtained was in 1833 by C. Hering. Of course, a 200C dilution is the equivalent to a 10-400 dilution, and the estimated number of atoms in the known universe is only on the order of 1080, which means that it’s incredibly unlikely that, even if the starting material were saliva from a rabid dog, there would be one molecule of starting material, much less one virus particle left. But who knows? Actually, who knows what homeopaths are actually using? Maybe some homeopath decades ago managed to get some saliva from a rabid dog without getting bit and infected, or maybe the origin of the starting material used to make Lyssinum is lost in the mists of time and just assumed to have come from a rabid dog. Also, either way, even if it would be incredibly unlikely for any virus particles to survive dilution many orders of magnitude greater than the number of atoms in the known universe, if the starting material really was saliva from a rabid dog, the workers making the homeopathic remedies would be at risk for contracting a disease that is almost always fatal if not treated early. Also, homeopaths are just nutty enough to have actually used such saliva, though. After all, there were homeopaths trying to use Ebola virus as a starting material to treat bleeding.
Now here’s the amazing thing. Health Canada has approved Lyssin as a natural health product The online database entry for Lyssin even says, quite unremarkably, that the source material is the saliva of a rabid dog or, for those in Quebec, “salive d’un chien atteint de la rage.” Lest you think that you can make fun of those wacky Canadians for having approved this nonsense, be aware that the source cited by the Canadian entry is the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia of United States. You might recall that, when Congress passed the Food, Drugs and Cosmetics Act in 1938, its principle author was Senator Royal Copeland. Copeland, it turns out, was physician who practiced homeopathy. In passing the law, he managed to include all articles monographed in the HPUS in the definition of drugs within the FDCA. As Jann Bellamy puts it, the HPUS is a “source for monographs, identity, methods of manufacture, standards and controls and potency levels of homeopathic products, both prescription and OTC” and “if the product is in the HPUS, it’s legal.” Yep, we have Lyssin in the US too, and veterinary homeopaths claim to be able use it as a nosode to protect against rabies. I kid you not.
The backlash
For her part, Not-A-Doctor Zimmermann seemed to be loving the attention she was receiving as a result of her story having spread so far and wide, at least for a time:
So today the CBC called me at 2 pm for an interview re my dog bit story. Here is the result. Not terrible, only… https://t.co/a0Dvi1bKXV
— Dr. Anke Zimmermann (@drzimmermann) April 17, 2018
And:
And:
More exposure for homeopathy? I suppose so, but the exposure for homeopathy is a mix of horror at the stupidity and mockery of the stupidity. Not-A-Doctor Zimmermann also claims that the ends justify the means, that her treatment “worked.” Of course, if you read the account it’s not at all good evidence that the homeopathic Lyssinum “worked.” Basically, his growling and aggressive behavior, according to his mother, has been in essence waxing and waning. For instance, his mother reported three months after initiation of homeopathic treatment that her son had relapsed.
As mentioned above, Zimmermann also decried the “misinformation” about homeopathy being spread. For instance, in her now revised version of her case report, she explains the rationale for using rabies in this child, as well as the supposed history of the remedy:
Rabies is an infection of the central nervous system, so early homeopaths realized that it might be useful for certain neurological and mental health issues.
Stop right there. This is the principle of “like cures like” taken to its most ridiculous extreme, like the use of Ebola to treat hemorrhagic conditions. Next up:
One brave soul, somewhere around 1833, 50 years before the crude experiments of Louis Pasteur, who developed the rabies vaccine, managed to extract a little saliva from the mouth of a small pet dog who had been bitten by a rabid fox. Then he made it into a homeopathic remedy. It’s quite a riveting story, any interested parties are directed to Allan’s Materia Medica of Nosodes. The dog had puppies when it was bitten and two of her puppies were also bitten. The doctor extracted the saliva, made it into a remedy, gave it to the puppies and was able to save them, but the mother died as her state was more advanced and she had been bitten more intensely.
One of the first symptoms a person with rabies may experience is a general over-excitability; they can be more lively and talkative than usual and may have trouble sleeping. Next they might feel a sense of dread, of something terrible about to happen, as well as a fear of dogs, the dark and water. Hence the reason it was given in the case in question and similar cases I have treated of children who were overexcitable, had trouble sleeping and had various behavioural issues.
I have on numerous occasions prescribed the remedy based on an unreasonable fear of dogs in both adults and children, as long as other indications were also present.
The amusing thing about Zimmermann’s defense of her actions is that it doesn’t actually make her or homeopathy look any better. If anything, it lays bare the utter ridiculousness of homeopathy. She even admits that there almost certainly isn’t a single viral particle or even molecule of anything from the dog saliva in the remedy:
The remedies I gave in this case were of the potencies of 200CH, 1M and 10M which means they went through the dilution and succussion process 200, 1000 and 10,000 times.
After the process is repeated 12 times it is basically impossible to have even one of the original molecules left in the solution, which is ultimately often used to medicate lactose or sucrose pellets.
Therefor there is no single molecule of rabies in the remedy. Again, you can’t catch rabies from the remedy.
That’s, of course, even assuming that the starting material was really saliva from a rabid dog. Zimmermann, of course, sees herself (and, by extension, naturopaths and homeopaths) as the victims here:
Pretty much all of our dogs and cats receive rabies vaccines and health officials think that’s a good thing. These vaccines contain the actual rabies virus, grown on mouse brain tissue cultures.
But if an ND or homeopath gives such a homeopathic preparation of rabies to a child and the child greatly improves, she experiments with rabid dog saliva on innocent children, obviously keeps rabid dogs chained up in her backyard, is clearly a child abuser and an animal abuser too, should go to jail, have her license pulled and deserves a baseball bat to head and these are just some of the milder comments and threats I’ve received.
I certainly do not condone threats of violence and unequivocally condemn anyone who made such threats, even if they were not serious. However, the entire passage above demonstrates a serious misunderstanding of vaccines. Of course, a rabies vaccine has to contain all or part of the rabies virus. That’s how an immune reaction against it is provoked. The point is that the entire rationale she as a naturopath using homeopathy used to treat this boy is utter nonsense with no basis in science. It is actually fortunate indeed that the homeopathic remedies given do not contain any rabies virus and that the starting material very likely never contained rabies virus. The whole point is that the claimed use of rabies virus shows just how detached from reality the principles of homeopathy are and, by extension, how pseudoscientific and downright quacky naturopathy is, given that it embraces principles of homeopathy that produce treatments like Lyssinum for childhood behavioral issues.
Beyond rabies
If you want another example of this sort of ridiculousness, consider Medorrhinum, a homeopathic remedy that Zimmermann has used to treat bedwetting and pervasive developmental disorder and epilepsy. What, you may ask, is the starting material for Medorrhinum? Gonorrhea. I kid you not. Any condition that homeopaths think to come from the Sycotic miasm, which homeopaths attribute to “suppressed gonorrhea.” In the case of bedwetting, the rationale is to use Medorrhinum because bedwetting involves the genitourinary tract and so does gonorrhea. In the case of the child with PDD and epilepsy, Medorrhinum was used to treat a “remarkably strong feature to bite, put everything in her mouth and even bite her toenails.”
In fact, one homeopath’s website describes Medorrhinum this way:
Medorrhinum is a very important remedy to consider for Autism. It is also a magnificent remedy for hormonal problems, and affects the generative organs very strongly. It is one of the best remedies for severe menstrual cramps and other problems connected with the menstrual cycle. It is the first remedy we consider in homeopathy for recurrent urinary tract infections. The remedy also affects the musculo-skeletal and nervous systems very profoundly.
And:
Medorrhinum is a massive remedy, which is possibly needed by a large percentage of mankind. When syphilis and gonorrhea are treated with antibiotics or other means in allopathic medicine, the genetic taint is not eradicted from the system, and it causes alterations in the genes, which are passed on to the offspring. Homeopathy offers a means of preventing this unfortunate scenario, which has generation-wide consequences.
Yes, the gonorrhea miasm persists down the generations. If you have an ancestor who ever had gonorrhea or was treated for gonorrhea, you could well have the Sycotic or gonorrhea miasm.
It’s delicious that this incident occurred during Homeopathy Awareness Week, too.
Naturopathy versus science
Naturopaths like to claim that their specialty is scientific, that their training is the equivalent of that of MDs, and that they can be primary care providers. As we have documented here time and time again, none of these claims are accurate, and naturopaths embrace a high level of outright quackery in their practices. Now naturopaths are lobbying for access to opioid mixed partial agonist/antagonists used to treat opioid addiction. In Alaska, they want to be able to prescribe Ambien and testosterone. Just listen to Abby Laing, the president of the Alaska Association of Naturopathic Physicians, justify giving prescribing authority to naturopaths:
Laing said that naturopaths use drugs and medication as a “last resort,” but for the efficacy of providing care, it makes sense for naturopaths to be able to prescribe drugs.
Instead of telling someone they need to get blood pressure medication, “I want to be able to prescribe it and not refer them out and hope they go and get it,” Laing said.
I would argue that people who are trained to believe that the principles of homeopathy are valid, that like cures like and diluting a substance makes its effects stronger, and that using essence of rabies virus or gonorrhea bacteria to treat a wide variety of symptoms, shouldn’t be allowed anywhere near a prescribing pad—or a patient, for that matter. Unfortunately, in all too many states and countries, legislators do not see it that way.

CEASE therapy for autism: Homeopathic quackery and “self regulation” by naturopathic boards
Naturopathy is quackery. If you doubt this, consider that you can’t have naturopathy without homeopathy. What’s even worse is when naturopaths subject autistic children to quackery like CEASE therapy. Expecting any naturopathic regulatory board to investigate quackery in naturopathy is the proverbial fox guarding the henhouse.
David Gorski on May 28, 2018
Link

[Editor’s note: Today is a holiday in the US, and your humble managing editor spent much of it working on a grant, a book chapter, and, all day yesterday in Toledo on family business. As a result, I didn’t have time to produce one of my usual 5,000-word epics. I do, however, have a post that some of you might have seen before (and many probably have not) from my not-so-secret other blog, modified and repurposed for SBM. I’ll be back next week as usual. In the meantime, I’ll be holed up working on a grant and book chapter in my air-conditioned office, given that it’s supposed to go up to 96° F here in my neck of the woods. That’s too much heat for me to venture outside without a damned good reason.]
We here at SBM write about naturopathy a lot because, almost alone among alternative medicine “specialties,” naturopaths think of themselves as real physicians. They aren’t, of course. They are basically cosplaying real physicians, but they really do think that their education, training, and methodology are equal to that of MDs (and, in the US, DOs), even though it’s been discussed many times here and elsewhere why they are not, why naturopathic “accreditation” is a joke, and just how low standards are in naturopathic “medical” schools. I personally have discussed many incidents of naturopathic quackery that are, as much as naturopaths deny it, well within the accepted practice of naturopaths. I’m referring, of course, to treatments like the use of saliva from a rabid dog as an “approved” remedy to treat a variety of conditions, how naturopaths can make even Epsom salts fatal, the horror of what happens when a naturopath tries to treat pertussis “naturally,” or, thanks to lax regulations on compounding pharmacies, a clean kill by a naturopathic quack injecting curcumin intravenously. This latter incident, in particular, resulted not in naturopaths in California trying to clean up their acts but rather in their circling the wagons to defend their profession. It was also a very good illustration of why naturopathic licensure doesn’t protect patients from bad naturopaths because naturopathy is quackery by its very nature. “Licensed naturopaths” are no safer than any other naturopath.
Don’t even get me started on “stuff” naturopaths say when they think no non-naturopaths are listening, or the antivaccine quackery that is at the heart of naturopathy, such that the vast majority of naturopaths being antivaccine. Yes, I know that there are a few who are not (although I point out that even some of those, when tweaked, reveal antivaccine tendencies), but they are vastly outnumbered by the majority who range from moderately antivaccine to rabidly antivaccine. (Maybe that could be treated with a bit of homeopathic Lyssinum)
Given that naturopaths are making yet another effort to achieve licensure in my state of Michigan (and, sadly, having some success at it), I’m likely to be writing more than usual about naturopathic quackery (but I repeat myself) more than usual, the better to build an armamentarium of examples of why naturopathy is not medicine and why it endangers patients. So, when several people Tweeted this story at me, I took interest. So did Jann, who wrote about this legislative alchemy last week, but, since I live in the state, I figured it wouldn’t hurt to add my take on the story:
The College of Naturopathic Physicians is investigating a complaint launched against three B.C. practioners.
The registered naturopaths are said to be offering a treatment known as “CEASE” – Complete Elimination of Autism Spectrum Expression. The idea is largely based on the unscientific claim that Autism is caused primarily by vaccines.
In the treatment, children are “detoxified” using a highly diluted version of the causative agent, or toxin, in order to “purify” the body.
Who are the three naturopaths? Another news story reveals their names:
B.C. naturopaths Anke Zimmermann, Janice Potter and Margret Holland are all certified CEASE practitioners, and the college has acknowledged it is investigating the public complaint against them.
Anke Zimmerman? Hmmm. Where have we heard that name before? Oh, yes, I remember. She’s the naturopath who loves to use homeopathy about whose use of a homeopathic remedy supposedly derived from the saliva of a rabid dog to treat a boy with behavioral issues I wrote about last month. She also uses a homeopathic remedy supposedly derived from gonorrhea. (I swear, you can’t make stuff like this up. At least, I can’t.)
So what is CEASE therapy?
First, for those not familiar with homeopathy, I do need to do a little primer again. (I know, I know, there probably aren’t that many readers not familiar with The One Quackery To Rule Them All, but I do occasionally get new readers, and I don’t want to force them to click a link to learn what homeopathy is.) As I like to say, homeopathy doesn’t really qualify even as pseudoscience given that there’s nothing scientific about it and that in reality it shows far more similarity to sympathetic magic than anything else. In other words, there isn’t even enough of patina of science slathered over the quackery to qualify as pseudoscience. It’s magical thinking, pure and simple, in which homeopaths believe that diluting a remedy makes it stronger, but only if it is shaken vigorously (succussed) between each serial dilution step. Even more magically, they believe that it is possible for a compound that has been diluted many orders of magnitude more than Avagadro’s number, such that it’s exceedingly unlikely that even a single molecule of active substance remains, to have a therapeutic effect. They justify this by claiming that water has “memory” and retains some sort of “imprint” of the substance that it’s been in contact with. Never mind that there’s no evidence that water has “memory” beyond an extraordinarily brief period of time. Homeopaths are impervious to reason.
So CEASE therapy involves homeopathy, which is more than enough to make it quackery. That’s not all, though. It also involves the belief that vaccines are the cause of autism, which they are not. So let’s take a look at CEASE therapy again. It’s an invention/delusion of an actual MD (unfortunately) named Tinus Smits, who “discovered” CEASE:
Dr. Smits discovered in his practice with over 300 cases the foundation of CEASE therapy and came to his hypothisis [sic] of what causes autism. In his experience autism is an accumulation of different causes and about 70% is due to vaccines, 25% to toxic medication and other toxic substances, 5% to some diseases. With isotherapy (see below), a form of homeopathy using the causative substances themselves in homeopathic preparation, the toxic imprints can be erased.
He continues:
The treatment of autistic children and even adults has matured through 300 cases over the last three years and is called CEASE Therapy, which stands for Complete Elimination of Autistic Spectrum Expression. Step by step all asumed [sic] causative factors (vaccines, regular medication, environmental toxic exposures, effects of illness, etc.) are detoxified with the homeopathically prepared, that is diluted and potentized substances that were administered prior to the onset of autism. Currently we use the 30C, 200C, 1M and 10M potencies to clear out the energetic field of the patient from the imprint of toxic substances or diseases.
Of course, a 30C dilution means 30 serial 100-fold dilutions, or a 1060-fold dilution. A 200C dilution means 200 serial 100-fold dilutions, or a 10400-fold dilution. 1M means 1,000C, or a 102,000-fold dilution. You get the idea. Indeed, one can’t help in these situations to point out that Avagadro’s number is approximately 6 x 1023. That means if you dilute a one molar solution of something by approximately 12C (1024), then the solution is highly unlikely to have more than one or two molecules of the substance left. Take the dilution up to 30C, 100C, and beyond, and the odds rapidly become vanishingly small that a single molecule will remain. How small? Well, for a comparison that I frequently use when I’m giving talks that include a section on homeopathy, there are only estimated to be approximately 1080 atoms in the observable universe. Also remember, when Smits says that he’s using these different potencies, what he’s doing is increasing the “potency” at each step by using a more diluted remedy:
The duration of a remedy course depends on the severity of the problems and the reactions of the patient and can vary from 2 weeks to 2 months. Potencies should be repeated until no further improvement is seen before passsing [sic] to the next poetency [sic]. After each course a 1 or 2 week break is applied. The administration is carried out by letting 2 granules melt in the mouth.
So basically Smits is deluded into thinking that he’s using increasingly strong medicine to treat his patients.
What, however, is “isotherapy”? Smits is happy to explain:
Using the causative substances as a homeopathic remedy, their profound toxic effects can be witnessed as the children begin to react to the remedies. The reactions on the isopathic remedies are so characteristic, that there can be no doubt about the existence of a link between the toxins as the cause and the development of Autism as its effects although this is not considered as scientific proof. In this way Dr. Smits discovered, step by step, why autism and other behavioral problems, with their specific developmental problems, have so dramatically increased over the last ten to twenty years. It also became clear that autistic children do not suffer from one single cause but from an accumulation of different causes.
Do tell. So it sounds as though Smits uses vaccines and other “toxins” as the basis for his homeopathic “detoxification.” Of course, inquiring minds want to know: How much of each vaccine is in the starting material? Does he replicate the CDC vaccination schedule and then use some of that as his starting tincture for his homeopathic dilutions? This is about as close to an explanation as Smits comes:
The homeopathic method as applied in the treatment of vaccination damage consists of administering four successive remedies of the suspected vaccine.
I’m guessing Smits must use a lot of MMR. Actually, no he doesn’t. After all, if he’s making such diluted solutions of vaccine he could buy one vial and then use it for decades. Later, he claims:
All autistic children should be detoxified using the homeopathically diluted remedies of the vaccines that have been administered to the child.
And:
Autistic children should never again be vaccinated!
One more time. Vaccines do not, as far as science has been able to tell, cause autism. Many have been the epidemiological studies, and none of the large, well-designed ones have found a hint of a whisper of an association between vaccination and an increased risk of autism. By urging that autistic children never be vaccinated again, he is placing them in danger of infectious disease and turning them into vectors to spread infection.
Of course, homeopathy isn’t the only quackery in CEASE. As any good quack is, Dr. Smits is very much into high dose vitamin C, claiming that it “seems to play an essential role in protecting children against the adverse effects of vaccinations or other stress inducing events.” Whether vitamin C plays a role in protecting against stress-inducing events is still up for discussion, but it surely doesn’t prevent, treat, or cure autism.
Let’s conclude by getting to training. The three naturopaths being investigated are listed as being “certified CEASE practitioners.” Apparently, it means undergoing “training” by one of a few CEASE practitioners who appear to be acolytes of Dr. Smits, such as Kim Kalina. There’s a CEASE Facebook page showing various training sessions, such as:
You get the idea. Show up at a CEASE course, and get a certificate that’s not worth the paper it’s printed on. But what do these courses cover? Here’s one by Kim Kalina herself given last summer:
The course will cover
    • how to individualise, evaluate the need for and accurately apply each of the core components of CEASE – Isotherapy Remedies, Orthomolecular Supplements and the ‘Saturday’ Remedies
    • how to recognise which cases are best suited to CEASE vs Classical Homeopathy
    • the additional case-taking skills, questions and information needed in a CEASE case
    • the key ‘ Saturday’ remedies, potencies and posology indicated in autism cases, as well as other frequently indicated remedies in general CEASE cases – including specific Inspiring Homeopathy, Matridonal and Sarcode remedies.
    • the key Orthomolecular supports needed to support cellular detoxification in various types of CEASE cases, including supplements, vitamins, baths, etc.
    • how to apply and adjust the Isotherapy components of CEASE, including resources for info about drugs, vaccines etc. and extensive vaccine charts Kim has personally developed to enable practitioners to quickly identify which vaccine may need to be cleared based on unique characteristic symptoms of each
    • how to manage CEASE cases – this is perhaps the single most important aspect of the training, and Kim uses several of her own cases (not just autism cases), as well as FAQ’s from clients and practitioners, to take participants through many follow-ups, crises, etc. so that practitioners can learn how to handle the many case management issues that can arise and how to correctly interpret and manage each one
    • how to manage herxheimer reactions – don’t know what these are? This is essential info if you want to use CEASE safely and appropriately!
    • other supports and therapies that are very beneficial in CEASE cases, particularly in the management of these complex cases – specific cell salts, bowel nosodes, flower essences and additional therapies to consider that can help the healing process to unfold much more gently and easily
Such a lot of quackery. I note that, elsewhere, it is revealed that Smits died in 2010 and Kalina is carrying on his “legacy,” such as it is. She is also described as “one of the five approved instructors for the CEASE Organization (the others being in the Netherlands, Germany and Sweden), and brings extensive experience in both teaching and clinical case management to the CEASE community.” Kalina also misuses the concept of the Herxheimer reaction, which is sometimes seen after the initiation of antibacterials for tick-borne relapsing fever due to the release of endotoxin-like products by microorganisms as they die off during antibiotic treatment. It was first described as a reaction to the treatment of syphilis with penicillin and is also seen after treatment of other diseases caused by spirochetes, such as Lyme disease and leptospirosis. Yes, basically, Kalina is claiming that CEASE therapy can cause a “healing crisis” in which the patient gets worse before getting better. This is a common claim among quacks.
So what will happen? It’s noted in one story:
College bylaws prohibit false and misleading advertising, including marketing “likely to create in the mind of the recipient or intended recipient an unjustified expectation about the results which the registrant can achieve.”
The college also forbids naturopaths from advising against vaccination unless there is a “sound, and properly documented, medical rationale for doing so.”
I expect that nothing will come of this complaint against these three naturopaths. After all, if any “board” of naturopathy were actually to enforce standards like the ones above, it would have to take away the license of pretty much every naturopath under its regulatory authority.
Michigan legislators, take note. This is what naturopaths want for Michigan, and, if you pass a naturopathic licensure bill into law, this is what they will get.

Australian review: Get homeopathy out of pharmacies
An independent review of Australian pharmacy practice has recommended that homeopathic products be kept out of pharmacies.
Scott Gavura on July 13, 2017
Link

For years, science advocates and health professionals have been singling out pharmacies for giving undue legitimacy (and shelf space) to homeopathy. But the pharmacy profession can’t seem to separate itself from the sale of this profitable placebo. The issue is one of paternalism and ethics. Homeopathic “remedies” look like conventional medicine when they’re stocked on pharmacy shelves. But unlike conventional medicine, homeopathic products don’t contain any “medicine” at all. Homeopathy is fundamentally incompatible with a scientific understanding of medicine, biochemistry and even physics. Questions have been raised worldwide about the ethics of pharmacists and pharmacies selling homeopathy to consumers who may think they’re buying medicine when they’re effectively buying sugar pills. The profession has largely ignored the issue, seemingly comfortable with leaving the decision to sell up to individual stores, and dealing with homeopathy strictly in commercial terms (which, I have argued, is also unethical.) While some retail pharmacists and pharmacies refuse to sell homeopathy, the overwhelming majority of community pharmacists have allowed it to find a space on most pharmacy shelves.
Homeopathy is not herbalism
It could be that pharmacists don’t understand the facts of homeopathy. Homeopathy is often misunderstood as a natural remedy, akin to a type of herbalism. The marketing and labeling of these “remedies” encourages this perception, often describing homeopathy as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing, and putting cryptic terms like “30C” beside long Latin names of what appears to be the active ingredients. In reality, there is little likelihood that a homeopathic remedy contains even a single molecule of any listed ingredient. So while there may be hundreds of homeopathic remedies in a pharmacy, they are chemically indistinguishable, usually containing just sugar, water, or alcohol.
As would be expected with inert products, rigorous clinical trials confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. Two of the more comprehensive reviews of the evidence are the 2010 Evidence Check from the United Kingdom’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee and the 2014 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council review, which reached the following conclusion:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness. People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner and should keep taking any prescribed treatments. The National Health and Medical Research Council expects that the Australian public will be offered treatments and therapies based on the best available evidence.
Emphasis added.
Do regulators understand the issue?
As a pharmacist, I’m responsible for my own continuous professional development and education. My provincial pharmacy regulator is responsible for ensuring pharmacists are competent, and a variety of tools are used to ensure that’s the case. I recently received a notification from my regulator that I’m required to complete a self-assessment tool as part of a quality assurance review. All pharmacists in my province are required to complete this requirement at least once every five years. In short, we must assess our own learning needs, implement a plan, and evaluate its effectiveness as it applies to pharmacy practice. We are required to document this plan, using a tool to describe our education plan. Imagine my surprise when I noticed this in the drop-down menu of categories:
Pharmacists are the health professionals with specialized training in pharmacology, and an education that concentrates on drug design, delivery and understanding how to use medicines effectively and safely. If any health professional should recognize the logical and scientific leaps that homeopathy necessitates, it should be pharmacists. So it’s obviously concerning when regulators themselves either don’t understand the issue, or don’t seem concerned about embedding homeopathy into a pharmacist’s education. While I personally believe that pharmacists need to make this change themselves (similar to how the profession has largely quit its tobacco habit), it could be that regulators are barriers, not enablers, of change.
An “unacceptable risk” in pharmacies
An independent review of Australian pharmacy practice has recommended that homeopathic products should be kept out of pharmacies that provide government-funded medications to patients. Entitled Review of Pharmacy Remuneration and Regulation, the report provides guidance to the entire retail pharmacy industry to support Australian access to safe, high-quality medicines and pharmacy care. The review is part of a broader agreement between the Australian government and the Pharmacy Guild, the national organization for pharmacists and pharmacies. Remarkably, the interim report describes homeopathy as presenting an “unacceptable risk” to consumers:
The general consensus as demonstrated by submissions to the Review and the Panel’s face-to-face consultations is that homeopathy and homeopathic products do not belong in community pharmacies. The majority of pharmacists and other stakeholders argued that these products lack any evidence base and have sufficient evidence of non-efficacy to preclude their ethical sale in community pharmacies. This is supported by the public positions of professional pharmacy bodies – for example, the PSA [Pharmaceutical Society of Australia], whose Position Statement on Complementary Medicine states: “PSA does not support the sale of homeopathy products in pharmacy.”
The only defence put to the Panel regarding homeopathy was that it was harmless and able to be used as a placebo in certain circumstances. The Panel does not believe that this argument is sufficient to justify the continued sale of these products in pharmacies that supply PBS [Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme] medicines. In particular, the Panel notes that the supply of homeopathic products through pharmacies is not benign but, rather, risks creating a perception of reliability and efficacy in the mind of the consumer based on the status of the pharmacy as a healthcare provider. This may encourage patients to choose a homeopathic product over a conventional medicine with robust evidence of efficacy, which creates a risk of harm to the patient’s health.
Its recommendation is unambiguous:
SALE OF HOMEOPATHIC PRODUCTS
Homeopathy and homeopathic products should not be sold in PBS-approved pharmacies. This requirement should be referenced and enforced through relevant policies, standards and guidelines issued by professional pharmacy bodies.
The report also give specific advice on “complementary” medicines such as supplements, recommending that they be shelved in a separate area of the pharmacy, recognizing that they are not subject to the same evidence requirements to be allowed for sale (similar to Canada and the United States):
In general, stakeholders put forward the view that pharmacists perform a valuable role in advising consumers on complementary medicines. However, there is some concern relating to the sale of products with a limited evidence base, or none at all, alongside prescription and other scheduled medicines.
Its recommendation is a compromise between access and evidentiary concerns:
Community pharmacists are encouraged to:
a. display complementary medicines for sale in a separate area where customers can easily access a pharmacist for appropriate advice on their selection and use
b. provide appropriate information to consumers on the extent of, or limitations to, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) role in the approval of complementary medicines. This could be achieved through the provision of appropriate signage (in the area in which these products are sold) that clearly references any limitations on the medical efficacy of these products noted by the TGA.
If you’re interested in commenting directly on the interim report, submissions are accepted through July 23, 2017.
Community or retail pharmacy is a unique mix of health care delivery within a private, for-profit retailer. Yet pharmacies have a specific, designated role in the health care system. For that reason, pharmacies can and should to do more than what we might expect from another retailer. Pharmacists ought to know better, and they ought to do better. It will be interesting to see the consequences of this review on the profession of pharmacy in Australia.

Pharmacies continue to sell sugar pills as flu remedy
Oscillococcinum is a homeopathic remedy that is made by taking the heart and liver of a duck and diluting it to nothing. It’s a placebo, but sold widely by pharmacies as a “treatment” for colds and influenza.
Scott Gavura on January 24, 2019
Link


Retail pharmacies have had a sugar pill problem for some time – in the form of glorified placebos that are sold as medicine. Homeopathic “remedies” may look like conventional medicine when they’re stocked on pharmacy shelves. But unlike conventional medicine that has actual ingredients, homeopathic products don’t contain any “medicine” at all. Not surprisingly, there is convincing evidence to show that homeopathy is useless as a medical treatment, and fundamentally incompatible with a scientific understanding of medicine, biochemistry and even physics. So why is it sold in pharmacies? There is a fair case to be made that this practice is unethical, as pharmacy sales may mislead consumers into thinking that these products are safe and effective. Yet a recent survey showed two-thirds of Montreal pharmacies sell the placebo flu remedy Oscillococcinum. In the midst of flu season, why would pharmacies sell an inert substance to consumers?
Duck that’s really, really, (really) diluted
Part of the objections to homeopathy in pharmacies is based on the fact that it is nothing but a placebo. Homeopathy is often misunderstood as a natural remedy, akin to a type of herbalism. Homeopathy was invented out of whole cloth in 1796 by Samuel Hahnemann, a German physician. He described the practice as guided by two key principles, which he called “laws”:
     1.  The “Law” of Similars – Hahnemann believed substances that produce specific symptoms in healthy people will cure those same symptoms in an ill person. Sometimes referred to as “like cures like”, the law of similars is simply a form of magical thinking. Homeopathic “remedies” can be made with natural ingredients like salt or onions, but also substances like shipwrecks, light bulbs, the Berlin Wall and even vacuum cleaner dust or moonlight. When infectious material is used, the remedy is called a “nosode” and homeopaths believe that these products can cure or prevent infections. Deciding which substances will cure which symptoms is determined by a process called a “proving” which is entirely without any scientific basis.
     2.  The “Law” of Infinitesimals – Hahnemann believed that the effectiveness of a remedy increases the more that remedy was diluted. He advocated a series of sequential dilutions with shaking (succussion) after each dilution, believing that the water would “remember” its contact with the original substance. According to Hahnemann’s theories, when sufficient water has been added to dilute the original substance away so that zero molecules remain, the “remedy” was thought to be at its most powerful. Imagine putting one drop of a substance into a container of water. Only that container is 131 light-years in diameter. Now shake it. That’s equivalent to the “30C” dilution that is popular with homeopaths. You’d have to eat a tablet of sugar the size of the Earth to get a single molecule of the original substance.
Oscillococcinum is prepared by decapitating a barbary duck, taking 35 grams of its liver and 15 grams of its heart and fermenting it for 40 days:
One duck supplies the world
The fermented duck broth then undergoes serial dilutions (1 part in 100) 200 times in a row, (i.e., 200C). The final dilution is dripped on tablets of lactose and sucrose. 200C is seriously potent in homeopathy-speak. It’s been noted that in order to obtain even a single molecule of the original fermented duck, a volume of tablets greater that the mass of the entire universe would need to be consumed. Here is a table showing just how dilute it is:
Oscilliocconium: Really, really, really dilute
It is mathematically impossible that there is any of the original fermented goo in the final product. Yet you might not know any of that if you read the packaging.
Selling nonsense
There is no serious scientific debate about homeopathy. Consequently you’d expect pharmacy schools, filled with PhD’s with backgrounds in pharmacology, medicinal chemistry, and therapeutics, to have the requisite background and ethical principles to caution students, and the broader pharmacy profession, about the implausibility and ethical unacceptability for the pharmacy profession to offer homeopathy for sale. You’d probably expect the profession (which is self-regulated in most countries) would want to avoid the association with pseudo-science. You’d be wrong:
A survey of 150 Montreal pharmacies conducted last month by the McGill Office for Science and Society found that two-thirds of them stocked Oscillococcinum, despite the fact that the product “does not work [and] cannot work according to our scientific knowledge,” reads a publication on the office’s website. The product, which claims to shorten the duration of flu symptoms, was retailing for $37.99 for a box of 30 doses at a Montreal Jean-Coutu pharmacy Wednesday.
The Office for Science And Society at McGill University recently undertook a survey in Montreal to understand just how easy it is to find Oscilliococcinum in a pharmacy:
We focused exclusively on the five biggest pharmacy chains in Quebec: Jean-Coutu, Familiprix, Uniprix, Proxim, and Pharmaprix. For each chain, a sample of 30 pharmacies was chosen by a random number generator.
And the calls started, all in French, with the following script: “I would like to know if you carry a certain homeopathic remedy. It’s called Oscillococcinum, it’s a homeopathic remedy against the flu made by Boiron.” If they did not have it, I asked if this was something they normally carried. I spoke to either a floor clerk or a member of the pharmacy staff behind the counter, depending on who knew the answer. That was it. And I kept a tally.
Out of the 150 pharmacies on the island of Montreal that were called for this investigation, 66% of them reported carrying Oscillococcinum (30% did not, while 4% could not be reached, often because the listed pharmacy had closed). Some chains were more likely to sell the product, with Jean-Coutu and Pharmaprix being the most likely (80% of their stores had it) and Proxim being the least likely (50% of their stores carried it).
Who is looking out for consumers?
I’m not surprised at the findings. I have seen Oscilliococcinum in virtually every pharmacy I’ve visited. In the few times I’ve asked the pharmacist why they sell it, the response is invariably “We don’t get to decide what’s carried on the shelves”, which is a fair point, because most pharmacists work for large corporations now – as employees, and the autonomy they might have in an owner-operated pharmacy is long gone. Yet it’s also fair to note that selling homeopathy is contrary to pharmacy ethics, a point I’ve made before and one that’s echoed in this investigation:
An evidence-based profession is selling you sugar pills
The fact that two-thirds of Montreal-based pharmacies will sell us a pseudo-treatment for the flu that targets adults, children and infants alike is hard to square with the Quebec Order of Pharmacists’ mission statement. They describe said mission as “ensuring the protection of the public”, but how is the public protected when pharmacies are selling them placebo pills? The harm is partly financial: 30 doses of these worthless globules retail for CAD 36. It is also in the false sense of security parents will gain and the delay in proper treatment if needed. And, ultimately, it is in the legitimization of a pseudoscience the founding principle of which is that the more you add water to something (like alcohol), the more powerful it becomes.
This isn’t just an issue for Quebec – it’s a worldwide issue for the profession of pharmacy. Given the ethics of homeopathy, it’s disappointing to see some pharmacy associations change their codes of ethics to facilitate the sale of homeopathy, rather than simply removing them from pharmacy shelves. In contrast, other pharmacy associations are calling for their removal, as we’re seeing in Australia:
Community pharmacy banner and buying groups should draw a line in the sand and cease all activities that encourage the stocking, promotion, recommendation or marketing of homeopathy, the Pharmaceutical Society of Australia (PSA) said today. PSA National President Dr Chris Freeman published an open letter and wrote to major banner and buying groups, stating that many people were not aware that there was no reliable evidence for the use of homeopathic products.
“Public health is put at risk if people choose homeopathy over treatments that evidence shows are safe and effective,” he said.
PSA provided advice to pharmacists in its Choosing Wisely recommendations last month. One of the six recommendations is:
“Do not promote or provide homeopathic products as there is no reliable evidence of efficacy. Where patients choose to access homeopathic treatments, health professionals should discuss the lack of benefit with patients.”
“Where there are homeopathic products available from community pharmacies, patients may see this as a de-facto endorsement,” Dr Freeman said. The supply of homeopathic products is in contravention of the PSA Code of Ethics for Pharmacists. The Code of Ethics, recognised by the Pharmacy Board of Australia, states that pharmacists should only “supply or promote any medicine, complementary medicine, herbal remedy or other healthcare product where there is credible evidence of efficacy and the benefit of use outweighs the risk.” “The PSA Code of Ethics makes it clear that homeopathic products should not be stocked or sold in community pharmacies. Banner and buying groups should do everything in their power to remove these products from their shelves,” Dr Freeman said.
This continued tension between the “business of pharmacy” and the professional responsibilities of pharmacists, as health care professionals, has always been around. At one time, most pharmacies sold cigarettes. Now (at least in Canada) they don’t – it was a professional decision to stop the sale, implemented by the profession itself. But that pressure to get the customer in the door and sell them what they want (and not just what they need) continues. And despite the evidence, homeopathy is allowed for sale, and it’s marketed for medical conditions. Few pharmacies seem willing to turn down a potential sale. Yes, pharmacists are trusted health professionals. That trust has been earned. Will the profession maintain it?

Stop Making Sense
Mark Crislip on May 4, 2012
Link
I usually rely on the Secret. Every two weeks or so the Universe offers up some bit of wacky whimsey and I have a topic for an SBM blog entry. This week the Universe has failed me. Nothing has crossed my LCD so I have no studies to evaluate and I have been unusually busy at work preventing my browsing the Interwebs for material. But try telling that to the Managing Editor. I write half to amuse myself, half to learn about the topic, and half to clarify in my own mind the topics at hand (1). So this week is content free idle thoughts for my own benefit.
I have been reading 13 Things That Don’t Make Sense by Michael Brooks. The book concerns topics in science that are unexplained by the current understanding of the laws of the universe or contradict the dominant paradigm. Well, almost. His final topic is homeopathy, and it is the one topic whose conclusions, while qualified, belong on Failblog. The first chapter concerns dark matter and dark energy and how what we can see makes up only a small fraction of the content of the universe. 
The author discusses the history behind the discovery of dark matter and dark energy, and the theories that attempt to explain the cosmological measurements that demonstrate the dark existence. Besides new kinds of matter, physicists have hypothesized that the problem is not undiscovered matter but a lack of understanding of the nature of gravity. He discusses at length the Pioneer anomaly, the fact that the Pioneer space probes, launched in the 1970’s, are not following their projected trajectories and perhaps this was a manifestation of the dark matter/dark energy/modified gravity. Evidently it wasn’t, the perturbations are probably due to radiation pressures.
What is striking is the description of the approach to the measurements that led to the hypothesis of dark energy and matter and the Pioneer anomaly. The investigators took extreme care in looking for every possible error within known physical parameters rather than looking for new physics to explain the data. The lead investigator of the Pioneer anomaly said something to the effect, when you go into something looking for something new, that is what you will see.
I do not have an exact quote, since I am reading (2) the Audible book version, and the one problem with audio books is you cannot underline important quotes.
That is a striking characteristic of the evaluations of observations that contradict the known laws of the universe. First, the researchers were meticulous at looking into every possible reason for the anomalous results within known laws. And when they found anomalies, like the paths of stars circling galactic centers that suggesting the presence of dark matter, they carefully peat and repeat the measurements to confirm the findings before releasing the results.
It is the care with which physicist/astronomers and others in the ‘hard’ scientist evaluate the natural world that is impressive. They consistently rely first on the basic principals that have centuries of careful observation and experiment to validate their approximate truth. In the case of the Pioneer anomaly, there was no new physics to explain the trajectory, although it took 30 years to find the solution. In the case of stars orbiting the galactic center and the accelerating expansion of the universe, something unexplained was occurring. In both cases, a meticulous comparison to known reality was key to the understanding of the validity of the observed phenomena. They relied on basic principals.
The author also notes what happens when investigators evaluate phenomena with pre-existing ideas as to what they should find. I have always used the example of N-Rays, but Brooks uses Percival Lowell as an example. Lowell was an astronomer who was committed to finding a civilization of Mars, and as a consequence saw and mapped a complex canal system on the planet. The ability to see what you want to be there, rather than what is actually there, is one of the hallmarks of bad science, although in Lowell’s case he may have been inadvertently mapping the vessels of his own eye. I initially wanted to write an entire entry on the topic of scientific paradolia, but besides N-rays and Mars canals, I could not come up with similar examples. Freud? Perhaps.
The counter example, the disasters that result from ignoring basic principles, and of avoiding repetition and careful measurement was typified by Pons and Fleishman and the cold fusion debacle. There are phenomena not yet dreamt of in our philosophy, but if you are going to discover results that violate the basic laws of the universe, it had best be measured carefully and consistently reproduced. Cold fusion does not meet those criteria.
It is quite a contrast with the studies of SCAM modalities. Most SCAMs have no basis in known physics, chemistry, physiology, anatomy, etc. Acupuncture, homeopathy, reiki, chiropractic and their ilk are not based in reality but fantasy. It is the concept of prior plausibility, or what I would call a reality bias (3), that makes any positive findings more likely to error and bias. It is clear, particularly well delineated with acupuncture, that these modalities have no effect on objective endpoints and only minor effects on subjective endpoints. Increasingly well designed studies reveal decreasing effects until excellent studies show no effect. SCAMs are the medical N- rays and Mars canals. Yet in medicine, rather than noting that the studies are based in unreality and repeating careful studies that help tease out the biases and mistakes that make most SCAM trials appear to have effectiveness, they open Centers for integrative, alternative and complementary therapies.
It is odd, the blindness of the medical practice for rank nonsense. Brooks describes the opprobrium that Pons, Fleishman and others received for their trumpeting of imaginary breakthroughs, although I suspect it was not what they did, but how they did it, bypassing peer review in favor of a press release, that led to the pariah status they now apparently have. Researchers in quackery, rather than exile in France, start Clinics and Institutes. While the collapse of the careers of Pons and Fleishman et. al as described by Brooks seems excessive for the ‘crime,’ the only consequence in medicine for practicing magic is cash.
Outside of medicine careful research confirms or denies our understanding of reality. In medicine, at least with SCAMs to judge from the Bravewell report, reality is ignored.
The last two chapters of the book cover placebo and homeopathy. In the case of placebo, Brooks is a little sloppy at times at differentiating the difference between subjective and objective outcomes. In the example of homeopathy he focuses on a few anomalous studies that were never reproduced and a long, and interesting, description of mysteries of water, to wonder about the unknown properties of H2o that could validate homeopathy, all the while admitting homeopathy is, by current understanding, total nonsense. But as he consistently noted in the prior chapters, anomalous studies that can’t be reproduced and violate the basic laws of science turn out to be nonsense. Then he ignores the same lessons in his conclusions about homeopathy: based on a bit of popularity of the crowd (how can millions be wrong?) and the fact that since there other anomalies have led to insights, homeopathy may indeed have something to it. I doubt it.
Understanding often advances with anomalous studies that are reproducible and where more mundane explanations consistent with known physical laws are excluded. As Asimov noted, “The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not “Eureka” but “That’s funny…” SCAMs remain funny, but not in the way Asimov suggested As they stand today, the anomalies of SCAM are no more than error and bias. If Ioannidis is correct about real medicine, and he is, then he is doubly correct for SCAM research. Instead of learning from past research, marginally positive results of poorly designed studies are seen as proof of efficacy, despite no prior plausibility for and the opportunities for error and bias are enormous. And then you charge the ill and vulnerable for the privilege of receiving your nonsense.
Astrology is not taught as a subset of astronomy for good reason. There is no alternative aviation, complementary engineering or integrative fire fighting. Medicine is different and it sometimes saddens me.
Notes1) 3 out of 2 Americans do not understand statistics.
2) Yes, I am reading the book. Unless you say the blind are feeling the book.
3) Foreshadowing of SBM to come.

Fake Homeopathy COVID Scam
A naturopath was arrested for selling fake homeopathic COVID treatments, which reveals the “alternative” rot in the medical system.
Steven Novella on July 21, 2021
Link

The Department of Justice announced that it has arrested Juli A. Mazi, 41, of Napa for, “one count of wire fraud and one count of false statements related to health care matters”. While the arrest is encouraging, it also highlights the incongruous double standard that currently exists in medicine.
Although this is not stated in the DoJ announcement, Mazi is a naturopath who practices as a primary care physician in California. Her practice includes “classic homeopathy”, which is something we have discussed at length on SBM. In short, homeopathic potions are made from fanciful ingredients but often diluted to such an extent that no original ingredients remain. They are therefore mostly just magic water, claimed to contain the “energy” of its previous contents. If that weren’t enough, extensive clinical trials have demonstrated that homeopathic magic water doesn’t work for any indication that has been tested.
What caught the attention of the DoJ was a tip that Mazi was selling homeopathic pellets as a substitute for COVID vaccination. As the announcement states:
This defendant allegedly defrauded and endangered the public by preying on fears and spreading misinformation about FDA-authorized vaccinations, while also peddling fake treatments that put people’s lives at risk. Even worse, the defendant allegedly created counterfeit COVID-19 vaccination cards and instructed her customers to falsely mark that they had received a vaccine, allowing them to circumvent efforts to contain the spread of the disease,
First, she was spreading misinformation about the FDA-authorized COVID vaccines. Obviously, in the middle of a pandemic, especially when we are bumping up against vaccine misinformation in terms of the vaccination program, such actions are horrific. But of course, Mazi is not the only one spreading such misinformation. As we pointed out previously, it was found that 65% of misinformation on Facebook and Twitter is coming from just 12 individuals – the “Disinformation Dozen”. That, however, is apparently insufficient to garner the attention of the DoJ. I understand that the DoJ has no authority to do anything in these cases, because they have technically not broken any laws (and that, of course, is the problem).
The DoJ statement also cited Mazi for “peddling fake treatments that put people’s lives at risk”. So – just like almost the entire alternative medicine industry and a huge part of the supplement industry. How is Mazi unlike any other naturopath? Anyone selling homeopathy, acupuncture, untested herbal remedies, energy medicine, or most things labeled “alternative” are “peddling fake treatments”.
What really makes Mazi different is the next bit – giving counterfeit COVID-19 vaccinations cards to her customers. Tellingly, the DoJ considers this to be “even worse” that peddling fake treatments that risk people’s lives. But is it really? I would consider selling fake treatments to be at the top of my list. From the DoJ perspective, the counterfeit cards is what makes this a legal case at all. If Mazi had just skipped that part, she could have continued selling fake homeopathic pellets to her customers, risking their lives, without any legal entanglements. We know this is true because there are countless alternative practitioners doing that right now, just as there are others spreading misinformation about vaccines.
There is also some concern about what is actually in those homeopathic pellets. Mazi claims they have a tiny part of the COVID-19. Hopefully, that’s a lie. If they were prepared from infected source material, that would be a legitimate concern (but this did not crack the DoJ’s top three). Homeopathic potions are not always harmless, sometimes they actually contain stuff. Let’s hope this is not one of those times.
Mazi instructs her customers that they should take 2-4 pellets, but the amount doesn’t really matter. You can give the same dose to infants. It’s all magic energy anyway, so silly things like dosing are inconsequential. She claims without evidence that this will produce lifelong immunity to COVID, because of the magic energy that will teach your immune system to fight the virus.
In the announcement the DoJ touts their “Health Care Fraud Strike Force”, which they indicate has charged individuals who have “billed the Medicare program for nearly $19 billion”. Again, they give away the real focus of this task force, Medicare fraud. So if you just charge your customers cash, you can fly under the DoJ radar.
My real point in discussing this case is to point out the hypocrisy of the whole situation. The government often makes a big show of cracking down on health fraud, but not for selling fake treatments with unproven claims. Cases typically involve some other kind of fraud. Meanwhile we allow, even celebrate, the increasing existence in our healthcare system and marketplace of unproven products and practitioners who are overtly not science-based. We allow practitioners to sell unproven, often blatantly unscientific, treatments and products with unproven health claims. Homeopathy is legal and has an FDA stamp of approval. Naturopaths are licensed by many states.
Now, during the worst pandemic in the last century, we are seeing what this brings us. Anti-vaccine disinformation is rife within the alternative medicine community. Practitioners will sell fake treatments for COVID – that is what they are often licensed to do. Homeopathy is literally 100% health fraud, and yet we sanction its existence. It is sold alongside real medicine in pharmacies. Our tolerance of what previous generations considered health fraud, our acceptance of rebranding fraud as “alternative”, “complementary”, or “integrative” is biting us hard.
You can’t water down the science-based standard of care in medicine, carve out exceptions, weaken regulations, and allow unscientific practitioners to spread dangerous misinformation, attack science-based institutions and undermine experts, and then complain when they do exactly that, just because we are in a pandemic.
This should be a wake-up call. People often ask “what’s the harm” of allowing what are essentially placebo treatments to thrive. This is the harm. Our science-based infrastructure has been devastated, and now we are literally dying from medical misinformation.

The Worst Homeopathy Study. Ever
Mark Crislip on September 18, 2015
Link


I run across a lot of information in my feeds that I need to save for further evaluation. The study “Does additional antimicrobial treatment have a better effect on URTI cough resolution than homeopathic symptomatic therapy alone? A real-life preliminary observational study in a pediatric population“, I saved with the file name, ‘jaw droppingly stupid’.
The worst homeopathy clinical trial ever doesn’t spring full formed like Athena from the head of Zeus. No. The worst homeopathy clinical trial ever started with a seed. The seed is “Homeopathic medicine for acute cough in upper respiratory tract infections and acute bronchitis: A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial, which is a standard lousy homeopathic study.
Would that it were syrup of Lethe
Individualization of care, so beloved by homeopaths as a reason their particular form of magic cannot be tested, was ignored so that 80 adults were randomized to receive either a homeopathic nostrum or a placebo. The nostrum, delivered as a syrup, was:
Anemone pulsatilla 6 CH, Rumex crispus 6 CH, Bryonia dioica 3 CH, Ipecacuanha 3 CH, Spongia tosta 3 CH, Sticta pulmonaria 3 CH, Antimonium tartaricum 6 CH, Myocarde 6 CH, Coccus cacti 3 CH, Drosera MT. It is important to note that concentrations are expressed in the usual format for homeopathic products, where 1 CH stands for a 1:100 dilution, so that a dilution of 3 CH means that three serial 1:100 dilutions were performed from a starting concentration of 1 M (i.e., 1 mol/L), and thus the overall dilution is 1:1003 , which corresponds to a final concentration of 1 μM. Similarly, a 6 CH dilution corresponds to a final concentration of 1 pM.
Unlike most homeopathic products, it appears that there are some actual chemicals left behind in this product. A homeopathic product needs to be deluded, er, I mean diluted past 12 C to contain nothing, 12 C being “the greatest dilution reasonably likely to contain even one molecule of the original substance.”They followed patients for cough resolution and on one day, the 7th, there was a statistically significant difference but the error bars overlapped (I have become convinced that the minimum significant p is 0.005, and that presumes a high prior plausibility). At the end of the two weeks both groups had equal cough resolution. They measured sputum viscosity (I gag just thinking about it) and while the measured viscosity was improved in the homeopathic group:
…the patients did not appear to significantly perceive this difference.
Whether blinding was successful is not mentioned. Oh yeah and:
Publication of this article was supported by an unrestricted grant from Boiron.
See, they are paid shills of Big Homeo. A positive study is what you would expect given who funded it, and the authors delivered as a lackey should*:
study shows that the tested homeopathic medicine was more effective and faster than a placebo in alleviating cough caused by uncomplicated URTIs.
Nope. I see the results as demonstrating no difference between placebo and placebo, but given there may be actual active molecules in the product, perhaps it had some effect. But I doubt it.
Turn your head and retch
I suspect that any product that really could suppress a cough, and all OTC products do not, would require the patient to be intubated. I do suffer from the naturalistic fallacy when it comes to treating the symptoms of infections for comfort reasons. Fever, cough and diarrhea, among others, have evolved for a purpose and there should be compelling reasons beyond comfort to suppress them. While there is good information to suggest usually treating fever is counter-productive, I can find little literature for the downsides of suppressing cough, probably as nothing is really effective. The urge to cough is too strong. The only good cough suppressant I know of is a rib fracture, and that has its own issues.
The seed was planted. I see fallow ground. The authors? The chance to grow the Worst. Homeopathic. Study. Ever.
Background: cough is common in children. The cough is usually viral and/or asthma. Viruses do not respond to antibiotics. Duh. Giving antibiotics for a viral infection is, from the perspective of an infectious disease doctor, stupid. Real stupid. Jaw-droppingly stupid, as noted by the file name. Patients often expect antibiotics and responsible/ethical physicians resist the pressure, since antibiotics cost money, have side effects and, when given inappropriately, only help breed antibiotic resistance, a growing problem.
Jaw-droppingly stupid is a term that does not usually appear in the medical literature. Instead they prefer the kinder, gentler inappropriate use of antibiotics.
Antibiotics should be used only for bacterial infections and are not effective against the viruses that cause many illnesses including influenza and most upper respiratory tract infections, including the common cold, or fungal infections like those caused by yeast. The inappropriate use of antibiotics for these types of infections as well as the more frequent use of broad-spectrum antibiotics has caused the emergence of newer strains of bacteria that are resistant to many antibiotics.
But in 2015 deliberately using antibacterials for non-bacterial infections is, let’s be honest, incompetent and/or stupid.
This study took children with a cough. Arguing that patients’ parents expect antibiotics (!?!), they decided to do a study comparing homeopathy to homeopathy plus antibiotics.
That is what made this the most jaw-droppingly worst study ever. They did not compare homeopathy with or without standard therapy. No. They compared the use of homeopathy with or without inappropriate unethical antibiotics. Or you could say they compared pseudo-medicine to pseudo-medicine combined with the deliberate practice of bad medicine.
Laser-guided incompetence
Quite a feat when you think of it. It is not often that a study is deliberately designed to provide and reinforce incompetent care. I cannot remember a study with such a flaw in all the time I have been reading SCAM papers.
The results? Remember: no placebo group. Well, no deliberate placebo group. Both interventions were, in reality, placebo. And there was no difference in time to resolution of cough. What a surprise. Treat a self-limited disease with two useless and one inappropriate intervention and patients get better at the same rate.
Their conclusion? The discussion says:
The data of the present study also indicate that adding antimicrobial agents to the homeopathic syrup does not in any way benefit the symptomatic treatment
And then suggest in the conclusion:
Our data confirm that the homeopathic treatment in question has potential benefits for cough in children as well
It does nothing of the sort. The study demonstrated that cough gets better when you give one of two placebos. Did the reviewers even read this paper? Another example of peer review, as in peer: look keenly or with difficulty at someone or something. Someone peered at the paper and suggested publication.
Remember that 24% of the children had a side effect to the antibiotics, an intervention that none of them would, or at least should, have received under appropriate medical care. The interventions in this study ONLY caused harm.
Worst thing to happen to Helsinki since Stalin
This study was approved, with another fail, by an institutional review board. They note the study:
was conducted according to the Helsinki declaration, which is here.
Since it is a homeopathy study they immediately fail:
Medical research involving human subjects must conform to generally accepted scientific principles.
And since the use of antibiotics in this study would, in the real world, be considered awful practice that should only give side effects without benefit, I do not see how they pass:
The Declaration of Geneva of the WMA binds the physician with the words, “The health of my patient will be my first consideration,” and the International Code of Medical Ethics declares that, “A physician shall act in the patient’s best interest when providing medical care.”
Not only jaw-droppingly stupid, but jaw-droppingly unethical, even for a pseudo-medicine study. This is a run up to a larger, and probably even more jaw-droppingly awful, study. It:
was a pilot study conducted before starting a larger trial on the role of antitussive and mucolytic drugs in children; however, the results of this preliminary study can provide valuable information for the sizing of future rigorous controlled studies
So expect more of the same, only bigger. But I bet not better. They will only harm more children without any potential benefit.
Worst. Homeopathy. Study. Ever.
Find me one that is worse.
* sarcasm for the irony impaired.
Note: Clay has already reviewed this study, but why should he get all the “fun”?

Homeopathy Ramblings
Mark Crislip on June 28, 2013
Link
There needs to be a SCAM index, some quantitative tool, a formula for ranking the SCAMs, so one SCAM could reign supreme, to be definitely declared the the goofiest of all SCAMs. Perhaps (number of adherents)x(number of Pubmed publications)x(age of SCAM) all divided by a plausibility factor.
Homeopathy would win and any SCAM index that did not rank homeopathy at number one would have to put up a very convincing argument indeed that their formula was not somehow fundamentally flawed.1
For first time readers, homeopathy is based on several fictions, totally divorced from reality, made up in the 1800’s.
The first law,2 with less reality than Joe Abercrombie’s, is, “similia similibus curentur,” or “let like be cured by like”. Substances which cause specific symptoms can be used to cure diseases which cause the same symptoms. If like cures like, I am uncertain what moonlight, one of many fanciful homeopathic nostrums, would cure. Lycanthropy?
Say you have a headache. What causes a headache? Being smacked on the head by a hammer. So in homeopathic thinking, being hit on the head with a hammer would cure your headache.
But you would not want to give known poisons like arsenic or belladonna to people in attempt for like to cure like, unless one would classify death as cure. Even the otherwise chemistry-challenged homeopaths know that would be a bad idea.
So there is the second law, that of infinitesimal dilutions, where the substances are sequentially diluted in either water or alcohol, and the potency increases with each dilution. And dilute it they do.
Take the hammer for the migraine. Take 100th of it. Thump the remainder against a Bible to activate it, the succussion of homeopathy. Then take 100th of that. Thump it against a Bible. Then 100th of that. Thump it against a Bible. And so on. Do that 6, or 15, or 30 or even 200 times. When finished you will have the an extremely small, perhaps nonexistent, but potentized hammer with power exceeding Mjölnir. Use that to hit the skull to relieve the headache.
It doesn’t get goofier than that. Homeopathy is one of those topics which demonstrates that I am not a true skeptic. A true skeptic would say that homeopathy is highly implausible. I tend to say it is wackaloon impossible on basic principles. Zero plausibility would make homeopathy infinite on the SCAM index.
Homeopathy and adverse effects
Given that homeopathy is nothing that does nothing, not only would I expect any homeopathic preparation to have no efficacy but also no toxicity. With the caveat that it is the dose that makes the poison. Any product with less than 12 serial dilutions could have an active ingredient, so depending on what was being diluted a homeopathic nostrum could have effects, both good and bad.
I spend most of professional life in the hospital taking care of very ill people with multiple diseases and interventions. Trying to decide what is an adverse event is not always as straight forward as one would like. It is easier if the intervention is physical: a dropped lung from an acupuncture needle or a stroke after a chiropractic neck whack.
Determining what is an adverse reaction from medications is more difficult. Is it an allergic reaction? A toxic reaction? A drug-drug interaction? An unexpected complication of the medication altering the patient’s physiology in known or unknown ways? Adverse reactions have different mechanisms and it is often not clear-cut what is causing the reaction. If you stop the medication and the adverse reaction fades, it is nice but not diagnostic. It would be optimal to rechallange the patient to prove the adverse effect, but given the potential morbidity it is very rarely done.
Imagine my surprise when I stumbled across “Adverse effects of homeopathy: a systematic review of published case reports and case series.” My first thought was – no way! Nothing can’t cause an adverse reaction and I would be skeptical that a homeopath would recognize, much less report, an adverse reaction.
The article was one of the usual complete evaluations by E. Ernst and colleagues. As always he scoured the published literature, finding the most obscure of articles pertaining to the topic at hand, and summarized them nicely.
The abstract flabbered my gaster:
In total, 38 primary reports met our inclusion criteria. Of those, 30 pertained to direct AEs of homeopathic remedies; and eight were related to AEs caused by the substitution of conventional medicine with homeopathy. The total number of patients who experienced AEs of homeopathy amounted to 1159. Overall, AEs ranged from mild-to-severe and included four fatalities. The most common AEs were allergic reactions and intoxications. Rhus toxidendron was the most frequently implicated homeopathic remedy.
Four fatalities from giving nothing? It turns out that most of the adverse reactions were intoxications or allergic reactions and were not from giving nothing after all:
In 94.7% of cases, the potencies were described as below 12 C, the point beyond which the likelihood of a single molecule being present in the remedy approaches zero. It is plausible that low dilutions of homeopathic preparations cause direct AEs, particularly allergic reactions.
People were being given cesium, bromide, petroleum, mercury (at higher doses found in vaccines) and arsenic and getting toxicities. Patients were being poisoned.
Allergic reactions were most common to Rhus toxicodendron given at dilutions where there was a measurable level of the plant. But what is Rhus toxicodendron? Poison ivy. Really? People taking poison ivy and getting an allergic reaction as a result? Who da thunk it?
I wonder if the patients were told they were being given poison ivy, or just given the Latin name. Latin can obscure so well. Who would take duck heart and liver for influenza? Not me. But Anas Barbariae Hepatis et Cordis Extractum sounds like it could be legit. Latin is the Confundus Charm of homeopathy.
I have to admit when I think of homeopathy I think of water and sugar pills. I do not think of homeopaths as giving measurable amounts of chemicals and poison ivy to people.
But that gets to one of the issues with many SCAMs: poorly educated practitioners providing useless therapies for processes that do not exist when there are real diseases and toxicities they do not understand. I am surprised they found so few adverse reactions, although I suspect it is less an issue of under-reporting and more likely that most homeopaths would not recognize an adverse event.
The authors do indulge in a little classic understated humor:
Evidence of indirect AEs highlight the need for all homeopaths to be adequately trained such that harm of this nature can be avoided in future.
and
The preference of homeopathy over conventional medicine when dealing with serious, life-threatening conditions may cause serious harm, and this issue relates to the question of practitioner training…Again, we would therefore stress the need for making sure all homeopaths are medically competent.
Then they would be, I don’t know, doctors? If homeopaths were adequately trained they would not be homeopaths, n’est pas? Can’t make a silk purse out of a sows ear.
Quantum homeopathy
35 years ago I graduated University of Oregon (Go Ducks) with a degree in physics. There was a time when I really understood modern physics (quantum mechanics and relativity), at least as it was 35 years ago and at the level of the undergraduate. I do not pretend to be a physicist, or even to play one television, although I like to read on the topics to maintain a general understanding. I may not be able to do the math anymore, but I remember the concepts and their limitations.
It is why I grimace whenever I see a SCAM article that attempts to explain its nonexistent efficacy in terms of quantum mechanics. The homeopaths seem to have a special affinity for this approach, starting with LR Milgrom, whose articles are gibberish to me. Yes, I know. If only I were a box of flashing lights I would be able to comprehend the deeper understanding of quantum homeopathy more fully.
Now there is more quantum understanding of homeopathy, A quantum-like model of homeopathy clinical trials: importance of in situ randomization and unblinding. Sorry. It was gibberish to me, and disappointing gibberish as well. The author states:
In order to make the notions of quantum physics more easily understandable, I will draw a formal comparison between homeopathy trials and single-particle interference in quantum physics.
And here I was so hoping they were going fire a series of homeopaths at a double slit to get the smearing effect of an interference pattern. No such luck. So disappointing. Somehow, and I am not certain how, the double slit is similar to homeopathic efficacy trials and their failure to demonstrate efficacy in randomized clinical trials (RCT):
I draw an analogy between the one-particle interference experiment and homeopathic trials, which appear to have comparable mathematical structures. Indeed, according to the context of the clinical trial (both observables e labels and pair concordance e measured by patient/practitioner vs. ‘external’ measure of labels), either only concordant pairs (CP) (equivalent to detection in D1) or both CP/ discordant pairs (DP) (i.e., equivalent to random detection by D1 and D2) are obtained (Figure 1 and Table 1). This suggested that a quantum (or more precisely quantum- like) model could be built to describe homeopathy trials, including the ‘paradoxical’ failure of homeopathy blind RCT.
And here I thought the failure of homeopathy to be effective in RCT’s was not paradoxical but was due to the fact homeopathy is based on fantasy and that its minimal (homeopathic?) effects were entirely due to bias. Homeopathy is the archetypal alternative medical beer goggles; it doesn’t alter the reality of disease, just the perception of it.
Our quantum-like model suggests that the correlations between positive outcomes and homeopathy treatment observed in open-label conditions vanish in conditions comparable to blind RCT.
Ioannidis got it wrong. The reason well-done studies show homeopathy does nothing is not because they minimize the confounding factors of
… study power and bias, the number of other studies on the same question, and, importantly, the ratio of true to no relationships among the relationships probed in each scientific field. In this framework, a research finding is less likely to be true when the studies conducted in a field are smaller; when effect sizes are smaller; when there is a greater number and lesser preselection of tested relationships; where there is greater flexibility in designs, definitions, outcomes, and analytical modes; when there is greater financial and other interest and prejudice; and when more teams are involved in a scientific field in chase of statistical significance.
Homeopathy failure in RCT’s is the result of quantum mechanics, not bias in poorly done studies on a fantastical intervention. The cat isn’t dead after all.
I thought it would be fun to finish this entry by explaining, as a joke, that the mechanism of homeopathy is not in quantum mechanics but is the result of dark energy and dark matter. Someone beat me to it, although not as humor:
What is required is just to understand Homeopathy medicines (alcohol) actually extracts this Dark Energy from substances when prepared and thus it’s energy that is in them and not any electrostatic potential, memory, magnetic field etc in them those have been proposed earlier and even then have not given any plausible explanation to Homeopathy. More so it must be clear from now onwards it is Energy in Homeopathic medicines than anything else.
Maybe that is why beer makes me feel good. Nothing like getting your Dark Energy extracted.
As I learned the day before this post went up, homeopathy is not quantum in its mechanism, but magnetism.
Or maybe it is dark quantum magnetism. Three for the price of one. Yeah, that’s the ticket.

     1.  Get to work guys and gals. Time’s a wasting.
     2.  Law here is like a legal law, like “any written or positive rule or collection of rules prescribed under the authority.” Essentially made up. Not like a law in physics, proven by experiment.

Homeopathy and COVID 45: The Toothless Old Man Laughs
As Billy Preston noted, “Nothin’ from nothin’ leaves nothin'”. And so it is with Homeopathy and COVID 45. Catholicon.
Mark Crislipon August 25, 2022
Tweet

O Homeo, Homeo, wherefore art thou Homeo?Deny thy fantasy and refuse thy name.Or if thou wilt not, be but sworn my loveAnd I’ll no longer be a Realist.‘Tis but thy fantasy that is my enemy:Thou art thyself, though not a Hanneman.What’s Hanneman? It is nor hand nor footNor arm nor face nor any other partBelonging to reality. O be some other name.What’s in a name? That which we call a dilutionBy any other name would smell not at all;So Homeo would, were he not Homeo call’d,Retain that dear delusion which he owesWithout that title. Homeo, doff thy fantasy,And for that name, which is no part of thee,Join reality.
Regular readers know I like to refer to our “Distinguished” Competition (we so need standard irony punctuation) using the rubric SCAM: Supplements, Complementary, and Alternative Medicine. It’s perhaps too cute by half (and not my invention) but I have never been happy with the nouns used to describe SCAMs. What is the opposite of science-based medicine? Fantasy-based? Fiction-based? BS- based? The nonsensical ravings of a lunatic mind-based? How would you even pronounce NRLM? See? We got issues here. But NRLM is perhaps the most fitting.
Of all the NRLM-based cults, homeopathy may be the most unhinged from reality. Well, there is Tong ren. Perhaps it is a fool’s errand to try to rank NRLMs that are based on less reality than Superman, Green Lantern, and Triplicate Girl. Although the last are/is the patron saints/saint of all bureaucracies in the multiverse.
COVID has been a boon to all NRLM-based therapies, allowing them to churn out what Harriet Hall has dubbed Tooth Fairy Science:
…refers to doing research on a phenomenon before establishing that the phenomenon exists. Tooth Fairy science is part of a larger domain that might be called Fairy Tale science: research that aims to confirm a far-fetched story believed by millions of scientifically innocent minds. Fairy Tale science uses research data to explain things that haven’t been proven to have actually happened. Fairy Tale scientists mistakenly think that if they have collected data that is consistent with their hypothesis, then they have collected data that confirms their hypothesis.
These studies get published in the Journal of Tooth Fairy Science or some equivalent and listed on the Pubmeds, sometimes resulting in remarkably credulous responses by legitimate medical organizations.
Pubmed has 80 hits for COVID and Homeopathy, compared to 28 for naturopathy, 51 for chiropractic, and a whopping 213 for acupuncture. The last not a surprise since COVID 45 started in China and there are far too many papers to review in one blog entry without an ondansetron prescription.
It is worth a high-level view of this peculiar medical literature to see what the homeopaths are up to. Many of these articles are from India, where homeopathy is popular and India may have surpassed the US in COVID 45 deaths. Association is not causation. But. Remembering that homeopathy is literally nothing, I am not so certain that applying homeopathy to COVID in India warrants the warning from one abstract, not in large friendly letters, that suggested, “there is no need to be panic”.
There are three broad uses of homeopathy for COVID 45. Actually, zero. Humor me here. But amongst homeopathic weaponry are for such diverse elements as prevention, vaccination, treatment, and long COVID.
One way to approach homeopathy is using Bayes Theorem, which makes my head hurt. As I have mentioned before, I took, and dropped, statistics 4 times in college. Once a year for 4 years. So I am not the best for explaining Bayes, but in medical practice, the basic application is that the less likely the disease, the more likely a positive test result is a false positive. Similarly, the less plausible the intervention, the more likely positive results are spurious.
Since the prior plausibility that homeopathic therapies will do anything is exactly zero, we understand that any positive homeopathic study is a false positive. Why waste time on the studies? Because it can be fun to point at homeopathy and laugh. And no matter how implausible an NRLM study, someone in reality-based medicine, as we will see, will be snookered into touting it. Same as it ever was.
Let’s look at some of the 80 hits (and I seriously considered a Rickroll for the last link) and see what the homeopaths are up to and, perhaps, have a chuckle along the away. So no drinking milk.
COVID-19 Pneumonia: A Potential Role of Homeopathy. Well, no potential role if you are a fan of reality, but the author feels that homeopathic remedies
may potentially improve the pneumonia in COVID-19 non-responder patients, especially in the early stages of the disease.
and suggests, as do many NRLM papers, that someone waste time and money to do a real clinical trial to demonstrate efficacy. I will note that most patients with COVID do fine and that in the early stages of disease, you do not know if they are going to be a non-responder. So how would one judge when to give said nostrum? The author suggests three nostrums, Arsenicum album, Stannum, and Ribes nigrum because he has found them helpful. When would one use Arsenicum? When
“Air passages constricted. Asthma worse at night. Burning in chest. Suffocative catarrh. Cough worse after midnight; worse if lying on the back. Expectoration. Wheezing respiration.”
I am always amazed are the specificity of homeopathic symptoms. What if the cough is worse at 11:59 p.m.? And if you are standing at a time zone line and jump across at the strike of midnight. Would that change the treatment?
That symptom complex is not like any COVID 45 I have taken care of. So often NLRM providers complain the real doctors only treat symptoms, not the underlying cause of dis-ease. But homeopathy is all about the symptoms, ignoring the underlying pathophysiology completely. COVID is too new for any homeopathic provings specific to that illness. So they can ignore COVID and just go after symptoms.
I suspect that it is the alleged immune effects that will be credited for the effects of most NLRM interventions and as a target for the those interventions. Support the immune system like it needs a sling.
Homeopathic Remedies in COVID-19: Prognostic Factor Research. It was open label, multi-centric, outpatient, observational study aka designed to be completely useless for any conclusions. Twenty-seven different homeopathic nostrums were given and, in a disease where most people get better, most people got better. They credited the homeopathy:
homeopathic medicines were associated with improvement in symptoms of COVID-19 cases.
and suggested further studies.Such garbage.
Homeopathy combat against coronavirus disease (Covid-19) got retracted. Why?
… the lack of empirical data and the lack of testing of the proposed model as a severe limitation that invalidates the conclusions drawn in the article. The conclusion that epidemiological studies are needed to evaluate homeopathic treatment are not justified based on the model developed by the authors. The simplified approach provided by the authors is not appropriate to model the complex biological associations and not based on evidence-based health research principles.
Doesn’t that apply to every homeopathy paper ever published? And almost every NRLM studies? I think so.
I did not realize that there was homeopathic psychiatry. Insert your own joke here. Well, there is in India where it is proposed that to cope with COVID isolation a
… web-portal will capture all the patients’ symptoms. Then homeopathy E-Prescriptions would be generated by the psychiatrists. This transmission of E-Prescription would be done using the proposed secret session key using Advanced Encryption Standards. Ignatia, Natrum Sulphuricum, Aconite, Arsenicum Album, Belladonna, etc are the important homeopathy medicines as prescribed by the homeopathy psychiatrists in COVID-19. Mathematical calculations were done on this proposed technique with positive efficacy. Hence, homeopathy telemedicine is the pivotal way to cure psychiatric patients remotely in this Post-COVID-19 “New Normal” context.
If mathematical calculations show positive efficacy, who am I to argue? Why bother with e-prescriptions when the homeopathic effect can be sent over the phone? Let’s get digital here people.
Homeopathy is popular in India where millions have received homeopathy as a COVID preventative. I will not suggest there is any association between homeopathy and the tremendous numbers of infection and deaths from COVID in India. Nope. Not me.
AYUSH for COVID-19: Science or Superstition? AYUSH is an acronym for Ayurveda, Yoga and Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha, Sowa Riga and Homeopathy. I think with our Bayesean knowledge alone we can safely assign the answer the question in the title to the latter rather than the former option.
The big problem for reality-based thinkers is that every study uses several dozen interventions. Some ‘personalize’ for the individual, others ‘personalize for the epidemic:
Successful homeopathic prescriptions are based on careful individualization of symptoms, either for an individual patient or collectively in the case of epidemic outbreaks.
It is nice to be able to have it both ways. It is the odd thing about many NLRM based therapies when viewed from reality. It is the system that is the catholicon, not the specific intervention within the system. It is homeopathy that is effective, not the specific remedy.
They are also trying nosodes for COVID. We have vaccines that are safe and effective and instead they are testing the homeopathic, well, not equivalent. I always wonder how NLRM studies make it through ethics committees and I would love to read the informed consent. But then I have always been a fan of science fiction and comics.
And there is homeopathic immunotherapy for COVID: dilute the convalescent serum from COVID patients and inject it in the ill. Really. Convalescent serum was tried early in the COVID epidemic and was not effective. Diluting the serum is unlikely to improve its efficacy.
Of course, there are no quality studies to show benefits from homeopathy. And, despite the plea that (bold added)
For homeopathy, shunned during its 200 years of existence by conventional medicine, this outbreak is a key opportunity to show potentially the contribution it can make in treating COVID-19 patients. This should be done through performance of impeccably controlled, prospective, randomized clinical trials, with publication of their findings in well-ranked conventional medicine journals. If the homeopathy community fails to take advantage of this rare opportunity, it might wait another century for the next major pandemic.
I doubt they will have to wait another century for a pandemic to prove their catholicon is worthless. New word. I learned a new word. I will use it freely moving forward. Catholicon. Sweet. I don’t expect any homeopathy studies that will meet those criteria. And even homeopaths recognize they are doing a bad job with clinical studies.
Confirmation bias leading to lowering of symptom threshold, keynote prescribing, and deficiency in checking of all symptoms in each case were identified as the most important sources of bias.
Remember when I mentioned someone would be bamboozled by a homeopathy study? I give you PulmonaryAdvisor.com, who
…offers healthcare professionals a comprehensive knowledge base of practical information and resources focused on pulmonary and critical care medicine to assist in making the right decisions for their patients.
Just no critical thinking applied to NRLM. Pulmonary Advisor asks the question, “Can Homeopathic Treatment Speed Recovery in Patients With COVID-19?” Yes! And demonstrates yet again that mainstream medicine can’t appropriately evaluate NLRM studies due to a lack of understanding of NLRM medicine.
It was a study out of India where patients were randomized to receive standard therapy plus placebo vs. standard therapy plus individualized homeopathy (bold added):
Forty homeopathic medicines were prescribed for the patients. Of these, Arsenicum album was prescribed to 9.93% patients (n = 15), Bryonia alba and Phosphorus were to 7.94% (n = 12) patients each; Rhus toxicodendron to 6.62% (n = 10); Natrum muriaticum (n = 9, 5.96%); Hepar sulphuricum & Pulsatilla nigricans (n = 7, 4.63% each); Lycopodium clavatum & Nux vomica (n = 6, 3.97% each); Belladonna, Carbo vegetabilis, Chininum arsenicum, Gelsemium (n = 5, 3.31% each). At first prescription 44.37% (n = 67) of patients received 30C potency, 47.68% (n = 72) received 200C potency and the remaining 7.94% (n = 12) received higher potency. Of all, 63% (n = 96) patients received one homeopathic medicine only, while 36.42% (n = 55) patients required two or more homeopathic medicines during the study period.
Remember at 30 C
this would require giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the original material to any patient.
So any reality-based human would realize that this study compared two placebos and found one placebo was better at improving mostly subjective symptoms. And it was a single-blind study, the treating naturopath knew who was getting what. As we have learned, and relearned, when NRLM practitioners are not blinded to treatment groups, the results are unreliable. Actually, the results are reliable in that there will be a false-positive salubrious effect credited to the NRLM.
Two major flaws in the study: the underlying treatment is unhinged from reality. The other was inadequate blinding.
Pulmonary Advisor recognizes neither if these flaws, gullibly quoting the paper:
A major limitation of the current study is the fact that because of the large number of COVID-19 patients at the hospital, follow-up laboratory tests could not always be performed because of a resource crunch. Further, restricted access to patients because of the high transmissibility of COVID-19 limits the number of homeopathic prescriptions, since various patient attributes and disease characteristics need to be known when selecting these medications.
Yet another medical reviewer falling off the turnip truck. No critical thinking whatsoever. Hey, Harriet. Can you write a book similar to There’s No Such Thing as the Tooth Fairy! for healthcare providers? Sorely needed.
The treatment of COVID with homeopathy did result in the funniest line in the medical literature, also the saddest. From Adjunctive homeopathic treatment of hospitalized COVID-19 patients (COVIHOM): A retrospective case series I give you
At the start of treatment, each patient received Influenzinum, either in CH200 potency or in case of very bad condition, in CH10,000 potency on day one.
Remember, at 13 C
If pure water were used as the diluent, no molecules of the original solution remain in the water.
At 30 C
this would require giving two billion doses per second to six billion people for 4 billion years to deliver a single molecule of the original material to any patient.
200C?
the total mass of pills that would have to be consumed to encounter a single molecule of the original substance would be billions of times greater than the mass of the Earth.
The multiverse isn’t likely not big enough to find one molecule on 10,000C. As many have said, it should be homeopathic delusions, not dilutions.
Still, there are some reality-based assessments. In Role of Complementary and Alternative Medicine in Prevention and Treatment of COVID-19: An Overhyped Hope, they sum it up as well as I could.
However, no clinical evidence of these alternative medicines to treat COVID-19, lack of high-quality data, little or no data to support their claims, lack of statistically significant number of participants, long-term efficacy, proper follow-up,no comparative control groups and no adherence to strict quality norms while conducting clinical trials are some of the concerns expressed by experts.Therefore, unless research is not conducted as per standard protocols, CAM will be seen with a lot of skepticism in medical science.
Except at Pulmonary Advisor.
That’s it, a brief tour of some the NLRM homeopathic studies.
After that I need a drink. Thank the gods bartenders do not subscribe to homeopathic principles.
Catholicon.

Department of Self Aggrandizement
See my talk at SkepticCamp 2022. Alt Med in the Age of COVID: What is the Evidence.

Homeopathic Arnica in Plastic Surgery
Homeopathic Arnica is clearly pseudoscience and does not work for wound healing, so why are so many cosmetic surgeons recommending it?
Steven Novella on July 18, 2018
Link

A follower of SBM e-mailed me to say that they had a recent experience with a plastic surgeon who prescribed homeopathic Arnica to promote wound healing following surgery. They were surprised not only by this one example, but on further investigation that this is actually common practice.
We are always alert to the infiltration of rank pseudoscience into the medical profession, and if true, this would be a prime example. I did some exploration myself, and found that this is unfortunately true. A simple Google search for “plastic surgery, Arnica” provided numerous examples of plastic surgery practices recommending Arnica, like this one:
You can find Arnica in a number of over-the-counter products, including creams, tablets and gels. At the Morgenstern Center, we offer two forms of Arnica available for purchase at our office:
Arnica 12C Pellets: start taking 2 days prior to surgery and continue for approximately 2 weeks post operatively. Take as directed (5 pellets 3 times/day).Arnica Cream: start post operatively and apply to the area of bruising as directed by our surgeons. This is not a substitute for your antibiotic ointment which is to be applied to your surgical incisions. The cream is not to be placed on open incisions at any time.We are committed to helping you look and feel your absolute best. Using advanced techniques and technologies, and recommending post-operative aftercare measures are just a couple of the ways Dr. Morgenstern brings you state-of-the-art care and great results.
For a quick review of what homeopathy is – it is perhaps the best example of 100% pure pseudoscientific nonsense in medicine. It is largely based on two principles, that substances which can cause symptoms can actually treat those same symptoms in tiny doses, and that the “essence” of these potions is realized by extreme dilutions and “succussions” (vigorous shaking). The ingredients themselves are often fanciful, sometimes nonexistent, and have more in common with witchcraft than medicine. This doesn’t really matter, however, because starting ingredients are typically diluted out of existence anyway.
The “12C” preparation referred to above, for example, mean a dilution of 1:100 (that is the C) 12 times. So that is a 1:1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 dilution (1 x 10^24). If you recall Avagadro’s number is the number of molecules or other units in one mole (for reference, one mole of water weighs 18 grams) of a substance, and is 6.022140857 × 10^23. So if you start with one mole of Arnica, you will end up with less than one molecule on average after a 12C dilution. (This is why the Merseyside skeptics called their anti-homeopathy campaign the 10:23 campaign.) So Dr. Morgenstern is recommending sugar pills (iconic placebos) and calls this “state-of-the-art.”
I could not find any data to show what percentage of plastic surgeons prescribe magic potions to their patients, but it is clearly common given the number of easily found examples.
The extreme implausibility of a homeopathic dilution of Arnica is enough to conclude that it does not work. But that has not stopped some from trying to answer the question with clinical research. This is almost certainly a waste of resources as messy clinical research is unlikely to be sufficient to overturn the laws of physics. It would take the most rigorous research and clear results to even get close – which, of course, we do not have. Typically what we find when researching clinical questions based on highly implausible (breaking the laws of physics level) treatments is lots of low quality research, and maybe some higher quality studies. There is always a clear relationship in that the more rigorous the study the smaller the effect, and the best studies tend to be negative. This is a pattern consistent with no effect, which is also consistent with the laws of physics.
This pattern of no real effect is what we find with all of homeopathy, and homeopathic Arnica for wound healing is no exception. The earliest systematic review I could find was from 1998 (lead author was Edzard Ernst, which is no surprise as he is known for high quality reviews of alternative practices), which found:
Eight trials fulfilled all inclusion criteria. Most related to conditions associated with tissue trauma. Most of these studies were burdened with severe methodological flaws. On balance, they do not suggest that homeopathic arnica is more efficacious than placebo.
What about in the last 20 years? There has not been much. The only study that would have met the inclusion criteria for the above review was this one from 2003, which found:
There were no group differences on the primary outcome measures of pain (P=0.79) and bruising (P=0.45) at day four. Swelling and use of analgesic medication also did not differ between arnica and placebo groups. Adverse events were reported by 2 patients in the arnica 6C group, 3 in the placebo group and 4 in the arnica 30C group. The results of this trial do not suggest that homeopathic arnica has an advantage over placebo in reducing postoperative pain, bruising and swelling in patients undergoing elective hand surgery.
Other than this there are a few preliminary or basic science studies published in homeopathy or alternative medicine journals. So yet again, there is some preliminary and essentially useless studies, and a few reasonable quality clinical trials which are essentially negative. Not only is this level of evidence (regardless of plausibility, but all the more damning given the extreme implausibility) not sufficient to form a basis for practice, it is sufficient to condemn the practice as ineffective.
Why, then, is the practice apparently common among plastic surgeons? That is an interesting question requiring further exploration, and I would be happy to hear from some of my colleagues in plastic surgery, but here are some possibilities. First, it seems that the practice is most common in (and perhaps limited to) cosmetic surgery. Cosmetic surgery is elective surgery purely for cosmetic purposes. Reconstructive surgery is cosmetic and functional surgery following some injury, disease, or to correct a developmental anomaly. These are different subspecialties within plastic surgery.
Cosmetic surgery has incorporated many “spa” practices to enhance their services and the experience of their clients. The “spa” services culture, which has existed for hundreds of years, is based largely on pseudoscience or hand-waving claims. The spa is where you can now find salt rooms, reflexology, have your chakras aligned, and partake in steam baths of dubious efficacy.
So my hypothesis is that the spa culture has infected the profession of cosmetic surgery, and the frequent use of homeopathic Arnica for wound healing has come along for the ride. But regardless of why it is used, homeopathic Arnica is demonstrable nonsense and clearly useless, and has no legitimate place in any medical practice. And if you are a science-based cosmetic surgeon offended by this post – direct your ire at your pseudoscience-using colleagues.

Homeopathic Syrup for the Treatment of Pediatric Colds: Randomized Controlled Nonsense is Still Nonsense
Clay Jones on November 18, 2016
Link

According to the authors of the latest study claiming to demonstrate effectiveness of homeopathic remedies, colds are common in the pediatric population. They further explain that colds and cough symptoms are a frequent impetus for parents to seek pediatric medical care. Finally, they add that evidence in support of decongestants, antihistamines and cough suppressants for the treatment of pediatric cold symptoms is lacking and that there are significant potential risks with their use in young children.
All of this is true and information I give to medical learners and patient caregivers all the time. I only wish they had quit while they were ahead. Sadly, the authors of “A randomized controlled trial of a homeopathic syrup in the treatment of cold symptoms in young children” continued:
One option for treating cold symptoms in young children is with homeopathy. Because the concentrations of active ingredients in homeopathic medications are extremely dilute, they are generally considered to be safe. However, there is a widely held belief that any efficacy related to use of homeopathic remedies is related to a placebo effect.

The study authors apparently stared into the face of homeopathy’s utter lack of scientific plausibility, and the fact that homeopathy is nothing but trumped up placebo, and laughed into the void. This actually isn’t surprising considering that the lead author, Jennifer Jacobs, is a long-time proponent and former employee of Standard Homeopathic Company, also known as Hyland’s, the makers of bogus teething remedies currently being investigated by the FDA. Those paying close attention to the unethical involvement of pediatric patients in homeopathy studies over the years may recognize Jacobs.
The study particulars
The study took place at the University of Washington Medical Center-Roosevelt Pediatric Care Center, a seemingly legitimate facility where pediatric residents learn primary care and parents probably don’t expect to be deceived by medical professionals. Children aged 2 to 5 years diagnosed with an upper respiratory infection and having less than a week of symptoms were targeted, and those with medical complications such as asthma or who were being prescribed a medication were excluded. Also excluded were children exposed to a homeopathic remedy within the 48 hours prior to recruitment, because multi-nothing interactions can be a real confounder.
Upon recruitment, parents of study subjects rated the severity of their child’s cold over the prior 24 hours based on 4 core cold complaints: runny nose, congestion, cough, and sneezing. Each complaint could be ranked from 0 to 3 in severity, with a maximum overall score of 12 points. This is an entirely arbitrary scoring system that is 100% subjective.
Study subjects were assigned an ID number and their parent given a bottle of either the homeopathic syrup or a placebo syrup, both essentially being simple licorice extract in water. This was done randomly with the parent, child, and research team unaware of what each bottle contained. The specific homeopathic syrup used in the study, which “contains” allium cepa 6X, hepar sulf calc 12X, natrum muriaticum 6X, phosphorous 12X, pulsatilla 6X, sulphur 12X, and hydrastasis 6X, was Hyland’s 4 Kids Cold ‘n Cough. Hyland’s, in the form of Standard Homeopathic Company, also funded the study.
Advanced data mining
Parents were instructed to give their child a dose of whatever was in their bottle every 4 to 6 hours as needed for cold symptoms over a three day period. If a dose was given, parents were asked to document changes in the 4 core symptoms using a 7-point Likert scale (from “much worse” to “much improved”). They were also charged with tracking non-specific symptoms such as lethargy, fussiness, and appetite as well as any observed side effects. This is homeopathy after all and they do like their provings.
Twice each day over the three day study period, parents completed a symptom diary which rated overall severity of the four core symptoms on the aforementioned 4 point scale. Again, these scores were added together to make a composite score with 12 being the maximum. Parents noted missed days of school and/or work and recorded any other medications or treatments given. Once each day, parents also were asked to use a 5-item functional health scale to assess their children on various activities such as being read to, eating, and sleeping. Finally, they also rated their child’s overall health once daily using a 1-10 scale with 1 being “very well” and 10 being “very sick.”
5 to 10 days after initiation, the caregiver was contacted and asked to assess the subjects’ current cold symptom severity, overall health, and functional status.
Data analysis
The primary outcome being assessed in this study was the effect of the homeopathic syrup on the 4 core colds symptoms an hour after being administered. All the other secondary outcomes described above were just bet hedging. If a parent assessed their child as even just slightly improved an hour after a dose, it was counted in the win column during statistical analysis.
The authors chose to perform a “preliminary, interim analysis” after the first 63 children had been enrolled in order to “assess for possible efficacy of the homeopathic syrup, with the option of discontinuing the study if there was no indication of efficacy.” They evidently found what they were looking for. Call me a cynic, but that part seemed fishy to me.
They recruited 261 subjects, collecting 154 dosage logs amounting to 957 doses, 497 being of the homeopathic syrup. Parents also returned 162 symptom diaries. This fell far below their predetermined goal of 1,425 total doses of study medication.
The results speak for themselves…I think?
In regards to the primary outcome being studied, the effect of the homeopathic syrup on 4 core cold symptoms (runny nose, sneezing, cough, congestion) an hour after dosing, this study was a complete and utter failure. There were no differences in any of the 4 core symptoms compared to placebo. There were also no differences in the non-specific secondary outcomes an hour after each dose. The homeopathic syrup was found to be indistinguishable from placebo. End of story.
Wait, there’s more. There is always more. Why is there always more? Let the torturing of data and convoluted post-hoc reasoning begin!
Next up for analysis were the twice daily symptom diaries. They found that improvement from baseline was significantly better in the homeopathic syrup group…for runny nose, cough, and sneezing (not congestion???)…and only at the first and second assessments. The composite cold scores were statistically better in the homeopathic group as well, also only on day one. On day 2, 3 and at the follow-up 5-10 days later, there were no differences in cold symptoms whatsoever.
Children randomized to the homeopathic syrup arm also received more ibuprofen and chest rubs (good old fashioned TLC) on day one. When taken into account, the supposed benefit of homeopathy was no longer seen in cough scores. Regarding the other secondary functional outcomes, there were no differences between the two groups at any point in the study. Furthermore, children in the homeopathic syrup group had worse cough at the 5-10 day follow-up and there were statistically more side effects in this group as well, although none were considered to be serious.
The authors attempt to salvage this shipwreck of a study
Jacobs and Taylor describe the results of this study as “provocative.” I disagree. After admitting their complete failure to find any benefit in the primary outcome being measured, or in any functional outcome, they focus on the finding that children randomized to the homeopathic syrup had statistically significant improvement in 2 of 4 of the arbitrarily chosen core symptoms, but only on the first day of treatment. This is extremely weak sauce.
The authors attempt to shrug off alternative explanations for their non-findings:
Because homeopathy is not consistent with the current understanding of chemistry and physics, it is crucial to consider alternative explanations for our findings.
As one astute follower of mine on Twitter (FuturePedsNP) exclaimed:
@skepticpedi I love that "current". Like any day now, results are going to come out of CERN that show how sugar pills can treat pneumonia.
— FuturePedsNP (@cantab_biker) November 14, 2016
They list some potential biases in the study which may have affected the results, such as they were. 38% of the symptom diaries were not returned, for example. The authors claim, however, that a higher response rate would have likely increased the chance of positive findings rather than revealing their thin gruel to be even more meager. They blame a lack of additional funding (NCCIH hasn’t funded homeopathy since 2008) and a lower than predicted number of kids with colds, the latter being almost as ludicrous as homeopathy itself.
They then go on to discount the possibility that poor blinding, inadequate randomization, or statistical chicanery could have biased their results, which I agree with. They aren’t needed and just serve as a distraction. They are essentially just straw man arguments. Random noise is a good enough explanation for me.
The study authors conclude with a few howlers:
The worsening of cough in the homeopathic group at the 5-10 day follow-up is difficult to explain but might be due to a rebound effect after stopping the medication.
No, just more random noise.
And:
Clinicians should consider recommending it for symptomatic relief, since there are no conventional medications that have been shown safe and effective in treating URIs in children.
Since nothing works, try syrup of nothing? I prefer a tincture of time and a soupçon of reassurance myself.
Finally:
There is presently no definitive explanation for the possible biological activity of such highly diluted homeopathic preparations. Current [there is that word again] speculation about a mechanism of action centers on the field of nanomedicine with the possibility of immune system modulation.
Why seek a definitive explanation for something that doesn’t exist?
Conclusion: Yet another unethical homeopathy study
This study is yet another in a long unethical line of studies boasting cargo cult methodologies designed to answer a question that nobody has asked since 1865. We know that homeopathy shouldn’t work, and it truly toes the line of can’t work. But let’s humor this study a bit and ask ourselves if the results might be enough cause doubt in our joyless skeptic hearts.
The study authors have presented a treatment that fails to reduce cold symptoms in any way a full hour after taking it, while somehow still causing an overall improvement in those same cold symptoms but only for one day. This improvement comes in the form of having slightly less runny nose and sneezing as determined by an outside observer, who I am assuming is not measuring nasal runoff in milliliters per hour. After one day of improved arbitrarily determined symptoms, the treatment stops reducing said symptoms and then has no effect on the overall severity or duration of the cold. Furthermore, despite reducing symptoms on the first day, it doesn’t lead to any functional improvement at any point.
Kids with the “statistically significant” improvement in composite cold symptom scores on day one didn’t have better appetites, more energy, or less fussiness, and they weren’t more likely to go back to school. And their cough was worse a week later! But it’s all just noise. And nanomedicine. Something something nanomedicine.
Related reading
    • A prior post of mine discussing and even dumber study of homeopathy for pediatric cold symptoms
    • Another ridiculous “ real life observational study.”

New Study on Homeopathic Cough Syrup for Children Reveals a Lack of Effectiveness and Ethics
Clay Jones on August 14, 2015
Link


On the pages of SBM we frequently discuss homeopathy, and rightfully so considering its position as one of the most pervasive yet dumbest forms of alternative medicine. Just yesterday our own Scott Gavura, who is neither pervasive nor dumb, wrote an excellent review of some recent improvements in the regulation of these ridiculous remedies in Canada, and I encourage readers to check that out. Sadly, despite numerous high profile setbacks for the practice, including a thorough trouncing by the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council in March, proponents of what is essentially the belief in sympathetic magic continue to clutter the pubmeds and interwebs with worthless studies.
You may think that you’ve heard it all when it comes to homeopathy by this point if you are a regular reader (homeopathic electricity???), and perhaps you have. Homeopathic research is certainly no stranger to exposing children to ineffective treatments, and proponents have often demonstrated extremely questionable ethical practices. So if you’ve kept up with the literature, this won’t surprise you one bit. Consider this post aimed more at those less familiar with just how bad it is out there, and how children are often victims of a world view that involves the religious-like belief in quackery.
The study in question, and questions about the study
The study in question, “Does additional antimicrobial treatment have a better effect on URTI cough resolution than homeopathic symptomatic therapy alone? A real-life preliminary observational study in a pediatric population“, was published in the August 2015 open-access online journal Multidisciplinary Respiratory Medicine. You too can publish a paper in this journal for the low, low price of just under $2,000 (for “article-processing“). After reading this paper, I’m not confident in their editorial process or claims of being peer reviewed.
The title is a monstrosity that pretty much stands on its own as evidence for why the ensuing paper is garbage. In fact, it might be the most ridiculous study I’ve encountered in pediatric medicine. Never mind. It would actually be funny, however, if not for the glaring ethical violation perpetrated on helpless children.
The lead researcher, who is featured here on Boiron Italy’s website, was likely inspired by his 2013 study showing that a homeopathic cough syrup (produced by Boiron) had minimal clinical impact in adult patients diagnosed with acute bronchitis when he decided to test the same remedy in children. Wait, that’s not exactly right. He actually decided to throw ethics, equipoise, and the standard of care out of the window and expose children diagnosed with uncomplicated viral upper respiratory tract infections (colds) to a full course of antibiotics as well as the same homeopathic remedy.
The reasoning for including antibiotics instead of a placebo control in this trial? According to the authors, cough is a common symptom in children with upper respiratory tract infections and, unfortunately, antibiotics are often prescribed for viral etiologies. They took it upon themselves to see, just in case decades of evidence and basic science were wrong, if antibiotics might actually be effective in treating cough in children with colds. Like the king of the Britons, I am continually amazed by this new learning.
Does it get worse?
It gets worse:
The aim of this preliminary study was to evaluate if the addition of antibiotics to a symptomatic treatment (homeopathic syrup) improves cough resolution in pediatric patients with acute cough due to uncomplicated URTI.
Referring to a homeopathic syrup as a symptomatic treatment begs one very concentrated question: that it actually reduces symptoms. And isn’t the whole point of homeopathy to treat the “whole person” rather than just a symptom? The totality of evidence, not to mention those pesky fundamental laws of physics and chemistry, cannot be ignored because of one questionable study in adults with bronchitis. Why is it included at all? Why did they choose to compare antibiotics plus homeopathy to homeopathy alone instead of antibiotics to a placebo if their goal was to investigate the role of antibiotics in reducing the severity and duration of cough? Why did they choose a “real-life” approach instead of one that actually might address their claimed endpoints?
The answer is pretty clear in my opinion, although I must admit that I don’t have an inside track to their innermost thoughts. It could be that they are just incompetent and don’t understand trial design. No, I doubt that. I think that it is considerably more likely that this trial was designed with the intention of using it to claim that the homeopathic remedy works and that the antibiotics were a not-so-clever distraction. The logic that they use to determine efficacy of the homeopathic remedy is also not very impressive. Have I mentioned yet that the authors, who claimed no conflict of interest, acknowledged Boiron for their “non-binding financial contribution?”
What did they actually do?
The study, which took place in Italy, was “conducted according to the Helsinki declaration” and approved by an institutional review board. More on this later. Eighty-five children between the ages of 4 and 15 years with cough caused by non-complicated colds were split into two groups. One received a homeopathic syrup produced by our friends at Boiron four times daily for ten days. The other received the same remedy for ten days plus a concurrent seven days of an oral antibiotic regimen.
For 28 days following initiation of their “treatment,” subjects/parents filled out a daily cough diary which assigned their symptoms a score from 0 (no cough) to 5 (constant distressing cough). Adverse events were also discussed and cataloged at the end of the 4 week study period. When all was said and done, they found that both groups did exactly the same in regards to symptom resolution. Cough generally started getting better after a few days and in most patients was completely resolved by the end of the study. A small percentage of patients in both groups continued to have mild cough.
In regards to safety, there were no significant adverse events in either group. As would be expected, however, there were more reports of mild side effects in the group receiving an antibiotic. These side effects consisted of the already well-established most common side effects associated with antibiotics, namely diarrhea, vomiting, and rash.
The predictable conclusion
So how did the authors come to the conclusion that homeopathy worked for cough in these children, even though that supposedly wasn’t what they were investigating? Remember, the whole point of their study was to see if antibiotics reduced cough severity and duration during uncomplicated colds wink-wink-nudge-nudge. Here you go:
Our data suggest an antitussive efficacy of this homeopathic syrup in children since the time-courses of the VCD severity score in the syrup treated children of this study resulted overlapping to that obtained in syrup treated adults in a randomized, double-blind placebo-controlled trail.
In case you didn’t catch that, they concluded that the homeopathic cough syrup worked in the current study’s pediatric population because the subjects did as well as the adults in the “treatment” arm of their prior study. The prior study, like the overwhelming majority of homeopathy research, was entirely consistent with the much more plausible conclusion that the minimal clinical effect was a mixture of placebo effects and statistical noise. All the subjects in both studies simply followed the expected course of cough symptoms caused by colds when no treatment is provided.
According to actual science, cough caused by uncomplicated colds follows a typical course. Prospective cohort studies have shown that it takes ten days for about half of kids to stop coughing, and about 10% of cough persists at 25 days. In the current study, most subjects improved noticeably within a few days with the majority experiencing steady improvement and complete resolution of their cough by two weeks. And roughly 15% had persistent, although milder, complaints of cough at the end of the 28 day study period. So neither the antibiotics or the syrup had any positive effect.
Somehow this study was approved by an IRB despite the complete lack of equipoise. There is absolutely no question that antibiotics do not help children get better more quickly when they have an isolated viral infection. And antibiotics are not risk free, which is even acknowledged in the paper. In addition to the risk of inducing resistance in potentially pathogenic bacteria living on and within a patient, antibiotics can result in a variety of complications ranging from the mild (upset tummy) to the deadly (severe allergic reaction or skin sloughing off from head to toe). I’m not convinced that the authors or the IRB are actually familiar with the ethical principles delineated in the Declaration of Helsinki.
My conclusion: Sometimes you are better off doing nothing
There are no effective treatments for the cough caused by an uncomplicated common cold in children or adults. Not cough suppressants, not antibiotics, and especially not homeopathy. Unfortunately, the problem of prescribing antibiotics for patients with viral infections has long been recognized in conventional pediatrics, and we are working on it with public and professional educational campaigns such as Choosing Wisely. I’ve actually written about the overuse of antibiotics in children in the past.
The study discussed in the post adds nothing to what we already know about the pathophysiology and clinical course of the common cold in children. It has uncovered nothing that isn’t already well documented regarding the treatment of the symptoms of the common cold. What it does do is once again demonstrate that homeopathy is ineffective nonsense unworthy of additional resources being spent on further study. And it illustrates how belief, and possibly financial motivation, can result in poorly designed research and incoherent conclusions.

American Journal of Public Health article touts “potential public health benefits” of homeopathy
Jann Bellamy on March 17, 2016
Link


An article in the April, 2016 issue of the American Journal of Public Health caught my eye: “Homeopathy Use by US Adults: Results of a National Survey.” I was pleased to see that homeopathy use is actually quite low. The 2012 National Health Survey found that only 2.1% of U.S. adults used homeopathy in the last 12 months, although that was a 15% increase over 2007. Users were mostly young, white, well-educated women, the typical CAM consumer.
Even fewer saw a homeopathic practitioner (only 19% of all users), although those who did perceived a greater benefit from homeopathic remedies. This difference, speculate the authors, could be due to several factors, one of which is
a more individualized and effective homeopathic prescription by the provider.
What? Are the authors suggesting that the series of off-the-wall questions asked by homeopaths leads to a prescription of an “effective” homeopathic remedy?
They certainly seem to be. Who are these authors, anyway?
They are Michelle L. Dossett, MD, PhD, MPH, Roger B. Davis, ScD, Ted J. Kaptchuk, and Gloria Y. Yeh, MD, MPH. All are, or were, with the Division of General Medicine and Primary Care, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center. All are also connected with Harvard and work, in various ways, in “integrative medicine” research. The article was funded, in part, by the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, and in part by Harvard.
But that was not even the first “What?” moment I had in reading the article. (Actually, a phrase beginning with “What” came to mind.) We know we have passed out of objective reporting and into advocacy in the very first paragraph:
Recent reports suggest potential public health benefits [of using homeopathy] such as reductions in unnecessary antibiotic use, reductions in costs to treat certain respiratory diseases, improvements in peri-menopausal depression, improved health outcomes in chronically ill individuals, and control of a Leptospirosis epidemic in Cuba.
We’ll return to this paragraph later in the post and see if the evidence supports these assertions.
The curious incidents of ignoring evidence
If one were unaware of homeopathy’s scientific implausibility (impossibility, really) one would be wholly unenlightened by this article. There is not a whiff of an acknowledgement that basically the entire scientific community readily discounts all of its many proposed mechanism of action and its effectiveness has been thoroughly debunked.
Steve Novella provides this succinct summary:
Homeopathy cannot work. That is as reliable a scientific statement as any we can make. In other words, if homeopathy did work, we would have to rewrite major parts of basic science textbooks, including physics, chemistry, and biology. When tested clinically, despite their utter lack of plausibility, homeopathic potions are shown to lack efficacy. So not only should they not work, they in fact don’t work.
Yet, Dossett et al. benignly describe homeopathy as “a system of complementary and integrative medicine (CIM) with a resurgence of public interest in recent decades.” For this proposition, they cite British homeopath Peter Fisher and an article by him titled, “What is homeopathy? An introduction.” I don’t have access to this article, but I do know Fisher’s explanation of how homeopathy “works.” Or, as Steve Novella described it in his decimation of another attempt by Fisher to explain homeopathy:
Fisher tries desperately to rescue the 200 year old pre-scientific notions of homeopathy, but only reveals the intellectual bankruptcy of that profession.
Also cited for this proposition is an article by Wayne Jonas and Ted Kaptchuk, titled “A critical overview of homeopathy,” in the Annals of Internal Medicine (which Mark Crislip discussed recently). They suggested, 13 years ago, that
Homeopathy deserves an open-minded opportunity to demonstrate its value by using evidence-based principles.
Fortunately, this has been done, and why the authors didn’t bother to mention it is indeed curious.
Most recently, The Australian Government National Health and Medical Research Council assessed the evidence of the effectiveness of homeopathy for treating health conditions, based on an overview of published systematic reviews by an independent contractor. Other information considered included an independent evaluation of information provided by homeopathy interest groups and the public, as well as clinical practice guidelines and government reports. The Council concluded:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.
Prior to that, another exhaustive review was undertaken by the U.K. House of Commons Science and Technology Committee (2010). It wasn’t cited either. The Committee concluded:
    • the principle of like-cures-like is theoretically weak. It fails to provide a credible physiological mode of action for homeopathic products. We note that this is the settled view of medical science.
    • the notion that ultra-dilutions can maintain an imprint of substances previously dissolved in them to be scientifically implausible.
    • the systematic reviews and meta-analyses conclusively demonstrate that homeopathic products perform no better than placebos.
This is not the first time Dossett, Yeh, Davis, and Kaptchuk have published a journal article with less than full disclosure regarding the overwhelming scientific consensus that homeopathy can’t and doesn’t work. In this effort they were joined by Iris Bell, MD, of the University of Arizona Center for Integrative Medicine, whose studies of homeopathy, funded by the NCCAM (now the NCCIH) to the tune of several hundred thousand dollars, have been duly lambasted by David Gorski. (Sample comments: “utterly scientifically bankrupt nature of the hypotheses and the methods of testing;” “although imagination is a good thing in science, there is a difference between imagination and just making stuff up, and Bell’s review article definitely falls into the latter category.”)
This article is “Patient-Provider Interactions Affect Symptoms in Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease, A Pilot Randomized, Double-Blind, Placebo-Controlled Trial.” Patients were given either an over-the-counter homeopathic product, Acidil, or a placebo. Patients also got either a standard visit with an “empathetic conventional primary care evaluation” or that plus “an expanded visit with questions modeled after a CIM [complementary and integrative medicine] consultation.”
Acidil, a Boiron product, as the authors explain, is not composed of “ultra-high dilutions” beyond Avogadro’s number, which, they point out, “is a source of controversy regarding the mechanism of action of homeopathic medicines.” Although diluted it is: at a 4C homeopathic dilution, one part of the “mother tincture” bobs around in 100,000,000 parts of inert solution.
Actually, while it is true that using dilutions beyond Avogadro’s number is one reason homeopathy has been rejected by science, that is not the only reason by any means. And there is no “controversy” regarding the mechanism of action at all, at least not among scientists.
As one might expect, Acidil was no better than placebo. They’ve got an explanation for that one too:
the study was not adequately powered to detect an effect. . . As we used a combination product and did not individualize based on subjects’ symptoms according to standard homeopathic methodology, our study should not be construed as a test of homeopathy per se.
As if any of these factors makes the least bit of difference.
What the study did determine is that patients who got the extra time with the CIM practitioner (who, despite their denial of using “standard homeopathic methodology,” used questions that seem lifted right out of the standard homeopathic methodology playbook), did better, although they couldn’t tell exactly which factor involved in this extra time together made a difference. They speculate there may be “some powerful salubrious effect” to CIM consultations, regardless of the intervention used, although why this “powerful” effect is exclusive to CIM practitioners, they don’t say. As University of Florida cardiologist David Winchester, MD has pointed out, an appropriate control in studies where the CAM practitioner is given extra time with the patient is a conventional practitioner with the same opportunity.
The “potential public health benefits” of homeopathy
As promised, let’s return to the “potential public health benefits” of homeopathy Dossett et al. “suggest” and the evidence cited for that “potential.” What we find is a massive exercise in cherry picking.
    • Reductions in unnecessary antibiotic use – This was an Boiron-funded survey based on patient recall of symptom resolution. Nowhere do the authors suggest that prescribed antibiotics were “unnecessary.” To the extent the AJPH article is implying that homeopathy be used as a placebo in lieu of antibiotics for infections, such use would be unethical.
    • Reductions in costs to treat certain respiratory diseases – No access to this article, which appeared in the journal Homeopathy. In any event, reductions in cost do not mean that the treatment was effective. (Article is incorrectly titled as a “cost-benefit evaluation.”)
    • Improvements in peri-menopausal depression – There was no no-treatment group, so improvements could be attributable to other factors.
    • Improved health outcomes in chronically ill individuals – This was another survey of patient-recalled health outcomes in which many patients were receiving treatments other than homeopathy. The article specifically says that the purpose was not to test the effectiveness of homeopathic treatment.
    • Control of a Leptospirosis epidemic in Cuba – This is an attempt to explain away confounding factors and other methodological problems in an earlier article supposedly demonstrating that a homeopathic vaccine was effective in preventing leptospirosis, a potentially deadly bacterial infection. Orac and others have already demolished the earlier study.
Let’s take a closer look at that last one. The cited article is Golden I, Bracho G. “A reevaluation of the effectiveness of homeoprophylaxis against leptospirosis in Cuba in 2007 and 2008,” J Evid Based Complementary Altern Med, 2014.
Here is the conclusion:
The results support the previous [thoroughly debunked] conclusions that homoeoprophylaxis can be used to effectively immunize people against targeted infectious diseases such as leptospirosis.
As well, Golden and Bracho note that,
The Cuban experience with homeoprophylaxis against leptospirosis has been and remains a very positive one. It has given rise to further government-directed immunization against hepatitis A, swine flu, pneumococcal disease, and dengue fever using homoeoprophylaxis. [Emphasis mine.]
I have to assume that Dossett and her co-authors, as well as the AJPH reviewers, read the manuscript citing homeopathic vaccines for leptospirosis as a “potential public health benefit.” I also have to assume that at least one of the authors read the article itself, could readily see the problems with the Golden and Bracho’s conclusions, and note their implication that homeopathic “vaccines” were effective for several other diseases.
Shame on them. It is nothing short of despicable that medical doctors, some of whom hold Masters of Public Health degrees, and others with responsible positions at prestigious educational institutions and hospitals, would sign on to an article supporting the preposterous and wholly unethical position that people should be vaccinated for infectious diseases with homeopathic “vaccines.” I am absolutely appalled that anyone could actually read this article and agree with its conclusions.
As well, they should be condemned for failing to present an accurate and scientifically defensible representation of homeopathy and the conclusions from responsible organizations, after exhaustive reviews, that homeopathy is ineffective for any disease or condition. And yet they have the audacity to suggest that “further research on this modality and targeted studies of users.”
Indeed, as the House of Commons Committee put it, after having experienced a similar problem:
We regret that advocates of homeopathy, including in their submissions to our inquiry, choose to rely on, and promulgate, selective approaches to the treatment of the evidence base as this risks confusing or misleading the public, the media and policymakers.
The American Journal of Public Health is published by the American Public Health Association, the nation’s premier public health organization and an obvious advocate of immunization. According to AJPH, papers submitted to the journal are assigned 3 reviewers and only about 18% make it to publication. That system failed here. The AJPH should retract this article immediately.

Systematic Review of Homeopathy for Rheumatological Disease
Steven Novella on November 12, 2025
Link

It really makes our job more challenging when otherwise reasonable medical journals publish pseudoscientific nonsense. The European Journal of Rheumatology is considered a respected peer-reviewed journal in the field. I have to wonder if the editors were completely asleep at the switch with this one, or if they may be harboring one or more true-believers (homeopathy remains popular in some corners of Europe).
I was recently asked for my opinion about this shockingly horrible systematic review of homeopathic potions for rheumatological disease. These kinds of studies make the rounds in social media, are gullibly reported in the media, and simply confuse the public about what counts as good science. If there’s a silver lining, it is a good teaching moment, to flex our SBM skills and dissect the many problems with this study.
I suspect English may not be the primary language for the authors, but how did the editors let phrases like this get by, “Homeopathy has mainly been used to treat several diseases. On the other hand, it has been used in a few rheumatic disorders.” This is not the main problem with the study – I point it out only as a marker for what I consider to be sloppy, even neglectful, editing. The abstract continues:
“PubMed and Embase databases were examined for literature on homeopathy and RDs between 1966 and April 2023. There are 15 articles found with 811 patients. The diseases treated were osteoarthritis (n=3), followed by rheumatoid arthritis (n=3), ankylosing spondylitis (n=1), hyperuricemia (n=1), and tendinopathy (n=1)…Most studies (9/15) demonstrated improvements after homeopathy. Side effects were not seen or minimal and were comparable to placebo groups. In conclusion, this review shows homeopathy is a promising and safe therapy for RD treatment. However, the data needs to be reproduced in future more extensive studies, including other rheumatic conditions.”
We see the common caveat – more study is needed – which is often code for “the evidence is basically negative”. But worse, the abstract generates more questions than it answers. Let’s review some basic SBM principles for what makes a good systematic review. Was there any evidence of publication bias? We any of these studies pre-registered? Was there any relationship between the rigor of the study and the outcome? Was there any heterogeneity in the study results? Don’t expect any of these questions to be answered.
Further, the number of studies is ridiculously low, especially for a review covering over 50 years. They found 15 articles, covering five different diseases, with each disease having 1-3 studies. This is extremely thin. Plus, it is absurd to conflate these studies – they should have analyzed each disease separately. Worse still. each study used a different assortment of homeopathic treatments, but they are treating them all as one thing, homeopathy. What does that mean? Does this mean all homeopathic treatments are equivalent? It doesn’t matter which specific treatment you choose? Saying that “homeopathy works” is like saying “medication works”. Which medication, at what dose, for which diseases?
But of course my primary question after reading the abstract and introduction was – what was the quality of these studies, and were the outcomes really positive? Well, let’s take a look. Of the 15 studies, 10 indicate that they were double-blind controlled trials.
1 – Andrade et al 1991, review claims this study showed improvement in homeopathy over placebo (without commenting on statistical significance), but the study reports: “There was no statistically significant difference between groups.”
2 – Gibson et al 1980, review claims a positive result but this is a small study, 20 patients in each group, and contains this curious note: “AM made two errors in assessing his patients on active homoeopathy and two in assessing his placebo patients, while RG made one error in assessing his patients on active therapy and four in assessing his placebo patients. The patients on active therapy who were assessed wrongly by both physicians had not improved and had therefore been assessed as being on placebo.” So both evaluators wrongly assumed that placebo patients with improvement were on active treatment and that non-responders on active treatment were on placebo – all errors in the direction of making the treatment seem effective.
3 – Koley at al 2015 – negative study.
4 – Haselen et al 2000 – no difference between homeopathic gel and analgesic gel, but no placebo arm.
5 – Shipley et al 1980 – negative study.
6 – Bell at al 2004 – statistically significant results, but high drop-out rate – 9 out of 63, which call the results into question.
7 – Shirmer at all 2000 – negative study
8 – Janczewska at 2023 – review reports as positive, but the three treatment groups (EM and LED therapy alone, homeopathic gel alone, and both combined) showed no significant difference.
9 – Fisher et al 1989 – reported as positive, but very small study (30 patients total) and not all outcomes were significant.
10 – Relton at al 2008 – reported as positive, but also had a high dropout rate, “Drop out rate in the usual care group was higher than the homeopath care group (8/24 vs 3/23).”
So of the 10 studies that were blinded and controlled, six were straight-up negative. Of the four with positive results, all were very small studies (essentially pilot studies) with some highly problematic features. Non-blinded studies with subjective outcomes are essentially worthless in terms of determining efficacy. Overall this is the pattern we expect to see for a treatment that does not work – small preliminary studies showing mixed results, with better studies that are mostly negative.
The review authors are simply wrong in saying that “most” of the studies were positive, and they failed to consider the relationship between the quality of the study and the outcome. They authors believe these results are encouraging, but they are the opposite.
It is telling how few studies have been down over five decades. With legitimate medical interventions, we generally see a building of studies in the literature, with increasing quality and rigor, larger studies, more definitive designs, and replications, until we build and evidence-base that allows us to reject then null hypothesis and conclude a treatment is efficacious or fail to do so and abandon the treatment as not effective. But with homeopathy, we never see this.
We never see any specific treatment for any specific condition where we have multiple high quality studies showing replicating a clinically significant and statistically significant effect. There isn’t a single indication for which any homeopathic product or treatment has been shown to be effective. Instead what we get is what we see in this review – a scattershot of poorly designed small studies with unreliable results. Studies of any quality tend to be negative. But there is no replicable effect here.
What we also see, which we should not, is gullible authors publishing horrible reviews that ignore standard practice and misrepresent the evidence-base, along with editors from an otherwise respected peer-reviewed journal publishing such terrible work.


Getting NCCAM’s money’s worth: Some results of NCCAM-funded studies of homeopathy
David Gorski on November 19, 2012
Link

As hard as it is to believe, the Science-Based Medicine blog that you’re so eagerly reading is fast approaching its fifth anniversary of existence. The very first post here was a statement of purpose by Steve Novella on January 1, 2008, and my very first post was a somewhat rambling introduction that in retrospect is mildly embarrassing to me. It is what it is, however. The reason I mention this is because I want to take a trip down memory lane in order to follow up on one of my earliest posts for SBM, which was entitled The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM): Your tax dollars hard at work. Specifically, I want to follow up on one specific study I mentioned that was funded by NCCAM.
Even though I not-so-humbly think that, even nearly five years later, my original post is worth reading in its entirety (weighing in at only 3,394 words, it’s even rather short—for me, at least), I’ll spare you that and cut straight to the chase, the better to discuss the study. It is a study of homeopathy. Yes, in contrast to the protestations of Dr. Josephine Briggs, the current director of NCCAM, that NCCAM doesn’t fund studies of such pure pseudoscience as homeopathy anymore (although she does apparently meet with homeopaths for “balance”), prior to Dr. Briggs’ tenure NCCAM actually did fund studies of the magic water with mystical memory known as homeopathy. Two grants in particular I singled out for scorn. The principal investigator for both grants was Iris Bell, who is faculty at Andrew Weil’s center of woo at the University of Arizona. The first was an R21 grant for a project entitled Polysomnography in homeopathic remedy effects (NIH grant 1 R21 AT000388).
Here’s the abstract:
DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): Classical homeopathy is a 200-year old system of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM), which claims that a substance that can cause symptoms in a healthy person (provings) can cure similar symptoms in a sick person (Law of Similars). In a design synthesizing homeopathic provings, health psychology, and psychophysiological methodologies, this revised 3-year R21 exploratory study (NCCAM PAR 03-153) will assess the effects of two different homeopathic, plant-derived remedies ([A]: Nux Vomica 30c or [B]: Coffea Cruda 30c) on polysomnographic sleep recordings of adult human subjects of both sexes (N=60). Primary Specific Aims are: I. To evaluate the effects of two different active homeopathic remedies versus placebo on standard sleep stages and spectral EEG in human subjects; and II.To determine the effects of two different active homeopathic remedies versus placebo on nonlinear characteristics of sleep EEG in human subjects; The Secondary Aim is: III. To assess the contribution of baseline individual difference traits and subjective expectation in modifying the physiological outcomes above. The study will examine the interaction of the remedy effects with two different human personality traits associated with insomnia and overlapping those of persons reported in classical homeopathy to respond most strongly to each remedy. Subjects will fall into two subclinical groups of otherwise healthy persons: (i) those who score high on the personality trait of hostility (Type A/coronary-prone; contained within remedy picture of Nux Vomica)(n=30) and (ii) those who score high on the personality trait of anxiety sensitivity (panic-prone; contained within remedy picture of Coffea Cruda)(n=30). All subjects also will report insomnia from drinking coffee (a symptom common in homeopathy to both remedy types) and will replace it with a non-coffee caffeinated beverage for at least 7 days before and for the duration of the study (beverage coffee is reportedly a clinical antidote for many homeopathic remedies). During the 4-week protocol, on the first two nights of each study week, they will undergo at home, all-night polysomnographic sleep recordings, i.e., on days 1 and 2 (baseline 1), 8 and 9 (placebo), 15 and 16 (baseline 2), and 22 and 23 (remedy [A] OR remedy [B]). All will receive placebo at bedtime on day 8, single-blind (placebo given before any remedy to eliminate risk of carry-over effects and/or experimenter intentionality on placebo responses, problems reported in previous homeopathic provings). At bedtime on day 22, half of the subjects from each personality type will receive one dose of Nux Vomica and half will receive one dose of Coffea Cruda on a randomized, double-blind basis. All participants will also record subjective sleep and symptom patterns over the 4 weeks. Statistical analyses will include hierarchical linear models and general linear models. The chosen remedies in 30c doses each showed specific and different effects on sleep electroencephalograms of healthy animals in previous studies. This study will contribute to our long-range goal of understanding the neurophysiological and biopsychosocial mechanisms of classical homeopathic remedy treatment in patients with specific clinical conditions.
Leaving aside the utterly scientifically bankrupt nature of the hypotheses and the methods of testing the, which involve homeopathic provings, health psychology, and psychophysiological methodologies, NIH R21 grants are exploratory grants designed to test preliminary hypotheses. As such, they are much smaller than the usual flagship R01 grants and don’t require much preliminary data. Actually, technically they don’t require any preliminary data, the idea being that an idea that is based in sound science designed to explore a promising novel hypothesis could potentially be fundable, but in all my years in the lab I’ve never seen an R21 funded with no preliminary data. Be that as it may, there’s no way that anything having to do with homeopathy could be based in sound science, but apparently that didn’t stop NCCAM from funding the polysomnography grant (1 R21 AT000388) for three years and scoring total funding of $583,974. If we estimate an indirect cost rate of approximately 50%, that means Dr. Bell scored roughly $389,000 in direct costs to do this study, the rest going to the University of Arizona. (These days, R21s are usually only funded for two years to a maximum of $275,000 in direct costs.) Even so, just the very nature of homeopathy, how it involves diluting compounds to nonexistence (note that Bell is using 30C preparations, which means they’ve been diluted 1060-fold, or approximately 1037-fold more than Avogadro’s number), should have been enough to kill this grant in any respectable study section. The same is true of the second grant, which was entitled Dilution and succussion in homeopathic remedy dose-response effects (NIH grant 1 R21 AT003212).
Here’s its abstract:
DESCRIPTION (provided by applicant): The purpose of this revised R21 exploratory grant to NCCAM in response to PAR-03-153 is to extend the PI’s previous human olfactory psychophysiology research and develop a quantitative electroencephalographic (qEEG) bioassay for registration of individually active (salient) versus inactive homeopathic remedies or placebo. Homeopathy’s founder, Samuel Hahnemann MD, originally proposed olfactory sniffing as a valid route for clinical remedy administration. Convergent basic science evidence suggests that succussion (vigorous shaking) in the preparation of homeopathic remedies from animal, mineral, and plant sources, may persistently modify the physical structure of solvent to generate order, i.e., a unique informational signal, even in ultra-diluted solutions beyond Avogadro’s number. Torres and Ruiz (1996) proposed that stochastic resonance in sensory systems is a model for optimizing detection of a weak signal (homeopathic remedy information) by addition of noise (succussions). No previous research has directly examined the effects in human populations of a given remedy dilution prepared with different numbers of succussions. Specific aims for the study are: I. To evaluate the feasibility of using acute evoked responses in quantitative electroencephalography (qEEG) alpha power during olfactory administration to detect the presence of a single homeopathic remedy (Sulphur) at different numbers of succussions per dilution step, prepared at a given dilution; II. To determine the feasibility of using the magnitude of acute evoked responses in quantitative electroencephalography (qEEG) alpha power during olfactory administration to detect the presence of a single homeopathic remedy at two different homeopathic serial dilution factors (prepared with a given number of succussions per dilution step); III. To evaluate the generalizability of findings for a separate polycrest remedy (Pulsatilla). Subjects will be N=108 (n=54/remedy) young adult volunteers with moderate (not excellent global health) prescreened for potential remedy salience of either Sulphur or Pulsatilla and tested in a two-phase study (one remedy per phase). Each participant will undergo pre-screening with the Homeopathic Constitutional Type Questionnaire for high criterion scores for symptoms of one of the two test remedies, followed by three laboratory sessions spaced one week apart (dilution sequence subject allocation balanced within each remedy type for 6c, 12c, and 30c potencies). Each session will involve eight presentations within a complete block design of randomized double-blind, placebo- controlled (both succussed remedy-free solvent and succussed plain distilled water) olfactory sniff tests (using time-locked sniff-EEG recordings via an airflow pressure transducer), using a given remedy dilution prepared with stirring only, 10, 20, or 30 succussions. The present study fills a major need in homeopathic clinical research to explore and understand remedy-related and remedy-person interactive factors that could contribute to well-known problems in replicability. Findings from this and follow- up studies via subsequent R01s could improve standardization of homeopathic remedy manufacturing and prescribing used in patient care and thereby advance the quality of clinical treatments and research for this leading form of complementary and alternative medicine worldwide.
Yes, as hard as it is to believe, this is an actual, NIH-funded grant. Yes, it’s an R21, and, yes, one could argue that it’s fairly impressive (for a believer in homeopathy) that Dr. Bell would like to actually test the effects of succussion on the production of homeopathic remedies. Or it would be, were it not for the science that shows that diluting remedies far beyond Avogadro’s number leaves not a single molecule left of the original remedy and that there is no even remotely plausible mechanism by which homeopathic remedies so diluted can work. The way that homeopaths hand wave as above, using terms such as “homeopathy remedy information” should tell you all you need to know.
Putting aside just how nonsensical homeopathy is, I can’t help but note that this is now all money that’s already been spent. As scientists, how do we judge the value of what came out of a grant like this? Given that, as a general rule, it’s often very hard to judge the value of the actual science funded by a grant as it’s being done or shortly thereafter, we have to rely on imperfect metrics. These include (1) publications that derive from the work done using the grant funding; (2) new grants that derive from the data generated from work done on the grant; and (3) patents that derive from work. In all fairness, we also have to take into account the fact that these two grants are R21s, which means they’re designed to fund preliminary research, which by its very nature is riskier and less likely to pan out than research funded by a nice, “safe” R01 backed by ten papers’ worth of preliminary data. Some R21s based in the soundest and most interesting of science will result in not a whole lot of results; it’s the nature of the beast. (Preliminary “risky” research is, well, preliminary and risky.) Fortunately, when it comes to finding this out, it’s not as difficult as it once was, as the NIH now requires that all papers that result from NIH-funding be reported and made available to the public through PubMed Central, albeit sometimes after a year embargo to satisfy the for-profit publishers. So let’s take a look at the publications credited to these grants so far:
Here are the publications deriving from the polysomnography/homeopathy grant (1 R21 AT000388):
     1.  Menk Otto L, Howerter A, Bell IR, Jackson N (2010). Exploring measures of whole person wellness: integrative well-being and psychological flourishing. Explore (NY) 6(6):364-70.
     2.  Brooks AJ, Bell IR, Howerter A, Jackson N, Aickin M (2010). Effects of homeopathic medicines on mood of adults with histories of coffee-related insomnia. Forsch Komplementmed 17(5):250-7. PMID: 20980764.
     3.  Bell IR, Howerter A, Jackson N, Aickin M, Baldwin CM, Bootzin RR (2011). Effects of homeopathic medicines on polysomnographic sleep of young adults with histories of coffee-related insomnia. Sleep Med 12(5):505-11. PMID: 20673648.
     4.  Bell IR, Koithan M (2006). Models for the study of whole systems. Integr Cancer Ther 5(4):293-307. PMID: 17101758.
Here are the publications deriving from the succussion grant (1 R21 AT003212):
     1.  Bell IR, Howerter A, Jackson N, Brooks AJ, Schwartz GE (2012). Multiweek resting EEG cordance change patterns from repeated olfactory activation with two constitutionally salient homeopathic remedies in healthy young adults. J Altern Complement Med 18(5):445-53. PMID: 22594648.
     2.  Bell IR, Brooks AJ, Howerter A, Jackson N, Schwartz GE (2011).Short-term effects of repeated olfactory administration of homeopathic sulphur or pulsatilla on electroencephalographic alpha power in healthy young adults. Homeopathy 100(4):203-11. PMID: 21962194.
     3.  Menk Otto L, Howerter A, Bell IR, Jackson N (2010). Exploring measures of whole person wellness: integrative well-being and psychological flourishing. Explore (NY) 6(6):364-70. PMID: 21040885.
So far, this is not promising. For all six papers (there’s one claimed for both grants), only one appears to be in a “real” journal (i.e., a journal that is not devoted to “alternative” or “integrative” medicine). That journal is Sleep Medicine. All of the other these journals, although ostensibly “peer-reviewed” and, for whatever unknown but almost certainly ridiculous reason, indexed in Medline, are the lowest of the low. Any journal whose title is Homeopathy is clearly devoted to pure pseudoscience. Explore: The Journal of Science and Healing is a journal known for its publication of truly ridiculous studies. Perhaps my favorite of the bunch is from a few years ago and involved looking at whether positive “intent” could be embedded in chocolate, much the way that Masuro Emoto tries to embed “intent” into water. And, of course, the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, Forschende Komplementärmedizin (Research in Complementary Medicine), and Integrative Cancer Therapies are well-known as go-to journals for all varieties of dubious “integrative” medicine. For instance, the former advertises that it will publish papers in, among other things, homeopathy, naturopathy, subtle energies, energy medicine, or whatever. (My personal favorite, something I haven’t quite yet figured out yet, is the topic of “integrative biophysics,” which is one of the topics listed as being relevant to this particular journal.)
Of course, it’s not enough simply to point out that these three journals are shams masquerading as real scientific journals. You never know. Maybe these three papers are simply awesome. Yes, I know it’s highly unlikely when the topic is homeopathy, but, as always, it’s necessary to dive into the papers themselves. So let’s look at a few of these papers, chosen because they piqued my interest in some way and they represented the number of papers I could get through in the time I had to write this. I’ll start with #3 from the succussion/dilution grant, which is also #1 for the polysomnography grant. It’s also published in the second woo-iest of the journals, Explore. Or maybe it’s the first woo-iest of the journals. After all, it doesn’t limit itself to just one quackery, the way Homeopathy does. Looking at the paper, I have a hard time figuring out what the relevance is to either grant, as it is not so much about homeopathy at all. Rather, it’s about what the authors abbreviate as WSCAM (which echoes in my mind as “W-SCAM”). WSCAM stands for “whole systems complementary and alternative medicine” and consists mainly of homeopathy, traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), Ayurveda, and naturopathy, defined as systems that “focus on the whole person indicators of health, including patients’ experienced global well-being.” To this, Bell wants to apply “nonlinear dynamical systems theory thusly”:
Investigators have proposed using scientific concepts drawn from complex nonlinear dynamical systems theory towards improving the external validity of the clinical evidence base on WSCAM studies [8, 11, 12]. Several medical specialties are using methods of complex systems science to evaluate the functioning of body systems in an effort to increase diagnostic capability and assess patterns of disease [13–19]. Study designs such as these are well suited to non-reductive WSCAM studies that evaluate whole-person outcomes, because they attempt to quantify complex variables. In complexity theory the person is an indivisible complex adaptive system of interacting and interdependent parts, nested within and responsive/reactive to a complex environment. Synthesis of WSCAM with complexity theory suggests the need for characterizing WSCAM outcomes in terms of both (a) global and local outcomes and (b) positively and negatively valenced systemic behaviors (i.e., symptoms, signs) [8].
Basically, Bell et al looked at the results of different measures of psychological health, calculating what is known as the “P:N” (positive to negative affect) ratio on a bunch of college students enrolled in an introductory psychology course, tried to figure out if the “ratio of positive to negatively valenced mood has a unique relationship to overall well-being different from its individual components,” and dividing the students up into what they called “flourisher” and “languishers.” Ultimately, they claim that their goal is to “apply complex systems theory” to additional studies and ask if that can “improve well being.” As I said, this study is purely observational and not even particularly interesting. It’s also only tangentially related to the grant, perhaps specific aim 3, which is “to assess the contribution of baseline individual difference traits and subjective expectation in modifying the physiological outcomes.”
Next up is a paper published in 2011. This trial was, in essence, a homeopathic proving, in which Bell et al had healthy college students sniff various homeopathic remedies while hooked up to an EEG machine. I kid you not. Even more bizarre, the students were screened and tested thusly:
College student volunteers (ages 18–30, both sexes) from an introductory psychology course were screened for good health and relatively elevated Sulphur OR Pulsatilla symptom scores on the Homeopathic Constitutional Type Questionnaire. Subjects underwent a series of 3 once-weekly double-blind sessions during which they repeatedly sniffed the remedy matched to their CTQ type and solvent controls. Each remedy was given in a 6c, 12c, and 30c potency, one potency per week, in randomly assigned order. Solvent controls included both plain distilled water and a water-ethanol (95%) solution. All sniff test solutions were further diluted just prior to laboratory sessions (0.5 ml test solution in 150 ml distilled water). Within a session, remedies and control solvents were administered via 2-second sniffs (8 sniffs of each of 4 different succussion levels for the potency in randomized order). Primary outcome variable was relative EEG power (alpha 1 8–10 hertz; alpha 2 10–12 hertz) averaged over 19 electrode sites, including all succussions for a given potency.
That’s right. Your tax dollars funded a study in which students sniffed homeopathic remedies, two of which, the 12C and 30C, were diluted to near-non-existence and non-existence, respectively. In the introduction the investigators went on and on about the “nonlinear” nature of the alleged dose-response of homeopathic remedies in previous studies. One wonders if it ever occurred to them that this would be the result one would expect if what they were seeing were spurious results; i.e., no consistent dose-response curve. It doesn’t matter, though. This study was massively unimpressive. If you look at the tables, you’ll see that there is no consistent “dose-response” curve. “Effects” fluctuate up and down as dilution increases. In Table 2, only one measure was statistically significantly different, and that appears to be only because the 12C dilution produced a lower power than either the 6C dilution or the 30C dilution. I’ll grant the investigators that that’s “nonlinear,” but it also goes against homeopathic “theory,” which claims that diluting the solution makes the remedy more potent.
Table 3 looks at the number of succussion steps. Basically, the investigators looked at whether succussion in addition to dilution matters. Again, I kid you not. Basically, the investigators looked at four different “succussion” levels: no succussion (stirred), 20 succussions, 40 succussions, and 100 succussions). Remember, whenever they are criticized for claiming that their remedies become more potent the more that they are diluted, homeopaths will piously and condescendingly tell us that homeopathy is so much more than just dilution. The succussion steps are supposedly absolutely critical, as they “potentize” the solution of the homeopathic remedy. You might remember that the founder of homeopathy, Samuel Hahnemann himself, recommended slapping the remedy against a Bible to succuss it. Three out of the four measures were not statistically significantly different, and the one that was shows no consistent change in one direction based on the number of succussion steps. In other words, this is about as close to a negative study as can be. Given the number of repeated measures that the investigators looked at, I would have been shocked if they hadn’t found one or two seemingly “positive” results; however, there is no consistency to them that would suggest a real effect. In any real world scientific application, this would be a negative study. It looks like nothing more than noise interpreted as signal. It is rather amusing, though, how inconsistent effects that follow no dose-response are touted as a feature, not a bug, of homeopathy.
Speaking of this very feature, I’ve saved the paper published in the “real” journal for last, specifically the paper in Sleep Medicine. This paper actually took some reading, unfortunately, but I didn’t think I could avoid discussing it because, well, it’s the only paper from these grants that appeared in a real journal. In brief, this study examines the effect of two homeopathic remedies, Nux Vomica or Coffea Cruda, on insomnia associated with caffeine use. Following the homeopathic principle (for which there is no evidence that it works as a general rule) of like cures like, Bell et al made homeopathic remedies out of unroasted coffee beans (Coffea Cruda). I can’t figure out the rationale for using Nux Vomica, which is basically strychnine, but apparently homeopaths use it for insomnia, colds, flu, bladder infections, and “premature, profuse or erratic menstruation periods wherein the patients tend to faint before the start of their menstruation cycle.” Why? Who knows? The one thing I do know is that it’s a really good thing that most homeopathic remedies are diluted to nonexistence. One wouldn’t want to be taking strychnine at pharmacological doses. In any case, Bell et al describe the use of these two remedies thusly:
Clinically, homeopaths report that Coffea Cruda patients are mild and timid, but also irritable and oversensitive to all types of sensory stimuli, especially noise, as well as to positive emotions [25,26]. Nux Vomica as a homeopathic remedy is used clinically to treat people with competitive, irritable and impatient Type A-like behavioral patterns and tendencies to abuse alcohol, caffeine, and other substances. Both Coffea Cruda and Nux Vomica patients report insomnia in the middle of the night as a symptom [27]. Taken together with the clinical reports, the animal EEG sleep data provide a basis for selecting Coffea Cruda and Nux Vomica as candidate homeopathic remedies to test in the first homeopathic PSG research on human subjects.
I’m sold. How about you? Note that reference 27 is a book quoting Hahnemann. I also can’t help but note that every single reference used as a basic science justification for this study, some of which were animal studies claiming that Coffea Cruda or Nux Vomica could decrease caffeine-induced changes in sleep in rats, all came from not just woo journals but homeopathy journals. I took a look at the papers, and, as one might expect, they were…underwhelming. But what about this study?
The experimental design was rather complicated:
Young adults of both sexes (ages 18–31) with above-average scores on standardized personality scales for either cynical hostility or anxiety sensitivity (but not both), and a history of coffee-induced insomnia, participated in the month-long study. At-home polysomnographic recordings were obtained on successive pairs of nights once per week for a total of eight recordings (nights 1, 2, 8, 9, 15, 16, 22, 23). Subjects (N=54) received placebo pellets on night 8 (single-blind) and verum pellets on night 22 (double-blind) in 30c doses of one of two homeopathic remedies, Nux Vomica or Coffea Cruda. Subjects completed daily morning sleep diaries and weekly Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index scales, as well as Profile of Mood States Scales at bedtime on polysomnography nights.
As the authors readily acknowledge, obtaining polysomnographic (PSG) measurements at home is not a trivial matter. In any case, the factor they were interested in was the PSG sleep time. Well, not exactly. According to the methods section:
Based on the clinical literature and animal studies, primary outcome variables of interest were total sleep time, slow wave sleep, stage changes, and awakenings after sleep onset, as a function of verum remedy versus placebo across all subjects. Given the exploratory and early research phase nature of the current study on human subjects, however, PSG sleep onset and rapid eye movement (REM) latencies, REM and other NREM stages, as well as actigraphic measures of TST, sleep onset latency, sleep efficiency, and fragmentation index, were examined secondarily for possible effects.
One thing I found highly irritating about this paper is the way that they reported their findings. Rather than showing the data in a straightforward bar graph or a table with clear descriptions of what each number means, we’re treated to a single table, (Table 2) showing regression findings, which are described as being within-subject Analyses on means for combined remedy nights (22/23) versus means for combined placebo nights 8/9, controlling for gender, personality scores, total time in bed, and means for combined baseline nights (1/2/15/16). Unfortunately, even after reading the paper, I’m not sure exactly how authors controlled for baseline nights. Another thing I noticed right away is that the 95% confidence intervals were large. Really large, as in at least half the value of the actual number, often considerably more.
Also rather curious were the findings themselves, which were that overall PSG for the remedy week showed significantly longer TST, increased NREM sleep including more minutes in stage 2 and increased slow wave sleep (SWS), with a trend toward increased minutes of stage 4 sleep (β=5.8, p<0.10) compared with placebo. The homeopathic remedies also led to more sleep disruptions after sleep onset, with significantly increased awakenings, number of stage changes, and more type 2 arousals compared to placebo. Sound familiar? Once again, it’s the same thing we’ve seen before: Mixed, inconsistent results.
There’s also another issue that is mentioned in the discussion, but the authors’ explanation is not convincing. The authors note that one possible interpretation of the data could be that the changes in sleep during the remedy week could be due to the passage of time and the adaptation of the subjects to the study protocol and equipment, rather than remedy effects. They are correct but not so convincing in their dismissal of that concern, in which they argue that everything is hunky dory because analyses were controlled for baselines taken on nights 1 and 2 and on nights 15 and 16. Here’s the problem. The very experimental design calls for a single-blind placebo during the earlier intervention week. Why single blind? Try not to laugh:
The study design was deliberately structured with single-blind placebo preceding allocation to one or the other of the two remedies double-blind, in order to address a different potential methodological and theoretical concern, i.e., the reported risk of non-local or entanglement confounds of placebo and remedy effects, when treatment arms are administered double-blind in a closed system of a homeopathic study. Keeping the experimental system open with single blind placebo may have provided a strategy to reduce the risk of entanglement between placebo and remedy effects [62–65].
Yes, Bell et al just invoked quantum entanglement. If you don’t believe me, check out references 62 through 65. Go ahead. I’ll wait. At least I was grateful when I read the paper that Bell actually refrained from citing Lionel Milgrom. Little victories matter. In any case, see how pseudoscience twists a normal protocol. There could very well be bias introduced by always having the placebo first and by having it be only single-blinded. However, because of some fantastical worry about “entanglement,” instead of doing the study the way it should be done, totally double-blinding it and not restricting whether subjects got the placebo or the “real” homeopathic remedy to one week, they do it in a way that makes it less rigorous and more prone to effects not due to the intervention. Of course, given that homeopathic remedies are basically water packed into sugar pills and then allowed to evaporate, the very concept of a “placebo” in a homeopathy trial is rather risible. After all, the homeopathic remedies are every bit as much placeboes as the placeboes. Be that as it may, this trial is not particularly convincing, either. Even the authors concede that their “present findings do not address the question of whether or not either of the homeopathic remedies tested here would be therapeutic for certain people with insomnia.” Now that’s an understatement.
Two years ago, NCCAM director Josephine Briggs assured Steve Novella, Kimball Atwood, and myself that NCCAM is a lot more rigorous now and that trials like these two would never be funded under the new regime. That’s reassuring, but it doesn’t convince me. For one thing, Briggs wouldn’t say that no trial of homeopathy would ever be funded by NCCAM, even though she conceded that homeopathy is based on principles that are so unscientific as to be incredibly implausible. While I understand that it’s hard for the director of an NIH center to say “never” about anything, what this told me is that Dr. Briggs would be willing to fund homeopathy research if it met some level of scientific rigor. What about homeopathy could have sufficient scientific rigor to be worth throwing hundreds of thousands of dollars at is never said, and another director might be more lax in judgment. Besides, there is a training grant whose principal investigator is—you guessed it!—Iris Bell and whose purpose involves preparing its fellows to be able to study all sorts of dubious alt-med modalities, including homeopathy. Yes, it’s the University of Arizona CAM research training program.
So even though NCCAM claims not to fund pure quackery anymore (although that’s debatable), it does fund education in quackery in the form of training grants. As for grants like those of Iris Bell, it’s depressing to think that NCCAM threw a half million dollars at studies this execrable, in addition to studies just as bad. It’s your tax dollars still at work, funding woo.

   The World Has Moved On
Mark Crislip 
Link
I do a lot of driving as part of my job. I am the sole Infectious Disease doctor at three hospitals and I can spend an hour or two a day in the car, depending on traffic. What prevents me from going crazy sitting in traffic is listening to podcasts and audible books. I especially like reading (and yes, audio books is reading, pedant) multivolume epics. Currently I am reading Steven King’s Dark Tower series, which occurs in a universe “where the world has moved on.” In Mid-world there was once a world with science and beauty and art, but something changed, what I do not know yet (I am only on the third volume; no spoilers in the comments), and the world moved on, leaving behind some artifacts of science and technology, but it appears to be an increasingly primitive world. Being fantasy, there is, unlike the world I live in, magic as well.
I like that phrase: “the world has moved on.” I have an understanding of the world and medicine, based mostly, but not entirely, on science. My understanding of the natural world is not complete, but mostly consistent and validated by hundreds of years of research. My undergraduate degree was in physics, and, like all premeds and medical school students, have an extensive education in chemistry, biology, biochemist, physiology, anatomy, biochemistry, etc. It all ties together nicely, especially in my specialty , where I have the most knowledge. I consider infections at many levels, from issues of single molecule changes that may confer antibiotic resistance, up through the patient and their family, and sometimes at the level of the entire planet. Truly wholistic, not the pseudo-wholism of SCAM.
The sciences gives a mostly coherent understanding of the world. Mostly coherent. It does give an understanding of the possible, the probable, the improbable and the impossible. Most of the sciences, unlike parts of medical science, are not concerned with the impossible. There is not complementary and alternative physics, or chemistry, or biochemistry, or engineering. These disciplines compare their ideas against reality, and, if the ideas are found wanting, abandoned. Perpetual motion is not considered seriously by any academic physicist; if perpetual motion were an alternative medicine it would be offered at a Center by a Harvard Professor of Medicine.
Most scientists outside of medicine are aware of how easy it is to fool themselves and, by extension, others. As Richard Feynman said.
“We’ve learned from experience that the truth will come out. Other experimenters will repeat your experiment and find out whether you were wrong or right. Nature’s phenomena will agree or they’ll disagree with your theory. And, although you may gain some temporary fame and excitement, you will not gain a good reputation as a scientist if you haven’t tried to be very careful in this kind of work. And it’s this type of integrity, this kind of care not to fool yourself, that is missing to a large extent in much of the research in cargo cult science.”
My archetype for scientists fooling themselves, and others, is the story of N-rays, which I have discussed before.
For whatever reason, and I do not pretend to understand why, medical people are occasionally unable to incorporate the simple concept that unless they are very careful, they can be fooled. The result is complementary and alternative medicine. It is the place that remains after the world has moved on.
That phase constantly popped into my head as I looked at the Huffington Post sections on Intergratve Medicine. The world of medicine, at least, has moved on and left the Huffington Post behind. So much on the HuffPo Intergrative medicine site is at odds with reality that I will mention only a few of the more egregious examples of medical nonsense. HuffPo is giving Natural News a run for their money in the production of fantasy. Most striking was the homeopathic (the facts being seriously deluded; isn’t that an underlying principle of homeopathy?) article by Dana Ulman entitled Homeopathy for Radiation Poisoning. Water for radiation toxicity. Seriously. And not even heavy water, which might catch the extra neutron. And the reasoning for its use is even more goofy, if possible, than that of oh-so-silly-ococcinum.
“Because one of the basic premises of homeopathic medicine is that small doses of a treatment can help to heal those symptoms that large doses are known to cause, Ludlam suggested to Grubbe that radiation may be a treatment for conditions such as tumors because it also causes them. This incident is but one more example from history in which an insight from a homeopathic perspective has provided an important breakthrough in medical treatment.”
I suppose since smoking causes cancer you should treat lung cancer with cigarettes and since alcohol causes cirrhosis you should treat cirrhosis is with vodka and guns cause acute lead poisoning so maybe we should shoot gunshot victims. That I suppose, would be reasonable conclusions from homeopathic theory derived from metaphor and faulty metaphor that.
What nostrums are recommend for radiation therapy? Cadmium iodatum, Ceanothus, and Cadmium sulphuratum, for which there are no Pubmed references to support treating radiation toxicity, even though the author says they are a well-known remedies for that condition. Not well known to medical science I suppose. Ah the wisdom of homeopathy, where saying it makes it so.
Then the author suggests
“Calendula (marigold) is a well-known herbal and homeopathic medicine. Highly respected research has found excellent results in using Calendula ointment on people who experienced radiotherapy-induced dermatitis.”
Now why is Calendula a homeopathic medicine? I went to the original reference and it appears from the literature to be a worthwhile agent for the prevention of radiation term burns. But I am not so sure I would classify Calendula as a homeopathic preparation. According to the producers site it is “Calendula Fresh Plant 4%” and in the original article it is “is fabricated from a plant of the marigold family, Calendula officinalis. The digest is obtained by incubation at 75°C in petroleum jelly to extract the liposoluble components of the plant.” The authors do not use the word homeopathic anywhere in the reference.
Real product came containing real parts of the plant at a measurable concentrations, hardly homeopathic in nature. Calendula ointment has not been subjected to proving, nor has it been potentiated, as if either are helpful. It is not a homeopathic preparation just because a preparation made by a producer of homeopathic nostrums, although that appears to be the reason. It is a new definition of a homeopathic preparation: if it is made by a homoepathic producer it is therefore a homeopathic preparation. By this standard, the effluent of the Boiron toilets would also be considered homeopathic preparations.
When it comes to homeopathy, not only has the world moved on, rational thought and consistency has moved on.
And there is acupuncture. There is a link to an article entitled As Medical Costs Rise More Americans Turn to Acupuncture. This is an article from AOL linked from the Huffington Post (now owned by AOL). If you want to get the heebie-jeebies take a look at the opening picture on that page. The text says “Practitioners must use needles produced and manufactured according to U.S. Food and Drug Administration standards, which require needles to “be sterile, nontoxic, and labeled for single use by qualified practitioners only.” The needles may be sterile, but what good is a sterile needle used by a bare hand?
Look at the accompanying photograph. That middle finger does not inspire confidence. It is no wonder that acupuncture is associated with outbreaks of hepatitis C, hepatitis B, and MRSA infections. Most the pictures of acupuncture on this website demonstrate that acupuncturists lack understanding of basic technique. It is hard to infect people with an injection. Heroin users inject themselves with a rich melange of bacteria every day without getting infections. It is hard to infect patients in the hospital with blood draws and IV’s. But if an infection can happen, it will happen. And those fingers, just recently in a nose, or picking a tooth, or scratching a butt, will spread an infection with an acupuncturist’s needle to one unlucky patient. Not only has the world moved on for acupuncture, it took with it an appreciation of germ theory.
The Huffington Post seems to be immune from advances in understanding of all of so-called intergrative medicines, or even basic anatomy and physiology. They link to a video entitled The Meridian System in Oriental Medicine. They might have linked to the anatomy of Orcs or the physiology of Dementors, for all the application to reality it represents. The video is gibberish when compared to nature as we understand it. The world has moved on.
When Huffington Post published absolute nonsense, I have to wonder how good their analysis is on issues like politics, war, the environment and other important areas. I was always taught to judge a man by the company he keeps. I have the same problem with my local newspaper, the Oregonian, which publishes the occasional nonsense piece in the Living section. They often get things wrong in Infectious Diseases, the one area I have expertise. If they are wrong in areas I know, can I trust their writings on other topics?
When I finish the series, I’ll let you know, metaphorically, what the alt med Dark Tower is.

Homeopathy and Nanoparticles
Harriet Hall on May 8, 2012
Link
I had never heard of Dr. Shantaram Kane, a chemical engineer in Mumbai, India. I don’t know how he heard of me, but he apparently knows I am critical of homeopathy. He e-mailed me out of the blue to tell me about a study he had published in 2010 in the journal Homeopathy: “Extreme homeopathic dilutions retain starting materials: A nanoparticulate perspective.” The full text is available online here. It was lauded in an accompanying editorial. Incredibly, it is an uncontrolled study.
Kane recognizes that a major objection to homeopathy is that, at high potencies, not a single molecule of the starting material is present. He says his study found nanoparticles of the parent metal in 200C dilutions of metal-based remedies. He says his findings represent a paradigm shift. In other words, there really is something there when we assumed there wasn’t.
The Study
They purchased samples of 6 homeopathic medications from market sources. The labels said they contained either 30C or 200C dilutions of gold, copper, tin, zinc, silver, or platinum. They analyzed these medications and found nanoparticles of the corresponding metals. They identified them with TEM (Transmission Electron Microscopy), SAED (Selected Area Electron Diffraction), and ICP-AES (inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrophotometry). I don’t understand the technology, and the published pictures just look like meaningless blobs to me, but for the purposes of this discussion I’ll accept that they reliably identified the presence of the metallic elements.
The Speculation
How to explain the presence of nanoparticles? They speculate:
     1.  Shearing forces could have produced them during the manufacturing process, both from mechanized lactose triturations and human-powered succussion.
     2.  Acoustic cavitation during the manual succussion process could have produced localized bubbles with temperatures high enough to melt metal particles.
     3.  The nanoparticle-nanobubble complex rises to the surface and forms a monolayer, and it is this top 1% that is collected and used for the next step in the dilutions.
Problems
    • They didn’t really know what they were studying. They didn’t verify that the contents of the products they purchased actually conformed to the labels or were prepared by the methods they speculate about.
    • They didn’t use any controls. Ideally, they would have used two kinds of control samples: one prepared by the same dilution methods but without any starting material, and one prepared with the same starting material but without succussion. And maybe another homeopathic remedy not based on metals.
    • They didn’t rule out contamination of the original products during the manufacturing process or subsequently from something in their lab (airborne contaminants, improperly washed equipment, etc.).
Biggest Problem
Even if nanoparticles are found in homeopathic remedies, the amount is too tiny to expect any effect on human physiology, and the remedies have not been shown to have any therapeutic effect.
He Offers to Answer Any Question
In his e-mail, Dr. Kane said:
I will be deligted to answer any question.i do hope you forward this finding to both the eblievers and sceptics. [sic]
I did have some questions, and I asked them in an e-mail:
     1.  Why no controls? Without them, can you be sure that there was not some contamination in the manufacturing process that would give the same findings for other homeopathic remedies or that some unrecognized contamination during your experimental preparation might give the same finding for non-homeopathic control samples?
     2.  How do the amounts you detected compare to the trace presence of other contaminants, such as minute particles suspended in the air that might fall in?
     3.  Even if your findings are replicated in other labs, what would that have to do with the claims of homeopathy to affect human health?
His Offer Retracted
It seems he had lied: he was not delighted to answer my questions. In fact, he flat out refused, saying 
Yur response is typical of a sceptic who has a totally closed mind and refuses to see any new information. I have coe across many such and in my experience, it is best to leave them alone. [sic]
His attitude says it all. This is not the response of a scientist.
Another Opinion
I asked Dr. Joe Schwarcz, McGill chemistry professor and science popularizer, to review the paper. He said:
It certainly doesn’t prove that homeopathy works…the question is …does it prove anything? Frankly I don’t believe the data. They found some sort of experimental artifact… 
Conclusion
This is just another pathetic effort to validate homeopathy by showing the remedies are more than water, similar to the recent effort by Luc Montagnier. Such studies never seem to get confirmed in other labs or to build towards any coherent body of knowledge. Publishing an uncontrolled study like this says a lot about the editorial and peer-review standards of the journal. Anyway, whatever anomalies proponents might discover in homeopathic remedies, that’s a far cry from establishing that homeopathy has any clinical effects.

Is Homeopathy Unethical?
Harriet Hall on August 4, 2015
Link

“A gentle ethical defence of homeopathy” by Levy et al. was recently published in an ethics journal. A full-text preprint is available online. They say:
Utilitarian critiques of homeopathy that are founded on unsophisticated notions of evidence, that adopt narrow perspectives on healthcare assessment, and that overstate the personal, social and ontological harms of homeopathy, add little to our understanding of the epistemology of medicine. But when they are used to denounce the ethics of homeopathy – they are not only ill-considered and counterproductive, but philosophically and socially perverse.
I found their arguments unconvincing.
They acknowledge that the evidence base for homeopathy is “insufficient” and its “efficacy cannot be broadly demonstrated.” Proponents have argued that homeopathy has utilities such as non-invasiveness, cost-effectiveness, holism and agent autonomy. Critics have argued that any benefits are minimal compared to negative features like failure to seek effective healthcare, waste of resources, promulgation of false beliefs, and a weakening of commitment to scientific medicine. Others have argued that homeopathy does not and cannot work except through contextual (“placebo”) effects, and that homeopaths are unethical because they deceive their patients by claiming specific effects.
And homeopathy is ethical because…?
Levy et al. argue that homeopathy is ethical because:
It offers significant value and benefits to patients [based on reports of patient satisfaction rather than on any objective measurements of outcomes. Translation: patients say they like it. Argument from popularity.]
It facilitates a diagnostic process that culminates in treatment or referral. [I don’t see how that claim could be substantiated. Homeopathic diagnosis is based on mythical miasms, homeopathic treatments are based on principles that are not valid, and they present no evidence that homeopaths give appropriate referrals to other providers or that they can even recognize conditions that would warrant referrals. How many of them even use a stethoscope?]
It is founded on a caring, therapeutic relationship between the clinician and patient. [True, but that is true of all good science-based clinicians too, and of charlatans, and of medieval blood-letters. That doesn’t mean it is ethical to use any random snake oil or to perform bloodletting to balance the humors. A caring relationship isn’t worth much by itself unless it is accompanied by an effective treatment.]
It is guided by the freedom of choice of consenting patients [essentially the old autonomy/health freedom argument. I would argue that patients can’t choose freely and rationally unless they are aware of all the pertinent facts and able to give truly informed consent].
Most of their claims refer to treatment by a homeopath. There is no diagnostic process or caring relationship involved in over-the-counter sales of homeopathic remedies to self-diagnosed customers in pharmacies.
Tu quoque and other fallacies
They argue that placebo or contextual effects of treatment are not valueless or irrelevant, and they are not equivalent across all healthcare contexts. They say homeopathy privileges time, listening, and therapeutic relationships, while conventional medical practice is systematically unable to attend to these domains of care and so to manifest these benefits. To my mind, that is not an argument for homeopathy but an argument for reducing time constraints and improving bedside manner in conventional medicine.They downplay homeopathic deaths and failures to refer, claiming that conventional medicine commits the same sins, and that many thousands of patients die each year from medical errors and adverse events. This is the old tu quoque and “death by medicine” fallacy. Examination of harms mustn’t be separated from examination of benefits, and the subjective benefits of patient satisfaction with homeopathy can’t begin to compete with the objective benefits of science-based treatments.
They argue that homeopaths are guided by both moral and professional virtues in their practice. I’m willing to accept that most homeopaths truly believe in the efficacy of their treatments and believe they are doing what’s best for their patients. But is belief enough?
They argue that conventional doctors often mislead patients too, and overstate their claims of efficacy. They say “the absence of evidence may not mean that the therapy does not work,” and that many mainstream health practices are not based on definitive evidence. Clearly, it is unethical for anyone to mislead patients by making claims that go beyond the evidence. But don’t essentially all the claims of homeopaths go beyond the evidence?
Autonomy, experience, anything but evidence
They argue that the choice to seek care from a homeopath can be just as valid and as ethically sound as any other healthcare choice. But can the choice be truly valid if it is based on a misunderstanding? They decry paternalism, but is it paternalistic to assist others in identifying misinformation from biased sources so they can give truly informed consent? I don’t see paternalism there; I see true autonomy and respect.
Finally, they want to re-define “evidence” to suit their own purposes, to include nebulous things like “values,” personal experience, and patient satisfaction.
Conclusion
In my opinion their arguments are fallacious and amount to a kind of tortured special pleading. They don’t even try to answer the criticisms of homeopathy that they list. They offer no evidence from controlled studies, only vague platitudes. They say it is non-invasive and cost effective; but how can it be cost effective if it isn’t effective?
It is unethical for any health care provider to lie to patients or to go beyond the evidence in representing the efficacy of their treatments. If homeopaths truly believe what they tell patients, they are not deliberately lying and so may be considered to be acting ethically. But it could be argued that it is unethical to withhold pertinent information, to not fully inform patients about how mainstream science views homeopathy, and about its incompatibility with the established body of scientific knowledge. And surely it is unethical for those who understand that homeopathic remedies have no specific effects to recommend them without full disclosure. For instance, I consider it unethical for pharmacists to put Oscillococcinum on the same shelf as Tylenol, Advil, and FDA-approved cold remedies.
Finally, the real question is whether a homeopath has anything to offer that couldn’t be better provided by the kind of science-based clinician who truly cares for the whole patient and knows how to take best advantage of the contextual effects of the therapeutic encounter. In my opinion, the answer to that question is a resounding “NO.” Science-based medicine is clearly more effective than homeopathic remedies; isn’t it unethical to provide second-rate treatment?

Homeopath Quits Homeopathy but Thinks the Homeopathic Approach Has Value
A former homeopath shows that there’s nothing scientific about homeopathy; in fact, it contradicts all known scientific principles. Nevertheless she finds value in the homeopathic approach to the patient and thinks all providers can learn from it.
Harriet Hall on February 26, 2019
Link

Natalie Grams is a German MD who was an enthusiastic practitioner of classical homeopathy. She had a successful homeopathy practice and got a lot of positive feedback from her patients. But then she set out to provide a scientific rebuttal of a book critical of homeopathy. Her illusions fell away as she realized there were no sound or convincing reasons to support homeopathy. She gave up her practice and found a new career in science communication.
Her book Homeopathy Reconsidered was recently translated from the original German. In it, she explains the origin of homeopathy, the underlying principles, the varieties of practice, and the identification of remedies through “provings”. She explains that science is the only reliable path to understanding how the world works and shows that there is nothing scientific about homeopathy; in fact, it contradicts all known scientific principles. But she finds value in the homeopathic approach. The homeopath provides what many patients long for: individual, empathetic counselling with attention to all aspects of the person (physical, mental, emotional, and spiritual) and long appointments. The homeopathic approach allows patients to tell the whole story of their illness experience and it employs the method of active listening developed by Carl Rogers for psychotherapy. She suggests that the same value could be provided in mainstream medicine in conjunction with effective remedies rather than useless homeopathic remedies.
She lists all the reasons patients turn to homeopathy; they boil down to time, empathy, and care. Mainstream medicine often seems rushed, perfunctory, and impersonal. The originator of homeopathy, Hahnemann, stressed making sure patients are allowed to say all they have to say. Mainstream doctors are often criticized for interrupting the patient’s narrative to ask questions.
She explains why patients believe homeopathy has helped them and offers alternative explanations. It gives them a sense of control; they believe they are doing something. It is reassuring to have a caring, optimistic person to talk to. Many diseases are self-limiting and resolve on their own. Most symptoms fluctuate; a decrease is attributed to homeopathy and an increase is explained away.
She thinks spirituality is important, but she defines the human spirit as that which enables us to develop ideas and perceptions, appreciate metaphors, and grasp complex interactions. She says homeopathic medicines contain nothing but the message “I’ll help you with your complaints.” She says, “the placebo effect does not mean that a drug is ineffective – only that it does not work through pharmacological ingredients.” She says homeopathic globules “are carriers of meaning and individualized autosuggestion.” She accepts Hahnemann’s concept of vitalism as an idea, but not as a fact. She sees homeopathy as a kind of conversation therapy, not a medical therapy. It can’t be studied in the same sense that drugs are studied; but she makes suggestions for other ways it might be tested, to elicit knowledge applicable to mainstream medical practice. She says homeopathy is bad in theory but good in practice, while the opposite is true of scientific medicine.
Conclusion: We don’t just need “homeopathy reconsidered,” we need “medicine reconsidered”
Natalie Grams makes a good case, not for homeopathy but for the homeopathic approach to patients:
    • Time for the patient
    • Openness and understanding
    • The possibility of expressing physical, emotional, and spiritual things and putting them into context
    • An individual approach (not just any pain, but my pain)
    • Improve self-perception and self-awareness and initiate situation-oriented changes in life
    • Medication with a high placebo effect (Keep in mind that every doctor/patient interaction has its own intrinsic contextual placebo effect)
I find it difficult to envision how such long appointment times could be implemented in conventional medicine, or whether that is even a good idea; but I think the principles of the homeopathic interview are worth thinking about. As Dr. Francis Peabody said in 1926,
Time, sympathy and understanding must be lavishly dispensed, but the reward is to be found in that personal bond which forms the greatest satisfaction of the practice of medicine. One of the essential qualities of the clinician is interest in humanity, for the secret of the care of the patient is in caring for the patient.

Ivermectin booster Dr. Tess Lawrie goes all-in for homeopathy for COVID and long COVID
Tess Lawrie has been promoting ivermectin for COVID-19 for two and a half years. Of late, she has becoming more of a general multipurpose quack, promoting ivermectin to treat cancer. Now she’s promoting homeopathy for COVID and long COVID while a Research Fellow at St. Mary’s University Twickenham. What does this tell us about medicine?
David Gorski on March 6, 2023
Link
I know that, since the COVID-19 pandemic hit, I keep repeating the mantra, “Everything old is new again.” I even know that I probably repeat it so much that it sometimes gets annoying. So be it. It’s a message that is important to me due to my simple hope that, if the newbies who have joined “our side” understand that none of this is new, they will learn the recurring themes, narratives, and forms of quackery, misinformation, and disinformation, the better to be prepared for the future. That brings us to homeopathy.
Remember ivermectin? Who can forget it, the repurposed drug used to treat helminthic (round-worm) diseases in animals and humans that COVID-19 quacks quickly repurposed to claim as a miracle cure for COVID-19 as evidence mounted that the last repurposed “miracle cure,” the antimalaria drug hydroxychloroquine (which is also used to treat rheumatoid arthritis), didn’t work against COVID-19, leading me to refer to it as the “Black Knight of COVID-19 treatments.” Basically, ivermectin was the new hydroxychloroquine, but its being the new hydroxychloroquine didn’t stop both drugs from remaining in the armamentarium of COVID quacks everywhere, immune to evidence, complete with conspiracy theories and dubious meta-analyses—even an appeal to the Nobel Prize!—to explain its lack of acceptance by “mainstream medicine.” Personally, I came to the conclusion that ivermectin was the acupuncture of COVID=19 treatments (a highly implausible treatment from a basic science standpoint supported by the flaws in the evidence-based medicine paradigm) and a perfect example to explain how science-based medicine isn’t just for “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” or whatever advocates of combining quackery with evidence-based medicine are calling it these days.
Which brings us back to Dr. Tess Lawrie.
Lawrie, you might remember, first made her name as one of the founders of the British Ivermectin Recommendation Development (BIRD) Group, a group that teamed up with the US group the COVID Frontline COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance (FLCCC) to vigorously promote ivermectin as a highly effective treatment for COVID-19, despite all evidence to the contrary, including basic pharmacokinetics. When last I discussed Lawrie, she had done what most quacks who believe in a particular treatment eventually do and embraced ivermectin as not just a highly effective treatment for COVID-19 but as a potential cancer cure.
Given that background (and the title of this post, which gives it away), I suspect that you know what’s coming next. That’s right. Lawrie has now embraced The One Quackery To Rule Them All for COVID-19, long COVID, and a number of other things. That’s right, it’s homeopathy time, baby!
Homeopathy: The air guitar of medicine
Advocates of science-based medicine like to refer to homeopathy as the “air guitar of medicine,” because, like an air guitar, it’s performative and can appear impressive, but, just as pretending to play guitar doesn’t produce any actual music, homeopathy doesn’t produce any therapeutic effects because almost by definition it can’t. I realize that our regular readers know what homeopathy is and why it’s quackery, but whenever discussing homeopathy I always feel obligated to provide a brief explanation for those who’ve never encountered this blog before, rather than just links. I hope our regulars will bear with me.
To reiterate, homeopathic remedies are the purest quackery, and I frequently refer to homeopathy as “The One Quackery To Rule Them All.” I also generally think it’s always worth a brief explanation of why. Basically, homeopathy was invented by a German physician Samuel Hahnemann in 1796 and is based on two “laws” that have no basis in science. (I suppose calling them “laws” made them sound more important, like Newton’s Laws of Motion.) The first is the Law of Similars, which states that you treat a given symptom using something that causes that symptom. No matter how much homeopaths try to claim otherwise and cite cherry picked examples, there is no physiologic, biochemical, or medical basis for such a broad general principle, and in fact what the first law of homeopathy resembles more than anything else is the principles of sympathetic magic, specifically Sir James George Frazer’s Law of Similarity as described in The Golden Bough (1922) as one of the implicit principles of sympathetic magic.
The second “law” of homeopathy, the Law of Infinitesimals, is even more ridiculous and pseudoscientific (or even mystical). I also find it the easiest to explain to the uninitiated why this “law” is utter bunk. In brief, the Law of Infinitesimals states that homeopathic remedies become stronger with dilution. Indeed, the process of making a homeopathic remedy involves serial dilution, usually 1:100. The mother tincture (or original compound or medicine) is diluted 1:100 and then shaken vigorously (succussed), the succussion step being claimed by homeopaths to be absolutely essential to “potentize” the remedy. After that, the remedy is diluted again in the same way. Each 1:100 dilution is designated by “C”, such that a 6C dilution equals six 1:100 dilutions. The problem comes with the higher dilutions. For instance, a 12C solution is on the order of a 10-24 dilution ((10-2)12 = 10-24). Many homeopathic remedies are on the order of 30C, which is a 10-60 dilution, or more than 1036-fold greater than Avogadro’s number. Some homeopathic remedies go up to 100C or more, or 10-200. Here’s a hint: The number of atoms in the known universe is estimated to be around 1078 to 1082. The math just doesn’t work, and remedies over around 12C are basically water. “Lesser” dilutions contain so little remedy that it’s highly unlikely that they have a pharmacological effect.
Even though these days Richard Dawkins gets on my nerves for a number of reasons that I will not go into here, I do have to give him props for perhaps the best two-and-a-half minute explanation why homeopathy is quackery ever committed to video:
With that explanation taken care of, let’s move on.
Tess Lawrie embraces homeopathy for COVID-19
Yesterday, as I was looking for topics to blog about, I came across an article on Tess Lawrie’s Substack entitled Homeopathy for long Covid. It is, unfortunately for my purposes, one of her articles only for paid subscribers, but, as is her wont, Lawrie had posted a promotional Substack newsletter three days before entitled There’s a reason why the Queen had a homeopath. I was half-tempted to retort that there’s a reason why King Charles III is heavily into homeopathy—something we used to criticize him harshly for when he was Prince Charles—but it’s not because homeopathy works. Instead, I noted how Lawrie had bought into the usual homeopathy narrative about its being “suppressed,” with a tagline reading: “On the pernicious rewriting of homeopathy’s history, and how well-crafted research is revealing what many have known all along: homeopathy works.”
Where have we heard that one before? Also, as our very own Dr. Mark Crislip has described, there is no good evidence that homeopathy is effective against COVID-19. As you will see, that is not unexpected given that homeopathy is basically quackery, mostly water or ethanol diluent with no medicinal value.
Lawrie, as is the case with most quacks, is not happy with Wikipedia. Indeed, she starts out by looking at Wikipedia:
Let’s start with the lies and misinformation about homeopathy. Here’s how the internet’s propaganda factory Wikipedia currently defines it:
Homeopathy or homoeopathy is a pseudoscientific[1][2][3][4] system of alternative medicine. It was conceived in 1796 by the German physician Samuel Hahnemann. Its practitioners, called homeopaths, believe that a substance that causes symptoms of a disease in healthy people can cure similar symptoms in sick people; this doctrine is called similia similibus curentur, or “like cures like”.[5]
The entry then describes homeopathy as ‘quackery and fraud’ and goes on to state:
During the 1970s, homeopathy made a significant comeback, with sales of some homeopathic products increasing tenfold. The trend corresponded with the rise of the New Age movement, and may be in part due to chemophobia, an irrational preference for “natural” products, and the longer consultation times homeopathic practitioners provided.
Reader, are you suffering from ‘chemophobia’? I think I may be, though I would argue that a preference for natural products is entirely rational. Out of curiosity, I thought I’d look at what the Wikipedia entry for homeopathy used to say. Here’s what it said on 31 October 2003:
Homoeopathy is a method of treating diseases and medical conditions invented, or at least popularized, by the German Samuel Hahnemann in the late 18th and early 19th centuries. It is based on the theory that each naturally occurring element, plant, and mineral compound will, when ingested or applied, result in certain symptoms. Hahnemann believed that, by diluting these substances in a standardized manner, one could reach the true essence of that substance. Hahnemann described this process of dilution as “potentizing” (German: “potenziert”) the substance. These dilute amounts could then be used to treat the very symptoms they were known to produce.
Hahnemann and his students approached their treatments in a holistic way, meaning that the whole of the body and spirit is dealt with, not just the localised disease. Hahnemann himself spent extended periods of time with his patients, asking them questions that dealt not only with their particular symptoms or illness, but also with the details of their daily lives.
Well, that’s quite a shift in perspective isn’t it?
Gee, Lawrie says that as though it were a bad thing to have quackery properly described as quackery and pseudoscience on Wikipedia!
It is a shift in perspective, but the shift doesn’t show what Lawrie thinks that it shows. Rather, it shows just how much alternative medicine practitioners dominated Wikipedia entries. Indeed, back in 2004-5, when I first started blogging, one of my biggest complaints about Wikipedia was that cranks and quacks had a lot more time and believers to edit entries like the one on Wikipedia, far outnumbering skeptics, leading to credulous Wikipedia entries just like the one that Lawrie posted. At this point, a shout out to Susan Gerbic and her Guerilla Skepticism on Wikipedia project is obligatory, to express gratitude for working to change that.
Complete with the narrative that homeopathy is being unduly “suppressed,” Lawrie continues, likening this “suppression” and “redefinition” to various narratives about COVID-19:
It continues to amaze me how successfully nefarious influences can redefine how we see the world. We have seen this in technicolour over the past three years, with respected dictionaries redefining words such as ‘vaccine’ to comply with a big pharma narrative, and people described as ‘variant factories’ in a clear attempt to demonise a specific group.
The claim that the word “vaccine” has been somehow “redefined” in order to encompass mRNA-based COVID-19 vaccines is, of course, a favorite conspiracy theory of antivaxxers. Let’s just say that the word “vaccine” was not “redefined,” although the definition was clarified to try to prevent misunderstandings, basically changing a very specific definition of “vaccine” to a more general accepted phrasing of the definition. There was no nefarious intent, but Lawrie, being the conspiracy theorist that she is, imputes nefarious intent.
She then likens that “redefinition” to what she perceives as having happened to homeopathy:
I was reminded of this recently, when I spoke to Dr Philippa Fibert, my next Tess Talks guest. Philippa is a practising homeopath, and also Research Fellow at St Mary’s University, Twickenham here in the UK.
She pointed out to me that the intense scepticism about homeopathy is actually a recent phenomenon. It wasn’t that long ago that homeopathy was fairly mainstream, and is still available on the UK’s National Health Service, albeit in only two locations: the NHS Centre for Integrated Care in Glasgow, and the Royal London Hospital for Integrated Medicine.
The latter used to be called Royal London Homeopathic Hospital; this was where Philippa’s great aunt, Dr Lena Banks, and her great aunt’s partner, Dr Marjorie Blackie, worked. Dr Blackie was the Queen’s Homeopath.
Only someone utterly devoid of knowledge of history can claim that skepticism about homeopathy is a recent phenomenon. Whenever I see that claim, I like to refer to a classic essay entitled Homeopathy and Its Kindred Delusions. The author? Oliver Wendell Holmes. The year? This essay was based on two lectures that he presented to the Boston Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge—in 1842! It is an essay worth reading in its entirety. Other than the lack of knowledge in the 1840s of Avogadro’s number, whose first accurate measurement was at the time of Holmes’ lectures decades in the future and whose magnitude lets us know that in 30C dilutions it is unlikely that even a single molecule of starting substance remains, its devastating critique of homeopathy as pseudoscience is relevant today.
That must be why Lawrie invokes the fantasy of future vindication, which is a favorite of quacks and supporters of quackery everywhere—and writes:
Like many safe, natural alternatives to pharmaceuticals, homeopathy has been under a sustained and calculated attack for some time. But I do believe that is about to change – and Philippa is playing a key role in its rehabilitation as an accepted and respected form of medicine.
So what is Fibert claiming. I think you can predict. Again, as I pointed out, there is no evidence that homeopathy can effectively treat COVID-19—not that homeopaths would ever admit that—and it’s equally improbable to think that homeopathy could be used to treat long COVID. None of this stops Fibert or Lawrie:
Those suffering from Long Covid have been turning to homeopathy – and so Philippa has led a service evaluation project to document the outcomes. The results have shown that people are experiencing improvements with homeopathic treatment so now, Philippa is spearheading a well-designed randomised controlled trial to evidence the outcome of the homeopathic treatment of the symptoms associated with long Covid.
It is not my purpose to discuss all the ins and outs of why homeopathy is quackery and will not be useful for COVID or long COVID. It’s homeopathy, and we at SBM have spilled so much digital ink explaining why homeopathy is quackery that I don’t want to reinvent the wheel here yet again. Rather, what interested me is the inevitable progression we have seen in Tess Lawrie. First, she started out promoting ivermectin for COVID-19, helping an army of quacks cement the narrative that ivermectin is a cheap, safe, and “suppressed” cure for COVID-19 in the public’s mind. Then she decided that COVID-19 wasn’t enough; ivermectin should also be used to treat cancer, because of course she did. Now she has gone beyond ivermectin for COVID or cancer and embraced The One Quackery To Rule Them All, homeopathy.
I will revisit this observation. First, however, who is Philippa Fibert, besides being a homeopath?
How medical academia can promote COVID quackery
At this point, I’m going to shift gears a bit and refer to an article by Matthew Hongoltz-Hetling that appeared in this month’s issue of The New Republic entitled, A Doctor’s War Against the Right-Wing Medical-Freedom Movement, which carries the tagline, “As alternative medicine infiltrates mainstream health care, one physician is fighting back with everything he has.” I’ll come clean right here. The doctor in the article is me, and the article is basically about how alternative medicine quackery has infiltrated medicine over the last couple of decades, laying the groundwork for a lot of what we are seeing now. As the “main character” in the article, I will say that I’m (mostly) happy with the narrative and how I come off. (My quibbles might be a topic for a future post sometime. For example, I get the impression that I come across like the aging gunslinger played by John Wayne in The Shootist, whom all the young guns are looking to knock off and who is on the declining side of his career, which, come to think of it, might not be that inaccurate. I do prefer, however, to look at myself more like G’Kar in Babylon 5 episode The Long Twilight Struggle, if only because G’Kar does ultimately triumph even if he does later die a tragically foretold death. But I digress, as I often do.) What Hongoltz-Hetling gets right is how alternative medicine has infiltrated academic medicine:
Between 1999 and 2017, NCCIH had spent a total of about $2.2 billion “for clinical trials [that] produced no sound, consistent evidence for the efficacy of any alternative therapies,” Dr. Donald Marcus of the Baylor College of Medicine pointed out in a 2020 article in The Journal of Clinical Investigation. The National Library of Medicine lists 49 different NCCIH-funded studies that reference homeopathy; some of the study authors lack medical degrees, and yet have associations with top-tier medical institutions—for instance, Ted Kaptchuk, an acupuncturist who went on to direct an alternative-medicine program at Harvard Medical School; or Gary Schwartz, whose research at the University of Arizona is focused primarily on mediums and energy healing.
The alternative-health industry also influences academia through overt lobbying. And even as it enjoys the financial benefits that come with being embraced by the political right (Americans spent $34 billion on products and services in 2007), it has aggressively wooed the academic circles that are usually dominated by the political left. For example, in 2017, after receiving a $200 million gift from the Henry and Susan Samueli Foundation, the University of California Irvine earmarked funds for up to 15 faculty chairs supporting a curricular focus on integrative health in its College of Health Sciences. Deep-pocketed alternative-medicine groups have also funded partnerships with University of California San Francisco, Harvard Medical School, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Sidney Kimmel Medical College of Thomas Jefferson University, and Vanderbilt University School of Medicine. As of 2017, 15 research medical schools had begun offering alternative medicine to the public, according to Marcus. Johns Hopkins offers Reiki “to transmit Universal Life Energy to the client”; Duke University offers acupuncture for stroke victims.
Why do I mention this—other than wanting to slip in a link to an article in a mainstream magazine about myself, something that has never happened before?—and point out how medical academia has been corrupted by quackery? Simple. Let’s take a look at Philippa Fibert. She is indeed a Research Fellow at St. Mary’s University Twickenham in the Department of Psychology and Pedagogic Science. Interestingly, this department is listed as a department of the Faculty of Sport, Allied Health and Performance Science, which lists itself as offering programs in these areas:
    • Applied Physics
    • Health and Exercise
    • Nutrition
    • Physiotherapy
    • Psychology
    • Sport Rehabilitation
    • Sport Science
    • Sports Coaching
    • Strength and Conditioning
Worse, Fibert describes her history thusly:
I am a Research Fellow with a particular interest in improving long-term outcomes for children, and assessing the effectiveness of non-pharmacological treatments.
I started out working with children with special needs as a teacher, then as a parent educator. I then came across a treatment that seemed to be really helpful for them, however few think it can work apart from those who have experienced it first hand.So, to start untangling the evidence, I embarked on research into this area. I completed a psychology research MSc at Goldsmiths University where I conducted a comparative case series examining the effectiveness of this treatment for children with ADHD. This was partly funded by Turner’s Court Youth trust, an ex borstal supporting crime prevention measures (1:4 prison inmates have had a diagnosis of ADHD).
The treatment is called Homeopathy. The Case Series findings were significant, and in several cases, life changing. Patient stories are available in articles in Green Parent and Autism Now Magazines, case reports in the European Journal of Integrative Medicine, and the full case series in the journal ‘Homeopathy’.
Quelle surprise. She plied her quackery on autistic children and children with ADHD, and Goldsmith University supported this research as part of her degree program. But let’s get to the quackademic medicine that allowed her to test water on children with significant medical conditions:
A pilot randomised controlled pragmatic trial was then conducted at the University of Sheffield to provide more substantial information about the long-term effectiveness of non-pharmacological approaches. It assessed the effectiveness of homeopathy and nutritional therapy. Results suggest that both treatments may be helpful: in particular nutritional therapy for restlessness/inattention, and homeopathy for emotional dysregulation (https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00431-019-03374-z).
I now work at St Mary’s University, Twickenham: within the department of Psychology and Pedagogic Science where we’re running a trial exploring the effects of Kefir on ADHD, sleep and the microbiome; and I teach on the MSc in Chronic Disease Management.
Meanwhile I continue to pursue my research interests in improving health outcomes. A recent study explored the effectiveness of the homeopathic remedy bacillinum for ringworm in rural Africa, and found it better and cheaper than conventional care over the long term. A service evaluation of homeopathic treatment for long COVID suggests that patients feel 47% better after 2 consultations (12 weeks).
Let’s look at her study cited above. Basically, it claims to be a randomized trial of homeopathy and nutritional therapy in ADHD, but it was not blinded, much less double-blinded. Those assessing the subjects after interventions knew which child was in which group. So basically, it was a useless trial, even as a “pilot” trial.
As for bacillinum? I hadn’t heard of this particular homeopathic remedy before, but a quick Google search revealed that it is purported to be made from the sputum of a patient with tuberculosis. I kid you not. It is claimed to be useful for:
Addison’s disease. Alopecia. Consumptiveness Growth, defective. Hydrocephalus. Idiocy. Insanity. Joints, affections of. Phthiriasis. Pityriasis Ringworm. Scrofulous glands. Teeth, defective; pitted. Tuberculosis.
If you ever want more of an indication that homeopathy is quackery, just look at the list of the diseases supposedly treated by a homeopathic remedy claimed to have been made by diluting the sputum of a patient with tuberculosis! Then be thankful that the sputum was diluted to nonexistence and bacillum is basically water, just as I was thankful to learn that Lyssinum, a homeopathic remedy purported to have been made from the sputum of a rabid dog, is also generally diluted to 200C, far beyond nonexistence. Ditto a homeopathic remedy to treat Ebola made from the sputum of Ebola patients. Again, you can’t make stuff like this up. (At least, I can’t.) It makes me wonder why the homeopaths didn’t use diluted SARS-CoV-2 to treat COVID.
Quackademic medicine, COVID, and homeopathy
We at SBM have been writing about quackademic medicine ever since the very beginning of this blog. Although I wish I could claim to have coined the term “quackademic medicine,” unfortunately I can’t. (Dr. R. W. Donnell has that honor.) The point, however, is how before the pandemic quackery had so thoroughly infiltrated itself into medical academia that even “hard core” academic medical centers, like Duke, Stanford, the Cleveland Clinic and even my alma mater, the University of Michigan, have embraced quackery, to the point where U. of M., for instance, has a naturopath in a high-ranking faculty position in its Department of Family Medicine who promotes homeopathy there.
Across the pond, Philippa Fibert is fundraising £40,000 to do a “pilot RCT” of homeopathy for long COVID. with this preliminary data:
Dr. Fibert told HINT: “This trial provides an excellent opportunity to develop much-needed evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy at a time when other healthcare providers are struggling to develop effective protocols for the treatment of Long-COVID.
“In a prelude to the pilot RCT, we have already been collecting the MYMOPs (Measure Your Own Medical Outcome Profile) of Long-COVID patients and found a 36% improvement after just one consultation. After their second consultation the improvement climbed to 48%.”
We hope this project will put homeopathy front and centre as the medicine of choice for the symptoms associated with Long-COVID. You can be part of this ground breaking project by helping us raise the funding needed.
We have the enthusiasm, now all we need is £40,000 and with your help we know we can do it!
There’s nothing like subjective outcome measures in a survey as “evidence” that magic water helps a poorly understood condition that often has vague symptoms and whose diagnostic criteria aren’t fully solidified yet to guarantee that placebo effects will provide a seemingly positive outcome to justify raising money for a pointless RCT. Let me remind you what the remedies used in the “preliminary trial” were:

Basically, it’s just a grab bag of common homeopathic remedies, including the quite rightly mocked Oscillococcinum®, which includes extract of duck liver and heart. Basically, it’s a “throw everything but the kitchen sink” approach to COVID-19, if that everything is the water in the kitchen sink without the actual, you know, kitchen sink.
I argued in Matt Hongoltz-Hetling’s piece that quackademic medicine is both a cause and symptom of what led so many doctors to embrace COVID quackery, antimask stances, and antivax beliefs. Certainly, homeopaths in universities and medical schools doesn’t help. It should thus be no surprise that people like Philippa Fibert exist and are now promoting homeopathy for long COVID, after having promoted it for so many other conditions.
Unfortunately, this example of Tess Lawrie expanding her quackery suggests two things that seem new but are not. First, once a doc starts down the dark path of quackery, forever will it dominate her destiny. Consume her it will (with only rare exceptions). This has clearly happened to Lawrie, who started out embracing the then “sort of” quackery of ivermectin, which is now COVID quackery because the evidence clearly shows that it does not work, and then progressed to embracing ivermectin quackery for more diseases (like cancer), and then ran headlong into the arms of The One Quackery To Rule Them All. It is incredibly likely that there is any coming back from this for her. The question is: Is there any coming back from this, period?

Release Active Drugs – Homeopathy By Another Name
A Russian company is marketing “release active drugs” as a new medical technology, but it is just bogus homeopathy dressed up with new jargon.
Steven Novella on December 12, 2018
Link

There is a system in place to protect patients and health consumers from fraudulent, worthless, harmful, or misleading medical treatments or products. Most people agree that there should effective protections, and in fact they assume that there are. But there is also quite a bit of money to be made selling healthcare products and services, which creates a massive incentive to bypass these regulations. That is basically what the alternative medicine movement is – an attempt to bypass standards of regulation and create a narrative to convince the public this is a good idea.
One of the methods for protecting consumers is to have a science-based standard – drugs, for example, need to provide adequate scientific evidence of safety and efficacy prior to being allowed on the market. Scientific research, therefore, provides one portal of entry for snake oil into the system of regulated health product. I recently came across an excellent example of this – “release active drugs”. This is an attempt at taking homeopathy, which is well-established as completely ineffective, and dressing it up with new pseudoscientific jargon.
I was actually first made aware of this phenomenon by Alexander Panchin, who is the co-author of a new BMJ article exposing so-called “release active drugs” or RAD. He is also a member of the Commission on pseudoscience and research fraud of the Russian Academy of Sciences. They are doing good work in trying to root out pseudoscience from the sciences in Russia (including homeopathy!), and is a good model that should be replicated in every country (are you paying attention, AAAS?).
The article lays out how the company that manufactures RADs are gaming the system. These dubious products are manufactured by a single Russian company called OOO ‘NPF ‘Materia Medica Holding’ (MMH). The company has tried to flood journals with articles showing efficacy for various RADs, but they are almost all co-authored by a single person, Oleg Epstein, who is the founder of MMH. This, of course, is a huge red flag.
Here is one study found on PubMed. This is a typical study used to generate the appearance of an effect for a bogus product, with poor methodology, and just reeking of p-hacking. The authors, including Epstein, argue that the results show a RAD of diclofenac makes diclofenac more effective, but the results don’t really show this, and are barely significant across the board – a red flag for p-hacking. In any case, without independent replication by researchers with no connection or interest in MMH, none of these results should be taken seriously.
They should also not be taken serious because RADs are essentially magic – they are “ultrahigh” dilutions of antibodies or drugs to the point that no active ingredients remain. In other words – this is just homeopathy dressed up with new technobabble jargon. The authors of the BMJ article report:
This is another misleading way to say that the pill contains no molecules of the active substance. Simple calculations show that only one molecule of antibodies is expected in ~100 million anaferon pills. From personal communications, we are aware of patients who knew about the scientific criticism of homeopathy and wanted to avoid any alternative medicine but were still tricked by the misleading descriptions of release-active products, which are sold over-the-counter in multiple countries.
Also
Russian regulators initially registered at least two RADs, anaferon and impaza, as homeopathic, but later, in 2009, the word ‘homeopathic’ disappeared from their descriptions, while the concentration of active ingredients did not increase.
This draws a pretty clear picture. The reputation of homeopathy is on the wane, in the wake of multiple reviews showing convincingly that no homeopathic product works for anything. Further, word is getting out (although not yet enough) of what homeopathy actually is. There is still a great deal of confusion, with many people thinking that homeopathy is herbalism or natural medicine. When most people learn that homeopathy is magic water, they correctly conclude that it is worthless. In fact, our campaign against homeopathy has largely consisted of just educating the public about what it actually is.
The strategy of RAD is just to repackage homeopathy to disguise what it is. They are further exploiting weaknesses in the system of scientific journals, with inadequate review allowing bogus studies to slip through. RAD is already a multi-million dollar international market, and they hope to break into the US and other Western markets. It is critical to raise awareness of what RAD is, that it is just homeopathy and not real medicine, in order to forestall its deceptive marketing. It should, at the very least, be properly labeled as homeopathic.
Of course – homeopathy is a complete scam and should be outright banned as fraudulent. The FDA and FTC have tightened their regulations of homeopathy, but have been unable or unwilling to completely eradicate this parasitic market. We need to keep the pressure on, continue to raise public awareness, and create the political will to finally rid ourselves of this harmful pseudoscience.
Meanwhile, we have to make sure that companies like MMH don’t just rebrand the same nonsense and start the cycle all over again.

Continued Battle over Homeopathy
Steven Novella on December 23, 2015
Tweet

The battle to rid modern scientific societies from the blatant and harmful pseudoscience of homeopathy continues. This past year has been overall a good one – in the US both the FDA and FTC decided to review their regulation of homeopathy. They have gathered their testimony and are now apparently reviewing everything. Their decisions on this topic are eagerly anticipated and could decide the fate of homeopathy for the next one or more generations.
Some success
In the UK the situation is also very positive. Their national health service is considering blacklisting homeopathy so that general practitioners cannot prescribe homeopathic products.
Success in the UK is largely due to The Good Thinking Society, founded by Simon Singh. They have been tirelessly campaigning against NHS coverage of homeopathy and are making steady progress. They are demonstrating that skeptical activism can be effective.
Likewise, SBM and the Society for SBM are having an impact in the US, mainly through persistent persuasive writing and being available as a resource to politicians, the press, and regulators. Members have personally consulted with the FDA, FTC, and staff of senators interested in the issue.
Overall we seem to be building momentum against homeopathy, but this backlash is primarily fueled by scientific evidence. I recall 20 years ago, when the push to research so-called alternative medicine was really starting. My attitude at the time was that it would all be a monumental waste of resources and serve only to promote CAM, but at the same time proponents should be careful what they wish for. Rigorous research into magical treatments that don’t work is extremely likely to have one outcome, and that is exactly what happened.
The picture is more complex as there is a great deal of not-so-rigorous research muddying the waters. Scientists, however, know how to look at a large body of research and discern what it says.
In the case of homeopathy, whenever objective scientific bodies look at the totality of research into homeopathy, they all come to the same conclusion – it does not work. Most recently, the Australian Government National Health and Medical Research Council reviewed the evidence and concluded:
The available evidence is not compelling and fails to demonstrate that homeopathy is an effective treatment for any of the reported clinical conditions in humans.
Consumer Reports has even reviewed the evidence and concluded that homeopathic products do not work and their labeling and placement in pharmacies can cause consumer confusion.
Response of homeopaths
Homeopaths, of course, are not taking this lying down. Their responses, however, are very telling, and betray their intellectual dishonesty. For example, Dr. Helen Beaumont, a UK GP and the president of the Faculty of Homeopathy, told the BBC:
Patient choice is important; homeopathy works, it’s widely used by doctors in Europe, and patients who are treated by homeopathy are really convinced of its benefits, as am I.
This is typical – an appeal to popularity, a naked assertion that it works despite the negative evidence, an appeal to freedom of choice, and an appeal to personal belief. It is difficult to pack more logical fallacies into one brief statement.
They defend their assertions, when they choose to reference research at all, by cherry picking:
In an email to Consumer Reports, Alissa Gould, a spokeswoman for the American Association of Homeopathic Pharmacists, cites a “significant body of evidence that supports the effectiveness of homeopathy,” including a large 2011 report by German researchers.
There is no “significant body of evidence” that supports homeopathy. There is a significant body of evidence that shows it does not work. In order to come to the opposite conclusion you have to ignore systematic reviews, ignore scientific rigor, ignore common sense even, and select only the poorly done studies that support your bias.
Conclusion: Homeopathy cannot work and does not work
The science regarding homeopathy is absolutely clear – it cannot work and it does not work. Homeopathic products are nothing but expensive placebos. Yet consumers continue to spend billions of dollars on these worthless products, threatening their health.
The only rational response is for regulation to properly reflect this science. The FTC should not allow homeopathic products to make unsupported medical claims. The FDA should do their job and regulate homeopathy as drugs, since they are classified as drugs. All they have to do is require evidence of efficacy, and the US homeopathic market would evaporate.
The UK should ban the prescription of homeopathic products and close remaining homeopathic hospitals. Other countries as well should remove any government support for homeopathy, and properly regulate their marketing.
Anything less is malfeasance. It is an injustice to consumers, and an affront to science and basic common sense.
Homeopaths can go down kicking and screaming, but they are on the wrong side of science, and hopefully soon will be on the wrong side of history.

No, sugar pills won’t repel insects, and other consequences of regulating nonsense
Scott Gavura on June 21, 2012
Link
As a group blog, Science-Based Medicine brings a variety of perspectives to issues of science in medicine. However we align around a few core principles which define what science-based medicine is, and how it should be practiced. One principle we emphasize is the importance of subjecting the evaluation of all health interventions and treatments to a single, science-based standard. One of the biggest successes of the alternative medicine industry, worldwide, has been the embedding of different regulatory standards for the evaluation and approval of so-called “non-drug” products such as supplements, herbal products, and non-scientific treatment systems like homeopathy or traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). The implications cannot be overstated: this different and lower standard is now so firmly entrenched in most health systems that few seem to question its rationale, or consider the consequences. As a practicing pharmacist I spent the first decade of my career working within this regulatory framework without ever stepping back to question why we regulate some products differently. I started reading, took the red pill, and here I am today.
As a Canadian, one of perspectives I hope that I can bring to the blog is the opportunity to compare how different countries address similar health challenges. While the FDA and Health Canada share similar drug approval processes, they differ dramatically in their approach to homeopathy. The American Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA) is an amendment to the U.S. Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act that establishes a regulatory framework for dietary supplements. Given the criticism of DSHEA that is regularly dished out by SBM bloggers, I assumed that it also applied to homeopathy. I was wrong. The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) points out,
Homeopathic remedies are regulated as drugs under the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act (FDCA). However, under current Agency policy, FDA does not evaluate the remedies for safety or effectiveness. FDA enforcement policies for homeopathic drugs are described in FDA’s Compliance Policy Guide entitled Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs May be Marketed (CPG 7132.15).
FDA allows homeopathic remedies that meet certain conditions to be marketed without agency preapproval. For example, homeopathic remedies must contain active ingredients that are listed in the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS). The HPUS lists active ingredients that may be legally included in homeopathic products and standards for strength, quality, and purity of that ingredient. In addition, the FDA requires that the label on the product, outer container, or accompanying leaflet include at least one major indication (i.e., medical problem to be treated), a list of ingredients, the number of times the active ingredient was diluted, and directions for use. If a homeopathic remedy claims to treat a serious disease such as cancer, it must be sold by prescription. Only products for minor health problems, like a cold or headache, which go away on their own, can be sold without a prescription.
What NCCAM doesn’t mention is that homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, where the “remedies” lack active ingredients. As would be expected with inert products, clinical trials confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. Yet these placebos, because they’re labelled “homeopathy” are regulated as drugs. Amazingly, the the regulations delineate some homeopathy products as “prescription” and some as “non-prescription” based on what they’re being used for — not based on what they contain. Which is odd, because homeopathic remedies are chemically and therapeutically indistinguishably – they are inert.
Nonsensical? Yes. But that’s homeopathy. To the FDA’s credit, they don’t waste resources reviewing products before they’re sold, and they explicitly don’t vouch for safety and effectiveness. Now let me introduce you to Health Canada’s Natural Health Products Directorate.
The Natural Health Product regulations, under Canada’s Food and Drugs Act, regulate homeopathic products as well as many of the products Americans regulate under DSHEA: nutritional supplements, probiotics, traditional Chinese medicine, vitamins, and herbal remedies. They are a deliberate shadow of the regulations that govern drug products — requiring some manufacturing quality and safety standards, while effectively removing the standards for product efficacy claims. Yet Health Canada insists that this doesn’t compromise quality, safety, or efficacy:
Through the Natural Health Products Directorate, Health Canada ensures that all Canadians have ready access to natural health products that are safe, effective and of high quality, while respecting freedom of choice and philosophical and cultural diversity.
The consequence? Regulation of the absurd. Health Canada reviews every remedy, and explicitly attests their safety and effectiveness. In Canada you can purchase Health Canada approved (Search each product by number here):
    • homeopathic sea water — DIN-HM 80017767
    • homeopathic insulin — DIN-HM 80016480
    • homeopathic granite — DIN-HM 80012752
    • homeopathic roasted sponge “Spongia Tosta” — DIN-HM 80011377
    • homeopathic chloroform DIN-HM 80010524
    • homeopathic table salt DIN-HM 80005389
There are hundreds more, including more well known products like Oscillococcinum and Traumeel, all deemed safe and effective.
It’s easy to laugh at the irony of homeopathic water, and the while the sale of these products is certainly unethical, when used for self-limiting conditions, the risk of harm may be slight. But a framework that gives even a veneer of credibility to sugar pills increases the perception that homeopathy has legitimate medical uses. We’ve seen this worldwide with homeopaths descending on Haiti or treating HIV in Africa, illustrating that proponents lack any insight into the lack of objective effects. More recently, the government of Madhya Pradesh, a state in India, announced a plan to use homeopathy to prevent malaria outbreaks. When homeopathy is used as a substitute for real medical treatments, the risk of harms are real, not theoretical. So I was concerned to to see the following in the Calgary Herald:
A Calgary business that aims to bring traditional homeopathic remedies to the mainstream public has received Health Canada approval for its first locally developed product. Mozi-Q is a natural mosquito repellent created by Calgary-based Xerion Dispensary. The product, made from a plant-derived substance called staphysagria, is taken orally and is advertised not only as a bug repellent, but as a product that will also lessen the stinging and itching associated with insect bites.
which also noted
All natural health products — including homeopathic remedies — sold in Canada are subject to the Natural Health Products Regulations, which came into force on Jan. 1, 2004. Only after Health Canada has assessed a product and decided it is safe, effective and of high quality, will a product be approved.
Effective. There it is. Yes, homeopathic insect repellent, approved by Health Canada with licence number 80031902, with the following “Recommended Use or Purpose”:
Homeopathic rememdy [sic] used for reducing the severity and frequency of insect bites.
And what’s in this product? Like most homeopathy, the labeling obscures the actual lack of ingredients. I converted the homeopathic labeling to English, and looked for evidence to support any of the ingredients – diluted or otherwise.
    • “cedron 4C:” This is Simaruba Ferroginea, commonly called Rattlesnake Bean in a 10−8 dilution (i.e., 0.000001%) — This product is related to the pinto bean. It is likely nontoxic, especially at this dilution.
    • “grindelia 6C”: Grindelia Robusta or Gumweed in a 10−12 dilution (i.e., 0.0000000001%) — This ingredient is considered “Possibly Safe” at non-homeopathic doses by the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database
    • “ledum palustre 3X” : Marsh Tea in a 10−3 dilution (i.e., 0.1%) — This ingredient is considered “Likely Unsafe” at non-homeopathic doses by the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, causing kidney and urinary tract damage as well as central nervous system excitation.
    • “staphysagria 4X”: Delphinium staphisagria or Stavesacre in 10−4 dilution (i.e., 0.01%) — This ingredient is considered “Likely Unsafe” at non-homeopathic doses by the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, as it is poisonous.
    • “urtica urens 6X” : Stinging nettle in a 10−6 dilution (i.e., 0.0001%) — This ingredient is considered “Possibly Safe” at non-homeopathic doses by the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database.
Interestingly, some of the ingredients aren’t diluted past the “12C” level, the point at which Avogadro’s constant establishes that there isn’t likely to be a single molecule of the original ingredient. The 3X dilution of Marsh Tea is only a 1:1000 dilution, which depending on the original preparation, could deliver detectable traces of the source plant. Should we be concerned? The amount is so minute that it’s unlikely to have any meaningful effects, toxic or otherwise. But does it work? Not surprisingly there is no published evidence suggesting that any component of Mozi-Q, either alone or in combination, have any effect on either reducing the frequency of insect bites” or “reducing the severity of insect bites”. The manufacturer states the following:
Has it been studied?In the ’60s a homeopath by the name of HR. Trexler studied Staphysagria for its effectiveness at preventing mosquito bites. In a study of 421 subjects over a 4 year period, he found this remedy to be 90% effective.
Tried and True!We have tested this remedy in our clinic over four mosquito seasons and found the response from the public confirmatory of Trexler’s findings.
And that’s the sum total of the evidence — which appeared to be adequate for Health Canada, who granted the “safe and effective” imprimatur of legitimacy. A published report from Trexler does date back to 1965, and it’s not available. There are no other published reports with the product. I did find Trexler’s US patent registration from 1956 claiming that staphsagria is an effective insect repellent. No evidence of a formal evaluation is described. A patent, of course, doesn’t establish efficacy. Given the totality of evidence, has failed to show that homeopathy has any meaningful clinical effects, I am skeptical that a homeopath identified an effective homeopathic oral insect repellent in 1956, and subjected it to a rigorous evaluation in the 1960’s. In any case, it would be easy to prove if it does work – it could be evaluated like every other insect repellent on the market.
How Real Insect Repellents work
For many of us, insect bites are an occasional annoyance that we can largely avoid. Yet insects can transmit over 100 diseases, including malaria, West Nile virus, yellow fever, Dengue fever, Lyme disease and even plague. Malaria alone kills 1.2 million people, mainly African children, annually. And now that we have West Nile and Lyme disease throughout North America, there is a bigger impetus to minimize bites. Given the importance of repelling insects effectively, validated methods have been created to test new products.
While it’s not definitively established what attracts insects to bite, carbon dioxide and lactic acid from our skin and breath seem to act as attractants. In light of this, it’s not surprising that no oral product has ever been demonstrated to effectively work as an insect repellent. What does work, beyond physical barriers, are chemical products that we apply to our skin. The most common ingredient in repellents is N, N- diethyl-3-methylbenzamide, more commonly known as DEET, although there are several other chemicals that have been approved for use in consumer products.
How do you know if an insect repellent works? You offer your forearm up as a meal. Consumer Reports illustrates the testing nicely. The US Environmental Protection Agency specifies these testing requirements in detail. Its approval outlines the duration of effectiveness as well as detailed descriptions of the efficacy and safety evaluations. In Canada, similar regulation rests with the Pest Management Regulatory Agency. When I asked the PMRA by email how a homeopathic remedy could be possibly be approved as an insect repellent, they replied with the following:
Please be advised that, according to the Pest Control Products Regulations (PCPR), pest control products that are used for the control of arthropods on or in humans or animals can be exempted from the Pest Control Products Act (PCPA), and made subject to the Food and Drugs Act (FDA), if the control product is to be administered directly and not by topical application. If the action of the product is not due to the simple presence of the active ingredient on the skin (the intent of topical application under the PCPA) but rather that the active ingredient has to be absorbed first before it can exert its effect, this is not considered to be a topical mode of action. This would be the case for mosquito repellent patch products. Even though the patch is to be applied to the surface of the skin, the PMRA does not register any pesticide that’s to be taken orally. Based on this systemic mode of action, as per a previous agreement between PMRA and Health Products and Food Branch (HPFB), the type of product you describe in your email would fall under the jurisdiction of HPFB.
Is there a facepalm emoticon? There is no “systemic mode of action” that has been demonstrated for homeopathy. There is no evidence that any oral products are effective as insect repellents. In the US, a product like Mozi-Q which lacks evidence of efficacy would not likely be permitted, (homeopathy or not) as there is a federal regulation on oral insect repellents in place, which notes:
Labeling claims for OTC orally administered insect repellent drug products are either false, misleading, or unsupported by scientific data.
Any OTC drug product that is labeled, represented, or promoted for oral use as an insect repellent is regarded as a new drug within the meaning of section 201(p) of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act for which an approved new drug application under section 505 of the act and part 314 of this chapter is required for marketing. In the absence of an approved new drug application, such product is also misbranded under section 502 of the act.
Clinical investigations designed to obtain evidence that any drug product labeled, represented, or promoted OTC for oral use as an insect repellent is safe and effective for the purpose intended must comply with the requirements and procedures governing the use of investigational new drugs set forth in part 312 of this chapter.
Yet these products are being deliberately exempted from testing in Canada, and Health Canada is approving them in the absence of any good evidence.
Conclusion
When a regulator clears away scientific barriers to product approvals, we should not be surprised by what emerges. Homeopathic insect repellent that is deemed “safe and effective” illustrates the consequences of regulating nonsense. Consumers who rely on regulators to test and approve products don’t care how a product is licensed – they want assurance that it works. Because while insect bites can be a nuisance, they can also be deadly. Who will be responsible if a consumer contracts a insect-borne disease if they use homeopathy instead of proven insect repellents: The manufacturer, or the regulator? In the absence of effective regulation, the science in this case is very clear: if you want to reduce your risk of insect bites and their consequences, use real insect repellents — not homeopathy.

False Balance for Homeopathy in the BMJ
Steven Novella on July 15, 2015
Link
The BMJ is a prestigious medical journal, which just goes to show that prestigious journals can sometimes make awful decisions. They recently published a pro vs con article on homeopathy. Peter Fisher dragged out the current repertoire of pro-homeopathy tropes, while Edzard Ernst did a fine job of summarizing why homeopathy is nonsense.
I also think the article is an excellent example of the difference between evidence-based medicine and science-based medicine. While EBM is led by a misguided notion of “scientific equipoise” or fairness, SBM endeavors to use all scientific knowledge to make the best judgments we can about treatments.
An SBM approach to homeopathy leads only to scathing condemnation, because it is among the purest of pseudosciences.
Ineffective treatments call for desperate measures
Fisher tries desperately to rescue the 200 year old pre-scientific notions of homeopathy, but only reveals the intellectual bankruptcy of that profession. He writes:
Homeopathy is part of a family of toxicological and pharmacological phenomena that are attracting growing interest, characterised by secondary, reverse, or paradoxical reactions to drugs or toxins as a function of dose or time or both. These include hormesis (the paradoxical, stimulatory, or beneficial effect of low doses of toxins), paradoxical pharmacology, and rebound effects.
No, it isn’t. Putting aside the legitimacy of hormesis and the question of whether or not this is clinically significant, these results depend on molecules of active ingredient doing something physiological in the body. Homeopathic potions cannot operate this way – therefore this is a false analogy.
As Ernst points out, most homeopathic preparations are diluted to the point that they do not contain any active ingredients. They are pure water.
Fisher has to further rescue his false analogy by claiming:
…basic physical research shows that the homeopathic manufacturing process changes the structure of the diluent, including the formation of nanoparticles of silica and gas.
He is playing the game of using one dubious science to support another dubious science. The existence of nanoparticles has not been established. He can only refer to a few preliminary studies of dubious quality without adequate independent replication to show that the phenomenon is real. These are the N-rays of homeopathy.
Further, there is no evidence that these dubious nanoparticles can be biologically active.
Further still, as I have pointed out before, transient anomalous phenomena of water are not a plausible explanation for a homeopathic potion. For this to be true, these miraculous nanoparticles would have to have amazing specificity – if they are to encode all of the various types of specific properties required for all the various claimed homeopathic products to work.
But even worse, they would have to maintain their properties even when placed on a sugar pill, stored in a bottle, then consumed, digested in the stomach, absorbed through the intestines, and travel through the liver and through the blood to whatever their destination is.
So, we have a questionable phenomenon (nanoparticles) that probably don’t exist that would have to have fantastical properties that defy sober speculation about how they could possibly work – and Fisher think this provides a plausible mechanism for homeopathy.
Homeopathy is magic with good PR
Let us also consider the principle of like-cures-like, which results in many fanciful starting ingredients to be diluted out of existence. There is no plausible connection between duck liver and the flu. The fact that a substance causes certain symptoms has no plausible connection to an unrelated disease process that causes superficially similar symptoms, while accounting for the patient’s personality.
This principle of homeopathy is as magical and completely devoid of evidence as astrology.
Clinical deceptions
Fisher then moves onto the clinical evidence, which he butchers. What he reveals is the astonishingly low threshold of evidence that true-believers use to support their wild theories.
In order for scientific evidence to establish convincingly that a new natural phenomenon exists we need repeatable results with a reasonable signal-to-noise ratio with adequately rigorous study design. We never get this with homeopathy.
What we get are positive results from poorly designed studies, or results that can only be produced by a particular lab, or razor thin effect sizes that look suspiciously like p-hacking – but never anything convincing.
There is a very simple and elegant explanation for this – homeopathy is bunk.
Fisher and other homeopaths, however, want to use low grade clinical evidence, like “comparative effectiveness research,” which is not controlled and not designed to test efficacy.
In essence they have built a house of cards of the weakest and worst forms of evidence possible in order to support an incredibly fantastical claim.
What are the odds that a crank physician from 200 years ago hit upon so many revolutionary ideas simultaneously, shaking the very foundations of our scientific understanding of physics, chemistry and biology, and that validation of these revolutionary ideas can only be acquired by the weakest forms of evidence, most easy to manipulate, and if you squint just right in the proper light?
It seems far more likely that homeopathy is just water, and people have a tendency to be fooled by placebo effects – something which is already very well established.
Conclusion: BMJ should be ashamed
The BMJ frankly should be ashamed of themselves. The only proper response of the scientific community to homeopathy is ridicule and outrage. It is outrageous that anyone takes homeopathy seriously. The scientific community should be united in condemning this pernicious form of pseudoscience and trying to rid humanity of this nonsense once and for all.
Giving a forum to a homeopathy apologist like Fisher, as if there is something legitimate to debate, is harmful. It legitimizes pseudoscience.

cientific American Declares Homeopathy Indispensable to Planet and Human Health
Harriet Hall on April 3, 2012
Link
I recently received an e-mail from one of SBM’s readers in Brazil, Felipe Nogueira Barbara de Oliveira, a PhD candidate in Medical Science who holds an MS in Computer Science and is who is trying to promote critical thinking and scientific medicine in his country. He sent me a jpeg copy of a short piece that was published (in Portuguese) in the April, 2012 issue of Scientific American Brasil. He was appalled that this appeared under the aegis of Scientific American, and so was I. He provided the translation which follows.
Warning: this is painful.
The Questioned Effectiveness of Homeopathy
Application of this technique in agriculture shows recuperation of plants and environment.
Homeopathy is known as an alternative treatment for human beings, but few people know about its utilization on animals, plants, soils, and water. This technique is the target of critiques regarding results and efficacy. One of them is about the “placebo effect” of its remedies, which do not contain any trace of the raw material used in its preparation. To answer this criticism, a clarification is necessary: homeopathy is not related to chemistry, but to quantum physics, because it works with energy, not with chemical compounds that can be qualified and quantified.
The application of homeopathy techniques to agriculture is not recent, as most people might think. One of the first studies in this field dates back to the 20s, with the research on plants carried out by the couple Eugen and Lili Kolisko, based on the theories of Rudolf Steiner about biodynamic agriculture. Since then a lot of studies have been done in countries like France, India, Germany, Switzerland, Mexico, Cuba, Italy, South Africa, and Brazil. Here the Federal University of Viçosa, in Minas Gerais, is a pioneer in this field.
One needn’t be a health or environment specialist to realize that the conventional methods of treating agricultural pests and diseases produce a disequilibrium in the ecosystem and, consequently, in human beings. Pathogenic agents and pests acquire, over time, resistance to pesticides (which, by market strategy, have come to be called “agricultural defenses”). Therefore, the quantity and aggressiveness of these chemical products must be increased to overcome this situation, causing a disastrous cascade effect: the soil becomes poorer and its yield is diminished; rural workers get severely sick by constantly handling these toxic products; water supplies, including underground ones, are contaminated; and the people who depend on agricultural products get all this exposure to poison, triggering a series of health problems.
With the exception of the pesticide and chemical fertilizer industries, who else benefits from the practice of these conventional treatments?
If Hippocrates could reassess his principle of opposites, represented by allopathy, in view of its later consequences on living beings and the environment, he would remove it from his considerations. Today, homeopathy as a sustainable technique, economically viable, and ecologically correct, has become indispensable to the equilibrium of the planet and to the health of all beings that live in it.
Author: Nina Ximenes, a biologist and postgraduate environmental education student.
This is so bad, I hardly know where to start. Homeopathy is nothing but an elaborate system for delivering placebos. It is based on magical thinking. Basic science tells us it can’t possibly work as claimed (with water remembering a substance that is no longer present and with more dilute solutions producing stronger effects). And there is no credible evidence that it has any objective therapeutic effect on humans, much less on animals, plants, soils and water. It has nothing to do with quantum physics: quantum effects are only important at the atomic and subatomic scales, and couldn’t explain homeopathy’s claim that the water “remembers” the original substance, much less explain how that memory could affect health. The claim that homeopathy “works with energy” is just imagination, not substantiated by any evidence.
Rudolph Steiner was a philosopher who founded the spiritual movement called anthroposophy. His “science” is so-called “spiritual science.” Anthroposophical medicine and biodynamic agriculture are two branches of his “science” that are still popular in some spheres but that have been accurately characterized as pseudoscience by real scientists. If you want to know more about anthroposophical medicine, you can read what Dr. Gorski wrote about it last year here.
The author uses inflammatory language to make extravagant claims of harm from pesticides and fertilizers, with no attempt to provide any context or supporting evidence. She uses the term “allopathy,” a meaningless pejorative word invented by Hahnemann, the founder of homeopathy, to disparage his mainstream rivals. She refers to Hippocrates’ “principle of opposites,” a distortion and over-simplification of his ideas. Hippocrates was a smart guy, and I like to think if he were alive today he would have rejected the old “four humor” theory and homeopathy alike, and would have adopted scientific medicine wholeheartedly. She asks “who else benefits” from conventional agricultural practices. I would argue that there are benefits to people who might have starved from food shortages if fertilizers and pesticides had not worked to increase the availability of food. That’s not to say current practices shouldn’t be improved and made safer, but discarding them wholesale and replacing them with homeopathy is hardly the answer!
I wondered if this might be some kind of satire, but I think not. It is on a page with the heading “Advances” and is labeled “Health.” Is she pulling our leg, or can she possibly really believe homeopathy has “become indispensable to the equilibrium of the planet and to the health of all beings that live in it”? Perhaps she is talking about some other planet in a parallel universe, or in her dreams. If Alice’s White Queen tried to practice believing this before breakfast, her brain might explode.
If this is what passes for science in Brazil, Brazil is in trouble. Apparently things haven’t changed very much since Richard Feynman had his disappointing encounter with the Brazilian educational system. Of course it really isn’t fair to single out Brazil, because the same things happen in other countries.
If this is what passes for science in Scientific American, the magazine is a reprehensible travesty and should strike the word “scientific” from its title. What were the editors thinking when they foisted this kind of rubbish on their readers? For shame!
Note: Thanks to Felipe Nogueira Barbara de Oliveira for bringing this to my attention and for providing the English translation of Ximenes’ article. He also provided a Portuguese translation of this blog post and suggested that I include it for the convenience of his compatriots. Here it is:
Portuguese Version of the Above
Recentemente recebi um email de um dos leitores do SBM no Brasil, Felipe Nogueira Barbara de Oliveira, um aluno de Doutorado em Ciências Médicas e que possui Mestrado em Ciência da Computação e está tentando promover pensamento crítico e medicina científica no seu país. Ele me enviou uma cópia em .jpg de uma pequena matéria publicada na edição de Abril de 2012 da Scientific American Brasil. Ele ficou horrorizado que isso apareceu sob a alcunha da Scientific American, e eu também. A matéria é a seguinte.
Aviso: isto é doloroso.
Eficiência Questionada da Homeopatia
Aplicação dessa técnica à agricultura acena com recuperação de plantas e ambiente
A homeopatia é conhecida como tratamento alternativo para os seres humanos, mas poucos conhecem sua utilização em animais, plantas, solos e água. Essa técnica é alvo de críticas quanto aos resultados e eficácia. Uma delas diz respeito ao “efeito placebo” de seus remédios, que não contém nenhum traço da matéria-prima utilizada em sua confecção. Para responder a essa abordagem é necessário um esclarecimento: a homeopatia não se relaciona com a química, mas com a física quântica, pois trabalha com energia, não com elementos químicos que podem ser qualificados e quantificados.
A aplicação da técnica homeopática à agricultura não é recente, como a maioria das pessoas podem considerar. Um dos primeiros estudos feitos nessa área remonta à década de 20, com pesquisas em plantas realizadas pelo casal Eugen e Lili Kolisko, baseadas nas teorias de Rudolf Steiner para agricultura biodinâmica. Desde então muitas pesquisas tem sido feitas em países como Franca, Índia, Alemanha, Suíça, Inglaterra, México, Cuba, Itália, África do Sul e Brasil. Aqui a Universidade Federal de Viçosa, em Minas Gerais, é pioneira nessa área.
Não é preciso ser especialista em saúde ou em meio ambiente para perceber que o método convencional de tratamento de pragas e enfermidades na agricultura gera um desequilíbrio no ecossistema e, consequentemente, no ser humano. Agentes patogênicos e pragas vão adquirindo, com o tempo, resistência aos agrotóxicos – que, por estratégia de mercado, passaram a ser chamados de “defensores agrícolas”. Assim, a quantidade e a agressividade desses produtos químicos tem ser aumentadas para contornar essa situação, provocando um efeito cascata desastroso: o solo se torna mais pobre e diminui sua produção; trabalhadores rurais ficam gravemente doentes pelo manuseio constante desses produtos tóxicos; as águas, incluindo as subterrâneas, são contaminadas; e os seres que dependem dos frutos da terra recebem toda essa carga de veneno, desencadeando uma série de problemas de saúde.
Com exceção das indústrias de agrotóxico e fertilizantes químicos, quem mais se beneficia com a prática desses tratamentos convencionais?
Se Hipócrates pudesse reavaliar o seu principio dos contrários, representado pela alopatia, e suas posteriores conseqüências nos seres vivos e no meio ambiente, ele o excluiria suas considerações. Já a homeopatia como técnica sustentável, economicamente viável e ecologicamente correta torna-se imprescindível ao equilíbrio do planeta e à saúde de todos os seres que nele vivem.
Autora: Nina Ximenes, bióloga, é pós-graduada em educação ambiental.
É tão ruim que não sei nem por onde começar. Homeopatia não é nada mais que um sistema elaborado de distribuição de placebos. É baseado em pensamento mágico. Ciência básica nos garante que a homeopatia não pode funcionar como afirma (com água lembrando uma substância que não está mais presente e com soluções mais diluídas produzindo efeitos maiores).
E não há evidência confiável que possui algum efeito terapêutico em humanos, muito menos em animais, plantas, solos e água. Não tem nada a ver com física quântica: efeitos quânticos são significativos apenas nas escalas atômica e subatômica, e não explicam a afirmação da homeopatia que a água “lembra” a substância original, muito menos como essa memória poderia afetar a saúde. A afirmação que a homeopatia “trabalha com energia” é apenas imaginação, não demonstrada por evidências.
Rudolph Steiner foi um filósofo que criou o movimento espiritual chamado antroposofia. A ciência de Steiner é a tão chamada “ciência espiritual.” Medicina antroposófica e agricultura biodinâmica são dois ramos da “ciência” de Steiner que ainda são populares em alguns círculos, mas que foram perfeitamente caracterizados como pseudociência por verdadeiros cientistas. Se quiser saber mais sobre medicina antroposófica, você pode ler o que Dr. Gorski escreveu (em inglês) sobre isso aqui.
A autora usa uma linguagem inflamatória para fazer extravagantes afirmações de danos de pesticidas e fertilizantes, sem nenhuma tentativa de prover alguma evidência para apoiá-las. Ela usa o termo “alopatia”, uma palavra pejorativa sem significado inventada por Hahnemann, o criador da homeopatia, para denegrir seus principais rivais. A autora refere-se ao “princípio dos contrários” de Hipócrates, uma distorção e simplificação de suas idéias. Hipócrates foi um homem esperto, e eu gosto de pensar que, se ele estivesse vivo, ele teria rejeitado a antiga teoria dos “quatro humores” e homeopatia, e teria adotado o método científico. A autora questiona “quem mais se beneficia” das convencionais práticas na agricultura. Eu argumentaria que há benefícios para pessoas que poderiam ter morrido de fome devido a escassez de alimentos se fertilizantes e pesticidas não tivessem funcionado para aumentar a disponibilidade de alimentos. Isso não significa que as práticas correntes não devem ser melhoradas e que não devem ser feitas com mais segurança, mas descartá-las de uma só vez e substituí-las por homeopatia dificilmente é a resposta!
Eu gostaria de saber se isso é algum tipo de sátira, mas eu acho que não. A matéria está na seção “Avanços” e com o rótulo “Saúde”. A autora está nos caçoando, ou ela realmente acredita que “a homeopatia torna-se imprescindível para o equilíbrio do planeta e à saúde de todos os seres que nele vivem”? Talvez ela esteja falando de algum planeta em um universo paralelo, ou dos sonhos dela. Se a Rainha Branca de Alice no Pais das Maravilhas tentasse acreditar nisso antes do café da manhã, o cérebro dela poderia explodir.
Se isso é o que se passa por ciência no Brasil, Brasil está em apuros. Aparentemente as coisas não mudaram muito desde que Richard Feynman teve seu encontro decepcionante com o sistema de educação brasileiro. No entanto, é claro que não é justo destacar apenas o Brasil, porque essas mesmas coisas acontecem em outros países.
Se isso é o que se passa por ciência para Scientific American, a revista é uma caricatura repreensível e deveria cortar a palavra “scientific” do seu título. No que os editores estavam pensando quando eles impuseram esse tipo de lixo aos seus leitores? Que vergonha!
Nota: Obrigado ao Felipe Nogueira Barbara de Oliveira por trazer isso a minha atenção e prover a tradução.

Update: Homeopathy in Brazilian Scientific American
Harriet Hall on April 10, 2012
Link
Last week I wrote about a regrettable piece on homeopathy that was published in Scientific American Brasil. There have been gratifying developments. Within hours, the editor in chief of Scientific American, Mariette DiChristina, appeared in the Comments. She said that Scientific American does not condone the pseudoscience of homeopathy, that the piece clearly should not have been published, that it would never have been published if Scientific American had been consulted beforehand, and that she had complained to the responsible parties. I was very grateful for her response to my article, for her intervention, and for her willingness to speak out in support of good science.
An Apology
Lo and behold, two days later Ms. DiChristina reported that the editor of Scientific American Brasil had written a letter of apology and had published it on the website. Here is a full translation:
Error of judgment
By Ulisses Capozzoli, Editor of Scientific American Brasil
In the 119th issue, published close to April 1 and on the eve of the 10th anniversary of Scientific American Brasil (in June), I committed an error in evaluating a note about homeopathy, published in the Advances section, an error that I want to recognize not only for Brazilian readers but in relation to the nearly bicentenary tradition of the American parent publication, Scientific American.
The note in question is related to a course on the application of homeopathy to agriculture, offered by the Federal University of Viçosa (UFV) through its department of phytotechnology, and, according to their information, with the support of the National Council of Scientific and Technological Development (CNPq).
The fact that it is a prestigious university in the field of agriculture and that the course is sponsored by the main agency that finances scientific research in Brazil, the CNPq, led me to accept and publish the note, which was written by a collaborator, a biologist who had completed the 10 month course at UFV.
This was my error of judgment.
If a homeopathic doctor, among the approximately 15 thousand who exist in Brazil, opens an office and treats patients with homeopathy, he cannot be accused of misconduct or charlatanism. This is because homeopathy is legally recognized here as a medical, pharmaceutical, and even veterinary specialty.
This situation relaxed my vigilance about the note in question and its content, which helps to explain my mistake. But, without a doubt, it doesn’t justify it; therefore I offer my apology to readers and to the original Scientific American.
By the end of this year, I will have edited 18 issues of Scientific American Brasil: 12 monthly issues and another 6 bimonthly issues. I prepare all the texts of each one of those issues, which means I read every word, before and after proofreading. The magazine, as my readers know, deals with subjects on the frontiers of science, with a concern for using clear, precise language and unequivocal concepts.
When I committed the error described above, I disregarded the conceptual content: Scientific American, reflecting what is probably the majority of scientific opinion, understands that homeopathy is not science.
Readers outraged by my evaluation have sent e-mails to our editorial offices and have addressed the question on social networks, which allowed me to realize that I had committed an error. In a dawn with a high, almost full moon in the sky, and the perfume of the lady of the night [night-blooming jasmine?] flooding a little garden, I realized that my only means of repairing the damage is to recognize the error and to apologize, as I am doing, with the support of the editorial office director, Janir Hollanda.
I am comforted by the fact that the history of science is full of mistakes, some perhaps more egregious than mine, but each of them properly corrected. I’ll cite a few for the enjoyment of readers. In 1887 the French chemist Marcellin Berthelot said, “for science, the world from now on has no more mysteries.” This short and apparently objective phrase is considered one of the stupidest of all time.
The American astronomer Percival Lowell’s proclamation that the canals on Mars were of artificial origin is certainly common knowledge and the same could be said of the theory of spontaneous generation: the idea that mice can be born naturally from trash. The genesis of this concept dates back to Aristotle, who said in his treatises The Generation of Animals and History of Animals that some insects “came from the dew that falls on leaves.”
Cold fusion was a fiasco (repeated in several parts of the world) by the American electrochemists Martin Fleischmann and Stanley Pons in 1989.
And all of this without mentioning the very accurate measurements of the size of the human brain that were given controversial interpretations by the French surgeon Paul Broca.
I hope this will be followed by an apology in print in the next issue of the magazine, but I’m glad it was published immediately. He readily admits that explaining why he made his mistake doesn’t justify it. Of course, someone in his position of scientific responsibility should never have been swayed by the factors that swayed him (legality, funding, etc.) And the fact that others throughout history have made famous mistakes does nothing to excuse his own errors.
Science Is Alive and Well in Brazil
Homeopaths are predictably crowing on the Internet that their beliefs now have the approval of Scientific American, for instance here, but it is encouraging to see that many Brazilians have complained about this infiltration of pseudoscience into the magazine. It is also encouraging to learn that the SBM blog has followers in Brazil. At least one Brazilian blogger had already complained to Scientific American Brasil, and he reproduced his own letter as well as my blog post here. I got an e-mail from a researcher in Brazil who sometimes writes against homeopathy. He attached several articles he had written, including criticisms of published articles favorable to homeopathy and a survey of Brazilian newspapers showing a favorable bias in their coverage of homeopathy. He’s currently going through a database of MSc and DSc dissertations from a Brazilian science foundation, and has identified dozens of dissertations on homeopathy — the vast majority of them claiming positive experimental results of some sort. I hope he will eventually publish his findings. It seems that although homeopathy is rampant in Brazil, so is science-based medicine and critical thinking.
Mariette DiChristina Sets an Example
Ms. DiChristina should be applauded for her prompt intervention and her defense of rigorous scientific standards. One of our commenters said
I find it very interesting that the editor-in-chief of Scientific American has demonstrated more scientific integrity in journal standards than the editors of journals claiming high impact factors in the field of medical science.
How true! How unfortunate! Another commenter provided a recent example where the editor of New Scientist tried to defend a pseudoscientific article.
On SBM we have frequently criticized the publication of poor studies and credulous articles about CAM by major medical journals and have wondered how the articles ever got past the editors and peer reviewers. There have even been articles that were proven to be fraudulent but that were never repudiated by the journals. The Lancet did finally retract Wakefield’s infamous article, but it took them 12 years. We have even criticized the prestigious New England Journal of Medicine for ill-advised articles on integrative medicine and acupuncture.
We have criticized the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) for wasting funds on very questionable research. Its director, Josephine Briggs, seemed receptive to our message, but she was equally receptive to an “international team of homeopaths” who left the building feeling quite satisfied that they had made a favorable impression.
It would take a lot of integrity for a medical journal editor or a political appointee to buck current trends of quackademic medicine, popular demand, and political correctness; to boldly call a quack a quack; and to stand firm for science-based medicine in the face of opposition from many of his colleagues or employers. It’s possible that doing so might even lose him his job. But surely it would be a worthy effort. Ms. DiChristina has set a fine example for others to follow. I can only hope that other editors will find the courage to follow her example.

For the convenience of our readers in Brazil, a translation into Portuguese follows.
Note: Thanks to Felipe Nogueira for the translations.
Atualização: Homeopatia na Scientific American Brasil
Semana passada, eu escrevi a respeito de uma nota lamentável sobre homeopatia que foi publicada na Scientific American Brasil.
Houve uma repercussão gratificante. Em questão de horas, a editora-chefe da Scientific American, Mariette DiChristina, apareceu nos comentários. Ela disse que a Scientific American não apoia a pseudociência da homeopatia, que tal nota não deveria ter sido publicada, que nunca seria publicada se a Scientific American fosse consultada previamente, e que ela reclamou com as partes responsáveis. Eu fiquei muito grata pela sua resposta ao meu artigo, pela sua intervenção, e pela sua vontade de se pronunciar em defesa à boa ciência.
E eis que dois dias depois a Sra. DiChristina reportou que o editor da Scientific American Brasil escreveu uma carta de desculpas e a publicou no website.
Eu espero que isso seja seguido por uma desculpa impressa na próxima edição da revista, mas estou contente que foi publicada imediatamente. Ele prontamente admitiu que explicar por que ele cometeu o erro não o justifica. É claro que alguém na sua posição de responsabilidade científica nunca deveria ter sido convencido pelos fatores que o convenceram (legalidade, financiamento, etc.). E o fato de outros durante a história terem cometido erros famosos não o desculpa de seus próprios erros.
Ciência está viva e bem no Brasil
Homeopatas estão presumivelmente comemorando na Internet que suas crenças agora possuem o apoio da Scientific American, como neste exemplo. Mas é encorajador ver que muitos brasileiros reclamaram dessa infiltração de pseudociência na revista. É encorajador saber que o blog SBM tem seguidores no Brasil. Pelo menos um blogger brasileiro já reclamou com a Scientific American Brasil, e ele reproduziu sua própria carta assim como meu post aqui.
Eu recebi um e-mail de um pesquisador brasileiro que às vezes escreve contra a homeopatia. Ele anexou vários artigos que ele escreveu, incluindo críticas a artigos publicados favoráveis a homeopatia e uma coletânea de jornais brasileiros mostrando um viés favorável na cobertura da homeopatia. Ele atualmente está pesquisando em uma base de dissertações de Mestrado e Doutorado de uma fundação científica brasileira, e identificou dezenas de dissertações em homeopatia – a grande maioria delas afirmando resultados experimentais positivos. Eu espero que ele eventualmente publique seus achados. Parece que, embora a homeopatia seja valorizada no Brasil, o mesmo pode ser dito da medicina baseada em evidências e do pensamento crítico.
Mariette DiChristina Dá Um Exemplo
Sra. DiChristina deveria ser aplaudida pela sua rápida intervenção e pela sua defesa de padrões científicos rigorosos. Um de nossos comentadores disse “Eu achei bem interessante que a editora-chefe da Scientific American demonstrou mais integridade científica em padrões de periódicos do que editores de periódicos que afirmam altos fatores de impacto na área da ciência médica.” Que verdade lamentável!
No blog SBM, frequentemente criticamos a publicação de estudos ruins e artigos crédulos sobre MCA (medicina complementar e alternativa) pelos principais periódicos de medicina e perguntamos como esses artigos passaram pelos editores e revisores. Há exemplos de artigos que foi provado serem fraudulentos, mas que nunca foram repudiados pelos periódicos.
Lancet finalmente retratou o vergonhoso artigo de Wakefield, mas isso demorou 12 anos para acontecer. Criticamos até mesmo o prestigiado New England Journal of Medicine por artigos mal orientados em medicina integrativa, e acupuntura.
Criticamos o National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) por desperdiçar fundos em pesquisas muito questionáveis. Sua diretora, Josephine Briggs, pareceu receptiva à nossa mensagem, mas ela foi igualmente receptiva a um grupo internacional de homeopatas que saíram das instalações bem satisfeitos com a favorável impressão que deixaram.
Precisaria de muita integridade para um editor de um periódico médico ou um político eleito resistir às atuais tendências de medicina “charlatã-acadêmica”, demanda popular, e ter honestidade política; para chamar charlatanismo de charlatanismo e manter-se firme à medicina baseada em evidências face à oposição de muitos colegas ou empregadores. É possível que ele perca seu trabalho. Mas com certeza seria um esforço que valeria a pena. Sra. DiChristina deixou um bom exemplo para outros seguirem. Eu só posso esperar que outros encontrem a coragem para seguir o exemplo dela.
Nota: Agradeço ao Felipe Nogueira pela ajuda nas traduções.

Homeopathy
Brennen McKenzie on January 26, 2013
Link
It can be frustrating, and sometimes even a little depressing, to be a skeptic. Promoting reason and science-based medicine often feels like a Sisyphean effort that garners lots of hostility and ad hominem attacks from proponents of pseudoscience and few concrete victories. But once in a while, something happens to give a little hope and inspiration.
In 2010, for example, the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee report on homeopathy came out, clearly unmasking homeopathy for the vitalist 18th century relic it is (though, sadly, politics is complicated and often unmoved by mere scientific truth, and the government didn’t eagerly embrace the findings or recommendations of the committee). About the same time, the British Medical Association called homeopathy “witchcraft,” and recommended it no longer be supported by the National Health Service. More recently, the Chief Medical Officer in Britain openly acknowledged homeopathy is “rubbish.” Perhaps there has been a shift in the winds? Maybe there is hope that the institutions of government and organized mainstream medicine here in the U.S. might be willing to start taking a stand against pseudoscience in the way they used to in the days before Wilk vs American Medical Association?
As a veterinarian, I was particularly delighted and inspired in March, 2012 when the Australian Veterinary Association (AVA) joined in this movement and took a firm and public stand on unscientific therapies, in particular washing its hands of homeopathy:
Australian Veterinary Association (AVA) resources will not be used to promote therapies that, in the Board’s opinion, are not compatible with current understanding of physiology and pathophysiology and have been demonstrated to be ineffective by the current accumulated body of knowledge.
That the Board agreed that the veterinary therapies of homeopathy and homotoxicology are considered ineffective therapies in accordance with the AVA promotion of ineffective therapies Board resolution.
This echoed the policies of the British Veterinary Association, and other national veterinary groups in Sweden, Denmark, and elsewhere in Europe. The idea that the central player in organized veterinary medicine in the U.S., the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), which has as members more than 80% of the licensed veterinarians in the country, could be moved to take a similar stand started to seem like a realistic possibility.

The existing AVMA policy on Complementary and Alternative Veterinary Medicine (CAVM) has some nice sentiments in it.
The AVMA believes that all veterinary medicine, including CAVM, should be held to the same standards. Claims for safety and effectiveness ultimately should be proven by the scientific method… Practices and philosophies that are ineffective or unsafe should be discarded…
However, in the roughly 11 years since that policy was adopted, not a single practice or philosophy actual has been discarded, or identified as inconsistent with the scientific method or established scientific knowledge. It has become merely institutional cover for veterinarians practicing alternative therapies to claim that these are recognized and compatible with scientific medicine despite the lack of meaningful supporting evidence.
So a group of veterinarians from the Connecticut Veterinary Medical Association (CVMA) and the Evidence-Based Veterinary Medicine Association (EBVMA; of which I am currently president), decided to submit a resolution to the AVMA governing body (the House of Delegates), re-affirming that veterinary medicine should be science based and finally identifying homeopathy as the pseudoscientific nonsense it is.
The full text of the resolution can be found here, but the core of it is in these statements:
RESOLVED, that the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) affirms that—
     1.  Safety and efficacy of veterinary therapies should be determined by scientific investigation.
     2.  When sound and widely accepted scientific evidence demonstrates a given practice as ineffective or that it poses risks greater than its possible benefits, such ineffective or unsafe philosophies and therapies should be discarded.
     3.  In keeping with AVMA policy on Complementary and Alternative Veterinary Medicine, AVMA discourages the use of therapies identified as unsafe or ineffective, and encourages the use of the therapies based upon sound, accepted principles of science and veterinary medicine.
     4.  Homeopathy has been conclusively demonstrated to be ineffective.
There is nothing here that ought to be remotely controversial for the vast majority of veterinarians who practice conventional medicine. And while proponents of all pseudoscience like to pretend their practices are scientifically legitimate, the evidence that homeopathy is both inconsistent with established science (should not work) and demonstrably ineffective (does not work) is overwhelming. The CVMA and EBVMA accompanied the resolution with a white paper, The Case Against Homeopathy, which illustrated in detail the following points:
    • It is generally accepted in veterinary and human medicine that the safety and efficacy of medical therapies is best determined by scientific investigation and scientific evidence.
    • The principles of homeopathy are incompatible with well-established scientific knowledge.
    • There is abundant pre-clinical research showing most homeopathic remedies (those that are highly diluted) have no biological effects.
    • There is abundant clinical research in humans showing homeopathy to be no more effective than placebo.
    • The limited veterinary research available is consistent with the research done in humans in showing that homeopathy has only placebo effects, not specific therapeutic treatment effects.
The resolution had support among a wide range of veterinarians working in different fields. Official endorsements came from the American College of Veterinary Clinical Pharmacology, the American Academy of Veterinary Pharmacology and Therapeutics, and the American Society of Laboratory Animal Practitioners. A number of individual veterinarians also publically supported the measure.
A particularly compelling letter of support came from Dr. Narda Robinson at Colorado State University. Though supportive of some forms of complementary and alternative treatment, Dr. Robinson was concerned about both the evidence against any real benefit from homeopathy and the official policy of the Academy of Veterinary Homeopathy (AVH) to discourage conventional medical care. The presence of such allies added to the sense that the times were a-changing, and at last we might be able to do something about this ridiculous bit of vitalism.
There was also, however, a conspicuous silence from many organizations whose members aren’t usually practitioners of homeopathy but who, for various reasons, were unwilling to acknowledge publically that it is nonsense. There was hope, for example, that the American College of Veterinary Internal Medicine (ACVIM) would endorse the resolution. One of the most respected specialty colleges in veterinary medicine, this group could have significant influence on the acceptability of pseudoscience like homeopathy.
The ACVIM declined to endorse the resolution despite the fact that most of its members do not accept the scientific legitimacy of homeopathy. The reasoning and individual comments offered in their explanation of this decision exemplifies the flaws in the philosophy of evidence-based medicine that have led the group founding SBM to take on the cause of science-based medicine instead:
It should be stated outright that the BOR believes that evidenced-based medicine should be the foundation of the practice of veterinary medicine as much as possible. Realistically, however, we all recognize that many treatment and diagnostic decisions applied to veterinary patients, both by general practitioners and veterinary specialists are made in the absence of evidence…
If I tried to say that I believe all therapy must be based on scientific evidence and clinical trial data, I would be an absolute hypocrite, and I would be reduced to being able to treat a handful of diseases.
This is the argument that says, in essence, that EBM requires optimal evidence before a judgment can be made, and in the absence of near perfect, gold standard RCT evidence, everyone should be free to do whatever they like based on any theoretical reasoning or personal intuition or experience. This approach, which ignores the vast knowledge we have already accumulated which makes some hypothesis far more likely to be true than others, reduces EBM to an intellectual curiosity with no practical value. If we cannot distinguish between homeopathy and conventional medicine after 200 years of scientific research, then we might as well give up entirely on the notion that science is of any use in informing clinical decision making.
Fifty years ago, we had no clue that genes could be normal, but silenced. We had no mechanism for how non-mutating substances cause cancer. We now know they do. I cannot feel comfortable speaking with strong certainty that an entire form of medicine does not work when it is practiced in many parts of the world, journals describing it are indexed in Pubmed, and many are equally convinced of its efficacy.
This is the familiar fallacy that because unexpected or improbable things have turned out to be true in the past, and because our knowledge is inevitable flawed and incomplete, we must refrain from ever judging anything to be untrue, with dash of the argumentum ad populum fallacy for seasoning.
There are too many shades of grey surrounding what we each do on a day-to-day basis to comfortably single out a particular therapy for condemnation because of a lack of evidence. There are many forms of “unconventional” or “alternative” therapy with no more evidence of efficacy than homeopathy. And even when using “conventional” therapy in an empiric manner, problems with the resolution arise. Every patient empirically treated without a definitive diagnosis is, in essence (in my opinion), a violation of at least the spirit of the resolution (and with as much potential for harm from delayed diagnosis as any non-traditional therapy). Every time I reach for certain dangerous drugs (eg, chemotherapy drugs, glucocorticoids) because I have nothing else to offer, I violate the spirit of the resolution (and arguably in a more severe manner in that my non-evidenced-based therapy has a greater likelihood of causing harm than the homeopathic treatment). Where would/should the lines be drawn then?
Given the necessity in many cases to make decisions with only scant, poor quality or even conflicting evidence an alternative wording to the resolution that many BOR members seemed comfortable with is offered:
     1.  Safety and efficacy of veterinary therapies should be determined whenever possible by scientific investigation.
     2.  When sound and widely accepted scientific evidence demonstrates a given practice as ineffective, or that it poses risks greater than its benefits, such ineffective and unsafe philosophies and therapies should be discouraged.
     3.  Veterinarians may legally employ any therapy not proscribed by applicable laws and regulations governing the practice of veterinary medicine. However, veterinarians have an ethical duty to society, and to their patients and clients, to ignore their biases and instead base their judgments and recommendations as often as possible on the best available scientific evidence.
This statement seems to me to be saying, “We believe science is the best way to validate medical therapies, but we aren’t willing to say that anything is ever invalidated unless nothing we do involves any evidentiary uncertainty.” To suggest that empirical use of chemotherapeutics is roughly equivalent to treating cancer with water is clearly ridiculous. Yet there is a component of humility and a sense of fairness that makes this sort of reasoning very appealing to the majority of veterinarians who don’t believe in homeopathy but are reluctant to criticize their colleagues who do.
While I applaud the recognition of our individual and collective ignorance and limitations, I believe it does no service to our patients and clients if we mistake post-modernism for humility. The evidence against therapeutic bloodletting was no better than that against homeopathy, and it was no less plausible. Should we revive that practice because we have not definitively demonstrated it is useless in all circumstances by extensive and perfect RCTs? Lines should, indeed, be drawn, and while they may not always be perfectly drawn and immutable, they can be based on a thoughtful and reasonable assessment of the available evidence.
As I see it, all conclusions in science are, of course, provisional and subject to revision as new evidence is developed. And our confidence in our conclusions should be proportional to the evidence available to support them. So it is possible evidence could be developed to validate homeopathy as a clinical intervention. Personally, I see this as about as likely as the emergence of evidence that the Earth does not, in fact, revolve around the Sun, but in some theoretical sense at least it is possible. And the evidence concerning homeopathy is not impervious to criticism, especially given the generally low level and poor quality of it. However, if we cannot draw conclusions about a therapy until near perfect evidence is available, then EBM is useless as a decision-making tool.
My own approach is that we must critically evaluate and rank the evidence according to EBM methods, then integrate this with other relevant information, such as biologic plausibility, and make a pragmatic decision based on the evidence that exists. Accepting the provisional nature of such decisions, we must be willing to re-evaluate them as necessary, but it does no good to simply refrain from making them at all if the evidence is less than ideal. We don’t entirely understand the mechanisms of gravity, but we refrain from leaping out of windows all the same.
In the case of homeopathy, the absence of evidence seems very much to be evidence of absence given the implausible foundations and the failure of numerous attempts to validate the method over two centuries. If even this is not sufficient to declare the therapy ineffective (with, of course, the very small caveat that allows for new evidence to someday emerge), then I cannot see how any therapy can ever be discarded or how EBM can provide effective guidance for clinicians in selecting interventions.
Less surprising and disappointing than the failure of support from the reasonable mainstream of veterinary medicine was the opposition from the expected sources. The AVH and the American Holistic Veterinary Medical Association (AHVMA) both opposed it. The AVH attempted to muddy the waters in the usual way by producing a white paper of their own, The Evidence for Homeopathy, which claims to show that homeopathy is based on legitimate, validated scientific principles and has abundant evidence of clinical benefit.
This paper illustrates exactly the points made and demonstrated in The Case Against Homeopathy. Low-quality studies with poor control for bias, confounding, and other sources of error are cited to justify claims that the evidence does not support. Sometimes, even studies which find no effect are cited to support claims of an effect. Bits of legitimate science are misinterpreted to generate the false impression that they validate the implausible theoretical foundations of homeopathy. Clear publication bias in support of homeopathy is ignored whereas negative evidence is dismissed on the basis of presumed individual bias regardless of the methodological controls used to account for this. This document was a transparent attempt to select and distort the evidence in favor of their pre-exiting beliefs.
Though tedious, I thought it might be useful to go through the AVH document point by point, including critically appraising each of the references cited. The result is The Evidence for Homeopathy-A Close Look, which deconstructs the bogus arguments of the AVH in exhaustive detail (for this, I want to specifically give my thanks to the other authors at SBM, to Orac of Respectful Insolence, and to the folks at Rational Veterinary Medicine, where I found invaluable information about some of the research cited in the AVH paper).
Apart from the AVH attempt to manufacture scientific legitimacy for their approach, there was the usual hue and cry of a less academic nature. The folks at Mercola.com offered some of the usual hysteria and hyperbole about “health freedom” and the right to peddle and procure whatever medical interventions anyone wants, regardless of evidence concerning safety or efficacy. And one leading opponent of the resolution, a homeopath involved in the AVH and often seen lecturing on homeopathy at mainstream veterinary continuing education meetings, went so far as to compare this resolution to the Holocaust: “She felt that this was her personal Kristallnacht, that the walls came down around her and that she was being marginalized from within her own AVMA.” The AVH submitted a letter full of smoke and mirrors and outright error commenting on specific statements in The Case Against Homeopathy, which I have responded to point by point. And apparently, individual veterinarians worried about losing their freedom to employ imaginary therapies contacted the AVMA to protest the shocking and outrageous idea of admitting homeopathy doesn’t work. About 700 emails and 250 phone calls were apparently received by the AVMA condemning the resolution. It goes almost without saying that the AVMA did not hear from nearly as many skeptics willing to openly speak against homeopathy.
So with pseudoscience and outrage pitted against a mountain of scientific evidence, any guesses as to the outcome?
Well, technically it wasn’t a defeat. The House of Delegates voted by about 3:1 not to vote on the content of the resolution but to refer it for evaluation to the committee that wrote the current CAVM policy quoted above. The same policy which made reasonable noises about the importance of science 11 years ago and has been rather quiet since in the face of apparently growing infiltration of homeopathy and other pseudoscientific practices into the mainstream. I’m not directly involved in the politics or the process, but my guess is the resolution will die quietly in committee, or perhaps be replaced by more vague noises about science and research without any clear statements about the validity of any specific intervention.
So are we slipping into a medical Age of Endarkenment in the U.S.? We still pay lip service to science evidence and reason, but even the best educated and trained among us accept shoddy science and postmodernist rationalizations as reasons to refrain from declaring even such egregious nonsense as homeopathy as out of bounds. It’s true, there are only about 130 members in the AVH, so homeopaths are a tiny minority within the veterinary profession. But with the complicity of the majority, unwilling to criticize anything our colleagues do, this minority can continue to sell pseudoscience and placebos to their clients.
And the AHVMA, which represents CAVM in general, is much larger and more influential than the AVH. They have recently raised about $400,000 to promote “integrative medicine” at mainstream veterinary schools, with an ultimate goal of $20 million and multiple academic centers promoting alternative therapies, positioning themselves as the Bravewell Collaboration of veterinary medicine. And despite their claims to respect science and support rigorous research, they have thrown their lot in decisively with the magic water that is homeopathy. What can skeptics use to combat those resources, other than mere facts and evidence, which seem less persuasive to our otherwise mainstream colleagues than we might hope?
The passionate few who are believers cannot, of course, make homeopathy anything other than a marginal practice, in most cases just added on to real medicine in true “integrative” fashion. After all, it doesn’t actually work. But the hope that we might actually see the death of it alltogether seems distant indeed. Like the proponents of intelligent design, homeopaths seem to be having some success generating a maufacturoversy, suggesting there is some legitimate scientific dispute concerning the plausibility and efficacy of homeopathy. And few of my colleagues in veterinary medicine seem inclined to look at the evidence critically and in depth themselves to see that there is, in fact, no real doubt or legitimate dispute. Money, popularity, and the voice of the passionate minority of believers seem unlikely to yield to mere reason and evidence, especially when shielded by the apathy or post-modern neutrality of the majority. Perhaps “Age of Endarkenment” is going a bit far, but some days the victories of the Age of Enlightenment seem evanescent, and it is clear we shall have to keep rolling the same old boulders up that hill for the forseeable future.

Homotoxicology
Mark Crislip on December 12, 2014
Link

What you’ve just said is one of the most insanely idiotic things I have ever heard. At no point in your rambling, incoherent response were you even close to anything that could be considered a rational thought. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.—James Downey, Billy Madison

My first experience with SCAM was as a first year medical student. I was on the bus to school when the person next to me asked, after looking at my reading material, if I was a medical student. Yes, I am. Why so was he, enrolled at the local naturopathic school. I knew nothing about naturopathy, or medicine for that matter, at the time, so when he told me that warts were not caused by a virus but in fact due to the body walling off toxins and expelling them through the skin, I did not have much to say. I suspected it was nuts, but lacked the education or understanding of disease to know for sure, and who knew, maybe he was on to something.
When we got to cutaneous diseases I learned that warts were indeed caused by the papilloma virus, not toxins, and the best therapy remained swinging a dead cat in a graveyard at midnight. So I filed that curious incident away as a fluke, even though it is part of standard naturopathic teaching, which is often separated from reality.
It should not have surprised me that there is a whole field of pseudo-medicine devoted to the pseudo-treatment of pseudo-toxins that goes by the nom de scam of Homotoxicology. Yet another One True Cause of all disease. Being a splitter, I think Harriet missed this one. All diseases in this particular SCAM are due the toxins and the bodies attempt to remove them.
Homeotoxicology was invented? Discovered? Created? Concocted? Fabricated? Made up? Pulled out of… thin air, yeah, that’s the ticket, thin air?
I am never certain as to the proper term for the process used by lone fantabulists like DD Palmer or Ignatz von Peczely to create, out of nothing, a complex pseudo-medical discipline and then waste their life, and other peoples time, money, and health, on the pursuit of a pot of SCAM at the end of the rainbow. What is the word for writing fiction but believing it real? Add your own snarky term below, I’m not going there. I am the last person to resort to extraneous partisan snipings.
Anyway. Hans Heinrich Reckeweg is the person behind Homotoxicology. He was a German MD who became a homeopath and had quite the imaginative career. Following his release from captivity in 1946 (by whom and for what I would be curious to know) he started to expand upon classic homeopathy.
Hahnemann was a one symptom/one worthless treatment kind of guy. Reckeweg reasoned that if multiple homeopathic nostrums had the same effect, then they should all be given at once and the body could choose which one it needed. You may scoff, but I get the feeling that is how empiric antibiotics are often given in the hospital. I exaggerate but a little.
But he expanded upon the Caedite eos. Novit enim Dominus qui sunt eius concept of multiple interventions. He gave not only multiple remedies (up to 30), but at multiple potencies (i.e. dilutions. ‘Potency’ in the homeopathic spiel is as misleading a phrase as ‘integrative’ is at a medical school) of the same preparation, so the body had to choose the medication and the dilution it wanted for a cure. And he got to charge the fee although evidently the body did all the heavy lifting.
He considered it a work of genius with the potential to be:
A Bridge Between Allopathic and Homeopathic Medicine.
Only if the bridge crosses the Tacoma Narrows. He was perhaps the Dr. Oz of his day with his interest in combining reality- and fantasy-based therapies. Not content with a new form of homeopathy, Rekeweg went on to elucidate what he considered to be the cause of all disease and its treatment. No hubris there.
Another website describes homotoxicology as:
a biological medicine that is a cybernetic system of information arranged in self-maintaining levels. Each level keeps the one immediately below in homoeostasis. With every disease or imbalance this affects the given level. If the homotoxins are not cleared in the matrix they impregnate the cell. The basic extracellular system is a uniform stable environment, regulated in all the cells of the body.
It is always odd to find a series of words that appear to mean something but have no actual content.
Diseases are caused by homotoxins. What are homotoxins? Substances that are harmful to the body. Or a more (or perhaps less) specific definition:
any substance that has a direct or indirect damaging effect on the human organism. Not the substance in itself is the most important. Crucial is its effect on the organism.
A pretty broad definition as at the right concentration or velocity anything can be harmful. One website gave:
examples of homotoxins (including) toxic mercury amalgam fillings in the teeth associated with electric currents and voltages, dysbiosis (unhealthy micro-organisms in the gut often due to an unhealthy diet, hormone replacement therapy, and antibiotics), chronic yeast infections (Candida), gas, diesel and petrol fume intolerance, exposure to unhealthy electro-magnetic fields, pesticides, and undiagnosed bacterial (Salmonella paratyphi), or protozoon (Giardia and Amoeba) infections in the gut, possibly picked up on holiday abroad.
It can include geopathic toxins (living in the wrong place) and:
an homotoxin can, in its highest state, even be immaterial.
So anything and everything can be a homotoxin, including nothing. It is a dangerous world out there.
Unlike the ‘like curing like’ of homeopathy, homotoxicology postulates a unique cause of and treatment of disease:
“diseases” are expressions of the battle of the organism against toxins, in its attempt to counteract and expel them. When the body can no longer expel them, for whatever reason, the organism tries through increased pathological means to make up for the damage already sustained. This process goes in six distinct phases:
     1.  Excretion phase or the expulsion of toxins through body orifices, e.g. diarrhea, vomiting;
     2.  Reaction phase – where toxins are removed by the body reacting against them, e.g. fever, inflammation and mobilization of white blood cells to consume the toxins;
     3.  Deposition phase – storage followed by deactivation of the toxins in connective and fat tissue and in the vascular system;The above phases are naturally “reversible.” The following phases become more and more difficult to deal with as in these processes damage occurs to the organs themselves
     4.  Impregnation phase – severe disease occurs in a “locus minoris resistentiae”, the body’s weakest organ;
     5.  Degeneration phase – the organ is increasingly and irreversibly damaged, with alteration of the cellular enzymes and in the organic structure;
     6.  Neoplasm or Cancer phase- the cell genes are damaged.
The International Academy for Homotoxicology produces tables and offers courses in homotoxicology that show the interrelationship of these phases of disease. Beware!
The academic and scientific level of the content of these programs is quite high…
Evidently, as they are way over my head, appearing to me to be a meaningless table of diseases with an arbitrary organization, unhinged from known anatomy and physiology. It is simple but complex: all diseases and symptoms are due to the body’s attempt to expel toxins from the body using the above hierarchy. So in this system, depending on one’s success in removing a toxin, you may end up on the spectrum from difficulty with concentration to meningitis to cerebral sclerosis to migraine to Alzheimer’s to glioblastoma. In the world of homotoxicology all these neurologic diseases are related to degrees of failure in toxin removal. Quite creative and not even wrong.
Homotoxicology offers imaginary treatments for these imaginary diseases, so it is well suited to naturopathic practice. One you discover what phase the patient is in you can then embark on a therapy with the:
3 pillars of homotoxicology which are 1. drainage and detoxification, 2. immunomodulation and 3. cell and organ support. These 3 pillars are filled in with medications containing plant preparation groups (PPG), mineral preparation groups (MPG), catalysts preparation groups (CPG) and organ preparation groups (ORPG).
These preparations can reverse the progressive vicariation, as the degeneration phases were originally named by Reckeweg.
These nostrums either inactivate the toxins or work through a modulation of the immune system. Being nothing but injected water they do nothing.
One of the foundations of homotoxicology is Madison’s, er, I mean Hering’s Law, a law that is a valid as the laws of homeopathy:
a disease evolving to recovery of health will do this from the inside out, from vital to less vital organs, from the torso to the extremities (centrifugally). A disease that is suppressed or becomes chronic tends to move to deeper lying (organ) tissues (centripetally).
And of course, homotoxicology is quantum. I bet quantum doctors do not get into boxes.
This does explain the theory of warts given to me all those years ago on the bus, why the wart toxins were migrating from the core to the periphery, but in reality what I was told was but a red Hering. Sorry. Could not resist.
It is a remarkably complex system of pseudo-medicine and all diseases are explained and treatable within the system. However, it is completely disconnected from reality and all that we know about the pathophysiology and treatment of diseases.
It is always a tough call. Do we follow the collected, albeit always-evolving, information of modern medicine and science or do we go with the epiphanies of a single person whose ideas of disease and treatment not only run counter to all of medicine, but all other pseudo-medicines?
Despite being a fictional system of diagnosis and treatment, homotoxicology has had time and money wasted on testing its efficacy. To summarize:
Despite mostly positive findings and high ratings on the Jadad score, the placebo-controlled, randomised clinical trials of homotoxicology fail to demonstrate the efficacy of this therapeutic approach.
No surprise there.
I don’t much care for the movies of Adam Sandler, but who knew that Billy Madison was homotoxicology personified? Although a simple “wrong” would’ve done just fine, it would not have been a blog entry.

Homeopathy First Aid Kits
$55 for a box of sugar pills? How on earth can anyone sell homeopathic first aid kits?
Harriet Hall on August 13, 2013
Link
I don’t know how I missed them, but somehow homeopathic first aid kits had not registered on my radar. They’re readily available. Even Amazon.com sells them, for $54.99. They contain 18 vials of tiny sugar pills, all with potencies of 200C, guaranteed by Avogadro not to contain a single molecule of the active ingredient. (For those of you who may not know, Avogadro was the Italian scientist who discovered the Avogadro constant, the number of atoms needed such that the number of grams of a substance equals the atomic mass of the substance.
If that paralyzes your brain, never mind. Just take my word for it that Avogadro’s discovery allows us to calculate that a 13C dilution (a 1 in 100 to the 13th power dilution), is the equivalent of diluting 1/3 of a drop of the original substance in all the water on earth, and to reach a 200C potency you would have to continue to dilute it by 1 to 100 a total of 187 more times.)
What’s in the kits?
On homeopathy websites you can buy special first aid kits for the car, for hiking and camping, for horses, for pets, for pregnancy, for childbirth, and for travel. One website sells a first aid kit that “contains all the major homeopathic first aid remedies which work so amazingly well particularly when given immediately after an accident or injury.” Only $99.95, but you’re also advised to buy a book to explain its use, for an additional $18.95. It contains 15 remedies in a 30C potency:
    • Aconite (the “queen of poisons): for colds, flu, sore throats, effects of fear, fright, chicken pox and croup
    • Apis mellifera (honey bee): for burning and stinging pains, insect stings, swelling of the lower eyelids, edema, swollen joints
    • Arnica: after injury, mental and physical shock, before and after operations or visits to the dentist. Stops bleeding, aids in the healing of wounds and reduces bruising and swelling. Good for general healing and shock, exhaustion, muscular pain, sprains from overexertion.
    • Arsen alb (arsenic): stomach upsets from food poisoning, diarrhea, vomiting and acute hayfever. Good for some dry skin conditions.
    • Belladonna (deadly nightshade): hot flushed face, sore throat, facial neuralgia, throbbing headache, earache, boils, chickenpox, measles and mumps
    • Bryonia (a toxic weed): dry chesty coughs, muscular pains, which is better for resting [sic]
    • Cantharis (a beetle, Spanish fly): burns and scalds before the blisters form, sunburn, constant urge to pass urine, urine passed drop by drop (cystitis)
I’ll spare you the rest, except to note that the list includes poison ivy to use for shingles, mumps, sciatica, herpes, etc.
It doesn’t matter what kind of poison is in them, because it’s all gone at that dilution. Which makes it really silly to choose one, because they’re all the same.
Scary advice
I was reassuring myself that people would mostly use these remedies while awaiting medical care, and then I found a website that horrified me.
For certain illnesses, it said “Depending on severity, seek medical care.” These included anaphylaxis, animal bites, bone injuries, third degree burns, carbon monoxide poisoning, cuts, drug overdose, electrocution, eye injuries, food poisoning, paint poisoning, pesticide poisoning, puncture wounds, and shock. It’s appalling to think that patients are left to their own assessment and might think these conditions were not severe enough to merit medical care.
For dislocated joints and heat exhaustion, there was no advice to seek medical care even if the condition was judged to be severe. What, you just leave your shoulder out of joint and non-functional?
In small print at the bottom you can find this disclaimer: “solely intended to provide a format in assisting the student in learning the principals of Homeopathy. It is in no way to be considered a substitute for a consultation with a health professional.”
No way to stop this dangerous nonsense, so you might as well laugh
The Quackometer was alarmed by the blurb accompanying these kits that said “to be used in even the most severe emergency and accident situations.” He describes the response (or rather non-response) of manufacturers and homeopaths to his concerns about them.
Myles Power has done a hilarious YouTube video about these kits
He says “It makes me so angry that it even exists.” But it gives him a fantastic idea. He goes out to save the world by dropping a pill from each bottle into a local stream that runs to the ocean and will eventually reach everyone on earth in an even more dilute form. He will eliminate all the diseases the kit instructions cover, from heart attacks and strokes to throttling and drowning.
Conclusion: What is there to say?
What can I say? “Aarrrgh!” is not very coherent, and “Good grief” doesn’t quite cover it. Treating an emergency with sugar pills that have once been in contact with water that was once in contact with poison is just offensive to all reason and logic.

Integrative Fire-Fighting
David Weinberg on April 1, 2012
Link
Having a housefire is a one of the most stressful, dehumanizing experiences a family can experience. Like cancer, fires appear unexpectedly, and fill victims with fear, grief, and hopelessness. Western firefighting methods do not adequately meet the needs of these victims. No one knows your house as well as you do, yet firefighters take a very paternalistic approach, removing you from the decision-making process, then leaving you to clean up their mess. In the same spirit as integrative oncology, advocates of integrative firefighting believe that families, practitioners of conventional firefighting, as well as advocates of alternative firefighting philosophies should work as a team to achieve their common goals. The integrative approach offers victims choices, and empowers them by inviting them to participate in their own journey through the extinguishing process.
The first fire department was in ancient Rome and provided free firefighting services to citizens. Today firefighting services are a dominated by a consortium of of big business (producers of firefighting equipment) the government (public works) and a militia of mercenary firefighters, collectively known a “Big Hydrant.” This alliance has resulted in a proliferation of expensive, impersonal technology, but firefighting results have not improved since the times of the ancient Romans.
Consider the following story: Sonya of Westchester Missouri had a grease fire in her kitchen. When the flames began to spread, she did what she had been programmed to do since childhood. She called 911, summoning the local fire department. When they were finished, the fire was extinguished, but her windows were smashed, and there were thousands of dollars worth of water damage to her house. It took nearly 6 months to complete all the repairs. 1 year later her house was struck by lightning and burned to the ground. This failure of conventional firefighting is commonplace in our country.
Methods of fire-fighting in the Western world are based on a set of principles derived from the scientific philosophy of fire propagation. Western philosophy reduces fire to only 3 elements, commonly know as the “fire-triangle.” This reductionist approach teaches that heat, fuel and oxygen are the three essential elements to a fire. True to the bidding of Big Hydrant, the Western philosophy of fire is indoctrinated in our children starting in elementary school. It is the only philosophy considered in American fire fighting. The Western approach is one of many ways of understanding fires. Yet, alternative philosophies are systematically ignored, and even ridiculed.
Alternative approaches recognize that there is a universal energy which unites a structure to its inhabitants and the world around them. These components cannot be viewed in isolation from each other, and must be in balance to achieve a harmonious state of noncombustion. It is widely ignored in allopathic firefighting that there is a natural tendency for nature to restore balance, and for fires to extinguish themselves. Conventional firefighting techniques use a “treat the fire” approach, while alternative philosophies use a holistic approach, supporting the tendency for fires to extinguish naturally.
In ancient Chinese philosophy, there are 5 elements: Fire, Earth, Water, Metal and Wood. These elements are interchangeable and in a constant state of flux. They are reflected in every aspect of life. For instance, fire is associated with Tuesday and the direction South. Water is associated with Wednesday and the direction North. These five elements are also critical in the practice of Feng shui. Feng shui analyzes the the various components and energies (qi) of our surroundings. The layout and design of a structure as well as the size, shape, color and location of all the elements within a structure connect in a way that affects the balance of the qi within. An imbalance in this elements may alter the energy in a way that disturbs the noncombustive state. Integrating Eastern philosophy into firefighting would encourage firefighters to always attack fires from the North, and only on Wednesdays. Insurance rates would be discounted for structures meeting local feng shui building codes.
Homeopathy is an ancient healing science invented in the late 18th century. Homeopaths understand the law of similars and and the law of infinitesimals. If a substance can create a symptom, the same substance given in very dilute solution has an opposite, therapeutic effect. For instance, homeopathic preparations of coffee are used as a treatment for insomnia. Homeopathic remedies are often diluted to such a degree that not a single molecule of the active ingredient remains, however, the memory of the original substance alters the energetic field of the solvent, enhancing the therapeutic effect.
It has recently been discovered that the principles of homeopathy can be applied to firefighting. Sodium is an alkali metal. In its elemental form it is highly reactive, and will spontaneously burst into flame when exposed to moisture. A homeopathic preparation of sodium (200C or 1 part sodium in 100²ºº parts water) is an excellent remedy for combustion. In accordance with the law of infinitesimals, higher dilutions are even more effective. In a recent study, fires treated with homeopathic sodium were extinguished much faster, and caused significantly less structural damage than untreated fires. Other effective homeopathic firefighting preparations include: lithium, arsenic, cobra venom, thyroid hormone, sulfur, Tobasco, and bee-vomit. A recent study by the NCCAFF (National Center for Complementary and Alternative Fire Fighting) suggest that aqueous preparations are more effective than tinctures.
America is a diverse society. It is time for Big Hydrant to relinquish its stranglehold on the choices of the public. The sooner that alternative philosophies of combustion are accepted, the sooner those in need will have choice in their journey to the state of true oxidative homeostasis. This will be achieved only when all philosophies are recognized and allowed to work together. We are grateful to advocates of integrative oncology for paving the way for our efforts.

Responding to Dr. Vinay Prasad’s “dunking on a 7′ hoop” criticism of SBM
Last week, Dr. Vinay Prasad decided to resurrect his misguided criticism from over a year ago likening SBM-style criticisms of alternative medicine to “dunking on a 7′ hoop”. Why he would decide to renew his attack on combating science disinformation in the middle of a pandemic that has killed close to 300,000 Americans alone we don’t know, but Drs. Novella and Gorski could not let such an off-base attack go unanswered.
David Gorski on December 13, 2020
Link

Last week, a prominent academic oncologist named Dr. Vinay Prasad published an article in MedPage Today entitled “Applying Skepticism to Medical Skepticism“. (I know, I know, the whole “skeptical of skeptics” or “skeptical of skepticism” bit is a tired, unoriginal, and unimaginative trope that never ceases to irritate skeptics and supporters of science-based medicine when we see it.) In a clear shot across the bow of this blog, though, the eminent Dr. Prasad’s article was subtitled: “Debunking should focus on areas most in need — which might not be homeopathy”. Further making it clear that he was referring to us and those like us here at SBM who devote a lot of time to deconstructing the bad science and pseudoscience behind a lot of claims of alternative medicine and the antivaccine movement, Dr. Prasad doubled down on an analogy he’d made before, that of “dunking on a 7′ hoop”:
A year ago, I got myself in trouble on Twitter. I tweeted a video of a man dunking on a basketball hoop. The young man took a big dribble and leapt into the air. The camera panned outward. He appeared to soar, defying gravity like Lebron James. He raised the ball up high and brought it down in a monster jam on the hoop. The camera continued to pan outward, and it became clear — the hoop was not the regulation 10-foot rim, but something much smaller. The man appeared to be dunking on a 7-foot hoop. My tweet went something like this “Dunking on alternative medicine is like dunking on a 7-foot hoop; let’s raise it back up to 10 feet.”
Basically, the whole thesis behind his post and analogy is that “dunking” on alternative medicine is so easy (like LeBron James dunking on a 7′ hoop) that it’s a waste of a physician’s intellectual firepower to bother with it. Instead, argues Dr. Prasad, we skeptics who’ve been “debunking” homeopathy should do what he does and devote our intellectual firepower to bad science in medicine and to conventional medical interventions for which the scientific evidence is not robust. In his post, he basically seems to think that all we at SBM and other skeptics do is “dunk on” homeopathy, jade eggs, and other Goop-like nonsense marketed to people with, as British comedians David Mitchell and Robert Webb once put it describing homeopathy, “more money than sense.”
Of course, the first time that Dr. Prasad made his argument on Twitter and in an episode of his podcast, which was late last year, a number of skeptics, myself included, responded by pointing out that we do, in fact, also do exactly what he said we should be doing and that dissecting clinical trials of various alternative medicine requires very much the same sort of skillset that dissecting any other clinical trial does, plus the additional skillset of knowing the alternative medicine claims and why they are pseudoscience. Sadly, Dr. Prasad revealed the disingenuousness behind his attacks by portraying such arguments as a tacit admission that we “medical skeptics” actually agreed with him that what he does is so much more important than what we do. Even so, ultimately he deleted a whole lot of those Tweets, for whatever reason, and blocked a lot of us on Twitter.
Why Dr. Prasad decided now to double down on his original analogy, who knows? What Steve Novella and I do know is that Dr. Prasad’s argument and dismissal of what skeptics do with respect to unscientific claims are particularly irresponsible during a pandemic in which unscientific claims about COVID-19, rooted in conspiracy theories, have arguably led to many tens of thousands more deaths by provoking uncertainty, distrust, and outright fear and hostility over masks, social distancing, and other public health interventions, and, now that the Pfizer COVID-19 vaccine has been granted emergency use authorization by the FDA and the Moderna vaccine is likely soon to follow suit, about vaccines. That’s why we wrote rebuttals on Friday:
    • “Skeptical of Skepticism regarding Medical Skepticism“, in which Steve Novella basically makes fun of the “skeptical of skepticism” trope in the title of Dr. Prasad’s article before explaining how Dr. Prasad goes wrong and observes that, when it comes to what skeptics do (and even how pervasive alternative medicine and antivaccine claims are), Dr. Prasad does not know what he is talking about.
    • “Dunking on a 7′ hoop, or: Refuting Dr. Vinay Prasad’s attack on medical skepticism“, in which a certain alter-ego does the same, only with more—shall we say?—insolence.
As editor of SBM and someone who has spent the last two decades dealing with harmful pseudoscientific varieties of medicine, such as cancer quackery and the antivaccine movement, all I can say is that it is very depressing to see that, 24 years after Carl Sagan’s death, academics like Dr. Prasad still don’t “get it,” to the point of still viewing science communication about things that they don’t consider intellectually challenging with such contempt and disdain. It’s particularly frustrating how, during a pandemic that has killed close to 300,000 Americans and still rapidly counting, Dr. Prasad can’t see the connection between “debunking” homeopathy and combatting the sort of conspiracy theory-based pseudoscience, misinformation, and disinformation that is contributing to making that death toll continue to climb. Dr. Prasad and we skeptics should be natural allies, as our areas of focus are complementary. It’s a shame he doesn’t see it that way.

AI And Pseudoscience
Steven Novella on August 5, 2026
Link

We have to deal with artificial intelligence (AI). We cannot simply dismiss it or criticize it, and we certainly shouldn’t just embrace it without significant skepticism. But I feel it is necessary for any science communicator to do their best to become AI-literate – even if AI itself is not your field of communication. AI now touches everything.
For example, increasingly people are searching the internet using AI. About 43-48% of Google searches trigger an AI summary, AI chat tools handle over 50% of search volume, and 37% of users begin their search with an AI tool. Further, many people have “discussions” with chatbots about a topic they are interested in to learn more about it. Increasingly we are getting our information filtered through AI, or explicitly composed by AI. This can have several concerning effects.
Several problems are well-documented, including that chatbots can hallucinate. It is important to understand that large language models (LLMs), the technology on which chatbots are built, are not really logic machines, they are prediction machines. Their output can be uncanny, but they do not really understand anything. They are really good at predicting language responses, partly because they are heavily trained on massive sets of data. LLMs are generative – they generate text based on their training data and internal algorithms. What this means it they can entirely make stuff up by generating text that is not true but resembles information which is out there on the internet and in their training data. They can even make up fake references, all properly formatted.
Even when information they provide is not a strict hallucination, it is just reflecting the weight of information on the internet. So in essence you are asking – what are most people saying about this on the internet? This may be fine for simple facts or uncontroversial topics, but don’t necessarily expect a rigorous analysis of a controversial topic.
I say “necessarily” because you might get a good analysis. It largely depends on your prompt and your history with your chatbot. LLMs not only reflect the biases in their training data, they reflect the biases of the user. Often this amounts to what is called the “sycophancy problem” – LLMs are programed to please their users, they are effusive with praise, and tend to “yes and” their users. This means you can have a conversation with a chatbot, and think that you are getting useful feedback and even criticism, but there is a massive bias toward affirming your biases and praising your ideas. In the end you may be convinced that you have created something brilliant and useful, when the AI has essentially just gaslighted you into believing so.
All of the above amounts to a serious limitation of current chatbots, but they can be mitigated to a large degree by a savvy user. You can prompt a chatbot to be skeptical, to not be sycophantic, to make the strongest case for the other side, to be harshly critical – and all of this will affect the outcome. AI, ultimately, is a powerful but flawed tool, and can be useful if used carefully, thoughtfully, and skeptically. I am not saying you should use it, just that outcomes vary wildly based upon the habits of the user.
Which leads to the final problem with AI, which I call the oracle problem. Many users are not savvy, and they use chatbots as if they are an unassailable oracle of definitive information. Increasingly I am getting e-mails or messages from those defensing a specific pseudoscience, and their “evidence” is output from a chatbot. Here is an example, from Dana Ullman, a homeopathy apologist we have discussed here many times.
Ullman, in my opinion, is a classic pseudoscientist – he tries to portray what he is doing as scientific, but he gets it consistently an horribly wrong. What prompted his most recent e-mail to me was an accusation that we are “censoring” him because we are afraid. In actuality his comment was simply flagged as spam by Discus (a common occurence, as is the knee-jerk accusation of fear-based censorship).
One of his e-mails contained this statement:
“One of the strongest statements verifying the efficacy of homeopathic medicines was the confirmation that four of the five leading previous systematic reviews of homeopathic research found a benefit from homeopathic treatment over that of placebo: ‘Five systematic reviews have examined the RCT research literature on homeopathy as a whole, including the broad spectrum of medical conditions that have been researched and by all forms of homeopathy: four of these ‘global’ systematic reviews reached the conclusion that, with important caveats, the homeopathic intervention probably differs from placebo.’
Mathie RT, Lloyd SM, Legg LA, Clausen J, Moss S, Davidson JR, Ford I. Randomised placebo-controlled trials of individualised homeopathic treatment: systematic review and meta-analysis. Systematic Reviews 2014; 3:142. doi:10.1186/2046-4053-3-142″
Essentially he is proving our case while naively thinking he is proving his own. All he is demonstrating is that he does not understand the nature of scientific evidence. He thinks this is the “strongest” case for homeopathy – a luke warm review from 2014. He did not quote the statement from the conclusion: ” The low or unclear overall quality of the evidence prompts caution in interpreting the findings.”
All he can do is quote “low or unclear quality” evidence, as the best case for homeopathy. I recount this to demonstrate his clear biases. He also states in this e-mail chain:
“I challenge you to debate ChatGPT on the subject of explaining how homeopathic nanodoses CAN have biological and physiological effects. YOU can even do some homework by reading 3 of my previous published conversations with ChatGPT at my blog.
I am not asking you to debate me (you’re too afraid)…but heck, are you AFRAID of ChatGPT?”
What do you get when a pseudoscientist prompts a chatbot – pseudoscience. But always game, I prompted ChatGPT with “Is there any clinical evidence that any specific homeopathic treatment has efficacy beyond placebo?” ChatGPT’s conclusion statement reads:
“There are positive clinical signals and isolated positive trials for several homeopathic treatments, but no specific homeopathic remedy–condition pairing currently has convincing, reproducible evidence of efficacy beyond placebo.
That is slightly more precise than saying “there is absolutely no clinical evidence,” but it still does not support prescribing any homeopathic treatment as an evidence-based therapy.”
I wonder if the nuances of my prompt resulted in a more science-based conclusion than Ullman’s rabbit hole of sycophancy.
I next prompted: “is there any basic science to support that homeopathic-level nanodoses can have biological effects?” And its response”
“The short answer is yes, but only in a very limited sense. There is basic science showing that extremely small numbers of molecules (even single molecules, in some contexts) can have biological effects. However, there is no convincing basic science supporting the core claims of homeopathy, particularly for the high dilutions used in classical homeopathy (typically beyond about 12C or 24X, where no molecules of the original substance are expected to remain).”
In homeopathic products, there is typically no active ingredient remaining. Originally the homeopathic preparation was supposed to contain the “essence” of the starting material, but such claims have not aged well scientifically. So modern homeopaths moved on to structured water – the original substance is not there but the water “remembers”. They still use this rationalization, but the evidence is not there – structures in water are fleeting and could not survive to have biological effects. There is also no evidence that such structures reflect the original substance in any meaningful way. Now they have moved on to “nanodoses”, but as ChatGPT correctly reflected, most homeopathic products don’t even contain nanodoses. Further, “biological effects” is not the same thing as clinically meaningful effects. None of this handwaving even addresses the other scientific problem with homeopathy – that the starting materials are fanciful (sometimes are not even real) and have no plausible connection to remedies.
So Ullman likely was just getting reflected back from ChatGPT his own pseudoscientific biases, and selectively interprets the results with those same biases, as he did above.
All of this is why we must do our best to understand and deal with AI. AI is increasingly the medium through which pseudoscience is being spread, and it is engendering an unearned confidence in its biased results.



   Law and Politics

The Swiss Report on Homeopathy
Proponents of homeopathy claim that a Swiss report published in 2012 vindicates homeopathy. The report was actually authored by homeopaths, who used an artificially low standard of evidence to conclude what they were selling actually works. This ignores the improbability of homeopathy, and the many other reviews that have concluded it is nothing more than a placebo.
Steven Novella on June 27, 2012
Link
In 2011 the Swiss government completed an official examination of homeopathy, as part of its consideration of whether or not insurance companies should be made to cover homeopathic treatment. Their report, which concluded homeopathy is effective and should be covered, was published in English in February 2012. Not surprisingly, homeopathy promoters, like Dana Ullman writing for the Huffington Post, were quick to proclaim the virtues of the Swiss report and tout it as evidence for the effectiveness of homeopathy. Recently, however, a more critical review of the Swiss report has been published, revealing the report to be biased and scientifically suspect.
Ullman begins his crowing about the Swiss report with this dubious statement:
The Swiss government has a long and widely-respected history of neutrality, and therefore, reports from this government on controversial subjects need to be taken more seriously than other reports from countries that are more strongly influenced by present economic and political constituencies.
Political neutrality is not equivalent to being scientifically unbiased. Ullman, and other homeopaths, however, are keen to prefer the Swiss report over other government reports. This is because in 2010 the UK government performed their own systematic review of homeopathy – Evidence Check 2: Homeopathy. In their report they concluded that homeopathy is essentially witchcraft – that it does not work, its underlying principles are scientifically invalid and tantamount to magic, that it should not be covered by the national health service, and that it is not even worth any further research. Ullman strangely does not mention this report directly in his article.
How can two governments analyze the same question with the same set of data and come to opposite conclusions? The review of the Swiss report, by David Martin Shaw, gives us a clue. He writes:
This paper analyses the report and concludes that it is scientifically, logically and ethically flawed. Specifically, it contains no new evidence and misinterprets studies previously exposed as weak; creates a new standard of evidence designed to make homeopathy appear effective; and attempts to discredit randomised controlled trials as the gold standard of evidence. Most importantly, almost all the authors have conflicts of interest, despite their claim that none exist. If anything, the report proves that homeopaths are willing to distort evidence in order to support their beliefs, and its authors appear to have breached Swiss Academies of Arts and Sciences principles governing scientific integrity.
The data they looked at was the same – scientific studies showing that homeopathy does not work. Published systematic reviews of clinical trials of homeopathy do not show evidence that homeopathy has any physiological effect. Edzard Ernst reviewing these reviews concludes:
The findings of currently available Cochrane reviews of studies of homeopathy do not show that homeopathic medicines have effects beyond placebo.
What is very telling is that even reviews of homeopathic trials that try to put a positive spin on the data can’t help giving away the game, such as the conclusion of this review from France (perhaps the center of support for homeopathy):
There is some evidence that homeopathic treatments are more effective than placebo; however, the strength of this evidence is low because of the low methodological quality of the trials. Studies of high methodological quality were more likely to be negative than the lower quality studies. Further high quality studies are needed to confirm these results.
They are looking at the same evidence as Ernst but desperately try to focus on the positive – there is some evidence of effect. But high quality studies were more likely to be negative. That pattern is what tells the tale. If you look at the literature of any scientific question what you see is an inverse relationship between study quality and the spread of results. Low quality studies are all over the place, while high quality studies tend to zero in on the true effect size of what is being studied (in the case of homeopathy, zero). Basing any conclusions on the low quality studies is pure nonsense and an indication of bias.
Further, the low quality studies are not randomly scattered but often show systematic bias toward being positive, both researcher and publication bias. This bias can sometimes be revealed in so-called funnel plots, which graphically display the relationship between study quality and outcome.
What all this means is that if you want to actually answer the question, does homeopathy work, you need to rely upon the most rigorously designed placebo-controlled trials. Anything less is likely to reflect bias and be highly misleading. Systematic reviews generally reflect this, and the UK report on homeopathy reflected this reality – when properly studied, homeopathy does not work.
The Swiss study looked at the same data, but apparently wanted to come to a favorable conclusion. So they argued for a change in the normal rules of evidence, a common strategy among CAM proponents. They decided to rely more on “real-world effectiveness,” which is just CAM newspeak for “poorly controlled studies.” In the real world we cannot control for variables and blind subjects – those are artificial conditions of rigorous trials. Homeopaths are not the only ones to try this gambit. Acupuncturists, for example, have been trying to push “pragmatic” studies as if they were efficacy studies, which they are not (again, because they study “real-world” conditions and are not properly controlled).
In other words, this is all an elaborate deception as a means of preferring low quality studies that are amenable to a positive bias to rigorous studies that are more likely to reflect the true (non-existent) effect of homeopathy. Pragmatic studies are meant only to compare treatments that have already been demonstrated to have efficacy in rigorous trials. They are not a substitute for double-blind placebo controlled trials, and they certainly should not be used to trump the results of more rigorous trials.
In his critical analysis Shaw zeroes in on the bias evident in the Swiss report, quoting:
If homeopathy is highly likely to be effective but this cannot be consistently proven in clinical trials, the question arises of what conditions are needed for homeopathy to show its effectiveness and realise its potential, and what conditions threaten to obscure this?
In this statement they are assuming homeopathy works, but are frustrated by the fact that high quality clinical trials show that it does not work, therefore they want to find a kind of evidence that will fit their pre-determined conclusion and help them to promote homeopathy. This is what Ullman concludes is unbiased. Rather, this is a core feature of CAM and even pseudoscience in general – starting with a desired conclusion and then looking for evidence to support it.
Shaw also points out that the majority of the authors of the Swiss report were in fact homeopaths. There was only one medically qualified expert on the panel who was not a homeopath or CAM practitioner. The fix, clearly, was in. And yet they declared no conflicts of interest. Shaw is very clear in his condemnation of this lack of scientific integrity:
The ethos of the research integrity guideline is that “Scientific misconduct must not be tolerated.” In this case, it has not only been tolerated but given the stamp of approval by the Swiss government and used to inform health policy: from January 2012, homeopathy will be included in health insurance cover, contributing in part to a rise in insurance premiums of as much as 4.4%.
Conclusion: The main product of CAM is deception
The Swiss report represents a biased review largely by homeopaths who changed the rules of evidence in order to declare that homeopathy works. Other homeopaths then present this review as unbiased and definitive. This is behavior that would make even the most unscrupulous pharmaceutical rep blush.
This is also, unfortunately, not an isolated incident. This represents a general strategy apparent in the world of CAM – to present themselves as the experts so that they can pack panels with proponents and then advocate for changing the normal rules of scientific evidence in order to produce highly biased assessments of CAM. Further, they portray skeptics (meaning those who advocate for consistent and rigorous scientific methods) to be biased so that when they point out that the emperor has no clothes they can be dismissed.
The Swiss report on homeopathy represents an embarrassing failure for the Swiss government. They should suspend any decisions based upon this report and put together an new scientific panel to perform a fresh and legitimate review of homeopathy. Or, they don’t have to reinvent the wheel – they can just review the UKs thorough and rigorous report and adopt its findings. Homeopathy is witchcraft and deserves no government support of any kind.

Homeopathic regulation diluted until no substance left
Jann Bellamy on April 4, 2013
Link

Homeopathy is quackery but it is perfectly legal to prescribe homeopathic products and to sell them directly to consumers in the United States as well as other supposedly civilized countries such as the United Kingdom and Germany. This makes as much sense as allowing the sale of batteries that don’t produce electricity.
What makes this state of affairs even stranger is that homeopathic products are classified as drugs under U.S. law. Does this mean that they undergo the same pre-market approval process and are subject to the same post-market requirements as pharmaceutical drugs? No, not by a long shot. In fact, the federal government and the FDA have pretty much handed regulation of homeopathic products over to their manufacturers.
How did this happen?
In 1938, Congress passed the Food, Drugs and Cosmetics Act. The Act’s principle author was Senator Royal Copeland, a physician who practiced homeopathy. He managed to include all articles monographed in the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS) in the definition of drugs within the FDCA, although why he did so remains in dispute. The HPUS is a source for monographs, identity, methods of manufacture, standards and controls and potency levels of homeopathic products, both prescription and OTC. (The vast majority of homeopathic products are OTC.) In short, if the product is in the HPUS, it’s legal.
Since the FDCA’s enactment, any attempt at imposing any reasonable regulation of these products has failed. As noted in a previous post, a federal district judge found that:
“As evidenced by the FDA guidance documents. . .the Court concludes that the FDA has largely abdicated any role it might have had in creating standards for homeopathic OTC drugs, and has instead attempted to delegate this authority to the non-governmental organization that determines whether homeopathic substances should be included in the HPUS. In addition, the FDA explicitly states that it makes no guarantee about the safety or efficacy of homeopathic OTC drugs even if they meet the unknown standards for inclusion in the HPUS.”
As explained in one excellent review of homeopathic product regulation reprinted on Quackwatch, part of the reason is that, all along, regulators and politicians thought that surely the demise of homeopathy was right around the corner and the problem would solve itself. Here they were partially correct. The practice of traditional homeopathy has all but died out, and only three states actually license practicing homeopaths, who must be medical doctors. Unfortunately, no one seemed to see the boom in over-the-counter homeopathic product sales coming, which in the U.S. amounted to $3.1 billion in 2007. And while traditional homeopaths may go the way of the horse and buggy, “integrative” medical doctors and naturopaths are taking up the slack.
Both the lack of regulation and the sales boom are directly attributable to the visionary leadership of the homeopathic product industry, specifically one John A. Borneman, III. Borneman made these claims during his Founder’s Day Address at the University of the Sciences in Philadelphia, upon the occasion of his being awarded an honorary doctorate. The University of the Sciences was formerly known as the Philadelphia College of Pharmacy and Science, and holds an honored place in the history of pharmacy education as the first college of pharmacy in the U.S., established in 1821. SBM’s own David J. Kroll, Ph.D., obtained his undergraduate degree in toxicology there and was, needless to say, distressed to learn that his alma mater was awarding an honorary Doctorate of Science degree to this man. In 2009, Kroll protested to the University’s president in a characterization that may inform your opinion of Mr. Borneman when we return to his explanation of how homeopathy has escaped regulation.
I wish to register my strongest objection to the recognition and University endorsement of an individual who has led an organization dedicated to the most egregious form of pseudoscience in pharmacy: homeopathic medicines. Awarding Mr. Borneman an Honorary Doctor of Science is an affront to every scientist who has ever earned a degree from the University and, I would suspect, all current faculty members who are engaged in scientific investigation.
Homeopathy is a fraudulent representation of pharmacy and the pharmaceutical sciences that continues to exist in the United States due solely to political, not scientific, reasons. . .But scientifically, homeopathic remedies are nothing more than highly-purified water misrepresented as medicine based upon an archaic practice that is diametrically opposed to all pharmacological principles. The mental gymnastics required to teach chemistry, pharmacology, and therapeutics while also embracing homeopathy are beyond the skills of anyone trained in the scientific method.
In awarding an Honorary Doctor of Science to Mr. Borneman, the University will be endorsing an “entrepreneurial spirit” that seeks to defraud health care consumers with “potentized” water as a medicine to treat and prevent disease. . .To reward Mr. Borneman’s leadership of a pseudoscience practice and its marketing to a public that holds pharmacy among the most trusted of professions is to return to the days of snake oil and deception that our founders worked tirelessly to remedy.
(You can read about University president’s response here.)
Borneman was a principal in his family’s homeopathic products company. He then joined Standard Homeopathic Company, of which Hyland’s is a subsidiary, as well as creating Homeopathic Laboratories of Pennsylvania and TxOptions Pharmacy, which also provides advice to consumers about homeopathic remedies.
In his Founder’s Day remarks, Borneman spoke of three pivotal events which guaranteed that the homeopathic products industry would be in complete control of their own regulation.
First, in the 1980s, there was an attempt to regulate all homeopathic products as prescription drugs. The FDA postponed any action toward that end by consulting with the homeopathic product manufacturers. The FDA ultimately decided it didn’t have the expertise to know what to do, so the agency left it up to the industry to draft a Compliance Policy Guide (CPG), which are directives from the agency to personnel providing guidance on a particular issue. The industry naturally obliged, the result being Compliance Policy Guide (CPG) 7132.15, “Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs may be Marketed.” Borneman is refreshingly (although perhaps unintentionally) honest about how the industry wrote the rules in this instance:
We sent them a streamlined document in 1983, and a revision in June 1986. They [FDA] circulated it internally for review & comment, including the Justice Department, and published a document in the Federal Register in June 1988. It was enforced in 1990 and still, unmodified, continues to be effective today. The CPG put to rest the OTC/Rx controversy. . .With the CPG well established, homeopathy in the US was investable and the Europeans seized the opportunity and purchased outright or appropriated almost all of the languishing American firms.
Fortunately for the Borneman family, the “investable” companies included his own, Borneman & Sons, which entered into a joint venture with Boiron, a French company and the world’s largest manufacturer of homeopathic products.
Enter the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States
That task out of the way, Borneman next concentrated on “refurbishing” the HPUS and the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States (HPCUS). The HPCUS decides what can be included in the HPUS, which, as you recall, is incorporated wholesale into the definition of “drug” under federal law. As I said, if it’s in the HPUS, it’s legal. As he explained:
I understood that regulators would not act favorably if it appeared I was looking out for the industry or myself. Economics could not be an issue. I had to make the argument that the consumer had rights and FDA could not disenfranchise them. They were obligated to accommodate the consumer. This struck a chord and the work began.
And here I was thinking that the FDA had some duty to actually protect the consumer, not accommodate. What really occurred was that the FDA apparently felt it had an obligation to accommodate the homeopathic product manufacturers. What happened next exceeded Borneman’s most optimistic expectations and was the third and final step in assuring that the industry gained control of its own regulation.
Borneman and other industry representatives met with Mark Novitch, MD, Deputy Commissioner of the FDA, and put on their dog and pony show. Two presenters were practicing MD homeopaths, Sandra Chase and David Riley, who explained “Basic Tenets, Corollaries, basic features, provings and methods of Cure.” (Cure?) Others were homeopathic pharmacists. Borneman continues:
I believed the meeting went well, but was not prepared for what was to follow. Dr. Novich told us the Agency was not prepared to run a new drug review and approval process for homeopathic drugs. . .Dr. Novich liked what he had seen and heard and asked if we would serve as the gatekeeper for new homeopathic drugs. We eagerly accepted the task and have been rigorous in its implementation since.
Having already dumped the entire homeopathic formulary into federal law in 1938 and succeeded in fending off regulation of original or added products since then, the homeopathic industry was thus poised to secure its future as the sole arbiter of what homeopathic products could be legally sold in the U.S. And all of this with only occasional interference by the FDA when products were, say, harming infants or causing loss of the ability to smell.
So, how does the HPCUS operate? Does it, for example, include public or consumer representatives? Does it have a process for insuring that those who do not share the view that homeopathy is safe or effective are included to provide a more balanced view? Let’s find out by looking at the organization’s own Bylaws and Procedure Manual.
The HPCUS is a non-profit corporation. It controls both the addition of new products and changes to existing ones. Application for inclusion of a new product must be supported by a monograph which goes through various committees for review and there is a period for public comment, although access to the monographs for comment is via homeopathy journals. Changes to the products already listed in the HPUS also go through a committee review process.
Proving nothing
Products are reviewed for safety and effectiveness by these committees. As to the latter, according to one journal article, while the traditional homeopathic proving is one way to approach this,
Overall, adequately designed and well-controlled clinical trials have become the norm for homeopathic medicine as they are for most allopathic [sic] medicines.
I don’t know of any such trials, but perhaps adequately designed and well-controlled has a different meaning in homeopathic research. Of course, the conclusion of this same article was
Homeopathic drugs in the United States are subject to well-defined regulatory processes that more closely resemble those that apply to allopathic medications than to dietary supplements.
So it is advisable to take the article’s conclusions with a grain of undiluted salt. Of the two authors, one was John P. (“Jay”) Borneman, John A. Borneman’s son. Jay is a principal owner of Standard Homeopathic Company and CEO of Hyland’s.
Once a product or change is approved, that information is incorporated into the HPUS, which is sold by the HPCUS to the public through subscription. For $100, you can get access for 24 hours. It is $1,000 per year for an individual and $15,000 per year for a corporate subscription.
More interesting than the process are the persons who are making these decisions. Membership in the HPCUS is vetted by the Board of Directors. Committees responsible for reviewing both new products and changes to the HPUS are appointed by the President, who is a member of, and chosen by, the Board. All final decisions on what is and isn’t included in the HPUS must be approved by the Board. And who chooses the Board? The Board. It is self-perpetuating and not elected by the members, so each Board elects new Board members. While a Board term is three years, there is no limit on the number of terms a Board member can serve.
So let’s see who is on the Board of the HPCUS. Because it has been granted charitable organization status (501(c)(3)) by the IRS, it does not pay federal income tax on contributions or earnings from subscription sales but it must file a federal tax return, which becomes public information. These returns list the current Board of Directors and are available for the last three years (2011, 2010, 2009) through Guidestar.
For 2009-2011, Chair of the Board is none other than John A. Borneman III, who has to be at least in his 80s. President of the Board (that is, the person who appoints all the committees reviewing HPUS additions and changes) is his son Jay. But they are not they only two Standard/Hyland’s connected directors. Another is Mark S. Phillips, who is Standard’s President. (A 2011 warning letter from the FDA to Phillips can be viewed here.) The Secretary and Treasurer are Sandra Chase and William Shevin, respectively, the two MD homeopaths who helped convince the FDA to allow self-regulation back in 1993. Rounding out the Board are David Riley, a homeopathic physician and “integrative medicine” consultant, and Eric Foxman, a homeopathic pharmacist. The Executive Director in 2009, since deceased, was Andy Bormeth, who also worked for a homeopathic products manufacturer before he opened his own homeopathic products consulting service. For 2010 and 2011, Todd Hoover, another homeopathic physician, served on the Board.
Conclusion: Conflicts of interest and homeopathic regulation
In summary, all decisions on the content of the HPUS (and therefore what may be legally sold or prescribed as a homeopathic product) are made by either practicing homeopaths, homeopathic pharmacists, or current or former officials or owners of homeopathic products manufacturing companies. And three are from a single company! Does this seem a bit too cozy? Does anyone think the Board is going to elect Board members who will rock the boat? Or who might be the least bit interested in telling the public the truth about homeopathy?
To be fair, the HPCUS does have a conflict of interest policy which requires disclosure of conflicts and recusal from deciding issues which may affect them financially. (Which makes me wonder how they get anything done, considering.) Even so, it is appalling that the federal government has totally defaulted in its responsibility for determining what homeopathic drugs can be prescribed and sold to a private non-profit completely controlled by industry insiders.
In my last post, I suggested that instead of the Quack Miranda Warning a more accurate disclaimer of FDA involvement in dietary supplement regulation might be:
FDA WARNING: Safety and effectiveness unknown. Use at your own risk.
Perhaps a more accurate FDA disclaimer for homeopathic product regulation might be:
FDA WARNING: Safety unknown. Effectiveness unknown but highly unlikely. Use at your own risk.

Should the FDA crack down on homeopathic “remedies”?
Scott Gavura on March 26, 2015
Link

In the category of potentially dangerous complementary or alternative medicine, I can think of few products worse than ones claimed to relieve asthma, yet don’t actually contain any medicine. Yet these products exist and are widely sold. Just over a year ago I described what might be the most irresponsible homeopathic treatment ever: A homeopathic asthma spray. If there was ever a complementary or alternative product that could cause serious harm, this is it:

Among the different treatments and remedies that are considered “alternative” medicine, homeopathy is the most implausible of all. Homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, where the “remedies” lack any actual medicine. Based on the idea that “like cures like” (which is sympathetic magic, not science), proponents of homeopathy believe that any substance can be an effective remedy if it’s diluted enough: cancer, boar testicles, crude oil, oxygen, and skim milk are all homeopathic “remedies”. (I think Berlin Wall may be my favorite, though vacuum cleaner dust is a runner-up). The dilution in the case of homeopathy is so significant that there’s mathematically no possibility of even a trace of the original ingredient in the typical remedy – they are chemically indistinguishable from a placebo. To homeopaths, this is a good thing, as dilution is claimed to make the medicine-free “remedy” more potent, not less. As would be expected with inert products, rigorous clinical trials confirm what basic science (and math) predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. Recently Steven Novella blogged about the Australian Government’s National Health and Medical Research Council’s (NHMRC) comprehensive report on homeopathy which concluded the following:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.
Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness. People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner and should keep taking any prescribed treatments.
The National Health and Medical Research Council expects that the Australian public will be offered treatments and therapies based on the best available evidence.
Despite the implausibility of homeopathy and the lack of any convincing evidence it is effective, homeopathy continues to enjoy modest popularity as an “alternative” medicine system, and some national health care systems have even funded treatments. In the United States, the Food and Drug Administration is responsible for regulating homeopathy – and it does so, with a very loose hand. If you want to sell a homeopathic remedy in the United States, you are not required to show that your product actually works. Unlike prescription drugs, there are no requirements for clinical trials at all. Yet these products can be legally sold. Thanks to a former US Senator who was a homeopathy fan, any product listed in the US Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia (HPUS) is by definition a drug to the FDA, and therefore falls under its purview. Alec Gaffney, in a nice summary of the regulatory framework, notes that the FDA relies on a Compliance Policy Guide (CPG), Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs May be Marketed, which defines labelling and manufacturing standards for homeopathic products. Those regulatory standards, are in a word, homeopathic themselves. The framework puts the FDA in a difficult situation, such as licensing these products as “drugs” while simultaneously acknowledging that there’s no evidence to show homeopathy works:
FDA is not aware of scientific evidence to support homeopathy as effective.
Do the current FDA standards provide adequate consumer protection, given the marketing of homeopathy for the treatment of very real conditions, like asthma? These products may be labelled “not a rescue inhaler”, but it’s fair to ask why they are sold at all, when they offer no plausible benefit. Last week the FDA issued a warning about homeopathic asthma inhalers:
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration is warning consumers not to rely on asthma products labeled as homeopathic that are sold over-the-counter (OTC). These products have not been evaluated by the FDA for safety and effectiveness.
and
OTC asthma products labeled as homeopathic are widely distributed through retail stores and via the internet. Many of these products are promoted as “natural,” “safe and effective,” and include indications that range from treatment for acute asthma symptoms, to temporary relief of minor asthma symptoms. In general, consumers can identify such products by looking for the word “HOMEOPATHIC” or “HOMŒOPATHIC” on a product’s label and looking for whether the product’s active ingredient(s) are listed in terms of dilution (e.g., “LM1” “6X” or “30C”).
Homeopathic asthma sprays are indeed widely sold, not just by Target, but by other pharmacies and online.
Now the FDA has announced plans to re-evaluate the homeopathy regulation framework, something I’m sure my American co-bloggers will applaud:
The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is announcing a public hearing to obtain information and comments from stakeholders about the current use of human drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic, as well as the Agency’s regulatory framework for such products. These products include prescription drugs and biological products labeled as homeopathic and over-the-counter (OTC) drugs labeled as homeopathic. FDA is seeking participants for the public hearing and written comments from all interested parties, including, but not limited to, consumers, patients, caregivers, health care professionals, patient groups, and industry. FDA is seeking input on a number of specific questions, but is interested in any other pertinent information participants would like to share.
The event will be held April 20-21 in Silver Spring, Maryland. Registration is free (there will be a webcast) and you can even make an oral presentation. I strongly encourage anyone able to participate and give a science-based perspective to register and do so. It’s clear that the FDA recognizes that homeopathy is ineffective. So what does adequate and appropriate regulation, from an FDA perspective look like? Let’s hope it ensures that products like “homeopathic asthma sprays” will become a thing of the past.
More Reading
Homeopathic regulation diluted until no substance left
CAM and the Law Part 4: Regulation of Supplements and Homeopathic Remedies
An Alternative Perspective: Homeopathic Drugs, Royal Copeland, and Federal Drug Regulation

How should the FDA regulate homeopathic remedies?
Jann Bellamy on April 2, 2015
Link


The FDA announced recently that it is holding a public hearing on April 21 and 22,
to obtain information and comments from stakeholders about the current use of human drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic, as well as the Agency’s regulatory framework for such products. These products include prescription drugs and biological products labeled as homeopathic and over-the-counter (OTC) drugs labeled as homeopathic. FDA is seeking participants for the public hearing and written comments from all interested parties, including, but not limited to, consumers, patients, caregivers, health care professionals, patient groups, and industry.
It’s about time. We know that homeopathic remedies are not, and cannot be, effective. I will not plough that ground again here. Unfortunately, the FDA does not have any authority to bar these fraudulent products from sale altogether. Only Congress can do that.
In this post, I review the current regulatory framework for homeopathic products. I then explore the possibilities, given the opportunities for regulatory change presented by the FDA at this time. In doing so, I answer some of the questions posed by the FDA in its formal notice of the hearing, printed in the Federal Register.
I argue that the FDA has no statutory authority for the manner in which it currently regulates (or, actually, doesn’t regulate) homeopathic drugs. I further argue this system, largely controlled by the homeopathic industry, must be abandoned, and that there is no reason why homeopathic drugs should not be regulated just like any other OTC or prescription drug.
(Note to those wanting to submit written comments or attend the hearing: there are deadlines and other requirements for participation. You can read those in the Federal Register.)
History
The original Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act (FD&C Act), passed in 1938, authorized the FDA to demand evidence of safety for new drugs, issue standards for food, and conduct factory inspections. Significant to our purposes here, the Act was directed in part at quacks selling adulterated and misbranded remedies throughout the U.S., with little fear of reprisal.
The Kefauver-Harris Amendments of 1962 strengthened the rules for drug safety and, for the first time, required manufacturers to prove their drugs’ effectiveness. In 1992, the FD&C Act was amended again to require the drug industry to bear part of the considerable expense of the drug approval process.
Under the FD&C Act, the definition of “drug” includes:
Articles recognized in the official United States Pharmacopoeia (USP), official Homoeopathic Pharmacopoeia of the United States (HPUS);
articles intended for use in the diagnosis, cure, mitigation, treatment, or prevention of disease in man or other animals; and
articles (other than food) intended to affect the structure or any function of the body of man or other animals.
A homeopathic drug can fall within any of these categories. It can also fall within the definition of a “biologic” under a different federal statute making these products subject to FDA regulation. However, we’ll stick to drugs here.
In the FDA’s own estimation,
the FDA . . . ensures the safety and effectiveness of all drugs [and] biological products . . .
That statement is not entirely true. By its own admission, the FDA does not ensure the safety and effectiveness of homeopathic remedies.
Yet, the FDA’s position is now, and always has been, that nothing in the FD&C Act exempts homeopathic drugs from any approval, adulteration, and misbranding provisions (including labeling requirements) of federal law.
Why, then, does the FDA not require that homeopathic drugs be proven safe and effective prior to marketing? Why has the FDA, in the words of one federal district judge,
largely abdicated any role it might have had in creating standards for homeopathic OTC [over-the-counter] drugs, and has instead attempted to delegate this authority to the non-governmental organization that determines whether homeopathic substances should be included in the HPUS. In addition, the FDA explicitly states that it makes no guarantee about the safety or efficacy of homeopathic OTC drugs even if they meet the unknown standards for inclusion in the HPUS.
(Although the judge was talking about OTC homeopathic drugs, the same is true for the tiny percentage [about 5%] of homeopathic drugs that are prescription only.)
The FDA, like any federal agency, must act only within the authority granted it by Congress. The FDA does not cite any statutory authority for these decisions, and my research didn’t disclose any. It may well be that the FDA, in fact, has no legal authority for its neglect of homeopathic drug regulation.
There are apparently historical reasons for this neglect. For many years, most homeopathic products required a prescription and there were few homeopathic practitioners to write them. There were only a handful of established firms making homeopathic remedies. The FDA had limited resources and did not consider homeopathic products much of a safety risk. Yet, when it did finally act, what it created was, in the view of some, a recipe for a booming OTC homeopathic remedy market.
(For a more complete review of the history of homeopathic drug regulation, or the lack thereof, see Junod SJ. “An Alternative Perspective: Homeopathic Drugs, Royal Copeland, and Federal Drug Regulation,” 55 (1) Food Drug L.J. 161-83 (2000), PMID 12375600, from which I learned the historical reasons for the FDA’s forbearance.)
Since 1988, both prescription and OTC homeopathic drugs have been manufactured and sold without FDA approval under enforcement policies set out in the FDA’s Compliance Policy Guide (CPG) 400.400, “Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs May be Marketed.” This 7-page document pales in comparison to the FDA pre- and post-market regulation of all other drugs and biologics. It basically covers only labeling.
CPGs are not are not regulations or laws and are not enforceable. They merely represent FDA thinking on a particular subject. Most importantly, they do not create or confer any rights for or on any person and do not bind the FDA or the public.
The FDA has now come to question whether this bare-bones guidance is sufficient. The agency cites several reasons for this.
The explosive growth in the OTC homeopathic remedy market. In 2007, Americans spent about $2.9 billion on the purchase of homeopathic medicine. They are being marketed as “natural, safe, and effective alternatives to other prescription and non-prescription products.”
Homeopathic drugs can contain a wide range of substances, including ingredients derived from plants, healthy or disease animals or human sources, minerals and chemicals. These can cause, and have caused, side effects. In 2012, there were over 10,000 reported “poison exposure cases” related to homeopathic agents, the vast majority of those attributed to children 5 and under, some of which required medical treatment.
Q & A
FDA has a list of questions in the Federal Register and encourages comments on these and other matters related to homeopathic remedies. We’ll address several of the questions here.
What are consumer and health care provider attitudes towards human drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic?
Consumers are obviously buying homeopathic remedies because they think they are safe and effective. Otherwise, why would they spend the money and ingest these substances or give them to their families? Yet, they have no reliable, objective information on which to make these decisions. (The internet is rife with unproven claims for homeopathic products.) The only source of label information is from those who are financially interested in the sale of homeopathic products.
Although I do not have statistics, naturopaths are likely the most common prescribers of homeopathic products. There are too few professional homeopaths in practice to account for much of the market and conventional medical providers widely disparage homeopathic remedies. Naturopaths, along with chiropractors and acupuncturists, regularly sell homeopathic products to their patients, giving them a financial interest that is in conflict with their ability to objectively evaluate these remedies.
The opinion of health care practitioners and scientists in general, other than the CAM practitioners just mentioned, is near-universally negative and long-standing. In fact, there are humorous videos widely available on the internet making fun of homeopathy. I will not attempt to catalog the massive amount of evidence that homeopathic remedies are no more effective than placebo, the most recent compilation of which can be found in the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council’s Statement and Advice on Homeopathy. No responsible scientist claims otherwise. The FDA is no doubt aware of the research. I do note, however, that the American Pharmacists Association is also calling for adequate regulation in their policy on homeopathy:
APhA supports the demonstration of safety and efficacy of homeopathic products from adequate, well-designed scientific studies before pharmacists advocate or sell homeopathic products. . .
APhA supports the modification of the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act to require that homeopathic manufacturers provide evidence of efficacy and safety for all products, including products currently in the marketplace.
(Actually, no such modification is necessary as the authority is, and always has been, contained in the FD&C Act and amendments thereto.)
I expect many other voices to join the call for adequate regulation during this process.
Are the current enforcement policies under the CPG appropriate to protect and promote public health in light of the tremendous growth in the homeopathic drug market? Are there alternatives to the current enforcement policies?
No, the CPG is not appropriate. It is wholly inadequate. Yes, there are alternatives.
Actually, the answer to this question is fairly simple. There is no statutory authority in the FD&C or subsequent Acts to carve out an exception for homeopathic drugs, which is essentially what the FDA has done with CPG 400.400. The CPG basically addresses only labeling. It does not require demonstration of safety or efficacy, despite being clearly required by federal law.
In fact, the FDA has abdicated its authority to the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States, a private organization answerable to no one, to decide what homeopathic drugs are on the market. The HPCUS is rife with conflicts of interest. Decisions on the content of the HPUS are made by either practicing homeopaths, homeopathic pharmacists, or current or former officials or owners of homeopathic products manufacturing companies. It is totally controlled by industry insiders. One can only imagine the outcry if a similar organization of Big Pharma companies were calling the shots in deciding which drugs made it to market.
Apparently, the HPCUS believes it is a lawful substitute for the Agency in the drug approval process. An industry representative active in the HPCUS claims that:
Instead of the [FDA’s] new-drug-approval process [for all other drugs], premarket approval for homeopathic drugs is by way of monograph approval by HPCUS. While homeopathic drugs are subject to the FDA’s nonprescription drug review, FDA has not yet used this authority . . .
In fact, Congress has most certainly not given the HPCUS authority to grant pre-market approval. Nor is the FDA’s authority limited to “nonprescription drug review.”
The only solution is to employ the same regulatory scheme for homeopathic drugs as the FDA uses for other prescription and non-prescription drugs. Federal law requires no less.
A large majority of human drug products labeled as homeopathic are marketed as OTC drugs. These products are available for a wide variety of indications, and many of these indications have never been considered for OTC use under a formal regulatory process. What would be an appropriate regulatory process for evaluating such indications for OTC use?
There is no reason the FDA’s formal regulatory process applicable to other OTC drugs should not be employed for homeopathic drugs. Fortunately, there is precedent for a post-market review to bring homeopathic OTC drugs in line with federal law. In fact, this very process is outlined in the FDA’s announcement in the Federal Register.
In 1972, the FDA undertook a massive review of all OTC drugs (and an estimated 100,000 to 500,000 separate ingredients) to determine which could be classified as safe and effective and not misbranded. In accordance with amendments to the FD&C, the FDA was to determine which OTC drugs are generally recognized among qualified experts as safe and effective and not misbranded under prescribed, recommended, or suggested conditions.
However, at the request of homeopathic trade groups, homeopathic remedies were deferred from review. The FDA never returned to the task and OTC homeopathic drugs have never been reviewed by the FDA for safety and efficacy.
There is no reason the FDA should not take up where it left off. A caveat is in order here. While the FDA may feel obligated to include homeopathic proponents among the reviewers, the FDA should not let the proponents have the final say. Nothing in federal law suggests that Congress intended to incorporate the homeopathic industry’s pseudoscientific notions or its low quality studies into law. If the FDA feels otherwise – that it is somehow beholden to prescientific ideas and widely discredited treatments because of Congress’s reference to the HPUS – it can simply proceed under the authority granted it pursuant to the second and third definition of “drug” in the FD&C Act.
Do consumers and health care providers have adequate information to make informed decisions about drug products labeled as homeopathic? If not, what information, including, for example information in labeling, would allow consumers and health care providers to be better informed about products labeled as homeopathic?
No, they do not have adequate information. For one thing, unlike the vast amount of drug information available free to the public on the FDA’s website, there is no objective, substantive, publicly-available homeopathic drug information. The HPUS can be accessed only through an expensive paywall, the proceeds of which go to the HPCUS. Simply following the rules for other OTC drugs, including the transparency legally required in this process, would go a long way toward helping the consumer become better informed.
As a thought exercise, let’s examine the information available on the website of Hyland’s, a homeopathic remedy manufacturer, about one of its homeopathic remedies versus what an OTC label would require if it were not a homeopathic remedy. I am using the website information on the assumption that it is the same as that given on the label. (Actually, in using Latin terms, Hyland’s appears to be violating even the minimal requirements of CPG 400.400.)
According to Hyland’s, its “4 Kids Complete Allergy” is a “safe, effective formula for children 2-12 years old.” The only warning is that it should not be used to treat food allergies. The product, according to the website,
temporarily relieves the symptoms of hay fever, indoor and outdoor allergens including itchy nose and throat, itchy watery eyes, runny nose, sneezing and sinus pain.
There is no statement that these claims have not been evaluated by the FDA, which is not required for OTC drugs, because any other OTC product would, in fact, have been evaluated by the FDA.
Active ingredients, their homeopathic dilution and their purposes are listed as:
Acontium Napellus 6X HPUS: itchy throat, sneezing
Allium Cepa 6X HPUS: hay fever, runny nose, watery, itchy eyes
Euphrasia 6X HPUS: irritated eys, nasal discharge
Galphimia Glauca 12X HPUS: sneezing, runny nose
Histaminum Hydrochloricum 12X HPUS: ear and nose discomfort
Luffa Operculata 12X HPUS: sinus pain, headache
Natrum Muriaticum 6X HPUS: runny nose, itchy irritated eyes
Nux Vomica 6X HPUS: stuffy nose
Pulsatilla 6X HPUS: sinus pressure
Sabadilla 6X HPUS: hay fever, sneezing
I could not find information about what these substances are, or what 6X or 12X HPUS means, anywhere on the Hyland’s website. In fact, it took a good deal of searching to find this information on the internet. Anyone who did not have prior knowledge of homeopathic dilutions, like I do, would presumably encounter even more difficulty.
If this remedy were regulated like other OTC drugs, Hyland’s could never make the claim that its “4 Kids Complete Allergy Relief” is safe and effective without having gone through the FDA approval process. Nor could it make the “uses” claims. However, putting those substantial barriers to the sale of this product aside, what would an OTC label otherwise require if homeopathic products weren’t exempted by the FDA?
Here’s my interpretation of what the Active Ingredients list would look like, based on my internet search. Of course, the FDA requires standardized label information for all OTC products and the end result would likely be far more informative than my attempt at revision, but we’ll give it a go.
Aconite (a poisonous plant)
Onion
Eupharsia (a genus of about 450 species of herbaceous flowering plants in the family Orobanchaceae)
Galphimia glauca (a plant)
Histaminum Hydrochloricum (a chemical made from histamine dihydrochloride, trade name Ceplene, a salt of histamine which is used as a drug)
Luffa (a plant, most commonly used, in dried form, as a skin exfoliator)
Table salt (sodium chloride)
“Strychnine tree” (a major source of the highly poisonous, intensely bitter alkaloids strychnine and brucine)
Pulsatilla (a plant)
Sabadilla (Schoenocaulon officinale, a plant, parts of which are used as an insecticidal dust; toxic to honeybees.)
Homeopathic dilutions used in this product:
6X = one part of ingredient to 1,000,000 parts of water
12X= one part of ingredient to 1,000,000,000,000 parts water
I could not find any indication that many of these ingredients have been proven safe and effective for anything in any amount, and none at these dilutions. Some are downright dangerous.
It would be ludicrous to argue that a parent choosing an allergy symptom remedy for his child would not think this information is important. Yet such is the current regulatory framework for homeopathic remedies.
In sum, the FDA already has in place a well-established regulatory system for prescription and OTC drugs. There is no reason to exclude homeopathic drugs from this process any longer.

FDA and Homeopathy: Part Two.
Mark Crislip on April 3, 2015
Link

Friends, FDA, countrymen, lend me your ears;
I come to bury Homeopathy, not to praise it.
The evil that homeopaths do lives after them;
The good is oft interred with their bones;
So let it be with Homeopathy. The noble Ullman
Hath told you homeopathy was effective:
If it were so, it was a grievous fault,
And grievously hath Homeopathy answer’d it.
Here, under leave of Ullman and the rest–
For Ullman is an honourable man;
So are they all, all honourable men–
Come I to speak in Homeopathy’s funeral.
It was my nostrum, faithless and worthless to me:
But Ullman says it was effective;
And Ullman is an honourable man.
He hath brought many provings home to HPUS
Whose prescriptions did the general coffers fill:
Did this in Homeopathy seem effective?
When that the ill have died, Homeopathy hath wept:
Efficacy should be made of sterner stuff:
Yet Ullman says it was effective;
And Ullman is an honourable man.
You all did see that on the Cochrane
I thrice presented Homeopathy a meta-analysis,
Which he did thrice refuse: was this efficacy?
Yet Ullman says it was effective;
And, sure, he is an honourable man.
I speak not to disprove what Ullman spoke,
But here I am to speak what I do know.
Edward De Vere, 17th Earl of Oxford. Sort of.
We only have a vague idea as to what other bloggers are going to write about. Yesterday Jann wrote on the same topic (and Scott the week before), which I will read tomorrow after my post goes up. Why would I want my post to be informed by another’s well-reasoned and thoughtful essay? I have a reputation after all. So here is my response to the FDA.
I am writing in response to the request for recommendations concerning the regulation of homeopathic nostrums by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).
I recognize that because of federal law the FDA has significant handicaps in the regulation of homeopathic nostrums since the Food, Drugs and Cosmetics Act of 1938 defines as a drug any product found in the US Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia (HPUS).
As a result of the Act, any nostrum in the HPUS is considered a legal medication in the US. The only premarketing evaluation required for a homeopathic nostrum is to find its way into the HPUS. Inclusion in the HPUS is usually by a homeopathic proving, a form of evaluation that does not prove either the safety or the efficacy of the nostrum.
So despite the fact that homeopathy is based on prescientific vitalism that is divorced from a modern scientific understanding of health and disease, homeopathy is protected from meeting the same standards of safety and efficacy that real medications must meet. I recognize that true, substantive regulation of homeopathy, requiring homeopathy to meet the same rigorous scientific medical standards as real pharmaceuticals, will require Congress to change the current laws governing the homeopathy.
Since homeopathic products contain no active product and have no effect on any disease or physiologic process, the need to remove a homeopathic product because of safety issues or serious side effects, such as happened with ephedra in 2004, is unlikely. Containing only water and/or sugar, homeopathic products are unlikely to suffer from issues of contamination and poor production quality that have been common with herbal and dietary supplements.
The major medical problems from homeopathy come from using the nostrums in lieu of effective medical therapies. Taking homeopathic nostrums for diseases such as asthma, meningitis, and malaria can have fatal consequences:
Moreover, some deaths were associated with “corticophobia,” with many patients preferring to use homeopathy or acupuncture.
One of many examples of relying on homeopathy resulting in death or serious illness. But it is a difficult scenario to regulate.
What then can and should be done to regulate homeopathy? Much of the use of homeopathy comes from a lack of transparency as to how homeopathic products are made and what they contain. To answer some of the questions asked by the FDA.
What are consumer and health care provider attitudes towards human drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic?
Many consumer think homeopathic products are the equivalent of herbal, vitamin, or other types of supplements. They are surprised and often express disbelief when the true nature homeopathic preparations and its dilutions are explained. Most people are unaware of what homeopathy is and homeopaths are not forthcoming with explanations.
What data sources can be identified or shared with FDA so that the Agency can better assess the risks and benefits of drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic?
The Science-Based Medicine blog (https://sciencebasedmedicine.org) has extensive reviews on homeopathy and the medical literature. Examples of the dire consequences of relying on homeopathy instead of science-based medicine can be found at the websites “What’s the Harm?” (http://whatstheharm.net/homeopathy.html) and “Discover Homeopathy” (http://discoverhomeopathy.co.uk/victims–2/).
Is there information regarding the regulation of homeopathic products in other countries that could inform FDA’s thinking in this area?
The best reviews on the complete lack of efficacy are the UK and Australian systematic reviews. They clearly demonstrate that there are no well-conducted clinical trials that demonstrates homeopathic nostrums have any effect on any disease. There is also the Swiss report on homeopathy. However, as noted by neurologist and Science-Based Medicine founder Steven Novella:
The Swiss report, which was favorable to homeopathy, was a reaction to a previous Swiss decision against homeopathy. The committee was packed with homeopaths, and not surprisingly they put a positive spin on the review.If you analyze the review you find that actually they came to the same conclusion about the data – that high quality studies show that homeopathy does not work. Then, however, they pulled a trick. As I previously reported:
The Swiss study looked at the same data, but apparently wanted to come to a favorable conclusion. So they argued for a change in the normal rules of evidence, a common strategy among CAM proponents. They decided to rely more on “real-world effectiveness,” which is just CAM newspeak for “poorly controlled studies.” In the real world we cannot control for variables and blind subjects – those are artificial conditions of rigorous trials.
The Swiss report was rigged and biased, and yet they still could not conclude that the data shows homeopathy works. They had to pull the “placebo medicine” gambit and claim that it sort of “works” even though there is no real effect from homeopathic products. Only homeopaths were apparently fooled by this ploy.
A large majority of human drug products labeled as homeopathic are marketed as OTC drugs. These products are available for a wide variety of indications, and many of these indications have never been considered for OTC use under a formal regulatory process. What would be an appropriate regulatory process for evaluating such indications for OTC use?
For OTC designation, at a minimum homeopathic should meet the same safety and efficacy as any other medications. Unlike most OTC medications, homeopathic nostrums are offered as treatments for potentially life-threatening diseases, from measles to whooping cough. Since homeopathic medications have no proven efficacy for any disease they should not be sold as OTC medications.
Allowing sugar and water to be sold as a treatment for serious illnesses and placing them next to medications with proven efficacy in drug stores gives the nostrums an undeserved credibility. Efficacy by association is not in the best interest of consumers.
Given the wide range of indications on drug products labeled as homeopathic and available OTC, what processes do companies currently use to evaluate whether such 8 products, including their indications for use, are appropriate for marketing as an OTC drug?
As an OTC product, homeopathic nostrums should meet the same standards of safety and efficacy as other medications. Patients will often turn to homeopathic products instead of seeing their doctor because see a physician costs both money and time and the homeopathic products are often less expensive. So if a patient is deciding to use a homeopathic product to treat their asthma or diabetes, it is imperative the product should have efficacy. Homeopathic nostrums never meet this criteria.
And although the FDA is not responsible for the ethics of homeopathic medications and prescribing, it is clear that selling a product that contains no active product and can have no efficacy is unethical. To quote retired physician and professor of Complementary Medicine at the University of Exeter, Edzard Ernst:
It should be axiomatic that ethics is indispensable to the practice of medicine, and is not something that can just be switched off at will. No branch of health care, including alternative medicine, can be considered exempt from it. But the subject of ethics is seldom even considered in alternative medicine; many alternative practitioners have never been taught medical ethics, and where training in this area does exist, it tends to be at best superficial…It is perhaps not surprising, therefore, that the principles of medical ethics are routinely ignored and frequently violated by promoters of alternative medicine…Medical ethics seem to me to be violated, for example: when homeopaths prescribe or recommend homeopathic vaccinations for which there is not a shred of evidence;
Selling homeopathic nostrums violates the first rule of medical ethics, that of beneficence. Physicians are expected not only to refrain from causing harm, but they also have an obligation to help their patients. Homeopathic nostrums accomplish neither.
Do consumers and health care providers have adequate information to make informed decisions about drug products labeled as homeopathic? If not, what information, including, for example, information in labeling, would allow consumers and health care providers to be better informed about products labeled as homeopathic?
The labels on homeopathic nostrums work to obscure the true nature of the product. As an example, the label of Oscillococcinum, a popular homeopathic preparation sold as a flu remedy, says it contains Anas Barbariae Hepatis et Cordis Extractum. Latin obscures the fact that the product contains Muscovy duck liver and heart, a product that has no efficacy, or reason for efficacy, against influenza. Although called an extract, letting a piece of duck liver and heart liquefy for 40 days and then diluting it in liter after liter of water (200 times) is not what most would consider an extract.
The ‘dose’ of the Oscillococcinum is 200CK which sounds strong, certainly stronger than the 10X, 30X, found in the King Bio Asthma homeopathic product, despite actually being diluted many thousand times more. If the serial dilutions of homeopathic nostrums were in plain English it would help consumers to be more aware of what they were purchasing.
It would be of benefit to the consumer to be informed that at the offered homeopathic dilution, the product should contain none of the original product.
The use of Latin and obscure dosing information runs counter to the current emphasis on health literacy: making all health care information understandable to all Americans, regardless of education. You should not have to know a dead language and college chemistry to understand your medication label.
It would also be of benefit to note on the label that no homeopathic product has ever been demonstrated to be effective for any medical condition.
For example:
Oscillococcinum: Duck heart and liver diluted to0.00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001%
This product as made should contain none of the original substance and no homeopathic product has ever been shown to treat any disease.
Given that there is no Physicians’ Desk Reference (PDR) and package insert equivalent for homeopathy, makes accurate and accessible labeling all the more important for consumers.
That the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States is behind a very expensive pay wall ($100 a day for a single user) represents an appalling barrier for consumers and health care professionals to understand homeopathic nostrums. It is in the public interest that this information be as freely available as the information in the PDR so that evaluations about the use of homeopathic nostrums can be made with all the available data. Can you imagine if the information in the PDR were equally unavailable? But big homeopathy has good reason to hide its data.
That would be transparent labeling, truth in advertising, and would protect the consumer by offering accurate and easily-understood information about the product. Cigarettes and alcohol have similar labels, clearly spelling out the contents and dangers in the product. Homeopathic nostrums and consumers deserve no less.
Accurate and easily understood labeling, free and easy access to the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States and the prohibition of OTC sales of homeopathic preparations, would all be important steps in consumer protection and the regulation of nostrums that, while legal in the US, are worthless and dangerous.
References
    • Edzard Ernst MD, PhD, FMedSci, FSB, FRCP, FRCPEd http://edzardernst.com/2015/03/wonderland–7-pseudoscience-is-a-deceit-perpetrated-on-the-weak-and-the-vulnerable/
    • Another Damning Homeopathy Report. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/another-damning-homeopathy-report/
    • The Swiss Report on Homeopathy. https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/the-swiss-report-on-homeopathy/
    • J Travel Med. 1996 Mar 1;3(1):62. Homeopathic Resistant Malaria. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9815426
    • J Allergy Clin Immunol. 1987 Sep;80(3 Pt 2):389–94. Asthma mortality in France. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3624689
    • A Cautionary Tale: The Risks of Unproven Antimalarials. http://www.cdc.gov/malaria/stories/homeopathic_drugs.html
    • Death by homeopathy. http://discoverhomeopathy.co.uk/victims–2/

Homeopathic industry and its acolytes make poor showing before FDA
Jann Bellamy on June 18, 2015
Tweet


On April 21 and 22, the FDA held a public hearing:
to obtain information and comments from stakeholders about the current use of human drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic, as well as the Agency’s regulatory framework for such products. . . . FDA is seeking participants for the public hearing and written comments from all interested parties, including, but not limited to, consumers, patients, caregivers, health care professionals, patient groups, and industry.
The FTC recently announced that it, too, is wading into the homeopathic waters. The FTC, which regulates advertising of homeopathic products, will hold a public workshop on September 21 in Washington, DC, “to examine advertising for over-the-counter (OTC) homeopathic products.” Like the FDA, it will also accept public comments online.
All of this regulatory buzz caused the FDA Law Blog to take notice. (The blog is hosted by a law firm specializing in food and drug regulation law.) A post titled “Will FTC Kill Homeopathic Products – or Will FDA?” gave this assessment:
Bottom line, if the FTC holds homeopathic products to the same scientific standards that are applied to claims for other OTC products like dietary supplements, as the FTC appears inclined to do . . . few if any homeopathic products will pass the test.
Actually, the FTC should hold homeopathic products to the same scientific standards as are applied to claims for OTC drugs, not dietary supplements, for that is how Congress classifies them. But we won’t be picky if the result is as FDA Law Blog suggests. Nor do we care who the killer is, as long as it gets done.
The homeopathic industry responded in spades to the FDA’s invitation (as I imagine it will to the FTC’s) trotting out not only its own representatives, but also sympathizers from the integrative and alternative medicine communities and consumers. These greatly outnumbered the voices of reason and science, but the industry and its acolytes were impressive in number only. The vast majority of the 7,000 online comments have also been pro-homeopathy, but that appears to have backfired, for reasons we’ll get to in a minute. (There’s still time to comment – the deadline was just extended until August 21.)
But before we get to the homeopathic dog-and-pony show, a brief background: Back in 1938, Congress passed the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act, which required drug manufacturers to demonstrate safety before their products could be marketed. In 1962, the Act was amended to require a demonstration of efficacy as well. Although Congress specifically included homeopathic drugs, the FDA has never required the homeopathic industry to demonstrate safety or efficacy of it products prior to putting them on the market. The FDA does have homeopathic-friendly labeling requirements and the industry is required to employ good manufacturing practices. The FDA can go after a homeopathic product post-market if it presents a safety issue or is not properly labeled, but that’s it.
Interestingly, the very situation that prompted Congress to pass drug regulation laws at the beginning of the 20th century perfectly describes the homeopathic industry today. As FDA historian John Swann, PhD, recounts, back in the day:
Lee Barlett, a former shirt salesman from Pittsburgh, promoted a medicine called Banbar as being effective for diabetes. Banbar was an extract of horsetail weed.
How little things have changed. The homeopathic remedy equisetum is made from the horsetail plant, used to treat certain bladder conditions and “cure” bedwetting. If that wasn’t a big enough dose of nonsense for you, perhaps you’d be interested to know:
People who benefit most from using the homeopathic remedy equisetum are those who are bad-tempered as well as get exhausted quite easily.
Not even the shirt salesman went that far.
As Dr. Swann said of remedies like Banbar,
Products like these were, at minimum, useless remedies that picked the pocket of the user, but they could also be downright harmful.
Of course, he was describing products sold at the turn of the last century. Which, in a reasonable world, is exactly where we should have left homeopathy.
The FDA hearing
The two strongest witnesses at the hearing for reality-based medicine, as Mark Crislip would call it, were Michael DeDora of the Center for Inquiry, and Adriane Fugh-Berman, Associate Professor in the Department of Pharmacology and Physiology and the Department of Family Medicine at Georgetown University Medical Center.
Fugh-Berman is concerned about stocking homeopathic products on the shelves right next to other OTC drugs because, in her view, most consumers and medical professionals have no idea what homeopathic remedies are, don’t know they aren’t reviewed for safety and efficacy, and likely think they are dietary supplements or conventional OTC drugs. Nor does their dilution necessarily make them harmless, a point that was confirmed by Edward Krenzelok of the Rocky Mountain Poison and Drug Center in his remarks. For example, according to Fugh-Berman, Cold-EEZE contains 13.3 milligrams of zinc per lozenge. At recommended six lozenges a day, that’s about 80 milligrams of zinc a day, or ten times the RDA for adult females, eight times the RDA for males. As well, she said, products can contain snake venom, heavy metals, controlled substances, glandular extracts and other potentially dangerous ingredients.
Fugh-Bergman, who pointed out that the evidence for homeopathy is “between scant and nil,” wants to see the labels accurately describe the ingredients and their amounts in the same language used for other drugs and dietary supplements rather than the obscure vocabulary of homeopathy. She noted that, at some level of dilution, this would require expression of amounts in terms like “less than .01 nanograms.”
DeDora also spoke to the lack of evidence for homeopathy as well as its conflict with basic scientific principles, of which he said the FDA was “well aware.” He said, and I agree, that homeopathic drugs should have to meet the same standards as other drugs. That is what the law says, and that is what the FDA should do.
Both DeDora and Fugh-Berman suggested that, short of this, manufacturers put the equivalent of the Quack Miranda Warning on homeopathic drugs, a position with which I disagree for legal and other reasons. It doesn’t seem to dissuade people from taking dangerous supplements and I don’t find it consistent with Congress’s mandate that the FDA oversee the process by which manufacturers show safety and efficacy. Blowing off your duty to regulate simply by telling people you haven’t done your job seems less than satisfactory.
So much for the scientific point of view.
Appearing for the defense, if you will, was none other than Wayne Jonas, MD, of the Samueli Institute. He says we need more studies of homeopathy. Actually, we don’t, but I would have said the same thing if my salary was paid by a group that specializes in attracting government funds to study “alternative medicine.”
Amy Rothenberg, ND, whom you’ve met before here on SBM, spoke on behalf of the American Association of Naturopathic Physicians. The AANP believes the “FDA’s current regulatory approach to homeopathic products is working well.” I’ll bet they do. (Rothenberg is also trained in classical homeopathy.)
Like other naturopaths who spoke at the hearing, Rothenberg began her comments with an infomercial for naturopaths, pointing out their “extensive” classroom and clinical training, post-grad exams, and such. She talked about her use of homeopathy in her practice, including treating an autistic child. I find this interesting, because neither homeopaths or naturopaths are licensed in Massachusetts, where she practices, which means she is skating very close to, and perhaps over the line into, the practice of medicine.
Rothenberg was the only speaker who attempted to explain homeopathy’s purported mechanism of action which is, according to her, hormesis, that homeopathic canard David Gorski has already deconstructed.
The luminaries of the homeopathic industry were all there: representatives from the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the U.S., American Institute of Homeopathy, Homeopathic Academy of Naturopathic Physicians, Arizona Homeopathic and Integrative Medicine Association, National Center for Homeopathy, American Association of Homeopathic Pharmacists, Consumer Healthcare Products Association (a trade group), the Integrative Health Policy Association, North American Society of Homeopaths, and the Center for Education and Development of Clinical Homeopathy. The Kool-Aid flowed freely.
I can summarize all of their testimony fairly quickly:
1. Cherry-picked evidence 
This included the famous Swiss Government Report, mentioned by Wayne Jonas, among others. Needless to say, other reports, such as the recent Australian National Health and Medical Research Council: Statement on Homeopathy or Evidence Check 2: Homeopathy from the UK were absent from pro-homeopathy discussion, save Jonas’s criticism of the former, which was, according to him, “very poorly done.”
2. Special pleading 
An example from the comments of Tanya Kell, President of the North American Society of Homeopaths: Kell testified that:
there is a long, established record of both safety and efficacy in homeopathy. Homeopathic practice is based on hundreds of years of clinical experience by both physicians in this country and around the world.
Panelist and FDA regulatory attorney Elaine Lippman asked Kell what her data sources were “for that long established record particularly with respect to efficacy.”
Kell’s answer:
This is more a compilation of anecdotal evidence, so when I studies [sic] social work that was an accepted form of evidence, is just compiling anecdotal stories. [Actually, it’s not.]
Homeopathy has hundreds of millions of those, and you know, as our reputation grows, so does those anecdotal stories, and we feel that they are a legitimate source of data.
Translation: RCTs don’t apply to us.
And, from Bernardo Merizalde, MD, of the American Institute of Homeopathy:
We believe the true scientist does not discard available data because the theory doesn’t correspond to their prevailing world view.
Translation: The sciences of physics and chemistry are simply “world views” that can be ignored.
3. A whole lot of declarations that homeopathy is “safe” and “effective” and “it works” 
Which just goes to show you: these people damn well know how to form a declarative sentence. They have it down. Totally. Good for their grammar teachers!
4. Explanations of the intricate process by which the HPCUS decides which homeopathic remedies are included in the HPUS 
To which I say: GIGO.
Yet, Elaine Lippman was able to extract this confession from none other than Todd Hoover of the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States, the industry-controlled group that decides what homeopathic remedies are included in the Pharmacopoeia. She asked:
What is it about the FDA’s process of establishing efficacy through the gold standard, placebo-controlled, randomized clinical trials, what about that is inconsistent with homeopathic remedies?
To which Hoover replied:
There’s nothing inconsistent. Impractical might be a better word.
He later admitted that it is “certainly possible.” But then there was a big, fat qualifier to his admission. Why it is impractical?
The selection process and inclusion criteria that would be required might require a large population selection in order to find people who fit that particular remedy perfectly in order to demonstrate effectiveness for a given claim.
In other words, to do an RCT the homeopathic way, you would have to buy into the ridiculous nonsense of choosing remedies based on the patient’s quirky characteristics. Sound like more special pleading. In any event, this is not the way most people use homeopathy. About 95% of homeopathic products are OTC, so the user is selecting the remedy, not a homeopath.
Several other MDs testified in favor of homeopathy as well. Robert Dumont, MD, a pediatrician, said that homeopathic products were “exceptionally versatile and efficacious for many medical problems,” that he has “prescribed homeopathic medicines in the hospital for premature infants,” and used it for “nausea, vomiting and losing weight” in a patient undergoing chemotherapy. Another MD and classically trained homeopath, Karl Robinson, uses homeopathy for patients with hepatitis A. Younger Chug, MD, a pulmonologist, said he uses homeopathic products for asthma, chronic cough, croup and in situations where there is no effective drug, such as dyspnea due to vocal cord dysfunction. Another said homeopathy was “especially beneficial in our sickest patients.”
These physicians might just want to take a look at the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners recent “Position statement: homeopathy,” which includes this:
Medical practitioners should not practice homeopathy, refer patients to homeopathic practitioners, or recommend homeopathic products to their patients.
If this is the best evidence homeopathy has to offer, and the FDA decides to regulate homeopathic drugs in the same manner as all other OTC and prescription drugs (assuming it doesn’t allow homeopathic pseudoscience any place in the process), then homeopathy is indeed dead in the water, as FDA Law Blog suggests. The homeopathic industry is surely busy supplementing its poor showing before the FDA with written submissions. Speaking of which, we’ll now turn to the public comments.
Public comments
There are, as I mentioned, over 7,000 comments online. I have no idea how many more have been submitted in writing via snail mail. As I also mentioned, the FDA extended the deadline for comments until August 21, for reasons I cannot imagine. What’s more to be said?
I read through about 325 comments of the 7,000 plus (you’re welcome). They can be divided into three categories:
     1.  A tiny percentage in favor of the FDA fulfilling its duty to regulate homeopathic drugs just like it regulates other drugs, some citing research in support of their position.
     2.  Something along the lines of “you can have my homeopathic remedy when you peel it from my cold, dead fingers,” usually served up with a big dose of conspiracy theory, Big Pharma and government bashing, and Health Freedom, or HEALTH FREEDOM!!!
     3.  Anecdotes demonstrating in the writer’s mind, with absolute certainty, that homeopathy “works.”
Boiron, the homeopathic remedy manufacturer, has been chumming up consumers to post their wonderful results online. What they’ve produced instead is a treasure trove of evidence that the public is being duped by the homeopathic industry. Based on my review, here is a list of diseases and conditions for which consumers are using homeopathy:
These consumers apparently have no understanding that the perceived “effectiveness” of homeopathic products could well be due to the natural course of disease, motivated reasoning, placebo responses, regression to the mean, confirmation bias, conditioning, the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy, or the effects of other treatments. In fact, from a scientific standpoint, these are the only plausible explanations for the putative effectiveness of homeopathic products.
These are exactly the sort of confounding factors that the premarket approval process is designed to weed out. By putting the onus on prescription and OTC drug manufacturers to demonstrate efficacy, this process ensures that consumers will not be purchasing remedies that actually do them no good and allows calculation of the true benefit of the product itself so that a proper risk-benefit analysis can be performed. As it now stands, the homeopathic industry is allowed to exploit other, plausible explanations for the perceived effectiveness of their products in order to sell an unnecessary product for its own financial gain.
One issue raised at the hearing was consumer confusion when homeopathic drugs are sold side-by-side with other OTC drugs. Homeopathy supporters pointed to the fact that these products are labeled “homeopathic,” but this begs the question. That means nothing if the consumer doesn’t understand what “homeopathic” means. Of course, to the homeopathic industry, it means that “like cures like” and that dilution combined with vigorous shaking makes the product more, rather than less, effective.
Consumers testifying at the hearing and commenting online parroted this explanation, ironically demonstrating they have no idea what “homeopathic” really means: that the product has been produced by a method that guarantees it will not work as advertised. One consumer repeated a version of the homeopathic industry’s attempts at reconciling their scientifically untenable “theory” with basic chemistry and physics: “we now know that water holds energetic information and the energy of each substance is stored within the homeopathic remedy.” Another said they are “effective through their energetic frequency and the effect they have on the cellular electrical energies.” Not only have consumers bought into the false claim that homeopathy “works,” they’ve swallowed the pseudoscience that “explains” its putative effectiveness.
What will the FDA do? I don’t know. If it wants to do the right thing, the FDA could impose the same requirements on homeopathic drugs as other drugs, which it has the authority to do. (And, if it had done this in the past, we wouldn’t find ourselves in the current situation.) But that carries some risk: homeopathic proponents might go running to their representatives in Congress to pass a law exempting homeopathic remedies from FDA oversight altogether. Or moving them to dietary supplement classification by redefining that term.
The most politically expedient thing to do may be requiring the homeopathic industry to label its OTC products like other OTC drugs, which would include a prohibition against making disease claims that are not supported by adequate evidence and stating ingredients in terms the average consumer has some chance of understanding. This would stop short of regulating them like other OTC drugs, but may take care of the problem without having to go there.
Blog archive: The FDA and homeopathic drug regulation (or lack thereof)
Science-Based Medicine
Homeopathic regulation diluted until no substance left
Should the FDA crack down on homeopathic “remedies”
How should the FDA regulate homeopathic remedies?
FDA and Homeopathy: Part Two
Respectful Insolence
Regulating the magic that is homeopathy: The sabotage of poor reporting and false balance

Society for Science-Based Medicine: Comment to FDA on homeopathic drug regulation
The Society for Science-Based Medicine has commented on the FDA’s reconsideration of how to regulate homeopathic products.
Jann Bellamy on August 6, 2015
Link

Author’s note: The FDA has asked for public comments on the regulation of homeopathic products. The Society for Science-Based Medicine’s Comment follows, modified for this format. The Comment is based in part on two previous posts, “How should the FDA regulate homeopathic remedies?” and “Homeopathic industry and its acolytes make poor showing before the FDA.” The comment period closes August 21, 2015.
Society for Science-Based Medicine
Comment: Homeopathic Product Regulation: Evaluating the Food and Drug Administration’s Regulatory Framework After a Quarter-Century
All homeopathic products on the U.S. market today, whether over-the-counter (OTC) or prescription, fall within the definition of “drug” in the Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act of 1938. The overwhelming scientific consensus is that homeopathy is highly implausible, unsupported by scientific evidence, ineffective in treating illness and, when relied upon instead of actual medicine, dangerous and even deadly. Yet the FDA has, without statutory authority, exempted homeopathic drugs from the regulatory scheme mandated by federal law. In accordance with its consumer protection mandate, the FDA should take immediate action to remedy this by requiring that all homeopathic drugs comply with the same statutes and regulations as all other OTC and prescription drugs.
Introduction
The Society for Science-Based Medicine welcomes the FDA’s examination of homeopathic prescription and OTC drug regulation. In many respects, the current regulation of homeopathic drugs resembles that of all drugs prior to the passage of the Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act in 1938 (FD&C Act). At that time, there was no premarket regulation. The FDA was limited to post-market enforcement actions against adulterated or misbranded drugs. Drug manufacturers controlled the premarket process, much as the homeopathic industry controls the premarket process today. This includes the determination of which homeopathic ingredients are included in the Homeopathic Pharmacopœia of the United States (HPUS) by a private, non-governmental organization, the Homeopathic Pharmacopœia Convention of the United States (HPCUS), as well as homeopathic manufacturer determination of indications for product use. Then, as now, the FDA promulgated labeling requirements, but there was no FDA process ensuring that the products were safe and effective for their intended use prior to their being marketed.
According to the FDA, Americans now spend about $3 billion a year on homeopathic drugs, which contain ingredients derived from plants, healthy or diseased animals or humans, minerals and various chemicals. These drugs can cause, and have caused, side effects, some of them serious. Yet, there is no reliable scientific evidence that these drugs are efficacious for any use. As FDA historian John Swann, Ph.D., noted, prior to Congress giving the FDA authority to regulate drugs, products on the market “were, at a minimum, useless remedies that picked the pocket of the user, but they could also be downright harmful,” an observation that describes perfectly homeopathic products today.
Obviously, a system widely recognized as insufficient over 75 years ago cannot be tolerated in 2015. It was this very insufficiency that prompted Congress to pass the FD&C Act and subsequent amendments further strengthening the FDA’s hand, laws from which the homeopathic industry has been largely, and curiously, exempt. Indeed, it is entirely unclear on what statutory authority the FDA bases its exclusion of homeopathic drugs from the pre-market regulatory process applicable to all drugs under federal law. There is certainly no such exclusion in the statutes themselves.
The FDA asked for public input on specific issues regarding regulation of homeopathic drugs. The Society’s comments follow.
What are consumer and health care provider attitudes towards human drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic?
The public has spoken with its pocketbook. Consumers are unlikely to purchase a remedy for themselves and their families unless they think the product is safe and effective. These consumers are apparently unaware of several facts:
There has been no objective, third-party confirmation of safety and effectiveness by the FDA or otherwise.
Claims of efficacy are in direct contradiction to basic principles of physics and chemistry and no reputable scientific authority supports the fantastical postulates upon which homeopathic remedies are reputed to “work.”
Clinical trials confirm the obvious: homeopathic drugs do not work as claimed.
There could be no more compelling evidence that the current system is inadequate than the public comments posted online at regulations.gov. As of this writing, there are almost 8,000 comments, the majority of them consisting of positive anecdotes about homeopathic drug use. Considering the fact that there is no evidence of efficacy, it is clear the homeopathic industry has the public fooled.
We see, over and over, comments that homeopathic remedies are “safe and effective” or “proven safe and effective” when the consensus of the scientific community is that they are not and, in fact, cannot be effective, and we know that safety remains largely unproven. One physician testified at the FDA’s hearing that “the majority of patients . . . that I encounter have no real understanding of what homeopathy is and often confuse it with herbal medicines.”
Many commenters claim that homeopathic remedies are effective for a wide range of illnesses and conditions, not all of them self-limiting and some quite serious. Some use the word “cure;” one claimed homeopathic drugs “cured people of serious diseases.” Another claimed that a homeopathic drug brought a seven-year-old out of a coma. Yet another said homeopathy was effective for a “vast range of ailments and conditions.” A random selection of about 350 of these comments included claims that homeopathic remedies are effective for:
These consumers apparently have no understanding that the perceived “effectiveness” of homeopathic products could well be due to such things as the natural course of disease, motivated reasoning, placebo responses, regression to the mean, confirmation bias, conditioning, the post hoc ergo propter hoc fallacy, or the effect of other treatments. In fact, from a scientific standpoint, these are the only plausible explanations for the putative effectiveness of homeopathic products.
Misattributions of efficacy are exactly the sort of confounding factors that the premarket approval process is designed to weed out. By putting the onus on prescription and OTC drug manufacturers to show safety and efficacy, this process ensures that consumers will not be purchasing remedies that actually do them no good and allows calculation of the true benefit of the product itself so that a proper risk-benefit analysis can be performed. As it now stands, the homeopathic industry is allowed to exploit these other, plausible explanations for the perceived effectiveness of their products in order to sell unnecessary and ineffective remedies for their own financial gain.
If the FDA ever believed that use of homeopathic drugs by health care providers offered some measure of protection for the public, those beliefs were certainly belied by the comments of providers who employ homeopathic remedies in their practices. In fact, while the industry’s self-interest and the public’s lack of accurate information can explain the average consumer’s being misinformed, it is much harder to reconcile the use of unproven drugs rejected by the vast majority of medical practitioners, and for good reason, by those presumably educated in the scientific method.
Robert Dumont, MD, a pediatrician, testified that homeopathic products were “exceptionally versatile and efficacious for many medical problems,” that he has “prescribed homeopathic medicines in the hospital for premature infants,” and used it for “nausea, vomiting and losing weight” in a patient undergoing chemotherapy. Another MD, Karl Robinson, testified he used homeopathy for Hepatitis A. Younger Chug, MD, a pulmonologist, said he uses homeopathic products for asthma, chronic cough, croup and in situations where there is no effective drug, such as dyspnea due to vocal cord dysfunction. Another said homeopathy was “especially beneficial in our sickest patients.”
Amy Rothenberg, ND, testified she prescribed homeopathy for an autistic child. Another naturopath said that “time and again [homeopathy has been] very, very safe and effective as adjuvant therapy in restoring people’s health and vitality.” She said it had been “life changing, a child born, depression lifted, digestion improved.”
As the FDA is well aware, none of these uses are supported by adequate evidence of safety and efficacy.
What data sources can be identified or shared with FDA so that the Agency can better assess the risks and benefits of drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic?
Before this question can be addressed, the FDA will have to determine what process it will use to evaluate these data sources, whatever they might be. As the FDA itself said in its notice of the public hearing, nothing in the FD&C Act exempts drugs labeled as homeopathic from the premarket approval process or the same safety and efficacy standards as all new drugs. There is no doubt that all homeopathic drugs meet the definition of “new drug,” because they are “not generally recognized, among experts qualified by scientific training and experience to evaluate the safety and effectiveness of drugs” for uses “prescribed, recommended, or suggested” by the label. Thus, homeopathic drugs must meet the same criteria as that applied to other new drugs, whether they are prescription or OTC.
As to the data sources themselves, the FDA is fortunate that the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) recently completed a comprehensive evaluation of the evidence. The resulting analysis, “Effectiveness of Homeopathy for Clinical Conditions: Evaluation of the Evidence” (2015), concluded:
There is a paucity of good-quality studies of sufficient size that examine the effectiveness of homeopathy as a treatment for any clinical condition in humans. The available evidence is not compelling and fails to demonstrate that homeopathy is an effective treatment for any of the reported clinical conditions in humans.
This led to the NHMRC Statement on Homeopathy:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there is no health condition for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.
As well, the UK House of Commons Science and Technology Committee, in its “Evidence Check 2: Homeopathy,” after a review of the evidence, concluded:
In our view, the systematic reviews and meta-analyses conclusively demonstrate that homeopathic products perform no better than placebos. We could find no support from independent experts for the idea that there is good evidence for the efficacy of homeopathy.
What cannot be tolerated, in our view, is lowering the FDA’s standards to permit the consideration of “data sources” widely rejected by experts qualified by scientific training and experience. The mechanism of action for homeopathy proposed by the homeopathic industry is inconsistent with basic principles of chemistry and physics. Indeed, as has been pointed out, what we understand now about chemistry and physics would have to be proven very wrong if homeopathy actually “works.”
As Tanya Kell, President of the North American Society of Homeopaths, admitted at the hearing, the “long-established record of safety and efficacy” claimed by the industry is largely “a compilation of anecdotal evidence.” It is unthinkable that any other FDA-regulated product would be allowed on the market based on anecdotes.
At this time, the FDA has defaulted to the HPCUS to determine what ingredients can be used in homeopathic drugs and to the homeopathic industry to decide, with no reliable evidence whatsoever, safety and appropriate indications for use. The industry’s conflict of interest is obvious. What may be less obvious is that the HPCUS is controlled solely by industry insiders. The HPCUS Board, which exercises final judgment regarding which ingredients are included in the HPUS, is composed of practicing homeopaths, homeopathic pharmacists, or current or former officials or owners of homeopathic products manufacturing companies.
Yet, the FDA has claimed, in testimony before Congress, that it applies the same evidentiary standards whether a therapy is labeled conventional or complementary and alternative. In 2000, an FDA official told a House Committee:
CAM is a broad term referring to treatments that are either unapproved or not widely accepted in this country. Treatments range from botanicals and animal extracts to biofeedback to visualization techniques, chiropractic, homeopathy, massage therapy, acupuncture, and prayer. As we have emphasized, FDA relies on evidence, and is required to do so under the FD&C Act, from adequate and well-controlled studies as its basis for approval, not on theories of healing, animal studies or strongly held beliefs. Complementary and alternative treatments are as readily studied in well-controlled trials as are conventional treatments . . . [Emphasis added.]
In sum, the FDA should use only data sources that meet the same requirements as those allowed for all other FDA-regulated drugs. Conversely, the FDA should reject scientifically implausible “theories,” anecdotal evidence, homeopathic “provings” and obviously biased industry sources as the standard for homeopathic drugs.
Are the current enforcement policies under the CPG [Compliance Policy Guide] appropriate to protect and promote public health in light of the tremendous growth in the homeopathic drug market? Are there alternatives to the current enforcement policies of the CPG that would inform FDA’s regulatory oversight of drugs labeled as homeopathic? If so, please explain.
Are there areas of the current CPG that could benefit from additional clarity? If so, please explain.
Given the fact that consumers who use homeopathic drugs are not aware of the overwhelming scientific consensus that homeopathy does not, and cannot, work, and that no robust clinical trial evidence for their efficacy exists, then it is quite obvious that the current CPG is inadequate. The fact that consumers do not confine their use to self-limiting conditions is further evidence of their confusion.
The only solution is to scrap the current CPG and apply the same regulations and policies to homeopathic drugs that the FDA applies to all other OTC drugs. (This same solution is applicable to prescription homeopathic drugs as well: regulate these drugs like all other prescription drugs.) If a homeopathic drug has never been properly evaluated to determine whether it is OTC or prescription, then that should be the first step. The rest of the regulatory process follows logically from there. As we have pointed out before, and as the FDA itself has said, there no statutory authority to regulate homeopathic drugs differently than all other drugs on the market.
If the FDA concludes that removing all homeopathic products from the shelves, because they’ve never been through the appropriate regulatory process, is impractical, interim steps could be taken until all homeopathic drugs can complete the process. As a first step, the FDA can, at the very least, apply the same product labeling rules to OTC homeopathic drugs it does to all other OTC drugs. This includes listing ingredients and ingredient amounts using the same terminology as is used for all other OTC drugs. In other words, the Latin names and reference to amounts in homeopathic dilutions should be abandoned. It would also mean that no homeopathic drug could claim to be safe and effective for any disease or condition until it met the same evidentiary standards as all other OTC drugs.
Is there information regarding the regulation of homeopathic products in other countries that inform FDA’s thinking in this area?
The FDA has in place an extensive regulatory process designed to evaluate the safety and effectiveness of OTC and prescription drugs and to ensure that the public and health professionals have adequate information for their use. It is this system the FDA should employ for homeopathic drugs. To the extent other countries are employing any regulatory scheme that allows the sale of homeopathic drugs based on false claims of safety and effectiveness, that system simply suffers from the same deficiencies as those that plague the current system in this country. Consequently, they should not be adopted.
A large majority of human drug products labeled as homeopathic are marketed as OTC drugs. These products are available for a wide variety of indications, and many of these indications have never been considered for OTC use under a formal regulatory process. What would be an appropriate regulatory process for evaluating such indications for OTC use?
There is no legal or practical reason why the FDA should continue to privilege homeopathy over all other drugs by indulging the homeopathic industry and ignoring basic science and the overwhelming evidence from clinical trials that homeopathy does not and cannot work. To date, the FDA’s rationale for doing so has been the presumed safety of homeopathic drugs, due to the fact that they contain anywhere from a small amount to no active ingredient. Safety aside, in light of the public’s, and health care providers’ obvious belief in the efficacy of homeopathic products for many conditions, some of them quite serious, the FDA can no longer afford to allow these misperceptions to go unremedied by regulatory action. Again, the appropriate regulatory process is the one already in place for other OTC drugs. This should include the payment of any fees required of other OTC drug manufacturers.
Given the wide range of indications on drug products labeled as homeopathic and available OTC, what processes do companies currently use to evaluate whether such products, including their indications for use, are appropriate for marketing as an OTC drug?
We submit that the processes these companies use, whatever they are, are highly irregular to the extent they are based on homeopathic principles. There is a plethora of scientifically valid information evaluating homeopathic drugs. It is abundantly clear that the homeopathic industry has not availed itself of this information in evaluating “whether their products, including their indications for use, are appropriate for marketing as OTC drugs.”
To the extent the evaluation of homeopathic drugs by their manufacturers does not conform to the processes used by other OTC drug manufacturers, they must be scrapped. We do not believe there is a way to create some hybrid regulatory system supported by one foot resting in science and the other in pseudoscience.
Do consumers and health care providers have adequate information to make informed decisions about drug products labeled as homeopathic? If not, what information, including, for example, information in labeling, would allow consumers and health care providers to be better informed about products labeled as homeopathic?
The answer to the first question is clear: Consumers and a handful of health care providers believe that homeopathic drugs are safe and effective for many uses and that the “theory” underlying homeopathic remedies is a tenable one. A necessary corollary to that conclusion is that they have inadequate information to make informed decisions about homeopathic drugs.
The fact that these products are labeled “homeopathic” (a fact mentioned by several homeopathy proponents at the hearing) begs the question. That means nothing if the consumer doesn’t understand what “homeopathic” means. Of course, to the homeopathic industry, it means that “like cures like” and that dilution combined with vigorous shaking makes the product more, rather than less, effective. Consumers testifying at the hearing and commenting online parroted this explanation, ironically demonstrating they have no idea what “homeopathic” really means: that the product has been produced by a method that virtually guarantees it will not work as advertised.
One speaker repeated the homeopathic industry’s latest attempt at reconciling their scientifically untenable “theory” with basic chemistry and physics: “we now know that water holds energetic information and the energy of each substance is stored within the homeopathic remedy.” Another said they are “effective through their energetic frequency and the effect they have on the cellular electrical energies.” Yet another, a naturopath, claimed that homeopathy can be explained by hormesis. All of these are nonsensical from a scientific standpoint.
This is exacerbated by the fact that ingredients are listed in Latin and dilutions are listed in a code used only by the homeopathic industry. In addition to these confusing labels, consumers commented that they relied on self-help books, the internet and personal recommendations, all unreliable sources of accurate information.
Proponents of homeopathic products testifying at the hearing gave examples of available online sources. However, these sources simply repeat the unproven claims that homeopathy is safe and effective for a wide range of diseases. For example, the Consumer Healthcare Products Association, a trade group, refers viewers to the websites of two homeopathic product manufacturers, Hyland’s and Boiron, hardly objective sources of reliable information.
The website of the National Center for Homeopathy, mentioned several times in testimony, contains information that can only be described as fantastical from a scientific standpoint. Likewise, the American Institute for Homeopathy website states that homeopathic remedies “stimulate the person’s own healing power,” which is nothing more than vitalism, a pre-scientific, and long-rejected, belief in an incorporeal “healing force” erroneously credited with healing powers. It falsely claims that homeopathic drugs are “deep-acting medicines [that] can be used to treat persons experiencing many kinds of medical conditions.”
Unfortunately, the FDA’s own website has almost no information about homeopathic drugs. This paucity is striking when compared to the plethora of information available for OTC and prescription drugs, as well as the many other products the FDA regulates, such as foods and medical devices. The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health has limited information. Fortunately for those consumers consulting NCCIH, the material is refreshingly honest: the FDA does not evaluate homeopathic remedies for safety or effectiveness, there is little evidence that it is effective for anything, and although highly diluted some products have concentrations capable of causing adverse effects.
At the hearing, the homeopathic industry was unable to produce any evidence that the consumer understands the true nature of homeopathic remedies. One industry representative testified it might be helpful to require a disclaimer on the label similar to that on dietary supplements. However, this appears to have had little effect on the public’s misplaced belief that dietary supplements are proven safe and effective, despite the fact that the FDA does not evaluate supplements prior to market and the lack of evidence that supplements are indeed either safe or effective for their advertised uses. Of course, unlike dietary supplements, where there is specific statutory authority in the Dietary Supplement Health & Education Act (DSHEA) to use this disclaimer, nothing in the FD&C Act permits the FDA to avoid its regulatory mandate in this manner.
Of note, there is popular support for the increased regulation of dietary supplements. (Again, DSHEA, unlike the FD&C Act, does not require pre-market approval.) One survey reported in the medical literature found that a substantial majority of respondents, including regular dietary supplement users, were in favor of
requiring the FDA to review the safety of new dietary supplements prior to their sale;
providing increased authority to remove from sale those products shown to be unsafe; and
increasing government regulation to ensure that advertising claims about dietary supplements are true.
Summary
The answer to the FDA’s questions is simple and can be summarized in a few words.
Homeopathy is highly implausible, unsupported by scientific evidence, ineffective in treating illness and, when relied upon instead of actual medicine, dangerous and even deadly.
The FDA should apply the FD&C Act as Congress intended. The law offers no exception for homeopathic products.

FDA Proposes Changes to Homeopathy Regulation
The FDA has proposed new guidelines for regulating homeopathy. They sound encouraging, and may signal a new era of actual regulation of the homeopathic industry.
Steven Novella on December 20, 2017
Link

It was almost three years ago, in April of 2015, that the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced it was reconsidering the way it regulates homeopathic products. We have been anxiously awaiting its decision, and finally they have published their proposed new guidelines. As with their previous proposals, there is a public comment period. Over this same time period the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) revised their own approach to homeopathy, and even gave a prod to the FDA to do the same.
So how are the new proposals? A move in the right direction, but they do not go nearly far enough. That was pretty much what we expected, and were hoping that it would be at least a significant move to actually regulate homeopathic products.
Some background
To understand the SBM position on homeopathy, you have to understand what homeopathy is. Here is a quick primer. Basically, homeopathy is a two-century-old pre-scientific medical system based on magical ideas. The first main pillar of homeopathy is that substances which cause symptoms in high doses will treat those same symptoms in extremely small doses. Often fanciful substances are used based upon silly criteria, such as if you cry when you hear piano music. The second pillar is that by diluting those same substances to an extreme degree, their “essence” is released in the final potion. Often the dilution is so great that essentially none of the original ingredient remains. I like to characterize this process as diluting fairy dust out of existence.
And yes – it is exactly that silly. Homeopathy is not the use of herbs or natural substances, as many in the public falsely believe.
Not surprisingly, when studied in proper double-blind clinical trials, homeopathy does not work. Multiple independent scientific reviews of all the published evidence have concluded that homeopathy does not work for any indication. So, how should such worthless magic potions be regulated by the FDA? Why is this even a question?
The story of the FDA and homeopathy goes back to the 1938 FDA Act. In the 1938 FDA Act, one Senator, Royal Copeland, who was a physician and homeopath, included in the bill that the provision that the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS) would be included in the list of official drugs. The legacy of that one senator survives to today.
For much of the intervening time homeopathy was a small niche market, and the FDA determined that it was not worth its limited resources to actually regulate it. In their proposed changes, however, they acknowledge:
Until relatively recently, homeopathy was a small market for specialized products. Over the last decade, the homeopathic drug market has grown exponentially, resulting in a nearly $3 billion industry that exposes more patients to potential risks associated with the proliferation of unproven, untested products and unsubstantiated health claims.
Now that the market for homeopathic products has exploded – thanks in part to lax FDA oversight – the FDA realizes it has to do its job. They are motivated not just by the fact that homeopathic products are nonsense, but because lax regulations have led to abuse. Companies can label anything as homeopathic as an end-run around FDA oversight. They state:
During this time, the FDA has seen a corresponding increase in safety concerns, including serious adverse events, associated with drug products labeled as homeopathic. In addition, the agency has also found an increasing number of poorly manufactured products that contain potentially dangerous amounts of active ingredients that can create additional risks.
What is the FDA proposing?
The FDA is clearly trying to split the baby in their new proposed approach. By this I mean they want to protect the public from harmful health products, but at the same time respect consumer choice. I understand, politically, why they might feel they need to do that, even though I disagree. I don’t disagree with consumer choice – I disagree that that is the issue. If consumers are offered a completely fraudulent product with zero actual value, that is no choice. There has to be a line somewhere.
The FDA is proposing that they take a risk-based approach. This means they will target homeopathic products that they feel pose the greatest risk to the public. Here are their criteria:
products with reported safety concerns;
products that contain or claim to contain ingredients associated with potentially significant safety concerns;
products for routes of administration other than oral and topical;
products intended to be used for the prevention or treatment of serious and/or life-threatening diseases and conditions;
products for vulnerable populations; and
products that do not meet standards of quality, strength or purity as required under the law.
That is a reasonable list, and I agree that these criteria represent greater risk. It is also perfectly reasonable for an agency like the FDA to prioritize the higher risks first. They further state:
Given the concerns about the proliferation of potentially ineffective and harmful products labeled as homeopathic, the FDA will consider taking additional enforcement and/or regulatory actions, consistent with the current enforcement policies, which also align with the risk-based categories described in the draft guidance, in the interest of protecting the public.
Here is the proposed new guidelines document. It contains only a little more information than the press release. But here is the meat – it is a bit technical, but this is the essence of what they are proposing (in addition to the risk-based approach to priority):
The definition of “drug” in section 201(g)(1) of the FD&C Act (21 U.S.C. 321(g)) includes articles recognized in the HPUS or any of its supplements. As such, homeopathic drugs are subject to the same regulatory requirements as other drugs. Generally, a drug, including a homeopathic drug, is considered a “new drug” if it is not generally recognized as safe and effective (GRAS/E) by qualified experts for use under the conditions prescribed, recommended, or suggested in the labeling (section 201(p) of the FD&C Act) (21 U.S.C. 321(p)). FDA makes GRAS/E determinations for OTC drugs marketed under the OTC Drug Review.4 The FDA has not reviewed any drug products labeled as homeopathic under the OTC Drug Review, because the Agency categorized these products as a separate category and deferred consideration of them. (37 FR 9464, 9466 (May 11, 1972)). Under section 505(a) of the FD&C Act (21 U.S.C. 355(a)), before any “new drug” is marketed, it must be the subject of an approved application filed pursuant to section 505(b) or section 505(j) of the FD&C Act; however, a biological product with an approved license under section 351(a) of the Public Health Service Act (PHS Act) (4272 U.S.C. 262(a)) is not required to have an approved application under section 505 of the FD&C Act. Accordingly, absent a determination that a drug product labeled as homeopathic is not a “new drug” under section 201(p), all drug products labeled as homeopathic are subject to the premarket approval requirements in section 505 of the FD&C Act or section 351 of the PHS Act. There are no drug products labeled as homeopathic that are approved by FDA.
Let me break that down. They are affirming that according to FDA rules, homeopathic products are drugs. They can be regulated as drugs. Up until now the FDA has simply chosen not to actively regulate them, and deferred to the homeopathic industry. But they are putting the industry on notice that they will now actually regulate their products as drugs, based upon the risk-based priority.
They further clarify what it means to be regulated as a drug. There are two ways to get to market. The harder way is to be FDA approved as safe and effective for a specific disease indication. That is the path that requires tens or hundreds of millions of dollars and multiple studies for safety and efficacy. The second path is to be marketed as an over-the-counter drug, which requires being determined to be GRAS/E – generally recognized as safe and effective.
That paragraph further states that no homeopathic products are FDA approved or determined to be GRAS/E. They were simply given a pass up until now.
What all this seems to be saying is that the FDA is putting the industry on notice (if they adopt these proposed new guidelines) that, without specific warning, any drug product labeled as homeopathic can be regulated like any other drug. That means it can be pulled from the market because it is not FDA approved or determined to be GRAS/E. They are prioritizing high-risk products, but these guidelines apply to all drugs labeled homeopathic.
Of course, if they adopt these guidelines, the real test is how they will be enforced. The most optimistic interpretation of these proposed guidelines is that the FDA is preparing to start decimating the homeopathic product industry by systematically taking such products off the market. That would be completely appropriate, and in fact anything less is a dereliction of duty, in my opinion. They plan on starting with high-risk products, but are giving themselves permission, essentially, to work their way entirely through the industry.
The most pessimistic interpretation is that the FDA plans on sending strongly worded warning letters to producers of high-risk homeopathic products asking that they make changes to the product or its marketing so that they will no longer be considered high risk. The reality will likely be somewhere in between, and it remains to be seen where along the spectrum from heroic to pathetic they will fall.
The press release does contain some weasel phrases, such as:
We respect that some individuals want to use alternative treatments, but the FDA has a responsibility to protect the public from products that may not deliver any benefit and have the potential to cause harm.
Let’s hope that the FDA is setting the stage to correct this historic travesty. The FDA is charged, as they acknowledge, with protecting the public from harmful or worthless products. Homeopathic products are all 100% worthless – that is the clear and undeniable scientific consensus. They have the authority to regulated homeopathic products as drugs – all they need is the political will to do so. These are internal guidelines for themselves. There is no new legislation needed. All the FDA has to do is decide to do their job.
Take advantage of the public comment period (90 days from Dec 18th). Let the FDA know that the public they serve wants science-based regulations.

FDA strengthens homeopathic drug enforcement (but falls short of actually enforcing the law)
The FDA may strengthen homeopathic drug regulation with its “risk-based” enforcement policy, but this still leaves illegal homeopathic remedies on the market and falls far short of actually enforcing the law.
Jann Bellamy on November 7, 2019
Link

Two recent actions by the FDA pave the way for what is purportedly more stringent regulation of homeopathic remedies:
     1.  announcement of an interim, and a revised proposed permanent, “risk-based” enforcement policy; and,
     2.  withdrawal of Compliance Policy Guide Sec. 400.400 (“Conditions Under Which Homeopathic Drugs May be Marketed”)
Though an improvement over the FDA’s decades-long benign neglect of the burgeoning homeopathic drug industry, the FDA’s step-upped enforcement still falls far short of doing what Congress authorized the agency to do: Regulate homeopathic remedies just like any other prescription or over-the-counter (OTC) drug. Instead, the FDA will concentrate on homeopathic remedies posing significant safety and quality issues, ignoring their lack of effectiveness and the consequent bamboozlement of the public wrought by a multi-billion-dollar industry and its minions in the healthcare practitioner and retail pharmacy sectors of the snake-oil industrial complex.
(If you are unfamiliar with homeopathy and the pseudoscientific principles upon which it is based, you can find out more here.)
As the FDA itself admits, per the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetics (FD&C) Act of 1938, the definition of “drug” includes any homeopathic remedy recognized in the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS). Thus, according to the FDA,
homeopathic drugs are subject to the same regulatory requirements as other drugs: nothing in the FD&C Act exempts homeopathic drug products from any of the requirements related to approval, adulteration, or misbranding, including labeling requirements.
Yet, the agency also admits, the “FDA has not reviewed any homeopathic drug products under the OTC Drug Review” nor has it approved any prescription homeopathic drug, meaning “there are currently no homeopathic drug products that are approved by the FDA.” In other words, all OTC and prescription homeopathic remedies on the market today are illegal for lack of FDA approval.
With that in mind, let’s take a look the revised risk-based enforcement plan, including a brief review of the policy it replaces.
For 50 years, despite the passage of the FD&C Act in 1938, the FDA pretty much ignored homeopathic remedies. Thus, any homeopathic remedy recognized by the HPUS could be marketed, not only sans FDA approval, but basically without the FDA’s involvement at all, including post-market regulation. Recognition of a homeopathic remedy by the HPUS was, and still is, totally controlled by the homeopathic industry, in the form of the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States [HPCUS],
a private organization answerable to no one, [which] decide[s] what homeopathic drugs are on the market. The HPCUS is rife with conflicts of interest. Decisions on the content of the HPUS are made by either practicing homeopaths, homeopathic pharmacists, or current or former officials or owners of homeopathic products manufacturing companies. It is totally controlled by industry insiders. One can only imagine the outcry if a similar organization of Big Pharma companies were calling the shots in deciding which drugs made it to market.
In 1988, the FDA issued CPG Sec. 400.400, which described the “conditions under which homeopathic drug products may ordinarily be marketed”. The new policy basically continued the FDA’s benign neglect of the illegal homeopathic drug traffic, generally limiting the agency’s enforcement actions to inappropriately labeled products or those manufactured in violation of good manufacturing practice (GMP) regulations.
This left the homeopathic industry with little to fear from the FDA. Indeed, as one federal judge ruled, in 2011, in a case against homeopathic remedy manufacturer Boiron,
As evidenced by the FDA guidance documents . . . the Court concludes that the FDA has largely abdicated any role it might have had in creating standards for homeopathic OTC drugs, and has instead attempted to delegate this authority to the non-governmental organization [the HPCUS] that determines whether homeopathic substances should be included in the HPUS. In addition, the FDA explicitly states that it makes no guarantee about the safety or efficacy of homeopathic OTC drugs even if they meet the unknown standards for inclusion in the HPUS.
The court also remarked that it could find
no record of any [FDA] investigation of homeopathic remedies due to a reported lack of efficacy.
In 2015, the FDA suddenly woke up and realized that, while the agency was looking the other way, the homeopathic remedy market had grown tremendously. It therefore decided to hold a hearing “to obtain information and comments from stakeholders about the current use of human drug and biological products labeled as homeopathic, as well as the Agency’s regulatory framework for such products”. (You can read the comment filed by the Society for Science-Based Medicine here.)
Despite a lot of handwaving about hormesis, special pleading, and cherry-picked evidence presented at the hearing by the homeopathic industry and its acolytes (e.g., naturopaths and “integrative” physicians), the FDA finally decided that, while actual compliance with the FD&C Act was not yet warranted, it would propose a new risk-based enforcement policy and open it for public comment.
Published in 2017, almost three years after the hearing, the draft “Drug Products Labeled as Homeopathic: Guidance for FDA Staff and Industry” elicited thousands of comments, many deriding the FDA for its “lack of authority” to regulate homeopathic remedies, despite the FDA having carefully explained, right there in the proposed guidance, how it was pulling its punches even though it possessed the legal authority to pull the plug on the entire homeopathic industry for lack of compliance with federal law. Many others claimed that the FDA should not regulate homeopathic remedies at all, because “it worked for me,” in spite of the fact that the FDA didn’t even hint that it would heretofore require a demonstration of effectiveness for homeopathic remedies to remain on the market, despite (once again) the clear language of the FD&C Act.
While the proposed guidance marinated in this public outrage, the FDA decided that the industry-friendly CPG Sec. 400.400 would remain in place.
Then, last month, the FDA issued “Revision 1” to the 2017 draft guidance. The new draft guidance does not amend the substance of the old draft guidance. Instead, for some reason, the FDA decided it needed to beef up the rationale for its proposed risk-based approach. This means a new round of public comment has been opened, ending January 23, 2020, which will undoubtedly lead to further railing against the FDA and its “lack of authority” and so on.*
The 2019 version simply repeats the FDA’s intent to “prioritize enforcement and regulatory actions” for products falling within the following categories:
    • Products with reports of injury that, after evaluation, raise potential safety concerns (e.g., MedWatch reports).
    • Products that contain or purport to contain ingredients associated with potentially significant safety concerns, such as infectious agents (like rabid dog saliva), controlled substances, and ingredients that pose a risk of toxic effects, particularly when manufactured in low dilutions (e.g., 1X, 2X, or 1C).
    • Products for routes of administration other than oral and topical, like injectables and ophthalmic remedies (like eye drops).
    • Products intended to be used for the prevention of serious and/or life-threatening diseases or conditions, in part because they may cause users to delay or discontinue proven medical treatments. (There’s plenty to work with on this front: Homeopathic remedies for autism, the flu, adjunctive breast cancer therapy, and vaccine-preventable diseases, for starters.)
    • Products for vulnerable populations, like infants, children, pregnant women and the elderly.
    • Products with significant quality issues (e.g., contamination with bacteria) such as those made in facilities with significant deviations from current good manufacturing practices.
In addition to adding a definition of “homeopathic drug product” to the 2019 version of the draft guidance, the FDA further explained why it found this new approach to regulation necessary: Since it issued CPG Sec. 400.400, there have been multiple situations in which homeopathic drug products posed a significant risk to patients even though the product was in compliance with CPG Sec. 400.400. For example, the FDA identified 99 cases of adverse events “consistent with belladonna toxicity” and possibly related to homeopathic teething products, including infant deaths and seizures. Poisonous belladonna alkaloids in some products far exceeded the amounts stated on the label. The FDA also received more than 130 reports of loss of the sense of smell associated with the use of Zicam homeopathic remedies containing zinc. These are only two examples among many, according to the FDA. Others include “many serious violations of Current Good Manufacturing Practice requirements”.
As it did in the 2017 version, the FDA justifies its actions by saying that it employs this risk-based approach to regulation “in many instances”. Yet, as the FDA itself notes, in cases involving other types of unapproved new drugs, using this risk-based approach prioritizes actions based not only on potential safety risks, but also on lack of evidence of effectiveness and potential health fraud, circumstances certainly present with homeopathic remedies but curiously ignored by the agency in this instance. And, in those other cases of unapproved drugs, the FDA is not effectively exempting an entire category of drugs with perhaps thousands of products used by millions of Americans, a multi-billion dollar market, from the FD&C Act.
In a separate decision, also issued in October, the FDA announced the withdrawal of CPG Sec. 400.400, meaning it is no longer in effect. So, how will the FDA regulate homeopathic remedies in the interim between withdrawal of CPG Sec. 400.400 and the finalization of its 2019 draft guidance, an interim presumably of several years duration considering the glacial pace of agency action?
FDA intends to apply its general approach to prioritizing regulatory and enforcement action, which involves risk-based prioritization in light of all the facts of a given circumstance. Risk-based enforcement best reflects FDA’s public health priorities.
To me, this sounds like the agency will simply employ the risk-based approach announced in the draft guidance until the draft guidance becomes final.
Although the FDA maintains that “any homeopathic drug product that is being marketed illegally is subject to FDA enforcement action at any time,” it also says that “many homeopathic drug products will fall outside” its new risk-based enforcement policy, meaning that the majority of these admittedly illegal drugs will remain on the market with little fear that the FDA will enforce the law. In other words, as it ever was, the homeopathic industry will, for the most part, regulate itself.

*Per the Federal Register, the comments on Revision 1 to “Drug Products Labeled as Homeopathic: Draft Guidance for Food and Drug Administration Staff and Industry” (posted Oct. 25, 2019) are due on Jan. 23, 2020. But, for some reason, the FDA’s announcement of Revision 1 gives the comment due date as Dec. 24, 2019.

FDA Warns About Homeopathic Teething Products
Steven Novella on October 5, 2016
Link

The FDA recently put out a consumer warning about homeopathic teething gels and pills. The warning states:
The FDA recommends that consumers stop using these products and dispose of any in their possession.
The warning is not because all homeopathic products are inherently useless. As we have discussed here often, the basic principles of homeopathy are pure pseudoscience. The practice of diluting substances so that almost no or no active ingredient remains means that most homeopathic products are just sugar pills. Further, clinical studies show that homeopathic products don’t work. There isn’t a single homeopathic product that has been shown to be effective for a single condition with rigorous clinical trials.
The FDA acknowledges this, writing in their warning:
Homeopathic teething tablets and gels have not been evaluated or approved by the FDA for safety or efficacy. The agency is also not aware of any proven health benefit of the products, which are labeled to relieve teething symptoms in children.
This may sound confusing, since the entire homeopathic pharmacopoeia has been pre-approved by the FDA and are sold as drugs. What they are saying is that they are not approved, “for safety or efficacy.” So they are approved, but without any guarantee that they are safe or effective.
Homeopathic belladonna
In the case of homeopathic teething gels and tablet, the concern is not that they are worthless, without any proven benefit, but rather that they can be toxic to children and infants. Many people falsely assume that because most homeopathic potions are typically diluted so that no active ingredient remains, all homeopathic products therefore have no active ingredients; that is not always the case, nor is it a requirement to be considered homeopathic.
In this case, homeopathic potions can cause direct toxic harm, not just the indirect harm of fooling people into thinking a worthless sugar pill is effective medicine.
This has come up before. In 2009 the FDA issued a warning about homeopathic Zicam nasal spray, which contained real doses of zinc and was associated with anosmia, or loss of smell.
The homeopathic teething products contain, according to the FDA, real doses of belladonna, which is a toxic alkaloid. In fact, they issued a similar warning letter in 2010, although that warning was limited to Hyland’s Teething Tablets, while the new warning applies to all homeopathic teething products. In the 2010 warning they stated:
Hyland’s Teething Tablets are manufactured to contain a small amount of belladonna, a substance that can cause serious harm at larger doses. For such a product, it is important that the amount of belladonna be carefully controlled. FDA laboratory analysis, however, has found that Hyland’s Teething Tablets contain inconsistent amounts of belladonna. In addition, the FDA has received reports of serious adverse events in children taking this product that are consistent with belladonna toxicity. The FDA has also received reports of children who consumed more tablets than recommended, because the containers do not have child resistant caps.
Hyland’s Teething Tablets were reintroduced to the market in 2011 after it was “reformulated.” In response to the recent warning by the FDA, the company put out a statement in which they state:
There is no current recall of Hyland’s Baby Teething Tablets.[and]There is NO scientific link between homeopathically-prepared belladonna, or Hyland’s Baby Teething Tablets, and seizures.
There is no recall, but that may be the next step after the FDA warning. It is also ironic that Hyland’s will defend their product by saying there is no scientific link between their product and seizures, but ignores the fact that there is also NO scientific link between their product and any health benefit.
The FDA’s conundrum
Right at the bottom of the warning letter, the FDA describes itself as:
The FDA, an agency within the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, protects the public health by assuring the safety, effectiveness, security of human and veterinary drugs, vaccines and other biological products for human use, and medical devices.
They need to add to their standard self-description: “Except for homeopathic products, which we allow to be sold as drugs with unsubstantiated health claims, confusing or misleading labeling, and without evidence of safety, because we allow the homeopathic industry to regulate itself.”
The FDA has essentially abandoned its job to “protect the public health by assuring the safety, effectiveness,” of drugs when it comes to homeopathic potions.
However, last year the FDA announced that it was reconsidering its regulation of homeopathy. There was a public comment period – here is our open letter to the FDA. Now we are just waiting for the FDA to makes its decision. Will it finally do its job when it comes to homeopathy, or will it continue to take the politically easy path? You can be sure you will read about it here as soon as we know.

An Update on FDA Concerns Over Homeopathic Teething Products
Clay Jones on October 21, 2016
Link

Steven Novella recently wrote a post discussing an FDA warning against the use of homeopathic teething products over safety concerns related to the possibility of toxic amounts of belladonna. He goes into the hypocrisy of the FDA regulation of homeopathic products, a topic covered numerous times here on Science-Based Medicine, as well as the misleading initial response from Hyland’s, producers of the most popular homeopathic teething remedies in the United States and Canada. There have been some updates over the past two weeks that I’ll cover in this post.
FDA reveals concerning cases of possible serious harm
Just as the media response to the initial FDA warning announcement on September 30th was dying down, a new round of articles, like this one from CNN, were published in response to new information from the FDA. Although the data is unpublished at this time, a spokesperson from the FDA has disclosed that their investigation into adverse events related to homeopathic teething products has revealed 400 reports, including 10 deaths, since 2010. They were clear that a causal relationship between these products and the adverse events has not been proven and that the investigation is ongoing.
I also want to be very clear and point out that as proponents of scientific skepticism we must not rush to judgement regarding these new revelations. While I am certainly no fan of homeopathy, because it is abject nonsense that carries risk of both direct and indirect harm to patients without any specific benefit, there is a very real possibility that the outcomes in question had nothing to do with these products. The reports absolutely do require further investigation, in particular when considering that this exact problem has happened before in 2010.
Why we shouldn’t rush to judgement
Adverse event reporting for drugs, which homeopathic products are designated as by the FDA despite not being tested for safety or efficacy, is no different than for vaccines. Vaccines are also drugs, but they have a completely separate reporting system known as the VAERS. Both systems serve only as a guide for more directed investigation because both can be misleading or even abused by biased individuals with a self-serving agenda.
Although it is a continuous source of cerebral embogglement for me, parents frequently attribute a variety of symptoms, even significant systemic manifestations of actual illness, to teething. Seizures, vomiting, constipation, difficulty breathing, and fever appear to make up the bulk of the adverse events discovered by the FDA so far in their investigation, but I’m sure there are more. Perhaps a child was even turned into the Hulk, or at the very least Matter-Eater Lad.
Because of how common teething is, and the sad fact that hundreds of thousands of doses of homeopathic remedies are given to teething children every year, it is possible that administration was simply coincidental to the reported outcomes. Bottom line, we need to wait until the investigation is complete and published. But we have plenty of legitimate reasons to question the availability of these products.
Response from the homeopathic community
The initial response from Hyland’s to the FDA warning, as discussed in Dr. Novella’s post, was predictably to deny the link between their product and serious adverse events, and to make clear that the FDA had not actually recalled any of their products. They followed this with a press release that again trumpeted the safety of their product and even included a condescending informational video that is full of propaganda. According to the video, even doctors can make the mistake of jumping to conclusions about homeopathic belladonna. But once we learn a little bit about the science of diluting a deadly poison into non-existence, our concerns become just plain silly.
On October 11th, just prior to the publication of numerous articles mentioning the FDA revelation of possible deaths and other adverse events caused by homeopathic teething products, Hyland’s released a letter to the public from their employees, and an accompanying FAQ, announcing that they will stop distributing their teething products in the United States. It came complete with signatures of the employees and pictures of their children and grandchildren, all supposedly relieved of their suffering by Hyland’s products. In the letter, Hyland’s lamented the confusion caused by the FDA warning and the fact that some retailers have chosen to pull their products from store shelves.
This voluntary cessation of distribution only affect retail stores in the United States. Canadian parents can still purchase Hyland’s teething products and they can still be ordered online. In the UK, homeopathic products such as Hyland’s that are produced in the United States and available online are not licensed for use, and parents across the pond have been advised by their government to avoid them.
The most obnoxious response to the FDA warning, which should come as a surprise to exactly nobody, was an “ACTION ALERT” from the National Center for Homeopathy on October 17th. It’s short but full of reality-challenged misinformation, so I’ll just reproduce it here:
On September 30th, the Food and Drug Administration issued a press release warning consumers to stop using homeopathic teething tablets and gels. The sensational and dramatic headlines that followed created a public scare and led to the removal of homeopathic teething products from the shelves of stores. This was met with wide spread “anti-FDA” sentiment in social media.
The FDA later clarified that they were conducting an ongoing investigation as a response to reported serious adverse events. While the FDA’s warning about homeopathic teething preparation seems arbitrary and capricious, the media’s exaggerated fear mongering has made a bad situation worse. In fact, an FDA spokesperson told news agencies that the relationship between serious adverse events and homeopathic teething products has not yet been determined and is currently under review.
Homeopathy has a laudable and extensively documented clinical record and there are hundreds of high quality, peer-reviewed basic science, pre-clinical, and clinical studies showing its efficacy and safety. There are no studies linking homeopathically-prepared medicines and serious adverse events.
Despite these facts, groups interested in seeing homeopathy destroyed continue to hammer away at the system – making exaggerated claims that create misunderstandings about [sic] and limit consumer access.
Homeopathy is a safe, gentle, and natural system of healing that works with your body to relieve symptoms, restore itself, and improve your overall health. It has been used successfully for the last 200 years by over 250 million people worldwide. Homeopathy is growing in popularity in the United States, where homeopathic over the counter (OTC) medicines are regulated by the FDA and have been so for decades.
No studies linking homeopathy to serious adverse events? I’ll just leave this here for you to review at your leisure. About the only accurate fact in this response is the date of the FDA warning. Even worse is the fact that they link to an anti-vaccine, conspiracy laden blog post from Living Whole.
Conclusion: It’s not personal, it’s about patient safety
The FDA and supporters of science-based medicine are not out to get Hyland’s, or any proponents of homeopathic treatments for that matter. There is no personal vendetta, only the desire for patients and parents to be given legitimate information and to protect people from possible harm, especially considering the absence of any benefit from these products beyond placebo. The FDA has reason to investigate these products and to let consumers know of their concerns so that they can make informed choices.

Battle of the feds: FTC tells FDA to do its job regulating homeopathy
Jann Bellamy on September 3, 2015
Tweet


Last month, the Society for Science-Based Medicine submitted a comment to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in response to its request for public comments on the agency’s current regulation (actually, lack of regulation) of homeopathic drugs. As the SFSBM pointed out, the FDA has, without legal authority, exempted homeopathic drugs from the safety and efficacy requirements applicable to other drugs under the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act (FD&C Act). Lax regulation has resulted in consumer confusion: consumers do not understand homeopathy, how the FDA regulates homeopathic drugs, and the lack of scientific evidence underlying claims made by homeopathic drug companies.
As it turns out, we were in excellent company. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the agency charged with preventing fraudulent and deceptive business practices, submitted its own comment to the FDA, making these same points. (The FTC is holding its own workshop on advertising homeopathic drugs later this month. We’ll get to that shortly.)
The FTC’s advertising substantiation policy requires that health-related efficacy claims be supported by competent and reliable scientific evidence. The FDA, despite federal law, does not require evidence of efficacy for homeopathic drugs prior to their being marketed. This creates a potential conflict between the two regulatory schemes, resulting in homeopathic over-the-counter (OTC) “drugs” on the market that both comply with FDA’s policy and violate FTC’s policy. This, says the FTC, can be harmful to consumers and create confusion for advertisers. The FTC “recommends that the FDA reconsider its regulatory framework for homeopathic medicines” and tells the FDA what it can do to remedy the situation.
According to the FTC, the FTC’s and FDA’s jurisdiction over OTC drugs overlaps considerably. [The vast majority of homeopathic drugs are OTC.] Since 1971, the two agencies have cooperated in regulating the marketing of OTC products, with the FDA focusing on product labeling and the FTC on advertising. Unfortunately, the FDA’s continued exemption of homeopathic OTC drugs from regulation imposed on all other OTC products has been an impediment to this cooperation and, we might add, greatly enriched the homeopathic drug industry, which has essentially regulated itself, with the blessing of the FDA.
As the FTC points out, in 1972, the FDA deferred homeopathic drugs from a process to determine which OTC drugs were generally recognized as safe and effective if taken as directed. Despite the FDA’s assurances that it would put homeopathic drugs through the same paces, over 40 years later it has not done so. Then, in 1988, the FDA issued a Compliance Policy Guide (CPG 400.400) permitting the manufacture and distribution of homeopathic drugs without FDA approval, thereby institutionalizing the regulatory neglect that had been going on since 1938, when the FD&C Act was passed. (The FTC doesn’t use those exact words, but that is the real effect of CPG 400.400.) Not only does the CPG exempt homeopathic drugs from demonstrating efficacy, it also allows claims that the drug treats specific conditions as long as the conditions are self-limiting and not chronic. As well, the CPG requires an indication for use on the label.
Translation: the entire homeopathic drug label could be a fabrication and the FDA isn’t going to do anything about it.
FDA interferes with FTC regulation
The FTC takes a far different tack in regulating homeopathic remedies, or, at least, it would like to if not for the FDA.
The FTC’s well-established position on advertising substantiation was first announced in 1972 and has been repeatedly reaffirmed. For health, safety, or efficacy claims, the FTC has generally required that advertisers possess “competent and reliable scientific evidence,” defined as “tests, analyses, research, or studies that have been conducted and evaluated in an objective manner by qualified persons and are generally accepted in the profession to yield accurate and reliable results.” Competent and reliable scientific evidence may take different forms depending on the type of claim being made. For some claims, the substantiation required may be one or more well-designed human clinical studies. Neither the FTC Act, nor any FTC rules or policy statement, exempts advertising claims for homeopathic drugs from these standards. [Footnotes omitted.]
Given the lack of evidence of efficacy for homeopathic products, homeopathic advertising should have been doomed by the FTC’s advertising requirements long ago. But the FDA’s slack regulation has not only allowed false labeling, it has prevented the FTC from doing its job. Where the FDA’s and the FTC’s jurisdiction over advertising overlaps, the FTC has been reluctant to pursue homeopathic drug companies because of this conflict.
The FTC’s comment suggests the conflict can be resolved by the FDA taking one of three actions:
     1.  Withdraw CPG 400.400, and make homeopathic drugs subject to the same regulatory requirements as other drug products. [This is the solution advocated by SFSBM. Indeed, we feel this is exactly what Congress has told the FDA to do.]
     2.  Eliminate the requirement that an indication for use appear on the label. [Remember: the FDA requires that a use be indicated but does not require that it be truthful.] If a company wanted to include an indication on the label it could. Of course, without an indication there would be no clue as to what the product is for, and the FTC thinks most companies will include one. If the company does so, however, it will need competent and reliable scientific evidence to comply with the FTC’s advertising rules, even if the FDA continues to exempt homeopathic products from demonstrating efficacy.
     3.  Actually require that any indication appearing on the label be supported by competent and reliable scientific evidence, just as the FTC does.
In addition to the FTC-FDA regulatory conflict, the FTC commented that the CPG could lead to confusion for both consumers and advertisers. We would say, of course, that it does lead to consumer confusion. If the consumer knew the truth, why in the world would he buy a homeopathic product? It also, according to the FTC, creates a loophole allowing manufacturers to skip more stringent requirements by labeling their products “homeopathic.”
Some advertisers may believe that compliance with the FDA’s CPG means they are home free when, in fact, they could be in violation of FTC substantiation requirements. This actually happened in a proceeding involving “Earache Relief Drops,” a homeopathic OTC remedy claiming it “relieves pain, sooths & calms” and is “safe for use with antibiotics.” Of course, the manufacturer did not have competent and reliable scientific evidence that this was actually true, although it is likely correct that the product didn’t interfere with antibiotics due to the fact that homeopathic drugs rarely contain any active ingredient. Indeed, evidence that the product “relieves pain” would have been impossible to produce, given the pseudoscience upon which homeopathy is based. The manufacturer’s defense, when told to produce such evidence, was that it didn’t have to, because the FDA didn’t require it. In fact, the manufacturer was under the false impression that the FTC didn’t require any evidence either.
Evidence of consumer confusion
At the FDA hearing, the homeopathic industry was unable to produce a shred of evidence that consumers understand the true nature of homeopathic drugs. SFSBM’s comment noted the many and varied unproven claims made for homeopathy’s effectiveness in online comments from consumers, including, among numerous others, effectiveness for ADHD, cancer, coma, food poisoning, infertility, various infections, psoriasis and spider bites.
The FTC’s comment brings valuable new information to the FDA’s decision-making: actual research the FTC undertook on consumer confusion. First, the FTC, working with an outside firm, set up small focus groups to inform further research efforts. The information gained was used to formulate a “copy test,” which gauged consumer beliefs about homeopathy based on variations on the product labels. According to the FTC,
our research suggests that a significant percentage of consumers do not understand the nature of homeopathic products, how they are regulated, or the level of substantiation to support claims for those products.
In particular, consumers in the focus groups:
    • had difficulty distinguishing between herbal and homeopathic products;
    • associated homeopathic products with “natural” or, in a misconception reminiscent of the Food Babe, “non-chemical” products; and
    • did not understand how homeopathic remedies are supposed to “work,” and, when told, questioned their effectiveness.
In the copy tests, consumers:
    • misconceived the level of evidence required by regulators for various products and mistakenly believed the FDA has approved homeopathic products for efficacy;
    • did not understand how homeopathic remedies are supposed to “work,” and, when told, questioned their effectiveness; and
    • believed that homeopathic remedy manufacturers tested their products for effectiveness.
The FTC is also concerned by the mingling of conventional and homeopathic products on store shelves, the unusual terminology used in homeopathic product labeling (“it is difficult to understand what 2X means”), and the risk that consumers will chose homeopathic remedies over proven medicine.
I don’t know how often (if ever) one governmental agency recommends that another government agency “reconsider its regulatory framework” because its current policies cause consumer confusion, potential harm, and inhibit the former’s ability to do its job, which happens to be preventing that very same consumer confusion and harm. Any of the FTC’s proposed solutions would effectively kill off the consumer market for OTC homeopathic remedies. (Depending on what the FDA does, prescription homeopathic remedies could possibly escape extinction.) An FDA Law Blog post asked: “Will FTC Kill Homeopathic Products – or Will FDA?” Looks like it will be a joint effort.
FTC workshop on homeopathic drug advertising
The FTC’s September 21 workshop examining advertising of OTC homeopathic products:
will bring together a variety of stakeholders, including medical professionals, industry representatives, consumer advocates, and government regulators.
According to an e-mail I received from the FTC, there will be no speakers, unlike the FDA’s hearing. The FTC’s announcement also:
invites the public to submit research, recommendations for topics of discussion, and requests to participate as panelists. The workshop will cover topics including:
    • A look at changes in the homeopathic market, its advertising, and what consumers know;
    • The science behind homeopathy and its effectiveness;
    • The effects of recent class actions against homeopathic product companies;
    • The application of Section 5 of the FTC Act to advertising claims for homeopathic products; and
    • Public policy concerns about the current regulation of homeopathic products.
(My own request to be a panelist was, sadly, turned down.)
Based on its comment to the FDA, the FTC appears to have made up its mind on topics 1, 2, 4 and 5. With regard to topic 2, in the FTC’s comment we see hints that it doesn’t seem inclined to accept the homeopathic industry’s fantastical claims as “science” or its flawed methodology (e.g., “provings”) as reliable evidence of effectiveness. When discussing the focus group results, the FTC referred to increased consumer skepticism upon learning “the theory of homeopathy” and “the principles behind it,” suggesting that, without this information, “consumers may choose homeopathic products based on incorrect and incomplete information.” [Emphasis added.] Of course, it should go without saying that no responsible scientist would ever accept homeopathy’s underlying “theories” as competent and reliable scientific evidence. One could become worried, however, when reading the transcript of the FDA’s hearing, where naturopath/homeopath Amy Rothenberg’s statement that homeopathy could be explained by hormesis (among other pseudoscientific explanations) went without further examination by the FDA’s panel.
As to topic 3, there is a recent decision in a class action which may spur the FDA and FTC to act. Prior to the decision, class actions had been allowed to go forward despite the homeopathic companies’ claims that these suits were preempted by federal law, that is, the regulatory scheme already in place for homeopathic drugs. To which the plaintiffs replied: Regulation? What regulation? There isn’t any.
However, a class action was recently brought against Whole Foods in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, seeking both economic damages and injunctive relief, in the form of an order prohibiting further sale. The products at issue were Whole Foods’ house brand homeopathic remedies. Whole Foods was successful in its preemption defense, which knocked out the claims for injunctive relief. Essentially the court ruled that the plaintiffs were trying to ban a product that the FDA allowed, something the court could not do.
Whole Foods also won on the “primary jurisdiction” issue. This argument was based on the fact that Congress had determined the appropriate forum for deciding the issues raised by the plaintiffs – the labeling of homeopathic drugs – was the FDA, not the courts. Thus, this court must abstain from deciding those issues:
The Food and Drug Administration has the necessary experience and expertise in regulating labeling of homeopathic medication and it is within the Agency’s purview to decide whether the labels are compliant with federal law and the comprehensive regulatory scheme it has devised. . . . In this case, however, given the extensive regulatory scheme to oversee homeopathic drug marketing and the questions presented over the labels in this case, the Court finds abstention appropriate under the primary jurisdiction doctrine.
The court is correct. There is an “extensive regulatory scheme to oversee homeopathic drug marketing.” It’s just that the FDA has chosen to ignore it. Now that one court has declined to grant relief, perhaps the FDA will be further induced to, in the words of the FTC, “reconsider its regulatory framework” and force these fraudulent products off the market.
SFSBM will be submitting a comment to the FTC and we hope you will too. You can find out how here. Comments are due by November 20, 2015. You can find out more about the FTC’s standards for truthful advertising here.

The Federal Trade Commission takes on homeopathy—maybe
David Gorski on September 14, 2015
Link


Well, I’m back.
OK, returning from London isn’t nearly as epic as Sam Gamgee’s final words in The Lord of the Rings returning to his wife and daughter after having accompanied Frodo, Gandalf, Bilbo, and key elves of Middle-Earth to the Grey Havens, there to say goodbye to them as they boarded a ship to the undying lands. I just love the quote. It says something to me returning home after a long journey, even if it was just a vacation to J.R.R. Tolkien’s native land. It also suggests a bit of the exhaustion after a long day of traveling, complete with a long-delayed flight, a late arrival, and a state of utter exhaustion that accompanied it, plus an unfortunate lower gastrointestinal issue.
All of this is a way of saying that this post might actually be relatively brief for a post by me…no epics this week. [Addendum: Nope. Even lower GI annoyances and exhaustion couldn’t keep me from going over 2,000 words. At least I didn’t hit 3,000.] In its nearly eight year history, I’ve never missed more than one week at SBM, and I don’t intend to start now. Specifically, with the FTC workshop on homeopathy rapidly approaching, one week from today, I couldn’t resist adding my 2 pence to the mix, now that the agenda and list of participants have been announced.
Homeopathy: The One Quackery To Rule Them All
A frequent topic on this blog is homeopathy, for reasons that regular readers no doubt understand all too well by now. Homeopathy is, as I like to call it, again borrowing from Tolkien, The One Quackery To Rule Them All. When it comes to quackery, few can even come close to homeopathy for the sheer ridiculousness of its precepts. Whether it is the Law of Similars, which claims that to cure a disease you need to use a substance that cause’s that diseases symptoms in healthy people, a “law” that has no basis in science, or the Law of Infinitesimals, which postulates that serially diluting a substance to nonexistence in the solution—with vigorous shaking (succussion) to “potentize” the mixture between each dilution step, of course—makes it stronger, few quackeries bring the pseudoscience to such a high level as homeopathy. Indeed, as I frequently like to say, for homeopathy to work, not only would much of what we know about physics and chemistry have to be wrong, but spectacularly wrong. Sure, reiki is nothing but faith healing that substitutes Eastern mystical beliefs for Christian beliefs in identifying the source of the “healing power” used, but that’s just pure magical thinking, little or no reference to science required. Few quacks can create a self-contained, self-sustaining world of pseudoscience the way homeopaths can.
Given just how utterly barmy (yes, London still lingers in my choice of language) homeopathy is, it is often puzzling to supporters of science-based medicine how it can be legal, not only in the UK, where the last time I visited England I made it a point to have my photo taken in front of the Royal London Homeopathic Hospital (which has “evolved” into the Royal London Hospital for Integrated Medicine) but right here in the US. As Jann Bellamy explained a few months ago, thanks to a quirk in the Food, Drug and Cosmetics Act (FD&C Act), passed in 1938 and history in which the FDA basically abdicated its responsibility to regulate homeopathic remedies as drugs, anything included within a publication known as the Homoeopathic Pharmacopoeia of the United States (HPUS) are, in practice, allowed to be sold. Jann makes a compelling case that, because under the FD&C Act of 1938, substances in the HPUS are defined as drugs, the FDA should have authority to regulate them as such, but, even in the wake of the Kefauver-Harris Amendments of 1962 that required manufacturers to prove safety and efficacy rather just safety before a drug could be approved, homeopathy remained largely unregulated. If it was in the HPUS, basically, it was okay.
FDA vs. FTC: A cage match made in Washington
Earlier this year, the FDA announced that it was considering modernizing how it regulates homeopathic remedies and held a hearing for public input. As was noted at the time, there were few skeptics and plenty of industry representatives and homeopaths who testified. Written comments were also solicited, and the Society for SBM submitted one, arguing that the FDA has, without legal authority, exempted homeopathic remedies from the safety and efficacy requirements applicable to other drugs under the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act (FD&C Act). The SfSBM further argued that lax regulation of homeopathy has resulted in consumer confusion, and consumers do not understand how the FDA regulates (or, more accurately, does not regulate) homeopathic drugs and the lack of scientific evidence for homeopathy.
It turns out that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the federal agency responsible for preventing, identifying, and prosecuting fraudulent business practices, also submitted a comment to the FDA making the very same points, as Jann Bellamy pointed out earlier this month, referring to it as the “battle of the feds” and noting:
The FTC’s advertising substantiation policy requires that health-related efficacy claims be supported by competent and reliable scientific evidence. The FDA, despite federal law, does not require evidence of efficacy for homeopathic drugs prior to their being marketed. This creates a potential conflict between the two regulatory schemes, resulting in homeopathic over-the-counter (OTC) “drugs” on the market that both comply with FDA’s policy and violate FTC’s policy. This, says the FTC, can be harmful to consumers and create confusion for advertisers. The FTC “recommends that the FDA reconsider its regulatory framework for homeopathic medicines” and tells the FDA what it can do to remedy the situation.
Jann also noted:
I don’t know how often (if ever) one governmental agency recommends that another government agency “reconsider its regulatory framework” because its current policies cause consumer confusion, potential harm, and inhibit the former’s ability to do its job, which happens to be preventing that very same consumer confusion and harm.
Neither do I, but I do know that the FTC workshop is scheduled for next Monday and will be webcast. It is instructive to look at who has been asked to participate in the workshop. The workshop’s agenda is divided into three sessions:
    • Panel 1: Homeopathic Industry & Advertising
    • Panel 2: Scientific Support for Homepathic Advertising Claims
    • Panel 3: Legal/Regulatory Issues Presented by Homeopathic Advertising
Panel 1: The homeopathic Dream Team
Not surprisingly, the homeopathy industry mobilized to defend its ability to make huge profits selling water and sugar pills at massive markup, assembling a “homeopathic dream team” of “experts to represent our interests at the FTC event.”
For panel 1, the panelists include just some of those “dream team” members. Here is the panel:
    • John P. Borneman, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Standard Homeopathic Company and Hyland’s, Inc.
    • Candace Corlett, President, WSL Strategic Retail
    • Mark Land, Vice President, Operations & Regulatory Affairs, Boiron, Inc.
    • Yale Martin, Independent Retail Consultant
    • Duffy McKay, Senior Vice President, Scientific & Regulatory Affairs, Council for Responsible Nutrition
On the surface, it looks like it’s four to one, quack-apologists versus a science advocate (Duffy McKay). John Borneman and Mark Land represent manufacturers of homeopathic remedies and can predictably be expected to defend the current system, from which their companies have profited so magnificently selling quackery. Also on the surface, Yale Martin seemed like an interesting choice:
Yale Martin is an independent retail consultant residing in Bentonville, Arkansas. He retired in November 2014 from Walmart Stores, Inc. after 18 years in Walmart’s buying office. Mr. Martin spent much of his career as a buyer and for the last five years supervised Walmart’s over-the-counter (OTC) buying office, responsible for more than 4,000 OTC items retailed in Walmart’s 5,000 US stores. Previously, Mr. Martin held buying positions in Baby, Pet, Health and Beauty Aids/Cosmetics, and OTC. Mr. Martin holds a bachelor’s degree from the University of California and serves on the Board of Directors of Angie’s Artisan Treats, an organic snack food company owned by a private equity firm.
My guess is that Martin will also be on the side of the current system, given how profitable over-the-counter homeopathic remedies are, perhaps with mild tweaks. Maybe he’ll recommend some minor changes in labeling or something like that, but I highly doubt he’ll say anything substantive. Don’t believe me? Check out his testimony at the FDA hearing:
The homeopathic products sold in typical mass retailers are successfully used by tens of thousands of consumers each day. The free market system has a tendency to quickly eliminate items which do not meet consumer expectations since they are not repurchased. Items that fail to meet a retailer’s “minimum sales threshold” are quickly replaced by other items. Shelf space is the most valuable commodity a retailer has and items that disappoint consumers do not last long in any retailer.
Many, if not most, of the manufacturers of homeopathic products are conservative, long-established companies. Some of these companies are nearing 100 years old. These companies have a history of producing quality products that address health issues of importance to consumers. Any additional restrictive regulations of these homeopathic drug products would hinder the public’s access to these products and would significantly limit consumer choice.
Yes, he’ll argue that the free market will take care of all those pesky problems of determining efficacy of homeopathic products. If they don’t work, people won’t buy them! Never mind that the advertising goes out of its way to give the impression that they work. And we wouldn’t want to “limit consumer choice” by requiring that companies be able to back up their claims of efficacy and safety, now would we? Again, the free market will take care of all that, at least, if you believe Mr. Martin. Expect the same drivel at the FTC panel. Of course, he’s on the “dream team” too; so of course he’s going to defend the industry.
But what about Duffy McKay? When I read the list, I must admit that the Council for Responsible Nutrition sounded as though it might be science-based. However, I was quickly disabused of that notion when I read his bio, which reveals that he is a “licensed Naturopathic Doctor who still sees patients on a part-time basis in an integrative medical practice, and previously was co-owner and practitioner in a family-owned New Hampshire complementary and alternative medicine private practice.” Basically, the CRN is, according to its website, the “leading trade association representing dietary supplement and functional food manufacturers and ingredient suppliers,” and its member companies “manufacture popular national brands as well as the store brands marketed by major supermarkets, drug stores and discount chains.”
So, in the first panel, it’s four quacks and a marketing flack (Candace Corlett). This does not look promising at all.
Panel 2: Evidence for hope, or hope for evidence?
In panel 2, the participants include:
    • Adriene Fugh-Berman, Associate Professor, Department of Pharmacology and Physiology, Georgetown University Medical Center
    • Paul Herscu, Naturopathic Physician, Director, New England School of Homeopathy
    • Wayne B. Jonas, President & CEO, Samueli Institute
    • Richard (Rik) Lostritto, Division Director and Acting Associate Office Director for Science in the Office of Policy for Pharmaceutical Quality (OPPQ), Food and Drug Administration
    • David Riley, Academy of Integrative Health and Medicine, Integrative Medicine Institute
    • John Williamson, Branch Chief, Basic and Mechanistic Research in Complementary and Integrative Health, National Center for Integrative Health
This list is a little better. Yes, it’s stacked with advocates of “integrative medicine” (the Samueli Institute is one of the big players in this field and has been discussed here before on multiple occasions). On the other hand, Adrienne Fugh-Berman, even though she is an advocate of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM), is no friend of homeopathy. At the FDA hearing, she said that the evidence for homeopathy is “between scant and nil” and expressed concern about stocking homeopathic remedies right next to real medicine on pharmacy shelves because, in her view, most consumers and medical professionals have no idea what homeopathic remedies are (which is undoubtedly true), don’t know they aren’t reviewed for safety and efficacy (also undoubtedly true), and likely think they are dietary supplements or conventional OTC drugs Then, of course, it’ll be interesting to see Richard Lostritto try to defend the current FDA policy regarding homeopathy.
Finally, although it might seem unpromising that there is a Branch Chief from the NCCIH there, I do note that the NCCIH of late hasn’t exactly been that friendly to homeopathy. The last time I checked, there hasn’t been a grant from NCCIH to fund research into homeopathy since 2008. Indeed, in our discussion with Josephine Briggs in 2010, although she didn’t explicitly rule out ever funding a homeopathy grant again (probably because she couldn’t do that) she definitely seemed to agree that homeopathy was not particularly plausible and didn’t express much enthusiasm for it, given that she was likely at the time involved in developing the 2011-2015 strategic plan, that I like to refer to as “let’s do some real science for a change.”
Still, overall, the second panel is packed with homeopathy advocates.
Panel 3: Legal niceties
Finally, there is panel 3:
    • Kathleen Dunnigan, Senior Staff Attorney, National Advertising Division, Council of Better Business Bureaus
    • Elaine Lippmann, Regulatory Counsel, Food and Drug Administration
    • Al Lorman, Partner, Law Office of Alvin J. Lorman
    • Paul D. Rubin, Esq., Partner, Ropes & Gray, LLP
    • Michelle Rusk, Senior Staff Attorney, Division of Advertising Practices, Federal Trade Commission
    • Christina Guerola Sarchio, Partner, Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe, LLP
    • David C. Spangler, Senior Vice President, Policy, and General Counsel and Secretary, Consumer Healthcare Products Association
    • Anthony Vozzolo, Partner, Faruqi and Faruqi, LLP
Not surprisingly, given that this last panel is to discuss legal and regulatory issues, it composed of all lawyers. Unfortunately, most appear to be flacks for the homeopathy industry, with Sarchio and Rubin being arguably two of the heaviest hitting of the homeopathic flacks. They’re both part of the AHRP homeopathic dream team, and both represent Boiron, the French manufacturer responsible for the homeopathic flu remedy known as Oscillococcinum, which is a 200C dilution of Anas Barbariae Hepatis et Cordis Extractum (extract of Muscovy Duck liver and heart, respectively). I kid you not. Then there’s David Spangler, director of Consumer Healthcare Products Association’s (CHPA) legal affairs and international affairs. He is also on the AHRP’s homeopathic dream team. (The CHPA testified at the FDA hearing in April in favor of the current regulatory system.) Let’s just put it this way, the CHPA says homeopathic medicines work and refers people to the websites of manufacturers of homeopathic remedies like Boiron and Hylands for more information.
Still, all is not lost. Elaine Lippman acquitted herself well in the FDA hearing, asking hard questions of the advocates trotted out by the homeopathy industry, such as why they couldn’t do the same kinds of studies that drug companies had to do to provide evidence that their products are effective, e.g., RCTs. She even got one to admit there wasn’t any reason they couldn’t do this, and got the Consumer Healthcare Products Association (CHPA) representative to admit that they had no evidence that consumers understood the labels of homeopathic drugs. Next, Kathleen Dunnigan represents the National Advertising Division for the Council of Better Business Bureaus. She has a degree in engineering, so she might be expected to understand why homeopathy is so completely implausible from a scientific standpoint. If that is true, she could be a valuable member of the committee. In addition, Anthony Vozzolo has handled a class action suit against Hyland’s (Forcellati v. Hyland’s, Inc.), a major manufacturer of homeopathic remedies; so that’s promising.
Finally, Michelle Rusk could be very good indeed, if this presentation she gave on the FTC’s substantiation policy for dietary supplements is any indication. As Jann noted to me in an e-mail, if this policy were applied to homeopathic remedies, the industry would take a major hit.
Conclusion: Hopes and ropes
I realize that any regulatory agency considering major changes in how it regulates an industry needs to hear from advocates of that industry. That’s just politics and policy. However, it is still depressing how heavily stacked the first two panels are in favor of homeopathy and CAM advocates. The last panel is less blatantly stacked that way, but still leans towards the advocates. I happen to know, for instance, that the Center for Inquiry tried to get a representative at the workshop. As the final makeup of the workshop shows, it was unable to do so. (At least at the FDA hearing in April, Michael De Dora and other critics of homeopathy made statements.)
I realize that there is an argument to be made that the FTC has already decided that homeopathic products need to be treated, for purposes of advertising, like every other drug and are simply giving advocates every opportunity to make their case; i.e., that they are giving industry advocates enough rope to hang themselves, but even in that event one would expect that the workshop wouldn’t be quite so unbalanced in favor of homeopathy advocates.

FTC Homeopathy Win
Steven Novella on November 16, 2016
Link
I love to see a regulatory agency actually do its job. Especially within medicine, where it is most important, the lack of political will seems to get in the way of properly regulating health care products and services in the way that most consumers assume they are regulated.
Homeopathy is perhaps the best example. Homeopathy is pure unadulterated pseudoscience and witchcraft. There is no legitimate scientific debate about this. Homeopaths create their potions by starting with fanciful substances that can’t work and then dilute them out of existence. The result is plain water that they claim has magical properties. Yes – that’s really what it is.
Unsurprisingly, rigorous clinical trials have shown that homeopathic potions in fact do not work.
Current regulation
Mainly for historical reasons, the FDA has categorized homeopathic products as drugs. They are not drugs, but that is how they are classified. This means that disease claims can be made for homeopathic products.
For all other drugs regulated by the FDA, the privilege of being able to claim that the drug can treat or cure a specific disease comes with a rather high bar of evidence for safety and efficacy. That seems fair – you can make specific disease claims, but you have to provide sufficienct evidence.
This is in contrast to supplements, for which companies cannot make disease claims. They can only make “structure/function” claims, that the product improves or enhances some structure or function within the body. Diseases cannot be mentioned. Additionally, companies do not need to provide any evidence to back these claims. This is a horrific back door which needs to be closed, but that is a topic for another time.
Homeopathic remedies, however, live in the regulatory netherworld. They have all the privileges of being classified as drugs, but the FDA has unilaterally decided not to enforce the requirement for providing evidence of efficacy. Rather, homeopaths can base claims entirely on their tradition. They can literally just write down a homeopathic potion in their book (the Homeopathic Materia Medica) and make whatever claims they wish. No scientific evidence is required.
Regulations under review
Last year both the FDA (Food and Drug Administration) and FTC (Federal Trade Commission) announced that they were reviewing their current regulation of homeopathic products. Keep in mind this is just about over-the-counter (OTC) products, not the practice of homeopathy by licensed homeopaths or other professionals. That is up to the states.
Both agencies had an open comment period, in which the SfSBM submitted rather strong recommendations. Both agencies have the authority to increase their regulation if they choose. It seems to me that this is purely a matter of political will.
Since the comment periods have closed we have been waiting anxiously for both agencies to announce their decisions. This could be, in the best-case scenario, a death blow to the OTC homeopathy industry.
Yesterday the FTC released their decision. Here is the key part:
The policy statement explains that the FTC will hold efficacy and safety claims for OTC homeopathic drugs to the same standard as other products making similar claims. That is, companies must have competent and reliable scientific evidence for health-related claims, including claims that a product can treat specific conditions. The statement describes the type of scientific evidence that the Commission requires of companies making such claims for their products.
That was all they had to do, and all we were asking for. Hold homeopathic products to the same requirement for evidence to back any clinical claims that they make. In essence, all we wanted was for them to do their job. The FTC now seems willing to do just that.
They further explain that companies can make claims for products based on things other than reliable scientific evidence, but that they then have to clearly explain the basis of those claims:
However, the policy statement also notes that “the FTC has long recognized that marketing claims may include additional explanatory information to prevent the claims from being misleading. Accordingly, it recognizes that an OTC homeopathic drug claim that is not substantiated by competent and reliable scientific evidence might not be deceptive if the advertisement or label where it appears effectively communicates that: 1) there is no scientific evidence that the product works; and 2) the product’s claims are based only on theories of homeopathy from the 1700s that are not accepted by most modern medical experts.
In essence, the net effect of the labeling on the product cannot be misleading to the consumer. I think this is giving some wiggle room for homeopathic manufacturers to try their best to mislead their potential customers, but this is probably the best the FTC can do within its mandate.
The FTC statement specifically notes that this policy does not violate the first amendment, which signals their primary concern. Companies still have the free speech to tell the public that they believe from their traditions that a product can work for a specific indication, as long as they also say this is not based on evidence or on modern accepted scientific concepts.
This all means that it is more important than ever to educate the public about the true nature of homeopathy. The new FTC policy only really works if the public has a basic level of scientific literacy. That is a much longer struggle.
The official FTC decision is here. The FTC has also published a much longer document in which they review all the comments that were provided to them and the information they reviewed.
Three other organizations skeptical of homeopathy, The Society for Science-Based Medicine (SSBM), The Center for Inquiry, and the Richard Dawkins Foundation for Reason and Science (the RD Foundation), also submitted comments. The comments argued that homeopathic products have no efficacy in treating illnesses and that there is no reasonable basis for homeopathic principles such as “like cures like,” the law of infinitesimal doses, or water retaining a memory of things that have been in contact with it. They pointed to the Australian NHMRC report, to a report by the UK House of Commons Science and Technology Committee that “could find no support from independent experts for the idea that there is good evidence for the efficacy of homeopathy,” and to a statement by the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health that “There is little evidence to support homeopathy as an effective treatment for any specific condition.” The SSBM asserted, based in part on its reading of individual public comments submitted to the FDA, that consumers do not understand the nature of homeopathic drugs or the support for their claims.
If you have time the document is an interesting read. It includes comments from the homeopathic industry, which is unsurprising. They argue that homeopathy must work because people use it, and that there are positive studies of homeopathy. These are the same tired, deceptive claims they typically make.
When it comes to medical treatments, the argument from popularity is worthless because of placebo effects and the inherent difficulty of knowing if a treatment is helpful from anecdotal observation. Bloodletting was very popular for centuries. Further, they continue to cherry pick the studies they want, ignoring or dismissing the many systematic reviews which clearly show that homeopathy does not work for anything.
The bottom line is that, after more than 200 years of use, homeopaths have failed to provide solid scientific evidence that any homeopathic remedy works for any indication. They will give a lot of hand-waving explanations for why this is true, but they all fall flat. The simplest explanation for this lack of scientific evidence is that homeopathy does not work.
What about the FDA?
The FTC essentially regulates the marketing of products, their labeling, and the claims that can be made for them. They don’t regulate the products themselves, that is up to the FDA.
We are still waiting to hear the FDA’s decision on homeopathy. We hope, like the FTC, that they choose to do their job. All they have to do is enforce their mandate, and hold homeopathic “drugs” to the same requirements for evidence of safety and efficacy as all other actual drugs.
If they really do this, then I don’t see how the homeopathic OTC product market can survive. It is clear that they cannot provide scientific evidence for efficacy.
The realist in me (some might say pessimist) thinks that the FDA will tighten up regulations of homeopathy, but for political reasons will give the industry a loop hole. I predict they will simply require more accurate labeling of homeopathic products, but not require them to provide evidence of efficacy in order to remain on the market at all.
I am still hopeful they will go the distance and do the only rational and honest thing – regulate homeopathic products by the standards demanded by their category. Remember, the privilege of disease claims go hand-in-hand with high standards of scientific evidence. The FDA carved out a special exception for homeopathy, and all they need to do is make that exception go away.
If they do this, effectively shutting down the OTC homeopathy industry, I further predict that Congress will act to save the industry. They shouldn’t. They should let it die a merciful death. If only our world were that rational. Perhaps I will be pleasantly surprised.
Congress controls the FDA. They can easily pass a law that creates whatever regulatory scheme for homeopathy that they want. They did this for supplements with the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994. This is pro-industry, anti-consumer regulation. If history is any guide, they will do the same thing for the homeopathy industry.
There is a glimmer of hope, however. Note that the FTC heard the voice of skeptics, both individuals and organizations. We have a powerful voice, if not in numbers then in the logic and evidence that backs our opinions.
Now is the time to keep the pressure up. If the FDA returns a good decision on homeopathy, we have to anticipate how the industry will respond. The decision could backfire if Congress decides to act, and things could actually get worse. Our collective voice will be more necessary than ever.
The FTC has set the stage. When the FDA gives their decision, and especially if it is a science-based one, we cannot take time to celebrate. That will be a dangerous time, and we must snap into action as quickly as the homeopathic industry surely will.
This will be an opportunity to educate the public and our politicians about homeopathy. We need to make clear that the public expects health care products to be safe and effective, and that they not be deceived by false or misleading claims. We will all need to write our representatives, to make the voice of science and reason heard as loudly as possible.

What do consumers think about homeopathic remedies?
A new survey gives insights into how consumers view homeopathy, and how they feel about homeopathy once they learn what it actually is.
Scott Gavura on November 28, 2019
Link

If a health professional that you trust also sells pseudoscience, does it matter to you? That’s a question that I have asked myself for several years as I have watched pseudoscientifc products move from fringe to mainstream in retail pharmacies. Once rare, homeopathy is now easy to find in almost any pharmacy. Frustratingly, it is often shelved right beside actually medicine (i.e., products with active ingredients) and it’s understandable (and perhaps expected) that consumers may be confused, purchasing products that they believe are safe and effective, only to be sold a product with no plausible effectiveness and no medicinal ingredients at all.
In January I blogged about a survey by the Office for Science And Society at McGill University that showed two-thirds of Montreal pharmacies sell the placebo flu remedy Oscillococcinum. Now there’s a new study by a research organization on behalf of the Center for Inquiry that sought to understand consumer views on homeopathy, focusing on Oscillococcinum. The study gives some interesting insights into consumer knowledge about homeopathy, and the impact on health professionals like pharmacists.
In 2019 a research organization polled 1,000 US adults with an oversample of 200 adults from Washington DC to determine their perspectives on a range of topics regarding the sale of homeopathy. It was a telephone poll of registered voters, stratified geographically to represent the US population.
Views on pharmacies, alternative medicines, and the FDA
Consumers generally have favourable views of major drug stores, the FDA, and alternative medicine, with WalMart and CVS holding net popularity totals greater than the FDA.
Most adults said that they trust their pharmacy to sell drugs that are safe and effective:
When asked about the relative safety of homeopathy vs. conventional medical over-the-counter treatments, most people felt the products were equally safe, with almost 1 in 5 stating they were unsure:
Similar views were expressed about effectiveness: notably, more felt that homeopathic remedies were less effective.
Interestingly, 10% of adults report purchasing a homeopathic remedy when they meant to purchase actual medicine:
This is not surprising, as pharmacies tend to intermix homeopathy and conventional remedies on the shelf, as you can see from this photo I took in a local pharmacy:
Next the survey examined perceptions and attitudes about the homeopathic remedy oscillococcinium, which you can see on the top shelf in the photo above. Considering the scenario of a child with a cold or flu, respondents were asked about the effectiveness of oscillococcinum, based on the description on the label. Most responded it was somewhat or very effective, and a third were not sure. Only 21% rated it not effective:
57% considered it to be safe, and 29% were unsure.
Over 40% said that based on the product information that they would likely purchase oscillococcinum for a child suffering from a cold or the flu:
And most felt it was reasonable to shelve oscillococcinum in the pharmacy along with the other cough and cold products, just as is done in the pharmacy photo above.
What happens when consumers learn the facts about homeopathy?
Oscillococcinum is prepared by decapitating a barbary duck, taking 35 grams of its liver and 15 grams of its heart and fermenting it for 40 days:
One duck supplies the entire world
The fermented duck (“Anas barbariae“) broth then undergoes serial dilutions (1 part in 100) 200 times in a row (i.e., 200C). The final dilution is dripped on tablets of lactose and sucrose. 200C is seriously “potent” in homeopathy-speak. It’s been noted that in order to obtain even a single molecule of the original fermented duck, a volume of tablets greater that the mass of the entire universe would need to be consumed. Here is a table showing just how dilute it is:
Oscilliocconium: Really, really, really dilute
It is mathematically impossible that there is any of the original fermented goo in the final product. Yet you might not know any of that if you read the packaging.
Back to the survey. When asked, only 1% of respondents knew what Anas barbariae actually is. Most had no idea what the “active ingredient” in the product is supposed to be:
After being told what the 200C potency actually means, positive opinion about homeopathy starts to shrink:
And opinion about the product continues to drop when respondents learn that homeopathy is based on the claim that the more a product is diluted, the stronger the activity is:
When asked again, positive perceptions about oscillococcinum drop overall by 15%, to 35% with 44% now considering it not effective. Positive perceptions go down across all adults and groups:
After hearing what Anas barbarie actually is, perceptions are much less favourable about oscillococcinum:
Opinions were divided on whether or not homeopathic products are properly labelled. 31% agreed it was misleading/deceptive to sell homeopathy next to actual medicine. 26% felt that homeopathy should be sold alongside non-homeopathy:
When asked, a solid majority support the FTC’s recommendation that homeopathy be labelled to point out that there is no scientific evidence these products work:
Finally, when asked how they would feel if they bought a homeopathic remedy for themselves or a child, 40% said “terrible/horrible/upset”, “cheated/deceived”, or “ripped off/scammed”.
What does this survey tell us?
While most consumers trust pharmacies, very few people understand what homeopathy is and the nonsensical belief system it is built upon. Few consumers read and understand product labels well enough to identify which products are homeopathic. These generally positive views carry over to oscillococcinum, at least until people learn what the product is, and how it is made. Once consumers learn about homeopathy and products like oscillococcinum, positive perceptions deteriorate. Perceptions of efficacy and safety decline, and people are less likely to buy homeopathy once they learn what it actually is.
Homeopathy is a good example of the friction between the profession of pharmacy, and the business of pharmacy. Pharmacists are health care professionals, but pharmacies sell lots of nonsense that isn’t evidence based or credible – and the number of these products is growing. But pharmacies want customers, and stores want to satisfy customer demands. There is equally a strong interest by homeopathy manufacturers to get the veneer of credibility (and plausible consumer confusion) by packaging, labelling and marketing these drugs in pharmacies, just as if they are actually medicine. Regrettably, the growing amount of shelf space devoted to dubious products is climbing, pointing to the direction the business of pharmacy is moving, and perhaps unwitting dragging the profession of pharmacy along with it.

Is the Homeopathic Industry “On the Ropes”?
The U.S. homeopathic industry is under growing regulatory and legal pressure.
Scott Gavura on July 2, 2026
Link

It’s been almost twenty years since I first wrote about my concerns with the sale of homeopathy, particularly in in retail pharmacies. Anecdotally, based on what I’ve seen walking pharmacy aisles, it feels more widespread and less niche today. Where few chain pharmacies used to even carry homeopathy, I now see homeopathic products shelved amongst actual medicines. While it seemed to have ignored the issue for decades, the U.S. regulatory backdrop for these products has shifted more in the past several years than in decades previously.The U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s approach has become one that’s worth watching, not only because of the FDA’s outsized influence on medicines regulation worldwide. A recent piece in Skeptical Inquirer prompted me to take stock of where things currently stand with this practice.
A recent piece by Robyn Blumner in Skeptical Inquirer argues that the U.S. homeopathic industry has lost significant ground over the past few years, despite an estimated $6 billion in annual revenue. Blumner, who leads the Center for Inquiry, (and whose organization is separately suing a manufacturer of homeopathy), argues that the industry is “on the ropes”. I hadn’t been tracking the regulatory side of homeopathy closely myself, so it seemed like an appropriate time to get caught up on developments.

The Air Guitar of Alternative Medicine
Samuel Hahnemann invented homeopathy in the early 1800s. While the practice of medicine was then progressing to a scientific model based on objective observations, homeopathy never progressed or evolved: It remains frozen in prescientific thinking. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like may sound familiar: It’s sympathetic magic, a pre-scientific belief.
Homeopathy proponents also believe that water has memory, and the more you dilute a substance, the more powerful its effects. The 30C “potency” is a common dilution used in homeopathy – that’s a dilution of 10-60. If something has been diluted this much, you would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original, pre-diluted material. The explanation for this is that water has a “memory” of the original material. This extreme dilution means that most homeopathic remedies are completely inert, and don’t contain a single molecule of the original reference material. And that original reference material can range from table salt to sunlight to vacuum cleaner dust. There is no product so bizarre that a remedy hasn’t been created from it. The scientific evidence is clear: No homeopathic product has been convincingly demonstrated to provide actual therapeutic effects.
The regulation of homeopathy in the U.S. differs from prescription or over-the-counter drug products. For decades, despite their regulatory status as “drugs” the FDA long allowed many homeopathic products to be sold under a permissive enforcement posture.
That is changing.
Over the past few years, the U.S. approach has shifted from this informal tolerance toward more active enforcement. The FDA’s guidance, Homeopathic Drug Products issued 2022 described how the agency would prioritize regulatory action for these products:
As a result of the Agency’s evaluation of its regulatory framework, including consideration of the information obtained as a result of the public hearing and the recent growth of safety concerns associated with some homeopathic drug products, FDA believes that it is in the best interest of public health to issue a new guidance that applies a risk-based enforcement approach to homeopathic drug products marketed without the required FDA approval, consistent with FDA’s risk-based regulatory approaches generally.
The Final Guidance noted that many marketed homeopathic products no longer meet the agency’s standards and may be treated as “unapproved new drugs”.
In response, the industry sued. The FDA then moved to remove homeopathic injectables and homeopathic eye drops that FDA considered high-risk or not lawfully marketed. I blogged about this back in 2023. The FDA warnings have put pressure on seller platforms like Amazon to remove listings it deems “unapproved new drugs” (like injectable products, or eye drops) or face enforcement action. Skeptical Inquirer notes, in their latest piece:
Under homeopathy’s medical theory, the more dilute a substance, the more potent it becomes. That is absolute nonsense, and no one knows that better than the homeopathy pushers themselves. They would rather spend every dime they have on lobbying and lawsuits than expose their products to the rigors of medical testing.
That is why the homeopathic industry is desperate to change this new regulatory environment. And so, another lawsuit was filed by homeopathic interests. This time, the Alliance for Natural Health (ANH), an advocacy organization for homeopathic medicine, and Meditrend, Inc., a homeopathic drug developer and distributor in Albuquerque, New Mexico, brought suit in a D.C. District Court claiming again that the FDA acted illegally.
Alliance for Natural Health, USA vs. United States is still ongoing, but the initial ruling by a U.S. District Court is promising. In July 2025, Federal District Judge Christopher Cooper dismissed all but one of the plaintiffs’ claims—and expressed little sympathy for the remaining one.
The final claim made by ANH is that the FDA did not have sufficient safety concerns about homeopathic drugs to justify its actions. Judge Cooper responded:
[The FDA] lists several examples to substantiate its safety concerns, including “99 cases of adverse events consistent with belladonna toxicity,” “more than 130 reports of anosmia (loss of sense of smell) associated with the use of Zicam homeopathic intranasal zinc products,” and a worry that consumers may forgo other treatments for homeopathic drugs. (Alliance for Natural Health, USA vs. United States 2025)
The final claim didn’t appear to survive because the judge was sympathetic to it, it survived because it hasn’t been tested yet. Judge Cooper’s citation of the belladonna and Zicam numbers, in the context of explaining why that question needs a full record, is why Blumner argues it “doesn’t look too good” for the industry.
Challenges with Post-Marketing Surveillance
The FDA’s 2022 risk-based guidance framed homeopathic drugs as unapproved new drugs subject to enforcement discretion. But enforcement discretion can only work if a regulatory knows where the risk is. For approved pharmaceuticals, the FDA has several mechanisms to collect data: mandatory adverse event reporting from manufacturers, the FDA Adverse Event Reporting System (FAERS), and periodic safety updates tied to an approved product’s labeling and indication. Homeopathic products, having never gone through that approval process, sit largely outside that scaffolding. There is no manufacturer obligation to report, no ongoing clinical trials or real-world evidence that is generating data, and if a product is diluted appropriately, no reason to think that there is an active ingredient that can cause harm. The overall consequence is that there is no homeopathy-specific postmarketing evidence base comparable to that for approved drugs.
The two examples cited in the ANH litigation illustrate the problem. The 99 reported cases of belladonna toxicity and the more than 130 reports of anosmia linked to Zicam’s homeopathic intranasal zinc products didn’t surface because a functioning surveillance system caught them early. They surfaced because the harms were severe and specific: Permanent loss of smell and infant toxicity. Patients, families and clinicians eventually connected these to a product, despite having no reason to suspect a homeopathic remedy of pharmacological activity in the first place. That’s a structural issue: A product marketed on the premise that it has no active medicinal or drug ingredients is likely among the last things a clinician would investigate when a patient develops an unexplained symptom. Passive reporting systems already capture a small fraction of actual adverse events industry-wide; homeopathic products are likely even more likely to generate reports, because the causal link is harder to imagine before it’s demonstrated.
As recently as 2026, legislators have moved to create protections for the homeopathic industry:
U.S. Senators Mike Lee (R-UT) and Tommy Tuberville (R- AL) today introduced legislation building an FDA framework for homeopathic medicine to protect Americans’ access to natural health solutions. The Homeopathic Drug Product Safety, Quality, and Transparency Act will provide a pathway for homeopathic medicinal products to be lawfully marketed by the Food and Drug Administration without needlessly banning safe products that simply do not fit into the same legal categories as traditional pharmaceuticals.
Skeptical Inquirer describes it as follow:
No surprise that the legislation withdraws the Final Guidance from 2022, saying that it “shall have no force or effect with respect to homeopathic drug products.”
The bill would also bar lawsuits that call out the industry’s deceptive labeling and marketing practices. And it explicitly states that “no premarket approval” may be required before homeopathic drugs are sold to consumers.
A newly established “Homeopathic Drug Product Advisory Committee” charged with providing advice to the Secretary of Health and Human Services would be made up of representatives of the industry—a classic fox guarding the henhouse scenario.
This legislation would give legal cover to a gigantic medical fraud industry that targets sick vulnerable people, including children. Passage would be an unconscionable abandonment of American medical consumers by Congress.
If this Act is successful, it would clearly narrow FDA discretion, creating a bespoke pathway for homeopathic products.
Conclusion
The current state in the U.S. could be said to be one of regulatory action – with pushback. The industry is not “on the ropes” in the sense of imminent collapse, but it undoubtedly is facing a more hostile U.S. regulatory and marketplace environment than it has in years. Higher risk products, like injectables and eye drops may not be as accessible, but I could fine no data confirming or refuting changes in sales. For other products, like OTC products marketed for self-limiting conditions, like colds, I don’t see any signs that substantive changes should be expected, federally, anytime soon.


Good Thinking Society’s successful challenge to NHS homeopathy
Michael Marshall on August 28, 2016
Link

[Editor’s note: For no reason whatsoever other than to share great news, we bring you this contribution from Michael Marshall, project director of the Good Thinking Society and vice president of the Merseyside Skeptics Society.]As regular readers of this blog may know, skeptics here in the UK have been campaigning for some time to end the funding of homeopathic remedies by the National Health Service. This is a campaign that we at the Good Thinking Society – the charity I work for full-time, led by science writer Simon Singh (yes, that Simon Singh) – have been at the forefront of over the last couple of years, and we recently secured a significant victory as NHS Liverpool brought their homeopathy service to a close, as a direct result of the legal challenge we brought in 2014.
While the background to our project was ably and generously described by Harriet Hall here at Science Based Medicine following her appearance at the QED conference last year, it is perhaps worth detailing the progress we’ve made in the last year, and how this success came about. After a series of Freedom of Information requests allowed us to determine where in the country homeopathy is funded by public funds, we were able to monitor for new funding decisions being made – knowing that any decision to spend public funds can be subjected to scrutiny and to legal challenges if not carried out correctly.
Delving into the details
Drawing on the expertise and advice of lawyers Jamie Potter and Salima Budhani at the public law firm Bindmans LLP, we were able to identify the first health body with a potential funding challenge, coincidentally in my hometown of Liverpool. Despite a full review of homeopathy services resulting in the recommendation to cease all funding, and despite there being no public objection on the proposal to end homeopathy funding during the public engagement phase of the consultation, NHS Liverpool clinical care group (CCG) made the inexplicable and (to our minds, at least) indefensible decision to recommission the service and sign a new contract with their homeopathy service provider.
Once the decision to renew funding was made, the clock started on a three-month window in which we could bring a legal challenge, with the help of Bindmans and with the support of the skeptical community who helped us crowdfund some of the legal costs of the campaign (the appeal is still open, as we’ll need funding for the rest of our work on this project!). Fortunately, our challenge was a success: in April 2015 Liverpool CCG decided to revisit their decision, electing to design a new consultation process which began in November 2015.
A rare opportunity firmly seized
The new consultation offered an unprecedented opportunity for skeptical activists and an organisation like ours. Often in situations such as these, the first time skeptics hear of a consultation process is after it is completed – we are rarely considered active stakeholders in the decision-making process, in the same way that homeopathy lobby groups, patients and industry bodies are. This means that while public consultations, in order to be run fairly (and to avoid legal challenges over their validity), often engage with proponents of homeopathy, they don’t necessarily engage people whose view is that homeopathy is not an effective treatment or a cost-effective way to spend limited resources.
Our involvement in the consultation took place in several stages. Firstly, we were able to review the proposed public engagement questionnaire, to help assess whether it was a fair method of gathering a true view of public opinion. This was particularly useful, as it’s often the case with opinion surveys that the manner in which questions are asked heavily influence the answers returned, so we were keen to avoid a survey which solicited nothing but “it worked for me” stories.
Meanwhile, with the date of the consultation in mind, we were able to prompt submissions and evidence reviews from prominent skeptics Edzard Ernst and the Nightingale Collaboration. Knowing it was very likely that professional homeopathy organisations such as the Society of Homeopaths and British Homeopathy Association would be writing to the CCG to offer their views, we were able to pre-empt a lot of their submissions, anticipating their core arguments and the studies they would rely on to ‘prove’ homeopathy works. This helped ensure an accurate reading of the evidence could be made, and that the consultation wouldn’t be side-tracked by red-herring studies.
Once the consultation was actually launched, we worked with the Merseyside Skeptics Society to ensure local skeptics gave their feedback in the consultation. We were confident there would be no shortage of homeopathy supporters offering their views, led by those professional homeopathy organisations, so it was important to us that there were plenty of skeptical voices in the consultation too.
Crucially, of course, this was not a case of a public vote: the outcome of public engagement exercise would be weighed up alongside reviews of the evidence. However, if the public engagement showed overwhelming support for homeopathy, it would have been harder for the health body to end funding than if there was more of a range of views within the public responses.
A marrying of opinions and evidence
One element of the consultation involved a public meeting, which turned out to be one of the most extraordinary experiences I’ve had during my time as a skeptical activist, where an attempt by the CCG to hear and make note of the range of views in the room was wholly hijacked by a homeopathy lobby group and the providers of the homeopathy service under threat. The full story of the afternoon meeting is much too involved and complex to detail here, but for those who are interested we spoke about it at length on my podcast Skeptics with a K. What I will say, however, is that the opportunity to hear from patients of pseudomedical treatments directly is always a valuable one, and one that I urge skeptics to take wherever possible. Being able to really listen, politely and empathetically, to why people are convinced to believe in alternative medicine allows us to be more effective in our activism and campaigning.
In the end, the response from the skeptical community and the wider public was astonishing, with more than 740 responses to the online survey – all of which are available to read in the CCG’s June 2016 agenda. 73% of all respondents called for an end to the homeopathy service, and if we focus on just the 300+ responses from Liverpool residents, 64% of respondents wanted to cease homeopathy funding. This was more than we anticipated, and shows public feeling around homeopathy is pretty clear: it has no role in public-funded healthcare. It is no surprise, then, that NHS Liverpool CCG ended their homeopathy service in June.
The next step!
While this is a useful local victory, its reach is far broader – with only a minority of NHS CCGs around the country still funding homeopathy services, this creates a clear precedent for those CCGs to review and close their service. Next up to review their funding is NHS Wirral CCG, across the River Mersey from Liverpool. Their consultation closed on July 15th, and Good Thinking has been able to take what we’ve learnt from the Liverpool CCG consultation and use it in our participation in the Wirral.
Once again, we’ve promoted the online survey around skeptics and encouraged participation. Once again, we attended a public consultation (highlighting issues that arose at the Liverpool public meeting to ensure a fairer and less hostile atmosphere for all). Once again, we’ve encouraged experts to write in with their appraisal of the evidence and their pre-emptive response to the evidence of the homeopathy bodies.
We are hopeful that NHS Wirral CCG, like their counterparts in Liverpool, are able to take this as an opportunity to make a sensible decision to end support for pseudoscience and free up limited resources for treatments that actually work. If they do, they’ll add their names to an increasing roll-call of health bodies in the UK to finally step away from this long-debunked quackery – leaving only a handful of CCGs left in the Bristol and London regions as the last bastions of NHS homeopathy. They will be the next focus of our attentions, along with our push to have homeopathic remedies blacklisted on the NHS.

   A homeopathy supporter notices our visit with the director of NCCAM
David Gorski
Link
On April 2, Steve Novella, Kimball Atwood, and I visited the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) to meet with its director, Dr. Josephine Briggs. I’m not going to rehash what was said because we agreed that Steve would handle that task, and he did so admirably last week. I agree with Steve that it was encouraging that Dr. Briggs apparently reads this blog and shares many of our concerns about NCCAM, the poor science that it has funded, and its use by promoters of unscientific medicine to promote their quackery. Most heartening of all was that she appeared to recognize how much CAM is infused with anti-vaccine beliefs and, worse, the promotion of these beliefs to the detriment of public health.
Those positive reactions to what was a friendly but frank exchange of views notwithstanding, as we were sitting in a conference room next to Dr. Briggs’ office, I couldn’t help but wonder what the reaction of CAM promoters would be when they found out about this meeting. Now I know. John Weeks over at The Integrator Blog is not happy:
Novella’s posting reads like a Fox News interview: 95% his team’s point, then a brief NCCAM response. That Briggs asked for the meeting likely grew out of an early March conference at Yale at which Novella and she both participated. For this, she deserves the Barack Obama Big Tent award for her proven interest in sitting down with everyone, no matter which party affiliation or belief. (Some have said this was proven in early 2008 when Briggs met with me.) Arguably, Briggs takes her openness to dialogue further than the President. While Obama has kept arms length from leaders who call for the demise of the United States, Briggs has now met with those who have been lobbing bombs at her professional home for years, calling steadily for NCCAM’s destruction.
Because our previous calls for the closing of a relatively small government institute because we view it as a poor use of taxpayer money is just like calling for the downfall of the United States government. Weeks clearly likes ridiculously overblown hyperbole. Interestingly enough, what appeared to upset Mr. Weeks the most was our discussion of homeopathy with Dr. Briggs. As Steve put it:
Dr. Briggs pointed out that it is not the job of the NCCAM to make final pronouncements about any treatment or medical claim. This is fair enough — but depends on context. The NCCAM is responsible for informing the public about so-called CAM modalities, and that should include a fair assessment of the science. If the science says a treatment is worthless, the NCCAM should not be afraid to say so.
Further, the NCCAM does determine what studies the NCCAM funds. The NCCAM accepts applications for research into homeopathy, but have not funded any in several years. What does this mean? Will they consider funding homeopathy research, and if so they are basically saying that they do not close the door on any medical modality, no matter how implausible or damned by negative evidence.
If they will not consider funding homeopathy, then why are they accepting grant applications for homeopathy research? This could be construed as disingenuous — perhaps a way to not fund homeopathy research without having to say they will not fund homeopathy research.
Steve is correct. The NIH can never totally close the door on any line of research. It can, however, set priorities. It could decide that, given the homeopathically diluted prior plausibility of homeopathy based solely on physics, chemistry, and biology, homeopathy is not a priority. It can make sure that only reviewers with the relevant background in basic and clinical science — not “homeopathic” science — make up the study sections that review NCCAM grants. Indeed, I was much heartened to learn from Dr. Briggs that she had already moved peer review of CAM grants out of NCCAM-sponsored study sections and into regular standing NIH study sections run by the Center for Scientific Review, which is where the vast majority of NIH grants are normally reviewed.
As a sort of counterpoint to our message, Mr. Weeks described in the same post a meeting that Dr. Briggs had with an “international homeopathic team.” Besides the amusement I felt at the word choice (is a homeopathic team a team so diluted that there is no one there?), the content itself was at the same time both disturbing and full of hilarious howlers. For instance, this passage concludes the section discussing our visit:
That said, what would have been especially interesting is if Briggs’ scheduler crossed wires and the anti-NCCAM bloggers and homeopathic researchers had showed up for the same meeting time.
I can’t speak for Steve or Kimball, but I assure Mr. Weeks, that I probably would have enjoyed such an encounter thoroughly, although we would have been disappointed that we wouldn’t have been able to have the discussion that we had planned on.
But how did the meeting between Dr. Briggs and the homeopaths go? This is how Mr. Weeks describes it:
Gahles, in a report to the Integrator, assessed that the meeting went “very well.” In her view, a presentation by Chaplin and Roy on chemistry and slides that “showed activity of homeopathic remedies on basophils and IgG” seemed to be particularly compelling to the NCCAM team in suggesting mechanism of action. Gahles underscored that conventional bio-markers seemed to be key in stimulating interest from the NCCAM team.
On the other hand, a presentation on quantum physics and energy medicine seemed to be less useful in making in the case. At one point, an NCCAM team member who said he found the presentation “powerful” asked what the community of top scientists would think. Those in the meeting responded: “We are the leading scientists in the field.”
More like the leading pseudoscientists in the field. The thought of a homeopath claiming to be a leading scientist, particularly when it comes to physics and energy brings to mind Dr. Charlene Werner’s tortured attempt to explain homeopathy through physics or John Benneth’s attempt to explain it as “nanocrystalloids.” Maybe they’re the “leading scientists” of the field of homeopathy. Or perhaps Mr. Weeks means Dana Ullman. Or maybe Jacques Benveniste. In any case, it’s disturbing that an NCCAM team member apparently found the presentation “powerful.” Anyone who finds the clinical research on homeopathy “powerful” does not understand the true tenets of homeopathy and what pseudoscience they are. Such attitudes will tend to stand in the way of attempts to bring more rigorous science to the study of CAM.
Still, Mr. Weeks has done us an unintentional favor — two, actually. First, he has demonstrated clearly that the CAM community wants its pseudoscience, not rigorous science, to guide NCCAM’s research efforts. This has only reinforced my appreciation of Dr. Briggs’ delicate situation. Every move she makes towards bringing rigorous science to the study of CAM is certain to enrage supporters of the purely pseudoscientific CAM modalities such as homeopathy, reiki, and various “energy healing” modalities that are no better than faith healing under different belief systems than Christianity.
Second, Weeks actually points out the heart of the conflict at the heart of NCCAM. Dr. Briggs is clearly trying to move NCCAM in a direction that we at SBM would approve of, namely towards a more drug discovery-oriented approach towards herbal and botanical remedies and various supplements, as well as the study of exercise and various relaxation techniques. After all, these are the most plausible remedies that fall under the general rubric of CAM, and a pharmacognosy approach is the most likely to yield useful information and scientific advances. But that is not what CAM proponents want. Indeed, they resent this approach, as Weeks demonstrates:
One of the perverse pleasures that comes from the disposition of the NIH to hire NCCAM leaders who have no prior experience in alternative or integrative medicine is to think of the culture shock when they move from a zone of relative comfort — drug research on fractions of botanical — into the far reaches such as homeopathic theory and practice. In truth, forms of energetic thinking and practice are infused throughout the “CAM” universe; homeopathy’s dance with Avogadro’s number merely makes it, with distant prayer, the most challenging.
“Challenging” is putting it mildly. But this is the kicker:
It is probably good that Briggs’ extensive and admirable self-education process over the last 2 years preceded this meeting. The culture shock may had this meeting been in her first months.
I rather suspect that Mr. Weeks is correct here, only not in the way he thinks. I’m willing to bet that it was a major culture shock for Dr. Briggs to find out just how much magical thinking, religion, and pseudoscience underlie so much of CAM. What Weeks calls a “comfort zone” is in reality nothing more than staying within what can be studied and demonstrated scientifically, which is what scientists do. If homeopaths could produce anything more than centuries-old magical thinking to support their quackery, if they could produce actual science in the form of physics, chemistry, and biology to support their mystical beliefs in the “memory” of water and that “like cures like,” then their discipline would enter the realm of science, rather than being relegated to the realm of pseudoscience. The problem, of course, is that homeopathy and the “energy healing” modalities are so removed from science that this is about as unlikely to happen as there is likely to be a single molecule of active remedy left in a 30C dilution.
Therein lies the conflict at the heart of NCCAM, and, although I approve of Dr. Briggs’ attempts to increase the scientific rigor of NCCAM and, given that NCCAM isn’t going anywhere, see that as the best path towards trying to make NCCAM a useful center in the NIH, I’m afraid that her actions will only exacerbate the conflict. It’s the institution and the laws that created it that are the problem, and Dr. Briggs won’t be there forever. Her successor might not be as dedicated to science as she is. (In fact, if people like John Weeks get their way, you can count on it.) No matter how much Dr. Briggs may change the culture of NCCAM under her stewardship, all it takes is a new director to change it right back. Directors come and go, but institutions last for generations.

   CAM and the Law Part 4: Regulation of Supplements and Homeopathic Remedies
Brennen McKenzie
Link
Another major set of legal standards that apply to alternative medicine are the laws and regulations that govern the manufacturing and availability of homeopathic and herbal remedies and dietary supplements. Although there is less ambiguity in these standards than in some of the areas I’ve covered previously, there are certainly loopholes aplenty available to avoid the need for any truly scientific standards of evaluating safety and efficacy. This is perhaps the area in which the triumph of politics over science is most vivid.
Regulation of Homeopathic Remedies
The Food and Drug Administration was constituted as the agency responsible for regulating medicines and most foods by the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA) of 1938. The FDCA has been updated and amended in various ways since then, but it is still the primary law governing the regulation of prescription and non-prescription substances used to treat illness. The law identifies substances acceptable for sale as medicines as those listed in its official compendia, the United States Pharmacopeia-National Formulary (USP-NF) and the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS). The HPUS was a list of homeopathic remedies first published by the American Institute of Homeopathy, a professional body for homeopaths, in 1897 and now published and maintained by the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States (HPCUS), an independent organization of homeopathic “experts.” The inclusion of homeopathic remedies as accepted drugs in the original legislation was primarily due to the efforts of Senator Royal Copeland, a physician trained in homeopathy and one of the principle authors of the FDCA.1
Most homeopathic remedies are available as over-the-counter products, though at least theoretically some homeopathic drugs do require a prescription. The distinction between ordinary drugs that can be sold over-the-counter and those available only by prescription is made by the FDA based on the history of use of the particular ingredients, the nature of the complaint for which they are used and, in the case of new OTC drugs, the scientific evidence concerning safety and efficacy. However, with respect to homeopathic products, the distinction seems to depend solely on the intended use of the remedy. If a complaint is expected to be easily recognized by a lay person and self-limiting or not life-threatening, then a homeopathic remedy for such a complaint can be sold without a prescription. However, remedies intended for use in conditions that are serious, not self-limiting, and not easily diagnosed by laypeople require a prescription. 
The HPCUS has promulgated detailed guidelines for approving new homeopathic drugs. According to one review:
The clinical benefits of the new drug must be established in one of the following ways: through clinical verification acceptable to HPCUS, after which there is a period of clinical verification; through published documentation that the substance was in use prior to 1962; through use established by at least two adequately controlled double-blind clinical studies using the drug as the single intervention; or through use established by data gathered from clinical experience encompassing the symptom picture before and after treatment, including subjective and any available objective symptoms.[citation omitted]
The criterion of clinical use prior to 1962 was used to grandfather many drugs during the 1970s and 1980s into acceptance. This criterion is now rarely, if ever, used, and HPCUS is rereviewing [sic] many monographs accepted under this approach. HPCUS reports that the criterion of clinical experience has never been used. Consequently, only the criteria of homeopathic drug “proving” and establishment by two adequate clinical studies are currently in actual use [citation omitted].1
This sounds very impressive and scientific if we ignore the fact that the vast majority of the “drugs” we are talking about are identical and contain nothing but water. It is a testament to the power of cognitive dissonance and faith that a complex set of laws and regulations as well as scores of dedicated professionals in government and the private sector are devoted to regulating the use of over 1200 differently labeled preparations of water. It is also a reminder that scientific facts are not as persuasive in the legal and political arenas as we might hope.
The FDA guidelines for marketing of homeopathic drugs specifies the labeling and manufacturing requirements for homeopathic remedies, but it is most interesting for the inclusion of a definition of Health Fraud:
The deceptive promotion, advertisement, distribution or sale of articles, intended for human or animal use, that are represented as being effective to diagnose, prevent, cure, treat, or mitigate disease (or other conditions), or provide a beneficial effect on health, but which have not been scientifically proven safe and effective for such purposes. Such practices may be deliberate, or done without adequate knowledge or understanding of the article.
The inclusion of this definition without any apparent acknowledgement of its clear application to the practice of homeopathy being regulated by the document is as fine an example of the disconnect between scientific and legal reasoning.
Regulation of Herbal Remedies and Other “Therapeutic” Dietary Supplements
Much has previously been written here at Science-Based Medicine on the subject of the Dietary Supplement and Health Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA) (e.g. 1, 2, 3, 4), and I don’t have a great deal to add. In brief, the supplement industry and sympathetic lawmakers created this law to pretend to regulate herbal remedies and other dietary supplements while effectively stripping the FDA of the ability to control the sale of these products for the prevention or treatment of disease. This was accomplished by classifying all such products as foods and codifying the principle that they must be assumed to be safe unless the government can generate substantial evidence to the contrary. There are some restrictions on the medical claims manufacturers can make on the labels of these remedies, but they are routinely ignored and the resources and will behind enforcement of them are manifestly inadequate.
It is instructive to look at some of the judicial opinions that have been rendered in cases where the FDA did attempt to restrict the use of supplements that had clear potential to be harmful or to challenge unsupported label claims. When the FDA banned the sale of the supplement Ephedra in 2004, for example, due to strong evidence of adverse effects and deaths due to use of the supplement, the company sued and the district court ruled in the manufacturer’s favor. The argument made by the company, and accepted by the district court, was that “by injecting a risk-benefit analysis, the FDA required [the manufacturer] to make a showing of the benefits of its product.” This would be inappropriate because in passing DSHEA “Congress expressly placed the burden of proof on the government to determine whether a dietary supplement” is unsafe.2 
The Tenth Circuit court agreed with the interpretation that the law requires no burden of proof be placed on supplement manufacturers to demonstrate the safety or efficacy of their products. However, it upheld the FDA ban on the basis that because the agency gathered all the data and conducted the analysis at its own expense and without requiring the company to prove any benefit to justify the risks identified, no inappropriate burden was placed on the manufacturer.2 At the risk of injuring myself, I have tried to imagine the public reaction to such a one-sided, industry-friendly regulatory system applied to the pharmaceutical companies, but the image of the resulting rhetorical conflagration is simply too horrible to contemplate.
In another case, a supplement manufacturer was denied permission to market their products with certain health claims on the label, due to a lack of sufficient scientific evidence to support the claims. The company sued the FDA, and the court of appeals found that denying the claims violated the company’s First Amendment commercial speech rights because the alternative of allowing the unproven claims accompanied by a disclaimer was not offered. The court did not challenge, or even address, the quality of the evidence for or against the specific claims. It simply ruled that not allowing them to be made, with appropriate disclaimers indicating the weakness of the evidence or the lack of FDA approval, was unduly restrictive of the company’s speech rights and represented a “simplistic view of human nature or market behavior” that did not give adequate credit to the ability of consumers to judge the merit of such claims for themselves.3
These cases illustrate, yet again, the priorities and concerns of justices and lawmakers with regard to the use of alternative medicine, which are often quite different from those of scientists and healthcare providers.
Where Do We Go From Here?
This series has been a relatively superficial survey of a complex subject, but hopefully I have been able to illustrate a few key issues. First, the scientific facts of claims made about alternative therapies, and the importance of using appropriate and effective epistemological methods to establish those facts, must be the foundation of a rational public policy concerning these therapies. Whether an intervention helps or harms or both is vital to the process of determining how government should approach regulating that intervention. However, the lawmakers and justices who shape public policy towards medicine are seldom themselves experts in scientific methods and the information they generate. To effectively argue the case for science-based medicine, we must understand the way the processes and data of science appear to smart, educated non-scientists, and we must be effective in communicating about science to such people. 
While I don’t want to wade too far into the debates surrounding science communication, I would recommend looking at the work of Michael Nisbet, Randy Olson, and Chris Mooney, all somewhat controversial figures who make a variety of interesting arguments about the most effective ways to communicate about science to the general public. If nothing else, these arguments are good for stimulating a healthy debate about how to promote science and science-based medicine in a culture not as friendly to science as it once was.
In addition to not necessarily understanding the nuances of scientific evidence, policy makers also have other agendas and sometimes have to serve their constituencies even when that means promoting policies based on unscientific or even irrational foundations. There are legitimate philosophical questions about the rights of the individual versus the power of the government, the most effective way to organize and run healthcare delivery systems, and other issues that are not primarily scientific but which influence law and policy concerning science and medicine. In promoting science-based and rational policies, we must take these other issues into account. And the plain political reality remains that if enough people, or people with enough influence, support an idea, it is unlikely to be effectively combated through law and regulation even if it is inherently unscientific and not in the best interest of the public health. Such ideas are better addressed through education and lobbying to alter public opinion rather than through legal or regulatory avenues.
I’ve tried in these posts to provide a rudimentary familiarity with the basics of how the laws that govern medicine in this country relate to the practices of alternative medicine. Hopefully, this will be useful in informing our efforts to advocate for science-based medicine and further marginalize unsafe and ineffective medical approaches.
References
     1.  Borneman JP, Field RI. Regulation of homeopathic drug products. Amerian Journal of Health-System Pharmacy 2006;63:p. 86-91. Return to text.
     2.  Nutraceutical Corporation v Von Eschenbach, Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, 459 F.3d 1033 (2006). Cited in: Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 208-10. Return to text.
     3.  Pearson v. Donna Shalala, Secretary, United States Department of Health and Human Services United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia 164 F.3d 650 (1999). Cited in: Jesson LE, Tovino SA. Complementary and alternative medicine and the law. Durham (NC), USA: Carolina Academic Press, 2010. p. 214-17. Return to text.

   The College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario’s muddled draft policy on “non-allopathic” medicine
David Gorski 
Links
Detroit is my hometown, and three and a half years ago, after nearly twenty years away wandering between residency, graduate school, fellowship, and my first academic job, I found myself back in Detroit minted as surgical faculty at Wayne State University and practicing and doing research at the Barbara Ann Karmanos Cancer Institute. One thing that I had forgotten about while I was away for so many years is just how intimately southeast Michigan interacts with Canada. This closeness is not surprising, given that Detroit and Windsor are separated by only about a half mile of Detroit River. Indeed, a there are a lot of Canadians who cross the border on a daily basis to work in the Detroit area, many of them in the medical center within which my cancer center is located. The reason I point this out is not to wax nostalgic for trips to Windsor or for the occasional trip to Stratford to see plays but to point out that Ontario is right next to us. What happens there is of concern to me because I know quite a few people who live there and because it can on occasion influence what goes on over here on the U.S. side of the border.
I recently learned that the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Ontario (CPSO) has been working on updating its policy on the use of nonconventional medical therapies. The wag in me can’t help but wonder why such a policy would need to say anything other than that, if it isn’t science- and evidence-based, the CPSO doesn’t support using it, but in a less sarcastic moment I realized that such a policy is probably not that bad an idea, as long as it doesn’t legitimize pseudoscience, which is, of course, the biggest pitfall to be avoided when writing such a policy. Not too long ago, the CPSO released its draft policy and has asked for public comments, with the deadline being September 1. I was happy to learn that I had not missed the deadline, because there is much to comment about regarding this policy, but it’s definitely true that time’s short. Unfortunately, I wasn’t so happy when I read the title of the draft policy, namely Non-Allopathic (Non-Conventional) Therapies in Medical Practice, with a subtitle of “Formerly named Complementary Medicine.” The full policy in PDF form can be found at this link.
“Allopathy” versus everything else?
Regular readers of SBM will probably notice one thing right away, even before clicking on either of the links and reading the draft policy. The problem is right there in the title and, in fact, I was floored when I first read the title. My jaw dropped, and dropped hard. Basically, I couldn’t believe that the CPSO had decided to use the term “allopathic” to describe science- and evidence-based medicine. True, that wasn’t the only problem, but it gave me a sinking feeling to see such a term right there in the title. So what’s the problem?
“Allopathic medicine” was a derogatory term originally coined by Samuel Hahnemann, the inventor of homeopathy to contrast homeopathy with the medicine of the time, namely that of 200 years ago. Hahnemann, as you may recall, believed in what he called the Law of Similars, which states that “like cures like,” or, to be more clear, that medicines that cause the same symptoms as a disease should be used to treat the disease. Doing this would stimulate the “vital force” and lead to resolution of the symptoms. Of course, this is nothing more than the principles of sympathetic magic transmuted (if you’ll excuse the term) into a different element, namely that of medicine; there has never been any convincing evidence—or even much in the way of evidence at all—that “like cures like” (or, using the Latin that Hahnemann favored, similia similibus curentur) is a general principle in biology or medicine. According to Hahnemann, “allopathy,” as opposed to homeopathy, is medicine that violated the law of similia similibus curentur and treats disease using remedies whose effects differ from those produced by that disease, the term meaning “other than the disease.” From its very origin, in fact, “allopathy” has been a derogatory term for medicine that is not homeopathy. Indeed, you can even find quotes to that effect documented in—of all places—the Wikipedia entry on allopathy. For instance, James Whorton points out in his book Nature Cures: The History of Alternative Medicine in America:
One form of verbal warfare used in retaliation by irregulars was the word “allopathy.” Coined two hundred years ago by Samuel Hahnemann, founder of homeopathy, it was taken from Greek roots meaning “other than the disease” and was intended, among other things, to indicate that regular doctors used methods that were unrelated to the disharmony produced by disease and thus were harmful to their patients. “Allopathy” and “allopathic” were liberally employed as pejoratives by all irregular physicians of the nineteenth century, and the terms were considered highly offensive by those at whom they were directed. The generally uncomplaining acceptance of [the term] “allopathic medicine” by today’s physicians is an indication of both a lack of awareness of the term’s historical use and the recent thawing of relations between irregulars and allopaths.
The other aspect of the term “allopathy” is that it was consciously used by practitioners of “unconventional” medicine to relegate “conventional” medicine to nothing more than another “competing” school of medicine. The term thus serves the simultaneous purpose of bringing “allopathic medicine” down to homeopathy’s level and elevating homeopathy to the level of conventional medicine. Far better, albeit still imperfect, characterizations could be:
    • Science-based medicine versus nonscientific medicine
    • Conventional medicine versus unconventional medicine
    • Medicine versus unproven medicine
Other possibilities come to mind. Of course, my preferred one (reality-based medicine versus magic) is probably a bit too stark. Be that as it may, I would contend that accepting the language of practitioners of unscientific medicine and using it in an official policy statement is not a good idea. Language has power and meaning. No one knows that better than promoters of “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM) or “integrative medicine” (IM) or whatever it is that quacks decide to call it next. While the use of language in the CPSO draft is disturbing enough in and of itself, there are more substantive problems with the draft that need to be discussed.
Beyond “allopathic medicine”
The opening of the CPSO statement does not begin any more auspiciously than the title, after which the statement quickly devolves into meaningless platitudes that accept many of the false equivalencies promoted by CAM practitioners when arguing for pseudoscience. For example, check out how the draft opens:
In increasing numbers, patients are looking beyond allopathic medicine to nonallopathic therapies for answers to complex medical problems, strategies for improved wellness, or relief from acute medical symptoms. Patients may seek advice or treatment from a range of health care providers, including Ontario physicians.
The College supports patient choice in setting treatment goals and in making health care decisions, and has no intention or interest in depriving patients of non-allopathic therapies that are safe and effective. As a medical regulator, the College does, however, have a duty to protect the public from harm. Thus, the object of this policy is to prevent unsafe or ineffective non-allopathic therapies from being provided by physicians, and to prohibit unprofessional or unethical physician conduct in relation to these therapies.
Right from the beginning, all the buzzwords and false equivalencies are right there. There’s the appeal to popularity in the form of the unreferenced, unsupported statement that more patients are embracing non-science-based medicine. That’s rapidly followed by the platitude assuring us that the CPSO supports patient “choice,” which implies by contrast that those who might not be as open to “non-allopathic” medicine are somehow against “patient choice.” particularly given the line of how the CPSO has “no intention or interest” in “depriving” (note the word choice) of their woo. Of course, one wonders what these “non-allopathic” treatments are that are both safe and effective might be. After all, if they were both safe and effective they wouldn’t be “alternative.” I’m tempted to repeat that old trope that alternative medicine that is proven to be safe and effective ceases to be “alternative” and becomes simply “medicine.” Never mind. I just did. So did the CPSO:
The categorization of specific therapies as non-allopathic is fluid: as clinical evidence regarding efficacy is accumulated, certain non-allopathic therapies may gain broad acceptance and thus be accepted in allopathic medicine.
I’ve tried to think of an example of any such therapies that have made the leap from “non-allopathic” to “allopathic” medicine and am hard-pressed to do so. Be that as it may, just because this is an old trope doesn’t mean it isn’t true. Substituting the term “non-allopathic” medicine for term “alternative” medicine or CAM in this draft statement not-so-subtly equates what was once called CAM or “alternative medicine” with “allopathic medicine.” Again, language matters, and the CPSO knows it. Its choice of the the term “non-allopathic” was deliberate:
Different operative terms have been adopted that were deemed to be value-neutral: ‘Allopathic medicine’ refers to traditional or conventional medicine (as taught in medical schools) and ‘non-allopathic therapies’ refer to complementary or alternative medicine.
Notice also how the CPSO chooses to characterize patients looking for CAM as “looking beyond” allopathic medicine, which implies that CAM modalities are somehow ahead of or superior to “allopathy.” A more appropriate way to phrase this concept would be to say that patients are looking “outside of” science-based medicine or “elsewhere than” science-based medicine. But, no. Patients are “looking beyond” that tired, old, hidebound scientific medicine.
Imagine my relief that the College is committed to preventing unsafe or ineffective “non-allopathic” therapies from being provided by physicians. You know, ineffective like homeopathy.
Platitudes mixed with disturbing statements
If there’s one thing about this draft that impresses me about the CPSO draft policy is the sheer number of meaningless platitudes the CPSO packed into it. Mixed in with these platitudes are statements that range from disturbing to just plain puzzling. For instance, one puzzling aspect of the draft occurs where the CPSO points out that physicians should “refrain from exploitation” and abusing his power over patients and avoid conflicts of interest. No one, least of all I, would argue that physicians should exploit their patients or engage in activities that represent a blatant conflict of interest, but nowhere in the draft is this principle related to the use of “non-allopathic” medicine by patients or physicians. At least for the other principles the draft at least takes a stab at trying to relate them to patient autonomy, which, of course, the CPSO supports. The CPSO also expects physicians to:
     1.  Act in patients’ best interests, in accordance with fiduciary duties;
     2.  Respect patient autonomy with respect to health care goals, and treatment decisions;
     3.  Communicate effectively and openly with patients and others involved in the provision of health care;
     4.  Maintain patient trust through a commitment to altruism, compassion and service.
As opposed to, I suppose, advocating not acting in patients’ best interests, not respecting patient autonomy, not communicating effectively and openly, and not being committed to altruism, compassion, and service. I know, I know, I’m being a bit curmudgeonly, and I realize that these sorts of principles have to be repeated and emphasized, but it’s about the specifics of how physicians will adhere to such principles “where the rubber hits the road,” so to speak that such a policy should provide guidance. I would argue that it is a physician’s responsibility always to be honest with his patients and to pull no punches when it comes to giving his professional opinion. That is the very essence of acting in the patient’s best interest and communicating effectively and openly. What, then, am I to make of some of the statements in this draft that sound suspiciously like advocating pulling punches? For instance:
The College expects physicians to respect patients’ treatment goals and decisions, even those which physicians deem to be unfounded or unwise. In doing so, physicians should state their best professional opinion about the goal or decision, but must refrain from expressing non-clinical judgements.
I can’t help but wonder whether calling, for example, homeopathy “quackery” would be viewed as a “non-clinical” judgment by the CPSO. The language used smacks of the CAM-enabling sort of language that demands that we physicians above all remain “nonjudgmental.” Personally, I would counter that it is our professional responsibility to be judgmental when it comes to evaluating the evidence for a treatment. It is our duty to judge what treatments are safe and effective and which are not; that’s what our patients come to us for.
Here’s another problematic passage:
When providing non-allopathic therapies, physicians are expected to demonstrate the same commitment to clinical excellence and ethical practice, as they would when providing allopathic care.
The problem here is that providing “non-allopathic” care that is not evidence- and science-based (in other words, virtually all of it) is inherently unethical and represents anything but “clinical excellence.” This is a rather amusing conundrum to me. Consider this example. If a physician (and, make no mistake, there are a fair number of physicians who do this) offers homeopathy, which is nothing more than magical water supposedly imbued with mystical healing caused by the “memory of water” remembering whatever remedy that was in it before and forgetting, as Tim Minchin puts it, all the poo that’s been in it. How can any physician ethically offer homeopathy, for example, to a patient? Similar arguments construct themselves for other “non-allopathic” therapies, such as reiki (which is faith healing that substitutes Eastern mysticism for Christianity as its basis) or acupuncture, which postulates that sticking needles into “meridians” that have no detectable anatomic counterpart somehow “unblocks” the flow of vitalistic mystical life energy to healing effect. Yet, the CPSO goes on to state:
Physicians must always act within the limits of their knowledge, skill and judgement9 and never provide care that is beyond the scope of their clinical competence.
This expectation applies equally to treatments or therapies that the physician proposes and those that may be requested directly by patients. Where patients seek care that is beyond the physician’s clinical competence, physicians must clearly indicate that they are unable to provide the care. Physicians should consider whether a referral can be made to another physician or health care provider for care the physician is unable to provide directly.
While this is simply a restating of basic physician ethics when it comes to science-based medicine, I can’t help but wonder: Does this policy in the context of emphasizing patient autonomy and choice somehow obligate or imply an obligation for an Ontario physician to refer to a “non-allopathic” practitioner if that is what the patient wants? Shouldn’t there be a clear statement that a physician is not obligated to support the use of “non-allopathic” medicine if he believes it—and correctly so—to be quackery? The whole thing is a muddle, particularly given the statements elsewhere in the policy about how diagnosis and treatment should be based on the principles of “allopathic” medicine?
A brief policy statement
It’s obvious from the wishy-washy approach to the scientific basis of medicine, the waffle words when it comes to whether an “allopathic” physician should support “non-allopathic” therapies, and the apparently inadvertent use of language favored by quacks that there were far too many “alternative” practitioners involved in drafting this policy. Similarly, the comments are dominated by believers, although I must admit that one of them does point out the conflict inherent in this policy, as the CPSO tries to have it both ways:
“To act in accordance with the standards of allopathic medicine, physicians providing non-allopathic care must reach an allopathic diagnosis”
This doesn’t make sense! If I want non-allopathic care, then that includes a non-allopathic diagnosis. Allopathic labelling is only useful for determining which prescription to write and has no business in non-allopathic medicine!
This would be a bit of a problem in traditional Chinese medicine, where the diagnoses are based on “imbalances” in heat, moisture, etc., and some diagnoses come about by mapping organs to locations on the tongue. Similarly, in homeopathy, diagnoses are not necessarily based on physiology and treatments are based on homeopathic “provings.” Yes, this believer nailed the conundrum that the CPSO is trying to dance around.
To that end, let me propose a much briefer policy statement for the CPSO to consider in a few bullet points:
    • Medicine should be science- and evidence-based. “Alternative” and “evidence-based,” “allopathic” and “non-allopathic,” “conventional” and “unconventional” are all false dichotomies. If a treatment is not evidence- and science-based, it is not medicine. Such a treatment becomes “medicine” only when it is demonstrated to work by science.
    • Competent adults have every right to seek out non-science-based medicine if that is what they desire. However, informed consent mandates that physicians who encounter such patients provide an honest professional assessment of such treatments based on science.
    • Physicians should always inquire about the use of non-science-based medicine when evaluating their patients, so that they can take into account possible interactions with medical treatments.
    • Physicians are in no way obligated to refer patients to “alternative medical” practitioners. For many forms of “alternative medicine” doing so is unethical because such modalities are not science- or evidence-based.
I’m sure readers can come up with their own versions or suggest modifications and/or additions to the bullet points above.
In the meantime, there is still more than a week left before the September 1 deadline for supporters of science-based medicine to let the CPSO know the problems in its draft policy by e-mailing ComplementaryMedicine@cpso.on.ca or filling out CPSO’s online survey. It’s clear from the comments that are there now that more input from supporters of science-based medicine is needed.

The CAM Docket: Boiron I
Jann Bellamy on March 22, 2012
Link
Author’s note: This will inaugurate a series of occasional posts observing the wheels of justice grind slowly over “CAM.”
In a previous post, I posited that CAM practitioners might well subject themselves to liability for the tort of fraudulent misrepresentation. This misrepresentation could be based on both the lack of scientific evidence of effectiveness and the lack of scientific plausibility for their treatments. One example was homeopathy, which, as Dr. Steven Novella aptly stated,
we can summarize . . . by saying it has extreme implausibility and the clinical evidence shows lack of efficacy. It should not work, and it does not work. There is no legitimate controversy about this.
In the last couple of years five lawsuits have been filed against Boiron, a somewhat prickly company based in France and the world’s largest manufacturer of homeopathic products. In 2011, Boiron had $520,000,000 in sales, although some of this revenue comes from its other products, such as dietary supplements. The plaintiffs are consumers who purchased Boiron’s homeopathic “remedies” and who now allege that they were deceived by Boiron’s false and misleading representations, allegations Boiron denies. Four of the lawsuits are pending in California and one in Illinois.
All of the suits are filed as putative class actions, which generally proceed like this: a plaintiff claims she was injured in a certain manner by the defendant’s conduct and that there are numerous others who were injured in the same, or a similar, way. She asks the court to allow her to proceed with a class action in which she will represent all those other people. In essence, the class members become plaintiffs themselves and are bound by the results of the case. (They can’t, for example, bring their own individual lawsuits.) If the plaintiff is successful, all class members are entitled to relief, including monetary damages.
Delarosa v. Boiron class action
The first suit filed was Gina Delarosa v. Boiron, in 2010. Ms. Delarosa alleged that she purchased Boiron’s Children’s Coldcalm, relying on Boiron’s representations that it was effective in relieving sneezing, runny note, congestion, and other cold symptoms, but that it didn’t work for her family. Her claims are for fraudulent misrepresentation and violation of California consumer protection laws. She sought to represent a class of other California purchasers of Children’s Coldcalm.
In the Complaint, Delarosa first hits hard on homeopathy itself, alleging that:
A Swiss government study conducted 110 placebo-controlled trials and found that homeopathy is no more effective than placebo.
The American Medical Association and Great Britain’s National Health Service stated that there is no scientific evidence to support the use of homeopathic treatments.
“Even homeopathy’s own supporters, such as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, admit that ‘[t]here is [] no condition for which homeopathy has been proven to be an effective treatment.’” [Empahsis added.]
(And here I’ve been thinking all this time that only hard-core SBM types and their fellow travelers noticed NCCAM’s pro-CAM stance.)
Ms. Delarosa then hones in on Coldcalm itself, alleging:
The homeopathic ingredients in Children’s Coldcam range from various flowers, vegetables, insects, metals, and poison. In order not to poison a user, the dilutions . . . are claimed to be up to 3C and 6C.
. . . a 6C dilution gives one part ingredient to 1 trillion parts of the solution. Dilutions to this extent leave the solution with no trace of the original ingredient.
. . . The idea that a substance could be completely physically lacking and still be effective violates fundamental principles of science. . . . and runs contrary to dose-response relationship established by pharmacology.”
Thus, Ms. Delarosa alleges Boiron’s representations, made on both the package and in other advertising, that Children’s Coldcalm relieves numerous cold symptoms are false, misleading, contrary to established medical authority, and constitute unfair and deceptive business practices. She seeks actual, punitive and other damages, as well as an injunction preventing Boiron from engaging in these deceptive practices.
As might be expected, Boiron opposed the lawsuit’s proceeding as a class action. It also argued, again as might be expected, that the suit was preempted by federal law. Boiron lost on both of these issues, which was a significant victory for Ms. Delarosa and the class of other consumers she now represents. Delarosa v. Boiron, Inc., 2011 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 80562 (C.D. Cal. 2011); 275 F.R.D. 582, 2011 LEXIS 106248 (C.D. Cal. 2011).
Especially interesting was the Court’s ruling on Boiron’s preemption claim. Briefly, under the U.S. Constitution, federal law is the “supreme Law of the Land.” Thus any state law that conflicts with federal law has no effect, and the federal law “preempts” state law on the subject. Very broadly, and without getting into the complexities of the law on preemption, Boiron argued that federal law gave the FDA the exclusive right to regulate homeopathic products and that this preempted the Plaintiff’s state consumer protection law and fraud claims. Had Boiron been effective in its argument the Court would have dismissed the Complaint.
In ruling against Boiron on the preemption issue, the Court was required, for procedural reasons, to accept as true the allegations of the Plaintiff’s complaint. This means that the facts on which the Court relied in making its decision are not findings of fact in the sense a jury would make after hearing the evidence – they are simply what the Plaintiff alleges to be true. On the other hand, it is exclusively up to the courts to determine what the law is, and this Court’s interpretation of federal law regarding homeopathic products highlights their almost complete lack of regulation.
First, by way of background, the Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act [FDCA], enacted by Congress in 1938, defines “drug” to include both prescription and over-the-counter [OTC] homeopathic products recognized in the “Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia of the United States” [HPUS]. According to the FDA, the HPUS is a “compilation of standards for source, composition, and preparation of homeopathic drugs. The HPUS contains monographs of drug ingredients used in homeopathic treatment.” As the Court noted, this means that “the FDA allows a private organization to designate which homeopathic drugs meet certain (and unknown) standards” and are thus eligible for inclusion in the HPUS. [Emphasis added.]
In addition, the Court concluded:
Unlike non-homeopathic OTC drugs, homeopathic OTC drugs, including the Coldcalm product at issue here, are not evaluated by the FDA at all. . . . Although the HPUS describes how these ingredients [in homeopathic products] are prepared for homeopathic use, it does not list the drugs as fit to treat specific symptoms, ailments, or conditions. Instead, the HPUS allows the practitioner or manufacturer to set forth the substance’s indications for use.”
[Citations omitted, emphasis added.]
And:
The Court is unaware of what standards, if any, exists to ensure that homeopathic OTC drugs are safe and effective. The FDA does not impose additional standards for strength, purity, quality, safety, or efficacy on homeopathic OTC remedies, Indeed, the FDA has advised that unless a homeopathic remedy is ‘being offered for use (or promoted) significantly beyond recognized or customary practice,’ federal policies on health fraud do not apply. And perhaps most significant, ‘[a] product’s compliance with requirements of the HPUS . . . does not establish that it has been shown by appropriate means to be safe, effective, and not misbranded for its intended use.”
[Citations omitted, emphasis added.]
Finally:
As evidenced by the FDA guidance documents . . . the Court concludes that the FDA has largely abdicated any role it might have had in creating standards for homeopathic OTC drugs, and has instead attempted to delegate this authority to the non-governmental organization that determines whether homeopathic substances should be included in the HPUS. In addition, the FDA explicitly states that it makes no guarantee about the safety or efficacy of homeopathic OTC drugs even if they meet the unknown standards for inclusion in the HPUS.”
[Empahsis added.]
The Court also remarked that it could find “no record of any [FDA] investigation of homeopathic remedies due to a reported lack of efficacy.”
To recap, the FDA, the federal agency charged with regulating the safety and efficacy of drugs, has abandoned its authority to do so in the case of homeopathic drugs. Instead, it allows a private organization, employing unknown standards, to decide what homeopathic substances can be used. These substances include insects and poisons. Whatever these standards are, according to the FDA, they do not mean that homeopathic products are safe, effective or not misbranded.
The other lawsuits
In addition to fraud and state consumer protection law claims, other suits against Boiron add federal law breach of warranty claims arising out of purchases of various other Boiron products in addition to Coldcalm. All cases seek to proceed as class actions, although there has been no ruling on this issue yet.
According to the Complaint in Fernandez v. Boiron, products purchased by the Plaintiffs include:
Arnicare Arthritis, which purports to treat “trauma and muscle soreness” and various types of pain, including “joint pain worsened by heat and slow motion.” Among the ingredients in Arnicare Athritis are “a class B noxious weed, alpine rose, and poison ivy.”
Chestal, which “loosens thick mucus” and claims to relieve many types of cough, including “barking cough worse at night” and “wet cough associated with the day becoming dry at night.” Active ingredients include “a parasitic insect, wind flower, lung moss, and sea sponge that has been roasted.”
Quietude, a remedy for, among other things, “restless sleep associated with nervousness” and “sleeplessness associated with worries and exhaustion.” Ingredients of Quietude include “stinking nightshade, nutmeg, purple passionflower, and seeds of the jimson weed.”
As the Complaint points out, none of the ingredients are listed by their common names, but rather by “their more exotic sounding Latin names.”
In Gonzales v. Boiron, Plaintiff is suing over claims made for Oscillo which, according to the Complaint, Boiron advertises as “medicine for headache, body ache, chills & fever,” that will “slow down the spread of germs,” has “a long history of efficacy and safety” and “is the first flu medicine recommended by pharmacists.” Oscillo is advertised as “tak[ing] care of the flu within 48 hours.” But, as the Complaint alleges, the listed active ingredient in Oscillo is Anas Barbariae Hepatis et Cordis Extractum, “a fancy way to hide the truth from the general public, which that this ingredient is actually Muscocy duck liver and heart.”
According to the Complaint, the duck liver and heart “is diluted to 200CK,” which means that for every part of the purportedly active ingredient, “there is 1^399 parts of the inactive ingredient, sugar.” Cleverly, the Complaint spells out this dilution, which results in a ratio of 1:1 with 166 zeros after it. (Assuming I counted all those zeros correctly.) As the Plaintiff points out, the probability of getting one molecule of the active ingredient in a regular dose is “approximately equal to winning the Powerball every week for nearly an entire year.”
Settlement?
An interesting development, in the form of a proposed settlement, occurred last month in one of the lawsuits, Gallucci v. Boiron.
The Plaintiffs in this case seek to represent a nationwide class of all persons who purchased a number of different Boiron products since January 1, 2000. They allege that the active ingredients in these products, even if effective, are so greatly diluted as to be non-existent. Thus, Boiron’s claims regarding the products’ benefits are false and misleading.
The Plaintiffs and Boiron have proposed a settlement of the lawsuit, now pending before the Court for preliminary approval. The settlement would require Boiron to put up $5,000,000 to pay damages, an incentive award to the named Plaintiffs, attorneys fees and costs, plus expenses of administering the settlement. Payouts to claimants are reduced pro rata if $5 million doesn’t cover everything. It would also require Boiron to make changes to its labeling and advertising.
(If Boiron needs any help coughing up the $5 million, although I doubt it does, I suggest it try to claim the $1 million prize offered by the James Randi Educational Foundation to any homeopathic remedy manufacturer who can prove, via valid scientific testing, that its products work.)
Consumers who can produce proof of purchase will get a full refund with a limit of $100 per household. Consumers without proof of purchase will get $10 per product, up to $50 per household.
Because the Court in the Delarosa case has already approved a class of purchasers of Coldcalm in California, the settlement would exclude those persons, but would include all other purchasers of Boiron products in the U.S. as well as California purchases of products other than Coldcalm. This would, in the estimation of the Plaintiffs, include tens of thousands of claimants.
According to the Plaintiffs, between January 2007 and September 2011 (less than 4 of the 11-plus years covered by the settlement), 12 million units of Boiron products were purchased in mass retail stores (which doesn’t include sales in specialty natural food stores or to homeopaths), approximately $13 million in sales per year. It is not clear whether the Plaintiffs are speaking exclusively of the 800 homeopathic products Boiron sells, or are including non-homeopathic products in these numbers. However, because the Plaintiffs themselves included this information in support of their argument that the potential class of purchasers would be very large, it is reasonable to assume they are referring to homeopathic products.
So let’s do the math: If sales are $13 million per year, and the period covered is over 11 years, how can $5 million possibly be adequate to pay out all claims plus attorneys fees, costs and other expenses? Based on unit sales figures included in the proposed settlement (for mass retail sales only), over the 136 months covered by the settlement, 36,040,000 units were sold. If only 10% of these purchases resulted in a claim of $10 each, that would equal $36,040,000 alone. Plaintiffs have already estimated that notice of the proposed settlement to class members will cost almost $160,000. And documents filed in support of the proposed settlement reveal that one of Plaintiff’s attorneys was awarded $595 per hour for his work in another settled class action lawsuit. To me, this just doesn’t add up.
Even if the Plaintiffs were using total sales figures, including non-homeopathic products, let’s assume only one-half of the sales cited by the Plaintiffs are for Boiron’s homeopathic products, and stick with our assumption that only 10% of purchasers make a claim of $10 each. That still results in claims of over $18,000,000.
One task in any class action settlement is figuring out the best way to notify the class members of the proposed settlement so they can make a claim. In this case, something called the “Simmons National Consumer Survey Data” was used to determine how to reach a target audience of class members, described as “U.S. Adults who Trust Homeopathic Remedies (approx. 45 million U.S. adults).” (Sigh.) This led to the conclusion that one appropriate vehicle for notice is an ad in Natural Health Magazine. Well, they got that right. Sample advice on restless leg syndrome from the magazine’s website:
A naturopath says: Homeopathic medicine can ease specific symptoms with diluted doses of plant- and mineral-based remedies.
The treatment: Take Zincum metallicum first because it helps relieve RLS sufferers’ most common complaint—the inability to control their leg and, sometimes, arm movements. If your jerky limbs wake you up at night, try to tame them with Causticum. Use Arsenicum album to ease the creepy-crawly sensations, especially if you also feel restless or cold. But if you’re itchy and hot, try sulphur. Rhus toxicodendron and Kali carbonicum may help, too. With all remedies, start with a 6C potency and take three pellets before bed. You can also buy combination formulas that will treat numerous symptoms.”
6C “potency”? That means the original material is diluted to one part in one trillion. But I digress.
In addition, according to the proposed settlement, Boiron would change its packaging and advertising in two ways. First, “Indications of Use,” which describes the treatment and relief of symptoms or ailments, will bear this “FDA Disclaimer language:”
These ‘Uses’ have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration.”
Sound familiar? It should. This is the infamous Quack Miranda Warning modified for homeopathic products. And, as we know, it has been remarkably effective in encouraging folks to do their own safety and efficacy research when purchasing dietary supplements, a $28 billion dollar a year industry in the U.S. alone. We all know plenty of people who’ve run their own randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind studies before buying dietary supplements, right?
Second, Boiron will have to include a “Dilution Disclaimer” on packaging stating “C,K,CK and X are homepathic dilutions” and direct the consumer to further information on Boirin’s website. Yet, it appears from this link that this information is already available on the company’s website, although difficult to find. In any event, the proposed information fails to tell the reader the significance of homeopathic dilutions. Thus, under “What does ‘200CK’ mean?” we find:
200CK means that the substance has been homeopathically diluted 200 times at the rate of 1 to 100. Therefore, the original substance has been diluted to 10-200.”
This doesn’t give the reader the valuable information that such a thing is impossible. In fact, that would be a far greater dilution than one molecule in the entire observable universe. One has to assume the consumer would find this helpful in deciding whether to make a purchase.
Boiron will not be required to amend misleading information like this from its website:
Q: Is there any scientific research on homeopathic medicines?
A: An increasing number of scientific studies on homeopathy are being conducted and, in recent years, more than 150 of these studies have been published in medical journals. Clinical research is providing evidence of the efficacy of homeopathic medicines, and basic laboratory research is confirming the biological activity of highly diluted substances and helping the scientific community better understand their mechanism of action.
Noted “CAM” researcher Dr. Edzard Ernst (both here and here, among other places) and world-famous author and scientist, Dr. Richard Dawkins, among many others, beg to differ.
Conclusionem
In sum, if the settlement is approved by the court, Boiron will be required to pay out less than $5,000,000 total to settle claims of everyone in the U.S. (except for some Coldcalm purchasers in California) who, in a period of over a decade, purchased its products. It will also have to add the Quack Miranda Warning to labeling and advertising. Finally, it must give consumers information that doesn’t fully inform them what the homeopathic dilution process really means.
Nor will Boiron have to stop listing ingredients in Latin. So I’ll end with this advice to potential customers of homeopathic products, because, after all, most consumers know Latin, right? And, of course, quidquid Latine dictum sit altum videtur. It is important to remember that cuiusvis hominis est errare, nullius nisi insipientis in errore perseverare. When considering your purchase, de omnibus dubitandum. Just because the package promises a remedy for your ills, et suppositio nil ponit in esse. As to the law of similars and other homeopathic nonsense, quod gratis asseritur, gratis negatur, et hoc genus omne.
Fiat iustitia.
Coming soon: “The CAM Docket: Boiron II” and “The CAM Docket: Bach Flower Remedies.”

The CAM Docket: Boiron II
Jann Bellamy on April 19, 2012
Link
Five consumer lawsuits are pending in the U.S. against Boiron, the world’s largest manufacturer of homeopathic products. One lawsuit is also pending in Canada. As reported in a previous post, the U.S. plaintiffs claim they purchased homeopathic products, such as Coldcalm, Oscillo, Arnicare and Chestal Cough Syrup, based on Boiron’s misleading and false statements that they are effective for various ailments. Therefore, these plaintiffs allege, Boiron has defrauded consumers, as well as violated various consumer protection laws. Boiron denies these claims.
The plaintiffs’ allegations in each of the five U.S. lawsuits are based in part on the same fallacies underlying homeopathy discussed many times before here at SBM:
we can summarize . . . by saying it has extreme implausibility and the clinical evidence shows lack of efficacy. It should not work, and it does not work. There is no legitimate controversy about this.
Which raises an interesting question: how does one defend a product that appears to be indefensible? Let’s take a look.
Delarosa v. Boiron
In Delarosa v. Boiron, Inc., the first lawsuit filed and now certified as a class action by the court, there are cross-motions for summary judgment pending. I won’t make you suffer through an explanation of Rule 56 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, which governs summary judgment motions. Suffice it to say that at this point each side apparently feels it has enough uncontroverted evidence to win, at least on some of the issues, without having to go to trial and is asking the judge to rule accordingly.
The plaintiff in Delarosa has the burden of proving Coldcalm does not work as advertised and that Boiron knew or should have known this. Conversely, Boiron, as the defendant, does not have to prove that Coldcalm does work as advertised or that it was unaware that Coldcalm does not work. However, in order to refute the plaintiff’s claims, Boiron has, as one would expect, offered its own evidence that Coldcalm is effective to relieve cold symptoms and that it believes in those claims. And although Boiron argues that the plaintiff cannot prevail simply by attacking homeopathy in general, the plaintiff has submitted evidence that homeopathy does not, and cannot, work. Thus, Boiron has, again as might be expected, submitted evidence on that issue.
Boiron has not yet filed a response to the plaintiff’s summary judgment motion, apparently because of a dispute over information it requested from the plaintiff in discovery. For this and other reasons, we cannot conclude that the evidence presented to this point by Boiron is all that Boiron may possess in support of homeopathy in general and Coldcalm in particular. But we do know that, in filing its own motion for summary judgment, it argues that the evidence is sufficient for the court to decide in its favor. Specifically, Boiron argues that the plaintiff cannot meet her burden of proof in showing Boiron believed its statements were false. “To the contrary,” Boiron argues, it “can provide extensive support regarding the efficacy of both homeopathic drugs generally and Children’s Coldcalm specifically.”
Plaintiff’s expert witness
One of the plaintiff’s experts, Lynn R. Willis, Ph.D, currently holds the position of Professor Emeritus at the Department of Pharmacology and Toxicology at the Indiana University School of Medicine, where he was the director of the medical pharmacology course for 23 years. [Another expert witness for the plaintiff is SBM’s own Harriet Hall, M.D.]
Dr. Willis’s sworn statement in support of the plaintiff’s motion offers this devastating, and unsurprising, analysis of homeopathy in general and Coldcalm in particular:
27. Homeopathy is based upon the ‘Law of Similars.’ Homeopaths assert that ‘like cures like’ or more precisely that one substance that causes symptoms when it is given in large doses will cure illnesses that have the same symptoms if that substance is given in an extremely small dose. There is no credible scientific evidence to support the Law of Similars. In fact, scientific evidence is contrary to the Law of Similars.
28. The dosages of homeopathic drugs are prepared through serial dilution. Serial dilution is done by taking the homeopathic drug and mixing it with water or alcohol at a specific ratio of 1:10 (X) or 1:100 (C). At each dilution the homeopathic drug is shaken in a process called succussion (also referred to as “potentizing”). Succussion is believed to activate the “vital energy” of the diluted substance. No evidence of this “vital energy” has ever been detected by modern science; nor can it be. The serial dilutions are repeated until the desired dilution is reached.
29. The ingredients in Coldcalm, the product at issue in this action, are diluted either to 3C (1:1,000,000) or 6C (1:1,000,000,000,000). There is no scientific evidence that homeopathic drugs, such as the ones found in Coldcalm, have any biological effect on the human body at such extreme dilutions. The dose-response relationship established and proven by modern medicine is contrary to the idea that such extreme dilutions of a medicinal agent can have biological effects on the human body.
30. There is no credible scientific evidence that homeopathy results in anything more than a placebo effect. Indeed, homeopathy theory and practice are contrary to modern scientific research.
. . .
44.The notion that the extreme dilutions found in Cold Calm and other homeopathic remedies should be associated with observable biologic effects and actions is wholly contrary to the proven dose-response relationships of modern pharmacology and medicine in which the intensity of drug action is directly proportional, not inversely proportional, to dose.
45. As outlined in paragraphs 33 through 41, the concentrations of the ingredients in ColdCalm have no detectable effects on the human body; however, as mentioned above, where there is no likelihood of a medicinal agent producing a tangible health benefit to a patient, any risk at all is unacceptable.
Dr. Willis goes through each ingredient in Coldcalm, which includes honeybees, poisonous plants and potassium dichromate (“a powerful oxidizing agent”), finding that, although some are dangerous (even deadly) to humans, at the dilutions stated on the label, none could possibly have any discernible effect on the human body. Dr. Willis opines not only that Coldcalm does not, and could not, have any effect on the common cold, the product itself violates homeopathy’s own precept that each treatment must be individualized, making “one size fits all” remedies inappropriate.
Boiron’s expert
To support its claims of plausibility and effectiveness, Boiron relies on Robert Charles Dumont, M.D. Dr. Dumont trained as, and practiced as, a pediatric gastroenterologist. However, he now describes himself as a “pediatric integrative specialist” with the Raby Institute for Integrative Medicine at Northwestern in Chicago, Illinois.
On its website, the Raby Institute for Integrative Medicine serves up this insult to thousands of dedicated, caring physicians who, poor slugs, practice the obviously inferior “traditional” medicine:
Our approach to healing is unlike what you might experience in a traditional medical setting. Rather than focusing solely on treating the symptoms of a disease or curing an illness, we focus on the whole patient as a unique individual – taking into account each element of a person’s health, environment, and lifestyle. We seek to restore our patients’ unique, natural balance that defines optimal health, and support them to develop health habits that maintain wellness and prevent disease.
“Unique, natural balance that defines optimal health?” What does that even mean?
In pursuit of this lofty goal, the Raby Institute offers a smorgasbord of “CAM” practices previously debunked on SBM and elsewhere, including acupuncture, reflexology, cranial sacral therapy, magnets (“Treatments include shoe inserts, knee wraps, and other bandages, to relieve soreness in joints and muscles from sports injuries”), reiki, the “HCG Longevity Diet,” detoxification, energy medicine, and, our topic here, homeopathy (“based on natural ingredients that work with your immune system rather than suppressing it”). Well, they’ve got me there. No one could argue that honeybees aren’t “natural.”
If you will permit me a digression, I cannot resist sharing this lyrical gibberish from the Raby Institute’s website describing a form of CAM with which I was heretofore unfamiliar:
Vibrational Medicine
Nearly everything around us that we touch and see carries a unique vibrational energy signature—a living pulse that connects all things. Vibrational medicine incorporates the use of this chi energy within living organisms such as plants, gemstones and crystals, water, sunlight, and even the foods we eat, to help us balance the energies in our own bodies. Vibrational medicine therapies include color therapy, crystal therapy, flower essence therapies, grounding, and herbal therapies.
If you make it up, they will come.
Turning back to Dr. Dumont and his statement filed in support of Boiron’s motion, Dr. Dumont says that he “received training in integrative medicine to include training in acupuncture, medical hypnosis, functional medicine, and mind-body medicine.” As well, he has trained in homeopathy and is currently instructor and on the board of the U.S. chapter of the Center for Education and Development of Clinical Homeopathy. In this and additional homeopathy-related training and other activities, he appears well-qualified to speak on the subject.
Dr. Dumont seems to be in agreement with Dr. Willis on the putative principles underlying homeopathic remedies and on the manner in which they are prepared. He does not specifically agree or disagree with the Dr. Willis’s conclusion, based on these principles, that homeopathic theory is contrary to current scientific research. In documents filed with the court, the only statement Dr. Dumont makes at all in this regard is that “basic laboratory research is confirming the biological activity of highly diluted substances and helping the scientific community better understand their mechanism of action.” He attaches two exhibits listing studies of homeopathy but does not indicate which specifically support this statement. Nor does he explain how “the biological activity of highly diluted substances” supports any of the highly implausible assumptions underlying homeopathy.
In answer to deposition questions as to whether there was any scientific evidence indicating how Coldcalm’s ingredients (honeybees, etc.) could relieve cold symptoms, he consistently answered to the effect that “the mechanism is not known.” The plaintiff’s attorney finally asked:
Q. do you have any idea how these things [Coldcalm’s ingredients] are supposed work to accomplish these purposes?
A. No one has any hypothesis within the scientific community how they work.
Q. And that includes you?
A. That includes me. I would have the Nobel prize if I knew.
This did not stop Dr. Dumont from opining that Coldcalm is effective as advertised. He says that there are studies supporting “the efficacy of several of the homeopathic medicines present in Children’s Coldcalm,” but does not know of any studies supporting the efficacy of Coldcalm itself. Rather, he relies on the fact that
patients who have used Coldcalm and children’s Coldcalm to relieve symptoms associated with the common cold have had success with these products. . . . My experience treating patients with Coldcalm and Children’s Coldcalm is extremely positive and I continue to regularly recommend both products to patients who are suffering from symptoms associated with the common cold.
When asked in his deposition whether the basis for his belief that Children’s Coldcalm has been effective for his patients “is just spontaneous statements by mothers indicating that it has worked for their children or them, right?” he replied, “Exactly.” [Homeopaths and their reliance on anecdotes as evidence of effectiveness is the subject of recent blog posts by Orac and Dr. Novella.]
In addition, Christophe Merville, Boiron’s director for education and pharmacy development, testified in his deposition that he was unaware of any scientific testing, research or evidence supporting the effectiveness of Coldcalm or Children’s Coldcalm.
In support of its position that Boiron did not defraud consumers because it “believes in the efficacy of both homeopathic drugs generally and Children’s Coldcalm specifically,” Boiron cites Dr. Dumont’s statement and the testimony of one of its employees, Ludovic G. Rassat. It is not clear how Dr. Dumont’s testimony is relevant to this point, as it occurred only after the suit was filed, long after Boiron made its claims for Coldcalm. Mr. Rassat testified in his deposition as follows:
A. . . . homeopathic medicine is believed to basically stimulate the body’s own ability to – to rebalance itself and get better, so this is all the concept of homeopathic medicine, and this is basically what doctors using homeopathic medicines are doing.
Q. Do you know how Children’s Coldcalm would work to stimulate the body’s ability to rebalance itself and get better?
A. Well, you see, in the back of the product, you have a list of homeopathic active ingredients.
Q. Right.
A. Each homeopathic active ingredients are basically – has been reviewed – have been – are listed in the Materia Medica as being – went through, you know, hundred (phonetic) years of clinical observations by homeopathic doctors, and that’s – all those ingredients are participating to the . . . the action of the product.
Q. Okay. Are you aware of any scientific support indicating that these active ingredients on the back of the Children’s Coldcalm label will be effective in accomplishing the purposes stated [on the packaging]?
A. Again you’re – again, the base of those – those ingredients is the Materia Medica and 200 years of clinical observations by doctors, so that’s the scientific base of those product – those ingredients.
Summation, for now
So, let’s sum up the evidence at this point:
    • Boiron has not come up with any reliable evidence that the basic principles upon which homeopathy depends are scientifically valid, and does not directly contradict plaintiffs’ experts’ statements that those principles are, in fact, scientifically invalid.
    • There are no studies, by Boiron or anyone else, demonstrating the effectiveness of Coldcalm or Children’s Coldcalm for the purposes stated on its own packaging, that is, the relief of cold symptoms.
    • Boiron’s only evidence that Coldcalm and Children’s Coldcalm are effective is anecdotal.
Does this mean that the plaintiff and the class of Coldcalm purchasers she represents will win their summary judgment motion? Not necessarily. Boiron has not filed its response to the plaintiff’s motion and may provide additional evidence when it does. Boiron could prevail on other factual issues, such as the plaintiff’s alleged lack of proof that she or her family members actually had colds when they took Coldcalm (as opposed to, for example, allergies). There are other legal issues to be decided, such as what burden of proof the plaintiff must carry to win her motion. To this point, Boiron argues that the plaintiff cannot rely solely on the implausibility and ineffectiveness of homeopathy generally, but must prove specifically that Coldcalm does not work and that Boiron knew or should have known this. It may also be that the court finds material questions of fact prevent a decision on the merits at this point.
But no matter what the ultimate outcome, this case highlights (as reported in the last post) the almost total lack of regulation of homeopathic products sold in the U.S. It also reveals that, given the need to come up with evidence sufficient to support its argument that the plaintiff cannot prove Coldcalm is ineffective or that Boiron knew that to be the case, Boiron utterly fails to overcome the overwhelming scientific evidence that homeopathy is nothing but pseudoscience.
The court has yet to rule on the parties’ cross-motions for summary judgment. I’ll keep you posted.

The CAM Docket: Boiron III, et al.
Despite denying wrongdoing, Boiron was still required to reimburse consumers for their products after losing a consumer fraud lawsuit.
Jann Bellamy on December 13, 2012
Link
Oh, the irony of it all! Quackery continues its increasingly successful assault on the citadel of medicine, viz: quackademic medicine, integrative medicine, credulous medical journal articles, shruggies, medical society support for CAM provider licensing. Will that nemesis of medical doctors, plaintiffs personal injury attorneys, turn out to be the last defenders of science in a world of health care fraught with so-called alternative medicine?
Maybe not. But the thought did occur to me while reading the Final Judgment and Order entered in Gallucci v. Boiron, the class action accusing the world’s largest manufacturer of homeopathic products of consumer fraud.
Update on Gallucci
As I reported in a previous post, the parties reached a settlement that covers:
    • everyone in the United States (save a few California purchasers party to another class action),
    • who purchased one of over 200 Boiron homeopathic products (basically, every homeopathic product Boiron sells in the U.S.),
    • over a period of about 12 years.
As is typical of settlement agreements, Boiron denies any wrongdoing. On October 31, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California entered a Final Judgment and Order approving the settlement. The case is closed and administration of the settlement terms has begun. Purchasers who file a valid claim will get between $10 and $100. The named plaintiffs will get a bonus of $1000 to $3500. All of this comes out of a $5,000,000 settlement fund, an amount which will be reduced after subtracting claims administration and other expenses and attorneys fees (which we’ll get to in a minute). Payments will be reduced pro rata if there is not enough to cover all claims. For reasons I explained in the earlier post, I consider this inadequate. Even more so now, when all of the deductions from the settlement fund are taken into account.
To address what the court described as “concerns that consumers may not be aware that homeopathic products have not been subject to the same FDA scrutiny as allopathic [sic] drugs,” Boiron will have to add the Quack Miranda Warning (homeopathy version) to packaging and some advertisements:
These ‘Uses’ have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration.
Of course, saying that homeopathic products have not been subject to the same scrutiny as “allopathic” drugs is understating it a bit. Homeopathic products actually are subject to no scrutiny whatsoever by the FDA. As a matter of fact, the court in another case found that in practice homeopathic drugs weren’t being regulated by the FDA at all.
FDA regulation, or lack thereof, was not the only possibility for consumer confusion addressed by the settlement. In the court’s own words:
. . . to address Plaintiffs’ concern that homeopathic labels do not sufficiently explain the concept of a homeopathic dilution, Boiron has agreed to provide a Dilution Disclaimer in close proximity to the Drug Facts on each of its labels which shall state: ‘C, K, CK, and X are homeopathic dilutions: see [link created pursuant to para. 4.14 of the Settlement] for details.’ . . . The identified webpage shall provide consumers a more detailed explanation of the dilutions.
Boiron has two years to make the required changes to its packaging. While Boiron’s website currently does not refer to its information on dilutions as a “Dilution Disclaimer,” it does explain dilution and succussion, as well as “the law of similars,” in a series of short videos. Anyone who has no background in biology, physics, chemistry or medicine – in other words, most of the public – will probably find these convincing. (I also found this interesting tidbit under “Boiron In The News:” “Dr. Oz Show Features Self Massage with Arnica Gel to Keep Lymphatic System Healthy.” But I digress.)
Finally, the settlement awards the plaintiffs’ attorneys $1,250,000. Note that this is one of the amounts subtracted from the $5 million settlement fund, as explained above.
Interestingly, Gallucci managed to swallow up another class action, Fernandez v. Boiron, under circumstances the judge in Fernandez found disturbing. Fernandez, which was stayed pending court approval of the Gallucci settlement, will now likely be dismissed, as will Gonzales v. Boiron, another class action stayed pending settlement approval. Because of the breadth of the class and number of products eventually covered by the Gallucci settlement, class members and Boiron products in these other suits are encompassed by the settlement.
You too can be a plaintiff!
At least consumers are ahead of where they were before this litigation, although I imagine this new labeling information will do as much to discourage purchase of homeopathic remedies as the Quack Miranda Warning does to discourage buyers of dietary supplements. Which is to say, not at all. I was reading the order with some consternation, thinking Boiron got off light, when this thought popped into my head: “This is great!” Why? Because once the plaintiffs’ bar figures out they can make some real money suing homeopathic product manufacturers under state consumer protection laws, they will do just that. And they have.
At least two informational websites offer a free evaluation of whether a purchaser of a homeopathic product may have a cause of action against the manufacturer: LawyersandSettlements.com (for all homeopathic products) and Top Class Actions (some manufacturers excluded). The Senators (Ret.) Firm will do the same. And now that the word is out I’ll wager any plaintiffs’ attorney in the U.S. will either take one of these cases or find an attorney who will. Consumers, take note.
As might be expected, one of the law firms currently handling class actions against homeopathic products manufacturers is the Law Offices of Ronald A. Marron ALPC, the very firm representing the plaintiffs in Gallucci v. Boiron. That case did nothing to temper Mr. Marron’s low opinion of homeopathic products. Here’s what he says on the Top Class Actions website:
What is Homeopathy Fraud?
Homeopathy, or homeopathic medicine, is based on the idea that the body has the ability to heal itself, and therefore utilizes extremely low doses of medicine to increase its effectiveness. Many homeopathic remedies are so diluted that little to no molecules of the original substance remain; which some argue makes these medicines ineffective for their advertised use.
Consumers looking for natural remedies turn to homeopathic medicines based on advertisements that they’re ‘Clinically Proven’ to treat ailments, unaware that they’re throwing away millions of dollars each year on worthless placebos. Class action lawsuit attorneys have successfully argued that these companies are falsely advertising their homeopathic products can treat ailments, even though zero or just trace amounts of active ingredients are present.
It’s not just homeopathic medicine that’s falsely advertised, either. Natural and homeopathic diet supplements and beauty products can also scam consumers into believing they’re ‘Clinically Proven’ to work.
Well said! And yes, Mr. Marron, some do indeed argue that these medicines are ineffective for their advertised use, more specifically here, here, and here, among other places.
Here’s a list of some homeopathic products Mr. Marron and his firm have in their sights:
    • Nelsons Homeopathy (Rescue Remedy, Bach Original Flower Remedies, Pure & Clear, Arnileve, H+Care)
    • CVS Homeopathic Products (Flu Relief, Cold Relief, Cold Remedy, Ear Pain Relief)
    • Nature’s Innovation (Naturasil Skin Tags, Bed Bug Patrol, Naturasil Scabies)
    • Boericke & Tafel Cold/Flu
    • Homeolab USA (Kids Relief Cough & Cold)
I’m pleased to note the Marron firm is taking on dietary supplement companies too.
There are at least two class action lawsuits pending against homeopathic manufacturers Hyland’s and Standard Homeopathy. A suit in California involves seven Hyland’s products (Hyland’s Calm Forte, Teething Relief, Migraine Headache Relief, ClearAc, Poison Ivy/Oak Tablets, Colic Tablets and Leg Cramps with Quinine PM). Another lawsuit is pending in New Jersey. According to this April, 2012, news report, a $30 million dollar lawsuit was filed in Canada against Shoppers Drug Mart and Boiron alleging that they have, in their marketing of Oscillococcinum (made from the heart and liver of the Muscovy duck), committed at least 12 violations of consumer protection acts.
Delarosa v. Boiron, covered in two previous posts (here and here), remains pending in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California. (The Gallucci settlement had to carve out the class represented in Delarosa, California consumers who purchased Boiron homeopathic cold-remedy products, because that class was certified before the one in Gallucci.) Summary judgment motions remain pending and trial is set for April of next year.
Conclusion
On the one hand, Boiron got off really cheap in the Gallucci class action, with a mere $5 million covering the vast majority of U.S. purchasers for 12 years, although that award is only part of the cost of the lawsuit to Boiron. The company will bear their own attorneys’ fees and costs as well as the estimated $7 million it will spend to change its packaging.
On the other hand, if the Delarosa case gets decided on summary judgment in the plaintiffs’ favor, with the judge making findings of fact that Boiron fraudulently sold Coldcalm in violation of the California consumer protection laws, it would be a major public relations debacle, any monetary award aside. Another big embarrassment would be a loss following a jury trial, which could result in a substantial monetary award. And even after a jury trial, only the judge has authority to order injunctive relief, which she could choose to support with written findings of fact underpinning her conclusion that Boiron violated state consumer protection laws. Many “ifs,” but we’ll see.
Even Gallucci won’t stop claims against Boiron over other products it may sell in the U.S. or outside of the 12 years covered by the settlement. Nor will it have any effect on action the FDA, Federal Trade Commission or individual state Attorneys General might take. And it won’t impact suits outside the U.S. or those against other homeopathic product manufacturers. I expect more of these will be filed due to media coverage and attorney advertising.
We haven’t even considered here the possibility of claims against health care practitioners who prescribe or sell homeopathic products. Sellers may be equally liable under consumer protection laws if they knew or should have known of homeopathy’s ineffectiveness. That would, of course, be easy enough to prove. And prescribers are vulnerable to malpractice claims.
Litigation is not the best way to solve problems that should be addressed by regulation. There is no reason the U.S. Congress could not ban the sale of homeopathic products altogether. It certainly could regulate them in a way that substantially affects the ability to market them. But, as in the case of tobacco products litigation, where the government fails in effectively regulating a product unsuitable for human consumption, sometimes litigation is the only avenue left for consumers.

Homeopathy in Pharmacist Education
A new paper that looks at homeopathy in pharmacy education raises more questions than answers.
Scott Gavura on August 29, 2024
Link

Some of these products contain no medicine at all.
Pharmacists are highly trusted health professionals with expanding roles in the health care system. Your local pharmacist can administer vaccines, modify prescriptions, and may even have limited prescribing authority. Most pharmacists practice in community (retail) settings, and retail pharmacies are widespread, making more health services more accessible to patients. This is good news for patients.
In the United States, the majority of retail pharmacies are corporately owned, meaning the pharmacist is usually an employee, and not an owner. Independent and pharmacist-owned stores do exist, but they are shrinking in number. A consequence of corporate ownership of pharmacies beyond challenging work conditions for pharmacists is the lack of pharmacist influence over store practices, including which products may be sold in the store. As we have seen the scope and importance of the pharmacist grow over the past few decades, so has the appearance of unproven and pseudoscientific products on pharmacy shelves. Notably, homeopathy is now easy to find in almost any retail pharmacy.
What we should expect of pharmacists with respect to homeopathy is the context for a paper that I want to review (h/t Dr. Edzard Ernst) about pharmacy education and the teaching of homeopathy to pharmacists. The paper is entitled Teaching Homeopathy in U.S. Pharmacy Schools and it’s from Esra’a Khader and William R. Doucette at the College of Pharmacy, University of Iowa.
What’s the problem with homeopathy in pharmacies?
Homeopathy is an alternative-to-medicine practice which has persisted in use despite the lack of evidence showing it has any beneficial effects. Based on the idea that “like cures like” (essentially sympathetic magic), proponents of homeopathy believe that any substance can be an effective remedy if it’s sequentially diluted enough: raccoon fur, the fermented duck liver, even pieces of the Berlin Wall are possible remedies. The more dilute the remedy, the more powerful it is claimed to be. Typical remedies in use are so dilute that they are effectively and literally placebos, containing no active ingredients at all.
Homeopathy is incompatible with a scientific understanding of medicine, biochemistry, and even physics. However, when sold commercially, homeopathic “remedies” look like conventional medicine when they’re stocked on pharmacy shelves. The marketing and labeling that is permitted for homeopathic “remedies” in the United States does not draw attention to the lack of active ingredients. Consequently, it would be difficult for the average consumer, who may never have heard of homeopathy, to identify that some of the products on the shelf may be inert. XKCD highlighted the ethical issues with homeopathy in pharmacies several years ago (I have pasted the hover text below):
“I just noticed CVS has started stocking homeopathic pills on the same shelves with–and labeled similarly to–their actual medicine. Telling someone who trusts you that you’re giving them medicine, when you know you’re not, because you want their money, isn’t just lying–it’s like an example you’d make up if you had to illustrate for a child why lying is wrong.”
The Pharmacist’s Role
Before I dive into the paper, it’s worth pausing to ask what we would expect a science-based pharmacist to know about homeopathy. Given there is a lack of evidence to demonstrate that homeopathy is effective for any condition, and that its underlying principles are essentially sympathetic magic, the therapeutic aspect of homeopathy are straightforward. There are no medicinal effects.
Since homeopathy may be sold in a pharmacy (potentially against the wishes of the pharmacist), pharmacists need to be able to distinguish homeopathic products from conventional medicines, and be able to answer questions from patients about them. Ideally, pharmacists will understand core concepts of homeopathy so that they could contrast its ideas with the facts of biochemistry, physiology, and pharmacokinetics. Perhaps as part of a module on alternative forms of medicine, and the nature and effectiveness of placebo effects. With that knowledge, pharmacists would be well positioned to provide evidence-based information on the lack of efficacy for homeopathy and guide patients to effective treatments (or at minimum, avoiding unnecessary expense.)
The Research
This new paper from Khader and Doucette was an “explanatory sequential mixed methods approach” – effectively an online survey followed by interviews. This was not a survey of pharmacists, but of pharmacist educators. The authors’ stated objectives were to: 1) describe how and which homeopathy topics are taught in US schools of pharmacy and 2) characterize pharmacist roles with patients interested in using homeopathic products. The authors get off to a shaky start in the introduction, seemingly reluctant to point out the obvious:
Because these basic tenets conflict with modern medicine, pharmacology and therapeutics, the effectiveness of homeopathic products can be viewed skeptically by many pharmacists.
and
Since homeopathic products are legal drugs in the U.S., pharmacists should have a role in assuring their safe and effective use.
The first part of the research, the survey, was an email invitation sent to 3,300 pharmacy practice faculty in the USA. Two follow-up emails were then sent. 365 usable responses were received, which was an 11% response rate. While this method included multiple responses from a single pharmacy school, the authors state that there were responses from 95.8% of all pharmacy school.
Questions in the survey included faculty demographics, if homeopathy was taught at the school, how it was taught, which homeopathic topics were covered, and the methods used to teach them. Disappointingly, the authors note:
Questions were developed after reviewing educational resources provided by a homeopathic manufacturer (Boiron USA).
The manufacturer-based framing of homeopathy didn’t lead the researchers to ask potentially more useful questions about homeopathy. Importantly, if it was being taught uncritically as a practice, or if was being examined from a science-based perspective. While the authors noted that 61% of pharmacy schools have homeopathy in the curriculum, not enough information was collected to determine if this was a critical appraisal, or not:
With regards to courses that incorporated homeopathy topics, 8 (5.8%) had them included in Basic Science Courses, 76 (55.5%) in Pharmacy Practice Courses, and 53 (38.7%) in Pharmacotherapy Courses.
Here are the titles of courses cited. While some of these may be critical in nature, it’s not clear for others.
In the second part of the study, 19 pharmacy faculty involved in teaching homeopathy were interviewed from 18 schools of pharmacy. Through these interviews, roles and themes related to homeopathy were identified:
    • Pharmacists’ preparedness to guide patients for using homeopathic products.
        ◦ Themes: 1) recognize the difference between homeopathic and allopathic (sic) or herbal products, 2) counsel the patients efficiently and 3) the pharmacist needs to be knowledgeable.
    • Ensure patients are getting benefits from using homeopathic products.
        ◦ Themes: 1) prioritize patients’ safety, 2) homeopathic remedies’ effectiveness and 3) triage the patient for the best use of homeopathy.
    • Communicating properly with patients.
        ◦ Themes: 1) maintain your relationship with patients, 2) listen to, respect, and guide patients and 3) acknowledge that homeopathic products are available.
Unfortunately, there is not enough information from the interview summary to discern if the approaches being taken a pharmacy schools is critical or not. While some of the comments extracted from the interviews suggest this is happening, others do not.
Are pharmacy students critically appraising homeopathy?
Homeopathy has no place in science-based pharmacy practice, but the reality is that it’s being sold in pharmacies and drug stores. Pharmacists will inevitably be asked about their appropriateness and place in therapy. While homeopathy appears to be in the curriculum in a majority of American pharmacy schools, it is not clear if it’s being examined from a science-base perspective, or if pharmacists are being taught how to critically appraise the accumulated evidence that demonstrates it offers no meaningful health benefits. Understanding what pharmacy students are learning about homeopathy is a worthy topic. Unfortunately, this paper provides limited useful information on the subject, focusing more on the question “is homeopathy being taught” and not what is actually being taught. As they say, more research is required.

Pharmacy and homeopathy: Will the profession change, or will change be forced upon it?
Scott Gavura on August 11, 2016
Link

Retail pharmacy is giving itself a credibility problem. While pharmacists are highly trusted health professionals, there are increasing questions about the products sold in pharmacies. Many of the non-prescription products that you can find aren’t backed by good evidence. And the number of dubious products seems to be growing. Homeopathy is an extreme example. Homeopathic “remedies” look like conventional medicine, but unlike actual medicine, homeopathic products don’t contain any active ingredients. They are effectively and sometimes literally sugar pills: placebos that are marketed to treat health concerns. Not surprisingly, there is zero convincing evidence to show that homeopathy has any value in medicine. Homeopathy is fundamentally incompatible with the current scientific understanding of the medicine, biochemistry, and even the basic physics that form the foundation of a pharmacist’s knowledge base about medicines. There is no medicinal benefit to homeopathy. Yet despite the obvious ethical issues of selling sugar pills to patients who may be led to believe these products may be beneficial, the profession of pharmacy hasn’t acted, or even seriously asked itself if selling these products is appropriate. And homeopathy has moved quickly from a fringe product to one that you can find in most retail pharmacies. Here’s a picture from a local pharmacy near me. Imagine you’re in a rush, searching for a cough and cold product. How easily can you identify the homeopathy?

Why do pharmacies sell snake oil?
A few weeks ago Steven Novella wrote a thoughtful post about pharmacist ethics and responsibilities. Building on editorials from Edzard Ernst and myself, he made an appeal to the professionalism of pharmacists to prioritize patient interests and good medicine over retail interests. In Steve’s opinion, which I share, it is up to pharmacists themselves to lead this change. Pharmacy is a self-governing profession in most regions of the world, which means that it can define the terms of its practice. And there is nothing to stop the profession of pharmacy from rejecting homeopathy; Steve wrote:
For pharmacists there is also a very simple and clear course of action that they can take. Just stop selling health care products that have no evidence of efficacy or evidence of lack of efficacy. Stop selling products that don’t work, can’t work, or are unproven to work.
This means a refusal to sell any homeopathic product. If you work for a large corporate pharmacy chain, that still does not obligate you to violate your professional ethics, and you should express your position up the corporate chain. If pharmacists as a profession refused to sell homeopathy, big pharmacy chains would have no choice but to drop the products.
Failure to take such a stand is interpreted by the public as endorsement. Most people believe that pharmacists would not be selling homeopathic products alongside actual drugs if they were nothing but snake oil. Failure to oppose the sale of snake oil is implicit acceptance.in
Yet, to date, I’m not aware of any pharmacy organization or regulator seriously considering this issue. Pharmacies profit from selling products like homeopathy, but there’s been no discussion within the profession about whether this is ethical or even appropriate. Increasingly, questions are being raised outside the profession about the professionalism of pharmacists and what pharmacies sell. There’s an excellent video from the Australian consumer affairs show The Checkout that looks at this issue from the patient’s perspective:
Do pharmacists recognize the problem?
While many pharmacists know that homeopathy is nonsense and are frustrated with the profession’s inertia, some of the resistance to change may be coming from pharmacists themselves. From the Canadian pharmacy trade magazine Pharmacy Practice, I found a remarkable statistic:

Starting the sentence with “just” signals how little emphasis the profession seems to place on the use of good evidence. If one in five pharmacists doesn’t understand that homeopathy is pseudoscience and has no medicinal benefit, then the profession has a serious knowledge gap, because the evidence is unambiguous. (Also notably, 50% believe homeopathy to be a placebo but believe they may have a place in therapy.) Data like this suggests that pharmacists may not have fully thought through the ethical implications of selling complementary and alternative medicine. In a recent paper published in the peer-reviewed journal Bioethics, Professor Chris MacDonald and I argue that selling CAM fails to not only meet the ethical standards of health professionals, it violates all three ethical principles of commercial transactions. Ignorance of the evidence isn’t acceptable, particularly for a health professional and especially for a pharmacist. We noted:
However, it is not plausible to excuse vendors for selling a product that does not work simply because they have either not taken the time and effort to investigate whether their product works, or turned a blind eye to the evidence that is available to them. There is, after all, such a thing as willful ignorance. While the credulous seller of (for example) homeopathy may not be guilty of knowingly selling something that does not work, he or she is guilty of having culpably low epistemic standards. Such a person does not sell knowingly, but he or she does arguably sell recklessly.
While I have yet to see any responses to our paper in print, it was interesting to see a column posted at Canadian Healthcare Network (registration may be required) by pharmacist Jeannie Collins Beaudin. She endorses homeopathy, sells it in her pharmacy, and argues for its use in pharmacy practice. She writes:
What is it about homeopathy that has enabled it to survive over 200 years of usage, in spite of having what current studies insist is no greater effect than placebo? Is it simply that the placebo, or essentially our own immune system, is that effective when given a little encouragement?
I have to say that my overall experience in using these medications with clients has been surprisingly positive. I was first introduced to the medication system in the mid-nineties when we had just opened a new pharmacy. My husband, who is also my business partner (and a non-pharmacist), had noticed the rising interest in natural remedies and, in spite of my hesitation, insisted that we should stock homeopathy as well as herbal medicines.
As a pharmacist, I had a hard time getting my head around the way homeopathy was prepared, and the Latin names and different preparations were confusing to me, but I agreed to give it a try. Of course, we didn’t have the meta-analysis studies that we have today, which would likely have convinced me to do otherwise.
Initially, my role was simply to provide the specific medications that clients came in looking for, or I would consult homeopathy texts to help clients determine which medication would specifically be recommended for them when someone asked. Although I didn’t have an overwhelmingly large number of clients and didn’t specifically track their responses, it seemed that I received far more positive feedback than negative.
and later
Knowing how homeopathic medications are prepared, I had difficulty understanding how it possibly could work. There is a parallel with vaccines, where the agent that causes the problem is basically destroyed and then made into a solution that then stimulates the immune system to do the action we desire. This seemed to be the only plausible explanation for how homeopathy could work, but why would a more dilute solution give a stronger effect rather than a weaker one?
Confounding my understanding was the existence (although rare) of the “exacerbation reaction,” which is reported in the literature and was experienced by one of my clients who tried an allergy product. How could a substance that is diluted beyond Avogadro’s number (leaving it unlikely to contain even a single molecule of the original substance) cause her allergic symptoms to strongly intensify only minutes after taking a homeopathic medicine?
Homeopathic medications are used around the world far more commonly than they are in North America. England even has homeopathic hospitals, according to a pharmacy student who had done a rotation in such a hospital. Another student from India told me that homeopathic medicines were routinely used at home.
One of my best clients was a veterinarian who regularly used homeopathic medications with his animal patients—if the action of homeopathy relies only the placebo response, how could they work in an animal?
Are we missing something? Could it be that standard testing methods cannot be used for homeopathy due to its individualization? Do we need to, perhaps, include the ability of the immune system to respond in our attempts to prove or disprove this system? More questions than answers…
Colllins doesn’t describe any struggle ethically with selling homeopathy. She seems to place greater value on anecdote over published and more systematic evidence. And she doesn’t discuss one of the most critical issues and challenges that homeopathy (and CAM more generally) presents: Homeopathy challenges patient autonomy. In order for placebos to “work”, patients must believe something that is untrue. Ethical codes for the pharmacy profession can vary, but any I have seen make it clear that the patient’s interests are central to the pharmacist’s role, and that pharmacists must provide evidence-based information to support informed decision making. As MacDonald and I discuss is our paper, selling sugar pills, without an adequate explanation that these products contain no medicine, and have been evaluated and are not effective, may mean patients are making decisions without being fully informed. Failing to provide complete disclosure is effectively a form of medical paternalism. Homeopathy illustrates, with perhaps the most clarity, why selling unproven or ineffective treatments is incompatible with ethical pharmacy practice. Mark Crislip summed it up nicely:
This is the paradox of alternative medicine; by understanding, we render the treatment ineffective. Yet by concealing medical knowledge, we return to a dangerous, medieval-like approach to healthcare. It is for this reason why alternative medicine is flawed. As tempting as it might be to embrace placebo-based treatments, the ethical standards we would have to sacrifice are infinitely more valuable.
I’m not convinced the profession will change on its own, so I’m cautiously optimistic about a new review of pharmacy in Australia. Change may be coming, and it may be forced on the profession:
From The Australian (may be firewalled):
Pharmacists have a conflict of interest in selling unproven drugs and therapies to supplement their incomes from dispensing medicines, an independent review has been told.
and
Apart from perennial issues of fees, business models and location rules, the paper questions the very nature of what pharmacists do, and what they charge, and asks should they be put to better use. “It was put to the panel that community pharmacists face conflicts of interest between their role as retailers and as healthcare professionals,” says the paper, noting pharmacists can sell over-the-counter, complementary therapies and other retail ­products.
“The panel has heard that some consumers are concerned that pharmacists may compromise on the level of professional advice provided to patients on the quality use of medicines and feel financial pressure to ‘up-sell’ to consumers, for example by recommending medicines or products that may not be necessary for the patient. It was also claimed that many complementary products do not have evidence-based health benefits and as such, the sale of these products in a pharmacy setting may misinform consumers of their effectiveness and undermine the professional integrity of community pharmacists.”
To be clear, the review, which will be conducted by the Department of Health, goes well beyond the sale of “complementary” product and promises to thoroughly examine the organization and practice of retail pharmacy (may be firewalled), including examining the entire distribution and funding model for medicines. If done well, this could prompt an overdue consideration of the responsibilities retail pharmacists hold as key members of health care systems. But it may threaten cherished ideas that pharmacists hold about their dual role as a retailer and health professional. The specific questions the review is asking (see page 47) highlight the important issues that the profession at large needs to discuss, before decisions are made (and imposed) on pharmacists:
    • Does the availability and promotion of vitamins and complementary medicines in community pharmacies influence consumer buying habits?
    • Should complementary products be available at a community pharmacy, or does this create a conflict of interest for pharmacists and undermine health care?
    • Do consumers appreciate the convenience of having the availability of vitamins and complementary medicines in one location? Do consumers benefit from the advice (if any) provided by pharmacists when selling complementary medicines?
    • Does the ‘retail environment’ within which community pharmacy operates detract from health care objectives?
Conclusion: Ethical practice means prioritizing patients over retailing
The tension between the “business of pharmacy” and the professional responsibilities of pharmacists, as health care professionals, has always been present in retail pharmacy practice. Owing to the close linkage with retail aspects of medicine (like the sales of over-the-counter drugs), there’s a much more obvious relationship between the provision of health care and the need to derive revenue from consumer purchases. This may explain why homeopathy has made such inroads into retail pharmacies. But the growing shelf space devoted to dubious products is raising broader questions about the role of pharmacists as partners in health care systems. Pharmacists are trusted health professionals. That trust has been earned. If the profession doesn’t take steps to maintain that trust, then change may be forced upon it.

Lawsuits against US pharmacy chains selling homeopathy to proceed
An Appeals Court will permit CFI to challenge Walmart and CVS for selling homeopathy alongside conventional medicine.
Scott Gavura on October 13, 2022
Link

In 2018, the Center for Inquiry (CFI) filed a lawsuit on behalf of the general public against US pharmacy chain CVS for selling homeopathy. In 2019, it filed a similar lawsuit against Walmart, alleging fraud through their sale of these products. Both lawsuits were filed under the District of Columbia’s Consumer Protections Procedures Act (CPPA), which “establishes an enforceable right to truthful information from merchants about consumer goods and services that are or would be purchased, leased, or received in the District of Columbia”. Importantly, as Jann Bellamy noted when she blogged about these lawsuits at the time, the CPPA does not require proof that any consumers were actually mislead, deceived or damaged.
Both lawsuits were initially dismissed. Last week, in a unanimous ruling the District of Columbia Court of Appeals overturned both dismissals. The lawsuits will proceed.
Dilutions of Grandeur: The myth of homeopathy
Among all the forms of alternative medicine, homeopathy is possibly the most implausible of them all. Samuel Hahnemann invented the practice of homeopathy in the early 1800s. While the practice of medicine slowly progressed to a scientific model based on objective observations, homeopathy, on the other hand, has never progressed or evolved. Its practices today are frozen in the same prescientific beliefs of Hahnemann. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like is simply sympathetic magic, a pre-scientific belief, and is the entire basis for homeopathy:
    • Like-cures-like: in homeopathy, a substance that is believed to cause a symptom, is diluted to treat that same symptom. Any substance is thought to be an effective remedy if it’s diluted enough: cancer, boar testicles, crude oil, oxygen, skim milk, even vacuum cleaner dust or moonlight can be (and is) a homeopathic remedy. Deciding which substances will cure which symptoms is determined by a process called a “proving” which is equally without any scientific basis. (See the homeopathic “provings” for the Berlin Wall remedy and sunlight reflected off the planet Saturn, for an example of how remedies are created.)
    • Water has a memory: the more you dilute the substance, the more powerful its effect. And I mean dilute. The 30C “potency” is a common dilution used in homeopathy – that’s a dilution of 10-60. If something has been diluted this much, you would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original, pre-diluted material. The result is that most homeopathic remedies are completely inert, and don’t contain a single molecule of what’s on the label. Whether bottled as a liquid or dripped onto lactose and sold as tablets, they are pure placebo.
Despite the implausibility of homeopathy, and its detachment from the increasingly science-based practice of medicine, it retained some popularity over time, with a resurgence in the past few decades as an “alternative” medical system. Rigorous clinical trials confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. While there are plenty of clinical trials that show homeopathy is associated with positive clinical effects, they are always small, poorly controlled, and often biased. Two comprehensive reviews of the evidence are the 2010 Evidence Check from the United Kingdom’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee and the 2014 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council review, which reached the following conclusion:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness. People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner and should keep taking any prescribed treatments. The National Health and Medical Research Council expects that the Australian public will be offered treatments and therapies based on the best available evidence.
What’s the problem with homeopathy in pharmacies?
If homeopathy actually works in the way envisioned by Hahnemann and homeopaths, then the rest of medicine wouldn’t work. It is fundamentally incompatible with a scientific understanding of medicine, biochemistry, and even physics. However, when sold commercially, homeopathic “remedies” look like conventional medicine when they’re stocked on pharmacy shelves, like the photo above. The marketing and labeling of these “remedies” encourages this perception, often describing homeopathy as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing, and putting cryptic terms like “30C” beside long Latin names of what are purported to be the active ingredients. So it is exceptionally difficult for the average consumer, who may never have heard of homeopathy, to understand that some of the products on the shelf may be inert. XKCD nailed the ethics of homeopathy in pharmacies several years ago (I pasted the hover text below):

Questions have been raised worldwide about the appropriateness of pharmacies selling homeopathy to consumers who may not realize what they’re buying. This was noted by the DC Court of Appeals in their judgement:
But, at this juncture, we cannot say that it is implausible that a reasonable consumer might understand appellees’ placement of homeopathic products alongside science-based medicines as a representation that the homeopathic products are efficacious or are equivalent alternatives to the FDA-approved over-the-counter drugs alongside which they are displayed.
What’s the basis of this lawsuit?
In 2020, the Superior Court dismissed CFI’s lawsuit because it failed to show it is a “nonprofit organization” or “public interest organization” within the meaning of the CPPA. The judge also stated that she did not find the marketing and product placement “to be an actionable representation, or to have the tendency to mislead under the CPPA”. She noted that “homeopathic” appeared on the front of the box as well as the federally-mandated disclaimer that the product had not been evaluated by the FDA (what has been called the “quack Miranda” disclaimer). The Walmart lawsuit was dismissed for similar reasons.
The Appeals Court disagreed. It accepted that CFI had a sufficient stake in the CPPA action and noted CFI’s activities regarding the regulation, testing, and marketing of homeopathy “align with consumers’ interests”. It also accepted that allegedly misleading product placement was within the scope of the CPPA. They describe a 2017 case brought forward under different state consumer-protection laws where obsolete motor oils were sold to consumers by placing them on shelves next to non-obsolete oils. The federal court denied a motion to dismiss that case based on the argument of “failure to recite a cognizable deceptive practice” even though there was a label on the oil stating it was unsuitable for most gasoline engines built after 1988. They also cited a case where CVS sold “Infant’s Acetaminophen” which was exactly the same as the CVS “Children’s Acetaminophen” but with a different photo on the package, and higher cost. The court was “…unable to conclude as a matter of law that no reasonable consumer would be deceived” even though both packages disclosed that they contained acetaminophen 160mg/5mL.
Finally, the appeals court disagreed with the superior court’s assessment that the placement of these products alongside “science-based medicines” did not have the tendency to mislead under the CPPA:
In this case, we do not find it facially implausible that a reasonable customer could believe, based on appellees’ placement of homeopathic drug products alongside FDA-approved over-the-counter drugs, that homeopathic products are comparably efficacious. We agree with CFI that whether signage and product placement influence consumers regarding the efficacy of medical products is a question that can be answered only with evidence, “not an inherently implausible assertion that can be dismissed out of hand.”
It also noted,
CFI’s complaints contains a number of conclusory allegations, but also contain numerous factual allegations and accompanying photographs to the effect that: the defendant retailers market themselves as offering products that will enable customers to get healthy; persons suffering an ailment will often turn to the pharmacy section of their neighborhood Walmart (or CVS) for relief; studies and patient experience have shown that homeopathic products are not effective; Walmart and CVS present homeopathic products alongside FDA-approved over-the-counter products, under aisle signs indicating that the aisles contain remedies for pain, colds, heartburn, and other conditions; and the retailers do so without informing customers that there is no scientific evidence that homeopathic products have any value in treating those symptoms and diseases. These factual allegations plausibly support an inference that, through their product placement practices, Walmart and CVS mislead consumers into believing that homeopathic products are equivalent alternatives to FDA-approved over-the-counter drugs.
What happens next?
This looks like a victory, but only re-opens the path for the original lawsuits, which can now proceed. The CFI Legal Director, Nick Little, concluded:
The Court of Appeals rightly recognized that giant retailers can’t just deny responsibility for how they present what are fundamentally worthless products. It’s a huge victory for consumers and their right not to be misled…DC’s highest court acknowledged what we’ve always known – CFI’s decades of work against pseudoscience like homeopathy is consumer protection work. We’re not going away, and it’s time for CVS, Walmart, and all other retailers to stop misrepresenting homeopathy as medicine.

A homeopathic win for consumers
Scott Gavura on August 13, 2015
Link

Do you believe in magic? It might surprise you to learn that some people believe sugar pills have healing properties. This belief system, called homeopathy, is a multi-billion dollar industry worldwide, and it’s growing. While there is no convincing evidence to demonstrate that homeopathic treatments are more effective than a placebo, many consumers and even some health professionals accept homeopathy as a legitimate health treatment, and its providers as legitimate health professionals. Responding to the perceived consumer demand for these products, government regulators have had a difficult decision to make: They could ignore homeopathy as a health practice, treating it like we might think of astrology: firmly outside of medicine. Or they could choose some form of regulation, targeting the providers (homeopaths) or the product (homeopathy), possibly with the goal of managing its use, or perhaps limiting harms to consumers. The risk of regulating nonsense, as has been described before, is the perceived legitimacy that recognition and regulation implies. Regrettably, regulation in many countries has had that exact effect. What’s worse, regulation often seems to have prioritized the commercial interests of homeopaths over the public interest, leaving consumers with little understanding that homeopathy lacks scientific credibility as a health practice. Consequently, homeopathy has attracted regular criticism from SBM’s bloggers, science and health journalists, and other science advocates over the years. It appears this advocacy is finally having an effect. Regular readers will recall several posts over the past few weeks, describing the possibility of new regulation of homeopathy by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA). And just recently, Health Canada announced two important changes to its homeopathy regulation, which may signal a new direction. Are we witnessing the beginning of more sensible regulation of this prescientific practice?
Dilutions of grandeur
Homeopathy is considered a form of “alternative medicine” but it’s more accurately described as alternative to medicine, given homeopathic remedies don’t normally contain medicine or active ingredients. Homeopathy was invented in the 1800s based on the idea that “like cures like” (which is sympathetic magic, not science). Proponents of homeopathy believe that any substance can be an effective remedy if it’s diluted enough: cancer, boar testicles, crude oil, oxygen, and skim milk are all homeopathic “remedies”. But while they may have different labels, the products are all essentially the same. In the manufacturing process, remedies are diluted in water so dramatically that there’s mathematically almost zero possibility of even a trace of the original ingredient remaining. To homeopaths, this is a good thing, as dilution is claimed to make the “remedy” more potent, not less. These rules contradict core scientific principles as well as what we know about biology and medicine. In short if homeopathy works, the rest of medicine cannot work. And the best evidence shows that they do not work.
Health Canada, Canada’s version of the FDA, has taken the approach of licensing homeopathic remedies (it does not regulate the practice of homeopathy) as part of an overall “natural health products” framework, lumping homeopathy in alongside supplements, vitamins and practices like Traditional Chinese Medicine. Health Canada states that this licensing framework benefits consumers:
Through the Natural Health Products Directorate, Health Canada assures that all Canadians have ready access to a wide range of natural health products that are safe, effective and of high quality.
The consequence, when it comes to homeopathy, has been the regulation of the absurd. There are now hundreds of indistinguishable homeopathic remedies that have been reviewed and approved by Health Canada, based what turns out to be an astonishingly low evidence bar. Health Canada will even allow references to homeopathy textbooks written in the 1800’s as “evidence” of a product’s efficacy. There is no requirement for any randomized controlled trial or any other form of evidence that could actually show efficacy. Health Canada’s bar is so low that when the “homeopathic insect repellent” Mozi-Q was approved, I questioned aloud if there was anything that Health Canada wouldn’t approve. As the television show CBC Marketplace discovered, the answer seems to be no.
A few years ago, Health Canada (and other regulators worldwide) undertook a safety review of cough and cold remedies marketed for children. While these products had a long history of use, there was scant evidence that they did anything beneficial. Given these products had some risks, most regulators concluded that the risks outweighed the benefits. Health Canada ordered that these products could no longer be promoted for use in children, and the products were pulled off pharmacy shelves. The supplement and natural health product industry responded quickly, bringing products to market that took advantage of the special rules created for homeopathy. Soon several homeopathic “cough and cold” products were on pharmacy shelves – not because they had any evidence of efficacy, but actually because they lacked any medicine at all. These were placebos, sitting on pharmacy shelves where the old cough and cold remedies used to sit, labelled as if they could treat coughs and colds.
CBC Marketplace, having previously described how homeopathic remedies lack any medicine at all, decided to test Health Canada’s own licensing process. They applied for approval to market a homeopathic remedy they named “Nighton” to be used to treat fever and pain in infants and children. For evidence, they submitted a few pages photocopied from an old homeopathy textbook. No trials were conducted and no safety data was provided. Just some forms, a few photocopies and a fee. Perhaps not surprisingly, their product was approved and licensed. Here is the listing, still active, on the Health Canada website. As subsequent focus groups revealed, parents do assume that Health Canada’s approved products had been thoroughly tested by Health Canada for both safety and efficacy.
Health Canada has now announced that it is strengthening the rules for homeopathic cough and cold products. It will no longer allow specific health claims for homeopathic cough, cold and flu products for children 12 and under, unless those claims are supported by scientific evidence. That’s a significant change from accepting photocopies from textbooks written in the 1800s. One wonders why this rule isn’t being applied to all homeopathic remedies that are marketed. It’s especially curious given a remarkable statement Health Canada published on its website when the new requirements were announced:
Health Canada regulates homeopathic products as a type of natural health product. Health Canada reviews homeopathic products to make sure that they are safe and that the health claims (what the product claims to do) are supported by textbooks and other references used in the practice of homeopathy (e.g., pharmacopoeia, Materia medica). These products are not supported by scientific evidence.
Emphasis added.
In putting new limitations on claims made by manufacturers, Health Canada is finally acknowledging what scientifically is known as fact.
Nosodes are not vaccines
The second change recently announced by Health Canada relates to homeopathic “nosodes”. In late 2014, CBC Marketplace used hidden cameras to record reporters asking homeopaths about vaccines. The show sent young mothers (with their babies) to speak with homeopaths about immunizations and vaccines in Toronto and Vancouver. They found homeopaths were giving advice that often contradicted scientific evidence. Rather than endorsing vaccines, some homeopaths promoted “nosodes” which they believe offer vaccine-like immunity from products that are, like all homeopathy, inert sugar pills. A “nosode” is a remedy that starts with infectious material, like polio, measles or smallpox, and then it’s diluted sequentially until mathematically, there’s nothing left but water. Unbelievably, Health Canada has approved hundreds of homeopathic “nosodes” for sale over the years. Two years ago advocacy group Bad Science Watch launched a public campaign against nosodes, and succeeded in getting Health Canada’s agreement to force commercial manufacturers to place a label on their products stating “This product is not intended to be an alternative to vaccination.” Many felt this didn’t go far enough. This year, the Canadian Paediatric Society issued a strong statement on nosodes:
Nosodes are approved for human use in Canada under Health Canada’s Natural Health Products Regulations. At the time of writing, there were 179 distinct products approved for sale, including 82 with labels stating that they can be used to prevent common and important infections. However, as stated previously, there is no scientific or medical evidence that nosodes are effective in preventing infectious disease.
It is important that Canadian parents are provided with the best available evidence to make informed decisions about their children’s health. Current regulations stipulate that labelling on nosodes must include the following statement: “This product is not intended to be an alternative to vaccination”. The Canadian Paediatric Society (CPS) does not believe this proviso fully captures the fact that nosodes are clearly not a safe or efficacious alternative to vaccination. The CPS recommends that labelling on nosode products should be changed to read: “This product has not been proven to prevent infection. Health Canada advises that your child receive all routine vaccinations even if they take this product”.
In July 2015, Health Canada responded with a new warning for the label, clearly modeled on the CPS recommendation:
This product is neither a vaccine nor an alternative to vaccination. This product has not been proven to prevent infection. Health Canada does not recommend its use in children and advises that your child receive all routine vaccinations.
While this is a welcome change, it won’t help all consumers, particularly the ones that see homeopaths for treatment. Health Canada doesn’t appear to require the warning when the remedy is produced by the homeopaths themselves, but only when the products are commercially prepared. So while the labelling change is an improvement, it’s somewhat of a hollow (homeopathic?) success. It doesn’t appear to apply to homeopaths who make their own products, like the ones Marketplace filmed with hidden cameras. Nor does it remove the license of the 121 products already approved, or commit to removing these medically useless products from the market. But it’s another acknowledgment of the lack of evidence supporting homeopathy, which hopefully will continue to raise questions about the entire licensing system.
Homeopathy still has nothing to offer
The evidence is overwhelming and unequivocal: Homeopathy is a belief system, not medicine, and consequently has nothing to contribute to the practice of medicine. Despite this reality, regulators have struggled to find licensing frameworks that prioritize consumers and public health above those of homeopaths and homeopathic manufacturers. Recent changes in Canada are a modest but hopeful sign for change.

Walmart sued for deceiving customers in selling homeopathic remedies
A lawsuit claiming Walmart fraudulently deceives consumers in the sale of worthless homeopathic remedies has been filed by the Center for Inquiry (CFI), acting on behalf of the general public. CFI says co-mingling ineffective homeopathic products with science-based treatments on Walmart’s pharmacy shelves and website misleads customers into thinking they are equivalent, when “there is not a shred of credible scientific evidence” that homeopathy works, “or indeed could possibly work.”
Jann Bellamy on June 6, 2019
Link

The Center for Inquiry (CFI) recently filed suit against retail behemoth Walmart, alleging the company is committing widespread consumer fraud through the sale and marketing of worthless homeopathic remedies. According to the complaint, Walmart places both its own “Equate” brand and other homeopathic brands alongside science-based, FDA-approved over-the-counter (OTC) medicines on its pharmacy shelves, with no distinction drawn between them. Searches on the Walmart website for condition-specific remedies, such as for colds, flu, or cough, will turn up both homeopathic and science-based products. This, says CFI, falsely presents ineffective homeopathic products as equivalent alternatives to FDA-approved science-based medicines.
In a press release, CFI President Robyn Blumner said:
Despite being among the richest corporations on Earth and the largest retailer in the United States, Walmart chooses to further pad its massive wealth by tricking consumers into throwing their money away on sham medicinal products that are scientifically proven to be useless and potentially dangerous . . . We intend to put a stop to it.
Like a similar suit filed against pharmacy chain giant CVS last year (now in settlement discussions, which a recent court filing described as “productive”), CFI is suing Walmart under the District of Columbia’s Consumer Protections Procedures Act (CPPA), which “establishes an enforceable right to truthful information from merchants about consumer goods” without proof that any consumers were in fact mislead, deceived or damaged. In other words, in the District of Columbia’s view, lying to consumers is wrong and should be prevented, even without the added insult of actual harm. The CPPA permits nonprofit and consumer protection organizations like CFI to file suit on behalf of the public and seek, on its behalf, treble damages or, in lieu thereof, $1,500 per violation, as well as an injunction against further violations. D.C. is a tiny jurisdiction and any judgment in CFI’s favor would apply only to Walmart’s three retail stores located there. An injunction against fraudulent marketing on the company’s website would pack a bigger punch.
The complaint explains the ludicrous pseudoscience behind homeopathy’s claims of effectiveness: homeopathic remedies are massively diluted with water or other inert substances, often to the level where no molecules of the original substance remain in the final product, based on the notion that the greater the dilution, the greater the power of the remedy. CFI also explains the homeopathic concept of “like treats like”, that is, if something is shown to cause a symptom in an individual, the same substance can be used to treat the symptom. Thus, CFI says, homeopathy is pseudoscience, without “a shred of credible scientific evidence that it works, or indeed could possibly work”, citing U.S., Australian, and U.K. government research.
(None of this is news to SBM regulars; we’ve covered “the one quackery to rule them all” many times here on SBM, including my personal experience with just the type of deceptive marketing CFI describes in the complaint.)
As it did in the CVS complaint, CFI uses an often-mocked example of homeopathic nonsense as a tutorial on homeopathy: Oscillococcinum, “duck offal” diluted to a scientifically-impossible concoction of one part offal to 10400 parts water, a number that exceeds the estimated number of atoms in the known universe (1082 ). According to homeopaths, the complaint explains, the potency of the offal is preserved through “succussion,” or shaking the product and hitting it against an elastic surface, such as a leather-covered book. Homeopaths rationalize that, even without a single molecule of the original ingredient remaining, the water can “physically remember the chemical properties” of the duck offal, though not a single molecule of the offal remains.
Yet, the complaint notes, with photos of Walmart pharmacy shelves to prove the point, Oscillococcinum is displayed alongside FDA-approved OTC medicines like Tylenol Sinus & Headache, Alka Seltzer, and Mucinex. When “flu remedy” or “flu relief” is typed into the search box on Walmart’s website, Oscillococcinum returns as a front-page result. Thus,
Walmart is announcing that if a customer has flu-like symptoms, Tylenol Cold and Flu medicine, containing acetaminophen, a medicine tested and approved ty the FDA, is an equivalent solution to Oscilloccinum, which contains the organs of a Muscovy duck, diluted to the power of 10400.
CFI alleges that this and similar juxtapositions of homeopathic and science-based remedies causes confusion and falsely implies to the consumer that there is no difference between them.
In a news report on the lawsuit, a Walmart spokesperson said
We want to be the most trusted retailer, and we look to our suppliers to provide products that meet all applicable laws, including labeling laws. . . . Our Equate private label homeopathic products are designed to include information directly stating that the claims are not based on accepted medical evidence and have not been evaluated by the FDA.
The disclaimer is apparently based on the FTC’s 2016 Enforcement Policy Statement on the marketing of homeopathic remedies, explained in an agency press release:
the FTC will hold efficacy and safety claims for OTC homeopathic drugs to the same standard as other products making similar claims. That is, companies must have competent and reliable scientific evidence for health-related claims, including claims that a product can treat specific conditions.
Of course, as the FTC admits, homeopathic remedies can’t meet this standard:
For the vast majority of OTC homeopathic drugs, the policy statement notes, ‘the case for efficacy is based solely on traditional homeopathic theories and there are no valid studies using current scientific methods showing the product’s efficacy.’ As such, the marketing claims for these products are likely misleading, in violation of the FTC Act.
However, the FTC offers homeopathic remedy marketers an out:
the policy statement also notes that the FTC has long recognized that marketing claims may include additional explanatory information to prevent the claims from being misleading. Accordingly, it recognizes that an OTC homeopathic drug claim that is not substantiated by competent and reliable scientific evidence might not be deceptive if the advertisement or label where it appears effectively communicates that: 1) there is no scientific evidence that the product works; and 2) the product’s claims are based only on theories of homeopathy from the 1700s that are not accepted by most modern medical experts.
Most?
In other words, the FTC will permit homeopathic remedy makers to lie about the effectiveness of their products as long as they tell consumers they are lying.
But,
the FTC will carefully scrutinize the net impression of OTC homeopathic marketing claims and that if an ad conveys more substantiation than a marketer has, it will violate the FTC Act.
While Equate brand homeopathic remedies may comply with the FTC policy statement, I could not find any similar language on other brands sold by Walmart, either in the photos included as part of the complaint or the Walmart website.
In any event, the disclaimer may not matter. The legal basis of CFI’s lawsuit is not that Walmart’s homeopathic products don’t comply with federal labelling laws or are illegal (although they are; more on that in a moment). Rather, it says displaying pseudoscientific remedies alongside science-based medicines falsely implies an equivalency in effectiveness and that violates D.C.’s consumer protection law. While Walmart might try to use the disclaimer as evidence in this case that these displays are not confusing or misleading, I don’t think the court would be persuaded. Tiny print on a small package hardly overcomes the implication that products grouped together on pharmacy shelves under a sign saying, for example, “heartburn relief”, actually provide heartburn relief.
The FDA’s policy only recently switched from ignoring the Food, Drug & Cosmetics Act’s mandate that homeopathic remedies go through the same approval process as all other OTC and prescription drugs to a “risk-based” enforcement approach that tackles only the worst players in the homeopathic market, leaving the others free to foist their worthless products on consumers. As the FDA itself admitted,
many homeopathic products will likely fall outside the risk-based categories described in the [FDA’s draft] guidance [on homeopathic drugs] and remain available to consumers.
Yes, and consumers will continue to spend billions on worthless products that not only won’t help them, but may, through poor manufacturing practices or delay in effective medical care, cause serious illness or death. That is why lawsuits like CFI’s against CVS and Walmart are essential in the battle against healthcare pseudoscience. With the FDA and the FTC failing to protect consumers from products they admit are both ineffective and sold illegally, in violation of the FD&C Act, the courts are the consumer’s only refuge.

CVS sued for deceiving consumers in sale of homeopathic remedies
A lawsuit claiming pharmacy giant CVS fraudulently deceives consumers in the sale of worthless homeopathic remedies has been filed by the Center for Inquiry (CFI), acting on behalf of the general public. CFI says co-mingling ineffective homeopathic products with science-based treatments on CVS’s retail shelves and online confuses consumers.
Jann Bellamy on July 19, 2018
Link

A lawsuit claiming pharmacy chain giant CVS fraudulently deceives consumers in the sale of worthless homeopathic remedies was filed in late June by the Center for Inquiry (CFI), acting on behalf of the general public. The suit seeks both damages and an injunction against CVS’s deceptive marketing practices in the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, alleging violations of the District’s consumer protection act.
In a press release, CFI’s president Robyn Blumner said that CFI had tried to discuss the situation with CVS:
but the concerns we raised were ignored . . . Homeopathy is a multi-billion dollar consumer fraud. If CVS would rather line its pockets than protect Americans’ heatlh, we have no choice but to take this fight to the courts.
The press release noted that, in addition to being a waste of money, using homeopathic products instead of evidence-based treatments can result in worsened or prolonged illness, and, in some cases, death. As well:
Several products have been found to contain poisonous ingredients which have affected tens of thousands of adults and children in just the last few years.
Nicholas Little, CFI’s Vice President and General Counsel, who represents CFI in the suit, charged that CVS can’t claim ignorance:
If the people in charge of the country’s largest pharmacy don’t know that homeopathy is bunk, they should be kept as far away from the American healthcare system as possible.
The suit is brought under the District of Columbia’s Consumer Protections Procedures Act (CPPA), which “establishes an enforceable right to truthful information from merchants about consumer goods” without proof that any consumers were in fact mislead, deceived or damaged. In other words, in the District of Columbia’s view, lying to consumers is wrong and should be prevented, even without the added insult of actual harm. The CPPA permits nonprofit and consumer protection organizations like CFI to file suit on behalf of the public and seek, on its behalf, treble damages or, in lieu thereof, $1,500 per violation, as well as an injunction against further violations. Although any ruling in favor of consumers would apply only within the D.C.’s tiny jurisdiction, it could send a powerful message if CVS were required to pull homeopathic products from the shelves of its 60 D.C. pharmacies and disclaim, per a court order, any intent to sell homeopathic products to D.C. residents on its website.
The complaint alleges that CVS engages in fraudulent and deceptive marketing practices in retail and online sales of homeopathic products, including CVS’s house brand, by:
using marketing, labeling and product placement to falsely present homeopathic products as equivalent to effective science-based medicines for specific diseases and symptoms.
For example, according to the complaint, homeopathic products like Oscillococcinum and its claim that it “relieves flu-like symptoms such as body aches, headache, fever, chills and fatigue” are displayed on CVS’s shelves in the “cold and flu” section, indistinguishable from FDA-approved over-the-counter remedies like Tylenol Sinus & Headache. Likewise, on CVS’s website, Oscillococcinum Quick Dissolve Pellets is nested for sale under the category path Health and Medicine > Cough, Cold, & Flu > Flu Remedies, along with Tylenol Cold + Flu Caplets, although the consumer is offered the convenience of purchasing only Oscillococcinum online. For the Tylenol product, the consumer must visit a brick-and-mortar CVS pharmacy.
CFI uses Oscillococcinum as a tutorial for the court on the nonsense behind homeopathy, explaining that it consists of “duck offal” diluted to a scientifically-impossible concoction of one part offal to 10400 parts water, a number that exceeds the estimated number of atoms in the known universe (1082). According to homeopaths, the complaint explains, the potency of the offal is preserved through “succussion,” or shaking the product and hitting it against an elastic surface, such as a leather-covered book. Homeopaths rationalize that, even without a single molecule of the original ingredient remaining, the water can “physically remember the chemical properties” of the duck offal, even though not a single molecule of the offal remains.
I am all too familiar with CVS’s deceptive marketing tactics. Last year, I came close to buying a homeopathic dry eye product at CVS for my late mother, who was suffering from cancer. Fortunately, I caught my mistake and purchased instead an evidence-based eye remedy. But the mere possibility that she might have suffered due to using a worthless product led to both my writing a post about my experience and filing a complaint with three government agencies, none of which has taken any action. Judging from the comments of those who had similar experiences with the confusing co-mingling of real and fake medicine on retail shelves, I am not alone.
The complaint correctly characterizes homeopathy as “pseudoscience” without “a shred of credible scientific evidence that it works” or “could possibly work” and as “no more accepted by the scientific community than the notion of a flat Earth.” These allegations are supported by citations to, among others:
    • The Australian National Health and Medical Research Council’s assessment that “There are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.”
    • The 2010 U.K. House of Commons Science and Technology Committee report on homeopathy and its conclusion that homeopathic remedies performed no better than placebo and that the National Health Service should stop funding homeopathic remedies, an action the NHS took in 2017.
    • The Federal Trade Commission’s 2016 statement that a homeopathic remedy’s claims of efficacy, if not backed by “competent and reliable scientific evidence,” would be considered misleading without a warning to consumers that there is no scientific evidence that the product works and homeopathic “theories” are not accepted by modern experts. [Although, according to the FTC, even this admission to consumers that you are lying to them may not be enough to protect the product’s false claims.]
Thus, the complaint alleges, in marketing homeopathic products as effective treatments for specific conditions, in creating the impression that homeopathic remedies can be used interchangeably with science-based medicines, and in failing to tell consumers there is no scientific evidence that homeopathic products are beneficial for these conditions, CVS has violated the D.C.’s Consumer Protections Procedures Act.
CVS responds
Per the court’s rules, CVS must file a response and “admit or deny the allegations asserted against it” by CFI. (It may file a motion that delays its duty to respond, and the court could possibly grant a motion to dismiss the case prior to CVS’s filing its answer, but the latter seems unlikely.) Denial of any factual contentions made by CFI must be “warranted on the evidence” or “reasonably based on belief or a lack of information.” Given the overwhelming scientific consensus that homeopathy is not, and cannot be, beneficial for anything, it will be interesting to see how CVS responds to the complaint’s specific allegations of homeopathy’s pseudoscientific principles and its demonstrable lack of effectiveness. And it will be interesting to see how CVS mounts a defense to the Consumer Protections Procedures Act’s prohibitions against:
    • Representing that products have characteristics that they do not have;
    • Representing that products are of a particular standard or quality when they are in fact of a different standard or quality;
    • Misrepresentation of a material fact which has a tendency to mislead;
    • Failing to state a material fact if that failure tends to mislead;
    • Using innuendo or ambiguity as to a material fact, which has a tendency to mislead.
Barring the use of a legal defense like preemption (see below), or the successful introduction of junk science as evidence, it’s hard to see how CVS can prevail on the merits. Then again, homeopathic remedies have been sitting on the shelves of American pharmacies and other retailers for decades despite their obvious ineffectiveness and scientific implausibility, defying (admittedly tepid) government regulation and numerous lawsuits.
While an answer to the complaint is not yet due in court, CVS responded to the suit in MD Magazine by saying:
‘We believe the Center for Inquiry’s civil complaint against CVS Pharmacy has no merit. We offer certain homeopathic products in compliance with federal law and applicable regulations set forth by the FDA and the FTC,’ Mike DeAngelis, CVS Health’s senior director of corporate communications, told MD Magazine. ‘CVS is committed to assuring that the products we offer are safe, work as intended, comply with regulations and satisfy customers. In the event of a regulatory issue concerning any product we sell, we take appropriate action.’
Actually, if CVS were committed to assuring that the products it sells are safe and work as intended, it wouldn’t be selling homeopathic remedies.
CVS’s statement possibly foreshadows the defendant’s claiming that the District of Columbia’s consumer protection act is preempted by federal law, specifically the Food, Drug, and Cosmetics Act of 1938 and the Federal Trade Commission Act of 1914. This defense has not always succeeded in suits against homeopathic product manufacturers, a federal district court judge having found that the FDA has largely abdicated any role in creating standards for homeopathic OTC drugs, a situation that, sadly, has not changed. Even if the FDA were to finally adopt its proposed “risk-based” enforcement of the FD&C Act against homeopathic remedies, the FDA has frankly admitted that many homeopathic products would escape enforcement action despite the agency’s tacit admission that, since no homeopathic remedy on the market today has been approved in accordance with the FD&C Act, each and every one of them is being marketed in violation of federal law.
CVS’s statement also takes a page from the tobacco industry’s playbook – “all we are doing is selling a “legal product:”
Gareth Davies, Chief Executive of [the U.K.’s] Imperial Tobacco, says [in 1997] of Labour’s proposed advertising ban: ‘Obviously I am very much against anything that tries to reduce consumption of a legal product that is used by adults …an advertising ban will do nothing to reduce consumption.’
And this from Brown and Williamson’s ad agency, in 1969:
We will continue to bring to the American people the story of the cigarette and any other legal product based upon truth and taste. We believe that free speech and fair play are both the heritage and promise in our society of free and responsible enterprise.
But as CFI’s General Counsel told Gizmodo:
The argument isn’t that they’re illegal, it’s about how they’re marketing and selling these products . . .
Of course, homeopathic remedies should be illegal, or, at the very least, the FDA should make them to undergo the safety and effectiveness evaluation required by the FD & C Act, a mandate that the FDA continues to ignore. Until that happens, I am grateful for CFI’s suit seeking consumer protection against the sale of fraudulent products by CVS and fully support their efforts. In preparing this post, I was brought to tears by the memory of my near-failure to help alleviate the suffering of my late mother, directly attributable to confusion brought on by CVS’s deceptive product placement. Since this and many similar incidents don’t seem to bother CVS, perhaps treble damages and an injunction will change its corporate mind.
UPDATE: To explain the problems with homeopathy and why CFI is suing CVS, CFI has put up a dedicated website at centerforinquiry.org/cvs.

CVS selling homeopathic remedies: It gets personal
I almost purchased a worthless homeopathic eye remedy at CVS for a cancer patient. I’m taking action to try to stop this from happening to others.
Jann Bellamy on March 30, 2017
Link

Taking care of a loved one with terminal lung cancer is an exercise in both the profound and the mundane. You attend heart-wrenching doctor visits discussing whether a blast of radiation might ease the pain of metastasis to the pelvis or whether we should increase the nebulizer treatments to alleviate her extreme shortness of breath. You shop for small items she needs, each designed to make life just a bit less uncomfortable: dry-mouth mouthwash, socks with no-slip treads on the soles, oatmeal raisin cookies to perk up a sagging appetite.
So it was last week that I found myself with both the profound and the mundane on my to-do list for the day. In the profound column: Meeting with my mother’s “care team” at the skilled nursing facility: nurses, a dietician and social workers in whose hands I must entrust her day-to-day care. On the mundane side: Going by a CVS Pharmacy to pick up some eye drops. Whether due to Tallahassee’s abundance of pollen, or the 24/7 oxygen she must breathe to stay alive, or the side effects of furosemide (the diuretic she must take to relieve fluid buildup), my mother suffers from dry, itchy, red eyes. The Hospice nurse suggested allergy eye drops to relieve these symptoms.
As I searched the CVS aisle, my eyes landed on a line of drops from Similasan, a company unfamiliar to me. Allergy eye drops were among Similasan’s several eye remedy product choices, which were themselves but one brand in a sea of eye drops, including CVS’s store brand, injected into a row of Similasan. Because I was in a hurry to visit my mother prior to meeting with the care team, I almost grabbed the Similasan box and headed to the checkout. But the words “natural ingredients” on the label set off my skeptical antennae. I picked up both the Similasan and CVS brand eye drops to compare.
And right there, printed on both boxes, was a word I knew well, and not for good reasons: “homeopathic.” I was stunned. In my rush, I had almost bought a homeopathic remedy. And I was angry. What if I had not noticed? What if my mother had used the eye drops, which would have given her no relief from the small misery, among many larger ones she suffers daily, of irritated eyes? What of other consumers, who don’t know any better?
I found, on a shelf just below this plethora of homeopathic eye drops, “conventional” allergy eye drops and made my way to the checkout counter, where I told a very nice young man (Albert, according to my receipt) what I thought of CVS selling homeopathic remedies, displaying them right along real eye drops to boot. He was profoundly apologetic and said I could call 1-800-SHOP-CVS to complain if I wished.
So I did. I will say this for CVS: they must put their complaint department employees through their paces in training them to handle irate consumers. The very nice woman (Jessica) on the phone listened politely while I expounded on homeopathic remedies, including the fact that CVS was well aware they don’t work and the confusion caused when they are sold next to “conventional” versions of the same product. I told her of my concern that my mother might have suffered unnecessarily had I purchased the homeopathic eye drops and that I planned to file complaints with the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services and the Florida Attorney General. She took my name and number in case CVS wanted to “reach out” to me. (They have not.)
What I almost bought
Similasan is a Swiss homeopathic remedy manufacturer. According to the label, Similasan’s allergy eye drops contain,
    • Apis mellifica 6X
    • Euphrasia officinalis (Eyebright) 6X
    • Sabadilla 6X
“Apis mellifica” are honey bees. Yes, honey bees. The other ingredients are plants. [Inactive ingredients: borate buffer, purified water, silver sulfate (preservative), sodium nitrate.]
The meaning of “6X” is not explained. The label says:
Active ingredients are manufactured according to homeopathic principles.
The label also tells consumers:
according to homeopathic principles the active ingredients in this product temporarily relieve minor eye allergy symptoms such as: itching, burning, excessive watering, redness of eyes and lids.
What are these “homeopathic principles?” Similasan’s website tell us:
Similasan products stimulate the body’s natural defenses by utilizing microdilutions of natural active ingredients . . . (originating from minerals, plants or animals) [which] undergo a process of serial dilutions. . . . [A]n ingredient diluted to the level of 6X contains 0.000001% of the active ingredient. This homeopathic mode of action is similar in theory to a conventional allergy or flu shot, yet the natural active ingredients in homeopathic products are much more diluted. . . . Your body’s immune system reacts to the ingredients by triggering the immune system to react to the underlying problem. For example, a microdilution of honey bee will trigger the body to fight symptoms such as burning, stinging and swelling, which are in many cases the symptoms of allergy. . . . In other words, homeopathy encourages the body to maintain proper health by imposing a gentle stimulus, and letting your system do the rest.
“In other words,” pure bunkum. Pseudoscience. Pre-scientific nonsense. Quackery. Fraudulent misrepresentation. Just yesterday, SBM guest blogger Craig D. Pearcey explained why the proposed mechanisms of action for homeopathy are, to use a scientific term, hogwash. [And, no, the proposed mechanism of action is not “similar in theory” to allergy and flu shots.] It’s a topic we’ve covered many times here on SBM.
Given the implausibility of homeopathy itself, it seems superfluous to discuss the ingredients in Similasan’s allergy eye drops. Nevertheless, I could find no evidence that killing and crushing honey bees and diluting them until one bit of bee is left knocking about in one million parts of inert substance is effective for anything other than further decimating their ranks. Their inclusion in homeopathic remedy lore is apparently based on the “like cures like” pseudo-theory:
The very characteristic effects of the sting of the bee furnish unerring indications for its employment in disease. Swelling or puffing up of various parts, EDEMA, red rosy due, stinging pains, soreness, intolerance of heat, and slightest touch, and afternoon worse are some of the general guiding symptoms.
Other indications for use “according to homeopathic principles:”
    • Jealous, fright, rage, vexation, grief
    • Stupor, with sudden sharp cries and startings
    • Awkward; drops things readily
    • Bores head into pillow and screams out
    • Coldness of tip of nose
Euphrasia, or eyebright, is an herb traditionally used for conjunctivitis and other eye inflammation. Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database finds it has “insufficient reliable evidence to rate” for conjunctivitis and “possibly unsafe” for use as an ophthalmic. Of course, when diluted to one part per 1,000,000 “according to homeopathic principles,” the evidence dissipates accordingly.
The sabadilla lily is a poisonous plant formerly used as a pesticide and for lice. The risk of fatality, however, is no bar to homeopaths. According to the National Center for Homeopathy, among sabadilla’s “provers” is none other than the father of homeopathy himself, 18th century physician Samuel Hahnemann. The Center’s poetic description of symptoms indicating one part sabadilla to 1,000,000 parts water is just what the doctor ordered include:
    • As if abdomen were shrunken, were empty.
    • Croaking as of frogs in the abdomen.
    • As if stomach were gnawed.
    • As of a thread or string in throat.
    • As if articulation were suspended.
    • As if tape prevented circulation in chest.
    • As if interior of bones were scraped out with a sharp knife.
    • As if hot breath came out of his mouth and nose.
    • As if everything were in motion.
    • As if the air itself were in tremulous motion.
    • As if he had taken wine.
    • Shaking as if in a severe chill.
CVS’s own brand of homeopathic “irritated eye drops” are not listed on the company’s website. I called CVS and was assured that they had not been discontinued. In fact, the company rep told me there were six bottles in stock at the very CVS where I had my unfortunate encounter with their product. According to the label, CVS’s “irritated eye drops” are “safe and effective” at “relieving redness, watery discharge, burning, grittiness, dryness & stinging.” They contain:
    • Belladonna 6X
    • Euphrasia 6X
    • Helpar sulphuris 12X
Belladonna, a toxic substance, is the same ingredient that caused the FDA to warn against using homeopathic teething remedies. Helpar sulphuris, diluted to 1 part per 1,000,000,000,000, is,
the inner layer of Oyster shells combined with flowers of sulfur and burned.
According to “homeopathic principles,” helper suphuris, among other things,
suits especially scrofulous and lymphatic constitutions who are inclined to have eruptions and glandular swellings. Unhealthy skin. Blondes with sluggish character and weak muscles.
What I’m doing about it
Science Babe generated some bad PR for CVS when she downed a 50-pill bottle of Hyland’s Calms Forte in a social media campaign to get the retail pharmacy giant and other retailers to stop selling worthless homeopathic remedies. CVS shrugged that effort off by essentially saying “everyone’s doing it” and “it’s legal.” (Fortunately, this sort of lame excuse did not prevent CVS from halting cigarette sales a few years ago in a much-lauded decision.)
True to my word, I’ve filed a complaint with the FTC and the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumers Services against CVS and Similasan. I am in the process of filing a complaint with the Florida Attorney General.
Under federal law, deceptive labeling of OTC drugs is illegal. According to the FTC,
companies must have a reasonable basis for making objective product claims, including claims that a product can treat specific conditions.
The FTC announced just a few months ago that it will hold homeopathic remedy advertising claims to the same standards as similar claims for conventional OTC drugs. (The Society for Science-Based Medicine was pleased to see its comment to the FTC on homeopathic remedy regulation mentioned in the staff report leading to the FTC’s decision.) This means claims of effectiveness, including claims that a product can treat symptoms, must be backed by “competent and reliable scientific evidence,” usually “well-designed human clinical testing.”
The FTC’s enforcement policy states:
For the vast majority of OTC homeopathic drugs, the case for efficacy is based solely on traditional homeopathic theories and there are no valid studies using current scientific methods showing the product’s efficacy. Accordingly, marketing claims that such homeopathic products have a therapeutic effect lack a reasonable basis and are likely misleading in violation of . . . the FTC Act.
If there is no competent and reliable scientific evidence supporting a product’s claims, the FTC won’t automatically consider the labeling deceptive if the company plainly states there is no scientific evidence that the product works and that the claims are based on theories from the 1700s that are not accepted by medical experts.
In my view, neither the Similasan nor CVS brand eye drops meet the FTC’s test and are therefore deceptive. There is no competent and reliable scientific evidence supporting their claims, but consumers aren’t told this. There is no explanation that “homeopathic principles” are bogus. There is no explanation of what “6X” or “12X” means. In my opinion, they are being marketed in violation of federal law.
Under Florida law, the Attorney General can bring a declaratory judgment action against, and seek to enjoin, a company from engaging in unfair and deceptive trade practices and seek a fine of up to $10,000 per violation. Because I did not actually rely on their false claims and purchase the products, I could not bring an individual action for deceptive and unfair trade practices based on state law. That does not prevent me from filing a complaint asking the Attorney General to take action. Under Florida law, interpretations of the FTC Act by the courts and the FTC itself are given great weight. Hence, I anticipate that the FTC’s new policy on homeopathic remedy marketing will be followed by the Attorney General.
I look forward to working with these agencies in pursuing state and federal law claims against Similasan and CVS.
And another thing
CVS and Similasan shouldn’t be scamming consumers with nonsensical remedies. But they had plenty of help stocking the shelves with their worthless products:
    • Congress, in dumping the entire Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the U.S. into the federal Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act of 1938.
    • The FDA, with its virtually non-existent regulation of homeopathic products.
    • A whole host of proponents who wield their MD degrees in the battle against the rational application of the scientific method to the practice of medicine: Wayne Jonas, David Katz, Iris Bell, Peter Fisher, and others who advocate the junk science of homeopathy.
    • The institutions that give homeopathy an undeserved patina of legitimacy by promoting its use, or sheltering physicians who do, The Cleveland Clinic, the University of Arizona, the University of Florida/Shands Hospital, Yale.
Without the support of Congress, the inertia of the FDA, and enthusiasm from certain quarters of the mainstream medical community, homeopathy would be relegated to the backwaters of naturopathic quackery and fringe MDs who practice homeopathy, or illegal even, instead of a multi-billion dollar industry.
I’ll end where I began: my mother has terminal cancer. She is on oxygen 24/7. She breathes with difficulty, sometimes great difficulty. Her body swells with fluid retention. She cannot walk without assistance and, even then, it exhausts her. She is nauseated. She has lost her appetite. And she has dry, red, itchy eyes. There are other discomforts, but I’ll stop there.
We – her family, Hospice, the nursing and other staff, her physicians – are doing all we can to relieve those symptoms, to keep her as comfortable as possible. At this point, it’s all we can do. But CVS and Similasan, and all those who support homeopathy, think it’s perfectly OK to deprive her one small comfort: relieving her troublesome eye symptoms. When I tried to help her, they wanted to scam me by selling me their worthless products, which are craftily displayed right alongside real remedies. They would prefer that we drop crushed honey bees and belladonna in her eyes. Shame on them. Shame on all of you who promote homeopathy.

It’s time for pharmacies to stop selling sugar pills
Why are pharmacies selling sugar pills to consumers that are packaged like medicine? And what will it take for pharmacies to stop?
Scott Gavura on July 16, 2015
Link


Retail pharmacies have a sugar pill problem. Homeopathic “remedies” may look like conventional medicine when they’re stocked on pharmacy shelves, like the photo above. But unlike conventional medicine, homeopathic products don’t contain any “medicine” at all. They are effectively sugar pills – placebos. Not surprisingly, there is convincing evidence to show that homeopathy is useless as a medical treatment, and fundamentally incompatible with a scientific understanding of medicine, biochemistry and even physics. Questions have been raised about the ethics of selling homeopathy in pharmacies to consumers who may not realize what they’re buying. This growing practice is attracting sharp criticism from other health professions. So why do pharmacies sell them? And what will it take for pharmacies to change?
Homeopathy is not herbalism
To understand why homeopathy has no place in a pharmacy, it’s essential to understand how homeopathy differs from other forms of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM). Homeopathy is often misunderstood as a natural remedy, akin to a type of herbalism. The marketing and labeling of these “remedies” encourages this perception, often describing homeopathy as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing, and putting cryptic terms like “30C” beside long Latin names of what appears to be the active ingredients. In reality, there is little likelihood that a homeopathic remedy contains even a single molecule of any listed ingredient. So while there may be hundreds of homeopathic remedies in a pharmacy, they are chemically indistinguishable, usually containing just sugar and water. The result is a growing assortment of placebos on store shelves, alongside medicines and even supplements that actually contain active ingredients. Homeopathy was invented out of whole cloth in 1796 by Samuel Hahnemann, a German physician. He described the practice as guided by two key principles, which he called “laws”:
     1.  The “Law” of Similars – Hahnemann believed substances that produce specific symptoms in healthy people will cure those same symptoms in an ill person. Sometimes referred to as “like cures like”, the law of similars is simply a form of magical thinking. Homeopathic “remedies” can be made with natural ingredients like salt or onions, but also substances like shipwrecks, light bulbs, the Berlin Wall and even vacuum cleaner dust or moonlight. When infectious material is used, the remedy is called a “nosode” and homeopaths believe that these products can cure or prevent infections. Deciding which substances will cure which symptoms is determined by a process called a “proving” which is entirely without any scientific basis. (Here are homeopath provings for the Berlin Wall remedy and also sunlight reflected off the planet Saturn, as examples of a typical “proving”).
     2.  The “Law” of Infinitesimals – Hahnemann believed that the effectiveness of a remedy increases the more that remedy was diluted. He advocated a series of sequential dilutions with shaking (succussion) after each dilution, believing that the water would “remember” its contact with the original substance. According to Hahnemann’s theories, when sufficient water has been added to dilute the original substance away so that zero molecules remain, the “remedy” was thought to be at its most powerful. Imagine putting one drop of a substance into a container of water. Only that container is 131 light-years in diameter. That’s equivalent to the “30C” dilution that is popular with homeopaths. You’d have to eat a tablet of sugar the size of the Earth to get a single molecule of the original substance.
Homeopathy and science are mutually exclusive
It goes without saying that if homeopathy works in the way envisioned by Hahnemann and homeopaths, than the rest of medicine cannot. And that’s exactly what the evidence shows. As would be expected with inert products, rigorous clinical trials confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. The two most comprehensive reviews of the evidence are the 2010 Evidence Check from the United Kingdom’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee and the 2014 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council review, which reached the following conclusion:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness. People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner and should keep taking any prescribed treatments. The National Health and Medical Research Council expects that the Australian public will be offered treatments and therapies based on the best available evidence.
Emphasis added.
Pharmacists should know better
Pharmacists are the health professionals with specialized training in pharmacology, and an education that concentrates on drug design, delivery and understanding how to use medicines effectively and safely. If any health professional should recognize the logical and scientific leaps that homeopathy necessitates, it should be pharmacists. Regrettably, there seems to be relatively few pharmacies that have made the deliberate decision not to sell homeopathic remedies. So that’s why it’s so heartening to see this recent commentary, from Australian pharmacist Ian Carr, who will not sell homeopathy in his pharmacy:
Fellow pharmacists, it is time to rid our shelves of these shonky products. Every time a consumer is able to pluck their chosen homeopathic drops from your shelf, you have given credence to quackery. You have increased the possibility that your patient’s next call might be to a homeopath, rather than a GP. You have helped confuse the market about what “natural” medicine might be. Perhaps your patient will decide that a homeopathic nosode will more safely protect the family from whooping cough than a real vaccine. Though no direct harm will come from imbibing from a magic bottle of pure water, there is the danger that proven treatment will be ignored, refused or delayed unnecessarily.
Poor thinking about health will lead to poor health decisions.
Many who choose a homeopathic remedy from the shelves may be totally unaware of its scientific implausibility. Your pharmacy should be ensuring patients are given clear and reasoned counselling, and in doing so, helping them avoid a lifetime of confused and deluded thinking about health.
In another column, Carr argued that staff (employee) pharmacists are just as responsible as pharmacy owners for deciding what’s on store shelves:
As an independent pharmacist proprietor, I do not stock homeopathic medicines, diet pills or ear candles. I am free to recommend therapies where I am convinced of an evidence base. However, were I an employee pharmacist in a discount chain, would I have the same opportunity to exercise my professional discretion and conscience? Or would I be encouraged to companion sell and recommend the chain’s favoured brands? Could I tell the truth and expect to keep my job?
An answer might lie in the recent newsletter from the Pharmacy Board of Australia, which warns: “Action by non-pharmacists (such as managerial staff) which impinges on the ability of pharmacists to meet their legal and ethical responsibilities may be subject to action under the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law”.
Another category of pharmacist which allows for the profusion of nonsense products is the uninvolved pharmacist, who sees no need to interfere with what goes on in the front of shop. Staff training is handed over to any company that offers it, with no oversight of quality or ethics. Given the multimillion dollar advertising by vitamin and supplement companies, the exponential growth of complementary and alternative medicines and folk cures, and the extreme level of science and health illiteracy in the populace, this laissez faire approach is not acceptable.
Pharmacists are well placed to be at the forefront of science-based medicine, trained and ready to counsel, explain and teach our clients, and help give them informed control of their health.
Another profession weighs in
The growing pressure on pharmacies to stop selling homeopathy is coming from other health professionals, too. The president of the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP), Frank R. Jones, recently criticized pharmacies for selling homeopathy, linking the profession’s decision to sell homeopathy with the simultaneous desire to play a bigger role in the health care system:
“We would certainly encourage our pharmacy colleagues to really critically look at what they are selling at their chemists (pharmacies),” he said. “I think they are very, very conflicted and I think really if they are on board with the rest of the medical community, they have to practise evidence-based medicine.”
This follows the RACGP’s formal recommendation [PDF] that general practitioners (family doctors) stop prescribing homeopathic remedies, and that pharmacist stop stocking these products:
The RACGP supports the use of evidence-based medicine, in which current research information is used as the basis for clinical decision-making. In light of strong evidence to confirm that homeopathy has no effect beyond that of placebo as a treatment for various clinical conditions, the position of the RACGP is:
     1.  Medical practitioners should not practice homeopathy, refer patients to homeopathic practitioners, or recommend homeopathic products to their patients.
     2.  Pharmacists should not sell, recommend, or support the use of homeopathic products.
     3.  Homeopathic alternatives should not be used in place of conventional immunisation.
     4.  Private health insurers should not supply rebates for or otherwise support homeopathic services or products.
It’s not just Australia. In the United Kingdom, the Chief Scientist of the Royal Pharmaceutical Society had given similar advice:
Is homeopathy’s popularity due to a distrust of modern medicines as has been recently suggested by the Chief Medical Officer for England who has just called for an independent review of the safety and efficacy of medicines? Or it is that patients are worried about the side effects associated with medicines, preferring what they perceive to be a safer approach; after all homeopathic preparations have not unsurprisingly no known toxic effects in over 200 years of use? Whatever the reason, as an evidence-based profession, why do we continue to sell homeopathic preparations in our pharmacies when the evidence shows that they do not work?
The public have a right to expect pharmacists and other health professionals to be open and honest about the effectiveness and limitations of treatments. Surely it is now the time for pharmacists to cast homeopathy from the shelves and focus on scientifically based treatments backed by clear clinical evidence.
Pharmacies can put customer health ahead of profits
There’s a precedent for pharmacies voluntarily ceasing sales of products. Most pharmacies worldwide have quit the tobacco habit, recognizing that tobacco isn’t compatible with health care. In the United States, CVS became the first national drug store to stop selling tobacco, as it changed its name to CVS Health with a bold plan to distinguish itself from its pharmacy competitors. In doing so it walked away from $2 billion in sales. Last week it even quit the US Chamber of Commerce over its stance on tobacco sales. The move has been well received and the action has been highlighted as a factor in continued expansion into what is now the largest health care organization in North America. Homeopathy isn’t tobacco, but its sale in pharmacies is raising the same questions about the profession’s intent. With pharmacists stating they want an expanded role in health care, will they confront the professional and ethical challenges that homeopathy presents?
Homeopathy is unethical
Ethical codes for the pharmacy profession will vary by region, but most of the ones that I have reviewed make it clear that patient’s interests are central to the pharmacist’s role, and that pharmacists must provide evidence-based information to support informed decision making. Selling sugar pills on pharmacy shelves alongside real medicine, without any explanation, could give patients the impression that homeopathy is effective. I’ve argued at length that the sale in pharmacies give homeopathy the perception of scientific legitimacy, and that this approach is fundamentally unethical. Selling placebos alongside medicine violates patient autonomy, reflecting a form of medical paternalism (or perhaps crass commercialism) that retail pharmacists need to eliminate if they want to be truly accepted as partners in the health care team. Homeopathy illustrates, with perhaps the most clarity, why selling unproven or ineffective treatments is incompatible with ethical practice. This statement from Mark Crislip sums it up nicely:
This is the paradox of alternative medicine; by understanding, we render the treatment ineffective. Yet by concealing medical knowledge, we return to a dangerous, medieval-like approach to healthcare. It is for this reason why alternative medicine is flawed. As tempting as it might be to embrace placebo-based treatments, the ethical standards we would have to sacrifice are infinitely more valuable.
A pharmacist’s defence of homeopathy
Harriet Hall’s Skepdoc Rule of Thumb states that when encountering a new or questionable claim, always try to find out who disagrees and why. Why do pharmacists defend homeopathy? Via Edzard Ernst, I found this interview with Christophe Merville, the “head pharmacist” at Boiron, one of the largest homeopathic manufacturers (if that’s the right term) in the world. Here are some of his arguments in support of homeopathy:
I remember attending the delivery of a woman and the contractions were very strong, and painful. She had some homeopathic medicine to take just at that time to make those contractions more regular and useful: less intense but longer and less brusque. I saw that happening within minutes, and I was thinking, “That’s very impressive.” That’s probably the time when I concluded that there is something to it. I witnessed the action of homeopathic medicines on pets also, on young children. I had enough personal anecdotes that I could say there is something more than just suggestion, or placebo, or just the simple act of being cared for. My attitude is to say, “There are enough signs to say that it’s really worth exploring more why it works, how it works, when does it work.” We are past the stage where we can say, “No, there is nothing.” It has been around for a long time and if was just mere placebo effect, it would have gone away, as so many different techniques did.
His explanation for how homeopathy works is equally muddled:
The main argument against homeopathy is that a remedy is very, very diluted, so it cannot work. My reaction to that is to examine what happens when you dilute something. The act of dilution is not very simple. Those molecules are interacting together, they are interacting with the walls of the container, they are interacting with the solvent, and this interaction does not adhere to a precise mathematical law. The skeptics say, “You divide the number of molecules by 100 each time, so after awhile, [sic] there is less than one chance to find one single molecule.” They have their math right, but they have their physics wrong.
Chemists try to use very pure substances. When you buy your reagent, you buy it at 99.999 percent pure. But you don’t have anything that’s 100 percent pure. It would take an infinite amount of energy to get rid of the last impurity. What I think we should explore is the fact that after a certain number of dilutions, the process is not very efficient at removing the last molecules. So there is always something that stays. That’s one thing. The second thing is in pharmacology for years, we were interested in the ability of large quantities of substances. But what about small ones? I always use the example of butterflies that can sense pheromones at great distances, salmon finding their way back to their native creek from far away, to sharks being able to detect blood in a huge amount of water. Biology uses very small quantities. In cells, you have communication between cells using a few molecules of a certain substance—and it works.
I don’t pretend that I’ve put A and B and C together, and I’m able to provide you with a complete explanation. But I would say those are things to explore.Already the research that exists points to possible action of homeopathic dilution on activation or deactivation of genes. I won’t go into details, but I welcome the skepticism, I think it’s very constructive. But what I don’t really like is people whose mind is set on their misconception of what exactly a dilution is. Of course homeopathy doesn’t violate the laws of physics and chemistry, because that’s absurd.
These are just excerpts of an extended interview and I encourage you to read the entire text to appreciate the arguments that Merville is making. To his credit, Merville is clear that homeopathy doesn’t replace medicine like vaccines, nor can it cure cancer or diabetes. However his basis for concluding that homeopathy is effective seems grounded entirely in anecdotes and his own observations, neglecting to consider how easy it is to fool ourselves. The Australian review I mentioned above considered this specific argument in its review, and gave a good explanation as to why we must look at the totality of the highest quality evidence, rather than trust anecdotes or personal experiences:
It is not possible to tell whether a health treatment is effective or not simply by considering individuals’ experiences or healthcare practitioners’ beliefs. One reason personal testimonials are not reliable is that people may experience health benefits because they believe that a treatment is effective. This is known as the ‘placebo effect’. Another reason is that healthcare practitioners cannot always tell whether changes in a person’s health condition are due to the treatment or some other reason. For these reasons, medicines must be tested in a planned, structured scientific research project designed to prevent these kinds of experiences giving the false impression that a medicine is more or less effective than it really is.
And importantly, why we cannot cherry pick individual trials that may suggest positive results:
Even where researchers take care to design studies in a way that minimises bias, there is a chance that the results will show a statistically significant difference in favour of a treatment, when there is actually no effect. Therefore, the results of individual studies need to be repeated in other independent studies, to make sure the effects seen were not just due to chance. The most reliable information comes from research that combines the results of all available similar studies and analyses the results together (systematic reviews).
Freedom to choose?
As an advocate for removing homeopathy from pharmacies, I’ve been accused by homeopathy advocates (both pharmacist and non-pharmacist) of wanting to limit “freedom of choice”, either the freedom to sell a legally approved product, or the freedom to buy legally approved products from pharmacy retailers. The case for not selling homeopathy in pharmacies seems pretty clear: pharmacists need to put patient interests above the desire to sell inert products that look like medicine and may confuse patients. Ending pharmacy sales does not ban homeopathy, nor will it stop the sale of homeopathy in the market. This is simply a call for pharmacies to cease selling the products. Homeopathic “remedies”, as long as they’re legally permitted for sale, can be sold elsewhere, just like tobacco remains for sale outside pharmacies. Pulling these products out of pharmacies will send a strong signal to patients and other health professionals that (1) Homeopathy has no medicinal value (2) Pharmacies and pharmacists see homeopathy as incompatible with science-based, evidence-based health care.
Putting patients first
Community or retail pharmacy is a unique mix of health care delivery within a private, for-profit retailer. Yet pharmacies have a specific, designated role in the health care system. For that reason, pharmacies can and should to do more than what we might expect from another retailer. The comic XKCD said it best in a comic on “alternative literature” that is captioned with a quote about today’s pharmacy practice:
I just noticed CVS has started stocking homeopathic pills on the same shelves with–and labeled similarly to–their actual medicine. Telling someone who trusts you that you’re giving them medicine, when you know you’re not, because you want their money, isn’t just lying–it’s like an example you’d make up if you had to illustrate for a child why lying is wrong.
Pharmacists ought to know better, and they ought to do better. It’s time for the profession to act in the interests of patients. Homeopathy has no place in today’s pharmacy practice.

Should physicians and managed care organizations offer homeopathy?
David Gorski on July 20, 2015
Link

Anyone who reads Science-Based Medicine on even a semi-regular basis will know our collective opinion of homeopathy. Basically, at its core, homeopathy is pure quackery.
I don’t care if it’s repetitive to say this yet again because it can’t be emphasized enough times that homeopathy is The One Quackery To Rule Them All. OK, there are others that compete for that title, such as reiki and other magical “energy therapies” like therapeutic touch, both of which, unfortunately, can be found in many academic medical centers where the faculty really should know better. Any “medicine” whose very precepts break multiple laws of physics and chemistry, laws that would have to be proven not just wrong but spectacularly wrong for homeopathy to work, deserves only ridicule.
The “laws” of homeopathy
Think of it this way. There are two “laws” of homeopathy, neither of which has any basis in reality. First, there is the law that states “like cures like” and asserts that, to relieve a symptom, you need to use a substance that causes that same symptom in healthy adults. There is, of course, no evidence that this is a general principle of medicine. For instance, we don’t generally treat fever by administering something that causes fever or treat vomiting with something that causes vomiting. The second law, however, is the one that’s completely ridiculous. Basically, it’s the law of infinitesimals. This law states that a homeopathic remedy is made stronger with dilution, specifically serial dilutions with vigorous shaking between each dilution step to “potentize” the remedy. That’s ridiculous enough, but homeopaths, never satisfied with the merely ridiculous have to turn the ridiculous up to 11 and beyond by using this principle to assert that dilutions far beyond the point where there is likely even to be a single molecule of the original remedy left are effective and become more so with more dilution. For instance, a 30C dilution is 30 one hundred-fold dilutions (C=100, get it?), or a 1060 dilution. Avogadro’s number is only on the order of 6 x 1023, or more than 1036-fold less than the dilution. The simple mathematics of homeopathy just doesn’t work, although this doesn’t stop homeopaths from coming up with some truly spectacular flights of pseudoscience (like the “memory of water”) to try to “explain” how it can work.
The persistence of homeopathy
Even though homeopathy was “discovered” over 200 years ago by Samuel Hahnemann, back in a time before Avogadro’s number had been determined, for some reason it has managed to live on into the 21st century. It was, in a way, understandable that homeopathy might persist throughout the 19th century. After all, homeopathy does nothing other than placebo. If, as was the case for all too many then “conventional” treatments 200 years ago, a treatment is worse than the disease, then of course homeopathy would produce better outcomes because doing nothing is better than, for example, bloodletting, purging using toxic heavy metals such as mercury and cadmium, and all the other things which were “standard of care” for various conditions at the dawn of the 19th century. It wasn’t quite as bad as Theodoric of York, but it was pretty bad. Remember, ether anesthesia wasn’t even discovered until roughly 50 years after Hahnemann first “discovered” homeopathy, and full acceptance of the germ theory of infectious disease was 70 years after Hahnemann’s discovery. Even so, as early as the 1840s, Oliver Wendell Holmes knew homeopathy was quackery, as his famous broadside against it demonstrated so well. Still, as useless and ridiculous as homeopathy has always been, it wasn’t until medicine started to become much more science-based and therefore effective that outcomes could clearly be shown to be better with modern scientific treatment.
The riddle of homeopathy
So why do we keep coming back to the topic of homeopathy again and again? If homeopathy is, as I like to refer to it, nothing more than the ancient concepts of sympathetic magic tarted up for a 19th century audience and then updated by generations of homeopaths to invoke pseudoscience such as the “memory of water” to “explain it,” why do we keep hearing about it? After all, homeopathy is so scientifically discredited that the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH, formerly known as the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, or NCCAM) hasn’t funded a grant to study it since 2008. Why is it that Prince Charles is such an advocate of homeopathy? Why is it that academic medical centers are embracing naturopathy, which, as I’ve described before, includes homeopathy as one of its core medical practices?
These were the questions in my mind as I came across two articles. The first published in a prestigious medical journal, the BMJ, in a “point-counterpoint” format asking the question, “Should doctors recommend homeopathy?” Steve Novella already covered this when it came out last week, but I want to look at it as well, particularly since fellow SBM blogger Mark Crislip made me aware of similar article in the journal Managed Care arguing that “Homeopathic Medicine Should Have a Role in Managed Care.” Yes, despite being no more than magic, homeopathy manages to attract educated people who actually think it should be included in the armamentarium of science-based medicine and even that it’s appropriate to include it in managed care.
Let’s look at the BMJ first.
False balance over homeopathy in the BMJ
There is no good reason for a reputable scientific journal to publish research about homeopathy, and certainly there is no reason to publish a “debate” about homeopathy, any more than there is a reason to publish a debate over whether creationism (intelligent design or young earth) has validity compared to evolution. Unfortunately, that’s exactly what a prestigious medical journal, BMJ, did last week, asking “Should doctors recommend homeopathy?” On the “yes” side there was Peter Fisher, director of research, Royal London Hospital for Integrated Medicine. Note that “integrated medicine” seems to be a British variant of “integrative medicine,” the oft-criticized (on this blog at least) practice of integrating quackery with real medicine. Note also that the Royal London Hospital for Integrated Medicine used to be the Royal London Homeopathic Hospital before being rebranded as a more inclusive quack hospital. Indeed, the last time I was in London (alas, eight years ago!), I made it a point to have my picture taken in front of its sign. In any case, Fisher is a homeopath, and a rather famous one at that.
On the “no” side, there was Edzard Ernst. I have no idea why Ernst agreed to this and wish he hadn’t. Notably, Ernst now expresses some regret over having chosen to participate but justifies his decision by noting that if he had refused another would have been chosen and “sure as hell, that person would subsequently gotten attacked for not ever having researched and/or practiced homeopathy”. (Ernst used to practice homeopathy himself before he realized it was quackery.) In any case, Ernst’s debating a homeopath was not unlike an evolutionary biologist debating a young earth creationist. There was no point, and all it did was to elevate the stature of the crank by association. In fact, it was even more like a creationist debate than you might think in that Fisher proved himself adept at doing the old Gish Gallop.
Hilariously, this is how Fisher chose to begin:
Of all the major forms of complementary medicine, homeopathy is the most misunderstood. Based on the concept of “treating like with like,” homeopathy originated with the German physician Samuel Hahnemann (1755-1843). But similar ideas are found in the Hippocratic Corpus, in the work of Paracelsus, and in the medical traditions of several Asian countries.
Homeopathy is part of a family of toxicological and pharmacological phenomena that are attracting growing interest, characterised by secondary, reverse, or paradoxical reactions to drugs or toxins as a function of dose or time or both. These include hormesis (the paradoxical, stimulatory, or beneficial effect of low doses of toxins), paradoxical pharmacology, and rebound effects.
The controversial element of homeopathy is that some medicines are highly dilute, including “ultra-molecular” dilutions, in which it is highly unlikely that any of the original material is present. This is a major scientific concern and the source of the view that homeopathy “doesn’t work because it can’t work.”
Of course, the problem with homeopathy is not that it is misunderstood. The problem with homeopathy, for homeopaths at least, is that it is understood all too well by scientists who have looked into it and become its critics, and that understanding is that it is quackery. The real problem with homeopathy being misunderstood is that most of the lay public and even most doctors don’t know its true principles and view it as nothing more than another form of herbal medicine.
Even though Fisher correctly pointed out the central problem with homeopathy, notice how he rebranded it in terms favored by homeopaths. Whenever you see “ultra-molecular dilutions” used as a term, it’s an almost certain bet that you are dealing with a homeopath. The term sounds all science-y and important, but it is utterly meaningless. Notice how he also attacks a straw man. Yes, we skeptics do say that homeopathy can’t work, because for homeopathy to work, our understanding of some long-established bedrock principles of chemistry and physics would have to be not just wrong but spectacularly wrong. But that’s not the only reason why we say homeopathy doesn’t work. We also look at the clinical evidence, which, when aggregated, is most consistent with the effects of homeopathy being nothing more than placebo effects. That’s not surprising, given that homeopathy can’t work, but in this case the science and the clinical observations we have both agree: Homeopathy doesn’t work.
The usual Gish Gallop, just not for creationism
Fisher also trotted out a veritable Gish gallop’s worth of homeopathy tropes, many of which I’ve written about here before, as well as on my not-so-secret other blog. Similar ideas are found in Hippocratic writings? So what? Hippocrates’s followers also believed that illness was caused by imbalances in the four humors. Yes, Hippocrates and those who followed made some significant contributions to medicine, not the least of which was the idea that diseases were natural and not caused by gods and evil spirits, but what they taught was based on prescientific beliefs about biology and physiology. Paracelsus, too, made great contributions to medicine, basically inventing the field of toxicology, but he was also an alchemist, astrologer, and occultist. In fact, it is true that the ideas of homeopathy do resemble those of various ancients. Unfortunately for homeopaths the ancient ideas that homeopathy most resembles come from sympathetic magic, namely Frazer’s Law of Similarity (“like cures like”) and the Law of Contagion or “contagious magic” (the memory of water).
Fisher also invoked the usual nonsense about hormesis and paradoxical drug effects. Repeat after me: Hormesis does not justify homeopathy. It’s an analogy that homeopaths love because it’s a hypothesis that states that some substances that are toxic at high doses might be benign or even beneficial at lower doses. That hormesis has anything to do with homeopathy is, of course, wishful thinking on the part of homeopaths, representing extreme over-extrapolation. Hormesis might apply to low doses, but much of homeopathy involves no dose; i.e., dilution far, far beyond the point where it is highly unlikely that even a single molecule of the original remedy remains. Not that this stopped Fisher:
However, recent in vitro research shows repeatable effects (for instance, inhibition of basophil degranulation by highly dilute histamine1) while basic physical research shows that the homeopathic manufacturing process changes the structure of the diluent, including the formation of nanoparticles of silica and gas.2 The physical research is of little clinical relevance but provides a possible mechanism of action for the controversial high dilutions.
He was referring to Jacques Benveniste’s study, which he claimed to have found evidence for the “memory of water.” Basically, Benveniste diluted allergens down to homeopathic dilutions and showed that they could trigger basophils to activate. The then editor of Nature, Sir John Maddox, agreed to publish Benveniste’s paper—but only on one condition. Benveniste was required to open his laboratory to a team of independent referees, who would observe and evaluate his techniques. Among that team was James Randi. Indeed, the Benveniste affair was, from my perspective, one of Randi’s greatest achievements in skepticism. Basically, Randi and the team of referees asked Benveniste to repeat the experiment, but went to extraordinary lengths to make sure that the people carrying out the experiments didn’t know what groups were the control groups and which groups were the ultradilute samples. Under these conditions, Benveniste’s results were not replicable. Basically, Randi showed how critical proper blinding was to experiments involving homeopathy. Indeed, this is a lesson that anyone doing lab work could take to heart, because blinding is actually uncommon in basic lab research for most experiments.
As for the bit on “nanoparticles,” that’s just the latest pseudoscientific “explanation” for homeopathy. It’s one particularly favored by a rather vocal proponent of homeopathy whom we’ve met many times before before, Dana Ullman. It’s nonsense, of course, just like every “explanation” of homeopathy other than that it “works” solely through placebo effects.
It also turns out that Fisher expressed—surprise, surprise!—great unhappiness with some systemic reviews and meta-analyses of homeopathy that show it to have no specific effects above and beyond placebo effects, as one would expect given what homeopathy is. As is usual for homeopaths, he attacks the 2005 Lancet meta-analysis by Shang et al, but worse, he misrepresents its findings. Contrary to Fisher’s characterization of the meta-analysis, Shang et al did not find that there was “weak evidence for a specific effect of homeopathic remedies.” That’s a cherry-picked quote. Actually, Shang et al concluded quite the opposite:
We acknowledge that to prove a negative is impossible, but we have shown that the effects seen in placebo controlled trials of homoeopathy are compatible with the placebo hypothesis. By contrast, with identical methods, we found that the benefits of conventional medicine are unlikely to be explained by unspecific effects.
Then, as homeopaths are wont to do, Fisher picks crappy or old meta-analyses. Incredibly, this leads to a discussion of comparative effectiveness research involving homeopathy! Here’s a hint: Doing comparative effectiveness research is only appropriate to compare the effectiveness of treatments already shown in clinical trials to be efficacious. Such is not the case for homeopathy. One study he cites is an old study looking at comparing homeopathy to conventional therapy for a self-limited condition. It’s not randomized (of course), and the two groups (conventional treatment and homeopathy) are ridiculously poorly matched in terms of age and location. Sure, they had, as an aggregate, well-matched health scores, but demographically the groups are so different as to be uncomparable, making the study basically uninterpretable. Other studies referenced are all basically unrandomized and relied heavily on interviews, with the possibility of recall bias. Indeed, what the two studies suggest is not so much that homeopathy works rather than that general practitioners tend to overprescribe antibiotics for upper respiratory infections and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs for musculoskeletal pain.
All of this leads Fisher to conclude:
Doctors should put aside bias based on the alleged implausibility of homeopathy. When integrated with standard care homeopathy is safe, popular with patients, improves clinical outcomes without increasing costs, and reduces the use of potentially hazardous drugs, including antimicrobials.
Finally, contrary to Fisher’s plea to ignore the inconvenient science that shows how ridiculously implausible homeopathy is, doctors should most definitely not put aside “bias” regarding its implausibility because homeopathy has plausibility that is as close to zero as it is possible to get. In other words, Fisher doesn’t think that “plausibility bias“—or, as Mark Crislip and I like to call it sometimes, “reality bias“—is a good thing. Indeed, the only reason I don’t give homeopathy zero plausibility is more philosophical than anything else. I always leave open the possibility, however small, that maybe several laws of physics are not just wrong, but spectacularly wrong. Whether that is being too “open minded” or not, I leave to the reader. In practice, the difference is negligible, undetectable even. Using Bayesian methods, which take into account the plausibility (or lack thereof) of the remedy being tested, equivocal tiny “results” plus extreme implausibility of the method equal negative results. Basically, in clinical trials of homeopathy what is being observed is statistical noise and publication bias.
I don’t feel a need to go over Edzard Ernst’s response. It’s just Edzard Ernst doing what Edzard Ernst does best and, of course, mentioning some of the dangerous things homeopaths recommend, such as homeopathy for Ebola. I encourage you to read it. What I do feel obligated to do is to ask once again what the hell the editors of BMJ were thinking when they decided to publish this “point-counterpoint” in their journal, which is nothing but false balance?
Homeopathy and managed care
The second article I became aware of was actually published late last year, but it is worth noting because it features a faculty from a school of pharmacy (!) arguing for the inclusion of homeopathic remedies in the formularies of managed care plans. Of course, part of the problem here is that one author, Albert I. Wertheimer, is more of an business expert and economist, a professor of pharmacoeconomics. In other words, he is clearly not a scientist. Neither is his co-author, Frances A. Brentson, who lists herself on LinkedIn as a “talented and disciplined senior-level medical communications professional with over 17 years’ experience delivering high-quality medical writing and project management.” This lack of rigorous science really shows in Wertheimer and Brentson’s arguments.
A lot of what they wrote overlaps with Fisher’s defense of homeopathy, so I’ll emphasize what Fisher didn’t already cover. In their introduction, they lamented that the “formularies of nearly all managed care organizations (MCOs) and pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) share the near-total absence of homeopathic drugs,” to which I reply: You say that as though it were a bad thing! MCOs and PBMs should stick with medicine that has strong scientific evidence backing its safety and efficacy, not magic, after all.
What most struck me about Wertheimer and Bentson’s arguments is that they get a lot about the history of homeopathy and the evidence (or rather lack of evidence) for its efficacy right but nonetheless come to exactly the wrong conclusion about it. For instance, they point out the origin of homeopathy in the late 18th century, its two main laws, how Hahnemann and his assistants recorded and compiled their homeopathic “provings” (although they don’t use the word) in the Materia Medica. They correctly note that in the US, homeopathic remedies are regulated by the FDA under the Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS), but “robust clinical testing is not a requirement for marketing approval.” (That’s an understatement!) Of course, they neglect to note how the HPUS was inserted into the 1938 Food, Drugs and Cosmetics Act by Senator Royal Copeland, a physician who practiced homeopathy, for unclear reasons. In any case, it’s correct that, if it’s in the HPUS, it can be sold in the US. Unfortunately, the process for deciding what is in the HPUS is controlled by the Homeopathic Pharmacopoeia Convention of the United States (HPCUS). It is a process that is—shall we say?—less than transparent. Fortunately, recently the FDA has held hearings on whether it should change how it regulates homeopathic remedies. In fairness, the FDA hearing took place months after this paper was published, but I can’t help but note that the representatives of the homeopathy industry made a poor showing.
Part of the problem is that this entire article keeps tending to conflate homeopathy with “complementary and alternative medicine” (CAM). Of course, the authors’ use of the term “CAM” instead of the more recent (and preferred among advocates of quackademic medicine) term “integrative medicine” makes me think that they aren’t too hip to the lingo, if you know what I mean, which makes me wonder how well they understand the whole issue. Be that as it may, their whole argument consists of three parts. The first part is an appeal to popularity. This is where they stumble into conflating all of CAM with the most pseudoscientific type of CAM, homeopathy. Starting with just homeopathy, they note:
Homeopathic preparations represent a growing market in the United States. From 1990 to 2000, the sale of homeopathic preparations rose 1,000% (Sayner-Flusche 2000), with that trend continuing to present. In 1994, 69% of all chain drugstores and more than 3,000 independent pharmacy retailers reported stocking homeopathic preparations (McDermott 1995). Furthermore, a 2000 study estimated CAM sales to be more than $34 billion in the United States (MacLennan 2002), up from $21 billion in 1998 (Eisenberg 1998).
And, conflating homeopathy with all of CAM:
CAM appears to be solidly entrenched in American society, enjoying support from politicians and health care professionals as well as the general public. Political support for CAM became manifest in 1992 when a controversial bill passed both houses of Congress to create the Office of Alternative Medicine within the National Institutes of Health. Dismayed by the office’s meager resources, in 1995 Congress transformed it into the National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and increased its budget to $50 million in 1999 (Jonas 2013). According to the NCCAM’s third strategic plan, which extends through 2015, 1 of its 5 strategic objectives is to advance research on CAM natural products, a category that includes homeopathic products, with a focus on mechanistic research that provides a scientifically sound hypothesis for these products (NCCAM 2011).
Of course, I’ve discussed NCCAM (now NCCIH’s) objectives before, and in reality, to its credit, it doesn’t really support research into homeopathy. Indeed, when we met with the director of then-NCCAM, Dr. Josephine Briggs, in 2010, while she would “never say never” about whether NCCAM would fund any more trials of homeopathy, she was very unenthusiastic about it. Also, the authors fail to note the influence of a single senator, Senator Tom Harkin, who created OAM and shepherded it past all obstacles.
Appeal to popularity
The authors then cite a bunch of surveys about how CAM is so popular and how even physicians recommend it. Of course, nowhere to be found is an explanation of how the popularity of CAM use is inflated by “rebranding” science-based modalities, such as nutrition/diet and exercise, and personal beliefs, such as religion and spirituality, as somehow being CAM. Let’s also not forget what I like to refer to as the “medicalization” of modalities that formerly were used just to help patients feel better and pass the time when in the hospital, such as massage, music, and pets as medical “therapies.” As Steve Novella has reminded us, when you strip away all of that, use of the “hard core” CAM therapies (like homeopathy) is in the single digits, percent-wise, and hasn’t changed much in years. Indeed, in the 2007 National Health Interview Survey (NHIS) administered by the NIH, only 3.65% of adults reported ever having used homeopathy. Unfortunately, that might be changing, given how, more and more, homeopathic remedies are finding themselves on pharmacy shelves alongside real medicine. Indeed, big chain drug stores like CVS now have now placed their brand on homeopathic remedies, leading to fiascos such as this response to a typical campaign to demonstrate the quackery that is homeopathy by taking “overdoses” of homeopathic remedies. In this case, it was the homeopathic sleep aid Hyland’s Calms Forte. This is how CVS responded:
In response, DeAngeli told PRWeek it is important to note that d’Entremont did not ingest a CVS brand product in the video.
“It appears to be a national brand product available at many pharmacy retailers,” he said. “She does indicate on the video that homeopathic products are available at CVS/pharmacy and other national pharmacy chains.”
The disingenuousness, it burns.
Money, money, money
The second argument, not surprisingly given that the authors come from a pharmacoeconomics background, is economic. True, this argument is intertwined with the appeal to popularity. After all, the reason why stocking homeopathic remedies could be profitable is because they are popular. However, darn it if that nasty federal government makes it hard for MCOs to cover CAM:
Despite the paucity of data on the use of homeopathy, specifically in a managed care environment, homeopathy represents a growing market in the United States. Historically, there has been an absence of coverage for homeopathic remedies by insurers in the United States. Over the last 2 decades, there has been some interest by insurers in favor of paying for these naturopathic remedies (Montoya 1998). With the popularity of CAM on the rise among subscribers in the United States, some insurers are taking a closer look at alternative treatments as a means to boost their enrollment numbers in a now marketplace that is now extremely competitive because of the advent of the Affordable Care Act. Some insurers, however, are still reluctant to pay for homeopathy because of the lack of standardization of care by clinicians and conflicting outcomes in programs designed to provide evidence-based medicine. CAM is not approved by the FDA, and thus the treatments offered are not eligible for payment under federal drug benefit programs (Medicare, Medicaid, etc.). Since CAM is not covered under this umbrella, managed care plans have no means by which to recapture costs and thus have been historically reluctant to offer benefits for any type of CAM
But, they argue:
An increase in public and private sector funding for research may lead to increased interest in establishing the safety and effectiveness of homeopathic preparations. This may help drive the number of MCOs that are paying for homeopathic treatments (Ullman 1999).
Take a look at that citation. Yes, that is Dana Ullman, who has been featured here many times. He is perhaps the most amusingly clueless yet vocal advocate of homeopathy currently alive and active, and Wertheimer cited an article by him published in the quackademic journal, the “Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine.” It’s half tempting to stop right here and conclude that Wertheimer is beyond ignorant of the issues involved, but that isn’t my way; instead I will note that there’s a reason Kimball Atwood once referred to Ullman as Dull-Man and postulated what he called the “Dull-Man” law: “In any discussion involving science or medicine, being Dana Ullman loses you the argument immediately…and gets you laughed out of the room.” I would broaden the law to “In any discussion involving science or medicine, invoking Dana Ullman to support your argument loses you the argument immediately…and gets you laughed out of the room.”
A return to medical paternalism
Finally, Wertheimer invokes—of course!—placebo effects. After all, since homeopathic remedies are no more than placebo, any time someone defends using homeopathic remedies, the topic will come up. And so it did in this article. Wertheimer first correctly describes why homeopathic remedies have been characterized as placebos, based on how most homeopathic remedies are diluted far beyond the likelihood that even a single molecule of active ingredient remains. He then tries to have it both ways, citing outlier randomized clinical trials that report benefits from homeopathy, such as one for fibromyalgia, which did not appear to assess adequacy of blinding, was more of a pilot study, and demonstrated at best modest results, and one for allergic rhinitis, which was not quite double-blinded (the investigators were not blinded to allergen testing). Basically, they’re cherry-picked studies. Then Wertheimer, seemingly admitting that homeopathy is placebo, asserts:
Thus, the use of homeopathy and the potential for the placebo effect may play an important role in the management of difficult-to-treat patients who present with symptoms of unknown etiology. For example, a patient may present with a generalized sense of anxiety but not be a candidate for treatment with a traditional pharmacologic agent because of 1 or more mitigating factors. Such a patient could be prescribed a homeopathic treatment for anxiety. In such a situation, the patient may feel satisfied with the holistic treatment approach and also may experience the placebo effect manifesting as a reduction in anxiety.
And concludes:
We posit that when no organic source of some symptoms can be determined, the use of some nonspecific homeopathic agent might be considered when the patient clearly expects a medication prescription. Perhaps, some brave P&T committees might monitor outcomes from homeopathic drug studies and, at least, report their experience in the literature.
So basically, Wertheimer is arguing that MCOs go back to supporting what physicians used to do decades ago, explicitly prescribing placebos (one was even called Obecalp). There are two big problems here. First, when you stock a homeopathic remedy, you aren’t saying that it’s a placebo, even though it is. You’re claiming that it works for something, that it is safe and effective for treating something. That leads to the second problem, and that stocking placebos inherently means either lying to the patient (contrary to what is sometimes claimed, there is no placebo effect without deception) or lying to doctors to convince them that the placebo is an active treatment. Let’s face it. There are enough doctors who do not know what homeopathy is and assume that it’s just herbal remedies. Some of them could be persuaded to believe that homeopathy works for some conditions, or at least that it might work.
Should doctors and MCOs recommend homeopathy? Wrong question!
Examining these two articles, one can see common themes from supporters of the sympathetic magic that is homeopathy. First is popularity; i.e., that we should study and offer it because it is popular, in essence ignoring its scientific impossibility and the lack of anything resembling good clinical evidence for it. The second is a false claim that homeopathy actually works, based on cherry-picked studies and fallacious attacks on meta-analyses that fail to find evidence of efficacy and the basic science that shows convincingly why homeopathy cannot work. Indeed, in the accompanying interview in the BMJ within which Fisher and Ernst butt heads, Fisher tries very hard to argue that homeopathy works and dismisses systematic reviews and studies that fail to find evidence that it does.
Finally, if all else fails, learn to stop worrying and love placebo effects, treating homeopathy as the placebo it is and using it for the “worried well” or for patients for whom an organic cause for their symptoms can’t be identified. That’s the argument that Wertheimer makes. Never mind that such an approach is now considered unethical and paternalistic. Of course, homeopaths don’t like that particular justification for using homeopathy, but in reality it’s the only one there is, because homeopathy is a placebo. All you have to do to accept it is to believe that it’s acceptable to lie to patients. Indeed, one can argue, as Ian Dunt does, that belief in homeopathy is a test of morality, although in Wertheimer’s case I’ll give him credit for being honest about advocating lying to patients and coming right out and saying that we should offer our patients placebos. Compare this to Fisher, who truly believes homeopathy works.

Junk science helps homeopathic remedy company win class action
Junk science from two of homeopathy’s biggest apologists help Hyland’s defeat a class action lawsuit for consumer false advertising claims, and nixed refunds for ineffective homeopathic remedies.
Jann Bellamy on January 19, 2017
Link

In 2012, Kim Allen and other consumers filed suit against Hyland’s, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Standard Homeopathic Co., for false advertising in a California federal district court. (Allen v. Hylands Inc., Case No. 2:12-cv-01150-DMG(MANx), U.S. District Court for the Central District of California) The judge certified a plaintiff class of purchasers of ten Hyland’s homeopathic remedies including Calms Forte, Teething Tablets (the subject of an FDA warning, also here) ClearAc (for acne), Migraine Headache Relief, Poison Ivy/Oak Tablets, Cough and Seasonal Allergy Relief, and Colic Tablets. At the 2015 trial, plaintiffs’ counsel argued to the jury that Hyland’s misled tens of thousands of purchasers and sought $255 million in refunds.
Experts with impeccable credentials testified on plaintiffs’ behalf that the principles of homeopathy are biologically impossible, that the overwhelming preponderance of the evidence from clinical trials is that it does not work, and, specifically, the Hyland’s products in question do not provide any effective relief beyond placebo. There was testimony that the FDA, the federal agency charged with regulating homeopathic remedies (however lightly) takes the position that there are little to no active ingredients in these products. Plaintiffs put into evidence the government reports from the U.K. and Australia finding there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective. They also put into evidence the NCCIH’s statement that the most rigorous clinical trials and systematic analyses of the research on homeopathy have concluded that there is little evidence to support homeopathy for any specific condition.
And they lost. The jury came back with a verdict in Hyland’s favor, after a 13-day trial held in 2015. (The case only recently came to my attention in a news report on pending motion, which we’ll get to shortly.) Based on the jury’s verdict, the judge ruled in favor of Hyland’s on claims that remained to be resolved after trial. In other words, it was a complete victory for Hyland’s.
Plaintiffs have moved for a new trial, arguing that the judge erroneously instructed the jury that they had to prove that Hyland’s products “cannot” work. While the plaintiffs did argue that homeopathic remedies, indeed, cannot work, because of biological implausibility, they say that was not their only theory of the case. They argue they merely had to prove the products were ineffective, i.e., that they “do not” work, but that the judge’s instructions to the jury failed to include this theory of the case. Hyland’s, in its response to the motion for a new trial, argues that this is merely semantics; that there is no difference between the two standards.
In their motion for a new trial, Plaintiffs also say they were entitled to a jury instruction that, if a product’s “effectiveness” is solely the result of a placebo effect, an advertisement that the product is “effective” is false even though some consumers may experience positive results. (This argument is based on a decision in a case brought by the FTC against a manufacturer of cure for baldness. The court held that where evidence developed under accepted standards of scientific research demonstrates that the product has no force beyond its placebo effect, advertising it as “effective” is indeed false.) Hyland’s was allowed to introduce evidence of customer satisfaction surveys – in other words, anecdotal evidence of effectiveness – which plaintiffs argue, correctly, could simply indicate the placebo effect at work. Thus, they say, they were entitled to this particular jury instruction on placebo effects.
Finally, the plaintiffs argue that a new trial should be granted because the verdict was against the clear weight of the evidence. The court has taken the motion under consideration.
The trial consumed two weeks and several thousand pages of transcripts and documentary evidence. The case was filed in 2012, finally went to trial in 2015, and is still under consideration on the plaintiffs’ pending motion. A complete summary of the case and discussion of the evidence is far beyond the scope of this post. However, two figures we’ve met before on SBM figured prominently in the trial and I felt their testimony worthy of discussion, for the record, so to speak. (If you have a Pacer account, you can read all 483 docket entries and their associated documents. Otherwise, I have downloaded selected documents and provide links to them.)
The evidence
And what was the evidence in Hyland’s favor, proving to the jury that their product claims were true? A whopping load of junk science, hauled into the courtroom by two of homeopathy’s biggest advocates: Iris Bell, MD, PhD, and Peter Fisher, the British homeopath and physician who treats the Queen.
In testimony at trial (also here), and by affidavit, Dr. Bell, who has been a paid consultant to Standard Homeopathic Co. since 2006, held forth on homeopathy. She said that homeopathy is based on two principles: “like cures like” and “remedies will retain their biological activity if they are repeatedly diluted and agitated or shaken between each dilution.” This is hogwash, of course, but lest the jury doubt that there is “modern” science behind homeopathy, she continues:
Modern homeopathy is premised upon a non-linear dose response for these natural substances. The non-linear dose response phenomenon is explained by a well-documented observation in the research literature known as hormesis, whereby the same substance can produces effects in different or opposite directions, depends on the dose of the substance and the state or condition of the organism at the time it receives the dose. Low doses tend to produce beneficial effects, whereas high doses of the same substance tend to produce adverse or toxic effects. . . . to take advantage hormesis, homeopathic drugs are prepared at the lowest subtoxic observed level sufficient to trigger the secondary symptoms without causing the primary symptom.
And, nanoparticles! If a juror might think the whole idea of diluting a substance until there is nothing left is crazy talk, Dr. Bell says
The method by which many homeopathic medicines are made involves grinding the source material before it is further diluted and succussed. This grinding process is similar to one of two major ways in which nanoparticles of plants, mineral, or drugs are made. . .
But do we know that nanoparticles of active ingredients actually remain in homeopathic remedies so they can work their magic via hormesis? Oh, yes, we do, as Dr. Bell testified at trial:
There was a paper published by investigators at the Indian Institute of Technology stating — studying six different homeopathic medicines using electromicriscopy and other techniques of that type where they actually showed that there were nanoparticles of the source material in the verum medicines. [See Dr. Gorski’s analysis of this paper here.]
In her view, this answered criticisms that
there’s nothing there if you keep diluting it enough. At that point there is something there. Based on that original study, there were nanoparticles of course material present even at those high potencies . . .
which she testified were up to 200C. (A dilution of one molecule in the entire observable universe would be about 40C.)
She also testified:
The literature suggests that many nanoparticles are capable of having some very interesting properties that could overlap with some of the finds that have been reported in homeopathic literature on the electromagnetic signals and the optical signals.
Faced with the testimony of plaintiffs’ expert that all of this violated the laws of physics, Dr. Bell testified that she did not agree. Why?
Because the materials were there.
Except that they weren’t. And hormesis doesn’t “explain” how homeopathy “works,” either. Dr. Bell’s testimony, which is basically a rehash of stuff she’s said before, has been thoroughly debunked by David Gorski and our good friend Orac, with an assist from Harriet Hall in deconstructing the Indian lab experiment supposedly demonstrating the presence of nanoparticles in homeopathic remedies.
I won’t go into the technical details here, but suffice to say that the “nanoparticles” the Indian researchers “saw” were almost surely contaminants and that the “signaling” from the nanoparticles is based on a roundly-criticized paper by Luc Montainger et al. Per the latest “explanation” from homeopaths, once you have nanoparticles (even if you don’t), then (insert lots of handwaving) hormesis. Hormesis is a hypothesis that some substances toxic at high doses might be benign or beneficial at low doses. Of course, no nanoparticles, no hormesis, but even if these magical nanoparticles existed, trying to invoke hormeis as an explanation is, as David Gorski says, “wishful thinking on the part of homeopaths, representing extreme over-extrapolation.”
Or, more colorfully, as Dr. Gorski put it when Dr. Bell set out her nanoparticles (existence + signals) = hormesis = homeopathy works “theory” in a journal article:
I started to wonder whether I was the victim of a Sokal-style hoax here or whether Bell wrote her paper the way that David Bowie used to like to write songs: By cutting up newspaper and magazine articles and randomly splicing the words back together. In this case, it seems as though Bell cut up a bunch of nanoparticle papers and some homeopathy literature and then threw them together to produce much of this paper.
Dr. Bell also testified (by affidavit) that each of the Hyland’s products
[c]ontrary to the assertion [by plaintiffs] that the dilutions result in ‘very little, if any, of the advertised ‘active ingredients’ are present in the Products’ the dilutions of each of the triturated and/or succussed ingredients in the products at issue in this case are sufficient to provide the relief of symptoms for which they are indicated.
All of which pleased the homeopathy crowd to no end.
Dr. Bell was not the only homeopath to testify, nor the most famous. None other than Peter Fisher, the Queen’s physician, also testified on Hyland’s behalf at trial and by affidavit. (For unknown reasons, one volume of his testimony does not appear to have been filed with the court.) Dr. Fisher is a well-known defender of homeopathy and the subject of several SBM posts debunking those defenses:
    • Should physicians and managed care organizations offer homeopathy?
    • False balance for homeopathy in the BMJ
    • Homeopathy and plausibility
    • Homeopathy for fibromyalgia: The Huffington Post bombs again
He cherry-picked his way through homeopathy studies and even “explained” slides to the jury supposedly showing nanoparticles in homeopathic remedies. He also tried to attack Shang et al. for their “beautiful demonstration,” as Dr. Gorski called it, that
whatever effects due to homeopathy ‘detected’ in clinical trials are nonspecific and not detectably different from placebo effects, exactly as one would anticipate based on the basic science showing that homeopathy cannot work unless huge swaths of our current understanding of physics and chemistry are seriously in error.
I read a good portion of his testimony and I have to admit, if you didn’t know anything about science in general or homeopathy in particular, he sounds convincing, partly for reasons we’ll return to in a moment.
At this point, you might well be asking yourself: why were Bell and Fisher allowed to put their pseudoscientific “theories” into evidence in the first place? The answer is: I don’t know. When I first looked at the docket, I was expecting to see a pre-trial motion to exclude their testimony based on federal evidentiary rules and Daubert, which require the judge to act as a “gatekeeper,” insuring that expert testimony is scientifically reliable. However, while plaintiffs sought to exclude their testimony on other grounds, they never explicitly attacked it as pseudoscience in a pre-trial motion to exclude it. In fairness, I cannot question that decision because I have no idea why they made it.
The larger issues
What is striking to me about this case is how it is an exemplar of everything that is wrong with “integrative” medicine and tolerance for pseudoscience. If Iris Bell was credible as a witness, and I have to presume she was if Hyland’s won, it is at least in part because she held a faculty position at the University of Arizona, was an NIH-funded researcher, and is a licensed homeopath and physician (she trained as a psychiatrist) in Arizona. In fact, she testified that one NCCAM grant paid half her salary for ten years.
The same is true of Peter Fisher. To burnish his credibility, he testified is on the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, a UK governmental body that advises the National Health Service on what treatments it should and shouldn’t use, the WHO’s expert advisory panel on complementary medicine, registered in homeopathy by the General Medical Council, and was for 17 years in a position of authority with the Royal London Hospital for Integrated Medicine, which is part of the University College London Hospital NHS Trusts, “one of the leading academic medical centers in the U.K.” (his words) as well as the Queen’s physician. He also testified he is the editor-in-chief of the journal Homeopathy, which, he said, is indexed in PubMed, a service of the National Library of Medicine, and published by Elsevier, “a leading international publisher of scientific medical and technical literature.”
This veneer of respectability and scientific veritas bestowed by quackademic medicine, government entities, state licensing authorities (via state legislatures who pass licensing acts), ACCME-approved courses in homeopathy, taxpayer-funded education in homeopathy, PubMed’s indexing of dubious journals, and companies that publish these “peer-reviewed” journals, allows companies like Hyland’s to rip off the public with its worthless products, and, for good measure, keeps consumers from recovering their money when they complain, no matter how scientifically air-tight their false advertising claims may be.
I have to fault the FDA here too. Had it done its job, and required homeopathic remedy manufacturers to comply with the law, manufacturers would have to prove safety and efficacy before their products went on the market. In fact, while we’re at it, we can blame Congress as well, for incorporating the entire Homeopathic Pharmacoepia into U.S. law in 1938.
I am pleased with the FTC’s announcement that it will clamp down on labeling homeopathic remedies by requiring that companies have competent and reliable scientific evidence for health-related claims, including claims that a product can treat specific conditions. It remains to be seen how much effect this will have. According to testimony at this trial, most people take homeopathic remedies based on their own past experience or recommendations from friends and family, not what they read on the labels. The FTC will still allow manufacturers to make unsubstantiated claims as long as the label says there is no scientific evidence that the product works and that the product’s claims are based only on theories of homeopathy from the 1700s that are not accepted by most modern medical experts. Given the fact that the jury in this case was essentially told the same thing by plaintiffs’ experts, I have my concerns. And, again, “modern medical experts” must overcome the positive PR homeopathy gets from its use at “modern medical” centers.
I don’t know how many homeopathic remedy class actions are pending in federal courts now. (There is at least one other suit against Hyland’s involving its teething remedy.) Perhaps it is time to set up an expert panel to review the scientific issues involved in these suits, as was done in the breast implant cases. Jurors may be confused, but there is no controversy among scientists that homeopathy does not, and cannot, work.

   Closing the Door on Homeopathy
Steven Novella
Link
Homeopathy, as a cultural phenomenon, remains an enigma. In the two centuries since its invention it has failed to garner significant scientific support. In fact, developments in physics, chemistry, biology, and medicine have shown the underlying concepts of homeopathy to be wrong – guesswork and speculation that lept in the wrong direction.
It turns out, like does not cure like. This is nothing more than sympathetic magic – popular at the time but now considered nothing more than superstition without any scientific basis.
It also turns out that diluting a substance does not make it more potent – this nonsensical idea (ridiculed even in the 19th century) violates the laws of thermodynamics, and the chemical principle of mass action. This is especially true when you dilute a substance beyond the point where chance would have even a single molecule of active ingredient left behind. The background noise of chemicals in homeopathic water is orders of magnitude greater than the signal of whatever had previously been diluted in it.
I also understand that water does not have a magical memory of the vibrations of what was diluted in it. Transient interactions of water molecules does not, by any stretch of the imagination, confer upon water the ability to store and transmit complex chemical information from a solution to a tablet to a biological system.
It is therefore demonstrably true, even with simple high school level science, that the plausibility of homeopathy, for all practical purposes, and to the extent that it is possible to make such statements within the methodology of science – is zero.
If this were not enough, putting aside the non-existent plausibility of homeopathy and the staggering failure of two centuries to validate any of its principles, clinical trials of homeopathic remedies have failed to reliably detect any effect above and beyond placebo effects.
Therefore, in the eyes of science, homeopathy = total fail. It should be laid to rest and relegated to a footnote in the history of science – a pre-scientific idea that survived into modern times as pseudoscience. We can squeeze it in somewhere after healing crystals and before humoral theory and iridology.
But here comes the enigma – why does homeopathy persist at all? It seems that after the rise of science-based medicine in the early 20th century homeopathy was marginalized, but was able to survive because it had already entrenched itself sufficiently in politics and society. It then flew under the radar until the recent rise of CAM – the successful re-branding of fraudulent and unscientific modalities as “natural” and “alternative”.
So successful was this re-branding that the scientific community was partly cowed by the incessant demands for being “open-minded” and for “academic freedom.” This caused many scientists who should have known better to forget themselves, to look the other way while advocates slowly inserted nonsense into the health care structure and academic institutions.
We are beginning to see a push back in the scientific community. Michael Baum and Edzard Ernst have recently published a commentary in The American Journal of Medicine which reflects the new found “permission” within the medical community to once again call nonsense nonsense, and close the door on failed therapies.
Should we keep an open mind about astrology, perpetual motion, alchemy, alien abduction, and sightings of Elvis Presley? No, and we are happy to confess that our minds have closed down on homeopathy in the same way.
They then give a detailed justification for this attitude – a sufficient record of basic science and clinical failure to justify the conclusion that homeopathy cannot and does not work.
There has been criticism from other avenues as well. The World Health Organization (WHO) has traditionally taken a very permissive approach to unscientific medical modalities, motivated by a desire to be “open” to indigenous medicine. The WHO is a political organization, after all, and sometimes politics gets in the way of science.
But they are also advocates for world health, especially for vulnerable populations. It was brought to their attention by an organization called Sense About Science that homeopaths were pushing ineffective homeopathic treatments for malaria, TB, and HIV/AIDS. This forced the WHO to make the following clarifications (among others) regarding their position:
Dr Mukund Uplekar: TB Strategy and Health Systems, WHO: “WHO’s evidence-based guidelines on treatment of tuberculosis…have no place for homeopathic medicines.”
Dr Teguest Guerma, Director Ad Interim, HIV/AIDS Department, WHO: “The WHO Dept. of HIV/AIDS invests considerable human and financial resources […] to ensure access to evidence-based medical information and to clinically proven, efficacious, and safe treatment for HIV… Let me end by congratulating the young clinicians and researchers of Sense About Science for their efforts to ensure evidence-based approaches to treating and caring for people living with HIV.”
Dr Sergio Spinaci, Associate Director, Global Malaria Programme, WHO: “Thanks for the amazing documentation and for whistle blowing on this issue… The Global Malaria programme recommends that malaria is treated following the WHO Guidelines for the Treatment of Malaria”. (These guidelines do not include any use of homeopathy.)
Homeopathy is no longer flying under the radar. While pushing worthless nostrums for the worried well may be tolerated, they can no longer hide the fact that symptomatic treatment of self-limiting conditions is simply the foot in the door for hardcore quackery – the treatment of serious and even life-threatening illnesses with worthless remedies.
The WHO has recently run up against homeopathy again, this time with respect to the H1N1 pandemic and vaccine. While the WHO is trying to stem a pandemic with a vaccination program, homeopaths seem to be doing everything they can to frustrate this public health measure.
The Swiss Society of Homoeopathic Physicians was recently warning pregnant women not to get vaccinated against H1N1. This forced WHO vaccines chief Marie-Paule Kieny to make the following statements:
“This (advice) may result in putting pregnant women and their fetuses at risk of severe consequences in case of pandemic influenza virus infection.
“We … regret that the recommendation of the Swiss Society of Homoeopathic Physicians does not take WHO recommendations in this matter into consideration,” she said.
This is also not an isolated incident of homeopaths warning against the vaccine, claiming that homeopathy can treat the flu and prevent the pandemic. A Google search of “flu” and “homeopathy” leads to numerous homeopaths and homeopathic groups making similar claims. The National Center for Homeopathy writes:
Homeopathy has a long and impressive track record in epidemics of all kinds, including influenza, and we are confident of its potential now.
Homeopaths argue that homeopathy was effective in treating the 1918 H1N1 pandemic. Their reliance upon historical records, however, is demonstrably absurd. Such data is uncontrolled and highly unreliable. It reflects their preference for reliance upon low quality data rather than higher quality controlled data.
While the current generation of scientists and regulators are beginning to wake up to the fact that homeopathy is dangerous quackery, the public is still largely uninformed. Homeopathic products are often marketed simply as “natural” leading to widespread confusion in the public as to what, exactly, homeopathy is. Most people believe it is a synonym for herbal or natural remedies.
I encounter many patients and people with these false assumptions, and they are often shocked to learn the truth about homeopathy.
We need to have an open and transparent discussion in our society about homeopathy. The science has spoken – homeopathy is a failed belief system that has no place in modern health care. It is also a great example of the dangers of allowing a system of medicine that is based upon pseudoscience to flourish. Such systems will never limit themselves to “harmless” symptomatic treatments.
Given the evidence and the state of the science, the only responsible position is to completely dismantle homeopathy and close the door on this pseudoscience once and for all.

ASA Smacks Down Homeopathy
Steven Novella on July 3, 2013
Link
It is always gratifying to see regulatory agencies actually do their job. If those regulatory agencies whose job it is to protect the public from false or harmful medical advertising, products, or services thoroughly did their job, so-called “alternative medicine” would cease to exist.
Recently the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) in the UK issued a judgment about advertising for homeopathy, specifically by the Society of Homeopaths. They had been receiving a number of complaints. After thorough investigation, and considering the response from the homeopaths, they came to two basic conclusions: homeopaths are engaging in false advertising by claiming that homeopathy is a proven treatment for specific indications when the evidence does not support those claims, and homeopaths sometimes “discourage essential medical treatment for conditions for which medical supervision should be sought.”
The ASA specifically investigated the following advertising and claims:
1. ad (a) could discourage essential treatment for depression, a medical condition for which medical supervision should be sought, and misleadingly implied that homeopathic remedies could alleviate symptoms of depression;
2. ad (b) could discourage essential treatment for conditions for which medical supervision should be sought; and
3. the claims in ad (b) that homeopathy could treat the following medical conditions were misleading and could be substantiated:
a. Allergies and upper respiratory tract infections;
b. Ankle sprain;
c. Bronchitis;
d. Childhood diarrhoea;
e. Chronic fatigue;
f. Ear infections;
g. Fibromyalgia;
h. Hay fever;
i. Influenza;
j. Osteoarthritis;
k. Premenstrual syndrome;
l. Rheumatic diseases;
m. Sinusitis;
n. Vertigo.
After reviewing the evidence provided by the Society for Homeopaths each decision was upheld. In other words, the Society was given the opportunity to provide evidence to substantiate their claims. After reviewing that evidence the ASA concluded that the evidence did not adequately support the efficacy claims being made. (For some reason a specific description of the evidence for Vertigo is missing from the page, which seems like a simple oversight.)
I agree with their assessment of the evidence provided. It reminds me of the British Chiropractic Association’s response to Simon Singh. They provided a list of references to support their claims for efficacy for chiropractic for a number of pediatric indications. When I reviewed that evidence, however, I found that it did not support the efficacy claims being made, and was highly cherry picked and misleading.
What this clearly demonstrates, in my opinion, is that homeopaths (even those heading major homeopathic institutions) have a very different idea about evidence in medicine than does mainstream medicine (and certainly than we do at SBM). They accept far lower standards of evidence than is generally accepted by the scientific community. The fact that they offered such weak evidence to back their claims demonstrates this unequivocally.
However, I do have a concern about the process of the ASA. They seemed to consider only the evidence provided by the homeopaths. This is not adequate, as such evidence is clearly cherry picked (and even then wasn’t convincing). An independent literature search for at least systematic reviews would put the evidence into better context.
The document does reference other sources in their decision, but not when reviewing the evidence for specific indications. Let’s consider one example, the use of homeopathy in childhood diarrhea. The ASA wrote:
The Society of Homeopaths provided one study to substantiate the claim that there was sufficient research evidence to support the use of homeopathic treatment for childhood diarrhoea. A meta analysis had been conducted on three double-blind trials on a total of 242 children. Children received either an individualised homeopathic medicine or a placebo. The authors concluded that individualised homeopathic treatment decreased the duration of acute childhood diarrhoea. However, our expert considered that the use of individualised homeopathic treatments was problematic because it meant the materials in the ‘active’ arm of the studies were not identical. He considered this meant the studies were assessing effectiveness rather than efficacy and therefore the evidence was not sufficient to support efficacy claims for homeopathy for the treatment of childhood diarrhoea. We therefore concluded the claim was misleading and had not been substantiated.
This one meta-analysis of three studies can only be the Jacobs 2003 review of three clinical studies of homeopathy for diarrhea. I have had this reference cited to me by homeopaths before. Jacobs concluded:
The results from these studies confirm that individualized homeopathic treatment decreases the duration of acute childhood diarrhea and suggest that larger sample sizes be used in future homeopathic research to ensure adequate statistical power. Homeopathy should be considered for use as an adjunct to oral rehydration for this illness.
However – other reviewers (Altunç U, Pittler MH, Ernst E) looked at the same studies and concluded:
The evidence for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder and acute childhood diarrhea is mixed, showing both positive and negative results for their respective main outcome measures.
Further, a 2006 study by Jacobs of homeopathic combination therapy was entirely negative.
So – the Society for Homeopaths referred to the 2003 review that was positive, despite the fact that other reviews of the same data were negative, and a high-quality follow up study by the same author, Jacobs, was negative. The ASA reviewers would not know this, however, unless they did their own literature search or consulted independent experts to do so.
Conclusion
We can conclude a few things from this episode:
– When the actual scientific evidence is examined, homeopathy has not demonstrated efficacy for any indication. Homeopaths can’t seem to prove their point even when they are given free reign to cherry pick the published studies.
– Homeopaths appear to accept any level of evidence as support for homeopathy, even when that evidence is completely inadequate, and even when better evidence clearly demonstrates lack of efficacy. The unavoidable conclusion is that homeopathy is not a science-based profession.
– Homeopaths engage in deceptive advertising that is potentially harmful to the public.
There is also a broader lesson to take from this example – don’t believe proponents of so-called “alternative medicine” when they make the “what’s the harm” argument. This is the “Trojan Horse” strategy that David Gorski has pointed out before. CAM proponents get their foot in the door of academia, hospitals, or regulatory acceptance by presenting a very benign picture of what they do. Typically they present themselves as simply “integrating” benign symptomatic treatment into mainstream medicine.
This is the Trojan Horse – once they are inside the gates, the horse opens up and out comes rank pseudoscience making unwarranted efficacy claims and scaring patients away from science-based therapies.
Evidence of this behavior is there to see for anyone who cares to look, and this latest assessment by the ASA is simply more evidence. This evidence can be found just by looking on the internet. Behind closed doors, the situation is far worse. Remember the homeopathy sting in which UK homeopaths were consulted and found to be offering ineffective homeopathic potions instead of effective medications for the prevention of malaria.
Don’t believe the “integrative, complementary” marketing deception. Proponents of these dubious treatments want to replace science-based effective treatments with their magic potions.

The Baloney Protection Act
Steven Novella on June 10, 2026
Link

We have had to endure a great deal of interference from government in the conduct of institutions that should be governed by science and evidence. I’m sorry to report – here is one more. Senators Mike Lee (R-UT) and Tommy Tuberville (R- AL) have recently introduced a bill that would limit the FDA’s ability to regulate the blatant pseudoscience of homeopathy. This is how they frame it: “The Homeopathic Drug Product Safety, Quality, and Transparency Act will provide a pathway for homeopathic medicinal products to be lawfully marketed by the Food and Drug Administration without needlessly banning safe products that simply do not fit into the same legal categories as traditional pharmaceuticals.”
They are promoting this bit of malfeasance with the usual tropes:
“Americans have a right to manage their own health and choose treatments that are right for them, including homeopathic methods,” said Senator Mike Lee. “The current federal regulatory framework is designed around traditional pharmaceuticals, but it is ill-equipped to review the safety and effectiveness of homeopathic products.
“I’ve long been an advocate for homeopathic medicine,” said Senator Tommy Tuberville. “The reality is that too many Americans today are hooked on pharmaceuticals when they could be using homeopathic remedies, which are often cheaper and can yield miraculous results.”
There is a lot to unpack in these statements, but let’s start with a quick review of what homeopathy is. It was invented in the late 18th century by German physician Samuel Hahnemann, based on prescientific notions. First, it uses substances which allegedly cause specific symptoms to treat those same symptoms. This is nothing but sympathetic magic (it is not based on any principles similar to vaccines, for example). These substances are often fanciful, and some even don’t exist. Oscilococcinum, still a popular homeopathic product, is nothing but artifactual air bubbles on a slide, mistaken for an organism by an ignorant and confused homeopath.
The silliness of the starting ingredients are also irrelevant – because whatever they are they are typically diluted out of existence (so homeopathy is magic squared). Homeopaths sometimes claim the “essence” of the substance remains, but there is no mechanism for this, nor for it to be stored in sugar pills or get absorbed into the body or have any effect on the body. In order for homeopathy to work one would have to believe in a chain of impossible things (even The White Queen would find this challenging).
Despite that, homeopathy has been clinically studied – and unsurprisingly, it doesn’t work. To put it more technically, there is insufficient evidence to reject the null hypothesis that homeopathic products have no specific efficacy or any effect beyond placebo for any indication. Multiple independent systematic reviews have come to this basic conclusion. Magic, it turns out, isn’t real.
Selling a product to the public that demonstrably does not work with claims that it does work is, quite simply, fraud. So why is this allowed at all? Partly because of a US Senator who was a homeopath, Royal S. Copeland (D-NY), who is responsible for creating the current framework in which the FDA regulates homeopathic products. Essentially homeopathy is in its own category, and does not require evidence for safety or efficacy. The FDA decided that homeopathy was too small a market to waste their limited resources on so they just accepted the homeopathic pharmacopoeia as a list of approved products – no evidence required.
However, in 2019 the FDA reviewed its regulation of homeopathy because of the growing industry, and they did strengthen their regulations (although not nearly enough). Mainly they required greater scrutiny of manufacturing for safety and quality concerns, while still ignoring the complete lack of any effectiveness. Meanwhile the FTC changed its regulations requiring more transparency in labeling – again, good but not far enough.
Now it seem that Tuberville and Lee are not happy with the FDA partly doing its job, so they want to stop them. Mike Lee is from Utah, which is the epicenter of the alternative health product industry in the US, so he is likely just serving this industry in his state (as Orrin Hatch did before him). He has been consistently anti-regulation of this industry, with the usually dubious justifications.
Saying that consumers have a right to make their own choices is grossly misleading. It’s like saying they should be able to drive over whatever bridge they want, or consume tainted meat, employ incompetent doctors and car mechanics, or endure unsafe work conditions. It’s nearly impossible for individual people to determine if a medicine is safe and effective from their own anecdotal use. Safety is often a matter of statistics from systematic reviews of many cases, as is efficacy. Placebo and non-specific effects also make efficacy extremely hard to accurately perceive. The existence of the homeopathic industry itself is hard proof of this.
Most people also do not even know what homeopathy is. Further most people falsely assume that if the government approves something, it must be legitimate. Over my career I have had countless conversations with both the public and fellow practitioners, and virtually no one who is not already steeped in skepticism or science based medicine have any idea what homeopathy is. Many are disbelieving when I explain it to them, believing that it can’t possibly be that nonsensical (until they look into it themselves). Given this profound lack of information, it’s hard to argue for consumer choice.
The senators are also borrowing the propaganda from the CAM industry, that scientific methods designed for drugs don’t work for homeopathy or other alternative products. This is also nonsense. Evidence is evidence – either a product is safe or it isn’t, either it works or it doesn’t. Safe and consistent manufacturing processes are also agnostic toward the type of product. This is just all pro-industry anti-consumer regulation sold with the same laughable justifications that we typically get.
So we appear to have an industry shill and a true believer trying to weaken the FDA’s ability to protect the public from clearly fraudulent and worthless products. Further, MAHA sycophants are lining up behind them.
If you live in the US, you might want to write your senator and explain that you want the FDA to actually protect US consumers from blatant health product fraud. 



   Homeopathy Gets a Reality Check in the UK
Steven Novella
Link
The House of Commons Science and Technology Committee (STC) has released a report, Evidence Check 2: Homeopathy, in which they recommend that the NHS stop funding homeopathy. The report is a rare commodity – a thoroughly science-based political document.
The committee went beyond simply stating that homeopathy does not work, and revealed impressive insight into the ethical, practical, and scientific problems caused by NHS support for an implausible and ineffective pseudoscience.
The STC formed in October of 2009, and this is their second report. The goals of the STC itself are significant step forward:
The purpose of Evidence Check is to examine how the Government uses evidence to formulate and review its policies.
We certainly can use more of that.
What Is Homeopathy
The report is impressive in its accuracy and insight, starting with its definition of homeopathy. It states that homeopathy is:
based on two principles: “like-cures-like” whereby a substance that causes a symptom is used in diluted form to treat the same symptom in illness and “ultra-dilution” whereby the more dilute a substance the more potent it is…
That is essentially correct. “Like cures like” is another way of stating the ancient superstition of sympathetic magic – the kind of magical thinking that led some ancient cultures to believe that rhino horn is a cure for impotence because of its superficial resemblance to the erect male organ. This is a pre-scientific notion, based upon vitalism or essentialism – that substances contain an essence that can be transferred separate from their physical substance. These notions remain core to homeopathy today.
The report is also careful to state that homeopathic remedies are not the same thing as herbal remedies (a common misconception), even though sometimes they are made from herbs (which are then diluted out of existence).
Ultra-dilutions refers to the homeopathic practice of diluting substances to the point where there is no original substance left – just the water in which it is diluted. This water is then given as a remedy, either by itself or placed on a sugar pill. Dilutions of 30C, or a 1/100 dilution 30 times, or 10^60 dilution are common in homeopathy.
Some Basic Principles
The report then lays out its most basic premise, referring to the National Health Service (NHS):
You have the right to expect local decisions on funding of [...] drugs and treatments to be made rationally following a proper consideration of the evidence.
This may seem like stating the obvious, but it is this very notion – basing medical decisions on reason and evidence – that is being challenged by the so-called alternative medicine culture.
The report also addresses the issue of plausibility – something very important to science-based medicine:
Our expectation of an explanation for a mechanism of action is that it is both scientifically plausible and demonstrable.
But then they add the caveat;
Historically, some medical interventions were demonstrably effective before anyone understood their modes of action. For example, after 150 years of use, there is still debate about precisely how anaesthetics work. It is more important to know whether a treatment works—its efficacy—than how it works.
I would characterize these statements as true but incomplete. It is not necessary to know exactly how a treatment works in order to be confident that it does work – but these two things are not isolated from each other. They are both part of the overall scientific evidence needed to conclude whether or not a treatment works, and this is relevant to homeopathy. Not knowing how a treatment works in not equivalent to knowing that a treatment is highly improbable (as is the case with homeopathy). Extreme implausibility should affect where we place the threshold of clinical evidence for efficacy.
The report gives an excellent overview of the nature of clinical evidence and the pitfalls of “cherry picking” data to support a biased conclusion. They justify their reliance on meta-analysis of systematic reviews of the best randomized controlled trials.
They follow this up with a discussion of the placebo effect, and how to distinguish placebo medicine from physiologically active medicine. They give a reasonable definition of placebo:
we are attracted to the definition produced by Dr Howard Brody, Director of the Institute of Medical Humanities at the University of Texas Medical Branch, who defined the placebo effect as “a change in a patient’s illness attributable to the symbolic import of a treatment rather than a specific pharmacologic or physiologic property”. According to this definition, the placebo effect does not necessarily require a dummy treatment. It is important to remember that when patients receive an efficacious treatment, they may benefit from a placebo (non-specific) effect as well as the specific effect of the treatment. Brody’s definition also allows for a wider range of non-specific effects, such as the doctor patient relationship, to be relevant to the placebo effect.
They also address the issue of placebo medicine, quoting Edzard Ernst (an outstanding critic of unscientific medicine whose influence on the findings of the committee is clearly seen).
I would argue it is unnecessary, unreliable and unethical to prescribe placebos through the NHS; unnecessary because if you do it well then an active treatment will also generate a placebo effect. If I give my patient an aspirin for his or her headache and I do it with empathy, time and understanding this patient will benefit from the pharmacological effect of the aspirin and she will also benefit from the placebo effect through the encounter with her clinician. It is unreliable and there is lots of data to show that placebo effects are notoriously unreliable; somebody who responds today may not respond tomorrow; responses are not large in effect size and they are not usually long-lasting. Foremost, it is unethical.
Does Homeopathy Work?
At the risk, of being anti-climactic – the simple conclusion the committee comes to is -no. But they do go through their reasoning in detail. They begin with plausibility, first addressing the principle of likes-cures-like. They correctly dismiss the analogy offered by some homeopaths that like-cures-like is similar to the toxicological principle of hormesis – which essentially states that some substances which are toxic at high doses may be benign and even beneficial at low doses.
However, there are significant problems with the hormesis justification. First, it represents over-extrapolation – just because some substances may display hormesis, that does not mean that most or all substances do. And second, hormesis may apply to low doses, but that is not analogous to the ultra-dilute (essentially non-existent) doses of homeopathic remedies – low dose is not no dose. Hormesis also is not analogous to the homeopathic claim that substances behave differently in well and sick individuals.
They conclude:
We conclude that the principle of like-cures-like is theoretically weak. It fails to provide a credible physiological mode of action for homeopathic products. We note that this is the settled view of medical science.
Next they dismantle the notion that ultra-dilutions can still carry the essence of what was diluted in the substance. This notion has been so thoroughly discredited on this and other scientific sites, I will just jump to their conclusion:
We consider the notion that ultra-dilutions can maintain an imprint of substances previously dissolved in them to be scientifically implausible.
And next we get to the real meat of the report – evidence for efficacy. The committee listened to proponents and critics, and found that homeopathy proponents cherry picked out-dated and fatally flawed studies to support their position, including a lecture series that wasn’t even a systematic review.
Meanwhile, the best reviews of the best evidence clearly show that homeopathy is no better than placebo – which means it doesn’t work. They conclude:
In our view, the systematic reviews and meta-analyses conclusively demonstrate that homeopathic products perform no better than placebos. The Government shares our interpretation of the evidence. We asked the Minister, Mike O’Brien, whether the Government had any credible evidence that homeopathy works beyond the placebo effect and he responded: “the straight answer is no”.
And then here is the zinger:
We regret that advocates of homeopathy, including in their submissions to our inquiry, choose to rely on, and promulgate, selective approaches to the treatment of the evidence base as this risks confusing or misleading the public, the media and policymakers.
That in our criticism of unscientific medicine in a nutshell. SBM is primarily about methodology, not a set of beliefs or conclusions. SBM is the application of fair and rigorous scientific methods to assessing treatments and medical interventions. The only “alternative” to SBM is not fairly and rigorously applying scientific methods. This includes the kind of biased cherry picking for which the STC now criticizes homeopaths.
More Research?
Many of us on SBM have pointed out before that the common ploy of alternative medicine proponents is to take a weak study, or a study that was clearly negative, and then conclude that even though the study was negative, it shows promise, and therefore we need to fund more research. This creates an endless succession of weak or negative research, calling for more research. The purpose seems to be to use the fact that a modality is being researched as a marketing tool, without ever discarding a modality due to negative research.
At some point, however, it must be reasonable to cross a threshold where we can conclude that there has been enough research and the medical community, with its limited research money, should simply move on. With homeopathy we have a highly implausible treatment that should not work, and the evidence shows convincingly that it in fact does not work. Homeopaths have had 200 years to make their scientific case, and they have completely failed. It is time to move on.
The STC agrees:
There has been enough testing of homeopathy and plenty of evidence showing that it is not efficacious. Competition for research funding is fierce and we cannot see how further research on the efficacy of homeopathy is justified in the face of competing priorities.
In fact, they go further to say that it is unethical to enroll patients into a research study of a treatment that we already know does not work.
Policy Recommendations
Given the soundly negative evaluation of the plausibility and efficacy of homeopathy, and the rejection of placebo medicine, it is no surprise that the STC recommended that the NHS stop funding homeopathy completely. This would include closing, or at least withdrawing funding for, the four homeopathic hospitals in the UK. They further recommend withdrawing licensing by the MHRA (the UK equivalent of the FDA):
We conclude that the MHRA should seek evidence of efficacy to the same standard for all the products examined for licensing which make medical claims and we recommend that the MHRA remove all references to homeopathic provings from its guidance other than to make it clear that they are not evidence of efficacy.
Imagine that – applying a single consistent scientific standard to all claims of efficacy.
The NHS spends about 4 million pounds a year on homeopathy (this is direct costs, and does not include maintenance costs for homeopathic hospitals). This is not much, but any money spent on nonsense is a waste of tax money citizens place in the trust of their government.
The implications of these recommendations go beyond the NHS. They further recommend that EU countries who support homeopathy, such as Germany and France, reconsider their own support for this dubious pseudoscience. It is also quite possible that the withdrawal of official government approval of homeopathy will have a ripple effect, leading major pharmacies to stop carrying homeopathic products.
The STC correctly observes that when the government supports a specific treatment, by either paying for it or for research, this becomes a tacit endorsement of the product or service in the eyes of the public. Therefore, they have a responsibility to get the science right.
Homeopathic Response
Defenders of homeopathy are, of course, not happy with the findings of the STC. I find it amusing that in various news article defenders respond to the accusation that homeopathy supporters use deception and misdirection, by using deception and misdirection. For example, in the Times Online:
Robert Wilson, chairman of Nelsons, Britain’s largest manufacturer of natural healthcare products, said: “There is good evidence that homeopathy works beyond placebo, for example in animals and babies.”
The assumption here is that any effect in a baby or animal cannot be due to the placebo effect, because placebo effects are dependent upon the expectation of benefit. This is a gross misconception, however. Placebo effects can result from the attention of the caregiver or other non-specific effects. Or they can simply be an artifact of observation – the person observing for an effect in the animal or baby may be the one responding to the placebo.
The above statement is simply false – there is no good evidence for the effectively of any homeopathic remedy in any population.
Prince Charles is a big supporter of homeopathy, and representative of his foundation to promote alternative medicine were quoted by the New Scientist:
“For patients suffering from long term disease, where no scientific, evidence based medicine can offer effective treatment, it does not matter how it works,” says the foundation, in a response to the committee’s report. “What matters to them is whether they get better, whether pain and other symptoms are alleviated.”
Michael Dixon, medical director of the foundation adds: “Science is a vital tool in healthcare, but so are compassion and caring and treating patients with dignity. It is not clear that the Committee took that into account.”
The report addressed and dismissed the notion of placebo medicine quite well. But we also see here some common ploys. The first sentence justifies using implausible and ineffective treatments simply because there may not be another alternative – but this is no justification. Resorting to an ineffective treatment will not help someone suffering from an untreatable ailment – it will simply add insult to injury. The statement also begs the question – assuming that patients “get better.” However, it is only through rigorous scientific research that we can know if anyone does benefit from a treatment – and the evidence clearly shows that there is no benefit from homeopathy.
The second statement by Michael Dixon is a despicable bit of bad logic, but also not uncommon. It is primarily a non sequitur – treating patients with compassion and dignity does not alter the scientific evidence. It is also a false dichotomy – as if you cannot have science-based medicine and compassionate medicine at the same time.
Further, I would argue that the most compassionate, caring, and dignified treatment a physician can give a patient is to give them proper informed consent and to prescribe treatments which are actually safe and effective. Using ineffective and implausible treatments is the most uncaring thing a physician can do, and prescribing placebos as if they were real medicine is an assault on the dignity of a patient.
Conclusion
The STC report is an impressive document defending many of the core principles of science-based medicine and rational regulation of medical practice and products. If the document were crafted by the authors of SBM itself I do not think we could have improved much upon it.
It remains to be seen what impact it will have – we can only hope that it is extensive and immediate.
It is heartening that a political body can thoroughly review the evidence, receiving testimony offering differing opinions, and come to a so thoroughly science-based conclusion. Its condemnation of homeopathy and the behavior of homeopaths is accurate and devastating.
I would like to see the recommendations replicated in the US and elsewhere. The FDA, for example, should withdraw its automatic approval of the homeopathic pharmacopoeia.
But perhaps even more important than its potential effect on homeopathy specifically, is the potential for this type of analysis, and the basic principles expressed in the report, to be applied to all of medicine. The committee’s report is a devastating condemnation of the foundations of so-called complementary and alternative medicine, smashing many of its pillars.
Perhaps the looming health care crisis and the attention that rising health care costs is currently receiving will make this kind of no-nonsense rigorous scientific assessment fashionable in Western politics. Removing worthless modalities from the health care system is certainly in the interests of efficiency and cost-effectiveness.
As the STC also points out – for the public to have faith in government regulation of health care, and for that trust not to be abused, government has a responsibility to be rigorously evidence-based. They conclude:
By providing homeopathy on the NHS and allowing MHRA licensing of products which subsequently appear on pharmacy shelves, the Government runs the risk of endorsing homeopathy as an efficacious system of medicine. To maintain patient trust, choice and safety, the Government should not endorse the use of placebo treatments, including homeopathy. Homeopathy should not be funded on the NHS and the MHRA should stop licensing homeopathic products.

Homeopathy and the UK’s National Health Service
Harriet Hall on May 12, 2015
Link
Homeopathy is arguably the silliest form of alternative medicine: the published studies show no evidence of anything beyond nonspecific contextual effects, and the underlying premise is incompatible with the existing body of scientific knowledge. Homeopathy has increasingly been questioned or denounced by organizations in several countries, most recently in FDA hearings in the US.
I recently spoke at the QED conference (Question, Explore, Discover) in Manchester, England. Another speaker, Michael Marshall, gave a talk on homeopathy and the National Health Service. He presented information that was new to me and that I thought was worthy of sharing with SBM readers.
Background
Homeopathy is more widely accepted in Europe than in the US. In Britain, homeopathic hospitals persisted long after the last one closed in the US, and the National Health Service (NHS) still provides homeopathy. Queen Elizabeth travels with a kit of homeopathic remedies, and Prince Charles is so infamous for his support of homeopathy and all things alternative that Simon Singh and Edzard Ernst ironically dedicated their book Trick or Treatment: The Undeniable Facts About Alternative Medicine “To HRH The Prince of Wales.”
A committee of British MPs has recommended that homeopathy no longer be funded by the NHS, but Parliament has not yet acted on that recommendation. Homeopathy not only wastes taxpayer money, but can endanger patients. A BBC investigation found that homeopathy was being recommended instead of effective malaria prophylaxis for travelers to endemic areas.
Where is homeopathy funded?
I thought homeopathy was funded by the National Health Service. I was right. I thought that meant anyone in the UK could get it for free. I was wrong.
Funding decisions are local. They are made by 211 Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs). There is no central accounting of how much the NHS spends on homeopathy. The only way to get information is to send FOIAs to every CCG individually, and that is exactly what the indefatigable Michael Marshall did.
The results:
174 CCGs said they did not fund homeopathy
6 CCGs were unsure if they funded homeopathy
14 CCGs said they funded homeopathy
17 couldn’t tell him whether it was funded
On a map , the areas funding homeopathy look strikingly sparse. It is funded in Newcastle, Liverpool, and Bristol; and London “could not say” whether it was funded.
How much is spent?
There are four CCGs in the Newcastle area, spending from £3.27 to £176.56 annually, for a total of £231.39. Total spending in Bristol is £242,303.
There are 17 CCGs in London that don’t know how much they spend on homeopathy. Marshall’s best guess, extrapolating from data from a single FOIA, is that it is probably well over £3,000,000.
In the Liverpool area, the 5 CCGs’ spending ranged from £18.68 to £34,050.
The total reported expenses for England were £2,004,012; but that doesn’t include London, so the actual figure may well be over £5 million, which seems quite a lot to spend on sugar and water.
In Glasgow, 355 patients were treated in Scotland’s only homeopathic hospital annually at a cost of £3,605 per patient for remedies. Remedies are supplied by Freeman’s Homeopathic Pharmacy, whose website lists 3,400 different remedies:
    • 489 from animals, including badger, buzzard and seven types of butterfly
    • 111 from humans, including dandruff, semen, and breast cancer aspirate
    • Six from colors, including blue, orange, rainbow, and full color spectrum
    • 104 from even weirder and potentially dangerous sources, including asbestos, MRI scan, Fairy Liquid (dishwashing soap), and fire
    • They also sell more extreme “nosodes” that they will not list online
    • Freeman’s told Marshall that homeopathic owl couldn’t be sold without a prescription, but he easily obtained some by buying it online
Liverpool reconsiders
In 2014, the homeopathy-funding contract expired for the Liverpool CCG and they had to decide whether to renew funding. Consultation (with input from skeptical groups) recommended ceasing funding, and there was no public support, but they decided to fund it anyway! Their decision was challenged through Judicial Review, and the contract is currently on hold until after the election.
Homeopathy in decline

Demand for homeopathy is declining in the UK. The number of prescriptions is down 94% from a high of 170,000 in 1996, and prescription costs have dropped by almost 90%.
Activism
Michael Marshall is a project director for the Good Thinking Society, an organization founded by Simon Singh for science advocacy, consumer protection, direct activism, media watchdog, and community support. They have addressed a wide variety of issues such as live blood analysis, astrology, dental amalgams, chiropractic, and cancer quackery. Their annual Golden Duck award is given to the person or organization that has supported or practiced pseudoscience in the most ludicrous, dangerous, irrational or irresponsible manner. In 2012 they gave a Golden Duck Lifetime Achievement Award to Andrew Wakefield (here is his nomination statement, and his co-nominees were Prince Charles and Member of Parliament David Tredinnick). If you want to help their efforts, you can donate via their website and PayPal.
Marshall is vice president of the Merseyside Skeptics Society, which organized the 10:23 campaign (a reference to Avogadro’s number, which shows that no active ingredient is left in highly dilute remedies). 10:23 raises awareness of the inefficacy of homeopathy by holding public demonstrations where participants overdose on homeopathic remedies, taking 20 times the recommended dose of arsenicum album. By 2011 the demonstrations had spread to involve 1,700 people in 70 cities in 32 countries and seven continents, even Antarctica!
An anecdote and a thank-you to the NHS
Within two hours of my arrival in Manchester for the QED conference, I had an accident. I missed a step and my face impacted the pavement, resulting in profuse bleeding, two broken upper front teeth, a bad lip laceration with embedded tooth fragments, and a chin laceration. Passers-by stopped to help and called an ambulance. I was transported to the university hospital, given pain pills, x-rayed, treated and sutured by a maxillofacial surgeon. It didn’t cost a cent, and I wasn’t even asked for ID. I was very impressed by the quality of care and by the caring attitude of the providers, and I couldn’t help but think how different an injured foreigner’s experience would have been in the US. Thank you, NHS! You do so many things so well; it is a shame you haven’t been able to completely eliminate funding for homeopathy.
Conclusion
Funding for homeopathy exists only in isolated pockets in the UK, and support for it continues to decline. In my opinion, government-supported health care should be for effective medicine; there is no reason for the government to spend taxpayer money on placebo medicine. “Health freedom” advocates still have access to homeopathy and they can pay for it themselves.
Note: Many thanks to Michael Marshall for sharing his PowerPoint slides with me and for all the good work he is doing to promote science and reason.
A personal note: In case anyone is worried about me, I am OK. My daughter was travelling with me, which was a big help. My facial bruising and scabs made it look from a distance like I was growing a beard, but it didn’t interfere with my giving my talk and participating in 2 panels at QED. I went on to speak at Skeptics in the Pub in York and Liverpool. Then we went to Reykjavik, Iceland, where I spoke to a humanist group. We got to do a lot of sightseeing, including the one and only Penis Museum in Reykjavik. Now back home, I’m getting two root canals and my dentist thinks he can save my teeth and restore them to a semblance of normality.

Homeopathy: Magical thinking, not medicine
Scott Gavura on December 19, 2024
Link
The Science-Based Medicine blog was established way back in 2008. Since that time, contributors to this blog have been sounding the alarm about the harmful effects of pseudoscience and conspiracy theories related to health. Few people in positions of authority heeded these warnings or recognized the severity of the threat over the next decade. Sometimes we as health professionals were even mocked for writing about these topics instead of presumably meatier medicine-related topics. The COVID-19 pandemic was the event that brought widespread awareness among physicians, public health officials, and scientists about the harms of medical misinformation, and demonstrated that there is still a lot of interest (and confusion) about rank pseudoscience.
One of the points that David Gorski likes to make is that “everything old is new again” and the pandemic has demonstrated this, again and again. Pseudoscience we thought we had definitively debunked a decade ago keeps finding a new, larger and seemingly even more accepting audience.
I was thinking of Gorski’s adage when I came across Tim Caulfield’s recent piece expressing bewilderment and frustration with his Canadian province’s apparent interest in moving away from a scientific framework for their healthcare system:
At the event, [Alberta Premier Danielle] Smith was also asked whether Alberta would provide funding for homeopathy. Here, her response was more definitive. “I love what you’re saying. Absolutely,” she said. And then she seemed to suggest homeopathy could be part of a strategy to deal with health in a “preventive way” that would stop ailments from becoming acute and, as Smith put it, “then you end up in the hospital.” Soon after this event, Minister of Health Adriana LaGrange mused about the provincial system covering homeopathy, noting that “a lot of Albertans value the services that they get from homeopaths”—homeopathy, despite the government’s enthusiasm, remains a fringe practice in Alberta. And at the federal level, the Conservatives are suggesting weakening the already weak regulation on natural health products, like “supplements and homeopathic medicines.”
Medical history is full of strange practices and beliefs. As scientific principles have become the framework for determining what works (and what doesn’t) work in medicine, we’ve seen progress towards more science-based, evidence-based care. Yet some unscientific practices still exist, despite evidence that they do not work. Homeopathy is one of these practices. While there is no convincing evidence to demonstrate that homeopathic treatments are more effective than a placebo, many consumers and even some health professionals believe homeopathy is an actual health treatment that provides beneficial effects.
Responding to the perceived consumer demand for these products, governments need to make decisions about how to deal with the practice. It could ignore homeopathy, treating it like we might think of astrology: firmly outside of medicine, and for entertainment purposes only. Or it could choose some form of regulation, targeting the providers (homeopaths) or the product (homeopathy), possibly with the goal of managing its use, or perhaps limiting harms to consumers. The risk of regulating nonsense is the perceived legitimacy that recognition and regulation implies. Governments or insurance programs can go even futher than regulation and even pay for these products and services. To understand why this is a very bad idea, it’s necessary to review what homeopathy is, and is not.
Dilutions of Grandeur
Homeopathy is often misunderstood as a natural remedy, akin to a type of herbalism. The marketing and labeling of these “remedies” encourages this perception, often describing homeopathy as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing. While it is often described as a type of “alternative medicine”, it’s more accurately described as an alternative to medicine, given homeopathic remedies don’t normally contain medicine or active ingredients.
Samuel Hahnemann invented the homeopathy in the early 1800s. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like is simply magical thinking, a pre-scientific belief that was first described in 1890 by anthropologist Sir James George Frazer in the book The Golden Bough:
If we analyse the principles of thought on which magic is based, they will probably be found to resolve themselves into two: first, that like produces like, or that an effect resembles its cause; and, second, that things which have once been in contact with each other continue to act on each other at a distance after the physical contact has been severed. The former principle may be called the Law of Similarity, the latter the Law of Contact or Contagion.
The so-called “Law of Contagion” is still very much alive, and is the basis for pseudoscientific ideas such as “detox” and “eating clean“. It is also the entire basis of homeopathy.
Proponents of homeopathy believe that any substance can be an effective remedy if it’s sequentially diluted enough: raccoon fur, the fermented duck liver, even pieces of the Berlin Wall are possible remedies. But while they may have different labels, the final products sold are all essentially the same. In the manufacturing process, remedies are diluted in water so dramatically that there’s mathematically almost zero possibility of even a single molecule of the original ingredient remaining. The 30C “potency” is a common dilution used in homeopathy – that’s a dilution of 10-60. If something has been diluted this much, you would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original, pre-diluted material. To advocates, this much dilution is a good thing, as it’s to make the “remedy” more potent, not less. These rules contradict core scientific principles as well as what we know about biology and medicine.
When Hahnemann invented homeopathy, he described it as a separate and more effective form of medicine compared to “conventional” medical practices. Given homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, homeopathy probably was safer than medical practice at the time, which was still based around the idea of the four humors. Eventually, germ theory emerged, ideas of humors disappeared, and medicine slowly turned towards a scientific model based on objective observations. Homeopathy, on the other hand, has never progressed or evolved based on evidence, because it was never based on science or evidence to begin with. Its practices today are frozen in the same beliefs from the 1800s.
Rigorous clinical trials of homeopathy confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. While there are plenty of clinical trials that show homeopathy is associated with positive clinical effects, they are always small, poorly controlled, and often biased. Two comprehensive reviews of the evidence are the 2010 Evidence Check from the United Kingdom’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee and the 2014 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council review, which reached the following conclusion:
Based on the assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of homeopathy, NHMRC concludes that there are no health conditions for which there is reliable evidence that homeopathy is effective.
Homeopathy should not be used to treat health conditions that are chronic, serious, or could become serious. People who choose homeopathy may put their health at risk if they reject or delay treatments for which there is good evidence for safety and effectiveness. People who are considering whether to use homeopathy should first get advice from a registered health practitioner. Those who use homeopathy should tell their health practitioner and should keep taking any prescribed treatments. The National Health and Medical Research Council expects that the Australian public will be offered treatments and therapies based on the best available evidence.
When homeopathic “remedies” are sold commercially, they look like conventional medicine when they’re stocked on pharmacy shelves. The marketing and labeling that is permitted for homeopathic “remedies” in the United States does not draw attention to the lack of active ingredients. Consequently, it would be difficult for the average consumer, who may think of homeopathy as a form of herbalism or natural medicine, to identify that homeopathic remedies are inert. XKCD highlighted the ethical issues with homeopathy in pharmacies several years ago (I have pasted the hover text below):
“I just noticed CVS has started stocking homeopathic pills on the same shelves with–and labeled similarly to–their actual medicine. Telling someone who trusts you that you’re giving them medicine, when you know you’re not, because you want their money, isn’t just lying–it’s like an example you’d make up if you had to illustrate for a child why lying is wrong.”
Real Consequences to Fake Medicine
Using homeopathy in place of real medicine can have fatal consequences. Avoiding actual medicine may be a choice but it can also be a mistake driven by marketing and promotion. Clay Jones noted in a past post how homeopathy contributed to the death of a child:
This case involves the 2017 death of a 7-year-old Italian child whose parents chose to follow recommendations from a local practitioner of homeopathy when their child had an apparent ear infection. Citing their failure to give the child antibiotics, which according to the judge would have prevented the infection from spreading to the brain, the parents were found guilty of aggravated manslaughter and given suspended sentences of three months in prison. The child’s grandfather has defended the convicted couple, stating that they “resorted to homeopathy” only out of concern over the harmful effects of antibiotics and are not anti-medicine in general.
Should Insurance Plans Cover Pseudoscience?
Public health care systems (and governments in general) usually face criticism when they spend money in wasteful ways. With ageing populations and the rising cost of health care there’s more and more scrutiny of what health insurance programs like Medicare and Medicaid play for. Services like homeopathy are not typically paid for by public health insurance because of their lack of evidence.
When public insurance doesn’t pay, private insurance may step in. And private insurance programs, from my observation, tend to be less evidence-based than public programs. They’re often offered as a benefit to employees, and so the occasional massage may be seen as a nice perk, even though it may not be medically necessary.
Australia has a comprehensive public healthcare system which is supplemented by private insurance to cover the cost of treatments and service that are not publicly funded. In 2015 the Australian government completed a review of “natural” treatments, including homeopathy, which were covered by private plans to determine if these therapies were effective, safe, and provided good value for money. While you might wonder why a government would care about what private insurance covers, it’s because the Australian government offers a rebate on insurance premiums, effectively subsidizing their cost.
With respect to homeopathy, the authors of the review looked at the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council report as part of this review. They noted that there is little high-quality evidence, the available evidence is not compelling, and overall fails to demonstrate that homeopathy is an effective treatment for any condition. Subsequently, the Australian government has removed coverage for all 17 therapies studied in the initial review, including homeopathy. What this meant was that while people can still choose to access these therapies, they cannot be offered as benefits under these (subsidized) private insurance programs.
Homeopathy is ineffective
    • I have written about homeopathy more time that I would like – it’s probably my most frequent topic. Since I started practicing pharmacy I have seen it move from a very fringe product to one that is easy to find in every pharmacy. To be clear, what people want to do with their own money and with full understanding of the facts is entirely their decision. If you’ve never bought it before, homeopathy is not cheap: Its prices are comparable to conventional products that actually have medicine in it. Given the lack of efficacy however, every dollar spent on homeopathy – particularly by insurance programs – is a waste of resources, in that it could otherwise be put to more effective use — for plausible treatments, or anything else, for that matter.

Russian Academy of Sciences Calls Homeopathy Pseudoscience
That homeopathy is pure pseudoscience is not news. Its basic principles are essentially magic, and the preparation of homeopathic products is indistinguishable from brewing a magic potion. Its two core principles, as the commission states, are a priori dogma – that like cures like, and that diluting substances out of existence leaves behind their magical essence. Science has progressed over two centuries since these ideas were invented, and they remain just as much pseudoscience as they every were – more, in fact, because the more we learn about chemistry, biology, and physics the less plausible homeopathy becomes.
Steven Novella on February 8, 2017
Link

Despite our many political differences, here is one topic about which the United States and Russia should be able to completely agree – homeopathy is pure pseudoscience. In fact Russia may have just taken the lead on this topic.
The Commission Against Pseudoscience and Falsification of Scientific Research of the Presidium of the Russian Academy of Sciences just published a memorandum (“№2”, so I assume it is only their second) called: “About pseudoscientific homeopathy.” (It’s in Russian but just hit the Google Translate button.) Like the UK and Australia before them, members of the commission reviewed all the evidence regarding homeopathy and concluded:
The Commission argues that the treatment of ultra-low doses of various substances used in homeopathy has no scientific basis. This conclusion is based on a thorough analysis of publications in scientific journals, clinical study reports, compilation and systematic reviews. The Commission confirms that the principles of homeopathy and theoretical explanation of the mechanisms of its alleged actions contradict the known chemical, physical and biological laws and convincing experimental confirmation of its effectiveness are not available. Homeopathic diagnosis and treatment should be qualified as pseudoscientific.
In other words, homeopathy cannot possibly work, and when studied it does not work. How many scientific organizations around the world have to come to this conclusion before governments wake up and do their job?
That homeopathy is pure pseudoscience is not news. Its basic principles are essentially magic, and the preparation of homeopathic products is indistinguishable from brewing a magic potion. Its two core principles, as the commission states, are a priori dogma – that like cures like, and that diluting substances out of existence leaves behind their magical essence. Science has progressed over two centuries since these ideas were invented, and they remain just as much pseudoscience as they every were – more, in fact, because the more we learn about chemistry, biology, and physics the less plausible homeopathy becomes.
Before I get into the details of the commission’s specific recommendations, let’s take a moment to notice that there is a Commission Against Pseudoscience and Falsification of Scientific Research in the Russian Academy of Sciences. How wonderful is that? Mainstream scientific organizations need to realize that promoting science and countering pseudoscience go hand-in-hand. You can’t really have one without the other. Understanding and combating pseudoscience as a systemic cultural issue, however, never seems to be on the radar of such organizations.
The American Academy for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) and the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) do not have such commissions, but they should. They put together panels on scientific integrity and may tackle issues one at a time, but there is no central coordinated effort to combat pseudoscience as a phenomenon. The Russian Commission’s memorandum on homeopathy is an excellent example of why there should be.
Specific recommendations
Each nation has its own regulation infrastructure, and so exactly how such recommendations are implemented (by which agency) will vary, but the details could apply anywhere. The commission’s recommendations are aimed at their Ministry of Health. They state that the adoption of homeopathy as part of the standard of care 20 years ago was undertaken without any systematic review of the scientific evidence. This error should be corrected by excluding homeopathy from any updates to the standard of care.
Their recommendations for labeling homeopathic products are interesting, and may even be a template for the FDA, which is currently reviewing its own regulation of homeopathy. First, they state that homeopathic products should be clearly labels as homeopathic. Any homeopathic preparation that is C12 or greater (“C” means a 1 to 100 dilution, so C12 is such a dilution 12 times) would likely leave behind no original ingredient. Therefore, they argue, such substances should not be included in the list of ingredients. That makes perfect sense. Therefore the ingredients list would include only things like water and sucrose which are actually in the final product.
For substances diluted out of existence, they suggest a separate list labeled “Used in preparation.” This can still cause some confusion, in my opinion, but at least they will not be listed as “ingredients.”
Further they recommend that products be monitored to make sure they do not contain actual active ingredients and are bypassing regulation by labeling them “homeopathic.” This is also a good idea, especially in light of recent events, such as the FDA warning about homeopathic teething products containing dangerous levels of belladonna.
They further recommend that products cannot advertise that they have medicinal properties that are not proven. This is similar to the recent FTC decision regarding homeopathic product labeling.
Finally, they specifically recommend that doctors be trained in popular medical pseudoscience and what the scientific evidence says about them. This way doctors will be better able to inform their patients who might inquire about such products.
All of these recommendations are spot on. I will note that while all of these measures will be positive, there is one measure that would be even more elegant and effective – simply ban the sale of homeopathic products. Homeopathy is fake medicine. Its sole reason for existing is to defraud the public by making or implying false medical claims for a completely worthless and inert product. (At best it’s inert, and sometimes may actually contain potentially harmful substances.)
Regulatory agencies are otherwise playing a game with the homeopathy industry. You can nibble away at homeopathic products by requiring accuracy in labeling, and evidence before making clinical claims. In the end, if product labeling was fully accurate and devoid of statements which mislead the public, what would you have? You would have a product without any active ingredients and without even the implication of any medicinal effect. Sellers will try to sneak by with statements and caveats, but the bottom line is that they will continue to do their best to deceive the public while regulatory agencies try to box them in.
As the FTC recently affirmed, the purpose of the agency is to protect the public from fraudulent health products. There is no such thing as a homeopathic product that is not a fraudulent health product, because there is no legitimate use of such products. Even if the package were thoroughly stripped of any misleading claims, the industry would still generate demand for their fraudulent products in other ways, such as through testimonials on websites.
I understand that the real issue here is consumer freedom – although it’s really about the freedom of an industry to sell a fraudulent product with misleading claims. The consumer is only free to waste money and potentially harm their health. The dance that regulatory agencies are doing is maintaining consumer freedom and choice while creating the illusion of proper regulation. Listing a substance as “prepared with” rather than an actual ingredient may be technically more accurate, but I doubt it will have a significant impact on the consumer.
As Daniel Patrick Moynihan is quoted as saying, “Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.” That homeopathy cannot and does not work is a well-established scientific fact about which there is deep scientific consensus. Doctors don’t get to make up their own medical facts. They have to practice according to the evidence-based standard of care. Engineers don’t get to use “alternative theories” when designing a bridge. Public schools should not be able to teach whatever they think is science. Industries don’t get to make up their own facts about their products. That’s called fraud.
Where the science is uncertain, there is room for opinions. There is no uncertainty about homeopathy. Any other conclusion is science-denial, and not just denial of the clinical evidence that shows homeopathy doesn’t work, but of vast areas of basic science across several fields. To deny this conclusion is to deny the scientific enterprise itself.
As a society we should listen to the scientific community and act accordingly. All that is lacking here is the political will. This latest statement from the Russian Academy of Sciences adds to other similar reviews and statement, and hopefully we are inching closer to that political will.

   Taking On Homeopathy in Germany
Steven Novella
Link
Homeopathy is having a bad year. From a scientific point of view, it has had a couple of bad centuries. The progress of our scientific understanding of biology, chemistry, and physics has failed to confirm any of the core beliefs of homeopathy. Like does not cure like (this is a form of superstition known as sympathetic magic, with no basis in science). Diluting substances does not make them stronger – a notion that violates the chemical law of mass action and the laws of thermodynamics. And countless clinical studies have shown that homeopathic preparations are nothing more than placebos. That homeopathy cannot work and does not work is settled science, as much as it is possible for science to be settled.
Despite the science, homeopathy has persevered through a combination of cultural inertia and political support. But in the last year there are signs that this trend may be reversing. In the UK The House of Commons Science and Technology Committee (STC) released a report, Evidence Check 2: Homeopathy, in which they conclude that homeopathy is failed science and should be completely abandoned – no further support in the NHS and no further research.
Following that the British Medical Association has openly called for an NHS ban on homeopathy, calling the practice “witchcraft.”
Now German politicians are starting to echo the same sentiments.
Karl Lauterbach, the centre-left Social Democrats’ chair on the Bundestag health committee, told German news magazine Der Spiegel that insurers should be “prohibited from paying for homeopathy.”
and
According to Spiegel, Rainer Hess of the Federal Joint Committee for doctors and insurers also characterized the current situation as “extremely unsatisfactory.”
The common thread in the UK and Germany is rising health care costs, which is creating the political will to oppose worthless interventions like homeopathy. Up until now systems like homeopathy which are not science-based have received political support from individual believers and promoted largely through the notion of “health care freedom.” But the political climate is changing, and suddenly paying for interventions that do not work seems unnecessarily wasteful. This creates an opportunity to focus attention on interventions like homeopathy.
In Germany, as in the US, homeopathy has received support from individual politicians. According to the cited news article:
“There have already been many attempts to drop protective provisions on such remedies, but influential politicians have consistently prevented this from happening,” Hess said, adding that despite hundreds of medical studies failing to clearly prove the benefits of homeopathics, insurers are still made to pay for them.
It sounds like Germany has had their own Tom Harkin and Orin Hatch to contend with. Political support for homeopathy in the US actually goes back much further. In 1938 Senator Royal Copeland from New York, a homeopath, managed to insert into the new FDA regulations automatic approval for homeopathic products. This situation continues to today – homeopathic products do not require any testing for safety and efficacy.
It is good to hear that politicians in Germany are now openly discussing not only removing the protections that force insurance companies to pay for homeopathy, but actually banning insurance companies from paying for it. This would be similar to the BMA proposed ban on NHS support for homeopathy.
In both cases no one is proposing that homeopathy itself be banned. If an individual wants to pay for water in the mistaken belief that it is an effective remedy, they are free to do so. However, the seller should not be free to make misleading or fraudulent claims – but that is a different type of regulation. What is now being discussed in Germany and the UK is simply preventing public money from being spent on treatments which have already been proven not to work.
I would like to see these efforts spread to the US. We are facing our own health care crisis here, with a new focus on cost-effective medicine. Amazingly, Harkin was able to hijack efforts to deal with the situation (through “Obamacare”) to increase public support for unscientific medicine. This trend needs to reverse – and homeopathy seems like the low-hanging fruit to me.
With homeopathy the science could not be more clear, and recent exhaustive reviews, like Evidence Check 2: Homeopathy, have shown that it simply does not work. It should therefore be an easy political position to take, that our limited health care dollars should not be spent on ineffective medicine.

Homeopathy Declining in Germany
Homeopathy is on the decline in Germany and elsewhere, partly due to the dedicated action of skeptics.
Steven Novella on December 16, 2020
Link

Recently David Gorski and I felt compelled to respond to a misguided commentary by Dr. Vinay Prasad in which he flogged the long dead horse of ivory tower academics wondering out loud why anyone would bother communicating science to the masses, especially confronting pseudoscience, misinformation, conspiracy theories, and fraud (yuk!). This was especially disappointing because we should be natural allies, as we all advocate for increased science-based standards throughout medicine. He had two primary points, the first being that such topics are too easy and therefore beneath true experts. He misses the point, however, that while the underlying science may often be a slam-dunk, the social, cultural, and psychological phenomenon of belief in pseudoscience and how to confront it is very complex and challenging. His apparent ignorance of this entire field does not make it simple.
His second main point is that pseudoscience in medicine is not a big deal (the old – “what’s the harm” argument) – if, essentially, people are wearing copper bracelets. Ironically this second point mainly reflects his ignorance of the first point. He used homeopathy as one of his main examples, which does perfectly represent everything wrong with his argument. Yes, the science showing that homeopathy is probably impossible is a slam-dunk. Homeopathy uses fanciful ingredients based on magical thinking and then dilutes them in most cases out of existence, claiming that their “essence” is left behind. There are multiple ways to demonstrate the absurdity of these claims from a scientific point of view, although, there are some nuances that a novice might miss, such as the claims for “water memory”.
Prasad’s error is in thinking that, once we have explained the math, chemistry, and physics that renders homeopathy pseudoscience, we are done, and can move on to more important issues. But what about the clinical trial evidence looking at homeopathic treatment? This too is resoundingly negative, but this did not stop a Cochrane systematic review from claiming that in some cases homeopathic treatments are “promising” and deserve more study. In fact, homeopathy is a perfect test case, a real-world meta-experiment, that nicely demonstrates why we need science-based medicine rather than just evidence-based medicine, and also all the things that Prasad himself advocates for in clinical trials.
Further still, his apparent belief that pseudoscience in medicine is a small problem is demonstrably false, and also betrays a very American-centric view of medicine. I was recently reminded of this by an article by Edzard Ernst (someone Prasad can look to who models how an academic can confront pseudoscience and improve quality in medicine). The article is an update to one he wrote 17 months ago about homeopathy in Germany (I also wrote about this – in 2010 – so this process has been going on for a while). Homeopathy is deeply embedded in German mainstream medicine, part of medical training with the option to get additional licensure as a “homeopath”. Insurance companies reimburse for homeopathic treatments.
However, over the last decade or so this has been slowly changing. What Ernst noticed last year was that:
In the last few years, several individuals in Germany have, from entirely different angles, taken a fresh look at the evidence on homeopathy and found it to be desperately wanting. Independent of each other, they published articles and books about their research and insights. Here are 5 examples:
Die Homöopathie-Lüge: So gefährlich ist die Lehre von den weißen Kügelchen, Christian Weymayr, Nicole Heißmann, 2012
In Sachen Homöopathie: Eine Beweisaufnahme, Norbert Aust, 2013
Homöopathie neu gedacht: Was Patienten wirklich hilft, Natalie Grams, 2015
Der Glaube an die Globuli: Die Verheißungen der Homöopathie, Norbert Schmacke, Bernd Hontschik, 2015
Der wahrscheinlich teuerste Zucker der Welt: Was Sie über Homöopathie und Alternativmedizin wissen sollten, Oliver Grunau, 2017
As soon as those ivory tower scientists starting paying attention, they started to realize that homeopathy just doesn’t deliver the goods. Even leaving the extreme scientific implausibility aside, the clinical evidence is not there. Homeopathy does not work. After 200 years homeopathy has nothing to show for itself scientifically, and it is hard to argue that this is due to bias against this practice when Germany considers itself the home of homeopathy, with a massive cultural bias in its favor.
Ernst also noted that the response of homeopaths, especially when their sales started to drop, was typical for CAM proponents – they did not marshal better evidence, look inward at their practices, or talk about reform. No – they went on a marketing blitz. Further, this marketing was largely framed around vicious personal attacks against the scientists who were simply pointing out that homeopathy is literally nothing. As Ernst points out, their personal attacks took familiar forms: “we are incompetent, we do not care about the welfare of patients, we are habitual liars, we are on the payroll of the pharmaceutical industry, we aim at limiting patient choice, we do what we do because we crave the limelight”. This is all ho-hum, just another day for skeptics.
Still, Ernst was optimistic because we have science on our side. He writes now to point out that recent developments have been moving away from homeopathy in Germany:
I have just received the news that the Board of the Bavarian Medical Association has unanimously decided in the meeting on 5.12. to remove the additional training in homeopathy from the medical training regulations. UNANIMOUSLY!!!11 of 17 medical associations have kicked homeopathy. That leaves 6. The next decision is due in Berlin.
This means that in most German counties (there is hope that, sooner or later, the other 6 will follow suit), doctors will no longer be able to train in homeopathy and use the title ‘homeopath’.
This is great news, and hopefully this trend will continue. We also need to end insurance reimbursement for homeopathy. These trends also need to be exported to every country in the world.
I do differ a little from Ernst’s optimism – I do not think such victories are inevitable, simply because we have science on our side. As he points out, this progress took 200 years to come. It is also too early to say if this will be a long term trend, or if this is just a blip on the otherwise-endless commercial success of homeopathy. False beliefs and rank pseudoscience can become essentially permanently embedded in cultures. Look at chi/qi in Asian culture, or Ayurveda in India. Sure, the trained scientists may reject pseudoscience and superstition, but not the billions of people living in those regions. Homeopathy in Europe is similar, although arguably not buried quite as deep. We cannot be complacent and delude ourselves that it will be easy to permanently banish homeopathic pseudoscience from medicine.
We are also making progress against homeopathy in the US, UK, and Australia. But in these countries also, homeopathy is far from gone, and past experience is that such beliefs are like vampires, they keep rising from the dead. The bottom line is that there are billions of dollars to be made selling just homeopathy (let alone the rest of medical pseudoscience) and that is powerful motivation to keep it alive.
I will also point out that what progress has been made is largely due to dedicated skeptical campaigns. In some cases this is more obvious than in others (the UK is probably the most obvious example), but it seems clear that constant pressure from skeptics, especially skeptics within the medical profession, is what is slowly turning this ship. We cannot let up on this pressure now – the other side certainly won’t.
And this pressure from skeptics is by far most effective when it occurs in collaboration with mainstream doctors and scientists. This collaboration is critical, and is why tackling pseudoscience, fraud, and conspiracy theories should not be ignored, and should not be relegated to a small band of dedicated skeptics. It needs to be part of mainstream scientific activity.
The ideal situation is for there to be a recognized and respected specialty that combines the public understanding of science (traditional science communication) with an understanding of pseudoscience, science-denial, conspiracy thinking, the philosophy of science, and media literacy (i.e. scientific skepticism). But combined with this needs to be a recognition among academics of all stripes that science communication, critical thinking, and media literacy are important, and that as part of their regular duties they should collaborate with the experts, to combine their topic expertise with skeptical expertise to fight misinformation and pseudoscience in society.
Where we see exactly this type of collaboration is where we have had the most success, such as in pushing back against the pseudoscience of homeopathy. We can also clearly see the dire need for such collaboration while we are in the middle of a deadly pandemic and yet there is popular pushback and misinformation regarding the vaccines that are the only plausible path out of this pandemic. This is also why Prasad’s commentary is so toxic, and why he needs to seriously reconsider his position.

   1023 2011
Steven Novella
Link
The 1023 campaign is a UK based organization whose purpose is to raise awareness of the actual claims of homeopathy. The name is a reference to Avogadro’s number (6.02214179×10^23), which is the number of atoms or molecules of a substance in one unit called a mole. This is an important basic concept in chemistry, for it means that there are a finite number of bits of a substance in any solution, which further means that solutions cannot be infinitely diluted. You cannot have fractions of a molecule of any substance. There is therefore a dilutional limit – a point beyond which if you further dilute a solution you are increasingly likely to have removed all of the original substance.
Homeopathic preparations frequently use serial dilutions that vastly exceed this dilutional limit. This is a central fallacy of homeopathy (what homeopaths call a “law” of homeopathy). Samuel Hahnemann, who invented the fiction of homeopathy, knew about the dilutional limit but believed that substances gave their magical essence to water when diluted. Modern homeopaths believe this too, but in order to make their nonsense more marketable to a 21st century culture a tad more used to science (or at least scientific jargon) than Hahnemann’s, they have desperately tried to wrap “magical essence” in sciencey technobabble.
The 1023 campaign’s main purpose is public awareness. It appears that the best tool defenders of science-based medicine have against homeopathy is simply to make the public aware of what it actually is. I have not found any good surveys that quantify public beliefs on the subject (sounds like a good project) but it is my subjective experience (and that of many of my colleagues) from talking to countless patients and acquaintances that many if not most people are simply not aware of what homeopathy actually is. The term is often conflated with herbal or “natural” remedies. Shock and disbelief is a common reaction to explanations of what homeopaths actually claim.
Therefore there is much to be gained by raising public awareness of what homeopathy is, so at least it doesn’t get a free pass out of simple ignorance. As part of this mission the 1023 campaign has had a public event in which groups around the world commit “homeopathic suicide” by massively overdosing on a homeopathic product. This is a stunt, but it is effective in garnering media attention, and so meets the mission of public awareness.
There is now a new event planned:
While international participation is yet to be announced, the challenge will culminate in a demonstration in Manchester on February 6th, at the ‘QED: Question. Explore. Discover. event, with over 300 protesters participating the largest ever single demonstration against homeopathy.
They also wisely add a word of caution – not all homeopathic remedies are highly diluted. Some products “cheat” by including measurable amounts of an active ingredient, and so a real overdose is possible. Before attempting such a demonstration, therefore, one should be sure that the product is truly “homeopathic” and contains, essentially, nothing.
These efforts are essential as the amount of misinformation available to the public about homeopathy and other medical pseudoscience is immense. For example, we have complained extensively about the National Center for Complimentary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM) and their soft promotion of nonsense. On their homeopathy page, for example, they write:
If You Are Thinking About Using Homeopathy
* Do not use homeopathy as a replacement for proven conventional care or to postpone seeing a doctor about a medical problem.
* Look for published research studies on homeopathy for the health condition you are interested in.
* If you are considering using homeopathy and decide to seek treatment from a homeopath, ask about the training and experience of the practitioner you are considering.
* Women who are pregnant or nursing, or people who are thinking of using homeopathy to treat a child, should consult their health care provider.
* Tell all your health care providers about any complementary and alternative practices you use. Give them a full picture of all you do to manage your health. This will ensure coordinated and safe care. For tips about talking with your health care providers about CAM, see NCCAM’s Time to Talk campaign.
The first recommendation is very important, but the fact is that once in the hands of a homeopath there is no guarantee that homeopathic nostrums will not be used instead of effective medicine. Homeopaths believe that their magic water works for treating and preventive real disease, and they are often hostile to science-based medicine. For example, there in an ongoing scandal regarding the use of homeopathic products instead of effective treatment for malaria. So this recommendation is like saying, “If you are going to play 3-card monte on the streets of New York, be sure you don’t get cheated,” when the only effective advice is, “don’t play, it’s a scam.”
The second recommendation to look for published research is ridiculous – while I am all in favor of patients being well-informed, it is not reasonable advice to tell the average patient to do the research for themselves to determine which treatments are safe and effective. That is the job of professionals and professional organizations. The body of research on homeopathy is large and complex, and it takes time and expertise to sort through it and come to a meaningful conclusion about what the evidence says. It seems like the NCCAM is trying to avoid doing this themselves – but isn’t that part of their mission? In fact experts have combed through the research, such as this review by Edzard Ernst, and have found that the clinical evidence shows that homeopathy does not work for any indication. Shouldn’t the NCCAM just state that?
Next they suggest you ask about the training and experience of the practitioner. But training and experience in nonsense is meaningless. There is no evidence that the training and experience of a homeopath means anything, or allows them to effectively treat any condition. This is akin to advising that one seek the council of only experienced psychics, or well-trained astrologers. And make sure you only consult certified numerologists.
The caution regarding women who are pregnant or nursing makes it sound like there is some potential effect from homeopathic treatment, which there isn’t (unless, as I stated above, they are not really homeopathic and sneak in some actual drugs). This recommendation also makes it sound like if you are not pregnant or treating a child you don’t have to consult your health care provider.
The last recommendation is the only one that is reasonable – patients should disclose their use of all treatments to their physicians. Although again, it is carefully worded to imply that the primary purpose is “coordinating” (or integrating) fake treatment with real medicine.
These recommendations, from a government agency allegedly dedicated to science and health, are an embarrassment. Here is what the recommendations should say:
If You Are Thinking About Using Homeopathy
* Do not use homeopathy. It is dangerous nonsense.
I much prefer the 1023 summary of what homeopathy is to the NCCAM’s.
Homeopathy is an unscientific and absurd pseudoscience, which persists today as an accepted form of complementary medicine, despite there never having been any reliable scientific evidence that it works.
Nuff said.

   Homeopathic Thuggery
Steven Novella
Link
There have been many cases now of big companies or organizations, or wealthy individuals, threatening to sue or actually suing a blogger for libel. The most famous case is that of Simon Singh who was sued by the British Chiropractic Association over comments he made in an article. Simon braved through the expensive and exhaustive legal process (which is especially onerous in England), but he is not just a lone blogger. He is a successful author and was writing for the Guardian. Eventually the BCA was forced to drop the case – but only after the blogging community rallied behind Simon, magnifying his criticisms of the BCA by orders of magnitude. By all accounts it was a PR disaster.
The blogging community as a whole is rather passionate about this issue. We exist on the premise of free and open public discourse about important issues. At SBM we take on many controversial issues and we don’t pull our punches when criticizing what we see as pseudoscience in medicine. So of course we take notice when a large company tries to bully a blogger to silence their legitimate criticism.
According to the BMJ this has happened yet again – this time the international homeopathy producer, Boiron, is threatening a lone Italian blogger because he dared to criticize their product, Oscillococcinum. The blogger, Samuele Riva, wrote two articles on his blog, blogzero.it, criticizing what our own Mark Crislip has called “oh-so-silly-coccinum.” The blog is entirely in Italian, but he is maintaining a page in English with updates on the Boiron vs Blogzero affair.
Criticizing homeopathy is always fun, because it is at the extreme absurd end of the silly pseudoscience spectrum, even among some stiff competition. But now homeopathy has a corporate face in Boiron – a large multinational corporation based in France. Boiron is the largest manufacturer of homeopathic products in the world and the second largest manufacturer of over-the-counter products in France.
What they are doing to this small blogger, in my opinion, is nothing less than corporate thuggery. They are using their resources and their corporate lawyers to try to silence completely legitimate criticism of their pseudoscientific products. Of course, they will only succeed in magnifying that criticism.
For example, Riva suggested that Boiron’s oscillococcinum has no active ingredient. Well, let’s see- the company lists the active ingredient in this product as “Anas barbariae hepatis et cordis extractum 200CK HPUS.” The “200C” means that the listed ingredient was diluted with a 1:100 dilution 200 times. Serial dilution is a funny thing – a 200c dilution is the equivalent of diluting 1ml of original ingredient into a volume of water that is the size of the known universe. This is far far beyond the point where there is any reasonable chance of there being even a single molecule of original ingredient left.
So Riva was completely justified (as have many other critics) in saying that Boiron’s 200c product has no active ingredient. In fact it is deceptive to list something that has been diluted 200C as an “active ingredient.”
Not that it matters in this case, because the original ingredient is a pseudoscience unto itself. Mark Crislip gives the full details, here is his summary:
In the 1919 flu epidemic a physician who did not understand that artifacts on the slide, probably bubbles, move randomly due to Brownian motion. Looking at the tissues of flu patients with a microscope, he found what he thought was not only the cause of influenza, but the cause of all diseases: small cocci (round balls) that oscillated under the microscope. He found these wiggling bubbles in all the tissues of all the ill people he examined and thought he discovered the true cause of all disease. Sigh. Yet another cause of all illness. He is the only person, before or since, to see these oscillating cocci. Hence the name.
That’s right, oscillococcinum does not even exist – essentially Boiron takes fairy dust and then dilutes it out of (non)existence. The “anas barbariea hepatis” is basically duck liver, which is supposed to contain the most concentrated nonexistent oscillococcinum. It’s a pseudoscience trifecta.
Boiron claims that their product treats the symptoms of flu. What does the evidence show? (Yes, there is evidence – someone bothered to test whether diluted fairy dust actually works)? Well, this is yet another interesting story. Oscillococcinum was at the center of another embarrassing controversy, this one involving the Cochrane Collaboration. They published a Cochrane review of Oscillococcinum for the flu, and the authors concluded:
Though promising, the data were not strong enough to make a general recommendation to use Oscillococcinum for first-line treatment of influenza and influenza-like syndromes. Further research is warranted but the required sample sizes are large. Current evidence does not support a preventative effect of Oscillococcinum-like homeopathic medicines in influenza and influenza-like syndromes.
This review became the poster child for what is wrong with Cochrane’s particular application of evidence-based medicine (EBM). Notice that the evidence is essentially negative, but with some positive studies – which is what we expect when studying a fancy placebo because of researcher and publication bias. But the authors concluded that the treatment is “promising” and “further research is warranted.” An SBM review of the same data would come to a very different conclusion – the data is what we would expect from an ineffective treatment. Further, the highly implausible nature of the treatment (on several levels) warrants a conclusion that it does not work, it holds no promise, and not another dime of precious research money should be wasted chasing this fantasy.
Eventually the Cochrane review was withdrawn. We interpreted this as a minor victory for SBM, although we have no way of knowing what role, if any, our criticism played in the decision to withdraw the review.
Conclusion
I hope Boiron does draw a line in the sand over their oscillococcinum product, and that it becomes the center piece of a broader public discussion about homeopathy. Most of the public does not understand what homeopathy actually is. They think it means “natural” or “herbal” medicine. They have no idea that homeopathy is about taking fanciful ingredients with a dubious connection to the symptoms in the first place, and then diluting them into oblivion, then placing a drop of the pure water that remains and placing it on a sugar pill. The resultant pill is then supposed to contain the magic vibrations of the original substance.
This rank pseudoscience, which has no place in 21st century medicine, is the business of Boiron. Let’s see them try to defend themselves and their products. Let’s see them harass bloggers and those who are just trying to expose the public to the truth. Let’s see them argue in public how air bubbles in duck liver fantastically diluted can treat the flu.

France To End Reimbursement for Homeopathy
Setback for homeopathy in France as a government agency actually does its job, but the fight against pseudoscience is long from over.
Steven Novella on July 10, 2019
Link

It’s nice to occasionally see elected officials do the right thing, especially when it is against popular opinion. Earlier this year a French independent health scientific advisory group, HAS (Haute Autorite de Sante, or French National Authority for Health) was tasked with evaluating the effectiveness of homeopathy. Health minister Agnes Buzyn agreed at the time to abide by their recommendation.
It’s always easy to predict what such reviews will find, although it can be difficult to predict how they will spin the results. There is now overwhelming scientific evidence, including hundreds of studies, that show that homeopathy does not work for any indication. This is now supported by multiple independent systematic reviews. Even if we put aside the scientific plausibility question (which we shouldn’t) and just look at the clinical evidence – that evidence is overwhelmingly negative.
Of course, if you do look at plausibility this result is no surprise, as homeopathy has a scientific plausibility as close to zero as you can get. When a UK science advisory panel reviewed the evidence, they concluded homeopathy was witchcraft.
France, however, has always been a bastion of support for this particular pseudoscience. The company Boiron, which is the largest manufacturer of this magic water, is located in France, employs about 3,600 people, most in France, and 60% of its sales are in France.
So it reaffirmed my faith in the ability for some people, sometimes, to put good quality science ahead of ideology when the HAS concluded its review and found that homeopathy does not work:
For nine months the HAS watchdog investigated the effects of the alternative medicine on 24 medical conditions, including anxiety, foot warts and acute breathing infections and said it did not find sufficient scientific evidence to justify continued state reimbursement of homeopathic drugs.
Now, I have to point out that, the way scientific evidence works, it is technically more accurate to say that there is insufficient evidence to support the conclusion that there are any specific effects of homeopathic potions beyond placebo for any indication tested. But after hundreds of studies for dozens of indications, all failing to find sufficient evidence for efficacy, we can fairly summarize that result by saying that homeopathy does not work (at least that is the simplest interpretation of the data).
I still get the tingles when I think of a government looking for objective scientific evidence to inform a specific policy decision. Better yet – imagine if they actually act appropriately on that evidence. Apparently, that is exactly what happened. True to her word, the Health Minister announced that France will phase out reimbursement for homeopathic products by 2021.
The government initially aims to cut refunds for the drugs from 30% of their cost to 15% as of January 2020 as a first step, she added. “That will give manufacturers time to get organised,” Buzyn said.
This was in the face of protests and opposition from – you guessed it – Boiron. They whined that this will cost them money. Uh – that’s the point. They also played the “freedom” card:
“Depriving French people of their freedom to choose (their treatment) is totally misaligned with the demands and needs of patients,” Boiron said in a statement, adding it had been due to meet Buzyn this Thursday and was shocked by the decision.
No – what patients need is transparency to make proper informed decisions, and a reasonable standard of evidence to determine safety and efficacy. Selling patients worthless magic beans with false claims and misleading and confusing labeling is not freedom.
What about homeopathy is other countries? Europe has always been the cultural center of homeopathy. It has been traditionally very popular in Austria, when it was first developed. If you ever visit Austria you will see homeopathic pharmacies everywhere – it is incorporated into the culture.
In the UK the popularity of homeopathy has historically been boosted by the royal family, who are fans. Prince Charles, in fact, recently became a patron of the Faculty of Homeopathy. There were even, until recently, homeopathic hospitals. But a relentless campaign by scientists and science advocates, led by the Good Thinking Society, has chipped away at NHS support for homeopathy. If you read the NHS website on homeopathy, it is a reasonable good treatment of the topic, that plainly states the scientific status of this pseudoscience but without using inflammatory language.
In the US our regulatory infrastructure is different. Homeopathy was essentially grandfathered into the FDA, where all homeopathic entries in the Materia Medica (and its supplements) are considered drugs. The FDA has the power to regulate homeopathic “drugs” but has mostly chosen not to, because the market was too small to be worth their limited resources.
However, recently the FDA has reconsidered this policy, and decided that it would crack down on what it considers to be the most harmful homeopathic products, those targeted to serious medical illnesses, like cancer.
On December 18, 2017, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) proposed a new, risk-based enforcement approach to drug products labeled as homeopathic. FDA re-examined its enforcement approach because the homeopathic drug industry has grown and we need to better address situations where homeopathic treatments are being marketed for serious diseases and/or conditions but where the products have not been shown to offer clinical benefits.
The FTC has also reconsidered its policy toward the marketing of homeopathy, and has rolled out harsher regulations requiring greater transparency and understandability in labeling:
The policy statement explains that the FTC will hold efficacy and safety claims for OTC homeopathic drugs to the same standard as other products making similar claims. That is, companies must have competent and reliable scientific evidence for health-related claims, including claims that a product can treat specific conditions. The statement describes the type of scientific evidence that the Commission requires of companies making such claims for their products.
However, even though this statement was made in 2016, I do not see any effect as of yet. If you look at homeopathic products, like the one above, a flu “remedy” from Boiron, it still contains all the elements that the FTC said would no longer be acceptable. It makes false claims about effects, it does not explain was “300CK” means, it lists “active ingredients” in Latin names, not plain English, and even when they are not present in the final product. This is the exact false and misleading advertising the FTC said it would crack down on.
Homeopathy remains a giant scam on the public with essentially zero plausibility and copious evidence for lack of efficacy. Governments around the world are moving in the right direction, but not nearly enough. We need to keep the pressure on, and keep educating the public about what homeopathy actually is, i.e. nothing.

   What is the Harm?

Homeopathy is Worthless and Not Always Harmless
More cases of homeopathic contamination remind us that it is beyond time to properly regulate this pseudoscience.
Steven Novella on June 17, 2020
Link

Most people don’t really know what homeopathy is, thinking it is some vague form of “natural” medicine. But those in the know understand that homeopathy is literally nothing – it is water. Any starting ingredients have been diluted to such an extent that effectively nothing is left. As I like to say, it is fairy dust diluted out of existence.
However, this fact not only leads to the ineluctable conclusion that homeopathy is worthless, it also leads to the conclusion that it is harmless, at least directly (there is always harm from wasting resources and depending on ineffective treatment). Unfortunately, we cannot count on this conclusion, because homeopathic products don’t always dilute their starting ingredients to negligible levels. Recent FDA warnings make this clear.
The FDA announced that they sent warning letter to four manufacturers of injectable products labeled as homeopathic for containing dangerous levels of known poisons.
“The FDA’s drug approval requirements are designed to protect patients by ensuring, among other things, that drugs are safe and effective for their intended uses. These unapproved injectable drugs are particularly concerning because they inherently present greater risks to patients because of how they are administered,” said Donald D. Ashley, director of the Office of Compliance in the FDA’s Center for Drug Evaluation and Research. “These products are further concerning given that they are labeled to contain potentially toxic ingredients intended for injection directly into the body. These warning letters reflect our continued commitment to patient safety.”
The products in question contain mercury, lead, strychnine, and deadly nightshade. Diluting horrible toxins to negligible levels is standard homeopathic practice, so that in itself is not new. But the FDA found that these substances were present in wildly variable doses in tested product, and in some cases in potentially toxic doses. The four companies have 15 days to alter their practices or the FDA will take further action.
This is not the first time something like this has happened. In 2016 homeopathic teething gels were found to contain active ingredients like nightshade and were linked to the death of 10 infants. Also, we cannot assume that “just water” is harmless when the water itself is contaminated with pathogenic bacteria.
All of this is very concerning – but I was alarmed at the very fact that there are injectable homeopathic products. When you have an utterly worthless product, why raise the stakes of potential harm in this way? It’s reckless and unethical, and should itself be banned. Medical decision-making revolves around risk vs benefit – any potential risk of an intervention has to be reasonably outweighed by the potential benefit. But when a treatment has zero plausible benefit, like homeopathy, how do you justify any risk? I believe the only reasonable answer is – you can’t. The only way for the risk-benefit equation to balance when the potential benefit is zero is for the risk to be zero, and the only way for that to happen is to not use the treatment at all.
But the FDA has decided that as long as the risk is minimal they are happy. So they seem to be focusing on contamination and manufacturing quality, and all of the above examples indicate. They pay particular attention to injectables, because the inherent risks are higher.
There is a deeper problem here, however, that the FDA approach simply does not address. You cannot regulate a blatant pseudoscience – meaning, you cannot allow a pseudoscience in medicine to exist and think you are going to mitigate the harm by making sure the pseudoscience adheres to some standards. This is partly because there is an inherent contradiction here that cannot be overcome.
Effective regulation is science-based. So how can you have effective regulation of something that is inherently not science-based? I would argue that you can’t. What standards are you going to use? The FDA resorts to things like contamination, because that is something they can grab onto, but they can’t get to the core of the problem. In fact the risk is escalating under their watch.
The other main reason is that you cannot regulate con-artists – because the industry is based on deception and lies. If the entire industry functionally does not believe in science, then how can they adhere to scientific standards? This is why acupuncturists don’t wear gloves. We see the same thing in the herbal product industry, where contamination, substitution, and adulteration are rampant.
The only sustainable solution is not to think that you can regulate pseudoscience, but instead to ban it. The FDA should not seek to make homeopathy safe. Pseudoscience is inherently unsafe. They should use their authority, which they have, to protect the US public from obvious provable pseudoscience.
They write: “These warning letters reflect our continued commitment to patient safety”, but if they really were committed to patient safety they would simply use their authority to actually regulate homeopathy. Instead they choose to allow the industry to largely regulate itself, while they focus only on blatant cases of contamination and similar instances.
        ◦ All the FDA would have to do is use their authority to regulate homeopathic products like they do all other drugs (homeopathic products are legally drugs in the US). Require evidence of efficacy above placebo effects, because only such efficacy would justify any potential risk, no matter how small. If they did that the homeopathic industry would vanish like one of their ingredients – diluted away to nothing. They apparently are not willing to fight that political fight, but they should be. Instead they make themselves feel like they are doing their job by occasionally trimming back the worst abuses.

Belief in Homeopathy Results in the Death of a 7-Year-Old Italian Child
Yet another child has suffered and died because of belief in pseudomedical nonsense, this time when his parents chose homeopathy rather than appropriate medical evaluation.
Clay Jones on June 14, 2019
Link

First up, a bit of shameless self-promotion: I was interviewed by Ben Brown for the excellent Tourette’s Podcast and I invite everyone to check it out.
Also of note, the number of measles cases in the Unites States so far this year has now officially topped the 1,000 threshold. We are at 1,022 to be exact. This is likely going to be the new normal folks.
Despite this, celebrities keep coming out of the anti-vaccine closet. Jessica Biel denies being anti-vaccine, of course. She is claiming only to be speaking up for a family friend whose child has a medical vaccine exemption, although if this were true and it wasn’t purchased from an unethical pediatrician (B. Sears for example. No, too obvious. Bob S.), the bill that Biel is speaking against would actually help to protect a child who is unable to be fully immunized. Judging by her character witness, however, she’s anti-vaccine.
Now on to the always frustrating, and sometimes heartbreaking, business of “exploring issues & controversies in science and medicine”. I hope that over the years we have made it clear that the risks of virtually all so-called alternative approaches to healthcare outweigh any potential benefits. Though direct harm is uncommon, there is no such thing as a completely benign unscientific medical intervention. Even less common, although we have documented many examples on the pages of SBM, are deaths directly attributed to quackery. Sadly, here is one more.
This case involves the 2017 death of a 7-year-old Italian child whose parents chose to follow recommendations from a local practitioner of homeopathy when their child had an apparent ear infection. Citing their failure to give the child antibiotics, which according to the judge would have prevented the infection from spreading to the brain, the parents were found guilty of aggravated manslaughter and given suspended sentences of three months in prison. The child’s grandfather has defended the convicted couple, stating that they “resorted to homeopathy” only out of concern over the harmful effects of antibiotics and are not anti-medicine in general.
According to reports from the time of the child’s death, his first signs of illness involved a viral upper respiratory illness with fever. Rather than seeking care from the family pediatrician, they had him evaluated by a local homeopath. Homeopathy is popular in Italy, with about 16% of the population using it regularly, so this isn’t surprising at all. Sadly, but also not surprising, the family received dangerous advice, again according to the child’s grandfather:
He scared them by claiming that the doctors would give medication to Francesco that would make him deaf or would damage his liver. He promised them that Francesco will recover soon.
I found it odd that the conviction appears to be specifically based on the parents choosing not to give an antibiotic, rather than on their failure to seek appropriate medical care for what had to have been an extremely ill-appearing child. I don’t know if early intervention with antibiotics would have prevented a fatal outcome, although it is highly likely. The more recent reporting claims that he developed encephalitis, which was what supposedly killed him. I’m a bit skeptical of this, however.
Encephalitis is the term for inflammation involving the brain, and is almost always caused by a viral infection such as herpes simplex virus, although there can be rare bacterial (Lyme disease for example) or even autoimmune causes. It is not something I think of as a potential complication of an untreated bacterial ear infection, and it is not something that would respond to antibiotics commonly prescribed for them. Earlier reports are more likely to be accurate as they discuss the development of a brain abscess (collection of pus), which is a rare but very possible sequelae of an untreated bacterial ear infection. He likely died from a combination of the abscess and meningitis that resulted in cerebral edema, coma, and ultimately brain death.
When he was finally brought to a local hospital after two weeks of suffering, it was too late. Piecing things together from several reports since 2017, he was already (brain) dead or at least close to it on presentation. Surgical drainage of the brain abscess was attempted but it didn’t help. Support was withdrawn after an EEG showed no brain activity and his parents agreed to organ donation, so at least some other family could find hope in this tragedy.
Up next will be the September trial of the homeopath whose quackery resulted in the death of this child. He is being accused of negligence, naturally, and of “having underestimated the typical clinical picture of a highly serious local infection” in addition to sticking with homeopathic treatments despite clear failure to improve. I hope he is put away for a very long time.
The family may not have been anti-medicine. Some of the recent reports claim that they refused antibiotics, but I don’t think that’s accurate. I think they went to the homeopath and believed what they were told and what they wanted to believe.
Ultimately, I don’t have enough information to determine what was in their hearts. But they did have a worldview that left them vulnerable to dangerous pseudomedical advice and are victims in this as well. I’m begrudgingly okay with them not receiving significant jail time because I think that they are going to suffer enough, although there would need to be special consideration should there be other children in the home. My mind would certainly change should it come to light that they have an attitude similar to the parents of poor Ezekiel Stephan, who have been thoroughly unrepentant. Then they should rot in jail.
I’d like to give thanks to thanks to our good friend Edzard Ernst, whose own post led me to translations of the initial reporting from 2017 which provided the most helpful information.

Another Child Harmed by Pseudomedicine: Lead Poisoning from a “Homeopathic Healing” Bracelet
The CDC has published a report on yet another child harmed by exposure to a caregiver’s belief in quackery…and the toxic level of lead found in a “homeopathic” teething bracelet.
Clay Jones on September 8, 2017
Link
Just a couple of months ago I wrote about a report published by the CDC which presented the case of a newborn infant potentially harmed by their mother’s belief in the absurd practice of placentophagy. In that case, it was impossible to firmly conclude that the mother’s consumption of her dehydrated and encapsulated placenta actually caused a serious bacterial infection in the baby. The most reasonable conclusion, in my opinion, is that it increases the risk of such infections without any demonstrable benefit.
The CDC report
Today I’m writing about yet another example of how parental belief in pseudomedicine can harm children, based on another CDC “Notes from the Field” report published last week. In the report, the authors discuss the discovery of lead poisoning in a 9-month-old baby during routine screening last September. This was eventually linked to the use of a “homeopathic magnetic hematite healing bracelet.” In this case, there is a more firmly established causal connection. In fact, I don’t really think the link is even in doubt.
The child was found to have a blood lead level of 41 μg/dL, which based on my calculation is a lot higher than 5 μg/dL, the level generally considered to be abnormal, although we consider any amount of lead in the body of a child to be problematic and actionable. Even trace amounts in the blood require intervention in the form of home investigation, nutritional assessment, and close follow-up to make sure that the level doesn’t increase. Most experts strongly consider chelation at 45 μg/dL even in an asymptomatic child.
We get very few details in the report unfortunately, such as whether or not the child was overtly symptomatic or what happened in the year since the initial diagnosis was made. I can say that the baby was very likely asymptomatic, based on how lead poisoning typically presents in a child, but that doesn’t mean that they didn’t have complications during treatment or that they won’t have challenges down the road. I’ll explain what I mean shortly.
As would be expected, an investigation of the child’s home took place in order to uncover any potential environmental sources of lead. In particular, investigations look for lead paint, which is still commonly found in homes built before 1978 and can be ingested by children in the form of chipped paint or dust particles. Lead can also be found in the home’s water supply and in the surrounding soil, deposited years ago by the exhaust of vehicles burning leaded gasoline. All young children can ingest lead from these environmental sources when present because of normal exploratory behaviors, but at particular risk are children with pica, an eating disorder with myriad etiologies that results in the pathological consumption of non-food items, such as dirt.
Two interior windows were found to have peeling lead-based pain. The home was not felt to have played a role in the child’s elevated lead level, however, because investigators were able to confirm that the child did not have access to the windows and also that the lead levels in the two siblings, aged 3 and 5 years, were normal. Chronic lead exposure, such as that seen in homes with a significant lead burden, results in deposition in the bones where the half-life is measured in decades. So levels would have almost certainly still been elevated in the siblings had they been living in an environment capable of producing a blood level that high in the baby.
This is why prevention and appropriate screening is so important in the management of lead poisoning. Once diagnosed, even with chelation to help quickly lower blood lead levels, the damage to the brain has often already been done in cases of chronic exposure, especially if the child is very young. And because chelation can only bind to lead in the blood, it can do nothing for the long term leaching of lead from the child’s own bones. Treatment with chelating agents can be used to manage some symptoms of severe lead toxicity, such as gastrointestinal distress, irritability, seizures and lead encephalopathy, but nothing has been shown to improve neurocognitive outcomes down the road.
An unexpected revelation
At some point the patient’s mother pointed out that she had purchased a “homeopathic magnetic hematite healing bracelet” at an art fair in the area. Nothing on the bracelet indicated what the various parts were made of or where they were manufactured, and investigators were unable to determine who had crafted and then sold the item to the patient’s mother. When one of the several small spacer beads was tested, it was found to contain 17,000 ppm of lead, which is 16,900 ppm higher than the limit established by the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008 for any part of a product made for children. Obviously this law doesn’t protect young children from jewelry.
We are told that the child wore the bracelet only “intermittently” for symptoms related to teething and that the child was seen putting it into their mouth, which could have been assumed based on their age. We are not told when the bracelet was purchased, but teething generally starts at around 7 months. That being said, many parents believe that their child is suffering from teething induced discomfort for many weeks prior to the actual arrival of a tooth, so it is possible that the child had frequent access to the bracelet for weeks to months.
We aren’t told if the child required chelation. If they were asymptomatic, as most children with lead poisoning are, they might not have. They would have undergone testing for comorbid conditions such as renal impairment and iron deficiency, and abdominal imaging to make sure that no flecks of paint or pieces of metals, such as one of those spacer beads, were sitting in the GI tract leaching out lead.
It is possible, although I would say unlikely, that the symptoms being blamed on teething in this case were actually related to lead toxicity. I’ve written about teething on SBM a few times, and even used it as an example of medical folklore in my recent talk at NECSS. Sadly this case is a perfect example of the issues I’ve raised. Not only are caregivers, and sometimes even pediatric medical providers, exposing children to risky interventions for a condition that is considerably more myth than reality, excessive focus on teething symptoms might delay appropriate evaluation when a child is truly ill.
Hopefully the child did well, although as I mentioned earlier there is unfortunately a decent chance that they will ultimately have neurocognitive deficits. This might include impaired learning and memory, language delays, ADHD, cognitive impairment, and speech, language, and hearing problems. This is why we assess for risk factors and screen children. This may have continued for months, and the lead level risen even higher, otherwise.
Homeopathic jewelry?
I think that it goes without saying that there is absolutely no scientific evidence, and zero plausibility, to support the claim that a bracelet such as the one in question would benefit a teething infant or anyone else for that matter. Magnetic hematite is still commonly incorporated into jewelry and promoted by believers for its pain relieving properties. Hematite is apparently also used in Feng Shui for its powerful grounding energy and ability to calm and focus the mind.
What does homeopathy have to do with a bracelet? I tried but was unable to find any explanation. It appears that people selling amber or hematite jewelry just use the “homeopathic” label to give a product more alt med cred, similar to how people sometimes use “quantum” to make something sound scientifically more impressive. Really nothing about this is homeopathic in any sense.
Conclusion: Pseudomedicine isn’t harmless
This wasn’t the first child to be harmed by pseudomedicine. They weren’t even the first to suffer lead poisoning because of a caregiver’s belief in nonsense. And it will certainly happen again. This case demonstrates not only the potential risk of turning to unproven and implausible treatments, but also the harm that can come when medical folklore and cultural inertia combine and result in caregivers treating normal variations in infant behavior, such as teething, as something that requires treatment.

Not just water! This homeopathy is contaminated with bacteria
Homeopathy from King Bio may contain an unlabelled ingredient: Bacterial contamination.
Scott Gavura on September 6, 2018
Link

The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Health Canada have issued a widespread recall of products manufactured by King Bio. King Bio manufactures hundreds of homeopathic remedies that are marketed to treat countless numbers of conditions in adults, children, and pets. Homeopathy is often misunderstood as a natural remedy, akin to a type of herbalism. The marketing and labeling of these “remedies” encourages this perception, often describing homeopathy as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing, and putting cryptic terms like “30C” beside long Latin names of what appears to be the active ingredients. However, homeopathic remedies typically don’t contain any active ingredients at all, and the worst that can be said is that homeopathy an expensive placebo that harms primarily by delaying proper treatment. But King Bio’s remedies may be actively harmful. An FDA inspection found an unwanted active ingredient: microbial contaminants such as Burkholderia multivorans which has the potential to cause serious illness. 
Water magic 101
Homeopathy is a recurring topic on this blog, and while the regular SBM reader has read this before, it continues to surprise me that few people that purchase homeopathy realize just how ridiculous it is. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like is simply magical thinking, a pre-scientific belief that was first described in 1890 by anthropologist Sir James George Frazer in the book The Golden Bough:
If we analyse the principles of thought on which magic is based, they will probably be found to resolve themselves into two: first, that like produces like, or that an effect resembles its cause; and, second, that things which have once been in contact with each other continue to act on each other at a distance after the physical contact has been severed. The former principle may be called the Law of Similarity, the latter the Law of Contact or Contagion.
The so-called “Law of Contagion” is still very much alive, and is the basis for pseudoscientific ideas such as “detox” and “eating clean“. It is also the entire basis of homeopathy. Samuel Hahnemann invented the practice of homeopathy, based on the ideas of sympathetic magic, in the early 1800s, with two main principles:
    • Like-cures-like: in homeopathy, a substance that is believed to cause a symptom, is diluted to treat that same symptom. Any substance is believed to be a medicine if it’s diluted enough: cancer, boar testicles, crude oil, oxygen, skim milk, even vacuum cleaner dust or moonlight can be a homeopathic remedy. Deciding which substances will cure which symptoms is determined by a process called a “proving” which is equally without any scientific basis. (Here are homeopathic provings for the Berlin Wall remedy and also sunlight reflected off the planet Saturn, to give you an example of the how the remedies are created by homeopaths.)
    • Water has a memory: the more you dilute the substance, the more powerful its effect is believed to be. And when I say dilute, I mean dilute. The 30C “potency” is a common dilution used in homeopathy – that’s a dilution of 10-60. You would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original, pre-diluted material. Most homeopathic remedies are completely inert, and don’t contain a single molecule of what’s on the label. Whether bottled as a liquid or dripped onto lactose and sold as tablets, they are pure placebo. Except, perhaps, in the case of homeopathic remedies recalled by King Bio.
When Hahnemann invented homeopathy, he described it as a separate and more effective form of medicine compared to “conventional” medical practices. Given homeopathy is an elaborate placebo system, homeopathy probably was safer than medical practice at the time, which was still based around the idea of the four humors. Eventually, germ theory emerged, ideas of humors disappeared, and medicine slowly turned towards a scientific model based on objective observations. Homeopathy, on the other hand, has never progressed or evolved based on evidence, because it was never based on science or evidence to begin with. Its practices today are frozen in the same beliefs from the 1800s. However, the number of products on the market has grown in recent years, owing to a lack of regulatory oversight, no requirement to do clinical trials, and probably most importantly, no active ingredients.
In the United States, homeopathy products are not inspected or approved by the FDA. In December 2017 the FDA proposed a new risk-based approach to regulating this growing practice:
Under the law, homeopathic drug products are subject to the same requirements related to approval, adulteration and misbranding as any other drug product. However, prescription and nonprescription drug products labeled as homeopathic have been manufactured and distributed without FDA approval under the agency’s enforcement policies since 1988.
“In recent years, we’ve seen a large uptick in products labeled as homeopathic that are being marketed for a wide array of diseases and conditions, from the common cold to cancer. In many cases, people may be placing their trust and money in therapies that may bring little to no benefit in combating serious ailments, or worse – that may cause significant and even irreparable harm because the products are poorly manufactured, or contain active ingredients that aren’t adequately tested or disclosed to patients,” said FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb, M.D. “Our approach to regulating homeopathic drugs must evolve to reflect the current complexity of the market, by taking a more risk-based approach to enforcement. We respect that some individuals want to use alternative treatments, but the FDA has a responsibility to protect the public from products that may not deliver any benefit and have the potential to cause harm.”
And that’s exactly what’s occurred with King Bio. Multiple products have been recalled as there was concerning evidence of bacterial contamination found.
King Bio’s homeopathy recall
King Bio is a homeopathy manufacturer. That is, they are not a pharmaceutical company that manufacturers drug products under processes that are subject to FDA inspection. “Dr.” King is a chiropractor and naturopath. King Bio has been criticized by the FDA in the past for making medicinal claims about the products it sells, without any evidence its products are effective.
This is a significant recall affecting about 600 products, sold under names like “Dr. King’s: Natural Medicine”, “Aquaflora”, “Natural Pet Pharmaceuticals”, “SafeCareRx”, “Natural Veterinary”, and “Safecare”. Products recalled include homeopathic candida treatments, homeopathic “flu relief”, homeopathic “stress control”, chicken pox “symptom relief”, homeopathic “fever reducers”, homeopathic “attention and learning enhancer”, homeopathic “kids bed wetting”, homeopathic “kids sleep aid”, homeopathic “EMF detox” and on and on and on and on. If you’re wondering how it’s possible that one small company can possibly manufacture so many products, recall that homeopathic remedies, when diluted (and prepared safely) are indistinguishable from each other – and from an equivalent placebo. They contain no medicine and no active ingredients. So there is likely no meaningful difference, from a manufacturing perspective, between “Food Chemical Intolerances” and “Good Mood Enhancer” or even “Indoor Air Pollution Detox”.

The FDA notes the following:
The FDA recently inspected King Bio’s facility and collected product samples. The FDA is currently testing and analyzing product samples collected at the facility. According to the company, several microbial contaminants were found in its products, including Burkholderia Multivorans, which is a strain of bacteria called Burkholderia cepacia complex (BCC) that can cause illness in people with compromised immune systems. Additionally, evidence collected during the FDA’s inspection indicates recurring microbial contamination associated with the water system used to manufacture drug products.
King Bio voluntarily recalled three drug products labeled as homeopathic due to confirmed microbial contamination in July 2018. The company then expanded its voluntary recall to include an additional 32 drug products on August 22, 2018. The FDA contacted King Bio on August 23, 2018, and recommended the company again expand its recall to include all products that use water as an ingredient, including drug products for humans and animals. The company is expanding its recall to drug products made with water marketed for human and animals.
Homeopathy is ineffective
Despite the implausibility of homeopathy, and its ejection from the practice of medicine, it retained some popularity over time, with a resurgence in the past few decades as an “alternative” medical system. Rigorous clinical trials confirm what basic science predicts: homeopathy’s effects are placebo effects. While there are plenty of clinical trials that show homeopathy is associated with positive clinical effects, they are always small, poorly controlled, and often biased. Two of the more recent comprehensive reviews of the evidence are the 2010 Evidence Check from the United Kingdom’s House of Commons Science and Technology Committee and the 2014 Australian National Health and Medical Research Council review, which are worth perusing if you haven’t seen them before.
Bacteria or not, skip the homeopathy
If you’ve never bought it before, homeopathy is not cheap: Its prices are comparable to conventional medicine that actually has active ingredients. Given the lack of efficacy, every dollar spent on homeopathy is a waste of resources, in that it could otherwise be put to more effective use — for plausible treatments, or anything else, for that matter. Regrettably, when it comes to homeopathy, consumers can’t depend on regulators to ensure marketed products are both safe and effective. In the King Bio example, the FDA has only acted because these products are unsafe – not because they are ineffective. Until there’s more effective regulation in place the most effective strategy is to steer clear of any product labelled “homeopathic”.

Homeopathic Vaccines Revisited
Steven Novella on November 28, 2012
Link
One of the core fictions of “complementary” or “integrative” medicine is that they are primarily offered in addition to science-based medicine and only to fill gaps in what SBM can offer. The original marketing label used to promote treatments that are not adequately supported by evidence , “alternative medicine,” was a bit more accurate in that at least it acknowledged that such treatments were being offered instead of SBM (the fiction being that they are a viable alternative, rather than just health fraud and pseudoscience). The switch to “complementary” and “integrative” did not reflect an evolving philosophy or practice, just an evolving marketing strategy.
Today proponents are likely to reassure the right people – journalists, regulators, and academics – that their offerings are not meant to replace proven therapies, but to complement them (the best of both worlds). (Mark Crislip is fond of pointing out that this is like mixing cow pie with apple pie. It doesn’t make the cow pie palatable, but it does ruin the apple pie.) However, behind closed doors practitioners of unscientific medicine generally prescribe their favorite pseudoscience instead of science-based treatments.
For example, Alice Tuff from Sense about Science investigated 10 homeopathic clinics in the UK.
In the consultations, Alice explained that she was planning to join a 10-week truck tour through Central and Southern Africa and that the anti-malarial drugs her doctor had prescribed made her feel queasy.
The results – all 10 homeopathy clinics offered homeopathic treatments for malaria protection, and none of them suggested this be done in addition to standard treatment. None of them referred Alice back to her medical doctor for further advice (in which case she could have been offered science-based alternative malaria treatments that she may have tolerated better). Only two homeopaths took a personal medical history.
Homeopathic vaccines are an excellent test case for the ethics of so-called CAM. In order to accept CAM one has to, in my opinion, disregard core scientific principles, or profoundly misunderstand them. It is therefore not surprising that proponents of CAM would generally not recommend science-based treatments, and may even advise against them. The more savvy practitioners understand that in order to get a foot in the door they need to publicly take the “integrative” approach, but this is often not what happens in practice.
Schmidt and Ernst surveyed chiropractors and homeopaths for their advice on the MMR vaccine. After gathering the data they disclosed that this was for research and offered them the opportunity to withdraw their responses. The results are below:
We contacted 168 homoeopaths, of whom 104 (72%) responded, 27 (26%) withdrawing their answers. We contacted 63 chiropractors, of whom 22 (44%) responded, six (27%) withdrawing their responses. No general practitioners responded. The table shows that only a few professional homoeopaths and a quarter of the chiropractors advised in favour of the MMR vaccination. Almost half of the homoeopaths and nearly a fifth of the chiropractors advised against it.
Only 3% of the homeopaths advised getting the vaccination, while 40% specifically advised against it. Meanwhile, 25% of chiropractors advised for and 19% against getting the vaccine. As interesting is the fact that more than a quarter of each withdrew their responses – indicating a desire to conceal their true beliefs and practice from the public.
In reaction to this study the Society of Homeopaths put out an official statement saying they do not advise against vaccines – but again, we are just seeing the disconnect between the public face and practice behind closed doors. This seems to represent a deception inherent in non-science-based practice.
As if it needs to be said yet again on this site – homeopathy is an unscientific philosophy based upon superstitious notions invented over 200 years ago. Homeopathic pills and potions typically are diluted beyond the point where any active ingredients remain. Not only do physics, chemistry, and biology dictate that homeopathic treatments cannot work, when studied clinically they in fact do not work. Specifically the scientific evidence does not support the claim that homeopathy is effective in preventive infectious illness and is a suitable alternative to proven vaccines.
In addition to offering an ineffective treatment in place of perhaps the safest and most effective medical intervention ever devised, vaccines, proponents of unscientific alternatives have a huge motivation to attack their competition. They therefore often make common cause with the anti-vaccine movement, as evidence by the fact that 40% of the homeopaths in the above study (that allowed their advice to be known) specifically advised against vaccination.
It is not difficult to find sites on the web both attacking vaccines and promoting an alternative, such as homeopathy. This is partly a product of scientific illiteracy, but also just brand competition. If you are selling an alternative it is in your interest to criticize the competition.
In some cases the conflict between homeopathy and vaccination takes on a legal dimension. A recent court case in Australia involves divorced parents fighting over whether or not to vaccinate their child. The mother is against vaccines, stating:
She told the court that she adhered to a ”simple and healthy way of life”, that included eating organic food, using non-toxic cleaning products and sending the child to a Rudolph Steiner school where the toys were made from natural products such as wool, wax and silk.
Most parents at the school focused on ”building up the immune system of the child through homeopathics”, she told the court.
We see here the alliance of anti-vaccine sentiments, the naturalistic fallacy, and homeopathy.
The father and the girl’s stepmother took her to get vaccinated after she contracted whooping cough at age five. They were further concerned over risks posed to their newborn from their unvaccinated sibling. This led the mother to sue in court to keep her daughter from being vaccinated by her father. The news report of the case further reveals:
A doctor in homeopathic medicine told the court that homeopathic vaccination was safe and effective, whereas traditional vaccination had short- and long-term risks, including a link to ADHD and autism.
Apparently it is not difficult to find a homeopath who will testify to blatant pseudoscience in the courtroom.
Conclusion
It is apparent that there is a real and meaningful conflict between science-based medicine and what is offered by some as an alternative (interventions not adequately based on science) – how could there not be? The notion of “complementary” or “integrative” medicine is a marketing fiction, a political necessity for proponents of nonsense. In practice proponents of unscientific alternatives largely oppose science-based interventions, or will at least happily jump on the bandwagon of any criticism or denial of mainstream medicine, while falsely promoting treatments that are not supported by basic science or evidence of effectiveness.
This all gets filed under the category of “what’s the harm” of believing in and promoting medical pseudoscience.

   Homeopathic Vaccines.
Mark Crislip
Link
It is probably of no surprise to anyone who has read my blog entries, I am a proponent of vaccines. They give the most bang for the infection prevention buck, and many of the childhood illnesses covered by the vaccine are now so rare that many physicians, even in Infectious Diseases, have never taken care of cases of measles or mumps or German measles, etc. It is a remarkable triumph of modern medicine. Of course, the decline of infectious diseases is always multifactorial: good nutrition, understanding of diseases epidemiology, and good hygiene all have contributed to the decline of many diseases, vaccine preventable or not, The application of science has resulted in an almost inconceivable decline in contagions that have killed and injured millions.
It is always better to prevent an illness than to have to treat it. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. Even those who erroneously believe that standard vaccines are not effective and/or dangerous understand that it is better to prevent illness with some sort vaccine. But rather than use an effective vaccine, they choose, instead, other options. Like homeopathic vaccines.
Vaccines offer a small, fixed amount of a pathogen (antigen) to the immune system. A touch of bacterial carbohydrate here, a smidgen of viral protein there. Something that the immune system can recognize and respond to, so that when the patient is exposed to the real infection, with its relatively massive amounts of antigen, the immune system is prepared and can react immediately to minimize the damage, rather than the usual delay it takes before immunity kicks in. You know, like FEMA and New Orleans. Or maybe not. Perhaps my metaphorableness is lacking today.
There has to be something there, a real molecule of some sort, for the immune system to recognize and respond to. There is a threshold below which foreign material will not be recognized. Tetanus is an interesting example. An impressively awful disease in those suffering from it, with every muscle contracting due to the tetanus toxin. But interestingly, there is sometimes not enough toxin causing the disease to result in an immune response, and those who get tetanus still need the vaccine after they recover to prevent recurrence.
Homeopathy is the art of giving absolutely nothing and believing that it is something. Kind of like election year promises. A reader sent me an article on homeopathic vaccinations, which is one of the more bizarro concepts I have yet to discover in my wanderings in SCAMs. I sometimes feel like someone is pulling an elaborate prank on me.
The first ‘law’ behind vaccines and homeopathy is the same: like cures like. Vaccines are the only medical validation of the first ‘law’ of homeopathy of which I am aware. It is the second ‘law’ of homeopathy where medicine, and reality, part company with homeopathy, the ‘law’ of dilutions. Where vaccines are given with a well characterized concentration of antigen, homeopathic nostrums are often diluted long past the point where anything remains behind. If a homeopathic nostrum is 20X, then there is no longer even a molecule of the original substance in the mixture. Which can be a good thing, since homeopaths use nosodes as their vehicle for imaginary vaccination.
A nosode “is a homeopathic remedy prepared from a pathological specimen. The specimen is taken from a diseased animal or person and may consist of saliva, pus, urine, blood, or diseased tissue.”
And people complain about the alleged toxins in real vaccines.
Nosodes are cargo cult medicine at its finest. The trappings of real medicine with none of the efficacy. Thank goodness they are diluted to the point of nothingness. At least with serial dilutions, HIV, Hepatitis B and C are unlikely to be spread from injecting the patient with concoctions derived from various and sundry body fluids. At least we left the techniques of Jenner behind with modern medicine. Fortunately nosodes are used primarily in veterinary homeopathy.
One can purchase nosodes for human use for everything from Anthrax to Variola (smallpox) at either 30 or 200 dilution. In a rare burst of honesty, one site notes
There are no whole molecules of the actual substance in 30C potency” and another notes “(homeopathic vaccines) do not contain Thimerosal, Aluminum, Borax (used to kill ants) and other chemical elements. Also in the studies that have been able to proceed, no child has had a any severe side effects from the homeopathic vaccines given.
Since they contain nothing, it would seem unlikely that they could have any side effects at all.
And they have a nosode for smallpox? It is supposedly derived from the ripened pustule of a smallpox patient and I have to wonder about their source. There has been no smallpox in the world since the mid 1970′s, either they have a stock of smallpox that they feed like sourdough starter or they are not really selling the real deal. Although even Twinkies have expiration dates, I guess the ‘energy’ in homeopathic remedies lasts for decades, with the smallpox nostrums maintaining their potency through the ages.
Are there any studies or case reports to support the use of nosodes? As best I can discover there are two clinical trials in animals of nosodes: one in calves that did not show benefit and one in mice that did, and both are in journals too obscure for my library to have subscriptions. There are two cases of fatal polio after receiving homeopathic vaccinations. That is it in Pubmed. Not a convincing literature for effectiveness.
One site does recognize that homeopathic vaccinations do not work like standard vaccines: by leading to the development of antibodies
Homeopathic preparations have not been shown to raise antibody levels. Smits tested the titre of antibodies to diphtheria, polio and tetanus in ten children before and one month after giving homeopathic preparations of these three vaccines (DTPol 30K and 200K). He found no rise in antibody levels (Smits, 1995). He speculates that protection afforded by a homeopathic remedy acts on a “deeper” level than that of antibodies. Other homeopaths have stated similar opinions. Golden says, “unlike conventional vaccines, the Homeopathic alternative does not rely on antibody formation.
Of interest, homeopaths argue the validity of the homeopathic vaccinations, since their nostrums are classically supposed to be effective only after symptoms have occurred. It does make for a curious reading, one group of nonsense arguing that another group of nonsense is, well, nonsense.
The sad thing is parents will be fooled into thinking that their children are protected from infectious diseases, when, in fact, they are not. Vaccines do not provide perfect protection; neither do seat belts. But a vaccine is superior to the nothing of homeopathy and I would bet that parents would not rely on a child car restraint made by the same process as homeopathy.

   Nosodes Redux: “I hate those meeces to pieces!”
Mark Crislip
Link
Life and medicine generate facts and experiences that require conceptual frameworks that aid in understanding. It is no good have a pile of facts if they cannot be understood within a broader understanding.
The practice of Infectious Diseases, while certainly aided by understanding anatomy, physiology, microbiology, chemistry and the other sciences that form the core of medicine (referred to in Medical School as the basic sciences), gains a broader appreciation from the concepts of evolution. Infectious Diseases, at its most fundamental level, is applied evolution, and understanding evolution often adds greater insight into infectious diseases. Me find bug, me kill bug, me go home may be my motto, but it is meant in jest.
There have been papers or books that have added conceptual frameworks to my understanding of the natural world and medicine. Besides evolution, there was Observations on Spiraling Empiricism a classic that all health care providers should read, as it outlines the cognitive errors we all make in prescribing medications; I have discussed this article before.
There is The Drunkard’s Walk: How Randomness Rules Our Lives by Leonard Mlodinow. So often the explanation of why something happens is a shrug of the shoulders; feces occurs. The book formalized my understanding that much of what happens is random and without cause. The challenge in medicine is trying find a pattern in the randomness of life upon which to base a diagnosis. It is equally important to recognize when patterns are not there. All too often what is seen as a pattern is our imposing structure on what are random events. Or maybe that really is a bunny in the clouds. Clinical study results often occur by chance and having a significant ‘P’ value may still be due to randomness if the study is measuring nonsense.
Recently, Why Most Published Research Findings Are False, by John P. A. Ioannidis has added to my understanding of the old saw that half of everything you learn in medical school will be proven false after you graduate, the problem is that they do not tell you which half.
Ioannidis has 6 rules for evaluating studies that stem from his evaluation of the literature:
Corollary 1: The smaller the studies conducted in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.
Corollary 2: The smaller the effect sizes in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.
Corollary 3: The greater the number and the lesser the selection of tested relationships in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.
Corollary 4: The greater the flexibility in designs, definitions, outcomes, and analytical modes in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.
Corollary 5: The greater the financial and other interests and prejudices in a scientific field, the less likely the research findings are to be true.
Corollary 6: The hotter a scientific field (with more scientific teams involved), the less likely the research findings are to be true.
It is why much of medicine and science is tentative and emphasizes the importance, as best as can be determined at a given time, of considering all the information. I tell the residents that a big part of becoming a Doctor is learning to be comfortable with incomplete and changing information. Being a specialist is being ignorant with style.
What matters is the totality of the evidence… instead of chasing statistical significance, we should improve our understanding of the range of R values—the pre-study odds—where research efforts operate. Before running an experiment, investigators should consider what they believe the chances are that they are testing a true rather than a non-true relationship.
It is where the Cochrane reviews fail, and fail so spectacularly, on topics as diverse as the efficacy of influenza vaccine to the efficacy of homeopathy. Failure to consider all the information casts doubt on the former and suggests legitimacy of the former. In the world of clinical medicine, when considering an intervention, I have to take into consideration as much of the literature as I can, from basic plausibility to the always messy clinical trials.
What separates a proponent of science based medicine from practitioners of SCAM’s is that those in SBM are aware of the all too numerous foibles and errors to which humans are prone, distorting a true understanding of the natural world. What makes a good skeptic, and a good doctor, is an understanding of the multitudinous ways we fool ourselves and others.
Which brings us back to nosodes and the reference Do homeopathic nosodes protect against infection? An experimental test by WB Jonas.
Just on the basis of the first five corollaries of Ioannidis, the odds are the study is wrong, not to mention that the pretest probability, the R, that this study, if positive, will be will be testing a true relationship is, lets see. Exactly zero. There is zero pretest probability that any positive result of a homeopathic invention represents an effect from the homeopathic nostrum.
Dr. Jonas, the sole author, is a former director of National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, so, while the study was done at Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, Corollary 5 jumps to mind as perhaps more important than where the study is done.
Lets look at the quality of the study.
Groups of 4 to 6 mice (Corollary 1) received either ethanol (70%) or a varying dilutions of pureed leptospira infected mouse lung/liver/spleen in 70% alcohol. Some of the nosodes had measurable proteins in it. The author measured the amount of proteins in the nostrums using the Lowry procedure, a semiquantitative measurement of proteins, which I remember using as a fellow. It is less accurate when there is a host of other organic materials in the mix, as one might expect from a melange of liver, lung and spleen.
For me, ingestion of 70% alcohol leads to amnesia, so how 70% alcohol can ‘remember’ the initial material better than water is not mentioned in the study. Is a study with 70% alcohol meaningful for ‘classic’ water based homeopathy? Are serial dilutions of 70% alcohol applicable to homeopathy as practiced? Stupid questions, since homeopathy has nothing to do with reality. Must. Remember. This. Is. Tooth. Fairy. Science.
Mice received about 16 doses of a nosode or placebo before infection challenge and about 40 doses after the infectious challenge with leptospirosis.
Compared to alcohol (which is not a placebo, since alcohol does have a variety of immunomodulatory effects, one example from where you find others,) over all the nosode group died after 18.6 hours and the control after 13.7 hours with a P of .002. Overall mortality was 75% in the control, 53 % in the nosode. Standard vaccination was, of course, vastly superior to alcohol or nosode, with 100% protection. There was no dose dependent result, which would be a surprise if a real medication were being used, but not, perhaps, an antigen.
If you expose an animal to a pathogen, say Candida, and then shortly thereafter infect the animal with, say, Listeria, the animals that had the prior exposure to Candida will have decreased mortality compared to those that were not exposed. The immune response is primed for subsequent infectious challenge.
One telling aside in the study is that one mixture had no effect, and that was a 1000C nosode prepared by a commercial pharmacy. The author postulates “perhaps handling while in transit or differences in preparation of the commercial nosode affected the 1000C level.” He also worries that the mechanical succussion does not have the same effect as hand succussion, which in the real world is akin to worrying that Tooth Fairies exchanged the real nosode for mere alcohol while he slept. Of course, Tooth Fairies only concern themselves with teeth, so a bad example.
I suspect, having been involved in bench research back in the day isolating and measuring proteins, that the author did a bad job at making his dilutions (but not the commercial pharmacy) and the nosodes were more contaminated with puree of infected mouse innards than he suspected. The result is the typical mild protective effect you get from prior exposure to antigens. Alternatively, it is just the usual random results you see in small studies combined, perhaps, with yet another example of seeing N-Rays.
Overall not impressive and a low quality study and of little applicability to ‘classic’ homeopathy. And, like many studies in the SCAM literature, not repeated with a better methodology. The author states at the end, “Attempts to replicate these experiments under more controlled conditions (eg with complete blinding (!!) and using aerosol methods for more uniform dosing) are underway.” That was 11 years ago. I wonder what happened to the results. Follow up with improved methodologies is not the strong suite of researchers in the SCAM field. Squirrel!
There must be a less expensive and less cruel way to kill off 142 mice. D-Con is cheaper and spring loaded traps are quicker. Given that homeopathy is divorced from reality, this is more needless cruelty to animals than a reasonable scientific study.
My colleagues use the terms like ‘highly unlikely’, or ‘highly implausible’ to describe the precepts of homeopathy. I guess I am not a true skeptic. Some things are, as the world is currently understood, impossible. Perpetual motion machines are impossible, accelerating past the speed of light is impossible. There are few SCAM’s I would classify as impossible out of hand. Stick needles in people, or pop their neck, and you will get some sort of effect, perhaps not the effect intended (infection and stroke). There is always the possibility that the SCAM is doing something, perhaps not in ways envisioned by the practitioner. Even something as goofy as iridology or live blood analysis has the opportunity, albeit very rare, to make a real diagnosis. Only homeopathy has the honor of being the only SCAM based totally on fantasy.
I would classify the basic precepts of succussion and dilution to increase potency as impossible, not implausible. I’m sorry, not dilution, potentiation, or as it is more appropriately called in fantasy fiction, casting a spell. Homeopathy is 100% nonsense, and, like its nostrums, uncontaminated by reality. Sometimes it is argued that in the lower concentrations of spells, there may be a molecule or two of an agent that could have an effect, to which I call shenanigans. I subscribe to the concept of dose-effect of agents and there is a concentration below which molecules will have no effect. The alleged toxins in vaccines are not toxic because the concentrations are inconsequential; the effects of homeopathic nostrums at initial spell castings are as equally unable to have an effect as the later spell castings.
If homeopaths were to say the act of serial dilution and succussion slowly transformed the water into Unicorn tears, a universal curative, it would not make the underlying concepts less rational or divorced from the natural law. I may not be doing a very good job of suppressing my total lack of respect for the underlying fictions of homeopathy.
At one time, as an example, we did not know how aspirin worked, only that it was effective. But the science of chemistry, pharmacology, etc. eventually lead to the understanding that aspirin results in irreversible inactivation of the cyclooxygenase enzyme, which prevents the production of prostaglandin and thromboxane. As you increase the dose of aspirin, the receptors are filled until all the receptors are used up and then there is no more effect by giving more aspirin. Elucidating the action of aspirin did not require a completely new understanding of the basic sciences. If homeopathy did indeed work, then all we know of the natural world is wrong. Which is more likely: all of the basic sciences are correct or homeopathy is correct. And maybe homeopathy does give us a deeper insight in to the natural world, since science as we know it as about to be overturned.
In the end, I wonder at times if SBM and medical journals are the correct forum for discussions of the validity of the underlying precepts of homeopathy. What is the proper forum for the discussion of magic? The fantasy fiction section, not the science section, of the library. Or perhaps homeopathy is the purview of the anthropologist and psychologist as a cultural delusion.
Delusions are irrational beliefs, held with a high level of conviction, that are highly resistant to change even when the delusional person is exposed to forms of proof that contradict the belief. Non-bizarre delusions are considered to be plausible; that is, there is a possibility that what the person believes to be true could actually occur a small proportion of the time. Conversely, bizarre delusions focus on matters that would be impossible in reality. For example, a non-bizarre delusion might be the belief that one’s activities are constantly under observation by federal law enforcement or intelligence agencies, which actually does occur for a small number of people. By contrast, a man who believes” that the fundamental precepts of homeopathy are true “holds a belief that could never come to pass in reality.
In medicine we determine that a behavior is pathologic when it starts to have negative consequences for the patient or others. Alcohol is the classic example where use blends from fun to pathologic as harm accrues in the patient and his environment. Homeopathy would appear to be another. I look forward to the inevitable ‘when you point a finger you have three pointing back at yourself’ reply.
When I was first in practice, I saw a patient in clinic for ‘parasites.’ The room reeked of garlic as he was continually chewing on raw garlic cloves as he said it suppressed the parasite.
In discussing his symptoms he told me that the air was full of these parasites, and they would land on his skin and burrow in.
Probably Delusions of Parasitism, I thought, as no parasite has this life cycle. But it is not unusual for patients to mis-attribute symptoms to an erroneous cause, so I had to make sure he did not have some illness he was mistakenly attributing to parasites.
“How do you know they are parasites?”
“I collect them.” he said, holding up a large brown jar that rattled dryly as he shook it.
“Can I see them? And where do you get them?”
“From my nose,” he replied as he dumped three cups of dried boogers on the exam table.
To my credit I neither screamed nor vomited, although I could not eat garlic for over a year.
I see no conceptual difference between that jar of ‘parasites’ and a jar of homeopathic nostrums, save the former, to my knowledge, never killed a child.

Randomized controlled trial of homeopathic nosodes finds, not surprisingly, that they are useless
Magic sugar pills go head-to-head against actual vaccines in a randomized controlled trial. The results will not surprise you.
Scott Gavura on April 4, 2019
Link

Sometimes you don’t need to read past the headline. If you’re a regular reader of the blog, the headline may seem self-evident and congruent with everything that we know about homeopathy. But should you not understand how homeopaths purport to offer vaccination through magical sugar pills called “nosodes”, and how regulators like Health Canada enable this pseudoscience, read on. We’re going to examine a randomized controlled trial that that compares homeopathy to real vaccines. The findings will not surprise you.
Sugar marketed as medicine
Homeopathy is an antiquated alternative-to-medicine belief system that is possibly popular because it isn’t well understood. Commonly packaged and sold alongside herbal products and “natural” remedies, homeopathy is unique in that remedies contains nothing at all – by design. Of the alternative medicines, homeopathy is the most implausible of them all. Based on the absurd notion of “like cures like” (which is sympathetic magic, not science), proponents of homeopathy believe that any substance can be an effective remedy if it’s diluted enough: raccoon fur, the sunlight reflecting off Saturn, even pieces of the Berlin Wall are possible remedies. And when I say dilute, I mean dilute. The 30C “potency” is common – it’s a ratio of 10-60. You would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original material. So remedies are effectively and mathematically inert – they are pure placebo. Not surprisingly, there is no persuasive medical evidence that these products have therapeutic effects.
Canada’s version of the FDA, Health Canada, has approved hundreds of varieties of sugar pills and declared them to be “safe and effective”. Given the regulatory and legislative “veneer of legitimacy” that homeopathy is being granted, you can see how consumers might be led to believe that homeopathic remedies are effective, or that homeopaths are capable of providing a form of health care. Concerningly, Health Canada approved dozens of homeopathic “nosodes” for sale over the years. A “nosode” is a remedy that starts with infectious material, like polio, measles, or smallpox, and then it’s diluted sequentially until mathematically, there’s nothing left but water. Homeopaths promote these products as vaccine substitutes. A few years ago the advocacy group Bad Science Watch launched a public campaign against nosodes, and succeeded in getting Health Canada’s agreement to force commercial manufacturers to place a label on their products stating “This product is not intended to be an alternative to vaccination.” Yet these products are still allowed to be sold, and the extent to which they continue to be promoted as an alternative to vaccination is unknown.
Homeopathy could be written off as a harmless nostrum if it caused no harm, but that’s not the case. Homeopathy can delay patients from seeking science-based treatments. And while nosodes only contain sugar, consumers could be led to believe that they actually provide immunity.
Should we test homeopathy?
Back in 2016, Steven Novella wrote about the study that is my subject for today:
A Canadian academic, Dr. Mark Loeb, who is a respected infectious disease researcher who knows how to conduct high quality research, wants to study homeopathic nosodes. Nosodes are essentially homeopathic vaccines.Tim Caulfield, a Canadian professor of health law and policy, thinks the study is misguided and unethical. The two are having a respectful public debate about the risks and merits of doing such a study.
And:
Despite the complete lack of scientific plausibility and the negative clinical trials, homeopathy is still a multi-billion dollar industry and enjoys approval by most governments. In the US homeopathic potions are classified as drugs and given automatic approval, although the FDA is reviewing that policy.
Because of this, Mark Loeb argues, it is helpful to conduct high quality research into homeopathy. Even if this research does not convince the true believers, the results, assuming they are negative, can be used to pressure governments to more appropriately regulate homeopathy.
Loeb argues that on this specific question, that of nosodes, there has not been any high quality research. He intends to compare nosodes to vaccines to placebos, looking at the production of antibodies and B and T-cell responses. His hypothesis is that nosodes will be no different than placebo.
Dr. Novella argues this debate cuts to the difference between Science-Based Medicine and Evidence-Based Medicine, suggesting that Loeb may have an EBM philosophy, where evidence is paramount (and perhaps could convince believers) while Novella argues that an SBM, Bayesian approach would hold that the prior plausibility approaches zero, so that even a well-conducted clinical trial will not change the priors.
What did the investigators study?
So let’s now look at the trial itself. It’s entitled “A randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled trial comparing antibody responses to homeopathic and conventional vaccines in university students” and was published in the journal Vaccine. It’s fully open access.
This was a randomized controlled trial where university students (aged 18-24) who had already received routine vaccinations as a child were randomized to one of:
    • diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus, mumps and measles homeopathic nosodes. The products were licensed for sale by Health Canada and had drug identification numbers. “Treatments” were given on days, 1, 2, and 3 with increasingly dilute remedies, starting at 30C. This group also received saline injections, to mimic the actual vaccine injections.
    • placebo. Participants received regular sugar pills and also saline injections.
    • diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus (Tdap), as an intramuscular injection, and measles, mumps, rubella (MMR) subcutaneous vaccine. They also received sugar pills to mimic the nosode dosing.
The exclusion criteria included anyone who had received adult boosters of vaccines. Participants, investigators, lab techs and data analysts were blinded to the randomization.
The primary outcome was antibody levels for diphtheria, pertussis, tetanus, mumps, and measles. Participants had their blood drawn immediately before the injections (placebo or real) and then after 3 weeks.
150 students were enrolled, and the three groups were evenly matched. Interestingly, while most of the participants has protective levels of antibodies for diphtheria (88%) and tetanus (97%), only 52% had adequate antibodies against measles and 66% against mumps. This speaks to the potentially sub-optimal measure of immunity in the community, and doesn’t bode well in a era where, thanks in part to the anti-vaccination movement, preventable infection disease has come back.
As powerful as a placebo
The results are as shown below. No patient in either the nosode group or the placebo group had any meaningful immune response whatsoever.
Table 1. Total (percentage) of response (≥2-fold increase) for each outcome by vaccine groups.
Group	N*	Mean age (yrs)	Number Female (%)	Diphtheria†	Pertussis†	Tetanus†	Measles†,‡	Mumps†,‡
Homeopathic Vaccine	50	19.9 (SD 1.6)	30 (60)	0/50 (0%)	0/50 (0%)	0/50 (0%)	0/50 (0%)	0/50 (0%)
Conventional vaccine	49	20.2 (SD 2.0)	32 (65)	33/48 (69%)	40/48 (83%)	42/48 (88%)	13/48 (27%)	7/48 (15%)
Placebo	51	20.3 (1.6)	32 (63)	0/49 (0%)	0/49 (0%)	0/49 (0%)	0/49 (0%)	0/49 (0%)

*N refers to the number of participants randomized.

†The denominator is based on the number of participants who completed follow up and were randomized.

‡The response to measles or mumps was combined for the primary analysis, for conventional vaccine the response was 17/48 (35%).
Here are the results shown another way – Geometric Mean Titres. Notice the similarity between nosodes and the placebo group.
As expected, the results for homeopathy are indistinguishable from placebo.
As expected, there were significantly more side effects in the group that received real vaccines. Redness, sore arm, and limited movement were reported more commonly than with homeopathy or placebo.
More research likely not required
The authors conclude that homeopathic nosodes are as effective as placebo, noting,
These findings suggest homeopathic vaccines should not be licensed.
Will Loeb’s research have any effect? Personally I think it’s unlikely, unless it compels regulators to act further – ideally removing these products from the market. Given the convincing data that already existing that homeopathy is a placebo system, one more study is unlikely to convince the true believers. Perhaps it will be more effective with the vaccine hesitant, or to those that may otherwise think that you can gain immunity with these “alternatives”. But as we’ve seen over years in addressing the anti-vaccine movement, this is a messaging issue, not an evidence issue.
While homeopaths, naturopaths, and others may promote homeopathic “remedies” like nosodes are effective, the facts are clear. Nosodes are an area where homeopathy can actively harm. Choosing homeopathy over a vaccine is a decision to forsake immunization, something consumers may not even realize. Why is all this so important? Because the evidence is very clear. Vaccines work. And nosodes are no alternative.

Homeopaths Threaten Public Health Selling Sugar Pills as Vaccine Alternatives
Scott Gavura on December 4, 2014
Link

Alternative medicine is ascendant in Canada. From the dubious remedies that are now stocked by nearly every pharmacy, to the questionable “integrative” medicine at universities, there’s a serious move to embrace treatments and practices that are not backed by credible evidence. Canada’s support for alternative medicine, and for its “integration” into conventional health care is arguably is worse than many other countries. Canada’s drugs regulator, Health Canada, has approved hundreds of varieties of sugar pills and declared them to be “safe and effective” homeopathic remedies. Some provinces are even moving to regulate homeopaths as health professionals, just like physicians, nurses and pharmacists. Given the regulatory and legislative “veneer of legitimacy” that homeopathy is being granted, you can see how consumers might be led to believe that homeopathic remedies are effective, or that homeopaths are capable of providing a form of health care. The reality is far uglier, and the consequences may be tragic. Canadian homeopaths are putting the most vulnerable in society at risk by selling sugar pills to consumers, while telling them that they’re getting protection from communicable diseases.
Last Friday, CBC Marketplace, a consumers affairs show, used hidden cameras to record reporters asking homeopaths about vaccines. The show sent young mothers (with their babies) to speak with homeopaths about immunizations and vaccines in Toronto and Vancouver. The entire episode is about 22 minutes, and it’s well worth watching:
Of the five homeopaths filmed, four warned the mothers against vaccines, and advised them to avoid giving basic vaccinations like MMR (measles, mumps and rubella). Only brief clips are shown in the episode, but the standard antivaccination tropes and misinformation are all there, such as saying that vaccines “overwhelm” the immune system, or blaming autism on vaccines. After the fear is created, then the sales pitch comes. Homeopaths just happen to have a substitute for real medicine and its toxic vaccines. The solution is sugar pills. The homeopaths pull out their homeopathic “nosodes” and offer them as “risk free” substitutes, claiming that they have effectiveness rates of “93-95%”. It’s appalling and frightening. As I watched the sales pitch, I wondered how many times homeopaths have counseled parents against vaccines – and how many parents actually knew that they’d been sold an expensive placebo, with zero ability to protect their children from infectious disease.
How did it ever come to this?
If you’re new to the world of alternative medicine, you might think of homeopathy as a variation of herbalism. The marketing and labeling of homeopathic “remedies” encourages you to think this, describing it as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing, and putting cryptic “30C” codes beside long Latin names. But with herbalism, at least you’re getting some herb. Homeopathy’s remedies contain no medicine at all – herbal, natural or otherwise. They are inert. Homeopathy is the air guitar of alternative medicine, going through the motions of medicine, without actually providing medicine. How water and sugar pills are thought to heal is based on nonsensical, prescientific ideas about biology, biochemistry and medicine itself. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like” (which is simply a form of magical thinking) and then performing successive dilutions of substances in water. Each dilution is believed to increase, not decrease, the “potency” of the final product. And these are serious dilutions. Think of putting one drop of a substance into a container of water. Only that container is 131 light-years in diameter. That’s the “30C” dilution you’ll see on packages. Homeopaths believe that the water molecules retain a “memory” of the original substance (while somehow forgetting all the other products it has come in contact with). The final remedy is diluted so completely that most “remedies” don’t contain a single molecule of the original substance you started with. The CBC used a great image to illustrate the absurdity – a tablet the size of the Earth might contain a single molecule of the original substance. The rest is sugar.
You might wonder how homeopathy could ever be approved as “safe and effective” by a drug regulator. It comes down to how you define “effective”. In the case of homeopathy, regulators diluted the standards just like homeopaths dilute their remedies. Health Canada was required to collect and evaluate some sort of evidence of effectiveness for each product it was responsible for regulating. But it realized that homeopathy could never meet conventional scientific standards of evidence. Consequently it allows citations about homeopathy from texts that date back to the 1800’s as “evidence” that homeopathy is effective. To put this in perspective, this means that homeopaths can cite “evidence” that precedes germ theory. Forget about randomized controlled trials – this is anecdote-based medicine.
Through this process, Health Canada approved 82 homeopathic “nosodes” for sale over the years. A “nosode” is a remedy that starts with infectious material, like polio, measles or smallpox, and then it’s diluted sequentially until mathematically, there’s nothing left but water. Those appear to be the remedies the CBC caught the homeopaths selling as vaccine substitutes. Last year the advocacy group Bad Science Watch launched a public campaign against nosodes, and succeeded in getting Health Canada’s agreement to force commercial manufacturers to place a label on their products stating “This product is not intended to be an alternative to vaccination.” This was the warning CBC Marketplace was looking for on the packages sold on camera. The warning wasn’t there – because Health Canada apparently doesn’t require the warning when the remedy is produced by the homeopaths themselves, only when the products are commercially prepared. Rather than reflecting on CBC’s question and Health Canada’s intent, homeopaths are instead gloating about their supposed “victory” over a requirement to give consumers a fair warning. No regulator is going to stop Canada’s homeopaths from selling fake vaccines to Canadians, it seems.
This isn’t the first time CBC Marketplace has scrutinized homeopathy. A 2011 episode asked if homeopathy was a “Cure or Con” and came to the expected conclusion. This episode had a similar reaction, with homeopaths outraged over the “bias” from CBC. (For LOLs, check out the Homeopathy and CBC Marketplace Facebook page.) CBC notes that not one of the five homeopaths filmed on camera was willing to go back on camera to defend their actions. Nor was any homeopathy spokesperson from the various homeopathy organizations that exist in Canada. But now that the show has been broadcast, several homeopaths are defending themselves in print. Their own words are further evidence that homeopaths do not appear to comprehend the risks they are taking with the health of children. Beth Landau-Halpern was one of the homeopaths that the CBC filmed. Writing in The Straight, she notes:
In May of this year I received a call from a young mother expressing concerns about the safety of vaccines for her baby and asking if she and her husband could come in and talk to me about homeopathic alternatives (which, in the simplest terms include homeoprophylaxis for those choosing not to vaccinate, or immune support for those who choose to vaccinate). This is a common request from (especially educated) parents, aware of media stories of vaccine damage as well as the myopic perspective of mainstream medicine for whom there are no alternatives, no accommodations, and no individualizing of vaccination schedules.
Vaccination is perhaps the most fraught decision a family makes in the first years of their child’s life. I do not believe that there is one right answer for every child and every family. People who come to talk to me about vaccination concerns and seeking information about alternatives are presented with a nuanced discussion. The primary goals of this discussion are to encourage families to do their research, understand the choices, and make a decision that is most suitable to their child, their family’s lifestyle (e.g. daycare or home care), their family’s health history and susceptibility to disease, and the risks and concerns they are most able to live with.
and
Upon leaving, “Emma” asked me for a nosode remedy to protect her son against measles while she and her husband were making their decision about vaccination; she told me they would be travelling to an area where there had recently been a measles outbreak and they were concerned about exposure. Of course I helped her—this is what homeopaths do. It turns out that Marketplace then made a formal complaint to Health Canada about my labelling of the remedy I had dispensed. Unfortunately, “Emma” and her team didn’t do their research and were unaware of the regulations that cover homeopathic practitioners. Needless to say, Health Canada found the complaint spurious and dismissed it, assuring me that I was practising well within regulatory norms. I might add, that Health Canada has conferred a DIN-HM number on many nosodes, giving them a “seal of approval” as it were. There is no salacious story here, no matter how Marketplace frames it.
Not only does Landau-Halpern appear oblivious to the science and is clearly anti-vaccine, she’s gloating about being exempted from Health Canada’s explicit expectation that nosodes should be labelled to indicate that they are not vaccine substitutes. She knows the warning is required on some products. But she’s not required to give it. So she doesn’t disclose it to her customers. You can’t get much more paternalistic than that.
Susan Drury, a homeopath, wrote the following in the comments section of Landau-Halpern’s column:
I am another one of the homeopaths who was “visited” by a young mother and accompanying “friend” (ie CBC Marketplace agent) under false pretenses, secretly filmed and included in their episode without my permission. When CBC informed me they had come to see me “undercover,” I wrote them a letter explaining, as Beth has done so well above, that my role is to support parents in whatever decision they make regarding vaccines. If they choose to vaccinate, there are ways to do so more safely and protect their child against possible ill-effects. If they make the difficult decision not to vaccinate, there are ways to educate their immune system to lessen their susceptibility to specific diseases.
Sonya McLeod, a homeopath who touts homeopathy as an alternative to vaccines on her website, also complained about the program in the same comment thread:
What was not explained in the context of this poorly done piece is that we offer alternatives to parents who have done their research and have made a decision for their family about the vaccine issue. We do not decide for the parent and their family, they decide for themselves. We all have the right to decide what we put into our bodies and into our children’s bodies.
What the CBC caught on camera is not a rare event – homeopaths in Canada continue to promote nosodes online, and some even offer public “alternative vaccine” clinics. I recently noted Ontario homeopath Sylvia Collins advertising a homeopathic flu clinic at a Zehr’s grocery store:
Sylvia Collins Homeopathic Practitioner is providing this clinic as a safe and effective alternative to the conventional flu vaccinations.
And the clinic had a disappointing amount of false balance in the Barrie Examiner:
When it comes to flu immunization, most of us choose the needle over the pill. While few enjoy the prick of a needle, most Canadians would rather suffer that injection with all the science of Western medicine behind it, than trust the less intrusive melting naturopathic pellet alternative.
“The homeopathic solution is made from the same three influenza viruses decided by the World Health Organization each year,” said Sylvia Collins, a homeopathic doctor who runs a flu clinic in Barrie and surrounding area each fall. “My own empirical evidence is that people aren’t getting colds as often, and if they do, it’s not as severe,” Collins said.
Her patient, Angela Hubbard, herself an occupational therapist, said she has a chronic illness that has been relieved by Collins homeopathic ministerings. Hubbard said she’s been taking the pellets-under-the-tongue method of flu vaccination from Collins clinic for at least a decade.
“Since I’ve been taking these flu remedies, I’ve never had the flu,” Hubbard said. She was trained as a therapist in the U.K. and said they studied anatomy, sociology and psychology as part of their training. She said it’s not about Western medicine versus homeopathy, but rather sourcing an alternative that was “cleaner”.
“(Vaccinations) are filtered through the liver and the kidneys, so the least I can put through my body, the better off I am,” she said.
Concerns that Health Canada approved influenza vaccination injections contain Thimerosal (mercury) and formaldehyde, leave many people – like Hubbard – searching for cleaner alternatives.
Homeopath Sylvia Collins may genuinely believe her homeopathic “remedies” are effective. Visitors to her “clinic” are being given the impression that what she’s offering is a legitimate alternative to the influenza vaccine, just like the hidden camera interviews of homeopaths recorded by CBC Marketplace. But this is where homeopathy can harm. Choosing homeopathy over a vaccine is a decision to forsake immunization, something a homeopath’s customers may not even realize – and seemingly something homeopaths have no intention of disclosing. Frustratingly, regulation has given homeopaths an opportunity, and now they’re exploiting it, suggesting that homeopathy may offer something valuable. It does not. Regulating homeopathy and its providers makes as much sense as regulating magic carpets and their vendors.
Why is all this so important? Because vaccines work. And we need high vaccination rates to control or eradicate disease. Vaccines are one of the most remarkable health interventions ever developed. This fact has been written about countless times in this blog, so I won’t rehash that evidence. I will share some amazing facts that Bill Gates described this week:
I’ll start with polio. Cases are down more than 99 percent since 1988. Earlier this year, we celebrated a fantastic achievement: India was declared polio-free. And in Nigeria, the number of polio cases is at an all-time low, just 6 so far this year versus more than 50 by this time last year. It’s one of only three countries that have never been polio free (the others are Pakistan and Afghanistan).
Wherever we make progress on polio, it’s a testament to the amazing work of many people: political leaders who prioritize stopping the disease, donors who help fund the effort, and—most importantly—the health workers who doggedly go from house to house to deliver vaccines. Thanks to all this work (and with a little luck), 2015 could be the first time Nigeria goes a year without a case of wild poliovirus, and the first time all of Africa is polio-free. If we maintain this commitment, I’m quite optimistic that by 2018 we will get rid of this crippling disease, everywhere, forever.
There’s also fantastic progress in delivering basic immunizations for diseases like measles and pneumonia. The impact is phenomenal: By next year, the public-health group known as Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance will have helped prevent 3.9 million deaths. And expanding vaccine coverage over the next five years can save as many as 6 million lives and unlock more than $100 billion in economic benefit.
And the image he shared is astonishing:
Millions of lives saved by an inexpensive and safe medical intervention. The potential that we’ll be able to eradicate a disease from the earth, like we did with smallpox. That’s what vaccines are doing. And that’s why the actions of homeopaths are so frustrating. With vaccine rates dropping in some areas (some Toronto public schools have up to 40% of students with “exemptions” from the vaccination schedule), health professionals and public health advocates need to be prepared to recognize and address the antagonism against vaccines that’s fostered by homeopaths.
Another image that really hit home for me recently was this photo series from Anne Geddes, whom you probably associate with photos of cute children. She recently did a photo session with the victims of meningococcal disease, an illness that can steal limbs and even kill within 24 hours. The photos are beautiful but heartbreaking, and speak to the catastrophic harm that this infectious disease can cause. Amazingly, this infection is now vaccine preventable. But you need to be vaccinated with medicine – not sugar pills.
Anti-vaccine sentiment is ugly, and it’s even uglier when there’s a profit motive behind it. I commend CBC Marketplace for yet again taking a hard look at homeopathy from a consumer protection perspective, as it’s something that regulators like Health Canada seem to show little interest in. The evidence is unequivocal – homeopathy has nothing to contribute to immunization or public health issues. One thing that you can do to counter-balance the harms of Canadian homeopaths is to contribute to vaccine programs directly, like those coordinated by Bill Gates or by other organizations. I’ve just contributed to UNICEF’s program and bought vaccines which should prevent measles, tetanus and polio in 139 children. The costs are modest, the risks are low, and the vaccines will save lives. If only this type of health care was supported by homeopaths.

Canada Is Sending Homeopaths to Honduras
The Canadian government is sending homeopaths to Honduras as part of an aid program. They dropped the ball on this one, and should just admit error and correct it, but they are doubling-down instead.
Steven Novella on March 6, 2019
Tweet

This is a tiny slice of the alternative medicine phenomenon, but it displays many of the problems with where we are today. The CBC reports:
Since 2015, Quebec-based Terre Sans Frontières (TSF) has been spending $70,000 annually in aid money from Global Affairs Canada to dispatch more than a dozen volunteer homeopaths to Honduras.
These homeopaths are mixed in with real doctors delivering real medicine. They are telling the vulnerable population they were sent to help that the magic water they provide will protect them from serious infectious diseases, like Chagas disease – which is potentially fatal. They are doing this with the imprimatur of the Canadian government.
This is obviously a scandal. For those readers who may be new to SBM and not fully understand what a scam homeopathy is, you can start here. Here is a more in-depth treatment. But the quick version is that homeopathy is a pre-scientific system of magic potions. Many people incorrectly think that homeopathy is herbalism or natural medicine, but it isn’t. Homeopathic concoctions begin with nonsensical ingredients that have no plausible connection to the illness they claim to treat, and then those ingredients are diluted to extreme degrees, usually out of existence. What is left is – magic water. Homeopaths claim this magic water retains the “essence” of what was previously diluted in it.
Unsurprisingly, when homeopathic magic water is tested in controlled clinical trials, it doesn’t work. Multiple systematic reviews of multiple clinical trials of homeopathy have adequately demonstrated that homeopathic potions work for nothing. They can’t work, and they don’t work. In a rational world homeopathy would be tossed on the trash heap of bad ideas, a victim of the advance of science and reason (somewhere between bloodletting and phrenology). But we do not live in a rational world, at least not one rational enough to take this obvious step.
So scientists find themselves in the position (when they take the time to understand what homeopathy is themselves) of explaining that magic potions are not effective medicine and it is unethical to use them and to claim that they can treat serious diseases, especially to vulnerable populations. Worse, they often get push back or dismissed with some hand-waving nonsensical defense. This case is no exception.
What essentially happened was that the charlatans managed to develop a sales pitch and a strategy that allowed them to rebrand health fraud as “alternative”. This case represents the fruit of that rebranding. As the CBC reports:
Under the Honduran Health Code of 1966, homeopathy, naturopathy and “other occupations considered to be harmful or useless” were banned until the code was rewritten in 1994.
Homeopathy was appropriately banned as worthless, but in the 1990s was rebranded as “alternative medicine” (or one of the many re-rebrandings – complementary, integrative, holistic, or whatever). Another feature of this rebranding which has occurred is that entire professions dedicated to unscientific medical nonsense have been legitimized. In this case a naturopath has been the one promoting homeopathy in Honduras.
The Montreal naturopath who leads the Honduran missions, Carla Marcelis, referred to homeopathy as “a beautiful way to use the body’s own healing system to come to healing” in a promotional video about the Honduras missions.
That is standard alternative medicine propaganda, a retconning of the superstition-based medicine of the past – it’s now all about making the body heal itself. This sounds nice, but actually means nothing, and is based on nothing. Meanwhile naturopaths try to present themselves as legitimate health care professionals who just specialize in natural medicine, but the core of what they do is pseudoscience. They have no science-based standard of care, they lack adequate scientific training, and much of what they do is nonsense like homeopathy. But because they are licensed, the government is essentially in the position of endorsing whatever nonsense they do. This also puts them in a position where they can promote their quackery, and even infiltrate academic institutions and government programs. They have become a self-sustaining phenomenon.
This infiltration goes all the way to the World Health Organization (WHO). This is a valuable and excellent institution, but has its weaknesses, mainly deriving from the fact that it is embedded in international politics. In this case the CBC reports:
CBC News contacted the office of the federal minister responsible for international development for an interview but was denied.
Instead spokesperson Maegan Graveline reaffirmed Global Affairs’s support for the homeopaths in an email, “The World Health Organization and Pan American Health Organization in its 2014–2023 strategy encourage the integration of traditional medicine and complementary medicine, including homeopathy, into national health systems”.
Here we see yet another feature of the alternative medicine phenomenon – they exploit legitimate issues about colonialism and oppression and use that to further exploit vulnerable populations. They do this by arguing that fake medicine is OK if it can be portrayed as “traditional” or indigenous. We cannot foist effective science-based medicine on native populations, but rather should encourage them to continue using the worthless magic potions that their culture happened to develop. In fact this then justifies culturally appropriating those magic potions, and selling them in spas to rich but clueless Westerners. As long as at the end of the day you get to justify and legitimize a multi-billion dollar industry of magic potions.
I have no problem studying indigenous medicine. There may, in fact, be some genuine natural remedies that get discovered in the process. I also have no problem incorporating cultural sensitivity in the delivery of medicine to native populations, even working with native healers when appropriate. But the goal should be to facilitate the delivery and acceptance of effective medicine. However, these legitimate concerns have been hijacked as yet another way to promote quackery – and the WHO, to their shame, bought it. They were conned, and now their endorsement of medical nonsense is used to promote that nonsense around the world. It’s the go-to defense whenever anyone is called out on promoting quackery to vulnerable populations. The WHO essentially has their back.
It’s also worth pointing out that homeopathy is not “traditional” medicine, in Honduras or anywhere else (except perhaps Austria where it was invented). Not that it ultimately matters – all that matters is that homeopathy is worthless nonsense. But promoting homeopathy as “traditional” in Honduras is ridiculous. It’s just another form of European colonialism, promoting one form of medicine instead of or alongside another. In this case, it’s promoting one that doesn’t work – so it’s pure colonialism. You can’t even justify it by saying that it works and will prevent disease. In fact, it will cause harm if anything by giving people a false sense of security.
This is something the WHO needs to realize. Delivering medicine, or any other benefit, to a poor country is not colonialism or exploitation when that benefit is science-based and everyone can agree, based upon objective evidence and review, that it’s a good idea. Then we are just sharing the fruits of more wealthy countries with poorer countries. What is exploitation and colonialism is foisting on other cultures our own magical belief systems. Homeopathy falls into that category. It is a belief system, one without evidence or even basic scientific logic.
The Canadian government made a mistake. They were hoodwinked by charlatans because they clearly did not do their due diligence. This one slipped below the radar. They should just admit fault and immediately make a correction. Instead they are ducking, doubling down, and hiding under the skirts of the WHO. They should be appropriately ashamed.

Médecins Sans Medicine? “Homeopaths without borders” iving sugar pills for infectious diseases in Honduras
Canadian homeopaths are in Honduras, and claim their magic water remedies can prevent diseases such as Chagas, dengue, and chikungunya.
Scott Gavura on March 7, 2019
Link

Note: Today’s post is on the same topic as yesterday. Apologies. Who knew Steven Novella follows Canadian news?
Also please note: Dr. Novella (and others) GET ACTION. See the conclusion for recent, positive, developments.
Measles outbreaks are currently occurring around the world, and vaccine hesitancy has been named by the World Health Organization as a top threat to public health. The causes of vaccine hesitancy are multifacted, but one of the reasons may be the growing legitimization and normalization of alternative-to-medicine practitioners and practices in first world countries, where scientific literacy and credible medicine may be ignored in favour of giving legislative and regulatory approval to parallel but alternative health practices that were once called (bluntly and accurately) quackery. In Canada, alternative medicine practitioners like homeopaths, naturopaths, acupuncturists and chiropractors are licensed in many provinces, and the “remedies” they prescribe may be approved and regulated by Health Canada (Canada’s equivalent to the FDA.) Notably, many of these practices, are at their core, anti-vaccine. Given these practitioners and practices have been legitimized in the eyes of regulators, it is perhaps not surprising that organizations that fund international medical aid might not immediately see the differences between health professionals that offer science-based medicine, and practitioners of alternative medicine. It might also come as little surprise that organizations like the federal government, which has enabled and promoted pseudoscience through regulation, might be willing to support the outreach and development of these practices. The Quebec-based organization Terre Sans Frontières was recently identified by the CBC as having received $350,000 in aid money from Global Affairs Canada. Some of this funding is being used to send homeopaths to Honduras, to share homeopathic remedies and to teach homeopathy to Hondurans. This is a terrible idea, with the potential to cause lasting, harmful consequences in Honduras.
Who are Terre Sans Frontières?
Terre Sans Frontières (TSF) is a Quebec-based charity that purports to offer community development, aid, and health care to developing countries in the Caribbean, Africa, and South America. As charities go, it’s relatively small, with total revenue of about $11 million per year (2016), most of which comes from donations, with some funding from government programs. Their programs run the range of conventional to quackery, and include Optometrists Sans Frontières, Dentists Sans Frontières, Acupuncture Sans Frontières, Chiropractors Sans Frontières and Homeopaths Sans Frontières (whose page was just scrubbed). Its agenda for Honduras for 2018 was as follows:
Mandate: objectives
    • Continued sharing of basic family health knowledge through homeopathy and homeoprophylaxis among students and health promoters:
    • Continuing education on the following common pathologies: diarrhea, infections, coughs, fevers, trauma, etc.
    • Continuous training on more chronic pathologies including high blood pressure, diabetes, fatty degeneration, etc.
    • Continuing education on preventive homeopathy on the following four vector-borne diseases: Chagas disease, malaria, dengue and chikungunya.
    • Follow-up of the 8 dispensaries (Teupasenti, San Juan de Flores, Opatoro / La Florida, Cane, Valle de Angeles, Omoa / Cuyamel) :
    • Continuation of the first and second level homeopathic training of the professional responsible for each clinic.
    • A deep introduction to homeopathy, its basic theoretical foundation and history.
    • The development of homeopathy as integral, preventive and scientific medicine.
    • The methodology of homeopathy.
    • Continued training in duplication of homeopathic remedies.
To understand just how dangerous this outreach will be, it’s necessary to explain what homeopathy is, and how it differs from other alternative medicine practices.
Homeopathy: Dilutions of grandeur
Apologies to regular readers, who can jump to the next section.Many think of homeopathy as a variation of herbalism. The marketing and labeling of homeopathic “remedies” encourages you to think this, describing it as a “gentle” and “natural” system of healing, and putting cryptic “30C” codes beside long Latin names. But with herbalism, at least you’re usually getting some herb. Homeopathy’s remedies contain no medicine at all – herbal, natural or otherwise. They are inert. Homeopathy is the air guitar of alternative medicine, going through the motions of medicine, without actually providing medicine. How water and sugar pills are thought to heal is based on nonsensical, prescientific ideas about biology, biochemistry, and medicine itself. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like” (which is simply a form of magical thinking) and then performing successive dilutions of substances in water. Each dilution is believed to increase, not decrease, the “potency” of the final product. And these are serious dilutions. Think of putting one drop of a substance into a container of water. Only that container is 131 light-years in diameter. That’s the “30C” dilution you’ll see on packages. Homeopaths believe that the water molecules retain a “memory” of the original substance (while somehow forgetting all the other products it has come in contact with). The final remedy is diluted so completely that most “remedies” don’t contain a single molecule of the original substance you started with. The remedies are pure placebo with no effectiveness. Homeopathy is truly the air guitar of medicine.
Exploitation, not humanitarianism
What is TSF promoting in Honduras? Fake vaccination, known as homeoprophylaxis. From their 2017 report:
With the opening of a new homeopathic dispensary in Cane and the addition of an annex to the Padre Pedro Drouin homeopathic dispensary in Valle de Ángeles this year, together with the existing dispensaries operating in Cantarranas, Omoa, Opatoro/La Florida and Teupasenti, TSF and GAC’s homeopathic care program in Honduras is now completely centred on strengthening local skills. We engaged in three missions, with five homeopaths and three students delivering nine homeopathy courses to 46 people who work at the dispensaries or in healthcare, as well as 121 health promoters. These courses emphasized the transfer of knowledge in primary, secondary and tertiary community health services as well as prevention through homeopathy and homeoprophylaxis, i.e. the use of homeopathy to prevent epidemics. In 2017–2018, 668 people (481 women and 187 men) received preventive or curative treatment at the dispensaries.
Some translation is warranted here. In 2017-18, 668 Hondurans received inert sugar pills instead of proper medicine. Homeoprophylaxis is fake vaccination, with sugar pills, producing no immune response and no protection. Giving homeoprophylaxis means that no immunization has been given – something these Honduran patients may not even have realized. Teaching people that sugar pills can protect against infectious disease, and that homeopathy has something to offer a country in terms of health care, is not just a bad idea – it’s demonstrably dangerous, especially when the intent is to grow the practice of homeopathy. As David Shaw noted an article on the Homeopaths Without Borders movement published in the BMJ back in 2013,
Despite Homeopaths Without Borders’ claims to the contrary, “homeopathic humanitarian help” is a contradiction in terms. Although providing food, water, and solace to people in areas affected by wars and natural disasters certainly constitutes valuable humanitarian work, any homeopathic treatment deceives patients into thinking they are receiving real treatment when they are not. Furthermore, training local people as homeopaths in affected areas amounts to exploiting vulnerable people to increase the reach of homeopathy. Much as an opportunistic infection can take hold when a person’s immune system is weakened, so Homeopaths Without Borders strikes when a country is weakened by a disaster. However, infections are expunged once the immune system recovers but Homeopaths Without Borders’ methods ensure that homeopathy persists in these countries long after the initial catastrophe has passed. Homeopathy is neither helpful nor humanitarian, and to claim otherwise to the victims of disasters amounts to exploitation of those in need of genuine aid.
Defending quackery?
The CBC followed-up on its initial story, contacting the federal minister responsible for international development, who denied an interview. On March 1, they reported that the government had reaffirmed their support for homeopaths, and for this work:
“The World Health Organization and Pan American Health Organization in its 2014–2023 strategy encourage the integration of traditional medicine and complementary medicine, including homeopathy, into national health systems”.
But that argument seemed to change quickly, in an update that was published last night:
A change in policy
Did Steven Novella’s post get action? Let’s give him credit, (in addition to Vik Adhopia, who broke this story for CBC news). Yesterday the Canadian press announced:
A Quebec-based aid group offering controversial homeopathic therapies in Honduras will not receive funding from the federal government after the 2019-20 fiscal year, Global Affairs Canada said Wednesday.
And
Louis Belanger, spokesperson for International Development Minister Maryam Monsef, said the five-year funding package was signed by the previous Conservative government.
“I am unclear why the Conservatives would [sign] off on this five-year program back in 2015. … We will not be funding these types of initiatives any longer,” Belanger said.
So while the initiative has one more year of funding, let’s hope this event leads Global Affairs Canada to look more carefully at what they’re funding in the future.
Conclusion: Hondurans deserve better
Sending homeopaths to Honduras, or any other developing country, makes as much sense to a health system as offering magic carpets to passengers at an airport. That’s an imperfect analogy, as it’s quickly obvious that magic carpets really aren’t magic after all. For Hondurans being treated for infectious disease with homeopathic magic beans, and being taught that magic beans are indeed magic, the long-term harms may be more subtle and harder to spot. In this circumstance, it appears that the public scrutiny and media attention has had an effect. But as long as countries normalize practices like homeopathy, we should not expect the “Homeopaths without Borders” movement to disappear anytime soon.

   Smallpox and Pseudomedicine
Kimball Atwood
Link
A good case of smallpox may rid the system of more scrofulous, tubercular, syphilitic and other poisons than could otherwise be eliminated in a lifetime. Therefore, smallpox is certainly to be preferred to vaccination. The one means elimination of chronic disease, the other the making of it.
Naturopaths do not believe in artificial immunization . . 
—Harry Riley Spitler, Basic Naturopathy: a textbook (American Naturopathic Association, Inc., 1948). Quoted here.
Here’s what a good case of smallpox will do for you:
If you’re lucky enough to beat the reaper (20-60%; 80% or higher in infants) or blindness (up to 30%), those blisters will leave you scarred for life. Oh, and the next time a good smallpox epidemic comes around, your children born since the last one will catch it and contribute their fair share to the death rate. But not you because you’ll be immune, so you’ll have the “preferred” experience of watching your children die well before you do.
Variolation and Vaccination
Except that none of this will happen, because the disease has been eradicated from the world—thanks, of course, to vaccination, which Napoleon reasonably called “the greatest gift to mankind.”
Smallpox was “the most terrible of the ministers of death.” It began at least several thousand years ago and rapidly spread wherever its human carriers traveled, eventually to the entire populated world. In endemic regions, it wiped out 1/4 to 1/3 of children in epidemics that occurred every few years. In epidemics among people who had not previously seen it, such as the natives of the Western Hemisphere during the early years of European explorations, it wiped out as many as 90% of everyone. It brought down armies and empires. Monarchs dropped like flies; it spared no socioeconomic class. Gods were invented in its name. There was never an effective treatment for it once it had begun.
Prior to the advent of vaccination, there was a heroic method that proved useful in reducing the severity of the disease. This was inoculation (‘variolation’): crude matter from a pustule of someone with the disease was etched into the skin of an uninfected person. This resulted in somewhat more indolent clinical cases, with death rates of ‘only’ around 2%, but the disease remained terrible and those so infected could still transmit it to others by means other than inoculation.
Vaccination, as many readers already know, was introduced near the end of the 18th century in England by the physician Edward Jenner. Jenner neither discovered it—it seems to have been discovered by milkmaids (and their close associates) who had noticed that after experiencing a cowpox blister, they never caught smallpox—nor was he the first to use it purposefully or even to write about it. He was the first, however, to conduct and report a series of convincing experiments demonstrating that people previously infected with cowpox could not subsequently be infected with smallpox (by variolation). He also showed that cowpox could be transferred from person to person by inoculation of matter from the cowpox blister, thus offering the first method for widespread use. Jenner is thus given credit not only for having introduced vaccination for smallpox, but for having introduced the concept of vaccination in general, although he would not live to see another example.
The Antivax Movement is Born
Opposition to smallpox vaccination (the name comes from the Latin for “cow”) began almost immediately after Jenner’s reports and remained substantial for more than 100 years. Some opposition was explicitly religious; some was based on disbelief in the method or, later, in the Germ Theory; some objectors claimed that vaccination caused terrible diseases, including smallpox itself; some voiced a political objection to state mandated vaccination programs. An early cartoon suggested that if Jenner had his way, people would start to look like cows:
Two antivax organizations in 19th century Britain were the National Anti-Vaccination League and the Society for the Abolition of Compulsory Vaccination. They sought to discredit Jenner’s reports and to argue, in keeping with the popular “hygiene” and “sanitation” movements of the day, that “cleanliness is more likely to prevent smallpox than [is] introducing filthy matter into the body.”
The Holy Trinity of American Quackery
These were, in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, homeopathy, chiropractic/osteopathy, and naturopathy. Hahnemann himself had approved of his contemporary Jenner’s assertion, believing that it confirmed “like cures like” (ably refuted by Oliver Wendell Holmes, Sr.). Constantine Hering, however, the “Father of American Homeopathy,” was the first homeopath to declare his opposition to vaccination. He called it “always a poisoning” and asserted, “we learn from year to year a more certain and better way of curing small-pox homeopathically.” He nevertheless admitted in 1883, near the time of his death, that this ‘better way’ had not achieved the certainty of prevention by vaccination.
In 1918, Benedict Lust, the “Father of American Naturopathy,” wrote this:
Like the alchemist of old who circulated the false belief that he could transmute the baser metals into gold, in like manner the vivisector claims that he can coin the agony of animals into cures for human disease. He insists on cursing animals that he may bless mankind with such curses.
To understand how revolting these products are, let us just refer to the vaccine matter which is supposed to be an efficient preventive of smallpox. Who would be fool enough to swallow the putrid pus and corruption scraped from the foulest sores of smallpox that has been implanted in the body of a calf? Even if any one would be fool enough to drink so atrocious a substance, its danger might be neutralized by the digestive juices of the intestinal tract. But it is a far greater danger to the organism when inoculated into the blood and tissues direct, where no digestive substances can possibly neutralize its poison.
The natural system for curing disease is based on a return to nature in regulating the diet, breathing, exercising, bathing, and the employment of various forces to eliminate the poisonous products in the system, and so raise the vitality of the patient to a proper standard of health.
Official medicine has in all ages simply attacked the symptoms of the disease without paying any attention to the causes thereof, but natural healing is concerned far more with removing the causes of disease…
In those words we find several of the recurring themes in quackery that were evident in the 19th century and remain so today. We know that naturopaths continued to espouse this view of vaccination at least until 1968, when the quotation at the top of this essay was among the materials they submitted to the Department of HEW in an unsuccessful attempt to be covered by Medicare. They’ve since learned to be somewhat more subtle about the issue, possibly because of the 1968 failure, but their distaste for vaccinations in general persists, as explained here.
An Aside: the “Cause of Disease,” Naturopathy-style
I’m sure you’ve been wondering, so here it is, right from the pen of Harry Riley Spitler, the author of the quotation that began this piece (courtesy of the 1968 HEW report):
The primary cause of disease is reaction to unnatural environment . . . When the body is weighted down by toxins in excess of the amount with which the vital force is able to cope, then enervation… supervenes and there is a lag in the body’s power to expel the “ashes” of metabolism… Enervation leads to the secondary cause of so-called disease — toxemia. Toxemia is the state of auto-intoxication resulting from the accumulation ot poisons in the body – poisons taken in from without in the form of incorrect food, impure water, vitiated air, etc., and which are not thrown off by the body because of its enervated state, and in addition thereto the poisons formed within the body itself by the processes of metabolism. . . The presence of these poisons within the blood stream and tissues causes the vital force to make efforts to eradicate toxemia, and these efforts are what is called “diseased crises.” . . . Disease, therefore, is not a hostile entity to be attacked, but is rather a manifestation of vital force in its efforts to continue to live and to remove anti-vital conditions caused by man’s deliberate, or ignorant, breaking of the laws of health and life … Disease, then, is the result of stagnation and accumulation of filth in the blood stream and in the tissues.
And the cure? Back to Lust:
The Program of Naturopathic Cure
1. ELIMINATION OF EVIL HABITS, or the weeds of life, such as over-eating, alcoholic drinks, drugs, the use of tea, coffee and cocoa that contain poisons, meat-eating, improper hours of living, waste of vital forces, lowered vitality, sexual and social aberrations, worry, etc.
2. CORRECTIVE HABITS. Correct breathing, correct exercise, right mental attitude. Moderation in the pursuit of health and wealth.
3. NEW PRINCIPLES OF LIVING. Proper fasting, selection of food, hydropathy, light and air baths, mud baths, osteopathy, chiropractic, and other forms of mechano-therapy, mineral salts obtained in organic form, electropathy, heliopathy, steam or Turkish baths, sitz baths, etc.
And, of course, enemas.
Natural healing is the most desirable factor in the regeneration of the race.
Wow. It’s all kind of fascistic, no? But I’m digressing.
More on the Holy Trinity
You probably noticed Lust’s approval of chiropractic, another field with a rich tradition of antivax fervor. Some chiropractors have learned to be a bit more subtle; others have not (and not all contemporary chiropractors are opposed to vaccinations). If you’ve perused the 1968 HEW report, you also know that the American naturopathic schools of the mid-20th century were mostly spawned by chiropractors, and that for some time there was little distinction between naturopaths and “mixer” chiropractors. Many “NDs” of that time also had “DC” after their names.
You may also know that contemporary naturopaths love homeopathy. Lust didn’t include it in his NEW PRINCIPLES OF LIVING, probably because of his emphasis on “drugless healing.” Nevertheless, he praised Hahnemann for having shown “the physicians of his day…that just as good results could be brought about by means so gentle that even a delicate child could be treated, without the slightest particle of danger.” It seems to have been left to the next generation of American naturopaths to fully embrace homeopathy, and this was done most conspicuously by a man who himself embodied the Holy Trinity of Quackery: John Bastyr, N.D., D.C. (1912-1995), the “Father of Modern Naturopathic Medicine.”
Bastyr was also described as a
…third-generation homeopath from Dr. Adolph von Lippe. His teacher was Dr. C. P. Bryant (who had been, in 1939, president of the International Hahnemannian Association). C. P. Bryant had been taught by Walter Bushrod James who had been one of Lippe’s closest students. He received doctorate degrees in naturopathy and chiropractic from Northwest Drugless Institute and Seattle Chiropractic College, respectively. He became licensed to practice naturopathic medicine in 1936. He is also credited with being the Father of Modern Naturopathic Medicine. Because of Bastyr’s influence naturopaths have been at the forefront of the rebirth of homeopathy in this country. He made sure that homeopathy shared equal emphasis with nutrition, hydrotherapy and botanical medicine in naturopathic education. Dr. Bastyr considered manipulation the most important therapy in his practice.
So there you have it: the mystical unity of three seemingly incompatible True Causes (Psora, Subluxations, Toxemia), and of three seemingly incompatible True Cures (similia similibus curentur, spinal manipulation, enemas). No wonder that John Bastyr the chiropractor is credited with having been the Saviour of naturopathy and homeopathy in the United States.
Another Aside: Early Vaccinations really were Dangerous
It’s ironic to consider that many of the early objections to smallpox vaccinations were somewhat justified, far more so than are contemporary objections to contemporary vaccinations. Material gathered from cowpox blisters, transferred from human to human, was invariably contaminated. Diseases plausibly attributed to such “arm to arm” vaccinations, in the era before the Germ Theory elucidated such risks in advance, included syphilis, hepatitis, and even smallpox itself, due to contamination from variolations occurring within the same hospitals or clinics. The advent of exclusively animal sources of cowpox didn’t occur until the mid-19th century, and “arm to arm” vaccinations weren’t outlawed in Britain until 1898. Preparations of pure virus—vaccinia—were introduced only in the mid-20th century.
The political objection to mandatory vaccinations also had more clout in the early days, when the concept of “herd immunity” had yet to be introduced.
“All this has happened before, and all this will happen again.”
This is from a meeting of the Connecticut Homeopathic Medical Examining Board, March 12, 2003:
TREATMENT OF SMALLPOX
The Board reviewed the following procedures for the prevention and treatment of smallpox as submitted by Dr. Mullen:
PREVENTION
Malandrinum
It is recommended to administer it at a potency of 30 CH twice a day for up to 5 days as a preventive. This remedy is also very useful to combat the ill effects of Allopathic small pox vaccination, as well as to control the disease that happens when a person gets unwillingly infested by the vaccine received from another.
Sarracenia
It is recommended to administer this remedy at potencies of up to 9 CH. I believe a good dosage schedule would be once a week for 2 or 3 weeks. It is recommended to administer this remedy at a potency of 6 CH every 8 days. Also useful in recent and distant ill effects of Allopathic vaccination.
Vaccininum
An indication for the use of vaccininum would be a patient’s fear of contracting smallpox.
Variolinum
Both Drs. Allen and Vosin enthusiastically endorse this remedy for the prevention of small pox. I would advice to administer it at potencies of 30 CH or 200 CH weekly for 3 or 4 weeks.
TREATMENT
Malandrinum
It is recommended to administer it at a potency of 30 CH. This remedy is particularly useful in patients whose symptoms are more evident in the lower half of the body. I would recommend daily administration for 5 consecutive days and then re-evaluate the patient.
Mercurius 200 CH every other day alternating with Thuja 200 CH.
I would recommend to use this combination up to 10 consecutive days and then re-evaluate the patient.
Sarracenia
It is recommended to administer this remedy at a potency of 9 CH. I would recommend to use it for 5 consecutive days and then re-evaluate the patient. This remedy can stop the disease in its earliest stages, including the development of pustules. The patient may be very sensitive to light, weak in the shoulder area and have shooting pains in zigzag from the lumbar region to the middle of the scapula.
Variolinum
It is recommended to administer it at any potency. I would recommend using it for up to 5 consecutive days, depending on the potency, and then re-evaluate. Variolinum is useful in patients with mild and uncomplicated small pox. Also when pustules are surrounded by a red halo and are often very itchy. Every other day for up to 10 consecutive days and then reevaluate the patient.
Thuja 200 CH
Every other day for up to 10 consecutive days and then re-evaluate the patient.
Wow. What exquisite, quaint, balderdash. Here’s a fun exercise that readers might enjoy: see what contradictions you can find between what you’ve just read and other efforts of the Connecticut Department of Public Health. Hint: start here. Then look at some of the practice acts, such as those for homeopathy, naturopathy, and chiropractic. Does one hand know what the other is doing?

FDA: Don’t use homeopathic eye drops
There are no homeopathic eye drops approved by the FDA.
Scott Gavura on December 21, 2023
Link

Eye drops were the subject of multiple FDA warnings and recalls in 2023. First, an artificial tears product was found to be blinding and killing people, through contamination with a drug-resistant bacteria. Later the FDA warned consumers not to use over two dozen brands of eye drops, as their investigation led to an inspection of the manufacturing facilities in India where staff were preparing these supposedly sterile products without gloves, gowns or even shoes. In September, the FDA wrote to several manufacturers, stating they were marketing ophthalmic drug products in violation of federal law. Building on additional recalls for eye drops, the FDA summed up 2023 with a “What You Should Know about Eye Drops” release last week which uses uncharacteristically blunt language. In addition to general advice about choosing over-the-counter products carfully, it specifically warns against using any ophthalmic products that are labelled as homeopathic, stating that these products should not be marketed.

Ophthalmic products such as eye drops carry an increased potential for harm, as products administered into the eye can evade certain natural bodily defenses. To minimize the risk of infection, any medication intended for ocular use must be sterile. When bacteria are introduced directly into the eye, bad things can result.
The astute reader may be wondering what exactly is the difference between “homeopathic” eye drops and good old “water”, given homeopathic remedies are typically chemically indistinguishable from water. But the casual consumer will likely just ignore the “homeopathic” label and look at what the product is purported to treat. The FDA likely cautioned against homeopathy owing to the risks that these products present to consumers, as products marketed as homeopathy have not been subjected to the same regulatory requirements as over-the-counter eye drops. This is despite the products looking like conventional drug products, often sitting directly alongside conventional drugs.
Samuel Hahnemann invented the homeopathy in the early 1800s. While the practice of medicine slowly progressed to a scientific model based on objective observations, homeopathy never progressed or evolved: it remains frozen in prescientific thinking. Homeopathy is based on the idea that “like cures like”, in that a small dose of what causes a symptom can actually cure that symptom. Like-cures-like is simply sympathetic magic, a pre-scientific belief. Homeopathy proponents also believe that water has memory, and the more you dilute a substance, the more powerful its effects. The 30C “potency” is a common dilution used in homeopathy – that’s a dilution of 10-60. If something has been diluted this much, you would have to give two billion doses per second, to six billion people, for 4 billion years, to deliver a single molecule of the original, pre-diluted material. The result of all this dilution is that most homeopathic remedies are completely inert, and don’t contain a single molecule of the original reference material. And that original reference material can range from table salt to sunlight to vacuum cleaner dust. There is no product so bizarre that homeopaths haven’t made a remedy out of it. None of these products have actually been demonstrated to provide actual medicinal effects. They are pure placebo.
The regulation of homeopathy regulation in the United States differs from prescription or over-the-counter drug products. For decades, despite their regulatory status as “drugs”, the FDA largely ignored homeopathic remedies, allowing any homeopathic remedy recognized in traditional homeopathic references to be marketed, without any FDA pre- or post-market approval. As the FDA itself notes,
There are no FDA-approved products labeled as homeopathic; this means that any product labeled as homeopathic is being marketed in the U.S. without FDA evaluation for safety or effectiveness.
The FDA’s guidance, Homeopathic Drug Products from 2022 describes how the agency will prioritize regulatory action for these products. It’s clear that homeopathic eye drops do not meet the FDA’s standard. Here is a statement from a warning letter issued to homeopathy manufacturer Boiron earlier this year:
We recognize that your “Optique 1 Eye Drops” product is labeled as a homeopathic drug with active ingredients measured in homeopathic strengths. Under section 201(g)(1) of the FD&C Act, 21 U.S.C. 321(g)(1), the term “drug” includes articles recognized in the official Homeopathic Pharmacopeia of the United States (HPUS), or any supplement to it. Homeopathic drug products are subject to the same statutory requirements as other drugs; nothing in the FD&C Act exempts homeopathic drugs from any of the requirements related to adulteration, misbranding, or FDA approval.
Despite this guidance, homeopathic eye products continue to be sold. Naturaleyecare.com describes common homeopathic “ingredients” in eye drops for cataracts, such as:
    • Cineraria Maritima to “supports circulation in the eye” (this is the plant silver ragwort)
    • Euphrasia (another plant, eyebright)
    • Causticum for “eye pain” (this is potassium hydrate)
    • Sepia for “glare, spots, veiled vision, streaks of light blurring the vision” (I think this is a pigment extracted from cuttlefish).
    • Calcarea phosphorica for “blurry vision and pain from tired eyes” (calcium phosphate)
    • Calcarea fluorica for “blurry vision, cataract, opacity of the cornea” (calcium fluoride)
It’s worth noting that while there is no evidence any of these ingredients would be useful to treat cataracts, there is also no evidence (and even less plausibility) that diluting these ingredients repeatedly with water would somehow make them effective.
Eye care product? Read the label carefully
Given the number of recalls, it’s important to choose your eye care product carefully. I am not normally one to recommend brand-name products when generics exists, but it’s perhaps worth noting that none of the recalled products came from the major vision brands. At minimum, avoid any product labelled homeopathic. Also avoid any product marketed to treat serious eye conditions such as glaucoma, cataracts, retinopathy or macular degeneration, as none of these products are approved as over-the-counter drugs. The FDA also warns against products containing silver sulfate or argentum, which can permanently change the white color of your eyes. There are also illegally marketed products that are labelled to contain methylsulfonylmethane (MSM). There is also a helpful website, Are my eye drops safe? which can be used to check if the product you’re considering is subject to any FDA warning or recall.
